You can purchase from us in-bond and cellar it with TFB, costs are detailed here, we bond at London City Bond Eton Park (previously called Vinotheque) or buy and transfer to your own bond account.
Spend £1000+ & the Transfer to your own UK bond account is free. Transfers under £1000 cost £15.
If you planning to buy more than ten cases please call or email us for a quote. LCB Eton Park is widely acknowledged as being the best temperature controlled fine wine bonded warehouse in the UK.
You can purchase from us in-bond and cellar it with TFB, costs are detailed here, we bond at London City Bond Eton Park (previously called Vinotheque) or buy and transfer to your own bond account.
Spend £1000+ & the Transfer to your own UK bond account is free. Transfers under £1000 cost £15.
If you planning to buy more than ten cases please call or email us for a quote. LCB Eton Park is widely acknowledged as being the best temperature controlled fine wine bonded warehouse in the UK.
“A new prestige cuvée from Palmer, the debut release of the NV Brut Amazone is a blend of the 2012, 2010 and 2009 vintages, complemented by some 19% reserve wines drawn from a perpetual reserve, and it's equal parts Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, all from the Montagne de Reims. Offering up aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, freshly baked bread, crisp nectarine, oyster shell and subtle hints of the biscuity complexity to come, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and seamless, its fleshy core of fruit girdled by ripe but racy acids and complemented by a pearly mousse. Disgorged last year with six grams per liter dosage, it's an impressively complete, well-structured wine that will be even better with a few years on cork.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“A lovely note of fresh Viennoiserie is as fragrant of butter as it is of lemon. Beneath that is a fresher, cooler note of green apple and wet chalk. The palate picks up that rich pastry note and adds lively lemon zest and a sense of creaminess. This is elegant, concentrated and vivid with very fine mousse. Lovely depth adds extra dimension and gives much length to the fresh, bright finish.”
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This Amazone de Palmer is a blend of 2012, 2010 and 2009, with an 18% addition from the house's perpetual reserve. The developing lemon colour speaks of the age. The nose also shows development in the form of soft, vanilla-laden fruitiness, opulent toastiness and spicy whiffs. There is also the lightest hint of oxidative development. Soft and cushiony on the palate, it is silky and concentrated, with the bubbles tiny and perfectly integrated with the wine's sumptuous richness. Long, lingering, juicy-fresh finish. A ready-to-drink prestige cuvée. Dosage 6g/l”
“Brut Gold’s strength is its easiness and quaffing character. At 10g/l dosage it is a soft, fruity and forward wine. The very first cuvée is by far the best but regrettably the oaky dosage wine they now use deducts from the purity and harmony. Soft, evolving nose of sweet vanilla, ripe apple and stylish gunpowder, but comes with a light oxidative note. Rich, linear structure with fine mousse. Long and fruity but rather straightforward. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2018
“The NV Brut (Gold) opens with lovely matured brioche, toast and ripe fruit flavors. Fresh, pure and elegant on the palate, with beautifully matured flavors and an elegant creaminess I don't find in the other cuvées, the "Gold" is a blend of 40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay and 20% Pinot Meunier as well as the vintages of 2009, 2010 and 2012. The wine reveals good grip and mineral tension and drinks well as an aperitif or with seafood and fish.”
“Brut Gold’s strength is its easiness and quaffing character. At 10g/l dosage it is a soft, fruity and forward wine. The very first cuvée is by far the best but regrettably the oaky dosage wine they now use deducts from the purity and harmony. Soft, evolving nose of sweet vanilla, ripe apple and stylish gunpowder, but comes with a light oxidative note. Rich, linear structure with fine mousse. Long and fruity but rather straightforward. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2018
“The NV Brut (Gold) opens with lovely matured brioche, toast and ripe fruit flavors. Fresh, pure and elegant on the palate, with beautifully matured flavors and an elegant creaminess I don't find in the other cuvées, the "Gold" is a blend of 40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay and 20% Pinot Meunier as well as the vintages of 2009, 2010 and 2012. The wine reveals good grip and mineral tension and drinks well as an aperitif or with seafood and fish.”
“The 2017 Extra-Brut Aÿ Grand Cru is another stellar wine from Bérêche in this difficult vintage. Even so, all the richness, power and intensity of Aÿ comes through loud and clear. The wine's presence and textural resonance are simply captivating. The Grand Cru is 70% Pinot Noir and 30% Chardonnay, a blend that works especially well this year. ”
“The 2020 Extra-Brut Blanc de Noirs Mailly-Champagne Grand Cru is a total stunner. Ample and explosive, with palpable vertical energy, the Mailly-Champagne has it all. The 2020 possesses superb textural depth, refined contours and vertical explosiveness that is hard to fully describe in words. Cranberry, chalk, mint, white pepper, slate and dried herbs soar across the palate. The 2020 boasts mind-blowing purity and class to burn. I would be thrilled to own it. Dosage is 3 grams per liter. Disgorged: July 2025.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2026
“The 2020 Blanc de Noirs Mailly-Champagne Grand Cru, disgorged in July 2025 with a dosage of three grams per liter, is another success, bursting from the glass with aromas of blood orange, red apple and freshly baked bread mingled with nuances of iodine. Medium- to full-bodied, racy and precise, it is built around an ample core of fruit enlivened by structuring chalky extract and bright acidity, concluding with a long, saline finish. Incisive and energetic, it presents an entirely different stylistic profile from the richer Ambonnay bottling and emerges as the strongest wine in this year’s range”
“Issuing from three old-vine parcels—Les Chalois, Les Baraquines and Les Côtes—rooted in deep, iron-rich red clay soils, the 2019 Blanc de Noirs Mailly-Champagne Grand Cru stands as the finest of Bérêche’s village bottlings this year. Disgorged in July 2024 with a dosage of 3.25 grams per liter, it soars from the glass with a deep bouquet of blood orange, ripe peach and pear, interwoven with nuances of dried flowers and smoke. Sourced predominantly from north-facing sites, it presents a medium- to full-bodied profile, marked by remarkable tension and definition. A vibrant core of youthful, bright fruit is underpinned by mouthwatering acidity, lending it impeccable precision that extends through a searingly chalky, enduring finish. The most accomplished wine from this estate this year, it comes with the highest recommendation.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2019 Extra-Brut Blanc de Noirs Mailly-Champagne Grand Cru is another fabulous wine in this range from Bérêche et Fils. This north-facing site handled the intense heat of the year especially well. Chalk, licorice, mint, white pepper, cranberry and dried flowers all run through this potent, driving offering. In 2019, the Mailly-Champagne is very clearly a standout. Impressive, and that is an understatement.”
“The NV Brut Réserve (base 2022) is such a classy wine. This release, based on 2022, is all finesse. Cranberry, mint, white pepper, slate and dried flowers all grace the palate. Stylistically, the Brut Réserve has evolved into a more refined Champagne than what was the norm just a few years ago. The one thing that is evident, though, is a slightly harder texture vis-à-vis the other wines in the range, likely because of aging on crown cap rather than cork. Élevage was done 70% in cask and 30% in tank. Dosage is 5.2 grams per liter.”
“The 2018 Extra-Brut Le Cran is another compelling wine in this range from the Bérêche family. Apple tart, apricot, mint, yellow flowers, vanillin and a kiss of French oak lend an exotic flair. Chardonnay speaks with an assertive voice; it was picked at 11.5% potential alcohol and comprises 60% of the blend as opposed to the more typical 50%. Pinot Noir is just behind in terms of ripeness. This needs a bit of time to absorb all of its oak. Dosage is 3.85 grams per liter. Disgorged: July 2025.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2026
“Originating from northeast- and northwest-facing sites harvested between September 4 and 5, the 2018 Le Cran Ludes Premier Cru is showing beautifully, opening with aromas of pear, peach and red apple mingled with nuances of blood orange. Medium- to full-bodied, intense and chalky, it is underpinned by ripe yet racy acidity and concludes with a long, saline finish. Disgorged in July 2025, it is a considerable success despite the vintage's abundant yields, even if it represents a slightly softer and more open-knit rendition of Le Cran. It will offer a broad drinking window.”
“The 2018 Extra-Brut Le Cran is another compelling wine in this range from the Bérêche family. Apple tart, apricot, mint, yellow flowers, vanillin and a kiss of French oak lend an exotic flair. Chardonnay speaks with an assertive voice; it was picked at 11.5% potential alcohol and comprises 60% of the blend as opposed to the more typical 50%. Pinot Noir is just behind in terms of ripeness. This needs a bit of time to absorb all of its oak. Dosage is 3.85 grams per liter. Disgorged: July 2025.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2026
“Originating from northeast- and northwest-facing sites harvested between September 4 and 5, the 2018 Le Cran Ludes Premier Cru is showing beautifully, opening with aromas of pear, peach and red apple mingled with nuances of blood orange. Medium- to full-bodied, intense and chalky, it is underpinned by ripe yet racy acidity and concludes with a long, saline finish. Disgorged in July 2025, it is a considerable success despite the vintage's abundant yields, even if it represents a slightly softer and more open-knit rendition of Le Cran. It will offer a broad drinking window.”
“The 2018 Extra-Brut Le Cran is another compelling wine in this range from the Bérêche family. Apple tart, apricot, mint, yellow flowers, vanillin and a kiss of French oak lend an exotic flair. Chardonnay speaks with an assertive voice; it was picked at 11.5% potential alcohol and comprises 60% of the blend as opposed to the more typical 50%. Pinot Noir is just behind in terms of ripeness. This needs a bit of time to absorb all of its oak. Dosage is 3.85 grams per liter. Disgorged: July 2025.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2026
“Originating from northeast- and northwest-facing sites harvested between September 4 and 5, the 2018 Le Cran Ludes Premier Cru is showing beautifully, opening with aromas of pear, peach and red apple mingled with nuances of blood orange. Medium- to full-bodied, intense and chalky, it is underpinned by ripe yet racy acidity and concludes with a long, saline finish. Disgorged in July 2025, it is a considerable success despite the vintage's abundant yields, even if it represents a slightly softer and more open-knit rendition of Le Cran. It will offer a broad drinking window.”
“The 2015 Extra-Brut Une Champagne is a blend of all the 1er and Grand Crus in the cellar. It's a step up from the debut 2014. Explosive in the glass, the 2015 possesses tremendous textural richness from start to finish. Orchard fruit, slate, chalk, mint, white flowers and a kiss of toasty brioche saturate the palate. Blending is such a central part of the identity of Champagne. Bérêche's Extra-Brut Une Champagne makes that point loud and clear.”
“The 2021 Extra-Brut Rive Gauche, 100% Meunier on clay, is floral and effusive right out of the gate. Crushed flowers, kirsch, cranberry and dried pear are all beautifully sculpted. The texture of the mousse is so silky, so finessed. The 2021 is incredibly impressive, especially within the context of the year. Aged on cork. Dosage is 2 grams per liter.”
“Today I was left speechless after tasting Billecart-Salmon Bicentenary Cuvee 200 MV #MagnumEffect first released in 2018 to celebrate the Maison bi-centenary. I haven’t tasted it before, though I remember a quote from the incoming CEO, Mathieu Billecart-Salmon “a champagne needing a lot of time before it will reveals itself” and he was 100% right, because eight years on this champagne is way off its drinking window! It is a red grape bonanza, 92% Pinot Noir, 4% Meunier & 4% Chardonnay, eight grands crus villages of the Côte des Blancs and Montagne de Reims plus half of the annual output from Le Clos St-Hilaire in their home at Mareuil-sur-Aÿ.
Exceptional reserve wines were blended in spring of 2013 from 2012, 2008, 2003 and 2000 half fermented in stainless steel and half in several times used oak barrels, finished with a dosage of 4.5 g/l
The aromatic left me with a big smile, I love #MagnumEffect to me a sign of absolute purity and a nod to oxygen having done nothing negative. That smoky charm leads you into a dense and dark forest of stone fruits that are super ripe like apricot, peach, bramble, blueberry, tangy orange and some lighter red fruits that are sensational on the palate. There is a tension, like something super tightly wound, not revealing itself, giving you clues, but leaving you almost on edge as you cant see it all. I haven’t seen a nervosity of tension like this before. With a little time the palate is more revealing and the texture is big and bold and really super dense and spicy with a stunning high at the end with salinity dripping from your tongue. I have not tasted a champagne quite like this before and cant wait to see it with a lot more time; I feel we are 5-10+ years away from being anywhere near the “full reveal” Today the wine is a clear winner a perfect 20/20 and with time I expect it will earn a 20++/20!
”
More Reviews +
96/100
Decanter,
decanter.com,
May 2018
“ This new wine was made to ‘capture the essence of Billecart-Salmon', according to seventh generation owner Mathieu Roland-Billecart. From 92% Pinot Noir, 4% Chardonnay and 4% Pinot Meunier, this is a blend of eight grands crus from the Côte des Blancs and Montagne de Reims, including the 1ha Pinot Noir vineyard of Le Clos St-Hilaire in Mareuil-sur-Aÿ. Exceptional reserve wines from 2000, 2003, 2008 and 2012 were vinified half in steel and half in old oak casks, with a dosage of 4.5g/l, making it an extra brut style. It has a hugely expressive nose of red apple, nougat and citrus, with the hallmark ‘old rose’ fragrance from Clos St-Hilaire. There's an elegant mousse with very fine, fast-streaming bubbles and powerful, juicy flavours of baking spices, praline, and tart apples. A smoky mineral note and bright acidity offer real refreshment through the long finish, and while drinking beautifully now, it has the structure to last and will improve with age. To mark the year of the house’s founding, just 1,818 magnums were made, along with 18 Jeroboams. Drinking Window 2018-2035.”
“There's a pure white fruitiness to the coolly reserved nose here: lemon, yellow apple and cream. Still, the most impressive feature is the fine toastiness and mineral notion present on both nose and palate. There is a really stylish lightness to the wine, despite a great fruit intensity. It feels focused, packed with fruit, and blessed with pristine fruit quality; this is no surprise, since the grapes originate from four grands crus of the Côte des Blancs: Avize, Cramant, Chouilly and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger. Disgorged 7/21; dosage 8g/l”
More Reviews +
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2015 vintage and dominated this year by Mesnil sur Oger, Billecart's NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru was disgorged in July 2021 with seven grams per liter dosage. Exhibiting aromas of citrus oil, tart stone fruit, freshly baked bread and white flowers, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and layered, its sweet core of fruit framed by racy acids and chalky structure.”
17.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2022
“An exceptionally elegant, silky and surprisingly delicate champagne. I was expecting power, but this is like a mouthful of shimmering ribbons. An unusual floral fragrance, like the elusive scent of lily of the valley in an early-morning garden. Rich citrus woven into baked pear, tingling with green-apple sherbet. The bubbles float over the wine like cashmere lace. Tremendous purity. And the wine develops in the glass in a way I was not expecting, becoming richer, more dense, beginning to taste of violets and fresh-churned pink clay, of bread-yeast starters and sleepy pools of candlelight. A poet's champagne.”
93/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“The NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru is showing beautifully today, with aromas of confit citrus, pear, herbs, orchard fruits, pastry and brioche. Medium to full-bodied, it is round and supple with the delicate, bright tension that is the signature of Billecart-Salmon. Perfectly balanced and offering a vinous, toasty and elegantly long finish, it's based on the 2017 vintage with 23% from 2016. Vinified and matured in stainless steel, it spent five years on the lees in bottle before being disgorged with a dosage of 1.7 grams per liter.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2017
“Mesnil, Avize, Cramant, Chouilly. No oak fermentation. Based on 2009 and a smaller proportion of reserve wines than the 45% in the Brut Réserve. RS 6 g/l. Feuille morte glass colour.
Bright, intense fruit on the nose. Broad, toasty and expansive. Very long. Elegant. Lots to chew on.”
91/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Disgorged in June 2024 with a dosage of 3.9 grams per liter and based on the 2018 vintage, supplemented by 37% reserve wines from 2017, 2016 and 2015, Billecart’s NV Le Blanc de Blancs offers up aromas of pear, lemon confit and freshly baked bread mingled with dried flowers. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and fleshy yet vibrant, with a muscular core of fruit and racy acidity framed by chalky extract. It is brighter than one might anticipate for the vintage, though undeniably of lesser concentration than the 2019 rendition. As ever, it is vinified in stainless steel and, for this bottling, is anchored in Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, complemented by wines from Chouilly, Cramant and Avize.”
“Mesnil, Avize, Cramant, Chouilly. No oak fermentation. Based on 2009 and a smaller proportion of reserve wines than the 45% in the Brut Réserve. RS 6 g/l. Feuille morte glass colour.
Bright, intense fruit on the nose. Broad, toasty and expansive. Very long. Elegant. Lots to chew on.”
More Reviews +
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2015 vintage and dominated this year by Mesnil sur Oger, Billecart's NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru was disgorged in July 2021 with seven grams per liter dosage. Exhibiting aromas of citrus oil, tart stone fruit, freshly baked bread and white flowers, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and layered, its sweet core of fruit framed by racy acids and chalky structure.”
89-91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2015
“A delicate, fruity blanc de blancs with a straightforward floral-lemony-mineral character and stylish toasty edge. A classic mix from the celebrated Grand Cru villages of Chouilly, Cramant, Oger and Le Mesnil aged on the lees for five years with 35 percent reserve wines bringing even further richness. Beautifully creamy, energetic mousse and a fresh, long, fruity length.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2009
“Light and zesty with tobacco notes. Fresh and lively. Again, a slightly fast fade.”
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“There's a pure white fruitiness to the coolly reserved nose here: lemon, yellow apple and cream. Still, the most impressive feature is the fine toastiness and mineral notion present on both nose and palate. There is a really stylish lightness to the wine, despite a great fruit intensity. It feels focused, packed with fruit, and blessed with pristine fruit quality; this is no surprise, since the grapes originate from four grands crus of the Côte des Blancs: Avize, Cramant, Chouilly and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger. Disgorged 7/21; dosage 8g/l”
17.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2022
“An exceptionally elegant, silky and surprisingly delicate champagne. I was expecting power, but this is like a mouthful of shimmering ribbons. An unusual floral fragrance, like the elusive scent of lily of the valley in an early-morning garden. Rich citrus woven into baked pear, tingling with green-apple sherbet. The bubbles float over the wine like cashmere lace. Tremendous purity. And the wine develops in the glass in a way I was not expecting, becoming richer, more dense, beginning to taste of violets and fresh-churned pink clay, of bread-yeast starters and sleepy pools of candlelight. A poet's champagne.”
93/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“The NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru is showing beautifully today, with aromas of confit citrus, pear, herbs, orchard fruits, pastry and brioche. Medium to full-bodied, it is round and supple with the delicate, bright tension that is the signature of Billecart-Salmon. Perfectly balanced and offering a vinous, toasty and elegantly long finish, it's based on the 2017 vintage with 23% from 2016. Vinified and matured in stainless steel, it spent five years on the lees in bottle before being disgorged with a dosage of 1.7 grams per liter.”
91/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Disgorged in June 2024 with a dosage of 3.9 grams per liter and based on the 2018 vintage, supplemented by 37% reserve wines from 2017, 2016 and 2015, Billecart’s NV Le Blanc de Blancs offers up aromas of pear, lemon confit and freshly baked bread mingled with dried flowers. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and fleshy yet vibrant, with a muscular core of fruit and racy acidity framed by chalky extract. It is brighter than one might anticipate for the vintage, though undeniably of lesser concentration than the 2019 rendition. As ever, it is vinified in stainless steel and, for this bottling, is anchored in Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, complemented by wines from Chouilly, Cramant and Avize.”
“Heavily based on the 2017 vintage (with 34% reserve wines dating back to 2006), fermented at low temperatures and entirely vinified in oak, the NV Le Sous Bois blends fruit from vast areas of Montagne de Reims, Vallée de la Marne and Côte des Blancs (notably Oger, Chouilly and Cramant). Disgorged with a dosage of five grams per liter in spring 2023, after five years of lees aging, it reveals aromas of green apple, vanilla, peach and toasted nuts, mingling with hints of caramelized sugar. On the palate, it is medium to full-bodied, precise and fine-boned, featuring a youthful fruit core supported by vibrant acidity, with subtle bitter phenolics asserting themselves on the finish. Given the challenges of the growing season, it incorporates a higher proportion of Chardonnay than usual.”
More Reviews +
92+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2014 vintage, the NV Brut Sous Bois derives from old vines, most of which are massale selections, vinified in old barrels. Wafting from the glass with aromas of green apple and crisp white peach mingled with freshly baked bread, buttery pastry, toasted nuts and flowers, it's medium to full-bodied, taut and chalky, with a crisp core of fruit underpinned by a tangy spine of acidity. A serious, tightly wound wine, even after seven years sur lattes, it will reward a bit of additional age on cork.”
93/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Based on the 2016 vintage with 26% réserve wines from eight different vintages, Billecart-Salmon's NV Brut Sous Bois exhales a delicate, toasty bouquet of mirabelle, tangerine, white fruits, ripe orchard fruits and baked bread, mingled with delicate notes of vanilla pod. Medium to full-bodied, round and creamy, it's perfectly balanced with a vinous, fleshy core of fruit and a delicately toasty finish complemented with gastronomic bitterness. This blend of 48% Pinot Noir, 32% Chardonnay and 20% Pinot Meunier was disgorged with two grams per liter of dosage.”
“Edgy, racy, tense nose. Excellent balance and intrigue already. Well-judged mousse and a tight texture suggesting quite a long life. A complete wine with notes of citrus and herbs – spring in a bottle? Admirably persistent. It may be Extra Brut but there is no shortage of fruit and pleasure.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2026
“The 2013 Brut Blancs de Blancs Louis Salmon is a powerful, dense Champagne that captures all the intensity of this late-ripening year. Apricot, peach, tangerine oil, mint and tropical inflections fill out the layers. Dense and very young, the 2013 is built for the cellar. It’s a seriously impressive wine from Billecart-Salmon. The blend is 44% Cramant, 26% Chouilly, 25% Le Mesnil and 5% Oiry, done entirely in tank with full malolactic fermentation. ”
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“The reference point of Billecart-Salmon’s contemporary direction, the 2013 Blanc de Blancs Louis Salmon, disgorged in January 2024 with four grams per liter dosage, stands as the most characterful wine of the new lineup, expressing itself from the glass with aromas of early-blooming white flowers, lemon oil, nashi pear and almond paste mingled with cardamom, oyster shell and freshly baked bread. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and elegantly muscular, with a tensile core of crystalline purity, racy acids and ample chalky extract. Harvested in October, it derives from the communes of Cramant, Chouilly, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oiry and was vinified entirely in stainless steel with full malolactic fermentation in pursuit of greater harmony in a cool-profile vintage such as this. It is slightly more elegant and simultaneously less powerful than the 2012 rendition, yet it remains equally compelling. Stylistically, it shares certain affinities with the 2008 and 1996 vintages, albeit with more fully realized ripeness.”
“Edgy, racy, tense nose. Excellent balance and intrigue already. Well-judged mousse and a tight texture suggesting quite a long life. A complete wine with notes of citrus and herbs – spring in a bottle? Admirably persistent. It may be Extra Brut but there is no shortage of fruit and pleasure.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2026
“The 2013 Brut Blancs de Blancs Louis Salmon is a powerful, dense Champagne that captures all the intensity of this late-ripening year. Apricot, peach, tangerine oil, mint and tropical inflections fill out the layers. Dense and very young, the 2013 is built for the cellar. It’s a seriously impressive wine from Billecart-Salmon. The blend is 44% Cramant, 26% Chouilly, 25% Le Mesnil and 5% Oiry, done entirely in tank with full malolactic fermentation. ”
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“The reference point of Billecart-Salmon’s contemporary direction, the 2013 Blanc de Blancs Louis Salmon, disgorged in January 2024 with four grams per liter dosage, stands as the most characterful wine of the new lineup, expressing itself from the glass with aromas of early-blooming white flowers, lemon oil, nashi pear and almond paste mingled with cardamom, oyster shell and freshly baked bread. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and elegantly muscular, with a tensile core of crystalline purity, racy acids and ample chalky extract. Harvested in October, it derives from the communes of Cramant, Chouilly, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oiry and was vinified entirely in stainless steel with full malolactic fermentation in pursuit of greater harmony in a cool-profile vintage such as this. It is slightly more elegant and simultaneously less powerful than the 2012 rendition, yet it remains equally compelling. Stylistically, it shares certain affinities with the 2008 and 1996 vintages, albeit with more fully realized ripeness.”
“Chardonnay grapes from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger lead the way in this all-grand-cru blend with contributions from Cramant, Chouilly and Oiry. A quarter of the wines have been vinified in oak casks. Deep, developing lemon colour. The pure, impressively intense but refined Chardonnay nose has a sweet fruit profile: confit lemon, orange blossom, toasted bread, smoke and pineapple. On the palate, huge concentration meets great minerality and a firm backbone of acidity. Youthful and well built, with heaps of delicious fruit, this age-worthy cuvée will be a pleasure to follow as it develops. Dosage: 3.9g/l”
More Reviews +
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Originating from a mid-September harvest following a mildew-pressured season that resulted in comparatively low yields, the 2012 Blanc de Blancs Louis Salmon has produced a flamboyant wine that blossoms in the glass with aromas of lemon confit, nashi pear, quince and peach mingled with almond paste and freshly baked bread. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, concentrated and profound, with ripe yet racy acidity and a layered core of fruit. Its textural attack segues into a resonant, pungently chalky mid-palate, concluding with a long, saline finish tinged with grapefruit. It is slightly more powerful than the 2013 rendition, exhibiting a subtle phenolic nuance; yet, it likewise reflects Billecart’s contemporary stylistic direction. Disgorged in January 2023 with a dosage of 3.9 grams per liter, only a quarter of the base wines were matured in barrel, while approximately 90% underwent malolactic fermentation. The blend is anchored in Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, complemented by wines from Cramant, Chouilly and Oiry.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2012 Brut Blancs de Blancs Louis Salmon is a gorgeous Champagne. Lemon confit, spice, baked apple tart, chamomile and dried flowers are all nicely amplified. The 2012 was done 75% in tank and 25% in oak, with most of the lots undergoing malolactic fermentation. There's a feeling of reserve in the 2012 that is quite appealing. This edition is terrific, but it also needs time to be at its best. I would be in no rush to open this. Low yields and a year beset by frost, hail, heavy rain, mildew and sunburn at various times produced a rich Champagne. The blend of sites in Mesnil-sur-Oger, Chouilly, Cramant and Oiry works so well. Dosage is 3.9 grams per liter. Disgorged: first trimester 2023.”
18+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2024
“Cuvee Louis 2012 Blanc de Blancs all grapes from Grand Cru rated villages with partial oak barrel fermentation. An impressive aromatic, that rich lemony sherbet on entry, overlays a layer of buttery shortbread that has been lightly toasted. This has the 2012 forward fruit charm, unctuous fruit, though restrained with hints of tropical guava. Its texture is a delight, wrapping round the palate, bright lemon, grapefruit, charred pineapple, it has richness on the palate, minerality and chalky charm. This is the best balance young Louis I have tasted.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“A 100% Chardonnay, sourced from vines planted in the communes of Mesnil-sur-Oger, Chouilly, Cramant, and Oiry, the 2012 Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuvée Louis Salmon evokes aromas of lemon oil, pastry, baked bread, walnuts and chalk. Medium to full-bodied, deep and seamless, it's vinous, almost creamy, with a layered, delicate structure that leads to a delicately citrusy, long and delicate finish. This Champagne is built to age, thanks to the power of the 2012 vintage and the house's signature tension. Disgorged in the second quarter of 2023 with 3.9 grams per liter dosage, it was matured 75% in stainless steel and 25% in barrels.”
“The 2012 Brut Blancs de Blancs Louis Salmon is a gorgeous Champagne. Lemon confit, spice, baked apple tart, chamomile and dried flowers are all nicely amplified. The 2012 was done 75% in tank and 25% in oak, with most of the lots undergoing malolactic fermentation. There's a feeling of reserve in the 2012 that is quite appealing. This edition is terrific, but it also needs time to be at its best. I would be in no rush to open this. Low yields and a year beset by frost, hail, heavy rain, mildew and sunburn at various times produced a rich Champagne. The blend of sites in Mesnil-sur-Oger, Chouilly, Cramant and Oiry works so well. Dosage is 3.9 grams per liter. Disgorged: first trimester 2023.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“Chardonnay grapes from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger lead the way in this all-grand-cru blend with contributions from Cramant, Chouilly and Oiry. A quarter of the wines have been vinified in oak casks. Deep, developing lemon colour. The pure, impressively intense but refined Chardonnay nose has a sweet fruit profile: confit lemon, orange blossom, toasted bread, smoke and pineapple. On the palate, huge concentration meets great minerality and a firm backbone of acidity. Youthful and well built, with heaps of delicious fruit, this age-worthy cuvée will be a pleasure to follow as it develops. Dosage: 3.9g/l”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Originating from a mid-September harvest following a mildew-pressured season that resulted in comparatively low yields, the 2012 Blanc de Blancs Louis Salmon has produced a flamboyant wine that blossoms in the glass with aromas of lemon confit, nashi pear, quince and peach mingled with almond paste and freshly baked bread. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, concentrated and profound, with ripe yet racy acidity and a layered core of fruit. Its textural attack segues into a resonant, pungently chalky mid-palate, concluding with a long, saline finish tinged with grapefruit. It is slightly more powerful than the 2013 rendition, exhibiting a subtle phenolic nuance; yet, it likewise reflects Billecart’s contemporary stylistic direction. Disgorged in January 2023 with a dosage of 3.9 grams per liter, only a quarter of the base wines were matured in barrel, while approximately 90% underwent malolactic fermentation. The blend is anchored in Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, complemented by wines from Cramant, Chouilly and Oiry.”
18+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2024
“Cuvee Louis 2012 Blanc de Blancs all grapes from Grand Cru rated villages with partial oak barrel fermentation. An impressive aromatic, that rich lemony sherbet on entry, overlays a layer of buttery shortbread that has been lightly toasted. This has the 2012 forward fruit charm, unctuous fruit, though restrained with hints of tropical guava. Its texture is a delight, wrapping round the palate, bright lemon, grapefruit, charred pineapple, it has richness on the palate, minerality and chalky charm. This is the best balance young Louis I have tasted.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“A 100% Chardonnay, sourced from vines planted in the communes of Mesnil-sur-Oger, Chouilly, Cramant, and Oiry, the 2012 Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuvée Louis Salmon evokes aromas of lemon oil, pastry, baked bread, walnuts and chalk. Medium to full-bodied, deep and seamless, it's vinous, almost creamy, with a layered, delicate structure that leads to a delicately citrusy, long and delicate finish. This Champagne is built to age, thanks to the power of the 2012 vintage and the house's signature tension. Disgorged in the second quarter of 2023 with 3.9 grams per liter dosage, it was matured 75% in stainless steel and 25% in barrels.”
“In pursuit of freshness, the 2009 Brut Blanc de Blancs Louis Salmon was vinified entirely in stainless steel, with malolactic fermentation largely blocked. Disgorged in June 2022 with a dosage of 3.8 grams per liter, it rises from the glass with aromas of orange, dried flowers and pastry, mingled with hints of licorice. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, fleshy and textural, with a rich core of fruit structured around racy acidity, culminating in a long, lemon-inflected finish. Heavily based on Cramant and complemented by fruit from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Chouilly, it derives from an early September harvest.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2023
“This is certainly not austere but there's not much sign of the richness of the vintage either. This is still extraordinarily taut for a 14-year-old wine. Dense and set for the long term. Very tightly wound – so don't serve this too cold. It deserves to unwind a bit and show its nuance and lacy delicacy – it should to be left to open out in the glass. Admirably persistent.”
96/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“This is showing an array of almonds, frangipani, dried lemons, apricots, pastries and white chocolate, evolving to salted caramel. Fantastic complexity and all in balance, with firm focus yet open and delicious. Creamy, very fine bubbles. Salty, turning chalky and mineral at the end. Drink or hold.”
“The 2007 Brut Cuvée Louis Salmon is another stellar wine from Billecart-Salmon. In many ways, it is the polar opposite of 2006. Here the team felt the wine needed body to balance the tension of the year. About half of the lots were done in barrel, while most of the wine underwent malolactic fermentation. Pretty citrus and floral notes abound. Stylistically, the 2007 is a bit more open than the 2006, even though the personalities of the two years would have suggested the exact opposite. The Louis Salmon is a blend from sites in Chouilly, Mesnil-sur-Oger and Cramant. Dosage is 7 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2020
“Deep greenish gold. Lime zest and layers of creaminess. Great balance (dosage 7 g/l apparently) and still pretty youthful. Just starting to open out. None of the oak that was evident on the nose when I tasted it before. Very much a Blanc de Blancs. Zesty rather than rich.”
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2020
“Disgorged in October 2018 with seven grams per liter dosage, the 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuvée Louis Salmon derives from the villages of Cramant, Chouilly and Mesnil-sur-Oger, and half of the vins clairs that went into the blend were vinified in older barrels. It's still tightly wound, even after over a year on cork, unfurling in the glass with a delicate bouquet of crisp yellow apple, Meyer lemon, blanched almonds, elderflower and crushed chalk. Medium to full-bodied, deep and searingly intense, it's seamless and complete, with a bracing spine of acidity, a delicate pinpoint mousse, and a long, mouthwateringly mineral finish. This is a serious, built-to-age wine that will really reward patience.”
93/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“The 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuvée Louis Salmon, anchored in Chouilly and complemented by fruit from Cramant and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, saw half of the vins clairs vinified in wood, with malolactic fermentation largely blocked. Even after eight years on cork, it remains a comparatively lean rendition, emerging from the glass with aromas of lemon confit, pastry and linden blossom, mingled with hints of verbena. On the palate, it is medium-bodied, defined by taut musculature and an incisive spine of acidity that drives a long, citrus-inflected finish. While the fruit is beginning to exhibit the first nuances of evolution, the wine remains somewhat unyielding in texture and plenitude. It was disgorged in October 2018 with a dosage of seven grams per liter.”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
essiavellan.com,
Jul 2020
“Yet another fine blanc de blancs from 2007. Chardonnay excelled presenting itself as fresh, pure and feisty. Billecart-Salmon’s Cuvée Louis comes with a sumptuous, creamy richness and fresh lemony appeal. Lemon meringue tart, baked apple and yuzu. It appley fruitiness is intense and the palate beautifully textured and long. Overt and enjoyable but lined with stylishly crisp acidity. ”
“The 2013 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon is a gorgeous, exotic Champagne. Crushed rose petal, mint, hard candy, cinnamon, kirsch, cedar and pipe tobacco all build in the glass. The 2013 boasts striking inner perfume and the textural resonance to match. There's a touch of new oak sweetness that works so well. A long growing season really helped concentrate flavors. Dosage is 4.4 grams per liter. Disgorged: January 2024.”
More Reviews +
94+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
May 2026
“Disgorged in January 2024 with a dosage of 4.4 grams per liter, the 2013 Rosé Elisabeth Salmon emerges from this cool, late-ripening vintage as a rather giving, generous rendition. It unfurls in the glass with aromas of dried apricot, dark cherry and grapefruit mingled with a subtle hint of mocha. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and enveloping, offering a sweetly fruited core underpinned by tangy acidity, culminating in a precise, perfumed finish. This is a fleshy, though somewhat old-fashioned Champagne that, at present, does not quite attain the depth of Louis Salmon of the same vintage; however, it would not be surprising to see it improve considerably with additional time on cork following disgorgement. It is composed of an almost equal blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir and was vinified almost entirely in stainless steel, with full malolactic fermentation.”
“The 2013 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon is a gorgeous, exotic Champagne. Crushed rose petal, mint, hard candy, cinnamon, kirsch, cedar and pipe tobacco all build in the glass. The 2013 boasts striking inner perfume and the textural resonance to match. There's a touch of new oak sweetness that works so well. A long growing season really helped concentrate flavors. Dosage is 4.4 grams per liter. Disgorged: January 2024.”
More Reviews +
94+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
May 2026
“Disgorged in January 2024 with a dosage of 4.4 grams per liter, the 2013 Rosé Elisabeth Salmon emerges from this cool, late-ripening vintage as a rather giving, generous rendition. It unfurls in the glass with aromas of dried apricot, dark cherry and grapefruit mingled with a subtle hint of mocha. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and enveloping, offering a sweetly fruited core underpinned by tangy acidity, culminating in a precise, perfumed finish. This is a fleshy, though somewhat old-fashioned Champagne that, at present, does not quite attain the depth of Louis Salmon of the same vintage; however, it would not be surprising to see it improve considerably with additional time on cork following disgorgement. It is composed of an almost equal blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir and was vinified almost entirely in stainless steel, with full malolactic fermentation.”
“Billecart-Salmon’s Valofroy vineyard in Mareuil-sur-Aÿ provides the colouring red-wine component to this deep, peach-toned cuvée. Outside of that, the grapes are grown in Chouilly, Avize, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Cramant, Mareuil-sur-Aÿ, Aÿ and Ambonnay. A mere 2.9% of the cuvée sees oak. Spice-laden nose, with deep Pinot Noir tones: dried apricots, sour cherry, mirabelle plums, tea and tangerine. Succulent and silky-flowing vinous palate; there is a lot of volume to it, but the wine carries itself to the long finish in a tight and seamless manner. A refined, delicious whole that already delivers a lot of pleasure. Dosage: 3.8g/l”
More Reviews +
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Disgorged in January 2023 with dosage of 3.8 grams per liter, Billecart’s 2012 Rosé Elisabeth Salmon is a dramatic, extroverted wine, soaring from the glass with a bouquet of raspberry, cherry and pink grapefruit mingled with spices and red blossoms. These aromatics usher in a medium- to full-bodied, rich and fleshy palate that is animated by succulent yet vibrant acidity and a sweet-toned core of fruit. The wine concludes with an enveloping, perfumed finish that lingers with considerable persistence. It currently exhibits less depth than the Louis Salmon of the same vintage, leading me to place greater confidence in the latter.”
97+/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“A blend of 45% Pinot Noir and 55% Chardonnay, the 2012 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon is a real success, wafting from the glass with aromas of red berries, rose, peony, orange blood and dried flowers. Medium to full-bodied, vinous and broad, it's dense and deep with a multidimensional core of fruit, racy acids and a textural structure, concluding with a long, delicate, mouthwatering finish. This is one of the finest rosé I've tasted at this address. Kudos!”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2012 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elizabeth Salmon offers up hints of red berry fruit, ginger, spice, rosewater, mint and crushed flowers. There is a feeling of classic austerity that runs through the 2012. I would prefer to cellar this for at least a few years, as it is quite reticent at this stage. Chalk, mint, white pepper and bright saline accents linger on the pointed finish. Dosage is 3.8 grams per liter. Disgorged: first trimester 2023.”
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2024
“Elisabeth Rose 2012 was effortless, juicy red fruit, so alluring, richness, concentration, delightful elegance. This is really special champagne, there is real density of fruit with that ultra-light floaty feel on the palate. Long length of flavour and will benefit at least five years more post disgorgement time.”
96/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Consistently great quality with harmonious flavours and some vinosity throughout the flight. The 2012 vintage has a bright salmon pink colour and depth of flavour, including floral, clementine, wild strawberry and white peach notes. It also has cinnamon cookies and vanilla touch. The creamy mouthfeel satisfies the palate, leading to a lingering finish with a touch of lemon zest. Still youthful, and expected to age longer.”
“The 2012 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elizabeth Salmon offers up hints of red berry fruit, ginger, spice, rosewater, mint and crushed flowers. There is a feeling of classic austerity that runs through the 2012. I would prefer to cellar this for at least a few years, as it is quite reticent at this stage. Chalk, mint, white pepper and bright saline accents linger on the pointed finish. Dosage is 3.8 grams per liter. Disgorged: first trimester 2023.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“Billecart-Salmon’s Valofroy vineyard in Mareuil-sur-Aÿ provides the colouring red-wine component to this deep, peach-toned cuvée. Outside of that, the grapes are grown in Chouilly, Avize, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Cramant, Mareuil-sur-Aÿ, Aÿ and Ambonnay. A mere 2.9% of the cuvée sees oak. Spice-laden nose, with deep Pinot Noir tones: dried apricots, sour cherry, mirabelle plums, tea and tangerine. Succulent and silky-flowing vinous palate; there is a lot of volume to it, but the wine carries itself to the long finish in a tight and seamless manner. A refined, delicious whole that already delivers a lot of pleasure. Dosage: 3.8g/l”
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Disgorged in January 2023 with dosage of 3.8 grams per liter, Billecart’s 2012 Rosé Elisabeth Salmon is a dramatic, extroverted wine, soaring from the glass with a bouquet of raspberry, cherry and pink grapefruit mingled with spices and red blossoms. These aromatics usher in a medium- to full-bodied, rich and fleshy palate that is animated by succulent yet vibrant acidity and a sweet-toned core of fruit. The wine concludes with an enveloping, perfumed finish that lingers with considerable persistence. It currently exhibits less depth than the Louis Salmon of the same vintage, leading me to place greater confidence in the latter.”
97+/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“A blend of 45% Pinot Noir and 55% Chardonnay, the 2012 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon is a real success, wafting from the glass with aromas of red berries, rose, peony, orange blood and dried flowers. Medium to full-bodied, vinous and broad, it's dense and deep with a multidimensional core of fruit, racy acids and a textural structure, concluding with a long, delicate, mouthwatering finish. This is one of the finest rosé I've tasted at this address. Kudos!”
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2024
“Elisabeth Rose 2012 was effortless, juicy red fruit, so alluring, richness, concentration, delightful elegance. This is really special champagne, there is real density of fruit with that ultra-light floaty feel on the palate. Long length of flavour and will benefit at least five years more post disgorgement time.”
96/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Consistently great quality with harmonious flavours and some vinosity throughout the flight. The 2012 vintage has a bright salmon pink colour and depth of flavour, including floral, clementine, wild strawberry and white peach notes. It also has cinnamon cookies and vanilla touch. The creamy mouthfeel satisfies the palate, leading to a lingering finish with a touch of lemon zest. Still youthful, and expected to age longer.”
“Incorporating fully 10% still red wine, Billecart's 2009 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon is showing beautifully, delivering fragrant aromas of plums, stone fruits, petals, sweet spices and marzipan. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and elegant, it's seamless and pillowy, with bright acids and a pure, precise profile, concluding with a bright, saline finish. In 2009, it was vinified entirely in stainless steel.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2022
“A wonderfully open nose immediately presents ripe red currant framed by notions as various as fresh gingerbread, iron oxide, berry sherbet, orange peel, candied tangerine and caramel: richness and freshness united. The palate is smooth with fine, vivid effervescence that propels the wine’s inherent freshness continually to the surface, both countering and complementing a certain roundness, a certain gourmandise that shimmers with red fruit, ripe, aromatic citrus and stony spice. A most gastronomic Champagne that will evolve beautifully.”
96/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“Copper-orange color with aromas of grapefruit pith, cherry stones, dried roses, white pepper, pastries, walnuts and oyster shells. Refined and elegant with pretty, dried red and citrus fruit, layered with subtle spice and toast. Fine bubbles. Dry. 55% pinot noir from Mareuil-sur-Ay and Ay, and 45% Grand Cru chardonnay from Cote des Blancs, with 10% of pinot noir red wine. Dosage 7g/L. Disgorged in July 2021. Drink or hold.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Very pale glowing salmon-orange colour. Rich, complex, burnished copper (somehow) nose. Very luscious and seductive. Strawberry flavours but not sweet and simple at all. Creamy-smooth texture but with quite enough acidity – even in this ripe vintage – to keep this wine appetising and intriguing on the finish. Great stuff! A wine to send you to the table…
Drink 2021–2028”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Aug 2022
“An elegant rosé Champagne that seamlessly knits juicy acidity and fine-grained texture with a subtle, smoke-laced underpinning and a delicate mesh of wild strawberry, kirsch, mandarin orange peel and toasted brioche flavors. Harmonious, with an open-knit, spiced finish. Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. Disgorged July 2021. Drink now through 2029.”
95/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Medium pink salmon colour. Alluring nose of sakura cherry blossom, redcurrant, blood orange and strawberry am with gingerbread and anise. The combination of vinous textures and fine mousse is pleasing on the palate. Concentrated and fleshy fruits continue towards the finish with candied-orange naunces.”
“Incorporating fully 10% still red wine, Billecart's 2009 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon is showing beautifully, delivering fragrant aromas of plums, stone fruits, petals, sweet spices and marzipan. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and elegant, it's seamless and pillowy, with bright acids and a pure, precise profile, concluding with a bright, saline finish. In 2009, it was vinified entirely in stainless steel.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2022
“A wonderfully open nose immediately presents ripe red currant framed by notions as various as fresh gingerbread, iron oxide, berry sherbet, orange peel, candied tangerine and caramel: richness and freshness united. The palate is smooth with fine, vivid effervescence that propels the wine’s inherent freshness continually to the surface, both countering and complementing a certain roundness, a certain gourmandise that shimmers with red fruit, ripe, aromatic citrus and stony spice. A most gastronomic Champagne that will evolve beautifully.”
96/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“Copper-orange color with aromas of grapefruit pith, cherry stones, dried roses, white pepper, pastries, walnuts and oyster shells. Refined and elegant with pretty, dried red and citrus fruit, layered with subtle spice and toast. Fine bubbles. Dry. 55% pinot noir from Mareuil-sur-Ay and Ay, and 45% Grand Cru chardonnay from Cote des Blancs, with 10% of pinot noir red wine. Dosage 7g/L. Disgorged in July 2021. Drink or hold.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Aug 2022
“An elegant rosé Champagne that seamlessly knits juicy acidity and fine-grained texture with a subtle, smoke-laced underpinning and a delicate mesh of wild strawberry, kirsch, mandarin orange peel and toasted brioche flavors. Harmonious, with an open-knit, spiced finish. Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. Disgorged July 2021. Drink now through 2029.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Very pale glowing salmon-orange colour. Rich, complex, burnished copper (somehow) nose. Very luscious and seductive. Strawberry flavours but not sweet and simple at all. Creamy-smooth texture but with quite enough acidity – even in this ripe vintage – to keep this wine appetising and intriguing on the finish. Great stuff! A wine to send you to the table…
Drink 2021–2028”
95/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Medium pink salmon colour. Alluring nose of sakura cherry blossom, redcurrant, blood orange and strawberry am with gingerbread and anise. The combination of vinous textures and fine mousse is pleasing on the palate. Concentrated and fleshy fruits continue towards the finish with candied-orange naunces.”
“The colour is invitingly glossy salmon pink and the nose full of charms. Almost two years of post-disgorgement time have ensured such openness and generosity. There is lots of delicious primary fruit like red cherry, strawberry, baked peach, lemon and blood orange. Age-derived complexity comes across in the form of spices, liquorice, and even leather, once given proper time in the glass to fully express itself. Still the most gorgeous feature of this cuvée is the phenomenally creamy texture. Billecart have for the first time used some oak barrels in the crafting of this cuvée (17%), which surely has aided in creating this appetising fleshiness, silkiness and caressing creaminess on the palate. Crisp by nature for sure, it isn’t too acidity driven due to that richness filling the mid-palate. Tannins are beautifully low-key yet the wine has beautiful structure to it. The carry is long and seamless with pure, fruity, palate-cleansing finishing notions. An exquisite Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon. The added bonus is that there will be magnums for the very first time”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Deep salmon pink colour, with onion-skin hues that speak of evolution. The truly complex nose combines primary fruit of cherry, strawberry, tangerine and apricot. But there is much more to it than mere fruit, with spicy liquorice tones and spirity Cointreau whiffs adding further complexity. Billecart has, for the first time, used some oak barrels (17%) in the crafting of this cuvée. The palate brings on a much tighter, more reserved side of the wine. High in acidity but not overly so; the silkiness charms, and the soft tannic bite brings a further element of freshness and firmness. Youthful still, and built to last, this is a truly fine Elisabeth Salmon.”
97+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Disgorged with seven grams per liter dosage, the 2008 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon is one of the finest wines I've tasted from Billecart in recent years. Unwinding in the glass with aromas of peach, mandarin oil, warm bread, red berries and petals, it's full-bodied, deep and vinous, with lovely mid-palate amplitude, terrific concentration and bright girdling acids. In what is quite a tightly wound vintage and from a house whose style is rather understated, this is a dramatic, fleshy wine that concludes with a long, flavorful finish.”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2008 Brut Rosé Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon explodes from the glass with a mesmerizing array of aromas, flavors and textures. Blood orange, cinnamon, mint and dried flowers. The 2008 is incredibly young, but it is also incredibly tempting. Patience will be rewarded. In the meantime, readers might enjoy adding a few bottles of the stellar 2007 to their cellars, as the nervy, taut 2008 needs time”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2021
“Orangey bronze colour. Very luscious, strawberry fruit nose is really rather captivating! Then quite tight and refreshing enough on the palate to suggest there is no great hurry to drink this. Seriously long, throat-consoling finish. Well-judged mousse.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“This deep salmon pink wine is a study in subtlety. It is gently fragrant and takes time to open up. At first, the nose is rather creamy, even lactic, but then, slowly, redcurrant and blood orange appear with an aromatic overtone of potentilla. The palate, with very fine mousse, exquisite texture and balance, then veers into a most Pinot-esque direction that reveals truffle and a dimension of earthiness and undergrowth. It shimmers with white pepper and has a touch of toasted hazelnut on the bright finish. A real treat.”
95/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Surprisingly still youthful, with fresh strawberry, cranberry and pomegranate. Delicate pure fruits are balanced by crisp and sharp acidity. Flavours such as toast, marzipan and vanilla custard add another dimension to the wine. A seamless and silky mouthfeel leads to a flinty, elegant finish. Promising for futher ageing.”
“Full bottle 1,634 g. Only the 10th edition of this unique single-vineyard champagne from a small, 1-ha, walled plot behind the winery in Mareuil-sur-Aÿ planted with Pinot Noir in 1964. (The inaugural vintage was 1995.) Vinified entirely in oak casks and aged on lees and only just released after ageing for 15 years on lees. Disgorged early 2024. Dosage 2 g/l.
Deep golden straw colour. Extremely complex, mildly pungent nose with layers of sandalwood and kumquats and obviously considerable autolysis but it’s still extremely fresh. Quite a triumph! And not a copy of another style of champagne. Really intense yet refreshing enough to enjoy as an (admittedly luxurious) aperitif. Scrumptious!”
More Reviews +
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Billecart-Salmon’s 2009 Le Clos Saint-Hilaire, disgorged in January 2024 with a dosage of two grams per liter, is showing even more impressively than it did when I tasted it with only a year on cork after disgorgement. The bouquet is deep and expressive, revealing notes of dried apricot, pear, blanched almond and orange oil, mingled with cherry plum and a touch of Madagascar vanilla. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and rich yet incisive, its amplitude deftly counterbalanced by racy acidity before culminating in a persistent, citrus-tinged finish that underscores the wine’s fresh, tight-knit profile—enhance by its non-malolactic style.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2009 Extra Brut Le Clos Saint-Hilaire is stellar. I can’t remember a young Clos Saint-Hilaire with this much sheer immediacy. Then again, we are talking about 2009. Blood orange, spice, gingerbread and new leather play off a core of vibrant, red-toned Pinot fruit. Blocking the malolactic fermentation further emphasizes energy. The 2009 finishes with mind-blowing purity and exceptional finesse. This is the first vintage with some of the production bottled in magnum. The essence of Pinot. Dosage is 2 grams per liter. Disgorged: January 2024.”
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“This champagne leaps out the glass, a mix of dark PN fruit and toasted almonds and hints of marzipan. The palate brings forward the clos chalky charm and salinity with super fresh acidity cutting through the toasty oak character. The palate builds within minutes to show more dark cherry, plum, dark chocolate and coffee and underneath you see grapefruit, ripe apricot and finishing bitter orange. Started showing off an oxidative edge and transitioned to become gently reductive. Fascinating as displays some tropical notes, from the hot summer, yet has a very significant “clos influence” of minerality from the soils. Drink now to 2035”
95/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“Sourced from a walled 0.97-hectare vineyard planted in 1964 and vinified entirely in oak, the 2009 Le Clos Saint-Hilaire remains true to its lineage, offering maturity and richness—more so than most other parcels in Mareuil-sur-Aÿ. Released ahead of the 2008 vintage and disgorged in January 2024 with a dosage of two grams per liter, it unfurls from the glass with a deep, concentrated bouquet of ripe orchard fruits, dried apricot, toasted nuts and exotic spices mingling with orange zest. On the palate, it is full-bodied and concentrated, textural and multidimensional, exuding richness and a more muscular personality than any other wine in Billecart’s portfolio. Underpinned by succulent yet racy acidity—enhanced by blocked malolactic fermentation—it concludes with a long finish, accentuated by the attractive bitterness of Pinot Noir phenolics. Expect a wine that is more demonstrative than the cool-vintage 2007, yet more mellow and immediately seductive than the 2006.”
“Full of life on the nose and richly textured on the palate. Thoroughly satisfying wine with quite a bit of body that reaches every crevice of the palate. Firm, savoury finish. A serious, dense champagne for the table.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2005 Brut Le Clos Saint-Hilaire is sublime. Silky and understated, the 2005 is a model of class. The mousse alone is utterly captivating. Dried pear, gentle hints of spice, dried flowers and mint are some of the many notes that grace the 2005. In this vintage, Le Clos Saint-Hilaire is quite soft and medium in body, a Champagne of refinement more than power. Orchard fruit, white flowers and bright saline undertones frame the long, very pure finish. ”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Apr 2023
“Disgorged at the end of 2019 with a dosage of one gram per liter, Billecart-Salmon’s 2005 Brut Le Clos Saint-Hilaire is the eighth edition (the release sequence is 1995, 1996, 1998, 1999, 2002, 2003, 2006 and 2005; Mathieu Roland-Billecart released this vintage after the 2006, to give it more time to mature in bottle.) This 100% Pinot Noir from the single vineyard in Mareuil-sur-Aÿ has a bright, vibrant, fresh nose of orchard fruits, dried fruits, nuts, pastry and spices. The palate is tense, delicate and medium-bodied and evokes notes of white pepper and chalk with a saline finish and a gently bitter aftertaste due to the vintage. It's a little more austere than the 2006 vintage but precise and crystalline.”
“Based on the 2018 vintage, Billecart's newly released NV Brut Réserve incorporates fully 53% reserve wines, up from just over a third in the past, and incorporates the usual 40% Pinot Meunier in the blend. Offering up attractive aromas of citrus zest, green apple and freshly baked bread, it's medium to full-bodied, fleshy and charming, with a demonstrative core of fruit and a pretty pinpoint mousse, concluding with a saline finish.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“Based on the 2020 vintage (the youngest vintage serves as the “base” of a bottling, even if it does not represent the majority of the blend) and incorporating 71% reserve wines—half stored as individual vintages and the other half as a perpetual reserve initiated in 2006—Billecart-Salmon’s latest NV Le Réserve is showing nicely. It offers aromas of green pear, honeysuckle, brioche and white peach. Disgorged in early 2024 with a dosage of three grams per liter, this reimagined cuvée has recently undergone a significant reduction in dosage. The sweetness that so often presents itself on the finish of NV Champagnes from Grandes Marques is no more. Medium to full-bodied, lively and charming, with a textural attack and vibrant acidity, it culminates in a long, precise finish. This reinvented cuvée replaces the Brut Réserve and, beyond the lowered dosage, sees a stricter fruit selection, an additional 20 months of aging sur lattes (now totaling 50 months) and an increased proportion of the perpetual reserve.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Fragrantly floral Meunier fruit comes across strongly on the bright, expressive nose here. There's a complex melange of red and white fruit, with attractive toastiness and sweet pastry tones. A similar sense of skilful crafting continues on the lightweight palate, which is harmonious and perfectly fresh. The vast 50-60% of reserve wines increase the complexity of the blend. This is smooth-textured, with an appetising sweetness at the finish. Dosage 8g/l”
91/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Based on the 2020 vintage, this blend of 43% Pinot Meunier, 29% Chardonnay and 28% Pinot Noir, with 71% vins de réserve and 10% perpetual reserve, the NV Brut Réserve offers up aromas of spring flowers, herbs, blossoms, lime and brioche. Medium to full-bodied, tense and precise, with a crystalline texture enhanced by bright acids, this is a long, delicate and ethereal Champagne. It matured 8% in barrels and 36 months on the lees in bottle, followed by six months after disgorgement with three grams per liter dosage.”
90/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Aug 2019
“Based on the 2015 vintage and disgorged with nine grams per liter dosage, the latest release of Billecart's NV Brut Réserve contains fully 55% reserve wines and is showing very well, offering up complex aromas of warm bread, crisp green orchard fruit and citrus oil. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied and charming but lively, with an elegantly textural attack, a fleshy core of fruit and lively balancing acids.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2019
“There is a QR code but it doesn’t tell people how old the cuvée is. ‘I don’t have the marketing resources to do this’, says Mathieu Billecart. They update it once a year – ‘though we’re not as precise as Krug’. 55% reserve wines. 40% Pinot Meunier, 30% Pinot Noir, 20% Chardonnay. For the last five years there has been a little bit of oak fermentation for 3 to 5% of the wine. The base is 2014, 2013 and 2012 and some solera. Dosage 9 g/l.
Nicely melded nose even if the whole impression is on the fruity side. Tight and fresh. But with very frank fruit aromas. Slightly drying on the end but brisk and fresh, even if dominantly fruity.”
90/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2013
“(40% pinot meunier, 30% pinot noir and 30% chardonnay; L200352): Light, bright gold. Fresh red berries, orange zest and white flowers on the perfumed nose. Juicy and precise, offering energetic redcurrant and blood orange flavors that show good concentration and a supple texture. A mineral nuance adds bite to the finish, with the floral note echoing.”
“Based on the 2018 vintage, Billecart's newly released NV Brut Réserve incorporates fully 53% reserve wines, up from just over a third in the past, and incorporates the usual 40% Pinot Meunier in the blend. Offering up attractive aromas of citrus zest, green apple and freshly baked bread, it's medium to full-bodied, fleshy and charming, with a demonstrative core of fruit and a pretty pinpoint mousse, concluding with a saline finish.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“Based on the 2020 vintage (the youngest vintage serves as the “base” of a bottling, even if it does not represent the majority of the blend) and incorporating 71% reserve wines—half stored as individual vintages and the other half as a perpetual reserve initiated in 2006—Billecart-Salmon’s latest NV Le Réserve is showing nicely. It offers aromas of green pear, honeysuckle, brioche and white peach. Disgorged in early 2024 with a dosage of three grams per liter, this reimagined cuvée has recently undergone a significant reduction in dosage. The sweetness that so often presents itself on the finish of NV Champagnes from Grandes Marques is no more. Medium to full-bodied, lively and charming, with a textural attack and vibrant acidity, it culminates in a long, precise finish. This reinvented cuvée replaces the Brut Réserve and, beyond the lowered dosage, sees a stricter fruit selection, an additional 20 months of aging sur lattes (now totaling 50 months) and an increased proportion of the perpetual reserve.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Fragrantly floral Meunier fruit comes across strongly on the bright, expressive nose here. There's a complex melange of red and white fruit, with attractive toastiness and sweet pastry tones. A similar sense of skilful crafting continues on the lightweight palate, which is harmonious and perfectly fresh. The vast 50-60% of reserve wines increase the complexity of the blend. This is smooth-textured, with an appetising sweetness at the finish. Dosage 8g/l”
91/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Based on the 2020 vintage, this blend of 43% Pinot Meunier, 29% Chardonnay and 28% Pinot Noir, with 71% vins de réserve and 10% perpetual reserve, the NV Brut Réserve offers up aromas of spring flowers, herbs, blossoms, lime and brioche. Medium to full-bodied, tense and precise, with a crystalline texture enhanced by bright acids, this is a long, delicate and ethereal Champagne. It matured 8% in barrels and 36 months on the lees in bottle, followed by six months after disgorgement with three grams per liter dosage.”
90/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Aug 2019
“Based on the 2015 vintage and disgorged with nine grams per liter dosage, the latest release of Billecart's NV Brut Réserve contains fully 55% reserve wines and is showing very well, offering up complex aromas of warm bread, crisp green orchard fruit and citrus oil. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied and charming but lively, with an elegantly textural attack, a fleshy core of fruit and lively balancing acids.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2019
“There is a QR code but it doesn’t tell people how old the cuvée is. ‘I don’t have the marketing resources to do this’, says Mathieu Billecart. They update it once a year – ‘though we’re not as precise as Krug’. 55% reserve wines. 40% Pinot Meunier, 30% Pinot Noir, 20% Chardonnay. For the last five years there has been a little bit of oak fermentation for 3 to 5% of the wine. The base is 2014, 2013 and 2012 and some solera. Dosage 9 g/l.
Nicely melded nose even if the whole impression is on the fruity side. Tight and fresh. But with very frank fruit aromas. Slightly drying on the end but brisk and fresh, even if dominantly fruity.”
90/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2013
“(40% pinot meunier, 30% pinot noir and 30% chardonnay; L200352): Light, bright gold. Fresh red berries, orange zest and white flowers on the perfumed nose. Juicy and precise, offering energetic redcurrant and blood orange flavors that show good concentration and a supple texture. A mineral nuance adds bite to the finish, with the floral note echoing.”
“Created in the 1960s, an era when rosés were not en vogue, this cuvée was envisaged 'not to look or taste too much like a rosé'. With its genius recipe, today this wine belongs among Champagne's most emblematic rosés. It comes with a hallmark delicate peachy colour and a pristine nose of delicious peach fruit. Its further charms include a whiff of roses, soft spiciness, apple compote, pencil shavings and apricot marmalade. The ethereal lightness of the palate suits the delicacy of the whole. Silky, dynamic and vibrantly fruity, it all comes together in a finish of perfect purity and suitably dry deliciousness. Disgorged 1/22; dosage 9g/l”
More Reviews +
91/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2018 vintage, Billecart's new NV Brut Rosé incorporates 40% reserve wines and some 6% still red wine. Bursting with scents of sweet red berries, peonies, stone fruits, white cherries, freshly baked bread and spices, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and charming, with a seamless and enveloping core of fruit and a lively, fine-boned profile.”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Aromas of rose, peony, red berries and guava preface the NV Brut Rosé, a medium to full-bodied, elegant and vinous Champagne rosé that concludes with a long, ethereal finish enhanced by menthol notes. A blend of 45% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 20% Pinot Meunier, it's based on the 2014 vintage with 46% vins de réserve from nine different vintages and the addition of 6% as a red wine, vinified and matured in stainless steel. Dosage: 4.7 grams per liter.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2018
“Tasted blind. Very pale greyish salmon. Rich rose-petal aroma with quite a bit of voluptuous sweetness. Crisp acidity. Brisk but satisfying. Slightly astringent end.
Drink 2018-2024”
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Jan 2015
“(45% Chardonnay, 30% Pinot Noir and 25% Pinot Meunier; 8 g/l dosage; L206454 17741): Pale orange. High-pitched red berry, orange zest and jasmine aromas, with suave mineral and smoky lees notes adding complexity. Spicy and precise on the palate, showing very good punch to its strawberry and bitter cherry flavors. Opens up smoothly with air and picks up a bitter rhubarb quality that lingers onto the long, tightly focused finish. This bottling showed more brawny character than many past renditions of this cuvée, but with no lack of vivacity.”
92/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Jan 2016
“This pale-pink wine is stylish, crisp and relatively dry. Full of wild strawberry and citrus, it is lively, bright and lightly perfumed. The texture shows a touch of tannin as well as delicate minerality. Drink this well-balanced wine now.”
“Created in the 1960s, an era when rosés were not en vogue, this cuvée was envisaged 'not to look or taste too much like a rosé'. With its genius recipe, today this wine belongs among Champagne's most emblematic rosés. It comes with a hallmark delicate peachy colour and a pristine nose of delicious peach fruit. Its further charms include a whiff of roses, soft spiciness, apple compote, pencil shavings and apricot marmalade. The ethereal lightness of the palate suits the delicacy of the whole. Silky, dynamic and vibrantly fruity, it all comes together in a finish of perfect purity and suitably dry deliciousness. Disgorged 1/22; dosage 9g/l”
More Reviews +
91/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2018 vintage, Billecart's new NV Brut Rosé incorporates 40% reserve wines and some 6% still red wine. Bursting with scents of sweet red berries, peonies, stone fruits, white cherries, freshly baked bread and spices, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and charming, with a seamless and enveloping core of fruit and a lively, fine-boned profile.”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Aromas of rose, peony, red berries and guava preface the NV Brut Rosé, a medium to full-bodied, elegant and vinous Champagne rosé that concludes with a long, ethereal finish enhanced by menthol notes. A blend of 45% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 20% Pinot Meunier, it's based on the 2014 vintage with 46% vins de réserve from nine different vintages and the addition of 6% as a red wine, vinified and matured in stainless steel. Dosage: 4.7 grams per liter.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2018
“Tasted blind. Very pale greyish salmon. Rich rose-petal aroma with quite a bit of voluptuous sweetness. Crisp acidity. Brisk but satisfying. Slightly astringent end.
Drink 2018-2024”
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Jan 2015
“(45% Chardonnay, 30% Pinot Noir and 25% Pinot Meunier; 8 g/l dosage; L206454 17741): Pale orange. High-pitched red berry, orange zest and jasmine aromas, with suave mineral and smoky lees notes adding complexity. Spicy and precise on the palate, showing very good punch to its strawberry and bitter cherry flavors. Opens up smoothly with air and picks up a bitter rhubarb quality that lingers onto the long, tightly focused finish. This bottling showed more brawny character than many past renditions of this cuvée, but with no lack of vivacity.”
92/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Jan 2016
“This pale-pink wine is stylish, crisp and relatively dry. Full of wild strawberry and citrus, it is lively, bright and lightly perfumed. The texture shows a touch of tannin as well as delicate minerality. Drink this well-balanced wine now.”
“Billecart-Salmon’s 2012 Nicolas François marks the first release since 2008 and stands as another success. The fundamentals remain unchanged: settling and fermentation at low temperatures, a small proportion vinified in oak barrels and partial malolactic fermentation (20% was blocked in 2012). This vintage was characterized by a prolonged flowering period, significant rainfall and mildew pressure, resulting in a small crop. The harvest of fruit, which contributed to this cuvée, took place between September 17 and 22. "It was crucial to select only the ripest fruit, as maturation varied significantly between plots," explains Billecart’s head winemaker, Florent Nys. But what of the wine itself? Disgorged in May 2023 with a dosage of 3.8 grams per liter, it exudes aromas of candied lemon, honeysuckle and ripe peach, mingling with nuances of beeswax and orange zest. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and enveloping, boasting a layered, concentrated core, a chalky structure and mouthwatering acidity, despite the warm vintage. It concludes with a persistent, saline finish, hinting at the savory complexity that has emerged with such notable bottle age. Compared to the 2008, which remains tightly coiled, the 2012 is broader-shouldered and more demonstrative.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2012 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart shows all the natural radiance of the year. There's gorgeous resonance and texture here. Apricot, spice, tangerine oil and lightly honeyed notes infuse the palate with notable depth and persistence. This rich, expansive Champage has a ton to offer. This release was disgorged nearly two years ago, which also adds to its complexity. Dosage is 3.8 grams per liter. Disgorged: May 2023.”
97/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Apr 2025
“This complex Champagne has delicious aromas. It’s electric on the palate, which is creamy yet structured and focused. It has a Long and tense finish.”
“Billecart-Salmon’s 2012 Nicolas François marks the first release since 2008 and stands as another success. The fundamentals remain unchanged: settling and fermentation at low temperatures, a small proportion vinified in oak barrels and partial malolactic fermentation (20% was blocked in 2012). This vintage was characterized by a prolonged flowering period, significant rainfall and mildew pressure, resulting in a small crop. The harvest of fruit, which contributed to this cuvée, took place between September 17 and 22. "It was crucial to select only the ripest fruit, as maturation varied significantly between plots," explains Billecart’s head winemaker, Florent Nys. But what of the wine itself? Disgorged in May 2023 with a dosage of 3.8 grams per liter, it exudes aromas of candied lemon, honeysuckle and ripe peach, mingling with nuances of beeswax and orange zest. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and enveloping, boasting a layered, concentrated core, a chalky structure and mouthwatering acidity, despite the warm vintage. It concludes with a persistent, saline finish, hinting at the savory complexity that has emerged with such notable bottle age. Compared to the 2008, which remains tightly coiled, the 2012 is broader-shouldered and more demonstrative.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2012 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart shows all the natural radiance of the year. There's gorgeous resonance and texture here. Apricot, spice, tangerine oil and lightly honeyed notes infuse the palate with notable depth and persistence. This rich, expansive Champage has a ton to offer. This release was disgorged nearly two years ago, which also adds to its complexity. Dosage is 3.8 grams per liter. Disgorged: May 2023.”
97/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Apr 2025
“This complex Champagne has delicious aromas. It’s electric on the palate, which is creamy yet structured and focused. It has a Long and tense finish.”
“Billecart-Salmon’s 2012 Nicolas François marks the first release since 2008 and stands as another success. The fundamentals remain unchanged: settling and fermentation at low temperatures, a small proportion vinified in oak barrels and partial malolactic fermentation (20% was blocked in 2012). This vintage was characterized by a prolonged flowering period, significant rainfall and mildew pressure, resulting in a small crop. The harvest of fruit, which contributed to this cuvée, took place between September 17 and 22. "It was crucial to select only the ripest fruit, as maturation varied significantly between plots," explains Billecart’s head winemaker, Florent Nys. But what of the wine itself? Disgorged in May 2023 with a dosage of 3.8 grams per liter, it exudes aromas of candied lemon, honeysuckle and ripe peach, mingling with nuances of beeswax and orange zest. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and enveloping, boasting a layered, concentrated core, a chalky structure and mouthwatering acidity, despite the warm vintage. It concludes with a persistent, saline finish, hinting at the savory complexity that has emerged with such notable bottle age. Compared to the 2008, which remains tightly coiled, the 2012 is broader-shouldered and more demonstrative.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2012 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart shows all the natural radiance of the year. There's gorgeous resonance and texture here. Apricot, spice, tangerine oil and lightly honeyed notes infuse the palate with notable depth and persistence. This rich, expansive Champage has a ton to offer. This release was disgorged nearly two years ago, which also adds to its complexity. Dosage is 3.8 grams per liter. Disgorged: May 2023.”
97/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Apr 2025
“This complex Champagne has delicious aromas. It’s electric on the palate, which is creamy yet structured and focused. It has a Long and tense finish.”
“Billecart-Salmon are one of the last houses to bring out their 2008 prestige cuvée after having it spend glorious 150 months on lees. The age-complexed nose is creamy with toffee layers as well as notable oaky presence. Sweet honey tones mark its autumnal red fruit profile of intriguing aromatic complexity. The palate comes with a refreshing contrast to the nose with its linear and driven palate of mouthwatering acidity. Some of the racy contrast comes from Billecart-Salmon going for as low a dosage as 2,9g/l, as they felt more would have masked the fruit and brought heaviness. Structure-wise it is suggesting great longevity and I am greatly looking forward to following its evolution. ”
More Reviews +
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Originating from a late September harvest in a cool, late-ripening season and disgorged in January 2022 with a dosage of 2.9 grams per liter, the 2008 Nicolas François is showing superbly. It opens with an aromatic array of lemon oil, quince, nashi pear and honeysuckle, segueing into a medium-bodied and chiseled yet layered palate. A crisp core of fruit deftly cloaks the vintage’s brisk acidity, avoiding the taut austerity that the year can occasionally impart. Long and penetrating, animated by a pinpoint mousse, the wine’s aromatic promise translates seamlessly from nose to palate. It comes warmly recommended and will continue to deliver considerable pleasure for years to come. Produced from 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, with malolactic fermentation largely blocked, it enhances the vintage’s refreshing profile.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2008 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart is an electric, nervy Champagne that very much reflects the style of the year. Crushed rocks, mint, spice, dried herbs, hazelnut, lemon peel and marzipan are all beautifully laced together. The 2008 is just entering its first plateau of maturity, making it a fine choice for drinking now and over the next two decades, possibly more. The blend id 60% Pinot Noir (from Mareuil-sur-Aÿ, Ambonnay, Bouzy, Verzy and Verzenay) and 40% Chardonnay (from Mesnil, Chouilly and Cramant). It's a terrific effort, although I must add that a recent visit made it pretty clear that even better things lie ahead. Dosage is 4 grams per liter.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2023
“The 2008 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François was disgorged during the third quarter of 2022 with less than three grams per liter. It has a delicate, pure, clean bouquet with aromas of orchard fruits, spring flowers, honey and licorice, with hints of brioche and pastry with aeration. Medium to full-bodied, chiseled and crystalline, with racy acids and a chalky texture, the palate is tense and the finish is long, penetrating and salty. It exhibits perfect Billecart style, yet tension is present, a sign of the vintage. It is a blend of 60% Pinot Noir (sourced from Aÿ, Mareuil and Verzenay) and 40% Chardonnay from Mesnil, Chouilly and Cramant, and it matured 83% in tanks and 17% in old oak barrels.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Apr 2023
“Lovely precision and drive to this with aromas of lemon curd, brioche, praline, apricots, pomelos, mandarin zest and salted caramel. It’s held together by a sharp, citrusy backbone of acidity, balanced with a fine, silky mousse. Both structure and softness here. Citrus fruit brightness on a beautifully elegant and seamless finish. 60% pinot noir and 40% chardonnay. 150 months on lees. 2.9g/L dosage.”
“Billecart-Salmon are one of the last houses to bring out their 2008 prestige cuvée after having it spend glorious 150 months on lees. The age-complexed nose is creamy with toffee layers as well as notable oaky presence. Sweet honey tones mark its autumnal red fruit profile of intriguing aromatic complexity. The palate comes with a refreshing contrast to the nose with its linear and driven palate of mouthwatering acidity. Some of the racy contrast comes from Billecart-Salmon going for as low a dosage as 2,9g/l, as they felt more would have masked the fruit and brought heaviness. Structure-wise it is suggesting great longevity and I am greatly looking forward to following its evolution. ”
More Reviews +
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“Originating from a late September harvest in a cool, late-ripening season and disgorged in January 2022 with a dosage of 2.9 grams per liter, the 2008 Nicolas François is showing superbly. It opens with an aromatic array of lemon oil, quince, nashi pear and honeysuckle, segueing into a medium-bodied and chiseled yet layered palate. A crisp core of fruit deftly cloaks the vintage’s brisk acidity, avoiding the taut austerity that the year can occasionally impart. Long and penetrating, animated by a pinpoint mousse, the wine’s aromatic promise translates seamlessly from nose to palate. It comes warmly recommended and will continue to deliver considerable pleasure for years to come. Produced from 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, with malolactic fermentation largely blocked, it enhances the vintage’s refreshing profile.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2008 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart is an electric, nervy Champagne that very much reflects the style of the year. Crushed rocks, mint, spice, dried herbs, hazelnut, lemon peel and marzipan are all beautifully laced together. The 2008 is just entering its first plateau of maturity, making it a fine choice for drinking now and over the next two decades, possibly more. The blend id 60% Pinot Noir (from Mareuil-sur-Aÿ, Ambonnay, Bouzy, Verzy and Verzenay) and 40% Chardonnay (from Mesnil, Chouilly and Cramant). It's a terrific effort, although I must add that a recent visit made it pretty clear that even better things lie ahead. Dosage is 4 grams per liter.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2023
“The 2008 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François was disgorged during the third quarter of 2022 with less than three grams per liter. It has a delicate, pure, clean bouquet with aromas of orchard fruits, spring flowers, honey and licorice, with hints of brioche and pastry with aeration. Medium to full-bodied, chiseled and crystalline, with racy acids and a chalky texture, the palate is tense and the finish is long, penetrating and salty. It exhibits perfect Billecart style, yet tension is present, a sign of the vintage. It is a blend of 60% Pinot Noir (sourced from Aÿ, Mareuil and Verzenay) and 40% Chardonnay from Mesnil, Chouilly and Cramant, and it matured 83% in tanks and 17% in old oak barrels.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Apr 2023
“Lovely precision and drive to this with aromas of lemon curd, brioche, praline, apricots, pomelos, mandarin zest and salted caramel. It’s held together by a sharp, citrusy backbone of acidity, balanced with a fine, silky mousse. Both structure and softness here. Citrus fruit brightness on a beautifully elegant and seamless finish. 60% pinot noir and 40% chardonnay. 150 months on lees. 2.9g/L dosage.”
“The 2007 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François continues to show beautifully, wafting from the glass with scents of sweet orchard fruit, citrus oil, clear honey, white flowers, buttery pastry and warm biscuits. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and incisive, with racy acids, a vibrant core of fruit and a pillowy, elegant profile, it concludes with a long, penetrating finish.”
More Reviews +
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Dec 2020
“This is a laser-guided Champagne with fabulous energy and intensity with a tight palate, racy acidity and super fine phenolics. It goes on and on. Fine bubbles. Light pine and praline character. One for the cellar. 60% pinot noir and 40% chardonnay. Disgorged 19 July, 2020. Wonderful now, but needs time to come together. Better from 2024 onwards.”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The pale gold colour shows some evolution, while the intensely fruity nose comes across more red-fruit-dominant, with apple and apricot meeting pastry and spicy tones. Fruity power continues on the concentrated palate of ripe peach. The Chardonnay gets more of a foothold on the palate, which shows feisty acidity and great drive. Time in oak for a fraction of the blend has brought about not only depth but also a minor oxidative note. Long, silky and appropriately dosed finish. Disgorged 11/20; dosage 6g/l”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Aug 2021
“The 2007 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart is positively stellar. Elegant, polished and sophisticated, the 2007 dazzles with effusive aromatics and gorgeous balance. It's not an obvious wine, though, but rather a Champagne built for long, patient cellaring. The 2007 is 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay taken from Mareuil-sur-Aÿ, Ambonnay, Verzenay and Verzy for the Pinots and Chouilly, Avize, Cramant and Mesnil for the Chardonnays. In other words, as good as it gets for villages. The wine was done mostly in tank with about 15% of the lots vinified in oak. Dosage is 6 grams per liter. ”
97/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“Disgorged with six grams per liter dosage, the 2007 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François is showing very nicely, offering up aromas of fresh bread, citrus oil, crisp yellow orchard fruit, white flowers, verbena, macadamia nut and hints of biscuity complexity to come. Full-bodied, chiseled but fleshy, its vinous core of fruit cloaks the vintage's brisk acids to achieve real plenitude in a year that's sometimes rather tautly austere. Long and penetrating and complemented by a pretty pinpoint mousse, this is a real success.”
98/100
Tyson Stelzer,
Tysonstelzer.com,
Apr 2021
“Pinot noir assumes a glorious lead in a magnificent display of red berry and cherry fruits, seamlessly fused to the bright lemon and pink grapefruit eut of magnificent chardonnay acidity”
“The 2006 Brut Cuvée Nicolas François is showing superbly, bursting with aromas of warm bread, citrus oil, wild berries, smoke and gingerbread. On the palate, it's full-bodied, broad and voluminous, with a concentrated and fleshy core, chalky dry extract and lively acids despite the vintage, concluding with a saline finish. It was disgorged in April 2018 with 5.5 grams per liter dosage, and it's the usual blend of 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, derived from Verzenay, Ambonnay, Ay and Mareuil-sur-Ay, as well as the Grands Crus of the Côte de Blancs, emphasizing Mesnil.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Deep gold. Very flirtatious nose soars out of the glass. Transparent and delicate. Firm and still quite structured and backward. Very immediate on the nose. Not that dense but a very confident blend.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Aug 2020
“The 2006 Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart is shaping up to be a jewel of a wine, but it needs time to be at its best. I am surprised by how tightly wound it is. But that only makes me think what it might develop into with time in the cellar. Lemon confit, white flowers, mint, crushed rocks and sage meld together in a bright, crystalline Champagne endowed with terrific purity.”
“Deeper gold than the 2006. Very dense and firm with lots of further ageing potential.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2018
“100% grand and premier cru vineyards. Pinot Noir (60%) from Montagne de Reims and Vallée de la Marne. Chardonnay (40%) from Côte des Blancs. Disgorged spring 2017. Dosage 4 g/l.
Tasted blind. The deepest colour of all these wines. Mid straw and persistent bead. Not particularly intense on the nose initially; needed time to open up. Quite noticeable autolysis. Bone dry. Some evidence of oak? Absolutely not a shred of simple fruit here – almost a metallic hint on the end but great, deep undertow. Very complex and uncompromising. Dry and distinctive.
Drink 2016-2030”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2017
“Previous vintage was 1999, which has only just sold out. Disgorged early 2016. Needs a year in bottle prior to shipment. 12-15% oak barrels. This was decanted in the famous Billecart-Salmon decanter to age this ‘baby’ a bit.
Deep gold. And with real presence. Real grip and savour. Serious stuff. A certain richness underneath. Described by Antoine Billecart as ‘still a baby’. Rich start and not that frothy. Dense and savoury. Intellectual wine! Broad and grippy.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2015
“Very pale. Sophisticated, very sleek, well balanced nose. A remarkably youthful 2002. Clean, brisk chalky palate with a finish that is just slightly sudden. Quite exciting. This still has quite a bit to give.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2015
“A mesmerizing, thrilling Champagne, the 2002 Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart is a great example of the vintage at its best. Silky and racy on the palate, yet a bit more restrained than many wines of the year, the Nicolas François Billecart remains vivid and remarkably nuanced. Brioche. apricot jam, wild flowers and honey are some of the many notes that blossom as the Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart shows off its voluptuous personality. The 2002 is 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay.”
91-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2014
“The Pinot feels particularly prominent in this vintage. Such a deep, rich, powerful red fruit nose with evolving characters and confectionary, nutty and perfumy tones. Not completely free of bruised notes but beautifully spicy and mellowing. Long-lasting and strong but truly refined palate.”
“Deeper gold than the 2006. Very dense and firm with lots of further ageing potential.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2018
“100% grand and premier cru vineyards. Pinot Noir (60%) from Montagne de Reims and Vallée de la Marne. Chardonnay (40%) from Côte des Blancs. Disgorged spring 2017. Dosage 4 g/l.
Tasted blind. The deepest colour of all these wines. Mid straw and persistent bead. Not particularly intense on the nose initially; needed time to open up. Quite noticeable autolysis. Bone dry. Some evidence of oak? Absolutely not a shred of simple fruit here – almost a metallic hint on the end but great, deep undertow. Very complex and uncompromising. Dry and distinctive.
Drink 2016-2030”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2017
“Previous vintage was 1999, which has only just sold out. Disgorged early 2016. Needs a year in bottle prior to shipment. 12-15% oak barrels. This was decanted in the famous Billecart-Salmon decanter to age this ‘baby’ a bit.
Deep gold. And with real presence. Real grip and savour. Serious stuff. A certain richness underneath. Described by Antoine Billecart as ‘still a baby’. Rich start and not that frothy. Dense and savoury. Intellectual wine! Broad and grippy.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2015
“Very pale. Sophisticated, very sleek, well balanced nose. A remarkably youthful 2002. Clean, brisk chalky palate with a finish that is just slightly sudden. Quite exciting. This still has quite a bit to give.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2015
“A mesmerizing, thrilling Champagne, the 2002 Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart is a great example of the vintage at its best. Silky and racy on the palate, yet a bit more restrained than many wines of the year, the Nicolas François Billecart remains vivid and remarkably nuanced. Brioche. apricot jam, wild flowers and honey are some of the many notes that blossom as the Cuvée Nicolas François Billecart shows off its voluptuous personality. The 2002 is 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay.”
91-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2014
“The Pinot feels particularly prominent in this vintage. Such a deep, rich, powerful red fruit nose with evolving characters and confectionary, nutty and perfumy tones. Not completely free of bruised notes but beautifully spicy and mellowing. Long-lasting and strong but truly refined palate.”
“The Rendez-Vous No.2 is another blanc de noirs, however this time a 100% Pinot Noir. A blend of Pinot from both sides of the Montagne de Reims, Ambonnay and Verzenay. The colour has the lightest peachy tinge to it. The nose is pure and fragrantly Pinot with floral and citrussy notes meeting red berries, notably raspberries and red cherries. There is a light biscuity evolution and spicy, peppery complexity to the nose, which is fresh and pure in its aromatics. The palate has Pinot depth and width with good structure leading to a dry, freshly fruity and stylishly chalky finish. ”
More Reviews +
17/20
Alistair Cooper MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2021
“Beautiful nose of ripe red apples and raw cashew nuts – stunning. The palate is fine, rich and supple with a mineral streak – a lovely streak of acidity and a chalky finish. Elegant and very fine and long. Still tightly coiled and expressive – lean, dry and overridingly attractively chalky – a floral tinge towards the finish. ”
“Real breadth of interesting autolysis on the nose. The Pinot Meunier perhaps shows itself in a slight lack of deep-flavoured follow-through but it really is lovely on the nose. Bone dry but not austere. An interesting bottle of very well-made champagne with sufficient depth.
Drink 2022–2025”
“The NV Extra Brut Les Rendez-Vous de Billecart-Salmon No. 9 is 100% Pinot Noir from Ambonnay, all 2018 vintage, done in stainless steel. Kirsch, dried flowers, mint and cedar give the No.9 lovely aromatic presence. In tasting, the No. 9 reminds me of the flagship Clos Saint-Hilaire, but without the textural dimension that wine shows through its vinification and aging in oak. This is a very pretty wine that shows the lighter, more ethereal side of the vintage. Dosage is 4.4 grams per liter. Disgorged: August 2025.”
“A finely textured Champagne, this is definitely dry, still young, and with great potential. The wine's minerality combines with the texture to give both tension and richness. So it needs to soften further to be ready to drink from 2025.”
“A finely textured Champagne, this is definitely dry, still young, and with great potential. The wine's minerality combines with the texture to give both tension and richness. So it needs to soften further to be ready to drink from 2025.”
“Disgorged with two grams per liter dosage, Billecart-Salmon's 2009 Extra Brut Vintage is more giving and demonstrative than its 2008 counterpart, offering up inviting aromas of crisp stone fruit, yellow apple, brioche, honeycomb and warm pastry. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a pillowy mousse and a generous core of fruit girdled by bright acids, it's seamless and complete. Indeed, such is its charm and persistence that I tend to prefer it, at least for now, to the 2008.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2009 Vintage is another stellar wine in this range from Billecart-Salmon. This is the first time the Vintage includes Meunier in the blend. That approach has worked out so well here. Resonant and generous, the 2009 is so expressive today. The low dosage of two grams per liter is expertly judged. The 2009 is rich, but not heavy, while offering all of the natural generosity of the year.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
jancisrobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Pure and limpid but perhaps without the depth of a great champagne. Very much on the dry side. For a wine from the luscious 2009 vintage this is quite taut and demanding!”
“Disgorged with two grams per liter dosage, Billecart-Salmon's 2009 Extra Brut Vintage is more giving and demonstrative than its 2008 counterpart, offering up inviting aromas of crisp stone fruit, yellow apple, brioche, honeycomb and warm pastry. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a pillowy mousse and a generous core of fruit girdled by bright acids, it's seamless and complete. Indeed, such is its charm and persistence that I tend to prefer it, at least for now, to the 2008.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2009 Vintage is another stellar wine in this range from Billecart-Salmon. This is the first time the Vintage includes Meunier in the blend. That approach has worked out so well here. Resonant and generous, the 2009 is so expressive today. The low dosage of two grams per liter is expertly judged. The 2009 is rich, but not heavy, while offering all of the natural generosity of the year.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
jancisrobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Pure and limpid but perhaps without the depth of a great champagne. Very much on the dry side. For a wine from the luscious 2009 vintage this is quite taut and demanding!”
“Disgorged with two grams per liter dosage, Billecart-Salmon's 2009 Extra Brut Vintage is more giving and demonstrative than its 2008 counterpart, offering up inviting aromas of crisp stone fruit, yellow apple, brioche, honeycomb and warm pastry. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a pillowy mousse and a generous core of fruit girdled by bright acids, it's seamless and complete. Indeed, such is its charm and persistence that I tend to prefer it, at least for now, to the 2008.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2009 Vintage is another stellar wine in this range from Billecart-Salmon. This is the first time the Vintage includes Meunier in the blend. That approach has worked out so well here. Resonant and generous, the 2009 is so expressive today. The low dosage of two grams per liter is expertly judged. The 2009 is rich, but not heavy, while offering all of the natural generosity of the year.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
jancisrobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Pure and limpid but perhaps without the depth of a great champagne. Very much on the dry side. For a wine from the luscious 2009 vintage this is quite taut and demanding!”
“Full-on rich and ripe fruity nose with baked apples, baking spices and red fruit taking the lead role. Highly Pinot prominent also on the fleshy, structured palate that shows some mellowed evolution. Fine freshness and vivacity. ”
More Reviews +
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The 2008 Brut Vintage is a delicious wine with which to explore the vintage, as it offers a lovely combination of richness, energy and early approachability. There is a sense of vibrancy that is so appealing. Orchard fruit, dried flowers, mint, spice and hazelnut all grace this enticing, impeccably rendered 2008 from Billecart-Salmon. Lovely. The blend is 65% Pinot Noir from the Montagne de Reims and the Vallée de la Marne and 35% Chardonnay from the Côte des Blancs done entirely in stainless steel. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. (Originally published in August 2020)”
93/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2020
“Disgorged with four grams per liter dosage, the 2008 Extra Brut Vintage hasn't appreciably evolved since I last tasted it. Offering up pretty aromas of honeycomb, crisp green apple, white flowers and fresh pastry, it's medium to full-bodied, tensile and incisive, with a tightly wound core, racy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. I wouldn't open bottles from my own cellar for another five years, as this is evolving at a glacial pace.”
97/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2019
“Bright golden yellow, silver reflections; very fine, persistent mousse. Fine yellow tropical fruit with a hint of biscuit, fresh peach, nuances of meadow herbs and orange zest, fine mineral touch, pineapple and caramel in the background. tight-knit, compact, ripe white fruit, chalky-mineral texture, taut and very well-balanced. An elegant food wine with very promising ageing potential; very lively, dynamic style.”
“2007 is a rather scarcely declared vintage and not one recognized for its Pinot Noir, yet Bollinger have managed to create something so fresh and delicious from it. Its secrets are in rigorous selection and in unusually high proportion of crunchy Verzenay fruit (29%). Glossy evolving lemon colour. The coolly fruity nose comes with golden raisins, yellow apple, orange zest, juniper wood and ginger. The spiciness gets enhanced over time in the glass. The palate has rare energy and tension for an R.D. , really driven and pure. The palate is still tight and reserved, palate cleansingly dry. Seems like a really slowly ageing R.D. worth cellaring. A great call from the winemaking team to release this La Grande Année vintage as R.D. (bottle disgorged 10th July 2020)”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Deep colour of shiny golden hues. With some six months of post-disgorgement time, this wine looks remarkably youthful, with its ripe, bright and expressive fruitiness. There is fresh apple and apricot alongside dried fruits and fruitcake complexity. The oaky notions are subtle, and oxidation is well under control. The sweet spiciness beautifully lines the aromatics. For a Bollinger R.D., the palate is rather lightweight, but it is beautifully fresh and vivacious. Its secret is rigorous selection and an unusually high proportion of crunchy Verzenay fruit (29%).The wine seems remarkably slow ageing, which is a fine surprise for the vintage. Disgorged 2/22; dosage 3g/l”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“Bollinger’s 2007 R.D. is superb, but it is also a wine that reflects the nature of a unique and challenging growing season. In most vintages the R.D. is marked by the distinct creaminess and breadth of Aÿ Pinot Noir. Two thousand seven, though, was a difficult year marked by very dry weather, rain at the end of the growing season and an early harvest in August, something that was not as common as it has become. Selection was essential. For the 2007, the blend is composed of just 14 villages compared to the more typical 18-25. Verzenay is the main Pinot component while Cramant plays the leading role in the Chardonnays. For these reasons, the 2007 is an R.D. driven by more focus, energy and tension than readers are used to seeing. Lemon confit, dried flowers, sage, mint, crushed rocks, almond and ginger are some of the aromas and flavors that give the 2007 its complex, multi-faceted personality.
The 2007 can be enjoyed now, but I would prefer to cellar it for a few years. It will age effortlessly for decades as it moves through the various phases of its life. I was reminded of the way Champagne can magically traverse time by magical bottles of the 1976 R.D. and 1996 Vieilles Vignes Françaises I tasted recently. The blend is 70% Pinot Noir and 30% Chardonnay, 91% Grand Cru fruit and the rest Premier Cru. Bollinger fans will notice the return of the original label, with the disgorgement date clearly visible, a tribute to Madame Bollinger, who was a pioneer in so many ways. Disgorged: July 10, 2020. Dosage is 3 grams per liter.”
97/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Disgorged on July 10, 2020, with three grams per liter dosage, Bollinger's eagerly awaited 2007 Extra-Brut R. D. is beautiful, unwinding in the glass with aromas of crisp orchard fruit, citrus pith and white flowers mingled with hints of honey, orange oil, buttery pastry, English walnuts and delicately spicy bass notes. Full-bodied, vibrant and incisive, it's unusually elegant and structurally fine-boned for what is routinely one of Champagne's more muscular tête de cuvées, with a bright spine of acidity that's cloaked in vibrant, concentrated fruit, complemented by a pearly pinpoint mousse and concluding with an intensely sapid finish. Long and penetrating, this is a tightly coiled R. D. that will reward bottle age.
The fruit of an early harvest, beginning on September 1st, Bollinger's superb 2007 R. D. is an unusually delicate, fine-boned rendition of this habitually muscular cuvée. An additional seven years on the lees has brought additional textural and amplitude to the acid spine that was already evident in the 2007 Grande Année, and the slight loss of pressure during aging on cork makes for a more refined, pearly mousse that complements the wine's enhanced texture and amplified sapid nuance. Fermented in used oak cooperage, with tirage under natural cork and disgorgement without added sulfur dioxide (but now with jetting to ensure consistency), it's one of the few tête de cuvée bottlings still made very much as it was 40 years ago. While I don't tend to comment on packaging, Bollinger's decision to revive the tasteful aluminum label that graced this cuvée's debut 1952 rendition, when the redoubtable Madame Lilly Bollinger still presided over this house, does underscore what is a real and not merely superficial commitment to artisanal traditions.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Rich and mushroomy in Bollinger style on the nose with a notably dry finish. I think I might stand a good chance of identifying this wine blind…
Drink 2020–2028”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“A hint of hazelnut praline clings to the creamy notions on the nose, aligned to a pleasant smokiness and a hint of dark peony. More air adds notions of white pepper and toasted cumin. The palate is exquisitely creamy – the Bollinger hallmark – but with 2007 this texture is presented with exquisite poise. The bright freshness that underlies all this keeps a subtle but constant presence, lending structure. Beautiful depth lends a kind of solidity that anchors this in chalky soil, a class act and a very grown-up wine that says one thing only: enduring elegance.”
17.5
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“Very, very different from the usual solid, powerful, broad Bollinger style. More rapier-like in approach with none of the density and mushroom notes that I usually associate with Bollinger. An unexpected style which may broaden perceptions of what this house can do. Crisp, mineral, the immediate effect was actually 'pretty' though with time in the glass it took on more weight. This reflects a little the Bollinger PN VZ15 exclusively from Verzenay with pretty marked acidity at this stage in its life. Refined with a bone-dry finish and a touch of quinine on the end. Should have a long life. Ideally I'd wait until mid 2021 before broaching this long-distance runner. With time in the opened bottle this took on more typical Bollinger weight and character.”
“Then it was time for the good James to enjoy one of the most magnificent champagnes in the 25th Bond film. An exclusive "Limited Edition" of the most delicious performance imaginable, where one in the sober text on the elegant bottle can discern the film titles in which Bond indulged in the Aÿ based house's unique elixir of life. The decision, in the usually somewhat thin vintage of 2011, to use Pinot Noir exclusively from the home village of Aÿ with its mighty fruit is nothing short of brilliant. As you might know, Bollinger's ungrafted rarity Vieilles Vignes Françaises comes from Aÿ. I have long argued that the greatness of the wine has less to do with the vines being pre-phylloxera than that they come from Aÿ's best locations aged in Bollinger's old oak barrels. This Bond champagne shows that I was right since the similarities are striking. Perhaps both we and James should wait about ten years until the wine has reached its peak and completely integrated its enormous fruit with the notes from the barrels, but the wine is already magnificent with its deep ripe aroma of Gravenstein apples backed by fresh wooden notes from a newly installed Finnish sauna decorated with fresh birch twigs. Very typical of the Producer and powerful, perhaps more as an energizing solo piece for cello than as a harmonious symphony with its direct and uncompromising power.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2019
“Medium greenish-yellow, silver reflections, fine, lively mousse. Hints of yellow pear and mirabelle plum, a touch of cucumber, delicate floral honey and candied orange zest. Juicy, nuances of fresh white apple, subtle fruit expression underpinned by racy youthful acidity, animated style, good length with a lemony touch on the finish. A multi-faceted food wine.”
“Medium greenish-yellow, silver reflections, fine, lively mousse. Hints of yellow pear and mirabelle plum, a touch of cucumber, delicate floral honey and candied orange zest. Juicy, nuances of fresh white apple, subtle fruit expression underpinned by racy youthful acidity, animated style, good length with a lemony touch on the finish. A multi-faceted food wine.”
“On this vintage with a prolonged growing season Bollinger played the cool card, choosing to go with a high proportion of Verzenay fruit (51%). The combination of cool vintage and cool terroir is truly attractive for a blanc de noirs. Already the nose has lovely zingy fruitiness to it, lemon custard, perfectly ripe peaches and elegant spicy and chalky tones. The ensemble comes across as elegant, super juicy and purely fruity. My favourite of Bollinger limited editions so far! ”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TheFinestBubble.com,
Jul 2021
“Has a beautiful freshness to the aromatics, delicious ripe peach radiates from the glass with bundles of red crunchy fruit. The palate has real tension, such lovely ripe radiant fruit with bitter orange and zippiness, it finishes so light it almost dances on the palate. Love the weight of fruit yet real lightness. Drink Now and will improve for many years to 2035+”
93/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Bright golden yellow, silver reflections, lively fine mousse. Delicate orange zest, yellow plum, peach, white flowers, fine touch of honey, a hint of nut. Juicy, ripe yellow apple, pronounced fruit without being sweet, a hint of grapefruit, fine acidity, lemony-salty touch on the finish, animating style.”
95/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Nov 2021
“For an 8-year-old champagne this is extremely vibrant, the red-fruit character from the pinot noir grape rather in the background. Quite a strict style with discreet lees creaminess. However the ripeness and power means that it isn’t austere. Feels bone-dry at the powerful, chalky finish. 100% pinot noir, 100% barrel-fermented and 100% matured under cork. Disgorged in March 2021. Drink or hold.”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2013 Blanc de Noirs B13 is another new Champagne from Bollinger. This 100% Pinot Noir is quite the surprise, as it shows a clearly bright side of Pinot in this late-ripening year. Citrus, orchard fruit, mint, crushed rocks and white pepper lend aromatic brilliance to a decidedly nervy, taut Blanc de Noirs. B13 is a blend taken from five villages on the Montagne de Reims. It will be interesting to see if more Pinot character emerges over time. Dosage is 6 grams per liter.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Nov 2021
“A graceful Champagne, with a subtle, pleasing tension to the invigorating aromas and flavors of crème de cassis, baked pineapple, verbena, toast and crystallized honey as they ride the silky mousse. Ends with a mouthwatering, mineral- and spice-laced finish. Drink now”
“Another limited-edition vintage release by Bollinger, this 2016 wine is super supple and blooming already upon release. Atypically for Bollinger, Bouzy from the south side of the Montagne de Reims is the dominant village with a 25% share. Of the 30% of Chardonnay complementing the Pinot Noir, Trépail leads the blend, lending exotic spiciness and sweet fruitiness to the appealing whole. Fermentation in oak gives a spicy signature to the lush, fruity nose of orchard fruit, yellow plum and orange blossom. This wine is on the elegance in its caressing silkiness and salty tang. In a quest of letting the terroir speak, Bollinger is restricting the dosage to 4g/l.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2025
“Lively and more floral than many a Bollinger champagne – almost transparent and filigree. The opposite of heavy with marked but not excessive acidity at this stage. Much is happening at the house of Bollinger under chef de cave Denis Bunner! B13 Brut preceded it. I think this may be a pre-release sample.”
“For the fourth consecutive year, the grapes from the north-west facing side of the hill produce La Côte aux Enfants Champagne. Known as a challenging year due to drought related issues, in 2015 the site’s chalky subsoil with thin topsoil came to rescue, showing a strong terroir imprint in the wine. The nose opens with sweet, sun kissed fruit of quince, orange blossom and golden raisins, completely free of the vegetal notes troubling many of the vintage’s wines. There is quite the contrast to the palate, which comes with scintillating vibrancy and energizingly prickly texture. There is immaculate saline freshness to the palate, into which the bitterness from the phenolics contributes. Refined and precise, this is the best edition of La Côte aux Enfants Champagne yet.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Bollinger’s 2015 Blanc de Noirs La Côte aux Enfants, disgorged in February 2025 with a dosage of four grams per liter, stands as the most harmonious iteration to date—a conclusion reaffirmed during a retrospective tasting that included every vintage produced from the vineyard’s northwest-facing slope, which boasts a steep 39% gradient and shallow soils that have been cultivated according to organic practices since 2009. Harvested at 11.2% potential alcohol, with meticulous selection to exclude herbaceous elements—a refinement made possible through vinification in small barrels rather than large tanks—the wine opens with a flamboyant bouquet evocative of red grapefruit zest, pear, red plum, mango and pastry notes. On the palate, it is full-bodied and concentrated, with a vibrant core of fruit supported by racy acidity and ample chalky extract. The finish is long, saline and resonant, marked by Pinot Noir phenolics that just amplify its mineral signature. Denis Bunner notes that sugar accumulation occurred rapidly in this vintage, outpacing aromatic development, yet the decision to delay harvest proved fortuitous—and I wholeheartedly concur. This is an extroverted, characterful expression that aligns beautifully with Bollinger’s house style, and while it can be drunk with considerable satisfaction in the near term, it promises a broad window of enjoyment. Drink Date: 2016-2041.”
“The 2014 harvest year provided another opportunity for Côte aux Enfants to prove its potential on a cool profile, lighter year. The wine is made only from the heart of the northern-facing part of La Côte aux Enfants. In 2014 they decided to wait, and picked the plot mid-September, several days after having picked Vieilles Vignes Françaises. The rich nose oozes Pinot power with its stylishly charred, vanilla, almond, pastry and toffee tones. Silky is the main descriptor for the wine’s impressively vinous and smooth texture. Intensely fruity, there is still a refreshing feeling of lightness and freshness to this tense and compact wine. The tamed phenolics have a firming effect on the long-lasting aftertaste, where sweet pastry and honey tones carry on lingering. ”
More Reviews +
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“While one is unlikely—if not hard-pressed—to find complaints with the 2014 Blanc de Noirs La Côte aux Enfants when enjoyed on its own, it does appear somewhat less harmonious when set against the 2015 and 2013 vintages. Disgorged in February 2024 with a dosage of six grams per liter, it opens from the glass with aromas of ripe pear, beeswax and orange zest. The palate is medium- to full-bodied, vinous and incisive, with an elegantly fleshy core of fruit supported by bright acidity. Lacking both the maturity of vintages such as 2015 and 2012 and the purity of 2013, the 2014 currently seems slightly overshadowed. That said, I wouldn’t be surprised if it gains cohesion and depth with further bottle age—in which case, my current score may ultimately prove conservative. As always, the fruit hails from the northwest-facing sector of a vineyard in Aÿ, this time achieving 10.7% potential alcohol prior to harvest.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2014 La Côte aux Enfants is a powerful, resonant Champagne. It emerges from north-facing parcels in a site best known for still reds. Kirsch, leather, spice, tobacco, ginger and cinnamon all build in the glass. Readers will find a Champagne that shows the wilder, gamier side of Pinot Noir allied to a good bit of supporting structure. This is a fine effort from Bollinger. Dosage is 6 grams per liter.”
97/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Aug 2024
“Already after a few seconds of encountering the wine's wonderful bouquet, I could state that 2014 Bollinger La Côte aux Enfants is in many ways the very essence of "old style Bollinger". The color is very deep golden and I was blown away by how rich and mature the wine felt right away. Significantly fuller and more voluminous than both 2012 and 2013. The scent is actually as big this time as VVF and even more mature. All of this surprised me as 2014 is generally the lightest of the three. Here it was the opposite. The only thing that somehow makes me recognize the vintage is the neat and elegant note of grilled lemons I find more and more marked as the wine sounds majestically in the mouth. Perhaps this wine personifies the soul and heart of Bollinger better than any other wine. If you have been in Bollinger's cellar and in the beautiful hall where all the oak barrels are lined up, you will probably never forget the unique aroma you find there. With Bollinger's deliberately oxidative vinification, all wines from there will be strongly influenced by their external environment. When everything goes right, as it has here, this fragrance makes for a fabulously stylish personal spice. In the first place, of course, it is the micro-oxidation through the fibers of the oak barrel that leaves an impression, but also the notes of old oak with their grilled, lightly burnt and faintly smoked notes that attract autumn forest and Finnish sauna give great pleasure. From the concentrated Pinot Noir grapes, you get an extract-rich juiciness and a chewy red fruit of Gravensteiner apple, beetroot, apricot jam, strawberries and honey. From Aÿ's terroir comes an unmistakable aroma of hazelnut, honeysuckle, leather and tobacco. Can this masterpiece be stored? Sure, but does it make it better? Hardly, probably a slump will come in a few years and a new beautiful phase will only enter in ten years when new parts of the personality take shape. Different and just as good, but hardly better.”
“This is the second bubbly release from Bollinger’s iconic Aÿ plot, renowned for its red wine. The late harvest season that left a brisk acidity to the wines gave its strong mark to this cuvée too, pushing the fine chalky-mineral qualities to the fore. Only the grapes from the coolest spots of the large monopole vineyard find their way into this cuvée. Thus, a crispy crunchiness of the fruit is evident alongside the strong mineral highlights. The deep gold-toned colour shows evolution. On the nose yellow apple, apricot tart and waxy notes are further complexed by a fine toasty undertone. The oaky notes linger elegantly at the back, leaving the fruit to the fore. The year’s imprint comes across strongly on the super saline palate with unmissable chalky tone. Even if this march 2022 disgorgement with over a year on cork is beautifully expressive already, due to its tightness and pure and bright fruit quality, it comes with fine ageing potential. Dosage 4 g/l. ”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jun 2023
“The 2013 La Côte aux Enfants is a rich, heady Champagne. Passion fruit, candied apricot, white flowers, vanillin, spice and tangerine oil all race across the palate. Deep and layered, with notable complexity, the 2013 is decidedly racy. Interestingly, the 2013 is much more expressive than the 2012 was at this stage. The 2013 was picked at 11.12% potential alcohol. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. In just its second release, the La Côte aux Enfants seems headed in a very positive direction. ”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“One of the greatest hits from this vineyard, Bollinger’s 2013 Blanc de Noirs La Côte aux Enfants has evolved beautifully, embodying everything that made the long, slow-ripening season so compelling. Harvested on October 5 from the vineyard’s cool, northwest-facing slope, the fruit attained 10.4% potential alcohol. Disgorged in March 2022 with a dosage of four grams per liter, it unfurls from the glass with a deep bouquet of pear, wildflower honey and white peach, mingling with spice and bread dough. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, tensile and racy, with a pure, chalky core that marries Bollinger’s characteristic Pinot Noir power with incisive acidity and underlying tension. Chiseled and mineral, it presents a stylistic counterpoint to the flavorful 2015—another highlight of this vertical—and, like its younger sibling, is well worth seeking out.”
99/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“Complex aromas of pie crust, iron, chalk and hints of sweet strawberries. Some ginseng. Full-bodied with very fine bubbles that give it tension and focus. Extremely fine and polished tannins that go on and on. Dried lemons and oranges. Chalk at the end. Hints of bitterness in the finish with subtle botanicals. Made from a single vineyard monopole of pure pinot noir. Drink now.”
97/100
Allen Meadows,
Burghound.com,
Aug 2023
“An even more reserved if noticeably more complex nose reluctantly displays its aromas of cool quinine, Granny Smith apples, spice, floral and vaguely exotic tea and toasty bread. The intense and lilting medium weight flavors are supported by a moderately firm but quite fine mousse on the strikingly complex, balanced, youthfully austere and strikingly long finale. This is at once very stylish and classy while offering excellent development potential. In short, this is stunningly good.”
97/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“While one might have expected the cool, northwest-facing part of this famed Aÿ vineyard to produce a rather unyielding wine in a vintage like this, Bollinger's brilliant 2013 Brut Blanc de Noirs La Côte Aux Enfants is actually easier to understand than the rather more reserved inaugural 2012 release. Unwinding in the glass with aromas of smoky orchard fruit, crisp peach, beeswax, mocha, warm spices and toasted nuts, it's full-bodied, taut and chiseled, with a deep and concentrated core of fruit, a beautifully refined pinpoint mousse and a long, electric finish. All the energy and cut that one could wish for is combined with the house's trademark vinous, complex style to deliver a wine of real character and élan.”
“An immediate nuttiness of grilled hazelnut along with freshly cut red apple peel, an edge of white pepper and melted candlewax mark the nose – very unusual. With air, this slowly verges onto baked skin of plum. That nuttiness is also apparent on the palate with a real phenolic and textural element, there is much density, almost a chewiness. Very fine acidity runs through this wine, expressing the customary Bollinger creaminess, underlined by finest foam, revealing a lovely hint of pithy bitterness, more pepper and nuances of ripeness expressed by baking spice. A most gastronomic Champagne and only at the beginning of a long trajectory.”
More Reviews +
99/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
May 2022
“Lively yet delicate mousse. Attractive yellow tropical fruit nuances, hints of peach and mango, fresh meadow herbs, lime zest, very fine hints of walnut and honey blossom in the background. Substantial, complex and silky with dense texture, white stone fruit, delicate hints of liquorice, cinnamon, salty freshness and subtle hints of Golden Delicious. Finely embedded acidity structure, ripe, without any unnecessary sweetness, candied orange on the finish, lingers very long, certain ageing potential for further decades. Already easy to drink, will continue to improve.”
94+/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2022
“The 2012 Blanc de Noirs La Côte aux Enfants is a new Champagne from Bollinger made from a southwest-facing, 2-hectare parcel in Aÿ that was redeveloped 25 years ago adjacent to the block that has informed the house’s Coteaux Champenois since 1934. Even in 2012 – a radiant year – the Côte aux Enfants is intensely bright and tightly wound, a reflection of very thin soils with just 30 centimeters of topsoil above pure chalk. That reticence is probably a very good sign for its long-term aging prospects. Time brings out hints of apricot, peach, red plum, kirsch, wild flowers, chalk, spice and white pepper, but the 2012 only starts to blossom with a ton of air. The 2012 was disgorged in March 2022. Dosage is 8 grams per liter, on the higher side these days, but not at all noticeable. Stylistically, the Côte aux Enfants is not as exotic as the VVF, nor as steely as the new series of multi-vintage PN Blanc de Noirs Bollinger began releasing with the 2015 vintage. I can’t wait to see how it ages, but I also wouldn’t dream of touching a bottle any time soon, except for academic purposes.”
95/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“With three years of maturation post-disgorgement—following its March 2022 disgorgement with a dosage of eight grams per liter—I am pleased to report that Bollinger’s inaugural 2012 Blanc de Noirs La Côte aux Enfants is no longer as restrained as described in William Kelley’s 2023 tasting note, and it now presents as expressive and inviting, though unmistakably distinct from the incisive, more linear style of the 2013 vintage. The fruit reached a potential alcohol of 10.9% prior to harvest in 2012, surpassed only by the 2015. On the nose, it reveals a deep bouquet of ripe pear, orange zest, baking spices, toasted nuts and a hint of brioche. Medium- to full-bodied and vinous in character, it is charming and flavorful, with a generous core of fruit supported by tangy acidity and concludes with a long, enveloping finish. Flamboyant and full of character, it is already drinking with satisfaction and unmistakably bears the hallmark of Bollinger’s style.”
94+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2022
“Produced from the northwest-facing part of this famed Aÿ vineyard, whose sunnier slopes produce Bollinger's red Côteaux Champenois, the 2012 Brut Blanc de Noirs La Côte Aux Enfants was disgorged in March 2022 with eight grams per liter dosage. Exhibiting aromas of golden orchard fruit, mirabelle plum, praline and honeyed toast, it's medium to full-bodied, vinous and chiseled, with a deep core of fruit, terrific tension and a long, penetrating finish. This is a serious, characterful Champagne that debuts in the Bollinger range with a clear identity of its own.”
“In the generous, precocious 2018 season, Bollinger chose to anchor La Grande Année in a resolutely classical register. Particularly satisfied with the authority of their Pinot Noir, the backbone is drawn from Aÿ, Verzenay and Mareuil-sur-Aÿ. The Chardonnays come principally from Avize, Chouilly and Cuis, but in total, 19 grands and premiers crus contribute to the assemblage. The bouquet is immediately expressive, unfolding with ripe orchard fruit, yellow apple and poached pear, layered with Mirabelle plum, dried meadow flowers and a touch of sun-warmed straw. Aeration reveals subtle hints of light pastry and spice. On the palate, the texture is broad and finely chiselled, carried by a persistent salinity. The phenolic maturity of the warm vintage lends structure, framing the lush fruit. Despite its early approachability, there is no heaviness; instead, the wine combines suppleness with vibrancy, finishing long and seamless. Already gratifying yet clearly built for graceful evolution.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2026
“Bollinger’s 2018 La Grande Année is quite pretty and delicate. Floral and citrus notes are nicely lifted in a Grande Année that offers notable sensuality and grace. Hints of orchard fruit, chamomile, mint and chalk build through the midpalate and into the taut, chiseled finish. There’s plenty of energy and focus. More importantly, this is a fine effort in a year marked by high yields in Champagne. I would give this a few years in the cellar. The 2018 is 66% Pinot Noir and 34% Chardonnay from 19 villages, 73% Grand Cru and 37% Premier Cru. The core villages are Aÿ, Verzenay and Mareuil for Pinot Noir and Avize, Chouilly and Cuis for the Chardonnay. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. Disgorged: March 2025”
94+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“Originating from a hot and dry growing season—particularly from mid-June onward—during which harvest began as early as August 23 and lasted for a full two weeks, Bollinger’s 2018 La Grande Année, composed of 66% Pinot Noir and 34% Chardonnay, was disgorged in March 2025 with a dosage of six grams per liter. The wine has turned out very well in the vintage context, presenting—unsurprisingly—a broader and more succulent profile than the racy, fine-boned renditions of 2014 and 2008. Unfurling in the glass with aromas of peach, yellow apple, and orange peel mingled with freshly baked bread and mango, it is medium- to full-bodied, ample and textural, with a generous core of fruit, animated by a pillowy mousse and laden with ripe yet vibrant acidity, carrying through to a long finish. It is slightly more expressive in magnum format, though in either case, it will benefit from a few years of post-disgorgement aging to fully unwind.”
94-96/100
Richard Juhlin,
Tastingbook.com,
Nov 2025
“If 2015 was like a walk in the forest in autumn, 2018 is spring-winter just when nature is starting to wake up. Enormous expectant energy and an underlying well-hidden power that will be firing on all cylinders after 2035. A real knockout fist treacherously draped in silk gloves. Cold, fresh and sparkling notes of citrus and Granny Smith apples dance beautifully together with the more classic Bollinger notes of brioche and gunpowder-smoky minerality. Right now, there are more green apples here than red apples, more raspberries than peaches, more acacia and yellow roses than honeysuckle, more bitter almonds than hazelnuts, more cinnamon than tar, more shiitake mushrooms than cep, more butterscotch than chocolate, more light birch wood than heavy sauna notes.”
“A hot year with drought issues made Bollinger seek freshness and subtlety via Pinot Noirs of north facing terroirs and an unusually high proportion of Chardonnay (40%). The nose oozes lush red berry fruit, golden raisins and tropical fruit exuberance. Rich and ripe in profile, the wine if laudably free of the culprit of the year, the vegetal austerity, which Bollinger was able to avoid by barrel vinifications’ effect in removing excess phenolics and the strict selection enabled by individual barrels. There is impressive density on the textured palate, that finishes on a spicy note adding on to the wine’s freshness. A rare success in 2015, this is a vintage for the friends of Bollinger’s classically vinous style. Due to its richness and structuredness it promises fine potential for ageing.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“Bollinger's 2015 Brut Grand Année is an intriguing wine in that is clearly reflects the decision to pick on the later side in order to avoid vegetal notes derived from the mismatch of alcoholic and phenolic ripeness. "Balance was hard to achieve in 2015," Chef de Cave Dennis Bunner notes. "At 10% in sugar, the fruit was simply not ripe. We had to wait to reach the optimal window of ripeness." Bunner also opted to increase the Chardonnay, so the blend is 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, as opposed to the more typical 70/30 blend, with more Verzenay than Aÿ in the Pinots. Dried citrus peel, sage, menthol, sage, tangerine peel and spice build with some coaxing. Light tropical overtones develop with aeration. There's real density and textural richness here. This will be a fascinating vintage to follow. Stylistically, it is the complete opposite from the much more linear 2014 that precedes it. ”
95+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2015 Brut La Grande Année was disgorged last year with eight grams per liter dosage. The wine has turned out beautifully, exhibiting a more muscular, old-school Bollinger profile in contrast to the unusually racy, fine-boned 2014 that preceded it. Wafting from the glass with notes of pear, orange oil and white flowers mingled with notions of mocha, toasted hazelnuts and fino sherry, it's medium to full-bodied, layered and textural, with a dense core of fruit framed by chalky structuring extract, concluding with a long, sapid finish.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Nov 2023
“Oops, is it already time for another vintage of this gem? Amazing how fast time goes. 2015 is generally a problematic vintage with heat stress and a period of drought. It is no art to get richness and power in the wines, but elegance and freshness are rare. Because Bollinger's house style is inherently so masculinely powerful, Bollinger's eminent team focused on preserving freshness first and foremost. According to Denis Bunner, Bollinger felt that the grapes they had access to gave more typicity and greater elegance to the Chardonnay this time. Hence a slightly higher content of the green grape than in the original recipe. Perhaps even more important was the choice of Avize and Verzenay as engines. Verzenay behaves in many ways like Chardonnay with its chalky elegance and great purity. This time the shares of Aÿ and Verzenay were equal for the unusual skull. Fat Cramant and Oger were now downplayed and Avize was primarily supported by tight Chouilly. An interesting detail that reduces tannin, clumsiness and contributes to an increased sense of freshness is, oddly enough, oak barrels. This is due to its great age and the company's strict selection of the best casks that only provide microoxidation. The color is already deep golden with a fine stream of tiny bubbles fighting their way up through the glycerol-rich concentrated wine. Intense and rich and at the same time nuanced and complex. The small concentrated grapes ultimately produced an ultimate gastronomic masterpiece. The scent cannonade is classic Bollinger, but fresh and more nuanced than I expected from the vintage. Stone fruits, honeysuckle, honey, plum marmalade, Cox Orange, raspberry, almond, hazelnut, leather, tanned skin, cigar, and duck liver are all clear instruments in the orchestra playing their richly generous vintage anthem. The freshness does not come from acid this time, but from lack of water and concentrated extracts in a similar way as the even more extreme 2003. I finish I find tobacco, forest and chocolate with sea salt, a delicious combination. Precisely the saltiness and the slightly higher tannin content contribute to making this a perfect partner for poultry in all its forms.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“The 2015 La Grande Année, disgorged in May 2024 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, continues to drink beautifully, emerging from the glass with a deep bouquet of yellow apple, dried apricot, nashi pear and toasted hazelnut mingled with dried flowers, freshly baked bread and a hint of sage. Medium- to full-bodied, the palate is layered and fleshy, underpinned by ample reserves of chalky structuring extract, and concludes with a long, saline finish. It is a considerable success in the vintage and a very classic Bollinger, a wine with real identity.”
“A hot year with drought issues made Bollinger seek freshness and subtlety via Pinot Noirs of north facing terroirs and an unusually high proportion of Chardonnay (40%). The nose oozes lush red berry fruit, golden raisins and tropical fruit exuberance. Rich and ripe in profile, the wine if laudably free of the culprit of the year, the vegetal austerity, which Bollinger was able to avoid by barrel vinifications’ effect in removing excess phenolics and the strict selection enabled by individual barrels. There is impressive density on the textured palate, that finishes on a spicy note adding on to the wine’s freshness. A rare success in 2015, this is a vintage for the friends of Bollinger’s classically vinous style. Due to its richness and structuredness it promises fine potential for ageing.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“Bollinger's 2015 Brut Grand Année is an intriguing wine in that is clearly reflects the decision to pick on the later side in order to avoid vegetal notes derived from the mismatch of alcoholic and phenolic ripeness. "Balance was hard to achieve in 2015," Chef de Cave Dennis Bunner notes. "At 10% in sugar, the fruit was simply not ripe. We had to wait to reach the optimal window of ripeness." Bunner also opted to increase the Chardonnay, so the blend is 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, as opposed to the more typical 70/30 blend, with more Verzenay than Aÿ in the Pinots. Dried citrus peel, sage, menthol, sage, tangerine peel and spice build with some coaxing. Light tropical overtones develop with aeration. There's real density and textural richness here. This will be a fascinating vintage to follow. Stylistically, it is the complete opposite from the much more linear 2014 that precedes it. ”
95+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2015 Brut La Grande Année was disgorged last year with eight grams per liter dosage. The wine has turned out beautifully, exhibiting a more muscular, old-school Bollinger profile in contrast to the unusually racy, fine-boned 2014 that preceded it. Wafting from the glass with notes of pear, orange oil and white flowers mingled with notions of mocha, toasted hazelnuts and fino sherry, it's medium to full-bodied, layered and textural, with a dense core of fruit framed by chalky structuring extract, concluding with a long, sapid finish.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Nov 2023
“Oops, is it already time for another vintage of this gem? Amazing how fast time goes. 2015 is generally a problematic vintage with heat stress and a period of drought. It is no art to get richness and power in the wines, but elegance and freshness are rare. Because Bollinger's house style is inherently so masculinely powerful, Bollinger's eminent team focused on preserving freshness first and foremost. According to Denis Bunner, Bollinger felt that the grapes they had access to gave more typicity and greater elegance to the Chardonnay this time. Hence a slightly higher content of the green grape than in the original recipe. Perhaps even more important was the choice of Avize and Verzenay as engines. Verzenay behaves in many ways like Chardonnay with its chalky elegance and great purity. This time the shares of Aÿ and Verzenay were equal for the unusual skull. Fat Cramant and Oger were now downplayed and Avize was primarily supported by tight Chouilly. An interesting detail that reduces tannin, clumsiness and contributes to an increased sense of freshness is, oddly enough, oak barrels. This is due to its great age and the company's strict selection of the best casks that only provide microoxidation. The color is already deep golden with a fine stream of tiny bubbles fighting their way up through the glycerol-rich concentrated wine. Intense and rich and at the same time nuanced and complex. The small concentrated grapes ultimately produced an ultimate gastronomic masterpiece. The scent cannonade is classic Bollinger, but fresh and more nuanced than I expected from the vintage. Stone fruits, honeysuckle, honey, plum marmalade, Cox Orange, raspberry, almond, hazelnut, leather, tanned skin, cigar, and duck liver are all clear instruments in the orchestra playing their richly generous vintage anthem. The freshness does not come from acid this time, but from lack of water and concentrated extracts in a similar way as the even more extreme 2003. I finish I find tobacco, forest and chocolate with sea salt, a delicious combination. Precisely the saltiness and the slightly higher tannin content contribute to making this a perfect partner for poultry in all its forms.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“The 2015 La Grande Année, disgorged in May 2024 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, continues to drink beautifully, emerging from the glass with a deep bouquet of yellow apple, dried apricot, nashi pear and toasted hazelnut mingled with dried flowers, freshly baked bread and a hint of sage. Medium- to full-bodied, the palate is layered and fleshy, underpinned by ample reserves of chalky structuring extract, and concludes with a long, saline finish. It is a considerable success in the vintage and a very classic Bollinger, a wine with real identity.”
“A hot year with drought issues made Bollinger seek freshness and subtlety via Pinot Noirs of north facing terroirs and an unusually high proportion of Chardonnay (40%). The nose oozes lush red berry fruit, golden raisins and tropical fruit exuberance. Rich and ripe in profile, the wine if laudably free of the culprit of the year, the vegetal austerity, which Bollinger was able to avoid by barrel vinifications’ effect in removing excess phenolics and the strict selection enabled by individual barrels. There is impressive density on the textured palate, that finishes on a spicy note adding on to the wine’s freshness. A rare success in 2015, this is a vintage for the friends of Bollinger’s classically vinous style. Due to its richness and structuredness it promises fine potential for ageing.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“Bollinger's 2015 Brut Grand Année is an intriguing wine in that is clearly reflects the decision to pick on the later side in order to avoid vegetal notes derived from the mismatch of alcoholic and phenolic ripeness. "Balance was hard to achieve in 2015," Chef de Cave Dennis Bunner notes. "At 10% in sugar, the fruit was simply not ripe. We had to wait to reach the optimal window of ripeness." Bunner also opted to increase the Chardonnay, so the blend is 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, as opposed to the more typical 70/30 blend, with more Verzenay than Aÿ in the Pinots. Dried citrus peel, sage, menthol, sage, tangerine peel and spice build with some coaxing. Light tropical overtones develop with aeration. There's real density and textural richness here. This will be a fascinating vintage to follow. Stylistically, it is the complete opposite from the much more linear 2014 that precedes it. ”
95+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2015 Brut La Grande Année was disgorged last year with eight grams per liter dosage. The wine has turned out beautifully, exhibiting a more muscular, old-school Bollinger profile in contrast to the unusually racy, fine-boned 2014 that preceded it. Wafting from the glass with notes of pear, orange oil and white flowers mingled with notions of mocha, toasted hazelnuts and fino sherry, it's medium to full-bodied, layered and textural, with a dense core of fruit framed by chalky structuring extract, concluding with a long, sapid finish.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Nov 2023
“Oops, is it already time for another vintage of this gem? Amazing how fast time goes. 2015 is generally a problematic vintage with heat stress and a period of drought. It is no art to get richness and power in the wines, but elegance and freshness are rare. Because Bollinger's house style is inherently so masculinely powerful, Bollinger's eminent team focused on preserving freshness first and foremost. According to Denis Bunner, Bollinger felt that the grapes they had access to gave more typicity and greater elegance to the Chardonnay this time. Hence a slightly higher content of the green grape than in the original recipe. Perhaps even more important was the choice of Avize and Verzenay as engines. Verzenay behaves in many ways like Chardonnay with its chalky elegance and great purity. This time the shares of Aÿ and Verzenay were equal for the unusual skull. Fat Cramant and Oger were now downplayed and Avize was primarily supported by tight Chouilly. An interesting detail that reduces tannin, clumsiness and contributes to an increased sense of freshness is, oddly enough, oak barrels. This is due to its great age and the company's strict selection of the best casks that only provide microoxidation. The color is already deep golden with a fine stream of tiny bubbles fighting their way up through the glycerol-rich concentrated wine. Intense and rich and at the same time nuanced and complex. The small concentrated grapes ultimately produced an ultimate gastronomic masterpiece. The scent cannonade is classic Bollinger, but fresh and more nuanced than I expected from the vintage. Stone fruits, honeysuckle, honey, plum marmalade, Cox Orange, raspberry, almond, hazelnut, leather, tanned skin, cigar, and duck liver are all clear instruments in the orchestra playing their richly generous vintage anthem. The freshness does not come from acid this time, but from lack of water and concentrated extracts in a similar way as the even more extreme 2003. I finish I find tobacco, forest and chocolate with sea salt, a delicious combination. Precisely the saltiness and the slightly higher tannin content contribute to making this a perfect partner for poultry in all its forms.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“The 2015 La Grande Année, disgorged in May 2024 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, continues to drink beautifully, emerging from the glass with a deep bouquet of yellow apple, dried apricot, nashi pear and toasted hazelnut mingled with dried flowers, freshly baked bread and a hint of sage. Medium- to full-bodied, the palate is layered and fleshy, underpinned by ample reserves of chalky structuring extract, and concludes with a long, saline finish. It is a considerable success in the vintage and a very classic Bollinger, a wine with real identity.”
“An intriguing combination of a sunny year’s forward fruitiness and late September harvest’s freshness. These characters get further amplified by the high percentage of Chardonnay and important share of cooler profile Verzenay Pinot Noir in the blend. On the nose ripe peach, candied apple and vanilla blend in beautifully with delicate floral and lemony notes as well as mineral iodine whiffs. The gentle oaky note stylishly stays in the background. There is supple volume on the lacey-textured palate, but this wine plays much less on concentration and weight than what we are used to with La Grande Année. Instead its finest feature is the salivating acidity and sensation of minerality that carries the wine until the long, palate-cleansing finish. Already open and pleasurable on the nose, but the palate stands firm with mineral restraint promising longevity. Perfectly dosed at 8g/l. Note for a bottle disgorged in April 2021.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2014 La Grande Année is stunning. In fact, it is one of the best recent editions I can remember tasting. What comes through most is the wine’s sizzling energy and tension, qualities that aren’t often associated with Bollinger, where the Champagnes tend to show more breadth and volume. In 2014, readers will find a Grande Année built on linear intensity and drive. The 2014 is a blend taken from 19 villages, 61% Pinot Noir and 39% Chardonnay instead of the more typical 70/30 mix. For the second time in two decades (the first was 2007), Verzenay takes the lead in the Pinots over Aÿ, more or less an inverse from the norm. Verzenay, a north-facing village in the Montagne de Reims that saw less rain than Aÿ and most of the Vallée de la Marne, yields Pinots of energy more than volume. That, married with Chardonnays mostly from the Côtes des Blancs (predominantly Chouilly, Vertus, Oiry and Cramant), results in a truly magical Grande Année that will delight Champagne fans for several decades. I can’t recommend the 2014 highly enough. It’s a total knock-out. Disgorged: April, 2021. Dosage: 8 grams per liter.
”
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2022
“Offering up complex aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, confit citrus, frangipane, walnuts, dried white flowers and subtle hints of iodine, Bollinger's 2014 Brut La Grande Année is medium to full-bodied, pillowy and vinous, with an elegantly fleshy core of fruit that's underpinned by racy acids and complemented by a pretty pinpoint mousse. Concluding with a long, chalky finish, this is a charming but precise Grande Année that's more giving and demonstrative than its immediate predecessor, the 2012, but which attains a very similar level of quality in a more challenging vintage—testimony to the serious viticulture that underpins Bollinger's contemporary excellence.”
94-96/100
Richard Juhlin,
Tastingbook.com,
Feb 2022
“I belong to the group of people that believes that Bollinger above all shows its greatness in lighter and more elegant vintages as the inherent Pinot-driven masculine power they possess is always sufficient. In the grand generous vintages, one must fight hard to hold back the rumbling force and maintain freshness and sublime details. 2014 is a textbook example in the lighter category. Many champagnes from 2014 are simply too light, vague, and floral in nature, but this does not apply in any way to Bollinger La Grande Année. Here, they have beautifully navigated their way between the grains of the vintage and instead focused on its merits. The champagne is thus clearer and more elegant with a higher proportion of Chardonnay from Chouilly and Oiry than usual to include and embrace the citrusy and floral sides. The extremely intense aroma is otherwise dominated by a marked air of sea breezes, sea urchins, oyster shells, iodine and gunpowder smoke originating from Verzenay. There is also a light note of hazelnut and leather from Aÿ. The combination of these pillars and all complementary villages also gives a delicate fruit with hints of orange citrus, peach, and Mirabelle plum. The aromas come again in the fine and medium-bodied taste with an added note of the finest vanilla and fresh cep in olive oil. Overall, this is an extremely beautiful and complex Bollinger on the finer and more elegant half of the whole. I love how you find new little details in a harmonious simplicity with each new sip. Fascinating and beautiful already, grand as R.D. in 10 years or more and without a doubt one of the vintage's rare hits.”
“An intriguing combination of a sunny year’s forward fruitiness and late September harvest’s freshness. These characters get further amplified by the high percentage of Chardonnay and important share of cooler profile Verzenay Pinot Noir in the blend. On the nose ripe peach, candied apple and vanilla blend in beautifully with delicate floral and lemony notes as well as mineral iodine whiffs. The gentle oaky note stylishly stays in the background. There is supple volume on the lacey-textured palate, but this wine plays much less on concentration and weight than what we are used to with La Grande Année. Instead its finest feature is the salivating acidity and sensation of minerality that carries the wine until the long, palate-cleansing finish. Already open and pleasurable on the nose, but the palate stands firm with mineral restraint promising longevity. Perfectly dosed at 8g/l. Note for a bottle disgorged in April 2021.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2014 La Grande Année is stunning. In fact, it is one of the best recent editions I can remember tasting. What comes through most is the wine’s sizzling energy and tension, qualities that aren’t often associated with Bollinger, where the Champagnes tend to show more breadth and volume. In 2014, readers will find a Grande Année built on linear intensity and drive. The 2014 is a blend taken from 19 villages, 61% Pinot Noir and 39% Chardonnay instead of the more typical 70/30 mix. For the second time in two decades (the first was 2007), Verzenay takes the lead in the Pinots over Aÿ, more or less an inverse from the norm. Verzenay, a north-facing village in the Montagne de Reims that saw less rain than Aÿ and most of the Vallée de la Marne, yields Pinots of energy more than volume. That, married with Chardonnays mostly from the Côtes des Blancs (predominantly Chouilly, Vertus, Oiry and Cramant), results in a truly magical Grande Année that will delight Champagne fans for several decades. I can’t recommend the 2014 highly enough. It’s a total knock-out. Disgorged: April, 2021. Dosage: 8 grams per liter.
”
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2022
“Offering up complex aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, confit citrus, frangipane, walnuts, dried white flowers and subtle hints of iodine, Bollinger's 2014 Brut La Grande Année is medium to full-bodied, pillowy and vinous, with an elegantly fleshy core of fruit that's underpinned by racy acids and complemented by a pretty pinpoint mousse. Concluding with a long, chalky finish, this is a charming but precise Grande Année that's more giving and demonstrative than its immediate predecessor, the 2012, but which attains a very similar level of quality in a more challenging vintage—testimony to the serious viticulture that underpins Bollinger's contemporary excellence.”
94-96/100
Richard Juhlin,
Tastingbook.com,
Feb 2022
“I belong to the group of people that believes that Bollinger above all shows its greatness in lighter and more elegant vintages as the inherent Pinot-driven masculine power they possess is always sufficient. In the grand generous vintages, one must fight hard to hold back the rumbling force and maintain freshness and sublime details. 2014 is a textbook example in the lighter category. Many champagnes from 2014 are simply too light, vague, and floral in nature, but this does not apply in any way to Bollinger La Grande Année. Here, they have beautifully navigated their way between the grains of the vintage and instead focused on its merits. The champagne is thus clearer and more elegant with a higher proportion of Chardonnay from Chouilly and Oiry than usual to include and embrace the citrusy and floral sides. The extremely intense aroma is otherwise dominated by a marked air of sea breezes, sea urchins, oyster shells, iodine and gunpowder smoke originating from Verzenay. There is also a light note of hazelnut and leather from Aÿ. The combination of these pillars and all complementary villages also gives a delicate fruit with hints of orange citrus, peach, and Mirabelle plum. The aromas come again in the fine and medium-bodied taste with an added note of the finest vanilla and fresh cep in olive oil. Overall, this is an extremely beautiful and complex Bollinger on the finer and more elegant half of the whole. I love how you find new little details in a harmonious simplicity with each new sip. Fascinating and beautiful already, grand as R.D. in 10 years or more and without a doubt one of the vintage's rare hits.”
“An intriguing combination of a sunny year’s forward fruitiness and late September harvest’s freshness. These characters get further amplified by the high percentage of Chardonnay and important share of cooler profile Verzenay Pinot Noir in the blend. On the nose ripe peach, candied apple and vanilla blend in beautifully with delicate floral and lemony notes as well as mineral iodine whiffs. The gentle oaky note stylishly stays in the background. There is supple volume on the lacey-textured palate, but this wine plays much less on concentration and weight than what we are used to with La Grande Année. Instead its finest feature is the salivating acidity and sensation of minerality that carries the wine until the long, palate-cleansing finish. Already open and pleasurable on the nose, but the palate stands firm with mineral restraint promising longevity. Perfectly dosed at 8g/l. Note for a bottle disgorged in April 2021.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2014 La Grande Année is stunning. In fact, it is one of the best recent editions I can remember tasting. What comes through most is the wine’s sizzling energy and tension, qualities that aren’t often associated with Bollinger, where the Champagnes tend to show more breadth and volume. In 2014, readers will find a Grande Année built on linear intensity and drive. The 2014 is a blend taken from 19 villages, 61% Pinot Noir and 39% Chardonnay instead of the more typical 70/30 mix. For the second time in two decades (the first was 2007), Verzenay takes the lead in the Pinots over Aÿ, more or less an inverse from the norm. Verzenay, a north-facing village in the Montagne de Reims that saw less rain than Aÿ and most of the Vallée de la Marne, yields Pinots of energy more than volume. That, married with Chardonnays mostly from the Côtes des Blancs (predominantly Chouilly, Vertus, Oiry and Cramant), results in a truly magical Grande Année that will delight Champagne fans for several decades. I can’t recommend the 2014 highly enough. It’s a total knock-out. Disgorged: April, 2021. Dosage: 8 grams per liter.
”
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2022
“Offering up complex aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, confit citrus, frangipane, walnuts, dried white flowers and subtle hints of iodine, Bollinger's 2014 Brut La Grande Année is medium to full-bodied, pillowy and vinous, with an elegantly fleshy core of fruit that's underpinned by racy acids and complemented by a pretty pinpoint mousse. Concluding with a long, chalky finish, this is a charming but precise Grande Année that's more giving and demonstrative than its immediate predecessor, the 2012, but which attains a very similar level of quality in a more challenging vintage—testimony to the serious viticulture that underpins Bollinger's contemporary excellence.”
94-96/100
Richard Juhlin,
Tastingbook.com,
Feb 2022
“I belong to the group of people that believes that Bollinger above all shows its greatness in lighter and more elegant vintages as the inherent Pinot-driven masculine power they possess is always sufficient. In the grand generous vintages, one must fight hard to hold back the rumbling force and maintain freshness and sublime details. 2014 is a textbook example in the lighter category. Many champagnes from 2014 are simply too light, vague, and floral in nature, but this does not apply in any way to Bollinger La Grande Année. Here, they have beautifully navigated their way between the grains of the vintage and instead focused on its merits. The champagne is thus clearer and more elegant with a higher proportion of Chardonnay from Chouilly and Oiry than usual to include and embrace the citrusy and floral sides. The extremely intense aroma is otherwise dominated by a marked air of sea breezes, sea urchins, oyster shells, iodine and gunpowder smoke originating from Verzenay. There is also a light note of hazelnut and leather from Aÿ. The combination of these pillars and all complementary villages also gives a delicate fruit with hints of orange citrus, peach, and Mirabelle plum. The aromas come again in the fine and medium-bodied taste with an added note of the finest vanilla and fresh cep in olive oil. Overall, this is an extremely beautiful and complex Bollinger on the finer and more elegant half of the whole. I love how you find new little details in a harmonious simplicity with each new sip. Fascinating and beautiful already, grand as R.D. in 10 years or more and without a doubt one of the vintage's rare hits.”
“The 2012 marks the second La Grande Année vintage bottled in the new bottle shape, whose narrow neck is to induce something similar to the magnum effect. Upon launch, the 2012 has 10 months of post-disgorgement time and the wine is showing elegantly restrained and youthful. On the nose the old-oak character is less prominent than in most other Bollinger vintages and the deliberate oxidation is well under control and in a supporting role. The fine, cool and pure fruitiness is at the fore with lovely spicy and nutty notes supporting. Lemony fruitiness with yellow apple and ripe apricot as well as some tropical fruit emerging in the glass. On the palate the key word is balance, the wine is very complete with freshness, intensity, refined tension and chalky salinity. 8g/l dosage is spot on. Still young but has the building blocks of longevity. For me similar in quality to the 2008 but this will come around and peak earlier. ”
More Reviews +
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Feb 2020
“Disgorged in July 2019, Bollinger's 2012 Brut La Grande Année is showing well, offering up an incipiently complex bouquet of crisp yellow orchard fruit, fresh peach, orange oil, toasted walnuts and dried apricot that's still quite reserved with less than a year on cork. Full-bodied, deep and muscular, the 2012 is blockier and broader-shouldered than its 2008 predecessor, with a weightier and even more concentrated palate built around a bright spine of acidity, concluding with a chalky finish that carries appreciably dry extract. This isn't quite as elegant as the exquisite 2008, but it is a superb effort and obviously built to age.”
95/100
Richard Juhlin,
,
Feb 2019
“I love the magical moment when I get the chance, as the first journalist, to lighten the cork of the latest vintage of Bollinger La Grande Année…….The wine is made from 21 villages with Aÿ and Verzenay in the driver's seat backed by elegance from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oiry. The wine is characterized by vitality and energy more than depth at present. The colour has a brilliant golden glow and the mousse is almost panting in its resilient youthfulness. The scent is beautifully house typical, dominated by apricot, almond, hazelnut and a smoky sophisticated intensity as from a newly lit outdoor fire. The attack is stunningly intense and the weight in the oral cavity leaves nothing left to wish for. Resilient energy and fullness are combined with greatness. Anyone who has patience will be rewarded with truffled flavour layers,chocolate saturated complexity and added exoticism of honeysuckle in the wine's bouquet.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2020
“65% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay. 21 crus: mainly Aÿ and Verzenay for the Pinot Noir, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oiry for the Chardonnay. All base wines aged in old oak and riddled and disgorged by hand. Dosage 8 g/l. Disgorged in May 2019.
Bright crème pâtissière nose with notes of Cox's orange pippin apple and lots of development. Really quite arresting. Much drier on the palate than the nose suggests, with a certain steeliness. Bone-dry finish but lots of substance on the mid palate. More recognisably Bollinger on the palate than the surprisingly rich, flirtatious nose, presumably informed by the vintage. Low-key mousse. This is clearly a long-distance runner.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“The 2012 Grande Année is vibrant and wonderfully nuanced. Citrus peel, orchard fruit, brioche, dried flowers and chamomile are all finely knit in a Grand Année built on energy and persistence more than size. Readers will find a restrained Grand Année in 2012. There is plenty of the textural richness that is such a signature of the house style, but I am also struck by the wine's freshness. Best of all, the 2012 will drink well right out of the gate. It is quite expressive today, even in the early going.”
“The 2012 marks the second La Grande Année vintage bottled in the new bottle shape, whose narrow neck is to induce something similar to the magnum effect. Upon launch, the 2012 has 10 months of post-disgorgement time and the wine is showing elegantly restrained and youthful. On the nose the old-oak character is less prominent than in most other Bollinger vintages and the deliberate oxidation is well under control and in a supporting role. The fine, cool and pure fruitiness is at the fore with lovely spicy and nutty notes supporting. Lemony fruitiness with yellow apple and ripe apricot as well as some tropical fruit emerging in the glass. On the palate the key word is balance, the wine is very complete with freshness, intensity, refined tension and chalky salinity. 8g/l dosage is spot on. Still young but has the building blocks of longevity. For me similar in quality to the 2008 but this will come around and peak earlier. ”
More Reviews +
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Feb 2020
“Disgorged in July 2019, Bollinger's 2012 Brut La Grande Année is showing well, offering up an incipiently complex bouquet of crisp yellow orchard fruit, fresh peach, orange oil, toasted walnuts and dried apricot that's still quite reserved with less than a year on cork. Full-bodied, deep and muscular, the 2012 is blockier and broader-shouldered than its 2008 predecessor, with a weightier and even more concentrated palate built around a bright spine of acidity, concluding with a chalky finish that carries appreciably dry extract. This isn't quite as elegant as the exquisite 2008, but it is a superb effort and obviously built to age.”
95/100
Richard Juhlin,
,
Feb 2019
“I love the magical moment when I get the chance, as the first journalist, to lighten the cork of the latest vintage of Bollinger La Grande Année…….The wine is made from 21 villages with Aÿ and Verzenay in the driver's seat backed by elegance from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oiry. The wine is characterized by vitality and energy more than depth at present. The colour has a brilliant golden glow and the mousse is almost panting in its resilient youthfulness. The scent is beautifully house typical, dominated by apricot, almond, hazelnut and a smoky sophisticated intensity as from a newly lit outdoor fire. The attack is stunningly intense and the weight in the oral cavity leaves nothing left to wish for. Resilient energy and fullness are combined with greatness. Anyone who has patience will be rewarded with truffled flavour layers,chocolate saturated complexity and added exoticism of honeysuckle in the wine's bouquet.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2020
“65% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay. 21 crus: mainly Aÿ and Verzenay for the Pinot Noir, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oiry for the Chardonnay. All base wines aged in old oak and riddled and disgorged by hand. Dosage 8 g/l. Disgorged in May 2019.
Bright crème pâtissière nose with notes of Cox's orange pippin apple and lots of development. Really quite arresting. Much drier on the palate than the nose suggests, with a certain steeliness. Bone-dry finish but lots of substance on the mid palate. More recognisably Bollinger on the palate than the surprisingly rich, flirtatious nose, presumably informed by the vintage. Low-key mousse. This is clearly a long-distance runner.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“The 2012 Grande Année is vibrant and wonderfully nuanced. Citrus peel, orchard fruit, brioche, dried flowers and chamomile are all finely knit in a Grand Année built on energy and persistence more than size. Readers will find a restrained Grand Année in 2012. There is plenty of the textural richness that is such a signature of the house style, but I am also struck by the wine's freshness. Best of all, the 2012 will drink well right out of the gate. It is quite expressive today, even in the early going.”
“Of the three bottles I so devotedly enjoyed before the rest of the journalism world had time to pounce on this rare treasure, two were somewhat tied up initially in the scent while the third showed off the impressive peacock's tail in its full glory at once. Regardless of the development phase, this is a regal and heroic Bollinger characterized by restrained power and energetic energy. I love meeting this untouched force and carefully analyzing its sublime elements, but at the same time I have to admit that we are dealing with a real "vin de garde" that will not reach its maximum capacity before its 25th birthday. The structure is impressive, based of course on the high acidity of the vintage in the first place. This very high acidity means that the other building blocks can appear as subordinate, but they have a great wealth of both oak embossed secondary aromas and flaunted dark fruit. At present, the aromatic spectrum is characterized by fresh hazelnuts from Piedmont, green apples, chalky minerals and perfumed orange blossom. Buy a case of 12 and follow its aromatic journey to heaven if you get the chance.”
More Reviews +
97+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2019
“Bollinger's 2008 La Grande Année is superb, wafting from the glass with aromas of crisp orchard fruit, ripe lemons, honeycomb, warm biscuits, dried white flowers and a delicate top note of walnuts and fino sherry. On the palate, the wine is full-bodied, broad and vinous, with a beautifully refined mousse, superb concentration at the tightly wound core, incisive acids and a supremely elegant intermingling of Bollinger's oxidative stylistic signatures with fresh, vibrant fruit. The finish is long, precise and chalky. This is a Grande Année built for the cellar—the real excitement will come with a bit more bottle age—but this is already a thrilling Champagne in the making. Finished with eight grams per liter dosage, it was disgorged by hand in July 2018. This is also the first vintage of Grande Année to be bottled in Bollinger's new narrower-necked 1846 bottle, which should make for a slower evolving wine.”
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2019
“Ripe fruity yet at the same time elegant nose with stylish restraint promising longevity. Golden delicious apples, biscuits and lemon alongside complex spicy tones. Lovely creaminess on the fresh and linear palate that finishes with a bite of mineral salinity. The tension and playfulness on the palate is its most attractive feature. Long and intense, yet light-weight palate finishing fresh with its 8g/l dosage (November 2018 disgorgement). Really satisfying already in the 75cl bottle, which benefits from the new bottle shape with narrower neck for “magnum effect”. But as always at Bollinger, the larger formats just sing bringing an attractive, complementary reductive toasty complexity. And of course the mousses in both magnum (96p->98p) and jeroboam (97p -> 99p) are ultra fine. This should have been a bigger quantity vintage for Bollinger and probably plenty will be held back as R.D. So prepare for a shortage of it.”
17.5++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2019
“Magnum - Dense nose with some of the really dry Bollinger savour on the palate. This is a wine, like so many Bollingers, that really needs time in the glass to open out – and indeed time in the bottle to develop to its full potential. This is an extremely dry-tasting wine, even though the dosage was 8 g/l, higher than usual because of the extremely low pH, 2.92. Very Bollinger but, for the moment, by no means a charmer. ”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“Bollinger's 2008 Grande Année is rich, ample and full-bodied, with all of the pedigree of the vintage on display. Dried pear, dried flowers, chamomile, red plum and mint develop as the 2008 shows the breadth and creaminess that are such signatures of the Bollinger house style. A whole range of brighter, more floral and chalky notes appear later, adding translucence and energy. The 2008 is 71% Pinot Noir and 29% Chardonnay taken across 18 crus, and it is the Pinot that very much informs the wine in both flavor and texture. More importantly, the 2008 is one of the best Grande Années I can remember tasting. Bollinger fans won't want to miss it. Disgorged November 2018. Dosage is 8 grams per liter.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2019
“Disgorged July 2018. Tasted blind.
The lightest of these, the most evanescent. Some astringency on the end. Rather loose-textured and the least developed in this blind tasting with, apparently, not that much persistence. Very embryonic. 12% ”
“Mid gold, with a fine bead. Buttered brioche, mellow lees, with stone fruit and bruised apple. Great palate finesse with very subtle mousse, nice balance, and old-cream and brioche complexity. Long, with a vinous finish. Ready now and likely to drink relatively early.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2019
“Opened three weeks earlier and then re-stoppered. Disgorged June 2016. Tasted blind.
Quite complex nose and really dry and fully integrated. Hint of walnuts. Evolved yet with good fruit. This could be the RD… Complicated – requires lots of intellectual concentration. Very long.
Drink 2017-2024”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2019
“Disgorged June 2016. Tasted blind.
Sweet and rich. I don’t think I’d guess it as Bolly on the nose. Then fairly dry on the end which might give it away. Lots of substance here. Firm and confident. Bone dry and rather demanding. Youthful. 12.5%
Drink 2016-2026”
92-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Deep, earthy-spicy, honeyed and nutty nose with dried fruit complexity. The oaky tones prevail underneath ample fruitiness. The evolved nose is complemented by a highly fresh, event tight palate with lovely nervosity and refreshment. The palate texture is silky smooth and vinous. Long lemony finish with notions of minerality. ”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2017
“Bollinger's 2007 Brut La Grande Année is quite pretty. Elegant, restrained and understated in style, the 2007 is one of the more delicate young Grande Années I can remember tasting. Mid-weight structure and silky texture only reinforce that impression. Lemon oil, red berry, dried flowers and chamomile open up nicely, but it is the wine's overall feel that stands out most. Best of all, the 2007 will drink well with no cellaring. Disgorged: September 2016.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Magnum. Current vintage. 70% Pinot Noir, much from their own vineyards. Disgorged April 2017. Dosage 7 g/l. About 13 different villages. pH is under 3. The vintage was criticised by many people. The opening date of harvest was 20 August because of botrytis but at that stage the potential alcohol was only 9.3 or 9.4 degrees – too low! Bollinger waited until September.
Mid gold. Lots of acidity. Masses of energy and a bit more honey than some Bollingers. Apples and honey on the palate. Very fresh and even a lightly yeasty note on the palate. More refreshing than the Bolly stereotype. Maybe not that long but hugely flirtatious within the Bollinger idiom. This will definitely be an RD, I was told. Subtly mineral. Muscular.
Drink 2017-2030”
92-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2017
“Deep, earthy-spicy, honeyed and nutty nose with dried fruit complexity. The oaky tones prevail underneath ample fruitiness. The evolved nose is complemented by a highly fresh, event tight palate with lovely nervosity and refreshment. The palate texture is silky smooth and vinous. Long lemony finish with notions of minerality.”
95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Oct 2016
“It might seem a bit surprising that Bollinger skipped the great vintage of 2006 for the more modest 2007. For me that choice is however quite logical since the Bollinger house style is much better suited to austere vintages than for fruit bombs. Here we have a classic and perfectly balanced Bollinger with deep layers and beautiful crisp apple acidity. Gorgeous balance between the dark and light as a perfect Ying and Yang marriage. Layers of dry cocoa, hazelnut fudge, dried apricots and juicy red apples dominate over a beautiful hint of forest aromas based on sous bois and mushrooms in the background. One of the three best champagnes from this vintage.”
“Mid gold, with a fine bead. Buttered brioche, mellow lees, with stone fruit and bruised apple. Great palate finesse with very subtle mousse, nice balance, and old-cream and brioche complexity. Long, with a vinous finish. Ready now and likely to drink relatively early.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2019
“Opened three weeks earlier and then re-stoppered. Disgorged June 2016. Tasted blind.
Quite complex nose and really dry and fully integrated. Hint of walnuts. Evolved yet with good fruit. This could be the RD… Complicated – requires lots of intellectual concentration. Very long.
Drink 2017-2024”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2019
“Disgorged June 2016. Tasted blind.
Sweet and rich. I don’t think I’d guess it as Bolly on the nose. Then fairly dry on the end which might give it away. Lots of substance here. Firm and confident. Bone dry and rather demanding. Youthful. 12.5%
Drink 2016-2026”
92-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Deep, earthy-spicy, honeyed and nutty nose with dried fruit complexity. The oaky tones prevail underneath ample fruitiness. The evolved nose is complemented by a highly fresh, event tight palate with lovely nervosity and refreshment. The palate texture is silky smooth and vinous. Long lemony finish with notions of minerality. ”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2017
“Bollinger's 2007 Brut La Grande Année is quite pretty. Elegant, restrained and understated in style, the 2007 is one of the more delicate young Grande Années I can remember tasting. Mid-weight structure and silky texture only reinforce that impression. Lemon oil, red berry, dried flowers and chamomile open up nicely, but it is the wine's overall feel that stands out most. Best of all, the 2007 will drink well with no cellaring. Disgorged: September 2016.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Magnum. Current vintage. 70% Pinot Noir, much from their own vineyards. Disgorged April 2017. Dosage 7 g/l. About 13 different villages. pH is under 3. The vintage was criticised by many people. The opening date of harvest was 20 August because of botrytis but at that stage the potential alcohol was only 9.3 or 9.4 degrees – too low! Bollinger waited until September.
Mid gold. Lots of acidity. Masses of energy and a bit more honey than some Bollingers. Apples and honey on the palate. Very fresh and even a lightly yeasty note on the palate. More refreshing than the Bolly stereotype. Maybe not that long but hugely flirtatious within the Bollinger idiom. This will definitely be an RD, I was told. Subtly mineral. Muscular.
Drink 2017-2030”
92-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2017
“Deep, earthy-spicy, honeyed and nutty nose with dried fruit complexity. The oaky tones prevail underneath ample fruitiness. The evolved nose is complemented by a highly fresh, event tight palate with lovely nervosity and refreshment. The palate texture is silky smooth and vinous. Long lemony finish with notions of minerality.”
95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Oct 2016
“It might seem a bit surprising that Bollinger skipped the great vintage of 2006 for the more modest 2007. For me that choice is however quite logical since the Bollinger house style is much better suited to austere vintages than for fruit bombs. Here we have a classic and perfectly balanced Bollinger with deep layers and beautiful crisp apple acidity. Gorgeous balance between the dark and light as a perfect Ying and Yang marriage. Layers of dry cocoa, hazelnut fudge, dried apricots and juicy red apples dominate over a beautiful hint of forest aromas based on sous bois and mushrooms in the background. One of the three best champagnes from this vintage.”
“Disgorged January 2016. Magnum. Tasted blind.
Very rich nose. Then slight fade on the end. Very well-balanced wine. Some sweetness on the end. 12%
Drink 2016-2025”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2017
“Already quite deep gold. Beefy and substantial with both breadth and depth but also great refreshment value. Real Bollinger character.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2016
“Medium-deep peach-hued colour. Strong, charred, characterful nose with a notable oxidative tone and explosive super-ripe fruitiness. Full and viscous, oily, concentrated palate. Massive and winey.”
94/100
Andrew Jefford,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2016
“Pale old-gold in colour, and searching, winey scents with an amplitude which recalls mature burgundy (the apple orchard, sweet hay and soft hazels). Structured, broad and full on the palate, with ripe acidity recalling many fruits, even red ones. There have probably been Grande Années with more nerve and sinew than this, but its breadth, complexity and texture are hugely satisfying and that ‘winey’ appeal surely owes much to 100 per cent old-wood fermentation. ”
94/100
Alison Napjus,
New Wine Spectator,
Aug 2015
“A powerful, structured and graceful 2005, showing deft integration of the rich, chalky underpinning, firm acidity and expansive flavours of crushed back currant, spring blossom, toasted almond, crystallized honey and preserved lemon. Offers a fine, raw silk-like mousse and a long, spiced finish. Disgorged February 2015. Drink now through 2030.”
94/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2015
“The 2005 is an impressively fresh Champagne that has an array of grilled nuts, nougat and chalky minerals ahead of red apple, lemon and grapefruit pith, red fruits and attractive red floral perfume. The palate's supple, smoothly cut, and has a wealth of concentrated dark and red berry fruit flavor that really speaks of pinot noir. This has warmth and richness; really bold and smooth with some spice to close too. The palate has a lot of power, weight and length. Will evolve to deliver brulée, toffee and mocha. Drink now or hold for five years.”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“Bollinger's 2005 La Grande Année is an attractive Champagne to drink now and over the next handful of years, as it is already quite forward. Burnished, slightly oxidative classic Bollinger notes meld into scents of honey, apricot jam, smoke, sage, mint and wild flowers. Open-knit and expressive, the 2005 has plenty to offer today, while it appears destined for near and medium-term drinking. Although a solid wine, the 2005 is a far cry from some of the other stronger recent editions.”
18.5+/20
Matthew Jukes,
MatthewJukes.com,
Apr 2015
“The bouquet is exuberantly floral, the bubbles are minuscule and it is ever so slightly pink-tinged. There is classic Bollinger richness here, but it is coupled with restraint. The fruit is very ripe and it is counterbalanced with less dosage than normal – 6 g/L (as opposed to the usual level of 9/10). More detail emerges as the wine opens – spice, bark and candied orange peel notes on the finish offset the creamy, honeyed, brioche notes on the palate. There is a very definite link between this wine and the 2005 Vieilles Vignes Françaises (also reviewed on matthewjukes.com) in terms of its power and dimensions. In 2005 Bollinger went back to the ‘pillar’ of the company, Pinot Noir, with 70% of this grape used (2002 RD used only 60%). The number of Crus used in this vintage is smaller than normal, too. Normally, in LGA, Bollinger uses 20 Crus, however in 2005 they only used 13, principally in their heartland of Aÿ and Verzenay. This is because of the large size of the bunches and the rainfall in September – rot was a danger. Many other Houses suffered a lot but Bollinger’s vineyards are grassed in between the rows and this helped enormously. They also stopped using fertiliser in 2005 which resulted in a superior crop. This is definitely a more forward vintage than expected at the beginning of its life but will also keep beautifully. You could drink it now, but I expect that its peak will be 2 years and it will last until 2030.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2015
“Disgorged Oct 2014. Very subtle, complete nose. Hedgerows and lift. Substantial wine that is not as tight-knit as some but is certainly attention grabbing.”
“Disgorged January 2016. Magnum. Tasted blind.
Very rich nose. Then slight fade on the end. Very well-balanced wine. Some sweetness on the end. 12%
Drink 2016-2025”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2017
“Already quite deep gold. Beefy and substantial with both breadth and depth but also great refreshment value. Real Bollinger character.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2016
“Medium-deep peach-hued colour. Strong, charred, characterful nose with a notable oxidative tone and explosive super-ripe fruitiness. Full and viscous, oily, concentrated palate. Massive and winey.”
94/100
Andrew Jefford,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2016
“Pale old-gold in colour, and searching, winey scents with an amplitude which recalls mature burgundy (the apple orchard, sweet hay and soft hazels). Structured, broad and full on the palate, with ripe acidity recalling many fruits, even red ones. There have probably been Grande Années with more nerve and sinew than this, but its breadth, complexity and texture are hugely satisfying and that ‘winey’ appeal surely owes much to 100 per cent old-wood fermentation. ”
94/100
Alison Napjus,
New Wine Spectator,
Aug 2015
“A powerful, structured and graceful 2005, showing deft integration of the rich, chalky underpinning, firm acidity and expansive flavours of crushed back currant, spring blossom, toasted almond, crystallized honey and preserved lemon. Offers a fine, raw silk-like mousse and a long, spiced finish. Disgorged February 2015. Drink now through 2030.”
94/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2015
“The 2005 is an impressively fresh Champagne that has an array of grilled nuts, nougat and chalky minerals ahead of red apple, lemon and grapefruit pith, red fruits and attractive red floral perfume. The palate's supple, smoothly cut, and has a wealth of concentrated dark and red berry fruit flavor that really speaks of pinot noir. This has warmth and richness; really bold and smooth with some spice to close too. The palate has a lot of power, weight and length. Will evolve to deliver brulée, toffee and mocha. Drink now or hold for five years.”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“Bollinger's 2005 La Grande Année is an attractive Champagne to drink now and over the next handful of years, as it is already quite forward. Burnished, slightly oxidative classic Bollinger notes meld into scents of honey, apricot jam, smoke, sage, mint and wild flowers. Open-knit and expressive, the 2005 has plenty to offer today, while it appears destined for near and medium-term drinking. Although a solid wine, the 2005 is a far cry from some of the other stronger recent editions.”
18.5+/20
Matthew Jukes,
MatthewJukes.com,
Apr 2015
“The bouquet is exuberantly floral, the bubbles are minuscule and it is ever so slightly pink-tinged. There is classic Bollinger richness here, but it is coupled with restraint. The fruit is very ripe and it is counterbalanced with less dosage than normal – 6 g/L (as opposed to the usual level of 9/10). More detail emerges as the wine opens – spice, bark and candied orange peel notes on the finish offset the creamy, honeyed, brioche notes on the palate. There is a very definite link between this wine and the 2005 Vieilles Vignes Françaises (also reviewed on matthewjukes.com) in terms of its power and dimensions. In 2005 Bollinger went back to the ‘pillar’ of the company, Pinot Noir, with 70% of this grape used (2002 RD used only 60%). The number of Crus used in this vintage is smaller than normal, too. Normally, in LGA, Bollinger uses 20 Crus, however in 2005 they only used 13, principally in their heartland of Aÿ and Verzenay. This is because of the large size of the bunches and the rainfall in September – rot was a danger. Many other Houses suffered a lot but Bollinger’s vineyards are grassed in between the rows and this helped enormously. They also stopped using fertiliser in 2005 which resulted in a superior crop. This is definitely a more forward vintage than expected at the beginning of its life but will also keep beautifully. You could drink it now, but I expect that its peak will be 2 years and it will last until 2030.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2015
“Disgorged Oct 2014. Very subtle, complete nose. Hedgerows and lift. Substantial wine that is not as tight-knit as some but is certainly attention grabbing.”
“Disgorged September 2012. Tasted blind.
Looks, and tastes, relatively youthful. More mineral nose. Very fresh palate. Lots of zest, almost citrus. Long and satisfying. 12%
Drink 2017-2025”
More Reviews +
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2014
“Red fruit dominant nose with pastry nuances. There is a beautifully Burgundian feel to it with an accentuated oaky note without too much of an oxidative ad-on. Dry, serious finish with its 7g/l dosage. Big and bold but not one of the most complex of vintages. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2014
“Really interesting, complex nose with lots of age and development and polished autumn-leaf characters. Fascinating wine that is probably too interesting to throw back at a reception. Complete and compelling.”
94/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2013
“(disgorged January, 2013): Light, bright gold. Powerful orchard and pit fruit aromas are complemented by smoky lees, iodine, chamomile and buttered toast. At once fleshy and energetic, offering deeply pitched poached pear, peach pit and brioche flavors and a suave floral element. Finishes smoky and very long, with mounting spiciness and lingering floral and vanilla notes.”
“Disgorged September 2012. Tasted blind.
Looks, and tastes, relatively youthful. More mineral nose. Very fresh palate. Lots of zest, almost citrus. Long and satisfying. 12%
Drink 2017-2025”
More Reviews +
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2014
“Red fruit dominant nose with pastry nuances. There is a beautifully Burgundian feel to it with an accentuated oaky note without too much of an oxidative ad-on. Dry, serious finish with its 7g/l dosage. Big and bold but not one of the most complex of vintages. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2014
“Really interesting, complex nose with lots of age and development and polished autumn-leaf characters. Fascinating wine that is probably too interesting to throw back at a reception. Complete and compelling.”
94/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2013
“(disgorged January, 2013): Light, bright gold. Powerful orchard and pit fruit aromas are complemented by smoky lees, iodine, chamomile and buttered toast. At once fleshy and energetic, offering deeply pitched poached pear, peach pit and brioche flavors and a suave floral element. Finishes smoky and very long, with mounting spiciness and lingering floral and vanilla notes.”
“60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. Disgorged November 2011. RS 6 g/l.
Tasted blind. Savoury and cheesy and interesting on the nose. Very distinctive. Exciting and very deep flavoured. Very confident and multi-layered. In the prime of life. Not heavy - sufficiently racy. Clean and neat. A firm cast-iron framework. Impressive. Very long.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2016
“Originally this wine showed an edge of austerity and bitterness over the powerful, compressed core. The R.D. showed more charm upon launch. Tasted in magnum only in May 2016: a mild earthy-mineral oxidative note but under control. Spice, vanilla, apple, apple pie. Long and firm, zesty but laudably harmonious. Points for magnum.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2019
“Disgorged October 2010. Tasted blind.
Something a bit rubbery on the nose but very tense and exciting. Is this the 2008? Tense and vibrant, with lots of complexity and persistence. Impressive for its age. 12%
Drink 2012-2030”
93/100
Richard Juhlin,
www.champagneclub.com,
Nov 2015
“Since the year 1990 made vintage wines from Bollinger in a little fruitier more persikodoftande style with slightly less pronounced smokiness and nuttiness. I was always more impressed initially by the previous style, but it feels like the differences even out over time. 2002 is very fruity and a little slippery at the moment, but I am convinced that the fruitiness will be low, and that we will see a deeper beauty over time. Fantastic in magnum.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2012
“60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. Pale gold. Very sumptuous nose. Inspirationally serious. Layers and dry with enormous tightness and very tiny bead. Something almost beery about the yeast element. You could definitely enjoy this already but there is also massive potential. Very dry finish. Uncompromising. You wouldn't give this to a beginner. Long, peacock's tail finish.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com ,
Dec 2011
“The 2002 Brut La Grande Annee is marvelous. The 2002 is an understated Grande Annee that caresses the palate with layers of effortless, weightless fruit. The mousse is exceptionally fine, which adds to the impression of total elegance. This is a relatively bright, floral Grande Annee with plenty of aromatic lift, inner perfume and no sense of heaviness at all. A rich, creamy finish adds the final note of complexity and pedigree. The 2002 is 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, 71% from Grand Cru villages and 29% from Premier Crus. Disgorged February 2011.”
“In 2018, a judicious 5% addition of red wine from the celebrated La Côte aux Enfants parcel lends this La Grande Année Rosé its luminous salmon hue and hallmark red-berry soul. The delicious bouquet is led by a mélange of freshly crushed berries - wild strawberry, cranberry and maraschino cherry - still decidedly primary in character. With aeration, the profile deepens: a subtle exotic spiciness emerges, together with dried rose petals and a distinctly stony minerality that speaks to its chalk origins. On the palate, the wine moves with a silky glide. Beneath its soothing texture lies almost an electric, gently sizzling energy that keeps the structure taut. The wine finishing with a juicy length, it leaves an invitation for another sip. A brilliant vintage for La Grande Année Rosé. ”
More Reviews +
97/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Mar 2026
“Like a prima ballerina, this is all about grace married to precision and fine definition. An expressive core of pureed raspberry, poached apricot, blood orange gelée and toast point is framed by well-honed acidity. A subtle, fragrant thread of fresh thyme, oyster shell, and ground ginger and cinnamon winds through and lingers on the plush, mouthwatering finish. Pinot Noir and Chardonnay.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2025
“Dense for a rosé – a serious, savoury wine with more than a hint of Campari bitters about it, but extremely refreshing as all champagne should be. Intriguing and very much up my street. Bollinger didn’t make a rosé until 2005 because Madame Lily Bollinger scorned the style but I think this is delicious!
This went beautifully with Ritz chef John Williams’ Suffolk lamb with stuffed morel, courgette flower and mint emulsion. Bollinger’s MD Charles-Armand de Belenet made the point that they make a rosé to highlight the quality of their red wine, and that they are toying with the idea of an RD rosé!”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2026
“The 2018 La Grande Année Rosé is open-knit and quite caressing. It offers a bit more up-front fruit than the Blanc, suggesting it will drink well right out of the gate. The addition of 5% still red Pinot from La Côte aux Enfants and slightly higher dosage vis-à-vis the Blanc soften the contours. Cranberry, chalk, mint, white pepper and orange peel fill out the layers nicely. This vibrant, mid-weight Rosé is quite versatile; it will drink well as an aperitif or at the dinner table. The Grand Année Rosé is crafted from the same base as the Blanc. Dosage is 8 grams per liter. Disgorged: May 2025. ”
95/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2026
“Being based on the white blend of Grande Année, one would expect a family resemblance in the rosé. Indeed the vintage's friendly, approachable nature is very much still here, yet even a small red wine addition in the blend (5%) brings an energising, complexing sense of substance and structure which elevates this slightly above the white with its gentle blackcurrant, raspberry and bitter herb intensity over the recognisable sweet stone fruit, blood orange and salty, briny savour of the style. Once again it is less structured and punchy than the 2015, but arguably finer in build, well-set for delicious drinking over the next decade at least. 2026-2036.”
95/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“Since its inception in 1976, this cuvée has been anchored in the white rendition of La Grande Année, complemented—this year by 5%—with red wine from La Côte aux Enfants vineyard in Aÿ. Disgorged in May 2025 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, Bollinger’s 2018 La Grande Année Rosé reveals aromas of peach, crisp red apple and blood orange mingled with redcurrant. Medium- to full-bodied, it opens with a textural attack that segues into a muscular palate, where delicate aromatic bitters gradually assert themselves along a sapid, persistent finish. While many wines from this solar vintage display comparatively soft, moderately concentrated profiles, this is not one of them.”
94/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2026
“A whiff of black pepper opens the aromas of toasted brioche, roasted almonds and delicate peonies. Medium-bodied with intense flavors of fresh strawberries, red fruit sorbet and wafer cookies. Delicious and lightly saline.”
“When Madame Lily retired, Bollinger did the unthinkable and added Jacques’s beloved La Côte aux Enfants red wine as the colouring component in the new cuvée Grande Année Rosé. She would ultimately have been proud, though, because it really works, as shown by this wonderful 2015. Deep peachy colour, then a complex nose of spice-laden fruitiness: cranberries, dried apricots, candied orange, dark cherries, even blackberries. The palate has both vinosity and freshness; it is still tightly focused and reserved, promising longevity. This is a beautiful edition of La Grande Année and one of 2015’s best surprises. Dosage: 7g/l”
More Reviews +
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2024
“Born from the addition of five percent of La Côte aux Enfants red wine into the white La Grande Année blend, this fine rosé delights with its sweet fruity appeal of freshly crushed strawberries, apricot tart, candied fruit and orange peel. Rather fruit-forward and highly youthful for the time being, there is much more aromatic complexity to surface over time. The fine quality of the red wine of the year can be sensed on the palate, where the tannin structure feels firm but extremely elegant. Its mouthfeel is juicy with an attractive rounding oiliness to the texture. The wine is free of the common vegetal austerity of the year, instead it shows the richness and deliciousness of its sun-kissed harvest year. The fine fruit quality and seductively silky tannin structure ensure its great ageworthiness. ”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“The soulful depth of La Grande Année Rosé stems from the discreet yet powerful addition of five percent La Côte aux Enfants red wine. The 2015 vintage shows a luminous deep orange hue. Its nose leans into savouriness, layered with char and a twist of black pepper. The fruit is refined and irresistibly charming, yet brimming with personality. Dried apricots lead, joined by Mirabelle plums and Maraschino cherries. On the palate, it flows with vinous grace and harmonious length, a standout achievement from a challenging year. Disgorgement date:01/02/24. Dosage:7g/l.”
96/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2024
“Bollinger's 2015 Brut La Grande Année Rosé was disgorged in May last year with seven grams per liter dosage. Offering up deep aromas of orchard fruits, blood orange, mandarin rind and peach mingled with nuances of coffee, praline and fino sherry, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and layered, with a broad attack that segues into a vinous palate framed by high levels of structuring dry extract that makes its presence felt on the sapid, nutty and penetrating finish. Given the skin maturity and inherent structure of the year, the Bollinger team elected to include only 4.5% of still red wine in the blend, a comparatively low percentage.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2024
“Pale, slightly gris salmon pink (a little paler than the Billecart 2012 Elisabeth Salmon rosé tasted alongside). Heady, mushroomy, off-dry, sumptuous Bollinger gloriousness on the palate. I wonder what the dosage is, and whether the richness comes mainly from the fruit and oak? Finishes dry, but with wonderfully soothing impact on the palate. Relatively gentle mousse. Really gets to the deepest part of the throat. Sensational!”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“Disgorged in February 2024 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, Bollinger's 2015 La Grande Année Rosé is showing very well, delivering notes of blood orange, cowberry and brioche mingled with nectarine stone. Medium- to full-bodied, the palate is muscular yet racy, with a crisp core of fruit animated by a pillowy mousse and framed by structuring extract that leads into a long, saline finish. Whereas many large-house rosés today tend to exhibit a cloying mid-palate sweetness, this cuvée avoids the trap and comes warmly recommended.”
“At this point of youthfulness the pink colour is rather rich and bright. Lovely clean and fruit-forward nose with fresh red berry aromas mixing with spice and orange notes. Quite shyly evolved with much more to surface on the complexity front. Today there is attractive exuberant fruitiness and perfect creamy freshness. Promising palate with power and persistence where an overall harmony enhances the feeling of sophistication.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Dec 2019
“Medium salmon pink, silver hues, fine persistent mousse. A hint of red forest berries followed by subtle smoky spice nuances, fresh cherry notes mingled with hints of white apple. Juicy and elegant on the palate, in perfect balance with enchanting fruit followed by a saline-mineral finish, displaying enormous length and a great drinking flow. An incredibly seductive rosé Champagne with great personality and real ageing potential.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The 2012 La Grande Année Rosé is airy, gracious and so wonderfully inviting. Crushed flowers, mint, white pepper and red berry fruit are all gracefully woven together. Today, the 2012 is naturally quite young and still shows the tension of a Champagne that was disgorged just a few months ago. Readers who prefer Champagnes with softer edges and a bit more flavor complexity will want to cellar the 2012. I have to admit, I very much like the wine today, in its youthful state, where its energy and focus are front and center. The 2012 is a blend of 67% Pinot Noir and 33% Chardonnay taken from 21 villages built around a core of Aÿ and Verzenay Pinot Noir and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oiry Chardonnay, crus that are quite complementary. Disgorged January 2020. Dosage is 8 grams per liter.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“A blend of white Grande Année 2012 with some still red from Bollinger's Côte aux Enfants vineyard.
Quite intense salmon pink with a sort of bronze tinge. Tiny bead. Heady nose. Tastes a little drier than the current Bollinger NV Rosé with a little more grip on the end and more depth – also less evolution. Long and vibrant with a hint of strawberry juice and vegetables (cabbage?). Really rather explosive on the finish. I think for current drinking I might even choose the NV version.
Drink 2022 – 2029”
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2020
“Disgorged with eight grams per liter dosage, Bollinger's 2012 Brut La Grande Année Rosé is showing beautifully, wafting from the glass with aromas of raspberries, plums, orange rind, walnuts and fresh bread that only hint of the complexity to come. Full-bodied, broad and vinous, with fine depth at the core, a pinpoint mousse and racy acids, it concludes with a long and perfumed finish. The blend includes 5% red wine exclusively from Bollinger's La Côte Aux Enfants vineyard—which imparts delicate phenolic grip.”
95/100
Richard Juhlin,
,
Jul 2020
“For the first time ever, I enjoyed the rosé edition of La Grande Année in January 2020. Mostly, LGAR has felt a little heavier than the white version. This time there is an extremely charming uplifting juiciness and fruit that makes the wine a winner. My thoughts and comparisons guides me towards historical bottles with their wonderful notes of orange fudge, nougat and white chocolate. The colour is also slightly brighter than before and the added wine from one of the foremost parcels in Aÿ, Côte aux Enfants, gives a delicious elegance and silky texture. Although the base wine is identical to LGA and only 5% red wine has been added, they are as different as night and day. The Rosé has a creaminess and charm that appeals at the moment. It is also exciting to see that the rosé has a strong element of red citrus, with blood orange and red grapefruit as clear components of the harmonic symphony. It will be an exciting journey to follow both LGA and LGAR into the future, but if I recommend a storage of at least five years in my own cellar for LGA, I will start drinking my rosé bottles with great pleasure next weekend.”
“This note is for a magnum that so well brings out the soul of La Grande Année and its characterful La Côte aux Enfents red wine heart. Such a combination of vinosity and silkiness coming with full-on Pinot aromas of red berries, oriental spices and forest floor notes. Structured and long with the softest mousse in magnum in absence of too many oxidative notes. ”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2018
“Tasted blind. Deep, slightly greyish salmon colour. Real depth and intrigue to this nose. Could be Nyetimber 1086? Lots of phenolics on the finish but pretty exciting on the way there. Very meaty. Food wine. Very good.
Drink 2019-2024”
18/20
Tim Jackson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“Medium onion-skin. Coffee lees expression over dark cherry, some flint and dried-herb savouriness. Some old-cream complexity that needs coaxing from the glass. Firm, chalky texture with red and black cherry, some orange-citrus and plenty of nutty lees. Fine, brooding and dense. Needs time to open. Very fine rosé.”
96/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
robertparker.com,
Jun 2018
“I have tasted an excellent, beautifully fresh, precise and and persistent range of Bollinger Champagne. The Brut Rosé is just fabulous and helps to bridge the time we have to wait for the promising and highly refined 2007 Grande Année Rosé that still needs some years in the bottle to play out its class and complexity. 2007 saw a very early harvest, and the exceptional wines are characterized by freshness and finesse. For the moment, I prefer the very fine, elegant and chalky style of the Grande Année Rosé to the more rich and full-bodied Blanc. I'm also excited to follow the evolution of the 2004 R. D. Extra Brut that was just disgorged in February and combines freshness with maturity but will improve over the years. The 2014 La Côte aux Enfants, a 12% alcohol Pinot Noir from Aÿ, is a filigreed red Coteaux Champenois and is fabulous in its lightness, purity and elegance. However, it is still young and peppery and needs some years to gain more complexity.”
“Bollinger finally based its 4th edition of this pure Pinot Noir cuvée on its home terroir Aÿ’s fruit. As much as 47% of the blend is made up of Aÿ Pinot Noir, lending its broad and silky yet chalky print on the wine, which Verzenay, Tauxières and Avenay-Val-d’Or support. The amply fruity 2018 vintage represents a half of the blend, its ripeness giving a light peachy tone already to the colour. The rest is constructed of 2017 and 2016 reserve wines and as much as 25% of 2009 vintage reserve wine magnums. The supple nose comes with sweet vanilla tones, apple compote, orange blossom and pencil shavings. There is an immediate charm also to the fleshy and airy yet precise palate. Towards the back palate an energising freshness emerges, adding vivacity to the creamy and textured whole. A beautifully constructed cuvée playing on all the Bollinger fortes. Dosage 6g/l.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Tyson Stelzer,
Tysonstelzer.com,
Jun 2023
“PN AYC18 is a showpiece for the expansive dimensions, intoxicating allure and purity of Aÿ pinot noir; a wonderfully characterful blanc de noirs that celebrates the sumptuous fruit generosity of 2018 and the purity and precision of this fabled cru. With the generous tones of a full straw hue and a blush tint, it ripples with grand fruit depth of red cherries and perfectly ripe plums. The magnificent depth of complexity that is Bollinger rumbles in deep reserves, reminiscent of fruit mince spice and dried nectarines. I love that it is so emphatically Aÿ, so intrinsically Bollinger, and yet all transposed with the transparency and delicious fruit generosity that is 2018. It holds fantastic, succulent allure on a very long finish; the ripeness of 2018 translating in supple, silky fruit generosity, yet in no way heavy or broad, beautifully energised by the fine chalk salinity and pure acid freshness that make Aÿ such a beloved place.”
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2018 vintage, complemented by reserve wines aged in magnum dating back to 2009, Bollinger's newly released NV Brut Blanc de Noirs PN AYC18 was disgorged this year with six grams per liter dosage. Foregrounding the village of Aÿ, a commune crucial to Bollinger's distinctive style, the wine wafts from the glass with aromas of golden orchard fruit, honeycomb, buttered toast, freshly baked bread and dried white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and vinous, with an ample core of fruit that's girdled by lively acids and animated by an elegant pinpoint mousse, this suave, charming Champagne concludes with a chalky finish. This has turned out beautifully.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
Champagneclub.com,
Jun 2023
“Finally, it was time for Aÿ to take center stage in Bollinger's new Pinot Noir series. It wasn't until the fourth edition that one got home to the house's most powerful stronghold and DNA. In comparison to the three previous editions, we are dealing with a tasting winner from the start. The oak notes and the home village's smoky features hit me like a wall of sauna, grilled meat, hazelnuts and tar. The color is deeper than in previous editions and the power stronger than in the first three PN. 47% of the wine comes from the home village in casks both from 2018 and in the reserve wine on magnums from 2009. In between these mighty parts we have steel tank-aged Tauxières, Avenay and Verzenay from the lighter and more mineral-influenced vintages of 2016 and 2017. This particular side takes the biggest place in the middle register and mid-palate of the wine. In aroma and aftertaste, Aÿ pushes forward with its broad muscular shoulders and leaves no one untouched. A bargain with peak 2030–2035!”
“Bollinger finally based its 4th edition of this pure Pinot Noir cuvée on its home terroir Aÿ’s fruit. As much as 47% of the blend is made up of Aÿ Pinot Noir, lending its broad and silky yet chalky print on the wine, which Verzenay, Tauxières and Avenay-Val-d’Or support. The amply fruity 2018 vintage represents a half of the blend, its ripeness giving a light peachy tone already to the colour. The rest is constructed of 2017 and 2016 reserve wines and as much as 25% of 2009 vintage reserve wine magnums. The supple nose comes with sweet vanilla tones, apple compote, orange blossom and pencil shavings. There is an immediate charm also to the fleshy and airy yet precise palate. Towards the back palate an energising freshness emerges, adding vivacity to the creamy and textured whole. A beautifully constructed cuvée playing on all the Bollinger fortes. Dosage 6g/l.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Tyson Stelzer,
Tysonstelzer.com,
Jun 2023
“PN AYC18 is a showpiece for the expansive dimensions, intoxicating allure and purity of Aÿ pinot noir; a wonderfully characterful blanc de noirs that celebrates the sumptuous fruit generosity of 2018 and the purity and precision of this fabled cru. With the generous tones of a full straw hue and a blush tint, it ripples with grand fruit depth of red cherries and perfectly ripe plums. The magnificent depth of complexity that is Bollinger rumbles in deep reserves, reminiscent of fruit mince spice and dried nectarines. I love that it is so emphatically Aÿ, so intrinsically Bollinger, and yet all transposed with the transparency and delicious fruit generosity that is 2018. It holds fantastic, succulent allure on a very long finish; the ripeness of 2018 translating in supple, silky fruit generosity, yet in no way heavy or broad, beautifully energised by the fine chalk salinity and pure acid freshness that make Aÿ such a beloved place.”
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2018 vintage, complemented by reserve wines aged in magnum dating back to 2009, Bollinger's newly released NV Brut Blanc de Noirs PN AYC18 was disgorged this year with six grams per liter dosage. Foregrounding the village of Aÿ, a commune crucial to Bollinger's distinctive style, the wine wafts from the glass with aromas of golden orchard fruit, honeycomb, buttered toast, freshly baked bread and dried white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and vinous, with an ample core of fruit that's girdled by lively acids and animated by an elegant pinpoint mousse, this suave, charming Champagne concludes with a chalky finish. This has turned out beautifully.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
Champagneclub.com,
Jun 2023
“Finally, it was time for Aÿ to take center stage in Bollinger's new Pinot Noir series. It wasn't until the fourth edition that one got home to the house's most powerful stronghold and DNA. In comparison to the three previous editions, we are dealing with a tasting winner from the start. The oak notes and the home village's smoky features hit me like a wall of sauna, grilled meat, hazelnuts and tar. The color is deeper than in previous editions and the power stronger than in the first three PN. 47% of the wine comes from the home village in casks both from 2018 and in the reserve wine on magnums from 2009. In between these mighty parts we have steel tank-aged Tauxières, Avenay and Verzenay from the lighter and more mineral-influenced vintages of 2016 and 2017. This particular side takes the biggest place in the middle register and mid-palate of the wine. In aroma and aftertaste, Aÿ pushes forward with its broad muscular shoulders and leaves no one untouched. A bargain with peak 2030–2035!”
18+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Oct 2024
“PN AYC18 #MagnumEffect – Very flattering the plush peachy ripeness 100% Pinot Noir of south facing chalky slopes overlooking the village of Ay, 47% of the blend, the chalky notes super visible and a chunk 25% of #ReserveMagnums really add the fat richness to the texture. I love this wine magnum effect adding a smoky freshness! ”
“"Oh wow! What a lovely Bollinger AYC21. Wonderfully bright freshly cut red apple skin is wrapped in smouldering smokiness on the nose. Beautiful concentration and energy-laden, almost driven vigour characterise the palate that is just so fresh, so bright and so Bollinger-signature creamy. This is defined by these three words: energy, elegance and elan on a taut yet generous body. This fits seamlessly into Champagne Bollinger's extraordinary - in the truest sense of the word - series of special releases that highlight Pinot Noir from different villages. It all started in 2020 with the release of PNVZ15. In this case the starring Village is Ay, where most of the fruit is from, supplemented by Tauxieres and Mutigny. 49% of the blend is from the base year 2021, with 51% of reserves. 25% of reserve wines date to 2012, 2013, and 2014. This is a wonderful fit showing warmer and riper Ay in the cooler 2021. Bravo!"”
More Reviews +
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2026
“A cooler damp summer and no LGA produced means the choice of grapes was wide open. Bollinger being super strong in the south facing slopes of Ay bring that ripe fruit charm, wafts of bitter lemon and grapefruit combine with spicy red fruits like strawberry and peach blended with hints of spice from the 49% reserve wines back to 2012 in magnum, bring density and texture to the palate. A lighter style than say the AYC 2018, but very much a delicious addition to the PN lineup.”
“From the commune of Tauxières and the 2017 vintage, Bollinger's new NV Brut Blanc de Noirs PN TX17 exhibits aromas of crisp pear, orange zest and wet stones mingled with subtle hints of warm bread and dried fruits. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and fleshy, with tangy acids and impressive ripeness for the vintage, it concludes with an elegantly mordant finish. This doesn't strike me as a year built to make old bones, but it should nonetheless enjoy over a decade's evolution.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jun 2022
“A tender nose shows of a sense of fresh, sweet cream and crushed berry – unusually with a hint of blueberry, followed by Red Delicious apple and a beautifully lifted and aromatic note of tangerine. The palate is sinuous and elegant, there is wonderful depth of fruit and that lovely signature creaminess of Bollinger expressed in superfine foam. There is subtle length that only emphasises the depth of flavour. Very elegant, very expressive, as vivid, energetic and vibrant as the previous releases under this series. Lovely. ”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“On the stylish nose, spicy, woody and hazelnut tones meet pristine Pinot Noir fruitiness. The challenging 2017 harvest is the base here, and Bollinger found, in Tauxières, the fruit quality and profile to craft this edition of its pop-up cuvée. Coming with a fine yeasty notion and well protected from oxidation, the fruitiness really shines loud and bright, supported by a complexity brought about by the reserve wines. The palate carries the lightness and freshness of the cool year, and it all ends on a brisk, dry note. This is a delightfully different and beautifully delicate wine from Bollinger. Disgorged 2/22; dosage 4g/l”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“A deep honey colour for a champagne. Very seductive nose with considerable apparent evolution on it. Much more youthful on the palate than the nose suggests and some dried apple-skin notes on the bone-dry, impressively persistent finish. Very much in the house style. A worthy successor to previous cuvées of this wine, with its own personality.
Drink 2022–2032”
92-94/100
Richard Juhlin,
farrvintners.com,
Feb 2022
“The wine is almost completely dominated by the extremely exciting and rare Tauxières Premier Cru, which is one of two villages classified 99% on the Grand Cru scale. Despite an impressive vineyard area of 237 hectares, it is extremely rare to come across champagnes dominated by this fantastic Cru. A cooler microclimate and a thinner soil layer with even more compact chalk than sunny Bouzy make the wines from here lighter and more elegant than Bouzy but stronger than Verzenay which is also part of this exciting Blanc de Noirs with predominantly base from 2017. Here is also a small splash of Avenay to give a little buttery roundness to the cuvée with its low dosage of 4 grams. The reserve wines that always come from magnum bottles under low pressure make up 48% from three vintages in 2016, 2009 and 2006. In total, half of the wine is made in oak barrels and the other half in steel tanks. The result is very beautiful and personal. The scent has features of lead pencil, juniper and freshly lacquered boat together with more classic coffee notes, rose petals, apricot and peach. The taste is vivid and multifaceted with a lively precision, lighter fruit aromas than you normally find in Bollinger's wines. Even cassis is one of the more unexpected aromas in this finely tuned complex symphony. Very impressive and exciting champagne that really makes me want to taste more and that I will look out for to my private cellar.”
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TheFinestBubble.com,
Jun 2022
“PN TX17 100% PN Base 2017 4 g/l Oldest Reserve 2006 D: Jan 2022
The partial barrel fermentation lends a toasty spice note, supported by masses of fruit, peach, grapefruit richness, blueberry, cranberry, dark cherry and hints of blackberry. Delicious dark fruit build on the palate, real richness to the fruit that’s super pure and the impact of the chalk is obvious on the palate, it adds minerality/chalk charm together with acidity make this super fresh with that great saline finish. Going back you really see the array of “crunchy fruit” and the low dosage sits really well. Barrel fermentation of 50% of the wines has created a great balance of oak impact and the 49% reserve wines back to 2006 add incredible depth. Bollinger’s own vineyards provide 80% of the fruit.”
93/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Feb 2022
“As with the PN VZ16, the NV Champagne Blanc de Noirs PN TX17 Brut was fermented half in barrels and half in stainless steel. It is also 100% Pinot Noir, mostly from the village of Tauxières, predominantly from 2017, with reserve wines contributing to the blend. Floral on the nose, with yellow orchard fruit and baked bread, it is ripe but more linear in its approach and follow through. It’s a very pretty wine to drink. Best after 2022.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Mar 2022
“A finely detailed Champagne, with pointillist bubbles softly bursting on the palate, carrying a delicate, layered range of ripe raspberry and yellow peach, candied ginger and crystalized honey, chopped nuts and fleur de sel. Minerally chalk and saline accents drive the finish.”
“MAGNUM - PN TX17 100% PN Base 2017 4 g/l Oldest Reserve 2006 D: Jan 2022
The partial barrel fermentation lends a toasty spice note that sits with the smoky charm of the Magnum Effect. The magnum seems more subtle, you feel a more youthful profile, but has similar fruit, maybe seems more dark fruit profile right now; peach, grapefruit richness, blueberry, cranberry, dark cherry and hints of blackberry. Delicious dark fruit build on the palate, real richness to the fruit that’s super pure and the impact of the chalk is obvious on the palate, it adds minerality/chalk charm together with acidity make this super fresh with that great saline finish. There is that characteristic “crunchy fruit” and the low dosage seems seamless. Barrel fermentation of 50% of the wines has created a great balance of oak impact and the 49% reserve wines back to 2006 add incredible depth. Bollinger’s own vineyards provide 80% of the fruit.”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“From the commune of Tauxières and the 2017 vintage, Bollinger's new NV Brut Blanc de Noirs PN TX17 exhibits aromas of crisp pear, orange zest and wet stones mingled with subtle hints of warm bread and dried fruits. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and fleshy, with tangy acids and impressive ripeness for the vintage, it concludes with an elegantly mordant finish. This doesn't strike me as a year built to make old bones, but it should nonetheless enjoy over a decade's evolution.”
94/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jun 2022
“A tender nose shows of a sense of fresh, sweet cream and crushed berry – unusually with a hint of blueberry, followed by Red Delicious apple and a beautifully lifted and aromatic note of tangerine. The palate is sinuous and elegant, there is wonderful depth of fruit and that lovely signature creaminess of Bollinger expressed in superfine foam. There is subtle length that only emphasises the depth of flavour. Very elegant, very expressive, as vivid, energetic and vibrant as the previous releases under this series. Lovely. ”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“On the stylish nose, spicy, woody and hazelnut tones meet pristine Pinot Noir fruitiness. The challenging 2017 harvest is the base here, and Bollinger found, in Tauxières, the fruit quality and profile to craft this edition of its pop-up cuvée. Coming with a fine yeasty notion and well protected from oxidation, the fruitiness really shines loud and bright, supported by a complexity brought about by the reserve wines. The palate carries the lightness and freshness of the cool year, and it all ends on a brisk, dry note. This is a delightfully different and beautifully delicate wine from Bollinger. Disgorged 2/22; dosage 4g/l”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“A deep honey colour for a champagne. Very seductive nose with considerable apparent evolution on it. Much more youthful on the palate than the nose suggests and some dried apple-skin notes on the bone-dry, impressively persistent finish. Very much in the house style. A worthy successor to previous cuvées of this wine, with its own personality.
Drink 2022–2032”
92-94/100
Richard Juhlin,
farrvintners.com,
Feb 2022
“The wine is almost completely dominated by the extremely exciting and rare Tauxières Premier Cru, which is one of two villages classified 99% on the Grand Cru scale. Despite an impressive vineyard area of 237 hectares, it is extremely rare to come across champagnes dominated by this fantastic Cru. A cooler microclimate and a thinner soil layer with even more compact chalk than sunny Bouzy make the wines from here lighter and more elegant than Bouzy but stronger than Verzenay which is also part of this exciting Blanc de Noirs with predominantly base from 2017. Here is also a small splash of Avenay to give a little buttery roundness to the cuvée with its low dosage of 4 grams. The reserve wines that always come from magnum bottles under low pressure make up 48% from three vintages in 2016, 2009 and 2006. In total, half of the wine is made in oak barrels and the other half in steel tanks. The result is very beautiful and personal. The scent has features of lead pencil, juniper and freshly lacquered boat together with more classic coffee notes, rose petals, apricot and peach. The taste is vivid and multifaceted with a lively precision, lighter fruit aromas than you normally find in Bollinger's wines. Even cassis is one of the more unexpected aromas in this finely tuned complex symphony. Very impressive and exciting champagne that really makes me want to taste more and that I will look out for to my private cellar.”
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TheFinestBubble.com,
Jun 2022
“PN TX17 100% PN Base 2017 4 g/l Oldest Reserve 2006 D: Jan 2022
The partial barrel fermentation lends a toasty spice note, supported by masses of fruit, peach, grapefruit richness, blueberry, cranberry, dark cherry and hints of blackberry. Delicious dark fruit build on the palate, real richness to the fruit that’s super pure and the impact of the chalk is obvious on the palate, it adds minerality/chalk charm together with acidity make this super fresh with that great saline finish. Going back you really see the array of “crunchy fruit” and the low dosage sits really well. Barrel fermentation of 50% of the wines has created a great balance of oak impact and the 49% reserve wines back to 2006 add incredible depth. Bollinger’s own vineyards provide 80% of the fruit.”
93/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Feb 2022
“As with the PN VZ16, the NV Champagne Blanc de Noirs PN TX17 Brut was fermented half in barrels and half in stainless steel. It is also 100% Pinot Noir, mostly from the village of Tauxières, predominantly from 2017, with reserve wines contributing to the blend. Floral on the nose, with yellow orchard fruit and baked bread, it is ripe but more linear in its approach and follow through. It’s a very pretty wine to drink. Best after 2022.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Mar 2022
“A finely detailed Champagne, with pointillist bubbles softly bursting on the palate, carrying a delicate, layered range of ripe raspberry and yellow peach, candied ginger and crystalized honey, chopped nuts and fleur de sel. Minerally chalk and saline accents drive the finish.”
“With the sixth edition of its PN series Bollinger is back to Tauxières as the core village (48%), complemented by Aÿ and Avenay. In a sunny and dry year, this terroir thrives, and Bollinger has 18 hectares here in one huge block. The wines of the year get complimented by 52% of reserve wines of three amazing harvest years: 2019, 2012 and 2008. Add on it Bollinger’s ever-improving viticultural work, we have a wine that is precise and deliciously on the fruit. Soft apple and sweet apricot nose with pastry complexity, fruit candies and peach compote. The oaky notions stay beautifully in the background, On the palate the oak has helped in taming the phenolics of the dry, solar year. Supple with a degree of vinosity, the mature reserve wines add texture to the mid palate. On the lighter and fresher side for cuvée PN, this is a charming edition with its deliciously fruity and saline length, enhanced by its 8g/l dosage.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Jul 2025
“The NV PN-TX20 is a powerful, tightly wound wine. All the drive of Pinot comes through in this decidedly virile Champagne. As with all the wines in this new series from Bollinger, the NV PN-TX20 is built around a base wine, in this case 2020 Pinot Noir from Tauxières, with 50% reserve wines, half of them from Bollinger's extensive library of reserve wines aged in magnum. This is an especially vinous Champagne, one that needs at least a year or two in bottle to unwind. The year was characterized by a relatively short cycle of just 87 days from flowering to a harvest that began on August 25”
92/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Named after the village of Tauxières, from which it takes its abbreviation, the new NV Blanc de Noirs PN TX20 contains 40% fruit sourced from Tauxières, and the remaining composition draws largely from Aÿ-Champagne and Avenay-Val-d'Or. This cuvée is based on the 2020 vintage (48%), complemented by reserve wines from 2019 (stored in tank) as well as 2012 and 2008 (both aged in magnums). Disgorged in February 2025 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, it bursts from the glass with expressive aromas of ripe pear, tangerine peel, clove and brioche. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, broad and textural, with lively acidity and a generous core of fruit. The finish is expansive, though a subtle sweetness emerges, lending the impression of being one of the least dry expressions among the house’s Pinot Noir Champagnes. Vinified equally in stainless steel and oak barrels, approximately 80% of the fruit for this cuvée is sourced from Bollinger’s own vineyards.”
“With the sixth edition of its PN series Bollinger is back to Tauxières as the core village (48%), complemented by Aÿ and Avenay. In a sunny and dry year, this terroir thrives, and Bollinger has 18 hectares here in one huge block. The wines of the year get complimented by 52% of reserve wines of three amazing harvest years: 2019, 2012 and 2008. Add on it Bollinger’s ever-improving viticultural work, we have a wine that is precise and deliciously on the fruit. Soft apple and sweet apricot nose with pastry complexity, fruit candies and peach compote. The oaky notions stay beautifully in the background, On the palate the oak has helped in taming the phenolics of the dry, solar year. Supple with a degree of vinosity, the mature reserve wines add texture to the mid palate. On the lighter and fresher side for cuvée PN, this is a charming edition with its deliciously fruity and saline length, enhanced by its 8g/l dosage.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Jul 2025
“The NV PN-TX20 is a powerful, tightly wound wine. All the drive of Pinot comes through in this decidedly virile Champagne. As with all the wines in this new series from Bollinger, the NV PN-TX20 is built around a base wine, in this case 2020 Pinot Noir from Tauxières, with 50% reserve wines, half of them from Bollinger's extensive library of reserve wines aged in magnum. This is an especially vinous Champagne, one that needs at least a year or two in bottle to unwind. The year was characterized by a relatively short cycle of just 87 days from flowering to a harvest that began on August 25”
92/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Named after the village of Tauxières, from which it takes its abbreviation, the new NV Blanc de Noirs PN TX20 contains 40% fruit sourced from Tauxières, and the remaining composition draws largely from Aÿ-Champagne and Avenay-Val-d'Or. This cuvée is based on the 2020 vintage (48%), complemented by reserve wines from 2019 (stored in tank) as well as 2012 and 2008 (both aged in magnums). Disgorged in February 2025 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, it bursts from the glass with expressive aromas of ripe pear, tangerine peel, clove and brioche. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, broad and textural, with lively acidity and a generous core of fruit. The finish is expansive, though a subtle sweetness emerges, lending the impression of being one of the least dry expressions among the house’s Pinot Noir Champagnes. Vinified equally in stainless steel and oak barrels, approximately 80% of the fruit for this cuvée is sourced from Bollinger’s own vineyards.”
“Disgorged in January 2021, Bollinger's newly released NV Brut Blanc de Noirs PN VZ16 offers up notions of pear, apple blossom, jasmine, orange zest and fresh pastry. Medium to full-bodied, precise and elegantly vinous, it's layered and charming, with racy acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse, and it concludes with a sapid finish. It's based on the 2016 vintage, complemented by older reserve wines matured in magnum, and derives, once again, largely from the village of Verzenay.
”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“Soft, open-knit and wonderfully inviting PN VZ 16 is a worthy follow up to the sublime 2015 that launched this new Blanc de Noirs in the Bollinger range last year. Sweet red cherry, Mirabelle, spice, mint and dried flowers all grace this wonderfully translucent, expressive Blanc de Noirs. North-facing sites in Verzenay that confer tension and energy make up about half the blend, with wines from Aÿ, Bouzy and Louvois playing supporting roles. Vinification is done in equal parts steel and oak. This release is based on 2016 (50% of the blend), with reserve wines that go back to 2006, including 23% from reserve magnums. Readers who enjoy Blanc de Noirs will adore the PN VZ 16. I find the interplay of vibrancy and the creamier notes that are so typical of the house style to be incredibly appealing.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Very pale pink. Wonderfully pure Pinot Noir character on the nose. Very fine bead indeed. Tight in texture yet playful in flavour. A worthy successor to the 2015.”
“On the ripe but fresh and harmonious harvest year 2019, Bollinger chose Verzenay as the pillar of its PN cuvée. A warm year needed the freshness from northern facing terroirs, thus 40% of the blend come from the Verzenay, including a hefty 25% of reserve wine magnums from 2009. The rest of the blend is made up by the other Bollinger hallmark crus Aÿ, Avenay-Val d’Or, Tauxières and, for the first time ever, Mutigny. All in all, 2019 represents 52% of the blend with a hefty addition of reserve wines, 48%. The first nose already comes across sweetly expressive with many aromatic assets. The dominant fruit is ripe yellow peach, which the 50% oak fermented wine complements with spicy mineral nuances, yet very few oxidative tones. If the nose promised ripeness, the palate counterbalances it by its lovely linearity and saline, scintillating nervosity. The warmth of the year can be sensed the textured fleshiness and juicy-fruity power. At the same time the wine projects immaculate precision and length.”
More Reviews +
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2024
“The latest rendition of Bollinger's blended blanc de noirs bottling is the NV Brut Blanc de Noirs PN VZ19; it is based on the 2019 vintage, which represents 52% of the blend, and the village of Verzenay, which accounts for the origin of 40% of this bottling's components. 2019 is complemented by fully 48% reserve wines, and above all, fully a quarter derives from 2009; and it has the tension of Verzenay by Aÿ, Avenay-Val-d'Or, Tauxières and Mutigny. If all that sounds complicated, the wine's appeal is easier to see, as it offers up a demonstrative bouquet of yellow stone fruit, mandarin and praline, followed by a medium to full-bodied, pure and pillowy palate that's charming, even giving, but also attractively racy, concluding with a saline finish. It was disgorged with six grams per liter dosage. This doesn't tower above its 2018-base counterpart (perhaps unsurprisingly, as the percentage of reserve wines in this bottling is so high), but it does seem to be marginally the strongest iteration of this cuvée to date.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jun 2024
“The NV (2019) PN VZ is another terrific wine in this new range of Champagnes from Bollinger that is now in its fifth release. Exotic floral and spice notes play off a core of Pinot fruit in this captivating, mid-weight offering. Time in the glass accents the wine’s inner sweetness and perfume. Pear, mint, jasmine and white pepper linger. In this release, the (2019) PN VZ is like a mini-Vieilles Vignes Francaises. It’s an incredibly racy, sexy Blanc de Noirs. This release is based on 2019, with 50% reserve wines back to 2009. About half of the reserve wines were aged in magnum. Dosage is 6 grams per liter. Drinking Window 2024-2039.”
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
May 2024
“The concentration for a relative recent disgorgement is surprising, abundance of dark fruits, orange, grapefruit, lemon, peach and a layer of spice intwined around tropical fruits, explodes further on the palate. The hallmark of 2019 as a year is more restraint over 18, I’d describe as a more vertical style with amazing freshness and racy acidity as opposed to a fatter horizontal year like 2018 and 2009. I really like the texture, wraps around the palate, oak is very much a contributor not dominator as you see in LGA and all in all this wins for me on overall balance, raciness and bright saline end. I would buy magnums and enjoy them a decade later and the bottles will reward a few more years post disgorgement time.”
97/100
Tyson Stelzer,
TysonStelzer.com,
May 2024
“PN returns to its Verzenay origins (as per its first iterations as VZ15 and VZ16, followed by TX17 and AYC18). 2019 ranks among the best of Champagne’s recent vintages and the cool, north-eastern slopes of Verzenay uphold compelling tension in the midst of a warming climate. The result is a magnificent juxtaposition between the rumbling, billowing depths of ripe pinot noir like only Bollinger can conjure, thanks to the presence and magnitude of primarily Aÿ and also Avenay-val-d’Or, Tauxières, and Mutigny, and the pristine definition and lifted freshness of vibrant fruit that characterises Verzenay. Boasting a medium straw hue, it wells up with deep black and red cherry fruit, satsuma plum, blackberries and layers of anise and sarsaparilla. Barrel fermentation and a record 25 percent of reserve magnums lend their characteristic creaminess and subtle patisserie complexity, but it is the fine chalk minerality of Verzenay chalk that remains the hero of a long finish, upholding magnificent texture, tension and crystalline brightness like no other pinot village.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
May 2024
“Unsurprisingly, the 2019 base year with its richness once again received mineral-influenced Verzenay (40%) as the base terroir when Aÿ produced slightly too rich wines. The reserve wines on the magnum once again go all the way down to the tasty 2009 vintage all from Verzenay. Aÿ, Louvois, Bisseuil, Avenay, Tours-sur-Marne, Mareuil-sur-Aÿ and Mutigny stand for the background chords. Currently, the champagne charms through its complex and youthfully energetic bouquet of peach peel, gooseberry, cox orange apples, sea buckthorn, geranium and marigolds. The texture is at the same time softly ripe and velvety. The breadth of flavours is magnificently orchestrated and each new sip brings additional aromas at hand. The potential alcohol content was record high from the start especially in Aÿ with 11.1 % straight away and Denis, just like me, sees great similarities between 2015 and 2019, but where the sharpness and freshness is better in 2019. It is not the acidity but rather the mineral salt that gives the freshness together with the sense of umami the concentrated grapes give. Here there is a swirl of exotic fruit and honey, but also a dry smokiness that I've learned to associate with the cluster of aromas that transforms over time into the note of railway on a hot summer's day. It might sound fuzzy, but it actually makes perfect sense. The combination of heated rail, dry gravel, dandelions and nettles that thrive in the embankment gives a concentrated warm dryness that is strongly reminiscent of the character the grapes acquire when the temperature crosses the vine's pain point on a few hot summer days. 41 degrees in the shade was a heat record in Champagne and especially a lot of shade, the vineyards in Champagne cannot boast of so the effect is reminiscent of that which arose in 1947, 1959, 1976 and 2003. Hence this aroma albeit less marked in 2019. Let's see if I'm right in 10 years when I expect that "the famous note of Railroad track" will appear in this beauty. PN VZ19 is tasted with great pleasure and intellectual challenge straight away, but personally, as usual, I will wait as long as I can before opening my own bottles to get the increasing depth of butter-fried cepp and toasted hazelnut aromas that only aging can provide.”
“On the ripe but fresh and harmonious harvest year 2019, Bollinger chose Verzenay as the pillar of its PN cuvée. A warm year needed the freshness from northern facing terroirs, thus 40% of the blend come from the Verzenay, including a hefty 25% of reserve wine magnums from 2009. The rest of the blend is made up by the other Bollinger hallmark crus Aÿ, Avenay-Val d’Or, Tauxières and, for the first time ever, Mutigny. All in all, 2019 represents 52% of the blend with a hefty addition of reserve wines, 48%. The first nose already comes across sweetly expressive with many aromatic assets. The dominant fruit is ripe yellow peach, which the 50% oak fermented wine complements with spicy mineral nuances, yet very few oxidative tones. If the nose promised ripeness, the palate counterbalances it by its lovely linearity and saline, scintillating nervosity. The warmth of the year can be sensed the textured fleshiness and juicy-fruity power. At the same time the wine projects immaculate precision and length.”
More Reviews +
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2024
“The latest rendition of Bollinger's blended blanc de noirs bottling is the NV Brut Blanc de Noirs PN VZ19; it is based on the 2019 vintage, which represents 52% of the blend, and the village of Verzenay, which accounts for the origin of 40% of this bottling's components. 2019 is complemented by fully 48% reserve wines, and above all, fully a quarter derives from 2009; and it has the tension of Verzenay by Aÿ, Avenay-Val-d'Or, Tauxières and Mutigny. If all that sounds complicated, the wine's appeal is easier to see, as it offers up a demonstrative bouquet of yellow stone fruit, mandarin and praline, followed by a medium to full-bodied, pure and pillowy palate that's charming, even giving, but also attractively racy, concluding with a saline finish. It was disgorged with six grams per liter dosage. This doesn't tower above its 2018-base counterpart (perhaps unsurprisingly, as the percentage of reserve wines in this bottling is so high), but it does seem to be marginally the strongest iteration of this cuvée to date.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jun 2024
“The NV (2019) PN VZ is another terrific wine in this new range of Champagnes from Bollinger that is now in its fifth release. Exotic floral and spice notes play off a core of Pinot fruit in this captivating, mid-weight offering. Time in the glass accents the wine’s inner sweetness and perfume. Pear, mint, jasmine and white pepper linger. In this release, the (2019) PN VZ is like a mini-Vieilles Vignes Francaises. It’s an incredibly racy, sexy Blanc de Noirs. This release is based on 2019, with 50% reserve wines back to 2009. About half of the reserve wines were aged in magnum. Dosage is 6 grams per liter. Drinking Window 2024-2039.”
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
May 2024
“The concentration for a relative recent disgorgement is surprising, abundance of dark fruits, orange, grapefruit, lemon, peach and a layer of spice intwined around tropical fruits, explodes further on the palate. The hallmark of 2019 as a year is more restraint over 18, I’d describe as a more vertical style with amazing freshness and racy acidity as opposed to a fatter horizontal year like 2018 and 2009. I really like the texture, wraps around the palate, oak is very much a contributor not dominator as you see in LGA and all in all this wins for me on overall balance, raciness and bright saline end. I would buy magnums and enjoy them a decade later and the bottles will reward a few more years post disgorgement time.”
97/100
Tyson Stelzer,
TysonStelzer.com,
May 2024
“PN returns to its Verzenay origins (as per its first iterations as VZ15 and VZ16, followed by TX17 and AYC18). 2019 ranks among the best of Champagne’s recent vintages and the cool, north-eastern slopes of Verzenay uphold compelling tension in the midst of a warming climate. The result is a magnificent juxtaposition between the rumbling, billowing depths of ripe pinot noir like only Bollinger can conjure, thanks to the presence and magnitude of primarily Aÿ and also Avenay-val-d’Or, Tauxières, and Mutigny, and the pristine definition and lifted freshness of vibrant fruit that characterises Verzenay. Boasting a medium straw hue, it wells up with deep black and red cherry fruit, satsuma plum, blackberries and layers of anise and sarsaparilla. Barrel fermentation and a record 25 percent of reserve magnums lend their characteristic creaminess and subtle patisserie complexity, but it is the fine chalk minerality of Verzenay chalk that remains the hero of a long finish, upholding magnificent texture, tension and crystalline brightness like no other pinot village.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
May 2024
“Unsurprisingly, the 2019 base year with its richness once again received mineral-influenced Verzenay (40%) as the base terroir when Aÿ produced slightly too rich wines. The reserve wines on the magnum once again go all the way down to the tasty 2009 vintage all from Verzenay. Aÿ, Louvois, Bisseuil, Avenay, Tours-sur-Marne, Mareuil-sur-Aÿ and Mutigny stand for the background chords. Currently, the champagne charms through its complex and youthfully energetic bouquet of peach peel, gooseberry, cox orange apples, sea buckthorn, geranium and marigolds. The texture is at the same time softly ripe and velvety. The breadth of flavours is magnificently orchestrated and each new sip brings additional aromas at hand. The potential alcohol content was record high from the start especially in Aÿ with 11.1 % straight away and Denis, just like me, sees great similarities between 2015 and 2019, but where the sharpness and freshness is better in 2019. It is not the acidity but rather the mineral salt that gives the freshness together with the sense of umami the concentrated grapes give. Here there is a swirl of exotic fruit and honey, but also a dry smokiness that I've learned to associate with the cluster of aromas that transforms over time into the note of railway on a hot summer's day. It might sound fuzzy, but it actually makes perfect sense. The combination of heated rail, dry gravel, dandelions and nettles that thrive in the embankment gives a concentrated warm dryness that is strongly reminiscent of the character the grapes acquire when the temperature crosses the vine's pain point on a few hot summer days. 41 degrees in the shade was a heat record in Champagne and especially a lot of shade, the vineyards in Champagne cannot boast of so the effect is reminiscent of that which arose in 1947, 1959, 1976 and 2003. Hence this aroma albeit less marked in 2019. Let's see if I'm right in 10 years when I expect that "the famous note of Railroad track" will appear in this beauty. PN VZ19 is tasted with great pleasure and intellectual challenge straight away, but personally, as usual, I will wait as long as I can before opening my own bottles to get the increasing depth of butter-fried cepp and toasted hazelnut aromas that only aging can provide.”
“Bright in colour with gold reflections, the aromatics are immediately captivating, with marzipan, acacia, apricot and patisserie all vying for attention. It’s impossibly youthful yet reassuringly mature, a bread basket of delicious contradiction. Cerebral seduction ensues on the palate, with dried fruits, bergamot and lime joining the party, then come the hazelnut notes – which have been identified as a leitmotif for the vintage – and a clean, almost chalky finish to restore rigorous harmony. Precision in no way undermines generosity, and generosity in no way undermines potential. A very fine piece of work all in all, tasted from magnum, alongside bottle and jeroboam. Disgorged: November 2022. Dosage: 3g/L.”
More Reviews +
98+/100
Sarah Mayo,
thewineindependent.com,
Nov 2023
“Emerging like a genie from a bottle, so full of life and magic, the Bollinger R.D. 2008 unwinds gradually to reveal aromatic layer after layer of white peach, Meyer lemon confit, kumquat, wafer cookies, wet stones and acacia honey intermingling with bready and faintly oxidative, nutty notes. Medium to full-bodied and full of high-toned energy, the palate is wonderfully silky and lithe with a super fine, creamy mousse full of stimulating acid freshness, exquisite saline intensity, and a chalky finish with a beautiful citrus peel note. A blend of 66% Pinot Noir and 34% Chardonnay, it was disgorged 09 December 2022 and finished Extra Brut with a three gram per liter dosage. As beautiful as it is now, it has many years of excellent drinking ahead.”
“2007 is a rather scarcely declared vintage and not one recognized for its Pinot Noir, yet Bollinger have managed to create something so fresh and delicious from it. Its secrets are in rigorous selection and in unusually high proportion of crunchy Verzenay fruit (29%). Glossy evolving lemon colour. The coolly fruity nose comes with golden raisins, yellow apple, orange zest, juniper wood and ginger. The spiciness gets enhanced over time in the glass. The palate has rare energy and tension for an R.D. , really driven and pure. The palate is still tight and reserved, palate cleansingly dry. Seems like a really slowly ageing R.D. worth cellaring. A great call from the winemaking team to release this La Grande Année vintage as R.D. (bottle disgorged 10th July 2020)”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Deep colour of shiny golden hues. With some six months of post-disgorgement time, this wine looks remarkably youthful, with its ripe, bright and expressive fruitiness. There is fresh apple and apricot alongside dried fruits and fruitcake complexity. The oaky notions are subtle, and oxidation is well under control. The sweet spiciness beautifully lines the aromatics. For a Bollinger R.D., the palate is rather lightweight, but it is beautifully fresh and vivacious. Its secret is rigorous selection and an unusually high proportion of crunchy Verzenay fruit (29%).The wine seems remarkably slow ageing, which is a fine surprise for the vintage. Disgorged 2/22; dosage 3g/l”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“Bollinger’s 2007 R.D. is superb, but it is also a wine that reflects the nature of a unique and challenging growing season. In most vintages the R.D. is marked by the distinct creaminess and breadth of Aÿ Pinot Noir. Two thousand seven, though, was a difficult year marked by very dry weather, rain at the end of the growing season and an early harvest in August, something that was not as common as it has become. Selection was essential. For the 2007, the blend is composed of just 14 villages compared to the more typical 18-25. Verzenay is the main Pinot component while Cramant plays the leading role in the Chardonnays. For these reasons, the 2007 is an R.D. driven by more focus, energy and tension than readers are used to seeing. Lemon confit, dried flowers, sage, mint, crushed rocks, almond and ginger are some of the aromas and flavors that give the 2007 its complex, multi-faceted personality.
The 2007 can be enjoyed now, but I would prefer to cellar it for a few years. It will age effortlessly for decades as it moves through the various phases of its life. I was reminded of the way Champagne can magically traverse time by magical bottles of the 1976 R.D. and 1996 Vieilles Vignes Françaises I tasted recently. The blend is 70% Pinot Noir and 30% Chardonnay, 91% Grand Cru fruit and the rest Premier Cru. Bollinger fans will notice the return of the original label, with the disgorgement date clearly visible, a tribute to Madame Bollinger, who was a pioneer in so many ways. Disgorged: July 10, 2020. Dosage is 3 grams per liter.”
97/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Disgorged on July 10, 2020, with three grams per liter dosage, Bollinger's eagerly awaited 2007 Extra-Brut R. D. is beautiful, unwinding in the glass with aromas of crisp orchard fruit, citrus pith and white flowers mingled with hints of honey, orange oil, buttery pastry, English walnuts and delicately spicy bass notes. Full-bodied, vibrant and incisive, it's unusually elegant and structurally fine-boned for what is routinely one of Champagne's more muscular tête de cuvées, with a bright spine of acidity that's cloaked in vibrant, concentrated fruit, complemented by a pearly pinpoint mousse and concluding with an intensely sapid finish. Long and penetrating, this is a tightly coiled R. D. that will reward bottle age.
The fruit of an early harvest, beginning on September 1st, Bollinger's superb 2007 R. D. is an unusually delicate, fine-boned rendition of this habitually muscular cuvée. An additional seven years on the lees has brought additional textural and amplitude to the acid spine that was already evident in the 2007 Grande Année, and the slight loss of pressure during aging on cork makes for a more refined, pearly mousse that complements the wine's enhanced texture and amplified sapid nuance. Fermented in used oak cooperage, with tirage under natural cork and disgorgement without added sulfur dioxide (but now with jetting to ensure consistency), it's one of the few tête de cuvée bottlings still made very much as it was 40 years ago. While I don't tend to comment on packaging, Bollinger's decision to revive the tasteful aluminum label that graced this cuvée's debut 1952 rendition, when the redoubtable Madame Lilly Bollinger still presided over this house, does underscore what is a real and not merely superficial commitment to artisanal traditions.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Rich and mushroomy in Bollinger style on the nose with a notably dry finish. I think I might stand a good chance of identifying this wine blind…
Drink 2020–2028”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“A hint of hazelnut praline clings to the creamy notions on the nose, aligned to a pleasant smokiness and a hint of dark peony. More air adds notions of white pepper and toasted cumin. The palate is exquisitely creamy – the Bollinger hallmark – but with 2007 this texture is presented with exquisite poise. The bright freshness that underlies all this keeps a subtle but constant presence, lending structure. Beautiful depth lends a kind of solidity that anchors this in chalky soil, a class act and a very grown-up wine that says one thing only: enduring elegance.”
17.5
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“Very, very different from the usual solid, powerful, broad Bollinger style. More rapier-like in approach with none of the density and mushroom notes that I usually associate with Bollinger. An unexpected style which may broaden perceptions of what this house can do. Crisp, mineral, the immediate effect was actually 'pretty' though with time in the glass it took on more weight. This reflects a little the Bollinger PN VZ15 exclusively from Verzenay with pretty marked acidity at this stage in its life. Refined with a bone-dry finish and a touch of quinine on the end. Should have a long life. Ideally I'd wait until mid 2021 before broaching this long-distance runner. With time in the opened bottle this took on more typical Bollinger weight and character.”
“2007 is a rather scarcely declared vintage and not one recognized for its Pinot Noir, yet Bollinger have managed to create something so fresh and delicious from it. Its secrets are in rigorous selection and in unusually high proportion of crunchy Verzenay fruit (29%). Glossy evolving lemon colour. The coolly fruity nose comes with golden raisins, yellow apple, orange zest, juniper wood and ginger. The spiciness gets enhanced over time in the glass. The palate has rare energy and tension for an R.D. , really driven and pure. The palate is still tight and reserved, palate cleansingly dry. Seems like a really slowly ageing R.D. worth cellaring. A great call from the winemaking team to release this La Grande Année vintage as R.D. (bottle disgorged 10th July 2020)”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Deep colour of shiny golden hues. With some six months of post-disgorgement time, this wine looks remarkably youthful, with its ripe, bright and expressive fruitiness. There is fresh apple and apricot alongside dried fruits and fruitcake complexity. The oaky notions are subtle, and oxidation is well under control. The sweet spiciness beautifully lines the aromatics. For a Bollinger R.D., the palate is rather lightweight, but it is beautifully fresh and vivacious. Its secret is rigorous selection and an unusually high proportion of crunchy Verzenay fruit (29%).The wine seems remarkably slow ageing, which is a fine surprise for the vintage. Disgorged 2/22; dosage 3g/l”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“Bollinger’s 2007 R.D. is superb, but it is also a wine that reflects the nature of a unique and challenging growing season. In most vintages the R.D. is marked by the distinct creaminess and breadth of Aÿ Pinot Noir. Two thousand seven, though, was a difficult year marked by very dry weather, rain at the end of the growing season and an early harvest in August, something that was not as common as it has become. Selection was essential. For the 2007, the blend is composed of just 14 villages compared to the more typical 18-25. Verzenay is the main Pinot component while Cramant plays the leading role in the Chardonnays. For these reasons, the 2007 is an R.D. driven by more focus, energy and tension than readers are used to seeing. Lemon confit, dried flowers, sage, mint, crushed rocks, almond and ginger are some of the aromas and flavors that give the 2007 its complex, multi-faceted personality.
The 2007 can be enjoyed now, but I would prefer to cellar it for a few years. It will age effortlessly for decades as it moves through the various phases of its life. I was reminded of the way Champagne can magically traverse time by magical bottles of the 1976 R.D. and 1996 Vieilles Vignes Françaises I tasted recently. The blend is 70% Pinot Noir and 30% Chardonnay, 91% Grand Cru fruit and the rest Premier Cru. Bollinger fans will notice the return of the original label, with the disgorgement date clearly visible, a tribute to Madame Bollinger, who was a pioneer in so many ways. Disgorged: July 10, 2020. Dosage is 3 grams per liter.”
97/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Disgorged on July 10, 2020, with three grams per liter dosage, Bollinger's eagerly awaited 2007 Extra-Brut R. D. is beautiful, unwinding in the glass with aromas of crisp orchard fruit, citrus pith and white flowers mingled with hints of honey, orange oil, buttery pastry, English walnuts and delicately spicy bass notes. Full-bodied, vibrant and incisive, it's unusually elegant and structurally fine-boned for what is routinely one of Champagne's more muscular tête de cuvées, with a bright spine of acidity that's cloaked in vibrant, concentrated fruit, complemented by a pearly pinpoint mousse and concluding with an intensely sapid finish. Long and penetrating, this is a tightly coiled R. D. that will reward bottle age.
The fruit of an early harvest, beginning on September 1st, Bollinger's superb 2007 R. D. is an unusually delicate, fine-boned rendition of this habitually muscular cuvée. An additional seven years on the lees has brought additional textural and amplitude to the acid spine that was already evident in the 2007 Grande Année, and the slight loss of pressure during aging on cork makes for a more refined, pearly mousse that complements the wine's enhanced texture and amplified sapid nuance. Fermented in used oak cooperage, with tirage under natural cork and disgorgement without added sulfur dioxide (but now with jetting to ensure consistency), it's one of the few tête de cuvée bottlings still made very much as it was 40 years ago. While I don't tend to comment on packaging, Bollinger's decision to revive the tasteful aluminum label that graced this cuvée's debut 1952 rendition, when the redoubtable Madame Lilly Bollinger still presided over this house, does underscore what is a real and not merely superficial commitment to artisanal traditions.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Rich and mushroomy in Bollinger style on the nose with a notably dry finish. I think I might stand a good chance of identifying this wine blind…
Drink 2020–2028”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“A hint of hazelnut praline clings to the creamy notions on the nose, aligned to a pleasant smokiness and a hint of dark peony. More air adds notions of white pepper and toasted cumin. The palate is exquisitely creamy – the Bollinger hallmark – but with 2007 this texture is presented with exquisite poise. The bright freshness that underlies all this keeps a subtle but constant presence, lending structure. Beautiful depth lends a kind of solidity that anchors this in chalky soil, a class act and a very grown-up wine that says one thing only: enduring elegance.”
17.5
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“Very, very different from the usual solid, powerful, broad Bollinger style. More rapier-like in approach with none of the density and mushroom notes that I usually associate with Bollinger. An unexpected style which may broaden perceptions of what this house can do. Crisp, mineral, the immediate effect was actually 'pretty' though with time in the glass it took on more weight. This reflects a little the Bollinger PN VZ15 exclusively from Verzenay with pretty marked acidity at this stage in its life. Refined with a bone-dry finish and a touch of quinine on the end. Should have a long life. Ideally I'd wait until mid 2021 before broaching this long-distance runner. With time in the opened bottle this took on more typical Bollinger weight and character.”
“One of my most exciting wine experiences was when I first tasted 1975 Bollinger R.D. with my parents at their home. During yesterday's Sunday afternoon, I served them the latest edition of 2004 blindly. The 82-year-old's reaction did not allow for a wait. Mom immediately exclaimed "the same wonderful scent of chocolate and apricot like when we drank Bollinger R.D. in the 80's". So right she was. When Bollinger decides to launch the newest vintage of R.D., the wine must have its distinctive autolytic character of freshly baked bread, chocolate, hazelnut and mushroom. That is at least the thought. I would like to say that the last vintage in 2002 did not have these features at the launch at all, but instead relied on an almost grassy elegance and refined acid structure in an remaining youthful attire. With 2004 it is different. It's precisely like this Bollinger R.D. should taste from the beginning. Nobody can be disappointed here. Perhaps, 2004, is not one of the most heroic vintages but on the other hand one of the most classic. The very essence of the R.D. concept is to try to capture a wine's optimal maturity along with maximum freshness. Unfortunately, I do not think life expectancy is as good as in the La Grande Année version, but I may be wrong. The intensity of the mature layers of dark chocolate, tobacco, black truffles from Vaucluse and a melancholy hiking in the moist autumn forest is, at least, impressive. The mousse may struggle to reach the surface of the glycerol rich essence of wine. Nevertheless, it tingles of lust on the tongue when stringency, chalk and jingeling pure acids dance over the finish line.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Toasty deep straw. Lots of evolution on the nose. A bit more evolved on the palate than the 2002 vintage. Less lively. Lower acidity. But lots to savour now.”
“Tasted blind. The most evolved of the lot. Smells similar to its pair but less dense than the other one (which turned out to be the 2002). Also demanding and dry but very slightly less tightly knitted weft. Still quite chewy on the end.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Current vintage. Late, cold harvest started 27 September because of the size of the crop. TA 7.1 g/l. Tasted from bottle.
Pale greenish straw. Interesting pungent nose. Tight but not austere. Great spread of flavours. More expressive than magnum, perhaps because it’s warmer.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2019
“Disgorged November 2016. Tasted blind.
Big and round and almost peachy on the nose. Then dry and Bollinger-esque on the palate. Almost dried out on the end! Very apple-skin-like. 12%
Drink 2017-2024”
18.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2018
“Magnum: 66% Pinot Noir, 34% Chardonnay. Disgorged 20 November 2017. Dosage 3 g/l.
Quite different to the regular bottle, with much more autolytic character and riper fruit too with a sort of orange peel fruit. Has the same slight honeyed note and generous flinty note. Not the biggest in terms of sheer weight, but certainly packed full of flavour. (RH)”
18+/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2018
“Bottle: Disgorged 20 November 2017. 66% Pinot Noir, 34% Chardonnay. Dosage 3 g/l.
Mid gold colour. Smoky hints on the nose. Creamy texture, salty. Ripe, slightly honeyed aromas. Brioche and baked apple. Moderate intensity on the palate, but there is good persistence and a touch of savoury salinity on the finish. Lovely honeysuckle and cream on the length. Still a long way to go, but superbly open already. Seems softer in acidity than the 2002. (RH)”
96/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Mar 2018
“One of my most exciting wine experiences was when I first tasted 1975 Bollinger RD with my parents at their home. During yesterday's Sunday afternoon, I served them the latest edition of 2004 blindly. The 82-year-old's reaction did not allow for a wait. Mom immediately exclaimed "the same wonderful scent of chocolate and apricot like when we drank Bollinger RD in the 80's". So right she was. When Bollinger decides to launch the newest vintage of RD, the wine must have its distinctive autolytic character of freshly baked bread, chocolate, hazelnut and mushroom. That is at least the thought. I would like to say that the last vintage in 2002 did not have these features at the launch at all, but instead relied on an almost grassy elegance and refined acid structure in an remaining youthful attire. With 2004 it is different. It's precisely like this Bollinger RD should taste from the beginning. Nobody can be disappointed here. Perhaps, 2004, is not one of the most heroic vintages but on the other hand one of the most classic. The very essence of the RD concept is to try to capture a wine's optimal maturity along with maximum freshness. Unfortunately, I do not think life expectancy is as good as in the La Grande Année version, but I may be wrong. The intensity of the mature layers of dark chocolate, tobacco, black truffles from Vaucluse and a melancholy hiking in the moist autumn forest is, at least, impressive. The mousse may struggle to reach the surface of the glycerol rich essence of wine. Nevertheless, it tingles of lust on the tongue when stringency, chalk and jingling pure acids dance over the finish line.”
“Bollinger’s 2004 R.D., tasted from magnum, is all class. Silky and understated, the R.D is super-expressive and inviting today. In 2004, the R.D. is decidedly light on its feet and more perfumed than tends to be the norm at Bollinger. Candied lemon peel, mint, apricot, pastry and yellow fruits are all laced together in a Champagne that delivers the goods. The 2004 is 66% Pinot Noir and 34% Chardonnay picked between September 25 and October 8. Disgorged: November 21, 2017.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Mar 2018
“One of my most exciting wine experiences was when I first tasted 1975 Bollinger R.D. with my parents at their home. During yesterday's Sunday afternoon, I served them the latest edition of 2004 blindly. The 82-year-old's reaction did not allow for a wait. Mom immediately exclaimed "the same wonderful scent of chocolate and apricot like when we drank Bollinger R.D. in the 80's". So right she was. When Bollinger decides to launch the newest vintage of R.D., the wine must have its distinctive autolytic character of freshly baked bread, chocolate, hazelnut and mushroom. That is at least the thought. I would like to say that the last vintage in 2002 did not have these features at the launch at all, but instead relied on an almost grassy elegance and refined acid structure in an remaining youthful attire. With 2004 it is different. It's precisely like this Bollinger R.D. should taste from the beginning. Nobody can be disappointed here. Perhaps, 2004, is not one of the most heroic vintages but on the other hand one of the most classic. The very essence of the R.D. concept is to try to capture a wine's optimal maturity along with maximum freshness. Unfortunately, I do not think life expectancy is as good as in the La Grande Année version, but I may be wrong. The intensity of the mature layers of dark chocolate, tobacco, black truffles from Vaucluse and a melancholy hiking in the moist autumn forest is, at least, impressive. The mousse may struggle to reach the surface of the glycerol rich essence of wine. Nevertheless, it tingles of lust on the tongue when stringency, chalk and jingeling pure acids dance over the finish line.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Toasty deep straw. Lots of evolution on the nose. A bit more evolved on the palate than the 2002 vintage. Less lively. Lower acidity. But lots to savour now.”
“Tasted blind. Tense, dense nose. Savoury. Lemony with marked acidity and lots to chew on. Bone-dry finish, rather a demanding nature. Intellectual wine. Quite long. One of the more evolved. A little like white burgundy plus carbon dioxide. Long. Krug or Bolly?”
More Reviews +
18/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2018
“Disgorged 17 May 2017. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay (usually more like 30%).
Incredibly intense aromas – baked apple, cinnamon, freshly baked bread. Conventional and recognisably champagne, but to a greater, more intense degree. Some creamy coffee on the palate and wonderfully savoury salinity on the finish. Very, very long persistence. Champagne to the power of ten. (RH)”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2017
“The most remarkable thing about the 2002 Extra Brut R.D. is how tense and structured it is. Despite having been disgorged over two years ago, the 2002 is very much tightly wound. After several hours, the power and resonance of the vintage start to come through, along with the natural richness of Pinot from Aÿ. Whereas most 2002 Champagnes are quite ripe in profile, the 2002 R.D. has plenty of depth, but it is depth through concentration as opposed to elevated ripeness. The low dosage style further adds to that sensation. Hints of chamomile, sage, dried flower and red fruits emerge over time, but only with reluctance. I would prefer to cellar the 2002 for at least a few years. If that is not possible, readers should open the wine at least a few hours in advance. Even so, the 2002's best drinking lies somewhere in the future. My sense is that the 2002 will be at its best between the ages of 20 and 30. Disgorged: September 11, 2015.”
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Sep 2023
“This 2013-disgorged bottle shows the super-ripe expression that has become RD’s calling card, with notable evolution in the colour and on the nose. A touch of oak on an upfront nose that comes with oxidative undertones on top of marmalade, cider and Christmas-cake fruit. There is quite the contrast between the sweet and age-mellowed nose and feisty palate”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Current vintage. Disgorged January 2017. 40% Chardonnay (high for Bollinger). Extra Brut. Dosage 3 g/l.
Deep straw gold. Start of that woodland-mushroom Bollinger aroma. Masses of character. Not quite as tense as some 2002s – more Bollinger style with the dry overlay. Very, very Bollinger.
Drink 2017-2026”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2016
“Disgorged October 2014. RS 4 g/l. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. From Bollinger's UK agent Mentzendorff.
Tasted blind. Dark gold. Mushrooms (a mature Bollinger trademark), savour and density with a dry finish. Definitely Bollinger RD. Some refinement too. Reminds me a little of a fine sake – umami?”
92/100
Robert Parker Jr,
RobertParker.com,
Oct 2016
“Big names do not help if you are not familiar with a certain house style, and so I can understand everyone who dislikes Bollinger's 2002 RD Extra Brut, which at first sight reveals a matured if not an old wine displaying toffee, floral (hyacinths, narcissus, sage), vegetal and spicy aromas (oak, cannabis, frankincense, black bread) -- but almost no fruit (at least no fresh fruit). This wine was disgorged in March 2014, but just needs a lot of time in the glass to develop its complexity. On the palate this is a very pure, fresh, lively, firmly structured and almost ascetic wine with complexity, but almost no sensuality. Very distinctive style.”
95/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Jul 2016
“Expressive and richly textured Pinot Noir. Profound.
”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2016
“Disgorged October 2014. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. RS 4 g/l.
Tasted blind. Pinkish gold. Very slightly oxidised but not dangerously so on the nose. Then great energy on the end. This is almost Krug-like in how complex and tight knit it is. Savoury. Impressive. Energetic. Unusually dry finish.”
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2016
“It has been a long wait for R.D. fans since the 1997 vintage, which was followed by only minuscule amounts of 1999 and 2000 coming in large formats only. Now there is a chance to celebrate 50 years of R.D. with the outstanding 2002 vintage. It is a bold, fresh and seamless vintage of R.D. with the higher than usual Chardonnay content bringing an extra layer of elegance. I enjoy the drive and linearity the wine has despite the huge concentration. The October 2013 disgorged bottle has been the best with super-stylish with its mineral restraint and autumnal. Apple and spice fruit profile with an under-control oxidative undertone. Perfected, super dry 3g/l dosage.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“(Bottle) Tasted blind. Disgorged October 2014.
A little less fruity on the nose, as though it is a little evolved so seemed clearly from a bottle rather than a magnum - confirmed. Again very dry end.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“(Magnum) Tasted blind. Disgorged October 2014.
Big and broad on the nose. With a hint of putty. Edge of cream-of-mushroom soup. Bone dry and even a little chewy on the end. It seemed as though it had to be a magnum and it was. ”
17.5
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2015
“Magnum. Lots of minerality on the nose and underlying fruit. Tense-issimo. Almost austere!”
94/100
Josh Reynolds,
VinousMedia.com,
Dec 2014
“Light gold. Powerful, mineral-laced scents of orange zest, pear skin, iodine and chamomile, with a hint of anise in the background. On the palate, vibrant orchard and citrus fruit flavors unfurl slowly, picking up toasty lees and mace nuances that build on the back half. Sappy, tightly focused and stony, finishing with excellent thrust and building florality. This is showing an extremely youthful profile for its age and while I know that the received wisdom is that R.D. wines should be drunk soon after release, I'd let this one get some more years on it. ”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“Bollinger's 2002 R.D. is striking in its beauty. Silky and caressing on the palate, the 2002 impresses for its exceptional balance and harmony. In 2002 so many Champagnes are ripe and explosive in style, but the 2002 R.D. is quite restrained by comparison. Hints of apricot pit, smoke, almonds, spices and pears ring out on the super-finessed, inviting finish. The 2002 is going to be nearly impossible to resist in its youth, but it should also age impeccably. All the elements are in the right place.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2014
“Very firm, savoury nose with Bollinger's trademark fungi. Very powerfully so but with excellent acidity and lift on the palate. This is touted as a 50th anniversary offering because the first RD (Recently Disgorged) vintage released on the UK market was the 1952, in 1967 (so it was three years older than this 2002). It was launched at the same time as the 1953 on the French and Swiss markets and the 1955 on the American and Italian markets. A nod to British taste for seriously mature champagne? This wine should not be served too cool. It has real weight - though does not taste heavy. I loved it on first release as Grande Année and it is less austere now. A bit mellower and more open though still with the deep throat salve sensation on the finish.”
99/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
May 2014
“Super fresh, this is striking given the 10 years in the cellars; it has a fine citrus nose - plenty of lemon, grapefruit, yellow chalky notes, some lighter floral elements too. The palate is super dry (dosage at 3-4g) and there's a silky, sherbet-like texture, smooth, fine and long. The citrus flavours give way to the driving surging acidity, thunderous acidity, really driving and powerful. The finish twists very slowly through to light-toasted cashew fruit flavours, but lemon citrus prevails. This is thrilling Champagne.”
“Magnum. Disgorged March 2013. 100% grands and premiers crus. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay.
Mid gold. Creamy, well-integrated nose. No sign of obvious oak. Lovely texture and no excess of fizziness. Bone-dry finish. No compromises! Very Bollinger but just the right side of austere. Massive activity somehow on the palate. Long and noble. But not flattering”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2010
“Disgorged 15 October 2007. An 'incredible, exceptional year'. Summer was very very hot and then rain came at the end of August. Cool September nights. A 16 September start to harvest in very good conditions. Exceptional Indian summer. Very high sugar and acid. 70% Pinot Noir. 16 villages. 75% grands crus. Yield 12,000 kg, initial potential alcohol 10%, TA 10 g/l, 2.92 pH, final total acidity 6 g/l, final alcohol 12.1%.
Quite deep gold. Much more developed (and even slightly oxidative) than 1997 on the nose. Strong scent of baked buttered apples. Still quite firm and dense and savoury on the palate. Dry finish. Long. Very complex and open on the nose but still very tense on the palate. Obviously this wine has a long way to go but the nose of this particular bottle was more evolved than I would have expected from the palate. A wonderful wine.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni ,
VinousMedia.com,
Jan 2009
“The 1996 R.D. from Bollinger is another superb wine from this vintage. An expressive bouquet of spices, acacia blossoms and perfumed fruit emerges from the wine's silky-textured frame. This generous R.D. is drinking well today, but also has enough freshness to age well for years. It is a great version of one of Champagne's legendary wines.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2012
“An absolutely fabulous Bollinger. There is so much of everything. Exotic fruit, spice, lemon, vanilla and charred characters. The lately tasted bottles have had some oxidative notes but there is so much fruit and structure that it remains secondary. Really zesty acidity, bold fruitiness and near-eternal finish.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Disgorged in 2013, this bottle of Bollinger's 1996 Extra-Brut R. D. vindicates the house's decision to harvest late in this high-acid vintage, as even though the 1996 has a notably low pH of 2.93, the wine also possesses the maturity of fruit to balance it. Bursting with aromas of golden orchard fruit, crème brûlée, espresso roast, spices, warm bread, smoke and honeycomb, with time in the glass hints of dried fruits and marmalade emerge. On the palate, it's full-bodied, layered and vinous, with a textural attack and an ample core of fruit that's complemented by a pearly mousse, concluding with a long, saline, bone-dry finish. This is the best bottle of the 1996 R. D. I've ever encountered.”
“Disgorged September 12. pH 2.99. TA 9.4 g/l.
Dark gold. A little bit of oxidation. Then the mushrooms and lots of dried fruit. Classic RD? Probably not to everyone’s taste but very true to the house style. Broad and still very good, fine mousse.”
More Reviews +
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2011
“Deep gold. Just wonderfully complex, well-integrated nose. The very special quality of this wine just leapt out of the glass. Minerals and enormous depth. Great substance and delicacy too. Absolutely archetypal Bollinger: solid, dry, yet complex and ethereal on the nose. Masses of acidity – still tense. It would be a crime to drink this wine thoughtlessly at a reception; it really does demand concentration, and applause.
Disgorged 7 March 2011. Rainy, late season. 72% Pinot Noir. 17 villages. 66% grands crus. Yield 9,000 kg/ha, initial potential alcohol 9.2%, initial TA 9.4 g/l, pH 2.9, final TA 5.6 g/l, final alcohol 12.1%.”
92/100
Wine Spectator,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2001
“Mature and nutty in character, this 1988 exhibits a firm texture and an elegant stature, a fine backdrop for the roast coffee, hazelnut and citrus flavors. Dry style.”
92+/100
Stephen Tanzer,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2000
“Classic Bollinger aromas of baked apple, toffee, coffee, nuts and brioche. Then superrich, highly concentrated and penetrating, with impressive chewy extract. Uncompromisingly dry and just beginning to unfold. Really saturates the palate. Remarkably young for a 12-year-old Champagne-but then the best '88s are evolving slowly. Finishes with superb length.”
“Disgorged 4 May 2010. Picked from 1 Sep. Hot, dry summer, the hottest since 1959. 65% Pinot Noir. 70% from Bollinger's own vineyards. 10,359 kg yield, potential alcohol 10.5+%, initial acidity 6.7g/l, pH 3.1, final TA 4.8 g/l.
Pale bronze. Extremely rich and candified on the nose. Soft and round. Relatively low acid. Toasty, this just washes over you. Really hedonistic. In view of the relatively low acidity, it's amazing how well this has lasted. Presumably the very late disgorgement helps.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2014
“Every one of my encounters with this wine has been a slight disappointment, but then again expectations fly really high for the vintage. The earlier disgorgements have had a really sweet appearing nose with candied fruit and patisserie notes. Mouth-filling, super ripe, chunky palate short of energy. It feels like its best days are already gone. From a very recent 2012 disgorged bottle if was still fully vibrant, with a peculiar combination of aged and youthful characters. Probably still recovering from the shock of such late disgorgement.”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TheFinestBubble.com,
Jun 2022
“Magnum tasted 10th June 2022 D: March 2014 The fruit aromatics leap out the glass, amazing intensity from this super-hot year. Has all those dried citrus notes, bitter orange, lemon, lime and grapefruit, with roasted cashews and those autumn like associations of dried blackberry, charcuterie, dark chocolate and cooked mushrooms. The palate is relatively soft and gentle, with all the power of the fruit on the aromatics and that iodine lift on the end with bitter orange really lingering. Absolutely glorious, probably about its peak now for ten years. ”
98/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“As I wrote last year, Bollinger's 1976 Extra-Brut R. D. is simply extraordinary, wafting from the glass with scents of dried orange rind, mocha, fresh pastry, honeycomb, yellow apple, peach and smoke, complemented by subtle hints of iodine, fresh girolle mushrooms and aromatic bitters. Full-bodied, deep and complete, it's vinous and muscular, with huge concentration, racy acids and a long, pungently saline and invigoratingly bone-dry finish, enlivened by a pearly mousse. This magical Champagne represents the distilled essence of the Bollinger style.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Picked 1 September. pH 3.01. One of the driest vintages ever. Disgorged 2007. 2.2 bars. Dosage 4 g/l.
Much less mushroom than in the 1989. A little simpler than the 1989 but some candied fruits and TDN. Pungent, dried lemon and orange peel with a bit of bitterness. Throbs a bit on the end. Less obvious decay than the 1989. This is the profile they are looking for in RD apparently. Quite a fine texture. Very distinctive and to me not that obviously Bollinger.”
“When I was tasting Bollinger's brilliant Grande Année in this vintage, I was trying to imagine how good the 2008 Extra-Brut R. D. would be, as the style of the vintage seems almost perfectly adapted to this cuvée. Four years later, we have the answer, and the wine is brilliant. Disgorged in 2022, it's more reserved out of the gates than the dramatic Grande Année was on release, unwinding in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, orange peel, freshly baked bread, subtle hints of fino sherry, wet stones and macadamia nut. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, with a deep core of fruit that's animated by racy acids and a refined pinpoint mousse, concluding with a bone-dry finish. Extremely harmonious and full of youthful energy, it's the finest R. D. of the decade and one that will richly reward a bit of additional age on cork. In style, the most obvious comparison is with the 1996, but the 2008 is more integrated and harmonious on release. These bottles were disgorged late last year with three grams per liter dosage.”
More Reviews +
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2023
“2008 is a remarkably slowly ageing vintage, thus it is laudable that Bollinger were able to lengthen RD's lees ageing from 12 to 14 years here. The house shifting to the narrow-necked new bottle shape in 2008 adds an element of interest to this launch from the super hyped harvest year. The layered nose shows cool restraint with sweet patisserie and roasted chestnut over yellow apple, lemon zest and crunchy yellow plum fruit. Over time in the glass the charred, tobacco and nutty notes get enhanced with sweet vanilla, dried apricot and apple compote tones. On the palate the wine is as vigorous and tight as ever, with a linear and racy body leading to a long, super saline finish. Compared to the earlier launched La Grande Année edition of the wine, there is more flesh on the bone, but the wine manages to keep its elegant crystalline transparency. No doubt the record-low 3g/L dosage contributes, as Bollinger wants to stay true to the wine. Many wondered about the short original release of La Grande Année, but Bollinger did wisely to keep back a large number of bottles for release as RD thanks to the wine’s colossal ageing capacity. Even today the wine is structurally super youthful, but aromatics are already beautifully enriched by fine charred, smoky and biscuity complexity. This RD is an age-defying beauty. Bottle disgorged 28.10.2022.”
97/100
Richard Juhlin,
Champagneclub.com,
Feb 2023
“This beautifully sparkling 2008 is surprisingly light in colour, but will surely deepen towards more golden tones in the near future a little further from its fresh disgorgement date. The colossal and wonderful scent is of such dignity that words can never do it full justice. If I do try to describe this unique perfume, it is dominated by hazelnut cream from Piedmont, Domori chocolate from Venezuela, madeleine cookies, almond paste, wood sauna, gunpowder, grilled beef, duck liver, honeysuckle, mushroom cream, honey and nougat. It takes a long time in the glass before the fruit appears and at the same time the nutty and grilled aromas tone down a bit. The taste is vibrantly fresh while being rich and grilled nutty. Here, minerality and sea aromas such as iodine and oyster shells show up together with an apricot-like sublime fruitiness. After a fresh attack, my senses are left supremely satisfied with an exemplary long aftertaste of honey.”
“When I was tasting Bollinger's brilliant Grande Année in this vintage, I was trying to imagine how good the 2008 Extra-Brut RD would be, as the style of the vintage seems almost perfectly adapted to this cuvée. Four years later, we have the answer, and the wine is brilliant. Disgorged in 2022, it's more reserved out of the gates than the dramatic Grande Année was on release, unwinding in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, orange peel, freshly baked bread, subtle hints of fino sherry, wet stones and macadamia nut. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, with a deep core of fruit that's animated by racy acids and a refined pinpoint mousse, concluding with a bone-dry finish. Extremely harmonious and full of youthful energy, it's the finest RD of the decade and one that will richly reward a bit of older age on cork. In style, the most obvious comparison is with the 1996, but the 2008 is more integrated and harmonious on release. These bottles were disgorged late last year with three grams per liter dosage. Drink 2025-2045.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Worldoffinewine.com,
Jun 2023
“Magnum - A notion of salty shortbread full of buttery richness opens the nose, followed by a citrus intensity of both lemon and fresh navel orange peel and rich hints of grilled hazelnut. More swirling brings out the telltale creaminess alongside overtones of rye bread and white pepper. The palate carries the serene sleekness and cool poise of 2008, but as the wine warms, Bollinger’s legendary creaminess comes to the fore, allowing glimpses of future glory with each little aromatic bubble burst. At first, nose and palate diverge, but with time and increasing temperature, the electric freshness and innate energy of 2008 converge with a pronounced saltiness and a more accessible richness. This will age more gracefully than any of us.”
97/100
Simon Field MW,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2023
“Magnum - Bright in colour with gold reflections, the aromatics are immediately captivating, with marzipan, acacia, apricot and patisserie all vying for attention. It’s impossibly youthful yet reassuringly mature, a bread basket of delicious contradiction. Cerebral seduction ensues on the palate, with dried fruits, bergamot and lime joining the party, then come the hazelnut notes – which have been identified as a leitmotif for the vintage – and a clean, almost chalky finish to restore rigorous harmony. Precision in no way undermines generosity, and generosity in no way undermines potential. A very fine piece of work all in all, tasted from magnum, alongside bottle and jeroboam. Disgorged: November 2022. Dosage: 3g/L.”
98+/100
Sarah Mayo,
thewineindependent.com,
Nov 2023
“Emerging like a genie from a bottle, so full of life and magic, the Bollinger R.D. 2008 unwinds gradually to reveal aromatic layer after layer of white peach, Meyer lemon confit, kumquat, wafer cookies, wet stones and acacia honey intermingling with bready and faintly oxidative, nutty notes. Medium to full-bodied and full of high-toned energy, the palate is wonderfully silky and lithe with a super fine, creamy mousse full of stimulating acid freshness, exquisite saline intensity, and a chalky finish with a beautiful citrus peel note. A blend of 66% Pinot Noir and 34% Chardonnay, it was disgorged 09 December 2022 and finished Extra Brut with a three gram per liter dosage. As beautiful as it is now, it has many years of excellent drinking ahead.”
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2023
“2008 is a remarkably slowly ageing vintage, thus it is laudable that Bollinger were able to lengthen RD's lees ageing from 12 to 14 years here. The house shifting to the narrow-necked new bottle shape in 2008 adds an element of interest to this launch from the super hyped harvest year. The layered nose shows cool restraint with sweet patisserie and roasted chestnut over yellow apple, lemon zest and crunchy yellow plum fruit. Over time in the glass the charred, tobacco and nutty notes get enhanced with sweet vanilla, dried apricot and apple compote tones. On the palate the wine is as vigorous and tight as ever, with a linear and racy body leading to a long, super saline finish. Compared to the earlier launched La Grande Année edition of the wine, there is more flesh on the bone, but the wine manages to keep its elegant crystalline transparency. No doubt the record-low 3g/L dosage contributes, as Bollinger wants to stay true to the wine. Many wondered about the short original release of La Grande Année, but Bollinger did wisely to keep back a large number of bottles for release as RD thanks to the wine’s colossal ageing capacity. Even today the wine is structurally super youthful, but aromatics are already beautifully enriched by fine charred, smoky and biscuity complexity. This RD is an age-defying beauty. Bottle disgorged 28.10.2022.”
97/100
Richard Juhlin,
Champagneclub.com,
Feb 2023
“This beautifully sparkling 2008 is surprisingly light in colour, but will surely deepen towards more golden tones in the near future a little further from its fresh disgorgement date. The colossal and wonderful scent is of such dignity that words can never do it full justice. If I do try to describe this unique perfume, it is dominated by hazelnut cream from Piedmont, Domori chocolate from Venezuela, madeleine cookies, almond paste, wood sauna, gunpowder, grilled beef, duck liver, honeysuckle, mushroom cream, honey and nougat. It takes a long time in the glass before the fruit appears and at the same time the nutty and grilled aromas tone down a bit. The taste is vibrantly fresh while being rich and grilled nutty. Here, minerality and sea aromas such as iodine and oyster shells show up together with an apricot-like sublime fruitiness. After a fresh attack, my senses are left supremely satisfied with an exemplary long aftertaste of honey.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Feb 2023
“Bollinger's 2008 R.D. is a powerful, vinous Champagne. Apricot, dried pear, tangerine oil, hazelnut, dried flowers, chamomile and brioche all race across the palate. The 2008 boasts notable depth and textural intensity, with a feeling of phenolic, almost tannin-driven grip from the Pinot that propels the finish. At times the R.D. is quite exotic, even if there is a good kick of energy from the bright, salivating acids and low dosage. The 2008 R.D. is very much a Champagne for the dinner table, a wine that benefits immensely from aeration. In 2008, the blend comprises fruit from 18 villages, 719% Pinot Noir, mostly from Ay and Verzenay and 29% Chardonnay, mostly from Mesnil-sur-Oger and Cramant. Dosage is 3 grams of dosage I would give this a few more years in bottle to fully come together. Disgorged: October 28, 2022”
“When I was tasting Bollinger's brilliant Grande Année in this vintage, I was trying to imagine how good the 2008 Extra-Brut RD would be, as the style of the vintage seems almost perfectly adapted to this cuvée. Four years later, we have the answer, and the wine is brilliant. Disgorged in 2022, it's more reserved out of the gates than the dramatic Grande Année was on release, unwinding in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, orange peel, freshly baked bread, subtle hints of fino sherry, wet stones and macadamia nut. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, with a deep core of fruit that's animated by racy acids and a refined pinpoint mousse, concluding with a bone-dry finish. Extremely harmonious and full of youthful energy, it's the finest RD of the decade and one that will richly reward a bit of older age on cork. In style, the most obvious comparison is with the 1996, but the 2008 is more integrated and harmonious on release. These bottles were disgorged late last year with three grams per liter dosage. Drink 2025-2045.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“It was curious to see what an extra year of post-disgorgement ageing has done to this majestic cuvée since tasting it for last year’s Champagne report. This time, an October 2023-disgorged bottle was tasted. Beautifully complex nose, with pastry and baking-spice nuances over luscious apricotty fruitiness. The intensely fruity body marries well with the brisk acidity of the wine, leaving an overall impression of seamlessness and precision. This is very slow in its development, promising superb longevity. Dosage: 3g/l”
98/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Worldoffinewine.com,
Jun 2023
“Magnum - A notion of salty shortbread full of buttery richness opens the nose, followed by a citrus intensity of both lemon and fresh navel orange peel and rich hints of grilled hazelnut. More swirling brings out the telltale creaminess alongside overtones of rye bread and white pepper. The palate carries the serene sleekness and cool poise of 2008, but as the wine warms, Bollinger’s legendary creaminess comes to the fore, allowing glimpses of future glory with each little aromatic bubble burst. At first, nose and palate diverge, but with time and increasing temperature, the electric freshness and innate energy of 2008 converge with a pronounced saltiness and a more accessible richness. This will age more gracefully than any of us.”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“Following this wine’s evolution over the past few years has been a true pleasure. The October 25th 2023 disgorgement is wonderfully expressive, with seductive spicy sweetness and beautifully evolved dried fruit richness. On the palate, it is vinous yet refined, lifted by a brisk line of acidity that carries the wine to impressive length. This impeccable vintage of RD continues to shine with vitality. Disgorgement date:25/10/23. Dosage:3g/l.”
97/100
Simon Field MW,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2023
“Magnum - Bright in colour with gold reflections, the aromatics are immediately captivating, with marzipan, acacia, apricot and patisserie all vying for attention. It’s impossibly youthful yet reassuringly mature, a bread basket of delicious contradiction. Cerebral seduction ensues on the palate, with dried fruits, bergamot and lime joining the party, then come the hazelnut notes – which have been identified as a leitmotif for the vintage – and a clean, almost chalky finish to restore rigorous harmony. Precision in no way undermines generosity, and generosity in no way undermines potential. A very fine piece of work all in all, tasted from magnum, alongside bottle and jeroboam. Disgorged: November 2022. Dosage: 3g/L.”
98+/100
Sarah Mayo,
thewineindependent.com,
Nov 2023
“Emerging like a genie from a bottle, so full of life and magic, the Bollinger R.D. 2008 unwinds gradually to reveal aromatic layer after layer of white peach, Meyer lemon confit, kumquat, wafer cookies, wet stones and acacia honey intermingling with bready and faintly oxidative, nutty notes. Medium to full-bodied and full of high-toned energy, the palate is wonderfully silky and lithe with a super fine, creamy mousse full of stimulating acid freshness, exquisite saline intensity, and a chalky finish with a beautiful citrus peel note. A blend of 66% Pinot Noir and 34% Chardonnay, it was disgorged 09 December 2022 and finished Extra Brut with a three gram per liter dosage. As beautiful as it is now, it has many years of excellent drinking ahead.”
“When I was tasting Bollinger's brilliant Grande Année in this vintage, I was trying to imagine how good the 2008 Extra-Brut RD would be, as the style of the vintage seems almost perfectly adapted to this cuvée. Four years later, we have the answer, and the wine is brilliant. Disgorged in 2022, it's more reserved out of the gates than the dramatic Grande Année was on release, unwinding in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, orange peel, freshly baked bread, subtle hints of fino sherry, wet stones and macadamia nut. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, with a deep core of fruit that's animated by racy acids and a refined pinpoint mousse, concluding with a bone-dry finish. Extremely harmonious and full of youthful energy, it's the finest RD of the decade and one that will richly reward a bit of older age on cork. In style, the most obvious comparison is with the 1996, but the 2008 is more integrated and harmonious on release. These bottles were disgorged late last year with three grams per liter dosage. Drink 2025-2045.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“It was curious to see what an extra year of post-disgorgement ageing has done to this majestic cuvée since tasting it for last year’s Champagne report. This time, an October 2023-disgorged bottle was tasted. Beautifully complex nose, with pastry and baking-spice nuances over luscious apricotty fruitiness. The intensely fruity body marries well with the brisk acidity of the wine, leaving an overall impression of seamlessness and precision. This is very slow in its development, promising superb longevity. Dosage: 3g/l”
98/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Worldoffinewine.com,
Jun 2023
“Magnum - A notion of salty shortbread full of buttery richness opens the nose, followed by a citrus intensity of both lemon and fresh navel orange peel and rich hints of grilled hazelnut. More swirling brings out the telltale creaminess alongside overtones of rye bread and white pepper. The palate carries the serene sleekness and cool poise of 2008, but as the wine warms, Bollinger’s legendary creaminess comes to the fore, allowing glimpses of future glory with each little aromatic bubble burst. At first, nose and palate diverge, but with time and increasing temperature, the electric freshness and innate energy of 2008 converge with a pronounced saltiness and a more accessible richness. This will age more gracefully than any of us.”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“Following this wine’s evolution over the past few years has been a true pleasure. The October 25th 2023 disgorgement is wonderfully expressive, with seductive spicy sweetness and beautifully evolved dried fruit richness. On the palate, it is vinous yet refined, lifted by a brisk line of acidity that carries the wine to impressive length. This impeccable vintage of RD continues to shine with vitality. Disgorgement date:25/10/23. Dosage:3g/l.”
97/100
Simon Field MW,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2023
“Magnum - Bright in colour with gold reflections, the aromatics are immediately captivating, with marzipan, acacia, apricot and patisserie all vying for attention. It’s impossibly youthful yet reassuringly mature, a bread basket of delicious contradiction. Cerebral seduction ensues on the palate, with dried fruits, bergamot and lime joining the party, then come the hazelnut notes – which have been identified as a leitmotif for the vintage – and a clean, almost chalky finish to restore rigorous harmony. Precision in no way undermines generosity, and generosity in no way undermines potential. A very fine piece of work all in all, tasted from magnum, alongside bottle and jeroboam. Disgorged: November 2022. Dosage: 3g/L.”
98+/100
Sarah Mayo,
thewineindependent.com,
Nov 2023
“Emerging like a genie from a bottle, so full of life and magic, the Bollinger R.D. 2008 unwinds gradually to reveal aromatic layer after layer of white peach, Meyer lemon confit, kumquat, wafer cookies, wet stones and acacia honey intermingling with bready and faintly oxidative, nutty notes. Medium to full-bodied and full of high-toned energy, the palate is wonderfully silky and lithe with a super fine, creamy mousse full of stimulating acid freshness, exquisite saline intensity, and a chalky finish with a beautiful citrus peel note. A blend of 66% Pinot Noir and 34% Chardonnay, it was disgorged 09 December 2022 and finished Extra Brut with a three gram per liter dosage. As beautiful as it is now, it has many years of excellent drinking ahead.”
“Disgorged in October 2024 with a dosage of three grams per liter, the 2008 Extra-Brut R.D. is superb, offering a bouquet of Granny Smith apple, pomelo and almond paste, mingled with white sandwich bread and oystershell. The medium- to full-bodied palate reveals a deep, vibrant core of fruit, underpinned by racy acidity and framed by high levels of structuring dry extract that assert themselves on the sapid, precise finish. This is a brilliant wine, built to age gracefully on its acidity, and it stands as one of the greatest achievements of the vintage. Its lower dosage, to my palate, also gives it the edge over La Grande Année in terms of energy and aromatic definition.”
More Reviews +
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2025
“So many dried-apple, grapefruit and buttery-croissant aromas follow through to a full body with density and richness, showing baking spices and pie crust. Turns fresh and vivid at the end with incredible acidity that contrasts the ripe fruit and electrifies your palate. 71% pinot noir and 29% chardonnay. Disgorged October 2024. Drink now.”
98+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2025
“When I was tasting Bollinger's brilliant Grande Année in this vintage, I was trying to imagine how good the 2008 Extra-Brut R. D. would be, as the style of the vintage seems almost perfectly adapted to this cuvée. Four years later, we have the answer, and the wine is brilliant. Disgorged in 2022, it's more reserved out of the gates than the dramatic Grande Année was on release, unwinding in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, orange peel, freshly baked bread, subtle hints of fino sherry, wet stones and macadamia nut. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, with a deep core of fruit that's animated by racy acids and a refined pinpoint mousse, concluding with a bone-dry finish. Extremely harmonious and full of youthful energy, it's the finest R. D. of the decade and one that will richly reward a bit of additional age on cork. In style, the most obvious comparison is with the 1996, but the 2008 is more integrated and harmonious on release. These bottles were disgorged late last year with three grams per liter dosage.”
“Bollinger is still a relative newcomer to the non-vintage rosé scene, having produced this cuvée only since 2008. But it was an instant match to the house style of rich and firm Pinot fruit. It takes a mere 5% of Pinot Noir wine from Verzenay and Aÿ to give this its desired colour (salmon, with delicate peachy hues) and character. The fine nose is characterised by pristine red fruitiness playfully intermingling with spicy complexity and mineral whiffs. Still primary in fruitiness, it comes with depth and complexity. The oak takes a supporting role, leaving the delicious Pinot fruit to the fore, and the well-built, muscular palate has a degree of vinosity. This is a non-vintage rosé that is worthy of ageing. Dosage 7-8g/l”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2022
“Pale to mid salmon. Light Pinot perfume. Well-managed mousse is just the right side of not-too-aggressive. Good balance of fruit and the dry finish. Serious rosé champagne but definitely not hard work to drink now.”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The latest release of Bollinger's NV Brut Rosé is showing especially well, offering up complex aromas of sweet stone fruit, honeycomb, freshly baked bread and orange oil, followed by a medium to full-bodied, pillowy and vinous palate. Layered and concentrated, with a pretty pinpoint mousse and ripe but racy acids, it concludes with a long, expansive finish.”
“Bollinger's NV Special Cuvée 007 is not a re-release of the 1969, which James Bond famously mentions in the film 'Moonraker,' but it is a pretty wine that captures the essence of the house style nicely, attractively packaged to coincide with the latest Bond movie. It offers up scents of orchard fruit, baked apple tart, brioche, spice and dried floral notes, all in a profile that holds plenty of near term appeal.”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“Disgorged in May 2021, the latest rendition of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing beautifully, offering up aromas of ripe orchard fruit, citrus oil and peach, mingled with hints of walnuts and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a generous core of fruit, lively acids and a pillowy mousse, it's seamless and complete, concluding with an expansive finish.”
89-91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Refined nose with stylish restraint. Richness of spicy-earthy notes carefully intertwined to the lemon, apple pie, baked pear, cinnamon and vanilla tones. Super mild oxidative character beneath the intense fruitiness. Seamless structure on the generous palate. Long, mineral, dry finish. Built to last, so deserves additional post-disgorgement ageing. ”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“60% Pinot Noir, 25% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Meunier. Bollinger don’t talk about which wine their non-vintage blends are based on because reserve wines constitute a good 50% of the blend. This was bottled in 2013 and disgorged in 2016 so 2012 is the youngest vintage. 150+ different wines in the blend. Maybe six or seven different vintages.
Very firm, Bollinger savoury style on the nose with a bone-dry finish and lots of chewiness. Dried apple-skin flavours. Really long. A fan of flavours on the end. Very distinctive.
Drink 2016-2020”
“Like its rosé counterpart, the latest release of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing especially well, bursting from the glass with aromas of honeyed apples, crisp stone fruit, buttery pastry, ripe lemons and fresh walnuts. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and vinous, with a deep core of beautifully ripe fruit, racy acids and a pillowy mousse, it's a charming, characterful wine that proves that Special Cuvée is firmly back where it belongs.”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“Disgorged in May 2021, the latest rendition of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing beautifully, offering up aromas of ripe orchard fruit, citrus oil and peach, mingled with hints of walnuts and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a generous core of fruit, lively acids and a pillowy mousse, it's seamless and complete, concluding with an expansive finish.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The nuanced nose delivers orchard fruits layered with spice and yeastiness, and the fine, ripe concentrated fruitiness is well protected from oxidation. The very complex Bollinger blending recipe, including the laborious and costly use of long-aged reserve wines in magnums, results in something classy and seamless; this is a wine full of character. The bold, powerful palate has a fine silky texture and a stylishly mellow mousse, leaving room for the vinosity to build in the glass. This is a non-vintage that is worth maturing and is especially recommended in magnum. Dosage 8-9g/l”
89-91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Refined nose with stylish restraint. Richness of spicy-earthy notes carefully intertwined to the lemon, apple pie, baked pear, cinnamon and vanilla tones. Super mild oxidative character beneath the intense fruitiness. Seamless structure on the generous palate. Long, mineral, dry finish. Built to last, so deserves additional post-disgorgement ageing. ”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“60% Pinot Noir, 25% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Meunier. Bollinger don’t talk about which wine their non-vintage blends are based on because reserve wines constitute a good 50% of the blend. This was bottled in 2013 and disgorged in 2016 so 2012 is the youngest vintage. 150+ different wines in the blend. Maybe six or seven different vintages.
Very firm, Bollinger savoury style on the nose with a bone-dry finish and lots of chewiness. Dried apple-skin flavours. Really long. A fan of flavours on the end. Very distinctive.
Drink 2016-2020”
“Like its rosé counterpart, the latest release of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing especially well, bursting from the glass with aromas of honeyed apples, crisp stone fruit, buttery pastry, ripe lemons and fresh walnuts. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and vinous, with a deep core of beautifully ripe fruit, racy acids and a pillowy mousse, it's a charming, characterful wine that proves that Special Cuvée is firmly back where it belongs.”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“Disgorged in May 2021, the latest rendition of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing beautifully, offering up aromas of ripe orchard fruit, citrus oil and peach, mingled with hints of walnuts and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a generous core of fruit, lively acids and a pillowy mousse, it's seamless and complete, concluding with an expansive finish.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The nuanced nose delivers orchard fruits layered with spice and yeastiness, and the fine, ripe concentrated fruitiness is well protected from oxidation. The very complex Bollinger blending recipe, including the laborious and costly use of long-aged reserve wines in magnums, results in something classy and seamless; this is a wine full of character. The bold, powerful palate has a fine silky texture and a stylishly mellow mousse, leaving room for the vinosity to build in the glass. This is a non-vintage that is worth maturing and is especially recommended in magnum. Dosage 8-9g/l”
89-91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Refined nose with stylish restraint. Richness of spicy-earthy notes carefully intertwined to the lemon, apple pie, baked pear, cinnamon and vanilla tones. Super mild oxidative character beneath the intense fruitiness. Seamless structure on the generous palate. Long, mineral, dry finish. Built to last, so deserves additional post-disgorgement ageing. ”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“60% Pinot Noir, 25% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Meunier. Bollinger don’t talk about which wine their non-vintage blends are based on because reserve wines constitute a good 50% of the blend. This was bottled in 2013 and disgorged in 2016 so 2012 is the youngest vintage. 150+ different wines in the blend. Maybe six or seven different vintages.
Very firm, Bollinger savoury style on the nose with a bone-dry finish and lots of chewiness. Dried apple-skin flavours. Really long. A fan of flavours on the end. Very distinctive.
Drink 2016-2020”
“Like its rosé counterpart, the latest release of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing especially well, bursting from the glass with aromas of honeyed apples, crisp stone fruit, buttery pastry, ripe lemons and fresh walnuts. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and vinous, with a deep core of beautifully ripe fruit, racy acids and a pillowy mousse, it's a charming, characterful wine that proves that Special Cuvée is firmly back where it belongs.”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“Disgorged in May 2021, the latest rendition of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing beautifully, offering up aromas of ripe orchard fruit, citrus oil and peach, mingled with hints of walnuts and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a generous core of fruit, lively acids and a pillowy mousse, it's seamless and complete, concluding with an expansive finish.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The nuanced nose delivers orchard fruits layered with spice and yeastiness, and the fine, ripe concentrated fruitiness is well protected from oxidation. The very complex Bollinger blending recipe, including the laborious and costly use of long-aged reserve wines in magnums, results in something classy and seamless; this is a wine full of character. The bold, powerful palate has a fine silky texture and a stylishly mellow mousse, leaving room for the vinosity to build in the glass. This is a non-vintage that is worth maturing and is especially recommended in magnum. Dosage 8-9g/l”
89-91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Refined nose with stylish restraint. Richness of spicy-earthy notes carefully intertwined to the lemon, apple pie, baked pear, cinnamon and vanilla tones. Super mild oxidative character beneath the intense fruitiness. Seamless structure on the generous palate. Long, mineral, dry finish. Built to last, so deserves additional post-disgorgement ageing. ”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“60% Pinot Noir, 25% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Meunier. Bollinger don’t talk about which wine their non-vintage blends are based on because reserve wines constitute a good 50% of the blend. This was bottled in 2013 and disgorged in 2016 so 2012 is the youngest vintage. 150+ different wines in the blend. Maybe six or seven different vintages.
Very firm, Bollinger savoury style on the nose with a bone-dry finish and lots of chewiness. Dried apple-skin flavours. Really long. A fan of flavours on the end. Very distinctive.
Drink 2016-2020”
“Like its rosé counterpart, the latest release of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing especially well, bursting from the glass with aromas of honeyed apples, crisp stone fruit, buttery pastry, ripe lemons and fresh walnuts. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and vinous, with a deep core of beautifully ripe fruit, racy acids and a pillowy mousse, it's a charming, characterful wine that proves that Special Cuvée is firmly back where it belongs.”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“Disgorged in May 2021, the latest rendition of Bollinger's NV Brut Special Cuvée is showing beautifully, offering up aromas of ripe orchard fruit, citrus oil and peach, mingled with hints of walnuts and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a generous core of fruit, lively acids and a pillowy mousse, it's seamless and complete, concluding with an expansive finish.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The nuanced nose delivers orchard fruits layered with spice and yeastiness, and the fine, ripe concentrated fruitiness is well protected from oxidation. The very complex Bollinger blending recipe, including the laborious and costly use of long-aged reserve wines in magnums, results in something classy and seamless; this is a wine full of character. The bold, powerful palate has a fine silky texture and a stylishly mellow mousse, leaving room for the vinosity to build in the glass. This is a non-vintage that is worth maturing and is especially recommended in magnum. Dosage 8-9g/l”
89-91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Refined nose with stylish restraint. Richness of spicy-earthy notes carefully intertwined to the lemon, apple pie, baked pear, cinnamon and vanilla tones. Super mild oxidative character beneath the intense fruitiness. Seamless structure on the generous palate. Long, mineral, dry finish. Built to last, so deserves additional post-disgorgement ageing. ”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“60% Pinot Noir, 25% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Meunier. Bollinger don’t talk about which wine their non-vintage blends are based on because reserve wines constitute a good 50% of the blend. This was bottled in 2013 and disgorged in 2016 so 2012 is the youngest vintage. 150+ different wines in the blend. Maybe six or seven different vintages.
Very firm, Bollinger savoury style on the nose with a bone-dry finish and lots of chewiness. Dried apple-skin flavours. Really long. A fan of flavours on the end. Very distinctive.
Drink 2016-2020”
“Extremely mellow, rich nose – like essence of Pinot Noir! Presumably thanks to the plant material, vine age and length of tirage. And one can see the rigour of the oak influence. Dry, lingering finish. A food wine, or wine to meditate over. A true thrill to experience. So neat and contained! A wine that takes you on a journey as you taste through from the rich start to the dry finish. My suggested drinking window is a guess as I haven't tasted this wine with much bottle age. Drink: 2025-2040”
More Reviews +
98/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“The recently released 2016 Blanc de Noirs Vieilles Vignes Françaises—harvested on September 18th at a relatively modest 10.2% potential alcohol—has turned out beautifully. It unites the richness of Pinot Noir and the concentration of old vines with the freshness imparted by the growing season and recent disgorgement. This balance serves to temper some of the exuberance that VVF can display in warmer vintages. Disgorged in February 2025 with a dosage of four grams per liter, the wine unfurls from the glass with a deep bouquet of orange zest, crisp pear and peach, mingling with notes of freshly baked bread, nuts and spices. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, expansive and multidimensional, with tangy acidity and a pillowy mousse. Generous and intense yet impeccably harmonious, it culminates in a long, resonant finish. Those fortunate enough to secure one or two of the mere 1,000 bottles produced will likely face a dilemma: when to open it. Promising a superb drinking experience, it is likely to show at its full generosity between 17 and 25 years after the vintage. Drink: 2026-2041”
“The 2014 Vieilles Vignes Françaises is a stunning, exotic beauty. Silky contours wrap around a core of apricot, tangerine, orange marmalade, spice, ginger, dried flowers and marzipan. The 2014 is a Champagne of real textural breath and intensity. It's a superb wine in a year that presented numerous challenges along the way. I would prefer to cellar this for a few years. In a word: fabulous. Dosage is 4 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2024
“After the broad, muscular 2012 and the incisive 2013, Bollinger's 2014 Blanc de Noirs Vieilles Vignes Françaises represents something of a middle ground, with its charming, suave profile and elegant bouquet of crisp yellow orchard fruit, mandarin oil, praline and buttered toast. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and layered, with impressive depth and density for the vintage but also unusually immediacy for this cuvée, it will offer a broad drinking window. Produced from ungrafted Pinot Noir vines and fermented in old barrels, it represents the ne plus ultra of the Bollinger style.”
99/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
May 2024
“How long will we be able to enjoy this treasure? You are well aware that the phylloxera louse can any day crawl under the gate and in a flash destroy the two fragile slabs of Clos Saint-Jacques and Clos Chaudes-Terres in Aÿ. This impermanence makes the wine even more treasured and unique, as if its stratospheric quality weren't reason enough to hold the world's finest Blanc de Noirs in high esteem. Tasted directly after the mellow La Côte aux Enfants from the same vintage, I was prepared for VVF to be beaten for the first time by its sibling wine from the same village. When I finished tasting it was clear that I had just tasted the perfect champagne in its style. The champagne combines the honeyed concentration of a Château d´Yquem with the buttery nutty power and sophisticated richness of a Montrachet from Comte Lafon. But my God, Juhlin, it's Pinot Noir. Yes, but the fabulous creation is more reminiscent of the mentioned wines than of a big red Burgundy this time. I don't really know why 2014 was so perfect for Bollinger. Perhaps one has become even more skilled at maneuvering all the details that give a perfect VVF, or does the old theory apply that naturally masculine Bollinger is often at its best in slightly lighter and elegant vintages? In any case, this is a colossal wine experience! The wine belongs to the small few who act with such self-evident weight that comments and comparisons feel redundant. The color is deep golden and the extremely small bubbles move slowly up through the glass. The bouquet is rich, dense and powerful like a rumbling thunderstorm in the distance. Filled with honey and hazelnut essence and screaming scent of honeysuckle. In the mouth you are met by an oily and creamy essence of dark fruit, 70% chocolate from Domori and licorice with the same grilled lemons and apricot marmalade I find in all Bollinger's wines from 2014. Monumental, long, dense and unreal wide like a parade street in Buenos Aires. Drink soon or wait ten years for the next phase. Just as with La Côte aux Enfants, there is a high risk of tunnel behavior for a few years. Right now pure happiness in a champagne glass.”
“A brilliant wine, Bollinger's 2013 Blanc de Noirs Vieilles Vignes Françaises is finer boned and more elegant than the powerhouse 2008, but it is still one of the most powerful, intensely flavored wines produced in the region. Wafting from the glass with a deep bouquet of golden orchard fruit, honeycomb, baking spices, orange oil and ripe stone fruits, it's full-bodied, broad and fleshy, with a layered core of fruit girdled by racy acids. Concentrated and vinous, it concludes with a long, saline finish.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous,
Mar 2022
“The 2013 Vieilles Vignes Francaises is a powerhouse. Deep in color, the 2013 is rich and ample in feel. Apricot, spice, orange jam, cedar, dried herbs, ginger, honey and leather all meld together in a VVF that is decidedly opulent and vinous, despite the cool season and harvest that took place on September 27, late by present-day standards. Sadly, production has decreased steadily since 2008. Accumulated drought has been a challenge. Those conditions are, of course, amplified by the walls of the clos in these two parcels and the naturally warm climate of Aÿ. I find the 2013 decidedly exotic and a bit on the heavy side. Those lucky enough to own it will experience one of the most distinctive wines in all of Champagne. Production was less than 1,000 bottles. 2022-2038”
95-96
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2022
“As 2013 was a late harvest, it took exceptionally until September 27th to harvest Vieilles Vignes Françaises. Deep golden colour. Heaps of ripe fruits greet you from the glass: candied orange, marmalade, apricot pie, fudge and black pepper. There is immense depth to the wine that comes with an underlying savoury profile, supported by the perfectly integrated old oak aromas. The viscous palate comes with a lot of matter. Almost chewable at first, but soon enters the beautiful, brisk acidity that energizes the palate and brings with it salinity and finesse. Dark toned and vinous until the very long, concentrated finish. This is a beautiful, brightly fruity VVF that will reward cellaring.”
“This impressive vintage of Vieilles Vignes Françaises greets you with an utterly sophisticated nose of magnificent toasty layers. Toasted bread and grilled almonds meet smoky woody nuances. The nose is beautifully reductively charged and elegantly spicy with sumptuous, sweet orchard fruit and dried fruits in layers. A fine woody note from oak lines the voluminous and concentrated palate. Rich yes, but heavy no, the juicy freshness just goes on and on. A stunningly deep and no doubt remarkably age-worthy vintage of this iconic champagne. Dosage 4 g/l. Bottle number 0007 tasted of 2193 produced. ”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jun 2023
“The 2012 Vieilles Vignes Françaises is one of the best recent editions I can remember tasting. All the elements are impeccably balanced. Rich and creamy, but also wonderfully poised, the 2012 has so much to offer. Readers will find a Champagne of unparalleled elegance and finesse. Hints of apricot, dried flowers, chamomile, spice, mint and marzipan fill out the layers. I especially admire the finesse of the mousse in the 2012. The choice to pick a bit earlier than usual, given the warmth of the year and a naturally low crop, paid off big time. Dosage is 6 grams per liter. In a word: fabulous. ”
98/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Disgorged in March 2023 with six grams per liter dosage, Bollinger's 2012 Blanc de Noirs Vieilles Vignes Françaises is a powerful, multidimensional Champagne that pushes the house's vinous, Pinot Noir-driven style to the furthest. Offering up rich aromas of orange rind, mandarin oil, grilled peaches, dried fruits and pear mingled with notions of nutmeg, beeswax, smoke and buttered toast, it's full-bodied, broad and layered, with a deep, enveloping core endowed with extraordinary texture and concentration, its broad attack and mid-palate segueing into a long, resonant finish. If the 2013 vintage tended to tame some of the Vieilles Vignes Françaises's exuberance, the 2012 vintage leaves this cuvée untrammeled.”
98-99/100
Richard Juhlin,
Champagneclub.com,
Feb 2023
“Tasted prerelease with Denis Bunner when he just decided to add 6 grams of sugar. I have never tasted such a freshly disgorged VVF before and was really surprised by its bright color and lively character. Even more, I was surprised by its aromatic spectrum which in many parts reminded me of Coche-Dury's most beautiful creations from Meursault. This VVF shared its high-intensity petroleum bouquet and a really ultra-strong grilled, nutty and powdery aroma. Imagine that a pure Pinot Noir can remind you so much of Chardonnay. Added to this enormous bouquet is a fabulous freshness and pure fresh fruit where floral, yes almost citrus notes dance together with the grilled notes. A different and absolutely fantastic VVF that may become more classic from a purely stylistic perspective over time, but today it stands out as both fantastic and personally unique. ”
“Bollinger’s 2009 Vieilles Vignes Françaises is tightly wound and reserved, which is quite surprising given the warm, dry weather of the vintage. That won’t be a problem in time, of course, but readers should plan on being patient. With a few hours of air, apricot, plum, spice, dried cherry and candied orange peel start to appear, but the 2009 remains rather taut. In some years, VVF can be quite opulent, 2002 and 2010 come to mind. The 2009, on the other hand is much more vibrant. I wouldn’t plan on opening a bottle anytime soon. VVF remains one of the most compelling wines – still or sparkling – in the world. It emerges from ungrafted Pinot Noir vines in Aÿ’s Chaudes Terres and Clos St. Jacques lieu-dits and is vinified and aged in barrel. Dosage is 4 grams per liter.”
“A fine, focused Blanc de Blancs. The Chardonnay really drives everything here – fresh, structured, mineral, precise. Always seems to deliver consistent (high) quality at a very fair price.”
More Reviews +
93/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Apr 2025
“A wonderfully creamy, round blanc de blancs that has almond-blossom, white-flower, peach, brioche and pie-crust aromas. The bubbles are silky and soft. Elegant. 100% chardonnay.”
“This wine was disgorged à la volée during my visit to Marguet, thus it was bone-dry. It has impressive gunpowdery toasty whiffs and a seductive ripe fruitiness. Quite the crowd-pleaser. The fruit is ample and approachable, with vinosity and richness on the adequately fresh palate. Instantly impressive and highly enjoyable upon release.”
“Deep gold. Tiny bead. Rich crème pâtissière nose. My sample is – just – not too warm (Rebecca Palmer of Corney & Barrow, poor thing, turned up with two bottles from the hot tube) – and was perfect for tasting rather than drinking. Quite open and ripe. Coppery richness. You can taste the warm season after a mild, humid winter. Much more accessible than most just-released Salons; atypical. Hint of lemon syrup. Long.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2015 Salon is exquisite. Bright and focused, the 2015 captures a gorgeous stylsitic middle ground between the riper and cooler years. The flavor profile leans towards the more citrus, floral and mineral-driven end of the spectrum typical of cooler years, and yet the wine is also wonderfully open-knit and accessible, with no hard edges and the textural balance that is more common in warmer years. It's a duality that works extremely well. There is a savory undertone typical of the year, but it is a strand in the fabric rather than a dominant characteristic. I left a bottle open for more than a week, during which I observed virtually no oxidation. The 2015 might not be as overtly impressive as some recent years, rather it is a Champagne of cool sophistication and total polish. Unusually, the 2015 is being released ahead of the 2014.”
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“Released ahead of the 2014 rendition and originating from a dry, sunny growing season, Salon’s 2015 Brut Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil, disgorged in spring 2025 with a dosage of six grams per liter, follows in the footsteps of 2013, continuing a run of releases that are friendly from the start, without the austere edge that has often characterized this cuvée in the past. It expresses itself from the glass with a deep bouquet of orange peel, linden and freshly baked bread mingled with notes of lemon confit and subtle hints of lychee and mango. Full-bodied, concentrated and broad, it is fleshy and charming, with a generous core of fruit underpinned by ripe yet racy acidity and enlivened by a pillowy mousse, before concluding with a long, saline finish. This is a structured, open-knit Salon that carries a similar substance to its two immediate predecessors and will not disappoint those who choose to open it in its youth, despite my strong recommendation to cellar it for at least a decade—if not longer—as I anticipate it will follow a comparable evolutionary trajectory to the 1990 rendition.”
“The 2013 is the most powerful, dense young Salon I have ever tasted. Champagne of mind-bending complexity, the 2013 possesses tremendous mid-palate intensity and power from the very first taste. Lemon confit, dried flowers, mint and a touch of brioche appear first, followed by light tropical accents that add an exotic flair. Imagine the sizzling energy of the 2008 and the persistence of 2004, with more mid-palate richness and riper fruit. Two-thousand thirteen was a cool, late ripening year. Harvest started at the beginning of October under sunny, dry days and cool nights, conditions that have not been seen since then. Readers will find a spectacular, modern Salon endowed with tremendous depth and very little of the youthful austerity that once defined Champagnes from cooler years here. The 5.5 grams per liter of dosage is perfectly judged. In a word: Magnificent.”
More Reviews +
18.5+/20
Andy Howard MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Sep 2023
“At the moment, disarmingly open and approachable (Didier Depond compares 2013 to 1983 in this respect and expects it to close down in 18–24 months). Subtle biscuit notes on the nose, creamy on the palate with masses of concentration and many layers of texture. Fine mousse with a savoury/salty edge freshening up the finish. Plenty of driving acidity underneath but not at all unbalanced. Clearly a very long future ahead and I suspect it will need to be cellared for at least 5 years if not enjoyed in the first flush of ‘youth’!”
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2024
“In the context of the vintage, the expressive and structurally open personality of Salon’s 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil took me by surprise. Expecting a taut, incisive version, considering the cool, late-ripening growing season, it shares more similarities with the 2012 rendition than differences. Disgorged in early 2023 with a dosage of 5.5 grams per liter, it soars from the glass with scents of iodine, orange zest and warm bread mingling with hints of tropical fruit. Far from linear, it is a flamboyant and elegantly glossy rendition that’s undeniably fleshier than the racy-fresh and chiseled 2007 at a similar stage of development. Laden with ripe yet vibrant acidity, complemented by a pinpoint mousse and concluding with a precise, vividly chalky finish, it is dangerously approachable even now. However, given its rarity and eye-watering market price, it would be rather hedonistic to pop the corks before it celebrates its 20th birthday. Since 1921, this marks only the 44th edition of Salon.”
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil continues its ascent and, even with just a couple of extra years in bottle, is already revealing different facets, expressing itself from the glass with aromas of citrus oil, white flowers, fresh hazelnut and freshly baked bread, mingled with marine inflections and a faint hint of mango. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and concentrated, underpinned by ripe yet racy acidity, animated by a pinpoint mousse and concluding with a resonant, chalky finish. While not fundamentally different, it is slightly tauter and more incisive in the context of the 2015; yet it possesses no austerity and will hardly disappoint those who choose to open a bottle in the mid-term. That said, it is undeniable that it will continue to gain depth with further aging, with no risk of deterioration.”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Jun 2026
“2013 is a cool, late-ripening vintage in Champagne, defined by an October harvest in cool but sunny conditions. With a dosage of 5.5 grams per liter, the 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil possesses a complex, fruity bouquet mingling aromas of orchard fruit with notions of lemon oil, exotic fruits, spring flowers, almond and hints of menthol and buttery pastry. Full-bodied, rich and dense, with lively acids, it’s more complex and incisive than the 2002 and exhibits similar power to the 2012 at this early stage. Despite what was a challenging growing season for some producers, this is a superb Salon with a long, resonant finish.”
99/100
Audrey Frick,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Dec 2024
“A very special vintage for this wine, the 2013 Champagne Salon pours a pale yellow/green-tinged color and has a very pretty nose revealing round, pure notes of citrus blossom, a hint of almond pastry, fresh lemon meringue, and pure pear. But while the nose is expressive, the palate is still coiled and intense, with a pure, driving, chalky texture, power, and length, as well as a great deal of electricity that carries through the palate, with a pinpoint, focused mousse. This is going to be a great wine for collectors and for aging over the coming decades. This wine is singing. Comparing it with the Salon 82 and Salon 83 will be one of the great arguments over the years. 5 grams per liter dosage. Drink 2024-2044.”
98/100
Allen Meadows,
Burghound.com,
Oct 2024
“The brilliant nose, at once fresh, bright and complex, is even more beguiling than that of the 2012, which is already reference standard for anyone who loves blanc de blancs Champagne. Moreover, it is more expressive than I anticipated with its array of green apple, baked bread, just sliced citrus, quinine and a hint of Chablis-like iodine. The racy yet delicate mouthfeel of the lilting middle weight flavors that is enhanced by the super-fine, if decidedly firm, mousse before terminating in an already complex, harmonious and very dry yet not especially austere finale that goes on and on. Among many attributes to choose from, perhaps my favorite is the underlying sense of poise the ’13 Salon exudes as it’s classy as hell but not inaccessible; otherwise expressed, this is seriously good but borderline gulpable. In short, I was knocked out by this monument in the making and it’s entirely possible that my rating will one day be found to be overly conservative. As longtime readers know, Burghound doesn’t hand out 98-point ratings like they’re candy so when I tell you that this is genuinely great, I’m not kidding. I would further note that despite the fact that this wine has years of evolution ahead of it, it’s already so good that I hesitate to advise waiting; that’s just how good this already is. If you can stomach the hefty tariff, doesn’t hesitate.”
“Back in 2014, Salon's president Didier Depond was quoted in the press as saying that “since 2008, there has been no genuinely great vintage in Champagne" and that a 2012 from Salon wouldn't be released. But the just-released 2012 Brut Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil shows that he had good reason to change his mind, as to my palate this is, after the 2008, the finest Salon produced this millennium. Unwinding in the glass with notes of citrus oil, wet stones, freshly baked bread, white currants and oyster shell, it's full-bodied, deep and concentrated, with a tightly wound core of fruit, racy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. Concluding with a long and resonant finish, this is a structured and powerful Salon that's a lot more incisive than, for example, the 2002 at the same stage, but which also carries more muscle and substance than a leaner vintage such as 2007. For readers that have balked at the pricing of the magnum-only 2008, the 2012 isn't far off the latter's level in quality, and will presumably be distributed more conventionally.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“A rollercoaster year in the vineyards with hopes for a quality crop only rising at harvest time. Salon initially wasn't promising a vintage, but changed its mind having come up with something instantly rewarding. Bright, sweetly fruity nose on the sweet green fruit side: lime, pear drops, licorice, jasmine and fragrant orange blossom tones. A flick of vanilla complements the whole. The palate has a silky flow of volume yet a firm backbone of brisk acidity enhancing the notion of explosive fruitiness. The chalky mineral bite comes forward on the long, intense and dry finish. This wine hasn’t moved a lot in the past year, promising longevity. Disgorged 3/21; dosage 5g/l”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2012 Salon is absolutely gorgeous. It offers a beguiling mix of radiance and energy that seems to capture a little bit of elements of some of its older siblings. The expression of fruit is radiant and quite overt, but without reaching the tropical exuberance of the 2006. In shape, the 2012 recalls the mid-weight style of 2007 with the freshness of 2008, but not quite the youthful austerity of that wine. If that sounds like an appealing combination, well it is. The 2012 Salon is all harmony and class.”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2021
“Pinot Noir was the king of this climatically challenging vintage. Thus early on Salon wasn’t promising us a vintage. However, they changed their mind having come up with something instantly rewarding and generous. Bright, sweetly fruity nose on the tropical side with lemon, jasmine and orange blossom. The palate has volume yet a firm backbone of brisk acidity. The chalky mineral notions come forward on the long, intense and dry finish. ”
“Disgorged January (‘Edition’) 2019. Dosage 5 g/l. (First release was disgorged 2017.) Didier Depond: ‘this vintage was pure light’. Picked from 30 August.
Transparency with a really round undertow. No longer the piercing quality of Le Mesnil but something much more accommodating. Tight bead and intricate crochet work but with lift and great freshness.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“The 2007 Salon (Edition 2019) is just starting to show the first signs of aromatic development and nuance, as well as a touch more body than it did upon release. Rich, creamy and ample, with stunning textural richness and freshness, the 2007 is incredibly expressive today, certainly much more so than it was upon release. The 2007 is a dark horse Salon that keeps getting better with time. This is a fabulous showing. Dosage is 6 grams per liter. Disgorged: January, 2019. ”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“ The 2007 Salon is gorgeous. Weightless, delicate and understated, the 2007 is all class. Today, the 2007 reminds me of the 2004 in its bright, citrus and floral-infused profile, but with a bit more creaminess, mid-palate depth and softer contours, all of which will make the 2007 easy to drink with minimal cellaring. Next to the 2006, the 2007 is quite a bit fresher and more delineated, with none of exuberance, power of tropically-leaning overtones found in its younger sibling. At this stage, the 2007 is a bit inward and closed in on itself. Then again, it is Salon. This is another terrific showing from Salon and the team headed by President Didier Depond. Dosage is 5 grams per liter.”
96/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil is showing very well, unwinding in the glass with scents of citrus pith, smoke, crisp green apple, Anjou pear, white flowers and subtle hints of fresh herbs. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and incisive, it's fine-boned and precise, with a bright spine of acidity, an elegantly fleshy core of fruit and a pretty, pinpoint mousse. Like the other vintages of Salon reviewed here, this bottle was disgorged in January 2019.”
“Disgorged January (‘Edition’) 2019. Dosage 5 g/l. (First release was disgorged 2017.) Didier Depond: ‘this vintage was pure light’. Picked from 30 August.
Transparency with a really round undertow. No longer the piercing quality of Le Mesnil but something much more accommodating. Tight bead and intricate crochet work but with lift and great freshness.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“The 2007 Salon (Edition 2019) is just starting to show the first signs of aromatic development and nuance, as well as a touch more body than it did upon release. Rich, creamy and ample, with stunning textural richness and freshness, the 2007 is incredibly expressive today, certainly much more so than it was upon release. The 2007 is a dark horse Salon that keeps getting better with time. This is a fabulous showing. Dosage is 6 grams per liter. Disgorged: January, 2019. ”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“ The 2007 Salon is gorgeous. Weightless, delicate and understated, the 2007 is all class. Today, the 2007 reminds me of the 2004 in its bright, citrus and floral-infused profile, but with a bit more creaminess, mid-palate depth and softer contours, all of which will make the 2007 easy to drink with minimal cellaring. Next to the 2006, the 2007 is quite a bit fresher and more delineated, with none of exuberance, power of tropically-leaning overtones found in its younger sibling. At this stage, the 2007 is a bit inward and closed in on itself. Then again, it is Salon. This is another terrific showing from Salon and the team headed by President Didier Depond. Dosage is 5 grams per liter.”
96/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil is showing very well, unwinding in the glass with scents of citrus pith, smoke, crisp green apple, Anjou pear, white flowers and subtle hints of fresh herbs. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and incisive, it's fine-boned and precise, with a bright spine of acidity, an elegantly fleshy core of fruit and a pretty, pinpoint mousse. Like the other vintages of Salon reviewed here, this bottle was disgorged in January 2019.”
“The 1996 Salon is just dazzling. It needs a good bit of air to fully open up, but the 1996 Salon is simply a mesmerizing Champagne that sizzles with energy, cut and total precision. A second bottle later in the week was every bit as compelling. When the 1996 Salon is on, it is just about as great as Champagne gets. ”
More Reviews +
99/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“This bottle of the 1996 Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil Brut was drinking superbly and represents the apotheosis of Blanc de Blancs, unfurling over the course of three hours with a stunningly complex bouquet of citrus oil, confit lemon, dried white flowers and oyster shell, with hints of praline and pastry cream becoming more pronounced as the wine opens up in the glass. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, deep and multidimensional, defined by the incisive spine so typical of the vintage that, here, is cloaked in layers of crisp fleshy and chalky extract. The finish is long, penetrating and saline. Unfortunately, since the 1996 Salon has been traded so zealously over the last decade, finding a bottle that hasn't travelled too far can be a challenge. But from a perfectly stored bottle, this is just the beginning.”
94-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2012
“The combination of Le Mesnil-sur-Oger’s raw power, Salon’s inox-fermented non-maloed winemaking and the extremities of the 1996 vintage suggest a masochistic experience. But miraculously the result is one of all times finest Salons (given that you love the sensation of acidity, a prerequisite of any Salon fan). This is truly razor-shard and driven, aging painfully slow for the impatient. ”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2016
“The 1996 Salon is just beginning to enter the early part of its plateau of maturity. Time in bottle has softened some of the razor-sharp focus the 1996 had when it was first released, but all of the energy it had as a young Champagne remains. A host of candied lemon, almonds and wild flowers punctuate the sculpted, persistent finish. Readers who own the 1996 can look forward to another two decades or more of exceptional drinking. This is the ultimate expression of Champagne as wine.”
“Disgorged in January 2019 with six grams per liter dosage, Salon's 2008 Brut Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil is a striking wine, unwinding in the glass with scents of citrus oil, fresh bread, crisp green apple, white flowers, smoke and oyster shell. Full-bodied, layered and incisive, it's deep and concentrated, with a tightly coiled core of fruit that's underpinned by a racy spine of acidity. Seamless and unerringly precise, it concludes with a long and penetratingly mineral finish. Immense though its potential for aging is, its intensity and balance make it pleasurable as well as persuasive, even today. Given the eye-watering price of this magnum-only release, I was determined to hold the wine to the highest possible standards, but it surpasses even the prodigious 1996 and surely ranks as the finest Salon since at least the 1970s. In short, this is a Blanc de Blancs that admits no argument.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Magnum. Disgorged (‘Edition’) January 2019. Just 8,000 magnums and no bottles produced. (Usually 60,000 bottles!) Didier Depond tasted the grapes with Chef de Cave Michel Fauconnet. Both of them decided that only magnums should be made because the concentration is so great. Like 1982. Dosage 6.2 g/l. Didier Depond calls 2008 ‘the dream vintage’. Picked from 17 September.
Big bubbles. Strong hedgerow aromas. Very ‘cool’ impression. Very intense and persistent. Complex and lacy. Filigree texture. Really quite open for a magnum - particularly for Salon. Wonderful length. Certainly a magical wine, likely to feed a frenzy among (well-heeled) investors.”
100/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jun 2006
“I knew it the moment I tasted it. The 2008 Cuvée S, bottled only in magnum, is perfect. I can ask nothing more. Citrus, sage, mint, white pepper, crushed rocks and oyster shells explode onto the palate. Complex and nuanced, with tons of saline intensity, the 2008 is an archetype. A truly great vintage for one of the most important wines in Champagne. Readers lucky to own it are in for an unforgettable experience. Production is just 8,000 magnums, about a third of a normal year in terms of overall volume. ”
20/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2020
“100% CH | Lees Ageing: 10 Years | Disgorged: January 2019 | Dosage: 6.2 g/l | Post-Disgorgement Ageing: 5 Months
A hint of reduction and that smoky charm, there is an abundance of ripe fruit, very generous ripe apples and then you get hints of ripeness with a faint trace of tropical fruits. The magnum has great texture, precision and ripeness. For a recent disgorgement this is currently very generous, so expect it to shine for a year and no doubt close down tight for many years after. Has freshness, power, elegance and a real lightness; it plays on your palate, very fine. Drink now but will be better in at least ten years and last for many decades.”
“This high-yielding year produced generous amounts of Les Robarts. Deep and pronounced nose on the mineral and spicy side. The fruitiness stays a little closed for the time being, promising longevity. So much concentration on the rich and textured palate. Yet the acid line cuts through it and leads the wine to its long, dry, chalky-saline finish. ”
More Reviews +
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2026
“The 2018 Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cramant Les Robarts, disgorged in July 2024 with a dosage of three grams per liter, continues to show superbly and retains considerable reserve, revealing a deep, layered bouquet of orange oil, dried flowers, pear and peach, mingled with nuances of toasted bread and iodine. On the palate, it is full-bodied, open-knit and textural, laden with racy acidity and a pure core of fruit, delivering an energy and incisiveness rare in the vintage and culminating in a long, saline finish. It is a terrific wine, even if it does not quite attain the concentration of the 2019.”
“The 2017 Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cramant Les Robarts, disgorged in June 2023 with a dosage of three grams per liter, is more brooding and darker in profile, offering aromas of beeswax, dried white flowers and orange peel mingled with rye bread and a faint hint of youthful reduction. On the palate, it is full-bodied and hugely concentrated, layered and expansive, built around a deep core of fruit and concluding in a resonant, chalky finish. Suenen recalls 2017 as a difficult vintage in which to ripen grapes properly, with fruit harvested at 10.8% potential alcohol (reaching 12.2% after the second fermentation)—a challenge he would not encounter again in 2018 and certainly not in 2019.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Dec 2024
“A bright yellow/silver color, the 2017 Champagne Les Robarts Cramant Extra Brut is always a personal favorite along with the Colluette. Offering notes of peach blossoms, dewy fresh stones, and fresh flowers, the palate is crystalline, pure, and fresh all the way through, with fantastic electric energy, a spritely, refined mousse, and a pure, chalky texture. This really makes the village shine and is a great expression in this vintage.”
95/100
Decanter,
Decanter.com,
Dec 2024
“This sought-after cuvée may be the most refined and energetic of Aurélien Suenen’s wines from the northern Côte, focusing on a single plot of Chardonnay planted on fine vermiculite clay over belemnite chalk situated on the border between Avize and Cramant. With a stunningly bright, fluid energy running through roasted citrus and groundnut richness derived from subtle oak fermentation, this is a tremendously elegant Chardonnay-driven Champagne full of chalky crunch and delicate, dancing detail.”
“The most tightly wound of the four lieux-dits is the 2018 Extra-Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Oiry La Cocluette. Sourced from a parcel planted in 1925 and exposed 70% north (with the remaining 30% facing south), it’s a site where Suenen has recently raised the trellising to 1.7 meters, rolling up the canopies without trimming the apex to provide shade for grapes and soil and benefit from higher maturity of fruit. Vinified in seven-hectoliter concrete egg and used six-hectoliter barrel from Stockinger, it was disgorged in July 2024 with four grams per liter dosage.
This year, it’s a great success, combining the tension informed by the the site with expressiveness of the vintage. Offering aromas of lemon zest, oyster shell and dried white flowers, it’s medium-bodied, structured around mouthwatering acidity and vivid chalkiness, concluding with a pure, intensely mineral finish. A harmonious, elegant wine, demonstrating understated complexity, it does not possess any of the 2018 extremes. I can’t wait to see what Suenen can do with the 2019.”
“75cl - This brand new wine follows the Charles Heidsieck non-vintage blanc de blancs tradition that was initiated back in 1947. The aimed style is sumptuous as one can expect from the house but cellar master Cyril Brun has also wanted to highlight freshness of youth in it to make a clear difference to age-mellowed and concentrated the Blanc des Millénaires. Pure and pristinely fruity, coffee and cream laden nose with ample lemony floral fruitiness with a touch of pepper. The palate expresses more minerality and salinity increasing towards the back palate. The wine hides its 10g/l dosage feeling perfectly balanced and fresh, even a little tight at this point. Stunningly creamy texture with minuscule gently bubbles waking up the palate. Long, driven palate with impeccable precision.
”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Launched in 2018. Based on 2012. 25% Reserve and aged 5–6 years on lees. Mainly Vertus and Oger. Renewal of what they did before Remy Cointreau took over the company. Very small volume: 20,000 bottles. Now available in magnum.
Pretty powerful nose. Putty nose and then quite rich on the palate. Really firm and fine. Broader than the average blanc de blancs but very well made and pleasing. Ambitious.”
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Based on the 2012 vintage and disgorged in 2019, Heidsieck's NV Blanc de Blancs continues to show nicely, exhibiting aromas of lemon oil, dried white flowers, green apple and walnuts. It's medium to full-bodied, taut and chiseled. If anything it exhibits a more reserved, austere profile than it did last year. Based on this showing, it's evolving more slowly than I anticipated, and I'd be inclined to counsel readers to wait another year or two before popping corks.”
“Disgorged in 2022, the latest release of the Charles Heidsieck NV Blanc de Blancs is elaborated with 30% of reserve wines, of which 10% to 12% are aged in old barrels. It has a captivating bouquet with aromas of honeysuckle, lemon oil, citrus, peach, tangerine and delicate hints of pastry, followed by a medium to full-bodied, round and creamy, layered and elegant palate that finishes with chalky and brioche notes. A little time in the cellar will be more than profitable.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“100% Chardonnay from the Côte des Blancs, Montagne de Reims and Montgueux. The 2016 base is refined and persistent, showing tart mirabelle plum and citrus confit on one hand, but also a more extroverted green mango/lime side. An invigorating, marine/salt-spray finish. The volume, the padding of pastry and nougat, will show with more time on cork – I would give this at least 2 years on cork.”
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Base 2016 | Pale lemon in colour, with an instantly charming nose that has a layered sweet toastiness. There are pristine vanilla-laden aromas, with orchard fruit, lemon, lime and even tropical nuances. The palate is youthful with vibrancy yet also age-mellowed, with reserve-wine richness contributing velvety sensations. This is a beautiful recipe, in which the steely, mineral wines of the Côte des Blancs gain gravitas from spicy Montgueux Chardonnay and tropical tones from Villers-Marmery and Trépail on the Montagne de Reims. This Mis en Cave 2017 is based largely on 2016 fruit and has a particularly pure and perky fruitiness. Disgorged 2021; dosage 10g/l”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Launched in 2018. Based on 2012. 25% Reserve and aged 5–6 years on lees. Mainly Vertus and Oger. Renewal of what they did before Remy Cointreau took over the company. Very small volume: 20,000 bottles. Now available in magnum.
Pretty powerful nose. Putty nose and then quite rich on the palate. Really firm and fine. Broader than the average blanc de blancs but very well made and pleasing. Ambitious.”
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Based on the 2012 vintage and disgorged in 2019, Heidsieck's NV Blanc de Blancs continues to show nicely, exhibiting aromas of lemon oil, dried white flowers, green apple and walnuts. It's medium to full-bodied, taut and chiseled. If anything it exhibits a more reserved, austere profile than it did last year. Based on this showing, it's evolving more slowly than I anticipated, and I'd be inclined to counsel readers to wait another year or two before popping corks.”
91/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2017 vintage, complemented by some 25% reserve wines, Heidsieck's new NV Blanc de Blancs was disgorged in January 2021 with only two grams per liter dosage. Sourced from the Côte de Blancs, along with Montgueux (historically a stalking ground for this house), Villers-Marmery and the Sézannais, it offers up aromas of crisp orchard fruit, white flowers and freshly baked bread, followed by a medium to full-bodied, ample and lively palate that's bright and layered, concluding with a chalky finish.”
92/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“Base 2016 | Attractive white-flower and ripe-lemon aromas are married to an elegant, medium-bodied palate, where the creaminess is neatly underlined by the mousse, the lively acidity making the chalky and saline finish very clean and straight.
”
“The NV Brut Blanc de Blancs, a pure Chardonnay from the Côte des Blancs Montagne de Reims and Montgueux, spent just over two years on lees. Youthful verve on the nose sprays with ripe Amalfi lemon and an overtone of ozone. The palate is light, bright and sprightly, alive with frothy smooth foam that underlines the wine's youthfulness even more. A perfect apero style with a lip-smacking finish. Dosage is 10 grams per liter. (Lot 230748-3170) - Anne Krebiehl MW”
More Reviews +
90/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Disgorged with eight grams per liter, Heidsieck's NV Blanc de Blancs reveals a delicately spicy bouquet of pastry, butter, walnuts, tangerine, lemon oil, honeysuckle and white fruits. Medium to full-bodied, enrobing and charming, it's satiny and elegant with a delicate mousse and a long, ethereal and citrusy finish. Crafted with 30% vins de réserve.”
“The 2017 harvest was super challenging for red grapes, yet for Chardonnay when I tasted them as vins clairs in spring 2018 surprised by the abundance of fruit, hints of tropical, freshness from acidity and great purity. BdM 2017 I tasted in Lehmann Synergy 60cl and it really brought forward the recent disgorgement; bundles of citrus, ripe lemon, grapefruit and hints of lychee all wrapped around a pronounced chalky core. The palate brings more citrus forward, some pithy grapefruit and hints of fresh pineapple. No shortage of freshness and a bundle of salinity give this a great finish. Super long flavours showing well for a champagne 7 months post disgorgement. FYI: 30% of the grapes are from Mesnil-sur-Oger and just over 20% from Vertus, which helps explain the mineral core of Mesnil and richness from Vertus.” Drinks well now, will benefit from at least 5 years ageing.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“Anchored in Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Vertus and complemented by fruit from Avize, Oger and Chouilly, the 2017 Blanc de Blancs Blanc des Millénaires—disgorged in July 2025 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—has turned out very well. It wafts from the glass with aromas of orange oil, dried flowers and roasted cacao bean, mingled with nuances of Sichuan pepper and a top note of burnt buttered toast. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, ample and textural, with a deep core of fruit and vibrant acidity that carries through a long, chalky finish. Darker and more brooding than its predecessor, it is also slightly more structured and promises to deliver considerable pleasure right out of the gate. In a vintage that, to put it mildly, did not make life easy in the vineyards, this represents a notable success.”
“Three Charles Heidsieck chefs de caves have contributed to this cuvée’s glories. The late Thierry Roset made the base wines, but Cyril Brun finalized the blend after Thierry’s unexpected passing. Eight years later, Elise Losfelt replaced Cyril, and she gave the final touches to the cuvée by mastering the dosage. Avize, Cramant, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger and Vertus make up this classic Côte des Blancs blend. There is a refined touch of salted caramel to the lemon/white-peach nose, which has an emerging toastiness. Beautifully airy on the lacy palate. This is an elegant Blanc des Millénaires, though highly youthful for the time being. If you are after Charles Heidsieck’s toasty extravaganza, leave it for several years. Disgorged: 2023; Dosage: 9g/l”
More Reviews +
95/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2024
“The only Blanc des Millénaires made during Thierry Roset's brief tenure as cellar master of Charles Heidsieck before his untimely death after the 2014 harvest. The wine was blended by Cyril Brun. It has seen less time on lees than the previous 2007 and 2006 wines – between eight and nine years rather than 12 – but the decision feels apt for this beautifully delicate, bright and serene edition of one of Champagne's top, if lesser-known, prestige Blanc de Blancs, emphasising purity over creamy richness. There are plenty of ripe aromatics, with fuzzy fragrant apricots, mandarin and even some fresh mango playing with hazelnut and coffee macaron complexity just starting to fire up. There's a quiet, calm insistence to the palate, more similar to the 2004 than the tension and drama of the 2007 or the generosity of the 2006. It seems set to be one of the vintage's top performers. Chardonnay from Cramant, Avize, Oger, Le-Mesnil-sur-Oger and Vertus, entirely vinified in stainless steel with full malolactic fermentation. Dosage: 9g/L.”
18.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“The aromatics leap out the glass, you see the core of citrus fruit plus tropical notes, grilled pineapple, guava, tangerine orange and the palate has the broadening effect from 8 years lees ageing and the fruit just expands further on the palate. You feel the Cote des Blancs minerality and bright acidities typical of the year, leaving you a tingle of salinity on the finish. There is real purity here, bright fruit and that lightness of touch of the chalk rich vineyards. This is the 8th release since the first 1983 vintage and there is no doubt this is by far the best. Purity, density, freshness and delightful lightness.”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“The eighth rendition of this cuvée, the 2014 Brut Blanc de Blancs Blanc des Millénaires evokes a complex, sweet bouquet of candied lemon, confit citrus, blanched almonds, brioche, honeycomb and ripe orchard fruits. Full-bodied, broad-shouldered and ample, it features a velvety attack and a vinous, fleshy core of fruit, with a textural mid-palate that leads to a spicy, long and delicate finish. This is a stunning new release of this cuvée, showcasing its depth and elegance.”
19.5+/20
Matthew Jukes,
MatthewJukes.com,
Mar 2024
“2014 Blanc des Millénaires is only the 8th vintage of this wine released since the inaugural wine in 1983. Let’s not beat around the bush – it is a spectacular Champagne... This is a raspingly refreshing wine. It is so precision-cut you might want to wear gloves. There is no doubt this unnervingly keen creation is not one for beginners. And if you feel a tear fighting to set free from a loose duct, just let it go. This wine is all about emotion and you must be leaden-hearted for it not to move you profoundly with its laser-sighted flavours and extraordinary tension. Flavour-wise it is incredible how so much direction and decisiveness can emerge from such a seemingly demure wine. Approaching its tenth birthday, and with eight of these years spent on its lees, it seems like this wine has been chiselled out of a gleamingly white chalk sarcophagus as it sits naked in the glass, and there is so much potential here it takes the breath away... This is a landmark vintage for Heidsieck’s incredible Chardonnay and while it is straight-jacketed, brutally honest, and epically long, there are just enough white florals, tender sablé tones and dramatic citrus zestiness, to signal that this wine will be nothing short of era-defining given time.”
95/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Mar 2024
“Complex biscuity, yeasty undertones to this blanc de blancs, along with crushed almonds, pears and apples. It’s fresh and beautifully integrated on the palate with silky and elegant layers, fine bubbles and attractive, lingering pastry character.”
“The 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Blanc des Millénaires is the seventh opus of this vintage after the 1983, 1985, 1990, 1995, 2004 and 2006 vintages. This 100% Chardonnay exhales aromas of candied lemon, lemon oil, spring flowers, ripe orchard fruits and hints of pastry. The palate is coated and fleshy, rich and dense, with racy acids and a chalky, penetrating finish. Hide bottles for seven to eight years.”
More Reviews +
18+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
Thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2022
“It was wonderful to taste the new vintage of Charles Heidsieck Blanc des Millénaires Blanc de Blancs 2007 with Chef de Cave Cyril Brun - 2007 was a fabulous year for Chardonnay, cooler than its predecessor and all the Côte des Blancs Chardonnay have a high salinity. For Cyril it’s most like 1983: there’s great precision on the aromatics, there’s fruit, super pure rich and ripe lemon with just a hint of some yellow tropical fruits. The palate has power and great freshness as the acid and salinity play on your palate, with hints of Chardonnay creaminess just emerging. There’s a textural roundness to the 2007 and yet leaves your palate fresh, utterly delicious. Drink now & well cellared to 2040”
95/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“100% Chardonnay from Avize, Cramant, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger and Vertus. The new Blanc des Millénaires presents the very best of the 2007 vintage, one that shows an intense, bristling kind of energy for Chardonnay. A compressed, tight core of chalky, pure flavours – green plum, charred peel, white flowers – with a lick of sea salt. Tasted again in November 2022, this cuvée showed richer sourdough and butter profile, suggesting it is opening up fairly obligingly. Much more focus than the 2006, yet more attitude than the serenely attractive 2004.”
98/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Mar 2022
“The nose is very subtle, has glimpses of oyster shell and lemon. The palate is taut, bright, super-fresh, linear, lemony and just incredibly youthful. There is a vein on ripe, lemony freshness that pervades this wine, that sets the tone, that defines its character. This is intense, insistent, urgent, yet also gentle and smooth with very fine mousse. A wonderful and most compelling personality. Exquisite. The finish is a serene stretch of lemony, chalky, profound freshness. Drink now or keep. Will evolve.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2022
“So densely packed on the nose. Explodes in the mouth but not with ersatz frothiness, with pure flavour and refreshment. Amazing it's so youthful while it's 15 years old! Lacy and built from the ground up. I wonder whether it will last as long as the 1995! Drink 2022 – 2030
”
96/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“Intense oyster-shell and candied-lemon aromas pull you into this very elegant champagne, which is so precise on the sleek and focused palate with a finish of crystalline purity and brightness. Still really youthful, thanks to the uplifting freshness! A Blanc de Blancs from 5 top Crus in the Côte des Blancs.”
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Aug 2022
“Cyril Brun considers the 2007 vintage more interesting for Chardonnay than 2008, and Charles Heidsieck's 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Blanc des Millénaires is certainly a compelling wine. Unwinding in the glass with scents of crisp stone fruits, honeycomb, buttered pastry, yellow apples, pear and freshly baked bread, it's full-bodied, ample and seamless, with a concentrated core of fruit and a chiselled, racy profile. Combining generosity and tension, it's a terrific new release.”
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“Revisiting the 2007 Blanc de Blancs Blanc des Millénaires, disgorged in 2023 with a dosage of 10 grams per liter, I arrive at the same conclusion as before—it is a tauter, leaner rendition, a quality that becomes especially apparent when tasted alongside the excellent 2017. The wine wafts from the glass with aromas of lemon confit, praline and roasted cacao bean, mingled with notes of quince and spice. On the palate, it is medium-bodied and racy, with a tauter musculature than some of the finest renditions of this cuvée, prompting me to continue questioning whether it possesses sufficient structure for proper aging.”
96/100
Michael Hill Smith MW,
Decanter.com,
Jan 2023
“Intense aromas of candied citrus, grapefruit juice and lemon peel. Incredibly youthful for its age, with a chalky minerality and richness on the palate. A finely built 100% Chardonnay with very discreet dosage, flinty acidity and an overall balance suggestive of a grande marque. It has great sophistication and poise.”
“The sixth creation of Blanc des Millénaires combines fruit from four grand cru villages (Oger, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Cramant and Avize) with Chardoonnay from the premier cru of Vertus. True to the sunny and warm year 2006, the wine comes with deep golden hued colour already upon launch. The nose is distinctly tropical with Charles Heidsieck’s hallmark toastiness emerging quickly in the glass. Beautiful coffee tones alongside candied lemon, baked pineapple and complex floral tones. The fruitiness is laudably clean and bright. The palate is round but soon after the initial feeling of richness, the wine’s minerality and high acidity kick in. The finish turns out to be long, pure and seemingly dry. An instantly open and generous Blanc des Millénaires with more complexity arising over time. ”
More Reviews +
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2020
“Recently disgorged with seven grams per liter dosage, the 2006 Brut Blanc de Blancs Blanc des Millénaires is expressive and charming, in keeping with the sunny, demonstrative style of the vintage. Offering up aromas of toasted brioche, honeycomb, yellow apples and preserved citrus, it's full-bodied, fleshy and textural, with a rich core of fruit, ripe acids and an attractive pinpoint mousse. It's already drinking well, and I'd be inclined to approach it sooner than the more tightly wound 2004 rendition.”
“The one wine poured solo rather than one of a pair made up of 2002 and 2004 in this comparative tasting, so not really blind. Mytik cork. Not the tensest of these champagnes but beautifully balanced. Super-pleasant with everything in place. Great confidence. A good follow up to the copious 1995?”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2018
“Grand cru vineyards: Avize, Cramant, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oger. Premier cru: Vertus. 100% Chardonnay. 11.5 years' ageing on lees. Disgorged November 2016. Dosage 9 g/l. Mytik Diam technological cork.
Tasted blind. A distinctive floral note on the nose and then very playful. A broad aromatic attack, some delicacy and rather more loosely textured than some.
Drink 2015-2023”
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Glossy gold toned colour. Full-on creamy nose with rapidly emerging toastiness, ground coffee tones and pristine white fruit layers. A fine combination of fresh and dried fruit and yeast-complexed aromas. The palate is at the same time linear and driven but also wonderfully sumptuous with viscous texture bringing on seductive roundness. There is tension and feisty aciditybut in the background of the ever-increasing generosity. Between January and March 2018 the wine had opened up significantly started to gain Charles’s hallmark generosity. Hugely promising and already delivering. November 2016 disgorgement tasted, 9g/l dosage. ”
18+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Dec 2025
“This was part of a large tasting of 16 CH champagnes from the 60's to the early 2000's in December 2025. The champagne is only slowly ageing, I taste it at least once a year and it is till energetic and vibrant full of citrus and just starting to go a little apple pastry like. I think this will age as well as the 1995 has done. The palate is showing more of the tropical with banana and charred pineapple, while retaining a chalky core. Good length and nothing aromatically that shouldn't be here which is encouraging for the long term. Drink Now to 2035+”
“Savoury, tight bead with some hint of blackcurrants(!), and a little richness and lemon sherbet on the long finish. Definitely not an austere grower's champagne! Quite long and flattering. Hint of cordite. Sweeter than average for a top champagne but it really builds on the end. ”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“With the slight dominance of PN in the blend you see those rich yellow stone fruit like apricot and peach and behind this those CH fruits, lemon, grapefruit and hints or charred pineapple add depth to the palate. Key components like Chardonnay from Trigny and Pinot Noir from the cooler growing village of Tauxières bring that freshness from acidity to a year that was otherwise hot, producing lower acidity champagnes. Great richness and texture to the palate give us confidence this will be age worthy. Drink now to 2034”
Matthew Jukes,
MatthewJukes.com,
Mar 2025
“During the course of this year, I predict only a handful Champagne releases will be genuinely eye-catching – those that are of sufficient ‘must-buy status’ to make it into my Finest Fifty round-up at Christmas. These are two of them! There is no doubt that these two 2018s are spectacular. The white wine is truly sensational, and you can open it now without worrying about a knock on the door from the wine police. That said, it will age for a decade with ease, too. The elegance and magnetism of white flowers and delicate orchard fruit on the nose and palate are magnificent. There is infinite detail here, and gentle, almost electrical pulses of teasing acidity maintain a heightened level of drama throughout. This is a thrillingly beautiful wine. The yin and yang of the 2018 Charles Heidsieck is fascinating, and you need both in your collection to find completeness.”
“Ten villages contributed grapes to this vintage cuvée in 2013: Oger, Vertus, Chouilly, Cuis, Verzy, Aÿ, Ludes, Ambonnay, Tauxières and Avenay. The colour is still youthfully lemony, whereas the nose already shows toasty charms. The wine's bright, vibrant fruitiness is building up exotic and spicy notes, as well as coffee and cream layers. The palate comes with fine precision in perfect purity. There is a brilliance to the wine on the lacy, refined palate. Very youthful still, this vintage seems to be ageing very slowly and gracefully, adding to its rich and toasty deliciousness.”
More Reviews +
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2023
“Charles Heidsieck’s racy 2013 vintage is a blend of ten Grands and Premiers Crus: Oger, Vertus, Chouilly, Cuis, Verzy, Aÿ, Ludes, Ambonnay, Tauxières and Avenay-Val d’Or. Usually appreciated for the richness and toast-enriched complexity of its Vintage cuvées, Charles Heidsieck 2013 plays on totally different assets, cool refinement and silky linearity. Despite excellent ripeness of the grapes, the October harvest brought about a tight acid line and fine aromatic restraint to it. Toastiness is subtle for the time being, but remarkably elegant, perfectly lining the sweet orchard fruit profile. Its best quality is the prism like radiance and purity of fruit. Showing highly youthful, this wine promises to be slowly but gracefully ageing. Suitably dosed at 9g/l.”
93/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2023
“The bouquet of the 2013 Brut Millésimé is compellingly fresh and minty, complicated by notes of white fruit—notably pear and apple—citrus and gentle spices, as well as a light touch of smoke. With aeration, elegant pastry notes come to the fore. On the palate, this is a structured, tension-filled but airborne Champagne with racy acidity, fleshy and charming texture and a long, penetrating finish. It should age well over the next eight to 10 years. Disgorged in 2022 with nine grams per liter, this is a blend of 57% Pinot Noir and 43% Chardonnay.”
94/100
Stuart Pigott,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“A very striking nose with Reine Claude plums, old-fashioned apple varieties and some Nordic herbs. Structured and crisp with a very firm core, the finish driving and full of energy. Rich long finish with a chalky core. 60% pinot noir and 40% chardonnay, the make up of the blend very unconventional for this house.”
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2013 year really suits Charles, it has the richness of the Maison mixed with fruit from the cool summer it adds a real sophisticated touch. Bundles of lemon, lime, grapefruit, twist of apricot and hints or clementines; the lees impact really build the texture, a delight and coming across today as a champagne that will excel even more with food.”
“60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, The 2012 vintage has it all. Intensity of dried stone fruit, fireworks of smoky charred yuzu/confit citrus, richness of coffee cream and papaya. Immense succulence and perfectly-pitched intensity, carried on a wave of freshness and mineral energy. Like many 2012s this is irresistible right now, but bound to improve, even if it is not the most tense or restrained style.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Both intense and discreet. Extremely tightly woven. Not as dry as some but certainly not simple. Tastes more youthful than many 2012s. Subtle and not flamboyant. You feel you could drink this in quantity!”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“There is fruity power beyond the reserved nose. This is a complex blend from 10 villages in which toasty coffee notes meet hay, wax, yellow apple and pear-pie notes. There is something appealingly crystalline about the fruit, but the lemony backbone of tightness seems a little austere on the palate. Structured and slowly ageing, this will rewards one's patience; however, it is currently missing some of the voluptuous sweet charm we are used to. Disgorged 2020; dosage 9.7g/l”
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2021
“Disgorged in 2019 with eight grams per liter dosage, the 2012 Brut Millésimé offers up aromas of crisp orchard fruit, white flowers and clear honey, complemented by hints of toasted bread, citrus zest and linden. Medium to full-bodied, elegantly fleshy and nicely concentrated, with lively acids and a pinpoint mousse, it's more generous and demonstrative than the 2008, but it will nonetheless reward a bit of bottle age.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Soon to be released in magnum, the 2012 Brut Millésimé continues to show well, delivering aromas of citrus zest, crisp orchard fruit, freshly baked bread, buttery pastry and beeswax and framed by a deft touch of smoky reduction. Medium to full-bodied, racy and chiselled, with fine depth at the core and a long, penetrating finish, this bottle was disgorged in summer 2021.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2020
“60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, from a season that until August was very challenging for a wide range of reasons. The wine has apparently gone down well enough in the UK to provoke a second order from importer Liberty Wines. They have shipped some to the US but there is still some 2008 to work its way through the distribution channel there. Cyril Brun sees 2012 as having the richness of 2006 and the austerity of 2008 and is very keen on the increasing levels of ‘noble bitterness’ on which he is banking to balance wines now that acid levels are plummeting in Champagne. It had six years on lees and was disgorged in May 2019. The back label promises it will drink well until 2035! This wine was made by his predecessor Thierry Roset (Brun joined in time for the 2015 vintage). He imagines that Roset deliberately chose some Pinot from north-facing vineyards on the Montagne de Reims to combat warmer summers. Dosage 8 g/l; experiments continue to show that a fairly high dosage suits the Charles Heidsieck house style.
A very savoury Charles Heidsieck champagne at the moment – extremely tight and youthful with some smoky reductive notes as well as one of lime cordial. Real undertow; an exciting combination of producer and vintage with real potential.”
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2020
“'A dangerously drinkable wine' according to chef de cave Cyril Brun, and I wouldn't contest that. I adore it for its inviting approachability, pure fruitiness, vibrancy and impeccable balance. The colour is intense with golden tones. The nose is not short of nuances: stunning smoky toastiness and rich biscuit notes are complemented by generosity of fresh and dried fruits ranging from apricots to tropical fruits and zesty lemony layers. It sits between reductive and oxidative styles, leaning safely towards the former. On the palate, the marriage of Charles’ hallmark velvety texture, the invigorating tension and the tiniest bubbles is disarming. Highly creamy and generous but ending on a fresh note of stylish bitterness at the back palate, probably partly due to the drier than usual style, dosed perfectly at 8g/l. A classic blend of 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay with Grand & Premier Cru sourcing from the Montagne de Reims and Côte de Blancs. The key villages are Aÿ, Oger, Vertus, Chouilly, Ludes and Cuis for Chardonnay and Ambonnay, Tauxieres and Avenay for Pinot Noir. ”
95/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“Very lemony (blossoms, zest and candied peel), with some red-berry and fresh tobacco-leaf notes. Impressive richness and concentration, the creaminess from lees beautifully matched by the fine mousse and mineral freshness. The latter also powers the structured and saline finish that makes a serious statement.
”
“60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, The 2012 vintage has it all. Intensity of dried stone fruit, fireworks of smoky charred yuzu/confit citrus, richness of coffee cream and papaya. Immense succulence and perfectly-pitched intensity, carried on a wave of freshness and mineral energy. Like many 2012s this is irresistible right now, but bound to improve, even if it is not the most tense or restrained style.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Both intense and discreet. Extremely tightly woven. Not as dry as some but certainly not simple. Tastes more youthful than many 2012s. Subtle and not flamboyant. You feel you could drink this in quantity!”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“There is fruity power beyond the reserved nose. This is a complex blend from 10 villages in which toasty coffee notes meet hay, wax, yellow apple and pear-pie notes. There is something appealingly crystalline about the fruit, but the lemony backbone of tightness seems a little austere on the palate. Structured and slowly ageing, this will rewards one's patience; however, it is currently missing some of the voluptuous sweet charm we are used to. Disgorged 2020; dosage 9.7g/l”
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2021
“Disgorged in 2019 with eight grams per liter dosage, the 2012 Brut Millésimé offers up aromas of crisp orchard fruit, white flowers and clear honey, complemented by hints of toasted bread, citrus zest and linden. Medium to full-bodied, elegantly fleshy and nicely concentrated, with lively acids and a pinpoint mousse, it's more generous and demonstrative than the 2008, but it will nonetheless reward a bit of bottle age.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Soon to be released in magnum, the 2012 Brut Millésimé continues to show well, delivering aromas of citrus zest, crisp orchard fruit, freshly baked bread, buttery pastry and beeswax and framed by a deft touch of smoky reduction. Medium to full-bodied, racy and chiselled, with fine depth at the core and a long, penetrating finish, this bottle was disgorged in summer 2021.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2020
“60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, from a season that until August was very challenging for a wide range of reasons. The wine has apparently gone down well enough in the UK to provoke a second order from importer Liberty Wines. They have shipped some to the US but there is still some 2008 to work its way through the distribution channel there. Cyril Brun sees 2012 as having the richness of 2006 and the austerity of 2008 and is very keen on the increasing levels of ‘noble bitterness’ on which he is banking to balance wines now that acid levels are plummeting in Champagne. It had six years on lees and was disgorged in May 2019. The back label promises it will drink well until 2035! This wine was made by his predecessor Thierry Roset (Brun joined in time for the 2015 vintage). He imagines that Roset deliberately chose some Pinot from north-facing vineyards on the Montagne de Reims to combat warmer summers. Dosage 8 g/l; experiments continue to show that a fairly high dosage suits the Charles Heidsieck house style.
A very savoury Charles Heidsieck champagne at the moment – extremely tight and youthful with some smoky reductive notes as well as one of lime cordial. Real undertow; an exciting combination of producer and vintage with real potential.”
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2020
“'A dangerously drinkable wine' according to chef de cave Cyril Brun, and I wouldn't contest that. I adore it for its inviting approachability, pure fruitiness, vibrancy and impeccable balance. The colour is intense with golden tones. The nose is not short of nuances: stunning smoky toastiness and rich biscuit notes are complemented by generosity of fresh and dried fruits ranging from apricots to tropical fruits and zesty lemony layers. It sits between reductive and oxidative styles, leaning safely towards the former. On the palate, the marriage of Charles’ hallmark velvety texture, the invigorating tension and the tiniest bubbles is disarming. Highly creamy and generous but ending on a fresh note of stylish bitterness at the back palate, probably partly due to the drier than usual style, dosed perfectly at 8g/l. A classic blend of 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay with Grand & Premier Cru sourcing from the Montagne de Reims and Côte de Blancs. The key villages are Aÿ, Oger, Vertus, Chouilly, Ludes and Cuis for Chardonnay and Ambonnay, Tauxieres and Avenay for Pinot Noir. ”
95/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“Very lemony (blossoms, zest and candied peel), with some red-berry and fresh tobacco-leaf notes. Impressive richness and concentration, the creaminess from lees beautifully matched by the fine mousse and mineral freshness. The latter also powers the structured and saline finish that makes a serious statement.
”
“The 2008 Brut Millésimé from Charles Hedsieck continues to perform superbly, opening in the glass with a youthfully reserved bouquet of pear, yellow apple, citrus oil, honeycomb, dried white flowers and warm biscuits. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, deep and incisive, with a racy spine of acidity, a pinpoint mousse, excellent concentration and a long, elegantly chalky finish. This 2008 is still several years from showing all its cards, but it is a brilliant Champagne in the making.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2019
“Dense nose and obvious evolution. More evolved in fact than many 2008s. Creamy rather than angular. Light toast. Lively but not as punchy as some other 2008s. ”
“Disgorged March 2017, embargoed until they sell in October 2017. They’ve done it the other way around from the vintage rosé releases. Cyril Brun thinks he would have released the 2006 before the 2005. But it had never been done… Dosage 10 g/l. Only grand cru and premier cru fruit. 61% Pinot Noir, 39% Chardonnay.
Quite deep gold. Quite creamy nose and round and quite rich on the palate. Welcoming with a candied-walnuts flavour. Lots of appeal, even if softer than some.”
More Reviews +
92-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Deep golden colour. Highly creamy nose with emerging toasty opulence. Full of luscious, ripe fruit. Opens beautifully in the glass. There is impressive generosity on the mouth-filling, oily palate, boosted by concentrated, age-mellowed fruitiness. Long, almost chewy but appropriately fresh finish. Finely balanced at 10g/l dosage. ”
“Disgorged March 2017, embargoed until they sell in October 2017. They’ve done it the other way around from the vintage rosé releases. Cyril Brun thinks he would have released the 2006 before the 2005. But it had never been done… Dosage 10 g/l. Only grand cru and premier cru fruit. 61% Pinot Noir, 39% Chardonnay.
Quite deep gold. Quite creamy nose and round and quite rich on the palate. Welcoming with a candied-walnuts flavour. Lots of appeal, even if softer than some.”
More Reviews +
92-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Deep golden colour. Highly creamy nose with emerging toasty opulence. Full of luscious, ripe fruit. Opens beautifully in the glass. There is impressive generosity on the mouth-filling, oily palate, boosted by concentrated, age-mellowed fruitiness. Long, almost chewy but appropriately fresh finish. Finely balanced at 10g/l dosage. ”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2019
“The 2006 Brut Millésimé spent nine years on the lees and was disgorged in 2017 with ten grams per liter dosage. The wine expresses the sunny vintage, exhibiting generous aromas of mirabelle plum, crisp yellow orchard fruit, confit citrus, toasted nuts and dried white flowers. On the palate, the wine is full-bodied, ample and mouthfilling, with a youthfully boisterous but elegant mousse, a fleshy core of fruit and a rich, expansive finish. This is a gourmand vintage of Heidsieck's vintage Brut, and it will be best enjoyed at table; it will age more on its concentration and extract than its acidity. The blend is a classic 59% Pinot Noir and 41% Chardonnay.”
“Disgorged 2016. Greenish gold. Intense and brooding with the merest hint of coconut (apparently a Charles Heidsieck trait). Very tense but rich and dense too. Dry finish. Would ideally be released now but in fact it’s coming to the end of supply. Should perhaps have been held back?
Drink 2017-2027”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2017
“This seems to have been around a long time! Deep gold. Very fine persistent bead. Lots of autolysis and substance on the nose. Real lift on the finish. This tastes like wine, with all its complexity, rather than a constructed champagne. Still quite a bit of grip on the end. Very satisfying indeed.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2015
“The nose is surprisingly reminiscent of the Bollinger 2005 tasted immediately before. Solid and complex with a wild floral note. Bone dry and with a bit more focus and lift than the Bollinger.”
93+/100-
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“The 2005 Vintage Brut – a classic mix of Pinot Noir and Chardonnay – is a very ripe and concentrated Champagne with a bit of bitterness in the finish. "2005 was austere as a young wine, but since 2015, it shows very well and promises a very good aging potential," finds chef de cave Régis Camus. The wine opens deep, pure and fresh on the nose, with very clear white fruit aromas, spiced bread and a very clear definition. Light, fresh and finesse-full on the silky-textured palate, but also round and intense, this is a very elegant and refined vintage Champagne. It has a pure and fresh finish, and a long and intense aftertaste.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“The 2005 Brut Vintage is an excellent choice for drinking now and over the next few years. Brioche, pastry, baked apple and apricot are some of the notes that flesh out in the glass. Supple, expressive and inviting, the 2005 offers lovely balance, especially for the year. Warm, toasty notes meld into the resonant, enveloping finish. This is quite lovely. Disgorged: May 6, 2014.”
95/100
Roger Voss,
winemag.com,
Dec 2014
“Still very young, this holds great potential. Rich, full-bodied and densely structured, it is a wine first, sparkling second. Ripe apple and peach flavors partner with a strongly mineral texture.”
94/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“Striking nose of candied orange, dipped in bitter chocolate and tobacco leaf. Powerful and mouth-filling, with impressive textural richness. Now at its best, the dry finish fully mature, but complex and spicy.”
“This was recently tasted in jeroboam only. Deep golden colour. Rich honeyed nose with roast coffee, vanilla and fudge. Aged but perfectly healthily so. Concentrated, round velvety palate with still plenty of fruity length. Long, winey, firm finish. Such a pleasurable gastronomic wine today, the essence of Charles. ”
“Deep, mature golden colour. Slightly mushroomy but otherwise healthy coffee-toned rich, sweet nose. Fresh vibrant palate where the fruitiness is fading but there is still plenty left. A mature wine showing ageing depths. Long with dried fruit profile. ”
More Reviews +
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2024
“I am always wowed by champagnes from this vintage, they for sure have longevity as this bottle, like most, is ageing at a very slow pace. You can take a sip and the fruits are a blend of zippy citrus and seductive bitter orange and hint of buttery richness. The palate shows such lightness and velvety pleasure. Amazing champagne, with a decade + ahead. 19/20”
“Deep, mature golden colour. Slightly mushroomy but otherwise healthy coffee-toned rich, sweet nose. Fresh vibrant palate where the fruitiness is fading but there is still plenty left. A mature wine showing ageing depths. Long with dried fruit profile. ”
More Reviews +
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2024
“I am always wowed by champagnes from this vintage, they for sure have longevity as this bottle, like most, is ageing at a very slow pace. You can take a sip and the fruits are a blend of zippy citrus and seductive bitter orange and hint of buttery richness. The palate shows such lightness and velvety pleasure. Amazing champagne, with a decade + ahead. 19/20”
“This 2016 based Brut Réserve is the first release to include a small proportion of oak-vinified wines. The proportion of reserve wine has crept up to 46%. Its softly and deeply fruity nose comes with refined, subtle toastiness and sweet coconut, vanilla and candied fruit aromas. There is still tightness on the fresh and vivacious lemony palate that harnesses both power and richness, but its best feature is the already caressingly smooth texture.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Based on the 2016 vintage. 40% Pinot Noir, 19% Pinot Meunier, 41% Chardonnay. Dosage 10 g/l. This is the first MEC that has some oak influence: 6% barrel-aged for texture. 46% reserve wine, the oldest is Cramant 1996. Average age of reserve wines is 10 years. Disgorged January 2020 and the first vintage to be bottled using the jetting technique and Diam Mytik closure. Full malo as on all these wines, though current winemaker Cyril Brun is keeping some no-malo reserve wines as a weapon against climate change.
Subtle lemony nose. Stony, too, with the merest hint of white blossom, holds up really well in the glass. The smoky, reductive character is very slight but highlights the mineral/stony aspect. The citrus fruit and peel are ripe but there is masses of tension. The mousse is fine and gentle and also lasts really well in the glass. Becomes a little more toasty with air. Deep yet extremely refined, pulling in to a precise finish.”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2016
“Age-complexed, plentiful coffee and cream, vanilla-laden super toasty nose with dried fruit sweetness. Yeasty fullness charms on the mellow, complex and concentrated palate. Velvety without losing its vitality. Blockbuster style with immaculate freshness and seamlessness. Beautiful. A guaranteed crowd-pleaser and many-fold award-winner - Gold at the 2014 CSWWC.”
93/100
Tom Cannavan,
Wine-Pages.com,
Dec 2015
“For the fourth year myself and my colleagues presented our Ultimate Champagne Evening that truly was an embarrassment of riches with magnificent wines like the Krug Grand Cuvée, the Cristal 1995 and the Dom Pérignon P2-1998 just brilliant. But as each costs £100 or considerably more, I've plumped for my value for money star of the evening: with up to 40% of old reserve wines, the nose is mature and nutty, with so much toasty brioche richness and a fat, ripe nectarine fruit too, but then the palate shimmers with elegant and delightful acid balance. A great Champagne.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
WineSpectator.com,
Sep 2015
“A rich and toasty style that’s framed by vivid acidity, this shows lovely integration and an expressive palate of coffee liqueur, baked peach and roasted hazelnut.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
WineSpectator.com,
Sep 2015
“Rich and creamy, this harmonious Champagne is expressive, with brioche, crystallized honey, black currant and toasted marshmallow flavours, accented by hints of verbena, baked peach and chopped nut. Vibrant and focused through to the lasting, saline tinged finish.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“2010 base. Disgorged March 2017, to be released at the end of 2017. No 2009 base was made so they jumped to a 2010 base.
Extremely powerful nose powers out of the glass! A certain sweet creaminess on the nose. Really quite rich. Very much more rounded and welcoming than the blend based on 2008. Not that many houses have a seven-year-old NV on the market! Real bullseye for the Charles style. Tastes readier than the 2008 base – a real standout.
Drink 2017-2022”
88/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
May 2015
“From a hundred or so villages and 40% reserve wines Daniel Thibault makes one of the very best non-vintage champagnes produced by a large house. With a couple of years extra storage in the bottle it develops a high-class nose of toasted bread and a long complex fruitiness with a smooth aftertaste of toffee.”
89/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“Blended with a high percentage of matured reserve wines, this NV Brut Reserve is based on 2008 and was disgorged in 2014. Clear and complex on the nose, this is a round and elegant, highly finesse-full and lifted cuvée with a silky texture ,and delicate nougat and herbal flavors. The minty finish reveals a remarkably good structure.”
91/100
Josh Reynolds,
VinousMedia.com,
Jan 2015
“Light, bright orange. Intensely perfumed scents of raspberry, orange zest, white flowers and chalky minerals. Juicy and precise in the mouth, offering vibrant red berry and blood orange flavors and a complicating hint of brioche. The floral quality comes back strong on the very long, incisive finish, which features a subtle anise quality and smoky minerality.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2014
“Complex nose and very well balanced palate. Seems definitely ready.”
93/100
Roger Voss,
winemag.com,
Dec 2014
“Fresh and fruity while also rich and full in the mouth, this is a superbly balanced nonvintage selection. It is not quite dry with its apple and citrus fruits both given some softness. Disgorged in 2012, it already has two years bottle age that has rounded out the wine.”
90/100
Gilbert & Gaillard,
gilbertgaillard.com,
Oct 2012
“Beautiful light gold. Endearing nose intermixing fruity, brioche and biscuit notes. Fleshy, full and melted palate showing lovely refined bubbles and freshness. Closely-integrated and harmonious. A nicely crafted dry Champagne.”
86/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Oct 2008
“A fresh, floral wine with attractive pear and apple fruit, and an accessible personality”
“The NV Brut Réserve, a combination of more than 60 different crus and 150 wines, evokes aromas of brioche, pastry, ripe orchard fruits, beeswax and spices. Medium to full-bodied, enrobing and charming, it has a fleshy core of fruit, a pinpoint mousse and delicate acids, making it a charming, delicate Champagne. This blend consists of 40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay and 20% Pinot Meunier, with 50% vins de réserve, and was disgorged with a dosage of nine grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2025
“Based on the 2019 vintage and enriched by 50% reserve wines—stored in steel tanks and incorporating some 100 individual wines, averaging a decade in age—Charles Heidsieck’s NV Brut Réserve opens with aromas of candied lemon peel, ripe pear and pineapple mingling with buttered toast and a hint of burnt sugar. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, charming and textural, with a sweet and fleshy fruit core, succulent yet vibrant acidity and a persistent, toasty finish. Disgorged in 2024 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, after nearly four years aging sur lattes, it represents another strong rendition of this reliable cuvée.”
“The NV Brut Réserve, a combination of more than 60 different crus and 150 wines, evokes aromas of brioche, pastry, ripe orchard fruits, beeswax and spices. Medium to full-bodied, enrobing and charming, it has a fleshy core of fruit, a pinpoint mousse and delicate acids, making it a charming, delicate Champagne. This blend consists of 40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay and 20% Pinot Meunier, with 50% vins de réserve, and was disgorged with a dosage of nine grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2025
“Based on the 2019 vintage and enriched by 50% reserve wines—stored in steel tanks and incorporating some 100 individual wines, averaging a decade in age—Charles Heidsieck’s NV Brut Réserve opens with aromas of candied lemon peel, ripe pear and pineapple mingling with buttered toast and a hint of burnt sugar. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, charming and textural, with a sweet and fleshy fruit core, succulent yet vibrant acidity and a persistent, toasty finish. Disgorged in 2024 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, after nearly four years aging sur lattes, it represents another strong rendition of this reliable cuvée.”
“36% Chardonnay, 36% Pinot Noir, 28% Pinot Meunier. Base 2012. Nick Baker didn’t have any cheaper NV rosé champagnes!
Tasted blind. Pale salmon pink. Dried-apricot aroma like a fine Condrieu! Nice bead and great balance of fruit and acidity. Hint of saltiness. Gorgeous!”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“A blend of 36% Chardonnay, 36% Pinot Noir and 28% Pinot Meunier is based on fruit bought regularly from the same growers in Riceys, Ambonnay and Aÿ. After the first fermentation in stainless steel, each tank undergoes malolactic conversion. After blending with a base of 20% red and white reserve wines, 5–6% of still red Pinot Noir is added. The non-vintage is aged for three years before disgorgement, after which residual sugar is a relatively high 11.2 g/l. They have experimented with lower dosage levels but apparently it just doesn't do the trick.
Pale orangey bronze that positively glows in the glass. Shades of Lucozade? Beautifully integrated nose with many a nuance. Now this is a romantic pink champagne! Creamy texture, seductive fruit that finishes very clean and dry – as in not sweet (despite all that dosage!). Delicate, stereotypically 'feminine', but not wimpy. With an admirable undertow that goes on and on on the palate. A wine that would mend a sore throat?
Drink 2020 – 2024”
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Vinified in stainless steel vats in the Charles fashion, this wine sees a 5-6% red-wine component, to give it its pale peachy colour and red-berry charm. This Mis en Cave 2019 was released particularly young, and even though it is delightfully succulent and pristinely fruity, it is lacking some hallmark qualities of the cuvée. The fruitiness is flawlessly pure and joyful, with wild strawberries and ripe peaches, but missing the toasty 'wow'. On the palate, the fruitiness is equally impressive, but some of that age-mellowed sumptuousness is still not there. Finely crafted and harmonious, but it needs time. Disgorged 2022; dosage 6.28g/l”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The NV Rosé Réserve is an attractive, aperitif-styled Rosé to drink now and over the next handful of years, while the flavors remain bright. This release is based on 2012. Now with two years on the cork, the Rosé Réserve offers lovely complexity in its slightly burnished dried cherry, crushed flower and spice nuances. Disgorged in 2017.”
93/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Apr 2019
“The new release of Heidsick's NV Rosé Réserve is based on the 2012 vintage, with the usual 20% of reserve wines and some 6% still red wine from Les Riceys in the Aube. Already exhibiting considerable complexity, it wafts from the glass with scents of orange rind, red plums, gingerbread and red berries. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, satiny textured and fleshy, with lively acids and an attractively vinous profile. It was disgorged a few months ago with 11 grams per liter dosage.”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2017
“Pale peachy colour with onionskin hues. Lovely autolytic, toasty yet flirtingly fruity nose. Very clean and fresh, beautifully crafted. Balanced and charming with juicy, succulent nature. Long and invigorating but a little tight for the timebeing.”
92/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“A slew of red-berry, candied-orange and leaf-tea aromas welcomes you to this well-structured rosé Champagne. Bright acidity that’s quite pronounced at the slightly vegetal finish, but this also provides some tension.
”
“A blend of 36% Chardonnay, 36% Pinot Noir and 28% Pinot Meunier is based on fruit bought regularly from the same growers in Riceys, Ambonnay and Aÿ. After the first fermentation in stainless steel, each tank undergoes malolactic conversion. After blending with a base of 20% red and white reserve wines, 5–6% of still red Pinot Noir is added. The non-vintage is aged for three years before disgorgement, after which residual sugar is a relatively high 11.2 g/l. They have experimented with lower dosage levels but apparently it just doesn't do the trick.
Pale orangey bronze that positively glows in the glass. Shades of Lucozade? Beautifully integrated nose with many a nuance. Now this is a romantic pink champagne! Creamy texture, seductive fruit that finishes very clean and dry – as in not sweet (despite all that dosage!). Delicate, stereotypically 'feminine', but not wimpy. With an admirable undertow that goes on and on on the palate. A wine that would mend a sore throat?
Drink 2020 – 2024”
“36% Chardonnay, 36% Pinot Noir, 28% Pinot Meunier. Base 2012. Nick Baker didn’t have any cheaper NV rosé champagnes!
Tasted blind. Pale salmon pink. Dried-apricot aroma like a fine Condrieu! Nice bead and great balance of fruit and acidity. Hint of saltiness. Gorgeous!”
More Reviews +
93/100
Stuart Pigott,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“Enticing nose of nectarines, citrus, red berries and summer flowers. Creamy and elegant on the generous palate with some red wine character forming the core. Long, very layered finish with just a hint of tannin adding emphasis. 90% of the cuvee is the same as the Brut Reserve with the rest made up of 5% pinot noir and 5% pinot meunier.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“A blend of 36% Chardonnay, 36% Pinot Noir and 28% Pinot Meunier is based on fruit bought regularly from the same growers in Riceys, Ambonnay and Aÿ. After the first fermentation in stainless steel, each tank undergoes malolactic conversion. After blending with a base of 20% red and white reserve wines, 5–6% of still red Pinot Noir is added. The non-vintage is aged for three years before disgorgement, after which residual sugar is a relatively high 11.2 g/l. They have experimented with lower dosage levels but apparently it just doesn't do the trick.
Pale orangey bronze that positively glows in the glass. Shades of Lucozade? Beautifully integrated nose with many a nuance. Now this is a romantic pink champagne! Creamy texture, seductive fruit that finishes very clean and dry – as in not sweet (despite all that dosage!). Delicate, stereotypically 'feminine', but not wimpy. With an admirable undertow that goes on and on on the palate. A wine that would mend a sore throat?
Drink 2020 – 2024”
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Vinified in stainless steel vats in the Charles fashion, this wine sees a 5-6% red-wine component, to give it its pale peachy colour and red-berry charm. This Mis en Cave 2019 was released particularly young, and even though it is delightfully succulent and pristinely fruity, it is lacking some hallmark qualities of the cuvée. The fruitiness is flawlessly pure and joyful, with wild strawberries and ripe peaches, but missing the toasty 'wow'. On the palate, the fruitiness is equally impressive, but some of that age-mellowed sumptuousness is still not there. Finely crafted and harmonious, but it needs time. Disgorged 2022; dosage 6.28g/l”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The NV Rosé Réserve is an attractive, aperitif-styled Rosé to drink now and over the next handful of years, while the flavors remain bright. This release is based on 2012. Now with two years on the cork, the Rosé Réserve offers lovely complexity in its slightly burnished dried cherry, crushed flower and spice nuances. Disgorged in 2017.”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Aromas of strawberries, white peach, baked bread, red berries and gingerbread introduce the NV Rosé Réserve, a medium to full-bodied, enrobing and round Champagne with a satiny attack, a fleshy and vinous mid-palate framed by lively acids and a mouthwatering, strawberries-inflected finish. This is a blend of 40% Pinot Noir (including 5% as red wine sourced from Les Riceys), 35% Chardonnay and 25% Pinot Meunier with a dosage of eight grams per liter.”
93/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Apr 2019
“The new release of Heidsick's NV Rosé Réserve is based on the 2012 vintage, with the usual 20% of reserve wines and some 6% still red wine from Les Riceys in the Aube. Already exhibiting considerable complexity, it wafts from the glass with scents of orange rind, red plums, gingerbread and red berries. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, satiny textured and fleshy, with lively acids and an attractively vinous profile. It was disgorged a few months ago with 11 grams per liter dosage.”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2017
“Pale peachy colour with onionskin hues. Lovely autolytic, toasty yet flirtingly fruity nose. Very clean and fresh, beautifully crafted. Balanced and charming with juicy, succulent nature. Long and invigorating but a little tight for the timebeing.”
92/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“A slew of red-berry, candied-orange and leaf-tea aromas welcomes you to this well-structured rosé Champagne. Bright acidity that’s quite pronounced at the slightly vegetal finish, but this also provides some tension.
”
“Strikingly opulent and rich, full of cream-laden coffee character and delicious candy floss notes. The winey, velvety palate shows graceful evolution, the best bottles are perfectly crisp and lively still. Peaking beautifully now but there is no hurry. ”
More Reviews +
94-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2016
“Grilled almonds, sweet acacia honey, fruits compote and vanilla on the complex, beguiling nose. It is only the light mushroomy note that deducts from the appeal. Rich and vinous on the palate with the finish slightly drying out. I have encountered encountered better bottles, less troubled by the mushroomy note. ”
“This glows with a golden amber colour. A note of aromatic, lifted mandarin and orange marmalade richness is immediate, pure, bright and vivid. The more tertiary notes are distinctly present but subdued: subtle smoke, melted wax, toasted nuts – the citric verve keeps everything vivid. Notes of liquid blossom honey pop up, too. The palate has the same lemon freshness; it's luminous, pervasive, lifted. The mousse softens with time in glass and turns into a subtle whisper, showing beautiful concentration, real chalky depth and wonderful length. What a marvel. Tasted from magnum.”
More Reviews +
94-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Tasted from magnum at the winery. Deep golden, maturing healthy colour. There’s a very sweet feeling to the nose, almost botrytised aromas. A touch of oxidation on the nose. Full, rich, oily-textured calm palate with crisp acidity bringing welcome freshness. Nicely hanging in there with no hurry to open in magnums. ”
“The return with a new iteration of this iconic Champagne, first produced in the 1980s, and named after Charles Heidsieck one of the great Champagne promoters of the 19th century, is to be welcomed. The wine itself lives up to the billing of its history, rich in the house style and with just a hint of maturity. This great wine, still full of white fruits, has so many years ahead. The wine is likely to mature gently for a decade at least.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“52% Chardonnay, 48% Pinot Noir. The return of Charles Heidsieck's true Prestige Cuvée is remarkable not only for the quality of the wine (and perhaps the price), but for the admirable choice of not simply going 'big' in terms of style. The youngest wine is from 2016 (20% Aÿ Pinot Noir), the rest composed of reserves back to 1998. What is striking is the harmony, purity and resolution of flavour here, with fragrant tropical fruits, brightness of starfruit and orange peel and fine apricot tart flavours, all sitting under gentle praline richness. Nothing steps out of line - a real sense of assemblage. Luxurious enough on the palate to enjoy now, but subtly-built for further ageing in bottle, this will be a fascinating cuvée to follow.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2022
“Based on the 2016 vintage, this wine builds on its magnificent wealth of reserve wines. There is already high expression upon release, a super complex nose with vanilla, burned sugar, caramel and liquorice meeting tangerine, pineapple, dried apricots and honey. The sumptuously sweet character continues on the soothingly mellow palate oozing reserve wine richness. Here, the 52% Chardonnay and 48% Pinot Noir going back down to 1998 blend harmoniously into something luxuriously textured. Perfectly balanced with its 7g/l dosage.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2016 vintage, this wine builds on a magnificent wealth of reserve wines. It already has a high expression on release: a super-complex nose, in which vanilla, burned sugar, caramel and liquorice meet tangerine, pineapple, dried apricots and honey. The sumptuously sweet character continues on the soothingly mellow palate, oozing reserve-wine richness. Here, the 52% Chardonnay and 48% Pinot Noir (going back to 1998) blend harmoniously into something luxuriously textured. Perfectly balanced with its dosage. No need to wait, even if the new Charlie has the structure to age too. Dosage 7g/l”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jun 2022
“Fresh, ripe apricot and salted shortbread are immediate on the nose. More air reveals a mouthwatering streak of ripe and juicy greengage, grapefruit zestiness and melted butter. The palate is wonderfully brisk, taut at first but endowed with cooling, depth with hints of chalk and more apricot, accentuated by fine mousse. This is complex, taut, fine and beautifully vertical. It will age beautifully.”
97/100
Stuart Pigott,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“What a stunning mature champagne! This marries complex toasty aromas with a vitality that makes it easy to enjoy. Enormous concentration and creaminess, but so clean and straight at the super-long, delicately spicy finish that extends out to the horizon. A cuvee of 20% 2016 vintage pinot noir from Ay, with 80% of mature reserve wines, of which a good third were over 10 years of age.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“When Cyril Brun was briefed to recreate this iconic cuvée, he struggled to achieve the plenitude and drama he was looking for. Then, he dug in the Heidsieck archives and discovered, as he tells it, that the famous vintages of Charlie, while vintaged on paper, actually contained reserve wines. Brun therefore gave himself carte blanche to draw on the house's best lots to put together the inaugural NV Champagne Charlie, based on the 2016 vintage but incorporating fully 78% reserve wines dating back two decades. Bursting with aromas of golden orchard fruit, brioche, honeycomb, peaches, spices and buttery pastry, it's full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a layered core of fruit, racy acids and a beautifully refined pinpoint mousse. Some 52% of the blend is Chardonnay, with Brun looking for ripe, exotic Chardonnay to complement more tensile lots of Pinot Noir. It's a compelling, flamboyant wine—the only thing that may make consumers smart is the price.”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
Decanter.com,
Dec 2022
“An astonishing bouquet presenting notes of petroleum and flint that mingle with scents of pastry and both dried apricot and apricot jam. Complexity and generosity stand out on the palate, with that exemplary creamy and mellow mouthfeel that aged Champagnes at their best can have, but there is also freshness and an underlying crystalline sensation serving as counterpoint to the fullness of texture that is enhanced by the dosage. The chalk-infused finish is long and subtle, leaving a lingering impression of spices, including vanilla and pepper, as well as dried fruits. Bottled and cellared in 2017. Disgorged: November 2021. Dosage: 7g/L. 80% reserve wines and 20% wines from the 2016 harvest. 52% Chardonnay and 48% Pinot Noir from Aÿ.”
97/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
JebDunnuck.com,
Dec 2022
“The NV Champagne Charlie (2017) is the first release since the 1985 “vintage.” The new rendition embraces the long-held emphasis for this cuvée on reserve wine (despite having previously been labelled as a vintage wine) and now represents 80% of the blend, with only 20% from the base vintage of 2016, the oldest of the reserve wines going back to 1998. The wine is fantastically detailed and unfolds with layers of delicate smoky perfume, peach, and citrus blossoms. A refined and delicate mousse wraps around a core of orchard fruits, quince, and chalk. There is impeccable detail with this edition that will continue to improve over the coming decades. Drink 2024-2044.”
“The return with a new iteration of this iconic Champagne, first produced in the 1980s, and named after Charles Heidsieck one of the great Champagne promoters of the 19th century, is to be welcomed. The wine itself lives up to the billing of its history, rich in the house style and with just a hint of maturity. This great wine, still full of white fruits, has so many years ahead. The wine is likely to mature gently for a decade at least.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“52% Chardonnay, 48% Pinot Noir. The return of Charles Heidsieck's true Prestige Cuvée is remarkable not only for the quality of the wine (and perhaps the price), but for the admirable choice of not simply going 'big' in terms of style. The youngest wine is from 2016 (20% Aÿ Pinot Noir), the rest composed of reserves back to 1998. What is striking is the harmony, purity and resolution of flavour here, with fragrant tropical fruits, brightness of starfruit and orange peel and fine apricot tart flavours, all sitting under gentle praline richness. Nothing steps out of line - a real sense of assemblage. Luxurious enough on the palate to enjoy now, but subtly-built for further ageing in bottle, this will be a fascinating cuvée to follow.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2022
“Based on the 2016 vintage, this wine builds on its magnificent wealth of reserve wines. There is already high expression upon release, a super complex nose with vanilla, burned sugar, caramel and liquorice meeting tangerine, pineapple, dried apricots and honey. The sumptuously sweet character continues on the soothingly mellow palate oozing reserve wine richness. Here, the 52% Chardonnay and 48% Pinot Noir going back down to 1998 blend harmoniously into something luxuriously textured. Perfectly balanced with its 7g/l dosage.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2016 vintage, this wine builds on a magnificent wealth of reserve wines. It already has a high expression on release: a super-complex nose, in which vanilla, burned sugar, caramel and liquorice meet tangerine, pineapple, dried apricots and honey. The sumptuously sweet character continues on the soothingly mellow palate, oozing reserve-wine richness. Here, the 52% Chardonnay and 48% Pinot Noir (going back to 1998) blend harmoniously into something luxuriously textured. Perfectly balanced with its dosage. No need to wait, even if the new Charlie has the structure to age too. Dosage 7g/l”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jun 2022
“Fresh, ripe apricot and salted shortbread are immediate on the nose. More air reveals a mouthwatering streak of ripe and juicy greengage, grapefruit zestiness and melted butter. The palate is wonderfully brisk, taut at first but endowed with cooling, depth with hints of chalk and more apricot, accentuated by fine mousse. This is complex, taut, fine and beautifully vertical. It will age beautifully.”
97/100
Stuart Pigott,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“What a stunning mature champagne! This marries complex toasty aromas with a vitality that makes it easy to enjoy. Enormous concentration and creaminess, but so clean and straight at the super-long, delicately spicy finish that extends out to the horizon. A cuvee of 20% 2016 vintage pinot noir from Ay, with 80% of mature reserve wines, of which a good third were over 10 years of age.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“When Cyril Brun was briefed to recreate this iconic cuvée, he struggled to achieve the plenitude and drama he was looking for. Then, he dug in the Heidsieck archives and discovered, as he tells it, that the famous vintages of Charlie, while vintaged on paper, actually contained reserve wines. Brun therefore gave himself carte blanche to draw on the house's best lots to put together the inaugural NV Champagne Charlie, based on the 2016 vintage but incorporating fully 78% reserve wines dating back two decades. Bursting with aromas of golden orchard fruit, brioche, honeycomb, peaches, spices and buttery pastry, it's full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a layered core of fruit, racy acids and a beautifully refined pinpoint mousse. Some 52% of the blend is Chardonnay, with Brun looking for ripe, exotic Chardonnay to complement more tensile lots of Pinot Noir. It's a compelling, flamboyant wine—the only thing that may make consumers smart is the price.”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
Decanter.com,
Dec 2022
“An astonishing bouquet presenting notes of petroleum and flint that mingle with scents of pastry and both dried apricot and apricot jam. Complexity and generosity stand out on the palate, with that exemplary creamy and mellow mouthfeel that aged Champagnes at their best can have, but there is also freshness and an underlying crystalline sensation serving as counterpoint to the fullness of texture that is enhanced by the dosage. The chalk-infused finish is long and subtle, leaving a lingering impression of spices, including vanilla and pepper, as well as dried fruits. Bottled and cellared in 2017. Disgorged: November 2021. Dosage: 7g/L. 80% reserve wines and 20% wines from the 2016 harvest. 52% Chardonnay and 48% Pinot Noir from Aÿ.”
97/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
JebDunnuck.com,
Dec 2022
“The NV Champagne Charlie (2017) is the first release since the 1985 “vintage.” The new rendition embraces the long-held emphasis for this cuvée on reserve wine (despite having previously been labelled as a vintage wine) and now represents 80% of the blend, with only 20% from the base vintage of 2016, the oldest of the reserve wines going back to 1998. The wine is fantastically detailed and unfolds with layers of delicate smoky perfume, peach, and citrus blossoms. A refined and delicate mousse wraps around a core of orchard fruits, quince, and chalk. There is impeccable detail with this edition that will continue to improve over the coming decades. Drink 2024-2044.”
“This is the second release of the newly revived Champagne Charlie Cuvee with 45% from 2019, the Chardonnay 23% from Vertus and 34% Pinot Noir from Bouzy, this shows the elegance of the year, fairly warm, but with cooler night time temperatures promoting ripe fruit character with underlying freshness. With 66% chardonnay its more on the smoky reductive side and delicious yellow fruits, lots of grapefruit, lemon, lime and charred pineapple and a distinct bitter orange core. The palate is where you notice the 55% reserves, there is more of that rich texture coming forward with two notable contributors; 11% Cramant and 20% Avize. A very elegant fine bubble and light fluffy texture is very appealing, concentration yet super lightness.”
More Reviews +
17++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2025
“Full bottle 1,703 g. Labelled 'Cellared in 2020'. Mostly from the 2019 vintage with 45% reserve wines. A blend of 66% Chardonnay, 34% Pinot Noir made up of 32% Bouzy 2019, 23% Vertus 2019, 20% Avize 2009 and 11% Cramant 1996 plus others presumably. Disgorged 2024. Dosage 8 g/l. (The magnum version will see 7 g/l and will be aged for at least 20 years.) 'If Blanc de Millenaires is the salt of the house, Champagne Charlie is the pepper', according to current chef de cave Elise Losfelt. This wine was created by her predecessor Cyril Brun, who also created the 'Cellared in 2017' cuvée.
Pale greenish straw colour. Complex nose but still with very youthful zest and a hint of lime. Lots going on underneath. I'd cellar this glamorous, creamy blend for a while.”
“This wine is a serial winner, having conquered nearly every pedestal in the wine world, amongst them FINE Champagne '100 Best' winner in 2013 and Gold at 2014 CSWWC. Super luscious, sweet apricot, coffee with cream, wheat, brown butter, ginger and honeycomb nose with toasty richness in opulence. So deep, complex and soft. Caressingly smooth, even velvety palate with plenty of fruit and leesy richness. Power but comes with elegance. Matured to perfection. Ready to drink but there is no hurry. Note for 2012 disgorgement.”
More Reviews +
18.5++/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Nov 2024
“This is an example of how great a champagne can be from what was considered an average growing season. In fact I have four favourites from 2000 which stand out; Charles plus, Comtes, Krug and Piper. There is something very joyful about the CH aromatics, that hint of creamy pastry richness wafts out the glass and instantly reminds me of 2000 and brings a big smile. On the palate you get the ripe fruit sensation, apricot, plum, mango, honey, such a creamy silky texture and flavours that go on and one and that bitter orange and grapefruit zing on the end. Delicious. No rush to drink, Now until 2035. This is a 2021 disgorgement.”
“The best of long lees aged 1996 vintage champagnes are coming into their own. The bright acidities of the vintage have been tamed with long lees ageing adding textural elements combined with lower pressures that happen naturally as the champagne ages result in a very pleasing mouthfeel. Lots of dried fruits here, apricot, plum, roasted pineapple, dried mango and with a few minutes wafts of dark chocolate & coffee appear. Still energetic and no rush to drink, in great condition for a 1996. Drink now to early 2030's - These late release CH champagnes are testament to how critical it is to store your champagnes at 10-12 Celsius.”
“Tasted as part of a vertical of CH vintages in Dec 2025 - It is rare to see a 75cl with so much #MagnumEffect this champagne leapt out of the glass with that mix of smoky gunflint charm and unctuous stone fruit, underneath some ripe charred pineapple keeps the freshness right up there. The texture at this age is gorgeously soft and velvety as the bubbles are more background. The blend of dried fruits is a delight, stone fruit intense, with dried grapefruit, bitter orange, lemon peel etc. With a few minutes in the glass you see all the delights of coffee and chocolate emerging. This is a wine at the peak of its life, there is loads of freshness and salinity keeping it super fresh. Drink now and enjoy for 10+ years. Disgorged in 2021.”
“This Collection Crayères release, disgorged in 1999, shows an evolved profile already at the nose. Jammy marmalade tones mingle with golden raisins and ripe nectarines and orange, with a subtle spirit-like hint pointing to its advanced stage of maturity. The palate comes across broad, oily and richly textured, carrying the wine with vinosity rather than freshness. Fully mature today and no longer in a phase of development, it offers immediate pleasure but should be enjoyed without delay”
“This Collection Crayères release, disgorged in 1999, shows an evolved profile already at the nose. Jammy marmalade tones mingle with golden raisins and ripe nectarines and orange, with a subtle spirit-like hint pointing to its advanced stage of maturity. The palate comes across broad, oily and richly textured, carrying the wine with vinosity rather than freshness. Fully mature today and no longer in a phase of development, it offers immediate pleasure but should be enjoyed without delay”
“Magnum. Disgorged 2019.
Creamy, savoury nose. Soy sauce on the nose, but sweeter than the bottle size on the palate initially, and a little less tense. Surprising! Caught up a bit in the glass.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Anthony Rose,
Worldoffinewine.com,
Nov 2017
“Disgorged 1997 - Yellow golden in color; the intensely toasty, nutty aromas are followed on the palate by an amazing concentration of wonderfully rich, intense, full peach and apple fruit, with a fine, lively mousse and excellent vinosity shot through with a super-fresh blade of linear acidity. This seems to me to be as close to perfect as Vintage Champagne gets”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Bottle. Originally called Oenothèque. To be sold from September 2019. Disgorged originally 1998 or 1999. Fewer bottles available than bigger sizes!
Pale! Intensity and freshness. Stunningly lively. Real zest and introversion.”
“Disgorged 1990. 65% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay. Six years on the lees. Dosage 10 g/l.
Bright coppery gold. Vegy top note. Very racy and youthful! Drier than the Blanc des Millénaires 1983. Strong tangerine notes on the palate and so fresh! Looks old but doesn’t remotely taste old. Long and crisp and really drills down on the palate. Citrus notes. Less dense than the 1981.”
“Disgorged 1988. In 1981 the blend included some Chardonnay from Sézanne and Trépail but these have since been eliminated. This was effectively the prototype of Blanc des Millénaires (there was a 1982 too). Six years on lees. Dosage 10 g/l.
Deep orangey gold. Light, fully mature nose. Not the very longest but the structure of Blanc des Millénaires with excellent balance. Quite rich and toasty. Pretty nice drink!”
“Surprisingly restrained aromatics, more full power on the palate with joyful rich fruit, lemon, orange and grapefruit, with a distinctly creamy soft texture. Very charming. There is a subtlety here, almost feels the youngest of the three. Below this subtle champagne, it is rich and powerful yet ends with a lightness! Delicious now, but no hurry, will likely hold similar for a decade.”
More Reviews +
96-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2016
“Superbly classy and polished wine in the hallmark Charles Heidsieck style. Powerful, intense character with plush, sweet fruit in opulence. Super velvety and seamless with fantastic freshness. Sheer pleasure, truly hedonistic. Peaking with lots of chewy succulent power left. ”
“Disgorged 1994. Winter frost killed some vines and then a heatwave in summer caused double concentration, including that of acidity.
Orangey gold. Lively and powerful nose that reminds me of early Australian Chardonnay! (Or perhaps the yeast that was used for them.) Plus earthy, undergrowth flavours. This vintage is much fresher than the 1990. Very lively and racy for its age. Long and just starting to dry out but very good. Has lasted well and taken on many layers. Some richness at first but very clean, crisp and fresh on the finish. Long. Dried citrus peel. Super-clean. Dramatic wine compared with the complete classiness of the 1983.”
More Reviews +
96-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jan 2015
“Strikingly opulent and rich, full of cream-laden coffee character and delicious candy floss notes. The winey, velvety palate shows graceful evolution, the best bottles are perfectly crisp and lively still. Peaking beautifully now but there is no hurry. ”
“Mis en Cave 2001 - This wine is based on the 2000 vintage, which was magical for Charles Heidsieck`s vintage cuvée. The aroma profile is distinctly on the tertiary side, with less prominent toastiness than usual. Charles` typical dried apricot and honey aromas are well represented in this fully mature wine`s sweet deliciousness, along with mushroomy and woody notes. The charmingly voluptuous palate, however, is full of life, with compact, healthy fruitiness and a refreshing acid line.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2021
“Charles Heidsieck 2000 - This wine is a serial winner, having conquered nearly every pedestal in the wine world, amongst them FINE Champagne '100 Best' winner in 2013 and Gold at 2014 CSWWC. Super luscious, sweet apricot, coffee with cream, wheat, brown butter, ginger and honeycomb nose with toasty richness in opulence. So deep, complex and soft. Caressingly smooth, even velvety palate with plenty of fruit and leesy richness. Power but comes with elegance. Matured to perfection. Ready to drink but there is no hurry. Note for 2012 disgorgement.”
18/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“MeC 2001 - Based on 2000. 37% Pinot Noir, 21% Pinot Meunier, 42% Chardonnay. Dosage 11 g/l. Lower percentage of Pinot Noir than in most MEC. 2000 was a great year in which the vintage wine was considered one of the best they had made. 34% reserve wine. Disgorged 2006.
Mid gold, super-fine mousse. Remarkable at this age. Less toasty than the 2008, still ripe in its fruit profile, a little more toasty with air and remains surprisingly delicate – at least it gives that impression but it is powerful underneath. A hint of torrefaction. Just a tiny hint of mushrooms. And with marked reductive struck match on the palate. Tastes incredibly youthful and has amazing length. Still so sharply defined, great balance between the richness and freshness. Very impressive. ”
“Mis en Cave 1990 - Deep golden colour. The stunning nose charms you with its opulent brown-butter richness and sweet dried-fruit complexity. Still markedly fruity on the glorious nose but also going strong on the vibrant, velvety, round palate. Magnificent - and promising to keep on this level for quite some time.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“MeC 1990 - Based on 1989, which had the third-largest yields in history, apparently, and a protracted harvest after uneven flowering. 40% Pinot Noir, 20% Pinot Meunier, 40% Chardonnay. Not such a good year for reserve wines – just 29% – as 1989 and 1988 were too young and 1987 and 1986 both so-so vintages. Dosage 11 g/l. Disgorged 1993.
Slightly deeper gold than the 1993. Stony and smells really dry, much less rich in fruit aroma at first but opens up to really toasty breadth. More mushroom on the palate and the acidity very marked. Not quite as well balanced as some in this vertical tasting of MEC. Fatter but the acidity is marked. It actually tastes younger than the 1996 because of the high acidity. Magnum was brilliant and more crisp.”
“Rich golden orange pink, looks a strong colour for its age. The aromatics are super alluring, all those dried citrus fruits and delicious dried strawberry which lingers long. Some delicious tangy orange builds up the volume on the palate which has a super velvety texture. Gently bubbles and freshness make the champagne seem super relaxed, today I am tasting it with some truffle pasta, both are working so well together!”
“A food wine! Round and perfumed with quite substantial body. Rewarding about absolutely ready to enjoy – preferably at the table.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“The addition of 9% red wine from predominantly Bouzy brings an exciting rich red fruit profile and a twist of spice. The velvety texture is chalky soft, with more of the classic PN fruit showing as apricot, bitter orange & sweet peach. The rose is more expressive of the pair showing fruits like rich dark cherry, blackberry and pomegranate. Super delicious expression of a 2018 with plenty of acidity on the finish. Enjoy now and for at least 15 years.”
Matthew Jukes,
MatthewJukes.com,
Mar 2025
“During the course of this year, I predict only a handful [Champagne releases] will be genuinely eye-catching – those that are of sufficient ‘must-buy status’ to make it into my Finest Fifty round-up at Christmas. These are two of them! There is no doubt that these two 2018s are spectacular. […] The Rosé, by contrast, is masterful, near-tannic and surprisingly brittle, with a commanding flavour that straightens the spine and insists on your full attention. It is reserved, proud, formal and structured and needs a year or more to drop its shoulders and acclimatise to its surroundings. The yin and yang of the 2018 Charles Heidsieck is fascinating, and you need both in your collection to find completeness”
“Disgorged in 2021 and now 3+ years on you are starting to see the full potential of this rose champagne. The aromatics leap forward, deliciously ripe peach, raspberry, pink grapefruit all combine with a big twist of spicy orange. The eight years lees ageing have produced a velvety texture, the 2012 freshness is as always appealing and finishes super light with a chalky saline lift on the end. Very elegant and with more than a decade of drinking to come. ”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2023
“The sumptuously fruity yet fresh and immediately impressive character of the 2012 vintage perfectly fits the Charles Heidsieck house style. This vintage rosé is a blend of 11 Grands and Premiers Crus (Oger, Vertus, Chouilly, Cuis, Verzy, Aÿ, Ludes, Ambonnay, Tauxières, Avenay and Les Riceys) with 9% of Pinot Noir red wine giving it its medium-deep salmon colour with copper tones. The lush fruit profile is ripe with sweet, vanilla-coated peach and dried apricot layers. A charmingly airy and lacey palate carries the wine to its long, intensely fruity, spice-complexed finish. A stylish wine of morish quality to it. Drinking perfectly well already but with lots more to come.”
93/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2023
“Disgorged with nine grams per liter dosage in 2021, the 2012 Brut Rosé is a blend of 62% Pinot Noir and 38% Chardonnay sourced from 11 villages. Nine percent red wine from Les Ryceys has been added. Offering up aromas of blueberry, wild strawberry, pomegranate, almond and spring flowers, the palate is energetic with lively acids, perfectly balanced and juicy, but it already exudes freshness and clarity that lead to a finish with a light grace note of gastronomic bitterness. It will drink at its peak in four to six years’ time.”
95/100
Stuart Pigott,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“A very elegant vintage rosé with wonderfully expressive red berry, blood orange and rhubarb aromas. Complex and finely-nuanced, this glides over your palate in spite of the healthy structure. Long finish that's driven by the fine tannins and chalky minerality. The same basic blend as the 2012 vintage champagne from this house, but with 9% of red wine.”
“The absolute quality of this vintage is only just starting to make itself clear, although it is not one for the immediate hedonists - a steely, long-distance stare of a rosé...63% Pinot Noir, 37% Chardonnay. I have to freely admit that I wondered whether this wine would prove too austere when I first tasted it in 2021. Retasting in summer 2022, though, that austerity has morphed into an exciting tension that promises much for the future, the reductive tightness eased open a little. Still, it's no casual rosé this, super compressed and steely with red and orange citrus intensity, around which fragrant blackberry, allspice and dried apple notes tempt you in. It may end up in a sweet spot a little earlier than imagined; worth waiting five years for some exciting flavour development.”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2021
“Launched some two years after its white sibling, Charles Heidsieck Rosé Millésime 2008 greets you with instant Charles charm. The typical, heavenly ground coffee note is there but it remains coolly reserved with crunchy fruit profile that still holds back a lot. Peach, blood orange and lemon peel with a spicy twist. A rosé d’assemblage with 9% red wine, half from Les Riceys, half from Montagne de Reims, it is elegant, focused, even tight for the time being. The palate finishes very dry with the lowest-ever dosage for Charles, 7g/l, bringing a gastronomic, phenolic bite to the fore. In its breezy lightness and vivacious style it differs greatly from the previous releases but promises to be a slowly ageing keeper. Only a tiny volume was produced and regrettably no magnums, soo ne better move fast with this one. ”
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This age-defying rosé is a blend of 15 crus, with villages such as Cramant, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Vertus, Ambonnay, Avenay, Aÿ and Tauxières all playing a part. The wine has received its developing pale peach colour from the 9% addition of Les Riceys and Montagne de Reims Pinot Noir. There is plenty of hidden power on the tight nose, which first releases super-fine toasty nuances of the mocha and bonfire kind. The fruitiness is crunchy and cool, with fresh berries meeting red and yellow apples, peach and apricot. The palate is tight and linear, with plenty of tension enhancing the sense of dynamism. Even if prickly from its bubbles, the texture is super-smooth and silky, leading to a long, purely fruity finish. The low dosage (by Charles standards) enhances the feeling of bright radiance. Disgorged 2021; dosage 7g/l”
96/100
Andy Howard MW,
decanter.com,
Aug 2021
“Elaborated with 63% Pinot Noir (including 9% of red wine) and 37% Chardonnay, this rosé from Charles Heidsieck is sourced from 11 grands and premiers crus. With a much lower dosage than in previous years (7g/L), it has a spicy and smoky nose with pomegranate, citrus, liquorice and red berry aromas. Harmonious and elegant, the palate is full-bodied with both tense and fresh texture interplays, with a vinous structure. A gastronomic rosé built for long ageing. ”
92+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“The newly released 2008 Brut Rosé unwinds in the glass with youthfully reticent notes of tart red berries, white flowers and citrus oil, framed by a touch of light reduction—which I suspect is accentuated by the wine's Diamant closure. Following the wine in my office, it was only on the third day that hints of plums and licorice began to emerge. Medium to full-bodied, taut and chiseled, it's concentrated and layered, with real cut and energy, but it's also borderline austere and will require patience to realize all its potential. When compared with the rich, demonstrative 2006, it was to be expected that the 2008 would represent a change of pace; but the contrast is even starker than I would have expected.”
98/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“An amazing 2008 rosé Champagne that has all the structure and aromatic complexity - sushi ginger, oolong tea and caramelised mandarin orange - we associate with this vintage, but also has more charm than most. On the palate, this has stunning concentration, yet is diamond bright. The interplay of creaminess, fine tannins and mineral acidity builds and builds at the breathtaking finish. The colour comes from about 7% pinot noir red wine, partly from the little-known Les Riceys in the far south of Champagne.”
“Disgorged 2016. Dosage 10 g/l.
Pale to mid salmon pink. Very lively and flirtatious. Lifted and berry fruit. For white meat and shellfish. Seems much lighter and sweeter than the 2005 vintage rosé that won't be released until spring 2018. Pretty.
Drink 2016-2022”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2017
“Mid coppery pink (same hue as the Dom Pérignon Rosé 2005) with a fresh strawberry aroma, even with a hint of strawberry jam. Enough acidity and nice balance with a very fine bead. Far from bone dry but with a light savoury thread running through it. Very nice texture.”
95/100
Decanter,
Decanter.com,
Jan 2017
“Seductive smoky, flinty aromas wrap around pretty red fruits and gentle oriental spices. A harmonious palate with a creamy texture, lovely strawberry and red currant fruits and a touch of spice. The finish is generous, yet subtly restrained, supported by fresh chalky minerality.”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2016
“Charles Heidsieck have decided to launch the Vintage Rosé 2006 before the 2005, which to them still needs time. Opulent raspberry, fresh peach and caramel nose with stylish spicy complexity but only emerging toastiness. The palate is highly youthful, plump, almost oily in its richness. The finish is tight with pencil shavings notes and slight phenolic feel to it. The dosage has been decreased to well-balanced 9g/l. A generous year suiting perfectly to Charles’ style but should be given time to develop its toasty and coffee complexity typical for Charles Heidsieck.”
94/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“Charles Heidsieck's 2006 Brut Rosé (with 10% Pinot Noir red wine) has been launched before the 2005. Disgorged at the end of 2014, the wine offers a delicate and intense wild strawberry flavor with some lovely spicy aromas on the nose. Ample, full and round, this is a lovely matured Rosé with a super intense and aromatic Pinot character (sweet cherries, red berries). The finish underlines the great complexity, purity and finesse of this vinous Rosé. There are cherry aromas again in the long aftertaste. An impressive Rosé.”
93/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Dec 2015
“This is a pale-colored wine with a finely wrought texture and great fruit. It is tight and mineral on the one hand, but balanced with the crispest red-currant flavors that offer a bright line in acidity. Delicious hints of age round out the final fresh aftertaste.”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“Heidsieck's 2006 Brut Rosé Vintage offers good immediacy and plenty of intensity, both of which make it quite appealing. Still a bit tight, the 2006 could use another year or more in bottle to soften. Although light in color, the 2006 packs a pretty serious punch. Hints of orange zest, chalk and white pepper add an attractive upper register on the finish. With time in the glass, the 2006 softens nicely, hinting at a bright future. Disgorged: October 28, 2014.”
95/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2015
“With a pale hue in the glass, this has a savory nose that delivers a very nicely struck toasty edge with chalky pastry and faint red fruits. The palate's sophisticated and fine texture is mesmerising, and this really dances. It leaves a trail of red berry fruits in its wake through to a long, pure, fresh and spicy finish. Drink now.”
“Disgorged 2016. Dosage 10 g/l.
Pale to mid salmon pink. Very lively and flirtatious. Lifted and berry fruit. For white meat and shellfish. Seems much lighter and sweeter than the 2005 vintage rosé that won't be released until spring 2018. Pretty.
Drink 2016-2022”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2017
“Mid coppery pink (same hue as the Dom Pérignon Rosé 2005) with a fresh strawberry aroma, even with a hint of strawberry jam. Enough acidity and nice balance with a very fine bead. Far from bone dry but with a light savoury thread running through it. Very nice texture.”
95/100
Decanter,
Decanter.com,
Jan 2017
“Seductive smoky, flinty aromas wrap around pretty red fruits and gentle oriental spices. A harmonious palate with a creamy texture, lovely strawberry and red currant fruits and a touch of spice. The finish is generous, yet subtly restrained, supported by fresh chalky minerality.”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2016
“Charles Heidsieck have decided to launch the Vintage Rosé 2006 before the 2005, which to them still needs time. Opulent raspberry, fresh peach and caramel nose with stylish spicy complexity but only emerging toastiness. The palate is highly youthful, plump, almost oily in its richness. The finish is tight with pencil shavings notes and slight phenolic feel to it. The dosage has been decreased to well-balanced 9g/l. A generous year suiting perfectly to Charles’ style but should be given time to develop its toasty and coffee complexity typical for Charles Heidsieck.”
94/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“Charles Heidsieck's 2006 Brut Rosé (with 10% Pinot Noir red wine) has been launched before the 2005. Disgorged at the end of 2014, the wine offers a delicate and intense wild strawberry flavor with some lovely spicy aromas on the nose. Ample, full and round, this is a lovely matured Rosé with a super intense and aromatic Pinot character (sweet cherries, red berries). The finish underlines the great complexity, purity and finesse of this vinous Rosé. There are cherry aromas again in the long aftertaste. An impressive Rosé.”
93/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Dec 2015
“This is a pale-colored wine with a finely wrought texture and great fruit. It is tight and mineral on the one hand, but balanced with the crispest red-currant flavors that offer a bright line in acidity. Delicious hints of age round out the final fresh aftertaste.”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“Heidsieck's 2006 Brut Rosé Vintage offers good immediacy and plenty of intensity, both of which make it quite appealing. Still a bit tight, the 2006 could use another year or more in bottle to soften. Although light in color, the 2006 packs a pretty serious punch. Hints of orange zest, chalk and white pepper add an attractive upper register on the finish. With time in the glass, the 2006 softens nicely, hinting at a bright future. Disgorged: October 28, 2014.”
95/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2015
“With a pale hue in the glass, this has a savory nose that delivers a very nicely struck toasty edge with chalky pastry and faint red fruits. The palate's sophisticated and fine texture is mesmerising, and this really dances. It leaves a trail of red berry fruits in its wake through to a long, pure, fresh and spicy finish. Drink now.”
“Pretty, orange hued onion skin colour. Deliciously toasty nose with sweet red and white fruit mix with peaches, spiciness, coffee, ashes and fruit cake aromas. Full-on rich and round palate speaks sunshine with real vinosity and muscular structure. Soft, seamlessly integrated acidity that carries on until the sweetly beguiling finish. Already monumental and bound to grow in richness and complexity. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Apr 2019
“This bottle of the 2005 Brut Rosé was disgorged in 2017 with ten grams per liter dosage. It's a lovely wine that offers up complex notes of red apple, mandarin, white cherries, brioche and nutmeg. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, pure and vibrant, with a fleshy core of fruit, brisk acids, a refined mousse and lovely chalky grip on the finish. This is a serious, vinous rosé that numbers among the challenging 2005 vintage's successes.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2018
“Disgorged July 2017 and embargoed until ready to sell in late spring or early summer 2018. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. 10% red (half from Montagne de Reims). Cellarmaster Cyril Brun loves the 2005 Pinots. Dosage 10 g/l.
Cyril Brun admits it’s still a bit locked and severe. Quite dark salmon pink. Cool but not much else on the nose at present. Massive and tight and designed for the table – even game. Really quite burgundian, especially on the nose. Mushrooms and game spectrum of red burgundy. Really very distinctive! Full-bodied and brooding. Positively throbs.”
“100% Chardonnay. Seven years' ageing on lees. Disgorged December 2014. Dosage 3 g/l.
Tasted blind. Greenish deep straw. Creamy, lively nose. Fairly high dosage. I was going to guess Comtes until I saw that it wasn’t in the line-up! Slightly pinched finish. But then a peacock’s tail. The richest of these wines.
Drink 2014-2023”
More Reviews +
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“100% Chardonnay in a special walled, so early-ripening, eighteenth-century vineyard in Reims. Part of it was planted in 1962 and part in 1986 after the frosts of 1985. What happened to these grapes before Clos Lanson was bottled separately to celebrate Philippe Bejot’s acquisition of Lanson in 2006? They went into vintage and Black Label. Fermented in pièces from Burgundy and 300-litre casks from Argonne.
Smoky nose. So distinctive! A bit like Laphroaig malt whisky! The oak still rather marks it but Hervé claims it’s ideal to drink now. Good acidity but there are definite oak overlays. Fruit is a tad weak for the moment, but should come out from behind the oak eventually. Good saline quality. Again, not one of the most intense on the finish.
Drink 2020-2030”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Aug 2016
“The 2006 Clos Lanson is bright, focused and exceptionally pure. Veins of underlying acidity and chalkiness give the 2006 its super-distinctive, saline-driven personality. Lemon peel, white flowers, chalk and white pepper develop in the glass, adding further dimensions of nuance. With time in the glass, the 2006 acquires lovely textural brilliance, but it remains tense, crystalline and absolutely impeccable in its purity. The aromatics could use a bit more finesse and freshness, but otherwise this is a solid debut. Clos Lanson is fermented entirely in barrel, but the oak is very nicely integrated. Disgorged December, 2014.”
93+/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“From the immured one-hectare vineyard on the top of the hill, which also harbors the cellar of Champagne Lanson that dates back into the 18th century, the 2006 Clos Lanson is 100% first press Chardonnay from a very fine, chalky soil. It was fermented and aged in Argonne oak until spring 2007 (no malolactic fermentation), and disgorged after seven and a half years on the lees in December 2014 as Brut Nature with a dosage of three grams per liter. This bright yellow-golden colored prestige Champagne offers a brilliant nose of pure and ripe Chardonnay, along with delicate chalky flavors. Full and round on the palate, with a nice freshness and purity, this is a very elegant and well-balanced Blanc de Blancs. it has an aromatic as well as clear, fresh and mineral finish. This very first release has a very good length and characteristic mineral taste, with iodine notes along with ripe fruit and vanilla brioche flavors in the finish. This is a great new entry in the Lanson portfolio and it will improve with age. Total production is 7,870 serially numbered bottles.”
16.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2016
“A new bottling on me in a broad, straight-sided flask from a single plot in Reims next to the cellars. 100% Chardonnay. Disgorged December 2014.
Pale golden straw. Impressive aromatic completeness and integration on the nose – although one is hit by Lanson’s trademark high acidity on the palate. Very firm and still quite chewy. Tastes pretty youthful and aggressively frothy. I’d hold on to this for quite a while. Embryonic. 12%”
93/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2016
“Generous fruit from the weathered chalk site is enhanced by a bright acidity, triggering mineral complexities. So delicious, tout en plaisir. The mineral imprint makes it a great match for ocean fish, especially turbot. A lovely surprise from the warm walled clos.
”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
www.EssiAvellan.com,
May 2016
“Rich golden colour. Highly expressive nose with tropical fruit, smoky layers sweet brioche and spicy vanilla aromas and finely integrated note of high-quality oak. Voluptuous, round, fleshy palate that is mouth-filling at first until the fine, zesty acidity kicks in and lifts the palate. The finish is minerality driven, fresh and succulent, emphasizing fruit purity. Great intensity and length.”
“The latest release of Delamotte's NV Brut Blanc de Blancs, the house's emblematic bottling, is once again showing very well, bursting with aromas of citrus zest, freshly baked bread, nougat, crisp stone fruit and white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, ample and pillowy, with a fleshy core of fruit, bright acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse, it's a seamless, elegant wine that concludes with a flavorful finish.”
More Reviews +
93/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Delamotte's NV Brut Blanc de Blancs is drinking very well out of the gates, offering up aromas of crisp orchard fruit and citrus zest mingled with hints of fresh bread and wet stones. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and precise, with bright acids and chalky grip, concluding with a dry finish, this is a classy, seamless wine that will offer a broad drinking window.”
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This is a classic racy-mineral Chardonnay from the grand cru villages of the Côte des Blancs: Avize, Cramant, Oger and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger. The reserve wines are kept to a minimum in the blend to enchance the fresh, zingy and mineral style. There is a stylish restraint to the youthful, cool nose, which gives off stony mineral tones, complemented by faint smoky notes. The palate is equally subdued, with impeccable fruit quality shining through in a highly transparent way. Long, linear structure and palate-soothing texture. This is a truly emblematic Côte des Blancs Chardonnay in a cool, reserved but pristinely fruity style. Dosage 7g/l”
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
VinousMedia.com,
Jan 2016
“(8 g/l dosage): Light yellow. Mineral-tinged peach, melon and pear aromas display excellent clarity, picking up a subtle floral quality with aeration. Supple and seamless on the palate, offering vivid honeydew and pit fruit flavors accented by a vibrant lemon zest quality. Finishes very long, silky and precise, with an echo of juicy melon and strong mineral lift.”
17/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2016
“Mostly 2012 with 25% reserve (2010 and 2011).
Wonderfully fragrant - smells white and pure but there are delicate notes of yeasty autolysis and scented lemons and white peach. Perfect balance here, finesse and elegance and no lack of flavour intensity and length. Fine and persistent mousse. (JH)”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Le Mesnil, Avize, Oger, ‘300% grand cru’. Base 2013 plus 30% reserve wines. Disgorged September 2017. Just released. No info on back label. Dosage 6.5–7 g/l. This wine is very successful in Japan apparently. 30–35% of Salon and Delamotte’s business is in Japan. ‘Italy and Japan are very similar markets for high-quality products’.
Fine and firm – tight-knit, tiny little bubbles. Fine bead with a tiny bit of softness but still a little chewy on the end.”
91+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“Delamotte’s latest NV Brut Blanc de Blancs is based on the 2019 vintage and complemented by reserve wines from 2018 and 2017. Disgorged in late 2024 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, it emerges from the glass with aromas of lemon confit, candied orange peel and shortbread cookie, mingled with Granny Smith apple. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and concentrated, fleshy and textural, with a rich core of fruit underpinned by ripe yet racy acids and framed by chalky extract. It will strongly benefit from three to five years of post-disgorgement aging. It is sourced from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Avize and Oger.”
89-91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2016
“One third of each, Le Mesnil, Cramant and Oger, make up for the lovely smoky-mineral yet pure fruity essence of Delamotte non-vintage blanc de blancs. Lemon curd, butter, pastry and charred wood nuances on top of a highly mineral backbone. Lean, long and mouth-watering as it should be.”
“The Delamotte 2018 Blanc de Blancs is showing well today, evoking a gourmand, complex bouquet of pastry, almonds, ripe orchard fruits, spices and spring flowers. Medium to full-bodied, layered and chiseled, it’s enveloping and round with a fleshy core of fruit, though not as fleshy as the 2012, concluding with a tense and long finish.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Allen Meadows,
Burghound.com,
Oct 2024
“The elevated heat of the 2018 vintage is manifest on the ripe aromas of citrus confit, poached pear, baked apple and quinine-scented nose. There is good richness allied with good verve to the moderately generous medium-bodied flavors where the supporting mousse is also moderate while remaining relatively fine before terminating in an acceptably complex, nice dry and sneaky long finale. For my taste this needs more depth and while it certainly could already be enjoyed, I would advise allowing to slumber for another 4 to 6 years first. (Drink starting 2028)”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2025
“100% Chardonnay. One of Champagne’s more ancient houses, founded in Le Mesnil-sur-Oger back in 1721. A blend of six grands crus – Le Mesnil (20%), Avize (20%), Oger (20%), Cramant, Chouilly and Oiry. Dosage 5 g/l. Cool, crisp and unmistakably Chardonnay on both nose and palate. A touch of oak adds to the complexity on the palate. Savoury finish. Precise, lingering aftertaste, plenty of upside ageing potential.”
91/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2018 Brut Blanc de Blancs is a blend of fruit from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Avize, Oger, Cramant, Chouilly and Oiry, six villages in the Côte des Blancs. Crushed rocks, mint, slate, lemon peel and green pear lend notable freshness. Like most wines in this vintage, the Blanc de Blancs is airy and medium-bodied in structure, but it shows lovely tension and fine balance. There's plenty of Delamotte class, in an understated style. Dosage is 6 grams per liter. ”
“Delamotte's just-released 2014 Blanc de Blancs has turned out very well indeed, opening in the glass with scents of citrus zest, crisp orchard fruit, fresh bread and wet stones. Medium to full-bodied, chiseled and incisive, with excellent depth at the core, racy acids and a chalky finish, this isn't as muscular as the 2008 or 2012, but it has real cut and persistence and should age very gracefully indeed.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This is only the third vintage of this cuvée composed of all six grands crus of the Côte des Blancs, since Chouilly and Oiry joined the original quartet of Cramant, Avize, Oger and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger in 2008. The nose prompts an instant wow reaction, being so irresistibly classy, with sweet, toasty exuberance complementing the shiny, bright fruitiness. Lovely intensity of lemony fruit, delicate floral notes wrapped in toasty tones. The palate is appropriately tight and lean for the time being but coming with laciness and drive. This is such a bright, vibrant, overdelivering wine, oozing its grand cru origins with every drop. Dosage 6.5g/l”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2014 Blanc de Blancs is seriously impressive. Ample in feel, Delamotte is especially rich in 2014, and yet there is plenty of freshness to balance things out. This is an especially savory style for Delamotte, and one that works so well. Dried lemon peel, pastry, almond, dried herbs and chamomile open in a beautifully translucent Blanc des Blancs that marries power and finesse. I can’t wait to see how it ages.”
92-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2021
“Such a consistent wine from vintage to another, Delamotte Blanc de Blancs brings together the six Grands Crus of the Côte des Blancs. Pristinely crafted, the wine is squeaky clean and radiant, with cool, crunchy lemony fruit at centre stage. Beautiful reductive smoky tones lining the intense fruitiness. The racy palate is pleasantly creamy and silky with a lingering long finish. ”
94/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Dec 2021
“A pretty Blanc de Blancs with aromas of white grapefruit, lemon pith, dried honeysuckle and white peach. Silky and creamy with bright acidity and
an elegant finish.
Drink now.”
93/100
wineenthusiast.com,
wineenthusiast.com,
Dec 2021
“From the Grand Cru village of Le Mesnil-sur-Oger on the Côte des Blancs, this well-textured Champagne shows a crisp apple freshness underlined by strong minerality. At seven years past vintage, the wine is just starting to lose its initial freshness and develop attractive toasty elements. Drink now”
92/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Nov 2021
“A finely-meshed, linear Champagne, with racy acidity and a citrusy overtone driving flavors of poached apricot, biscuit, candied lemon peel and a toasty hint of brioche. Fine and creamy.
Drink now through 2026”
94/100
Yohan Castaing,
Decanter.com,
Nov 2021
“Offering up an elegant yet bright bouquet, this 2014 Delamotte Blanc de Blancs opens in the glass with orchard fruits, verbena, lemon zest, pastry, and slightly reductive aromas. Chiselled and perfectly balanced, the palate is lively and intense, and expresses clearly the fruit and the straightforward nature of the 2014 vintage. Should age well for a decade or so.”
“Delamotte’s 2012 Brut Vintage is rich, creamy and super-expressive. This is only the second vintage (the first was 2008) in which fruit from Oiry rounds out the classic core of Le Mesnil, Oger and Cramant that forms the backbone of the Vintage. Dried pear, white flowers, chamomile and mint are some of the notes that grace this exquisite understated Blanc de Blancs. The 2012 offers terrific depth and textural resonance in a creamy, expressive style that captures the radiant personality of the year and the understated, quiet voice that is such a Delamotte signature.”
More Reviews +
94+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Shortly to be released in magnum, Delamotte's 2012 Blanc de Blancs continues to perform very well, unwinding in the glass with scents of crisp orchard fruit, buttered toast, white flowers, fresh bread and orange oil. Medium to full-bodied, deep and layered, it's racy and concentrated, with an elegant mousse and a long, mineral finish. This is well worth seeking out.”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2020
“The 2012 Delamotte is such a charmer in its refined, cool fruitiness and zingy acidity. Well balanced with plentiful ripe, expressive fruit in the lemony-floral genre. Energetic and vibrant with steely minerality kicking in towards the dry and perfectly pure finish. ”
“The latest release of Delamotte's NV Brut is especially charming, bursting with aromas of crisp orchard fruit, peach and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and enveloping, it's a fleshy, giving wine that's ample and pliant, with a pinpoint mousse and a nicely defined finish.”
More Reviews +
91/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Sep 2019
“Quite impressive richness and gently toasty aromas on the nose here with almond, savory and sweet, bready autolysis notes. The palate has a fresh, succulent and smooth feel with soft, citrusy fruit flesh. Holds long. Drink now.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The purely fruity, classily withdrawing nose gives off lovely reductive gunpowdery and smoky whiffs. The fruit is mainly on the white-fruit side, with lemon, mirabelle plums and sweet peach contributing. The palate is silky but airy, with a lovely friendliness to it all. This is a great-value, quaffable Champagne, but it's by no means boring. The secret here is the 90% grand cru fruit. Dosage 8g/l”
“The latest release of Delamotte's NV Brut Rosé is showing beautifully, offering up aromas of tangerine, red plums, cherries and spices. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and precise, with a fleshy core of fruit, bright acids and a pinpoint mousse, it concludes with a chalky finish. As ever, it's a seamless, elegant wine.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Bright salmon colour, with a peachy tinge. Since Laurent-Perrier is the winemaking parent of Delamotte, the maceration method of the house is also employed here. The expressive nose is all about sweet Pinot fruit of Montagne de Reims origin. There are primary strawberry and cherry fruits here but also some curious spicy sous-bois development. The high proportion of Pinot Noir comes across even stronger on the palate, and a touch of tannin brings some grip to the dry finish. An elegant but gastronomic style. Dosage 7g/l”
90/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The latest release of Delamotte's NV Brut Rosé offers up expressive aromas of red apples, crisp stone fruit, cherries and fresh pastry, followed by a medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping palate. Comparatively rich and textural for this routinely elegant, fine-boned cuvée, it's more gastronomic than usual.”
“MAGNUM TASTING: Having recently tasted both the 75cl and 1.5L the magnum isn't just a hint more glorious, but a big dollop more! The aromatics really draw you in, just gently wafting that smoky charm, with the backbone of ripe yellow fruits, this is not at all shy, it screams Côte des Blancs chardonnay with its apple, lemon and ripe plum aromas and a waft of patisserie shop richness! This is exciting and it just gets better on the palate, that chalky charm really adds in layers between the fruit and being 2019 there is a good spoonful of acidity which lift it up at the end and gives you such a delicate finish. This is drinking now, in 2026 but will be better in a few years and will perform well until late 2030's.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“75cl: The 2019 Blanc de Blancs soars from the glass with scents of lemon peel, chalk, mint, white pepper and lemon oil. Aromatic and deep on the palate, with plenty of layers, the 2019 has a lot to recommend it. It is the finest of the entry-level vintage Champagnes at Deutz. Light tropical notes extend the resonant, gracious finish.”
92/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Dec 2025
“75cl review: Bright and harmonious, with fine, pinprick-sized bubbles enlivening the creamy mousse, this offers a lithe mix of poached pear and pastry, preserved lemon, apple blossom and crystallized honey. A latent push of toasted almond adds richness on the lingering finish. Drink now through 2035.
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs is broad and ample on the palate, with the natural richness of the vintage. An extra year in bottle provides a stark contrast to the steelier personality of the 2014 tasted alongside it. Lemon confit, white flowers, mint and pastry notes give the 2013 an extra kick of flavor intensity and textural depth that is hugely appealing.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jan 2025
“This is one of those vintages that has that character at holding back the wine, making it seem tight and not expressive and having watched this grow over the last 6 years the wine is just coming round to drink, but no rush. Beautifully rich citrus fruits, lemon and grapefruit with those hints of patisserie emerging. The champagne is richly textured and almost that hint of "oily chardonnay" emerging. A great value glass. Drink Now to 2035.”
“The 2010 Blanc de Blancs is a very pretty, finely-knit wine with striking Chardonnay purity but also the textural depth that makes the best wines here so compelling. Lemon confit, white flowers, vanillin and spice all open up nicely in the glass. This is an especially generous, fleshy style of Blanc de Blancs, although brighter, chalkier notes emerge with time in the glass. All the elements are in the right place. Disgorged: February 24, 2016.”
More Reviews +
90/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Jun 2018
“Deutz's 2010 Blanc de Blancs Brut (LR114D05516) opens quite clear, fresh and fruity on the open, elaborate and very fine nose from which I pick up some popcorn, burnt milk, toast and yeasty notes but also stewed seed fruit and a possibly a hint of botrytis. On the palate, this is a round, finessed and elegant Chardonnay with a firm, mineral structure, grip and good length. Tasted June 2018.”
“75cl-The NV Brut Classic is a pretty, entry-level wine. Warm, generous fruit comes together beautifully in this rich, expansive, mid-weight Champagne. The bouquet, texture and purity of the finish are all first-rate. The Brut Classic is equal parts Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier and Chardonnay. Like all Deutz Champagnes, it undergoes full malolactic fermentation.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2024
“75cl-A blend of the three key Champagne varietals in equal proportions, the nose opens with pristine orchard fruit tones underlined by a light, refined toasty and charry layer. There is an overall feeling of harmony and seamlessness here. Pleasurably smooth and rounded palate with the quaffing character. A pristinely made champagne that charms with its polished fruitiness and drinkability. ”
93/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
May 2025
“75cl- Very attractive nose of lemon blossom, tarte au citron and lemon curd. Very elegant and delicate with an inner strength that doesn't make this at all loud. I love the interplay of the fine mousse and citrusy fruit on the medium-bodied palate. Long finish with subtle spicy notes. 39% chardonnay, 31% pinot noir and 30% pinot meunier. Based on the 2019 vintage with 53% reserve wine. Drink now.”
89/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
May 2023
“75cl-Generous, mature flavors make this brut substantive. Full-bodied, ripe and complex, with a plush texture and lingering finish. Drink now.”
17/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jul 2026
“Subtle smoky edge from magnum effect, with a bundle of bright citrus and delicate white flower perfume. I like the texture here, light and airy, with some chalky notes and lingering lemon and plum on the finish and plenty of freshness on the finish. Drinking well now, but no rush with these magnums, keep for five plus years to enjoy more complexity.”
“This is one of those vintage champagnes where the Pinot Noir fruit character really dominates, those peach and red berry fruits leap out the glass and you only notice the 34% Chardonnay on the palate where it really lifts up the freshness and plays a key role in lightening up some powerful PN fruit. With a few minutes in the glass you seem some spice charm. A great champagne, more built to enjoy with food than as an aperitif. Enjoy now, will cellar for at least 5+ years.”
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Millésimé Amour de Deutz is every bit as expressive as it was last year. Hints of candied lemon peel, passion fruit and tangerine zest give the 2013 subtle exoticness that’s balanced by the wine's driving, bright acids. Now past its first decade, the 2013 remains very youthful. What a gorgeous Champagne it is. ”
More Reviews +
96-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
essiavellan.com,
Aug 2022
“Deutz excels in blanc de blancs, and Amour de Deutz epitomises the house's Chardonnay elegance. Here, Côte des Blancs grand cru Chardonnay is complemented by a small share of Montagne de Reims fruit from Villers-Marmery. Youthful, pale green in colour. The fruit purity and delicacy are impeccable from the first nose onwards: lime zest, floral fragrance, green apple and even some green fruit such as gooseberry and pear. All is crowned by the prettiest whiff of super-stylish toastiness. The palate is suitably lightweight, continuing on the path of ultimate finesse, purity and delicacy. Silky smooth and caressing the palate, this is long and juicy, finishing on a precise, dry note. There is much more to come here, but the wine is already perfectly delightful. Dosage 7g/l”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2013 Amour de Deutz Blanc de Blancs, a delicate, charming Champagne, reveals a gourmand, fruit bouquet with aromas of ripe orchard fruits, menthol, sweet spices, lemon oil and white pepper. Its medium-bodied palate is both charming and enveloping, with a pure and salty texture that is underpinned by chalky extract on the finish.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Millésimé Amour de Deutz shows how compelling Chardonnay is in the 2013 vintage. Rich and creamy, with striking tropical nuances, the 2013 is both exotic and vibrant. Tangerine peel, lemon confit, marzipan, jasmine and passion fruit are some of the many notes that develop with some coaxing. Bracing graphite-tinged mineral notes open with some time in the glass. The 2013 Amour de Deutz is one of the best in recent memory. I loved it. ”
17.5
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2023
“A serious fizz with deeply carved contours of flavour and structure. More smoke-and-stones minerality than most of the 20-odd sparkling wines (mostly champagne) that I’m tasting today. Salted lemons, lemon marmalade. Firm and classic and fabulous. (TC)”
“75cl - Harvested in October, the 2013 Amour de Deutz—disgorged in September 2022 with a dosage of seven grams per liter—has evolved beautifully with additional post-disgorgement maturation. Based heavily on the Côte des Blancs fruit, it offers a profound bouquet of candied lemon, peach, pear, roasted pineapple and gooseberry layered with roasted cacao bean and smoky accents that underscore its subtly reductive signature. These olfactory impressions transition seamlessly onto the medium- to full-bodied palate, which is unusually generous in context of the vintage: fleshy, multidimensional and with a sweet fruit core enlivened with pinpoint mousse. This Blanc de Blancs culminates in a lingering, toasty finish, rendering it irresistibly approachable even at this early stage.”
More Reviews +
96-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2022
“75cl - Deutz excels in blanc de blancs, and Amour de Deutz epitomises the house's Chardonnay elegance. Here, Côte des Blancs grand cru Chardonnay is complemented by a small share of Montagne de Reims fruit from Villers-Marmery. Youthful, pale green in colour. The fruit purity and delicacy are impeccable from the first nose onwards: lime zest, floral fragrance, green apple and even some green fruit such as gooseberry and pear. All is crowned by the prettiest whiff of super-stylish toastiness. The palate is suitably lightweight, continuing on the path of ultimate finesse, purity and delicacy. Silky smooth and caressing the palate, this is long and juicy, finishing on a precise, dry note. There is much more to come here, but the wine is already perfectly delightful. Dosage 7g/l ”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Jun 2024
“75cl - A rich Champagne, with a lush, almost viscous creaminess, nicely reined in by vivid, mouthwatering acidity—a finely knit frame for flavors of white peach purée, passion fruit, toasted brioche, and accents of elderflower, fleur de sel, and candied grapefruit peel. Long, lingering finish.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“75cl - A rich Champagne, with a lush, almost viscous creaminess, nicely reined in by vivid, mouthwatering acidity—a finely knit frame for flavors of white peach purée, passion fruit, toasted brioche, and accents of elderflower, fleur de sel, and candied grapefruit peel. Long, lingering finish.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Millésimé Amour de Deutz is every bit as expressive as it was last year. Hints of candied lemon peel, passion fruit and tangerine zest give the 2013 subtle exoticness that’s balanced by the wine's driving, bright acids. Now past its first decade, the 2013 remains very youthful. What a gorgeous Champagne it is. ”
96-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
essiavellan.com,
Aug 2022
“Deutz excels in blanc de blancs, and Amour de Deutz epitomises the house's Chardonnay elegance. Here, Côte des Blancs grand cru Chardonnay is complemented by a small share of Montagne de Reims fruit from Villers-Marmery. Youthful, pale green in colour. The fruit purity and delicacy are impeccable from the first nose onwards: lime zest, floral fragrance, green apple and even some green fruit such as gooseberry and pear. All is crowned by the prettiest whiff of super-stylish toastiness. The palate is suitably lightweight, continuing on the path of ultimate finesse, purity and delicacy. Silky smooth and caressing the palate, this is long and juicy, finishing on a precise, dry note. There is much more to come here, but the wine is already perfectly delightful. Dosage 7g/l”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2013 Amour de Deutz Blanc de Blancs, a delicate, charming Champagne, reveals a gourmand, fruit bouquet with aromas of ripe orchard fruits, menthol, sweet spices, lemon oil and white pepper. Its medium-bodied palate is both charming and enveloping, with a pure and salty texture that is underpinned by chalky extract on the finish.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Millésimé Amour de Deutz shows how compelling Chardonnay is in the 2013 vintage. Rich and creamy, with striking tropical nuances, the 2013 is both exotic and vibrant. Tangerine peel, lemon confit, marzipan, jasmine and passion fruit are some of the many notes that develop with some coaxing. Bracing graphite-tinged mineral notes open with some time in the glass. The 2013 Amour de Deutz is one of the best in recent memory. I loved it. ”
17.5
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2023
“A serious fizz with deeply carved contours of flavour and structure. More smoke-and-stones minerality than most of the 20-odd sparkling wines (mostly champagne) that I’m tasting today. Salted lemons, lemon marmalade. Firm and classic and fabulous. (TC)”
“Deutz's newly released 2010 Brut Millésimé Amour de Deutz is very pretty, wafting from the glass with scents of citrus zest, white flowers, brioche and hazelnuts. Medium-bodied, pillowy and incisive, with a chiseled core of fruit, racy acids and a pinpoint mousse, it's a bright, fine-boned wine that represents a fine success in a rather challenging vintage.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Decanter,
decanter.com,
Mar 2021
“Classy wine filled with scents of citrus and brioche and hints of woodsmoke. The palate brings impressive soft bubbles and notes of citrus, praline and cream. Long, breezy and vivid finish with a persistent prickle of mousse. Kudos!”
97/100
Michael Edwards,
worldoffinewine.com,
Mar 2021
“Wonderfully pure and fresh – delights that as in all truly great Champagnes, it should never lose, just acquiring an extra patina of vinosity till 2030…without doubt a great wine and nowadays, maybe, the leader in the non-oaked school of Champagne making. A real treat.”
“Pale peachy colour. Gentle charred complexity on the nose which shows fresh white fruit and baking spices. Beautifully toasty showing fragrant gunpowdery undertones. Soft and gourmand, light-weight, lively palate. Juicy and delicious with a long length of pure fruitiness. ”
More Reviews +
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2009 Brut Rosé Millésimé Amour de Deutz is airy and gracious. Sweet red cherry, kirsch, mint, red flowers and vanillin are all nicely lifted throughout. The 2009 is quite pretty, but it is also a bit ethereal. Given the vintage, I expected more depth and richness. As it is, the 2009 is very attractive, but readers should expect a slightly nervous, clenched style.”
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2020
“The recently released 2009 Brut Rosé Millésime Amour de Deutz is showing beautifully, wafting from the glass with a classy bouquet of citrus oil, crisp red apple, warm brioche, sourdough bread and dried rose petals. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, fine-boned and elegant, with racy acids, a pretty core of fruit, a delicate mousse and a deceptively long finish. Understated but displaying terrific finesse, this wine exemplifies the Deutz style.”
18+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jul 2026
“Such expressive fruit, dried raspberry and some redcurrant with a soft peachy core of texture; this champagne seems to be at a perfect drinking phase. The fruit and chalkiness waft across the palate with bright minerality on the finish. Enjoy now, but this has years ahead: Drink now to 2036+”
“The original Deutz prestige cuvée before the emergence of Amour de Deutz, Cuvée William Deutz highlights the house's Pinot Noir roots in the Montagne de Reims. Complex nose on the red-fruit side, with spiciness and pastry tones adding to the developing fruitiness. Red apple, strawberry, vanilla and woody tones. The palate is playful and energetic, with a joyous lightness to it, despite the fruity intensity and a touch of aromatic austerity. Silky and long, this finishes on a sweet, fruity note. Dosage 7.5g/l”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2023
“Punchy, intense mineral nose. Very refreshing and well put together. Fine texture and a little more open than some 2013s. Beautiful balance. Super-refreshing. A relatively delicate, Pinot Noir-based champagne.”
96/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Nov 2023
“Discreet and nuanced nose, showing lemon-curd, brioche and pie-crust notes. A hint of savory umami, too. Beautiful integration of autolysis with the fruit. Subtle and creamy, with a really fine, nicely woven perlage that is closely knit with the zesty citrus fruit. Elegant, chalky and long, with a gentle and mouthwatering finish. There is power even it is more about finesse and elegance here. Drink now or hold.”
94/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2023
“A mature Champagne that has fine, ripe white fruits set against a mineral edge. The wine's lightly toasty character is now integrated with the fruit. It is ready to drink. ”
“(Tasted in magnum) Bottles of Cuvée William Deutz are exquisite enough, but the magnums come with the additional charm of an amazingly creamy texture and refreshing zinginess. Polished pristine fruitiness on the nose. Plentiful and driven at the same time, with fine smoky complexity framing the whole. The finish is dry and pure, ending on a cool, saline note. ”
More Reviews +
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2021
“Cuvée William Deutz carries the 2008 vintage’s signature of elegance and vivacity. It seems to be so slowly ageing with its youthful, crunchy red apple fruitiness that comes with refreshing sweet lemon, baked pear and vanilla notes. There is lightness and drive to the lacy and fruit-packed palate. A smart and age-worthy vintage of Cuvée William Deutz.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“If there were such a thing as salty red apple flesh, this would be it. There is an exquisite combination of fruit and chalkiness, of generosity and stone that is immediately evident on the nose. The palate has all the poise of 2008, all of the freshness and sense of eternity. Air allows notions of salted, roasted cashew to appear while the finish speaks of precision, linearity and depth. A class act.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2022
“Very mouth-filling and more lifted and lacy than the 2011 Amour de Deutz. A hedonistic aperitif? I can just imagine sinking into a red velvet seat in Paris with a glass of this. A very light touch on the ageing button… Drink 2021 – 2027
”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Apr 2021
“This is incredibly long and beautiful. It’s full-bodied, but comes across with so much finesse and complexity. It goes on for minutes. Compressed with very fine phenolics. One for the cellar.”
94/100
Wineenthusiast.com,
Wineenthusiast.com,
Mar 2021
“A high proportion of Pinot Noir gives this Deutz prestige cuvée richness as well as a strong green fruit character. Citrus, green apples and intense acidity underpin this finely understated wine. ”
“(Tasted in magnum) Bottles of Cuvée William Deutz are exquisite enough, but the magnums come with the additional charm of an amazingly creamy texture and refreshing zinginess. Polished pristine fruitiness on the nose. Plentiful and driven at the same time, with fine smoky complexity framing the whole. The finish is dry and pure, ending on a cool, saline note. ”
More Reviews +
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2021
“Cuvée William Deutz carries the 2008 vintage’s signature of elegance and vivacity. It seems to be so slowly ageing with its youthful, crunchy red apple fruitiness that comes with refreshing sweet lemon, baked pear and vanilla notes. There is lightness and drive to the lacy and fruit-packed palate. A smart and age-worthy vintage of Cuvée William Deutz.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“If there were such a thing as salty red apple flesh, this would be it. There is an exquisite combination of fruit and chalkiness, of generosity and stone that is immediately evident on the nose. The palate has all the poise of 2008, all of the freshness and sense of eternity. Air allows notions of salted, roasted cashew to appear while the finish speaks of precision, linearity and depth. A class act.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2022
“Very mouth-filling and more lifted and lacy than the 2011 Amour de Deutz. A hedonistic aperitif? I can just imagine sinking into a red velvet seat in Paris with a glass of this. A very light touch on the ageing button… Drink 2021 – 2027
”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Apr 2021
“This is incredibly long and beautiful. It’s full-bodied, but comes across with so much finesse and complexity. It goes on for minutes. Compressed with very fine phenolics. One for the cellar.”
94/100
Wineenthusiast.com,
Wineenthusiast.com,
Mar 2021
“A high proportion of Pinot Noir gives this Deutz prestige cuvée richness as well as a strong green fruit character. Citrus, green apples and intense acidity underpin this finely understated wine. ”
“The 2019 Brut Rosé Millésime is creamy, pliant and wonderfully inviting from the first taste. Cranberry, white pepper, citrus peel and crushed rocks race across the palate. The 2019 is a versatile Rosé; it will drink beautifully as an apéritif but also has the mid-palate pliancy and seriousness to be a fine choice for the dinner table.”
“Charming and expressive, Deutz's 2014 Brut Millésimé bursts from the glass with aromas of fresh peach, citrus oil, ripe green apple, clear honey and pastry cream. Medium to full-bodied, elegantly fleshy and fine-boned, it's bright and lively, with a pinpoint mousse and a long, nicely defined finish.”
More Reviews +
16++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Smells very much more youthful than the Taittinger 2014. Not to say restrained. Very dry and bracing, and still pretty young. I’d ideally keep it for a while before broaching. Marked acidity but lots of fruit.”
“The Deutz 2012 Brut is a lovely entry-level vintage Champagne from Deutz. The white orchard fruit and floral notes confer freshness. Medium in body and light on its feet, the 2012 is a terrific choice for drinking over the next handful of years, while the flavors remain fresh. This is a very pretty wine from Deutz.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2017
“Deep gold. Deeply savoury and almost white burgundy-like on the nose. Very broachable and well balanced. No suggestion of excessive youth. Brisk but not tart.”
“The Deutz 2012 Brut is a lovely entry-level vintage Champagne from Deutz. The white orchard fruit and floral notes confer freshness. Medium in body and light on its feet, the 2012 is a terrific choice for drinking over the next handful of years, while the flavors remain fresh. This is a very pretty wine from Deutz.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2017
“Deep gold. Deeply savoury and almost white burgundy-like on the nose. Very broachable and well balanced. No suggestion of excessive youth. Brisk but not tart.”
“100% Pinot Noir from the Aube, grown organically in a first for the Union Auboise. 2019. Bright and dynamic with some crunchy pear, orange zest and almond, lifted with pale florals. A fresh and immediate style of Blanc de Noirs, with a slightly wild, naturalistic side helping to open up the style a little despite the youthfulness.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jan 2022
“With an almost pink hue in its straw colour, the wine shows its blanc de noirs nature. The nose is wonderfully fruit-driven, showing notes of Red Delicious apple and ripe, yellow stone fruit. These notions are bedded in a sense of creaminess that continues onto the palate. The body is fresh, crisp and slender, yet shows the generosity and roundness of Champagne’s south while fine, smooth bubbles drive the fruit even further forward. A lovely style that is as suited to aperitif as it is to lighter meals.”
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This Côte des Bar blanc de noirs is the very first organically certified cuvée from Devaux. On the curiously fragrant nose, zingy rhubarb tones mix with sweet red-fruit characters of strawberry and apple. The palate feels drier than the nose suggests and is a little simple and short. Highly youthful and primary but also friendly and fragrant, putting the supple Côtes des Bar Pinot fruit to the fore. Dosage 4g/l”
91/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“Dried lemon, green apple, walnut and white strawberry here with salted butter, too. Crisp and bright with fine bubbles. Tangy and vibrant finish. From organically grown grapes. Dry.”
“Notes of both Golden Delicious and Granny Smith apples fill the nose with their respective ripeness and freshness. The palate is slender, almost delicate, and vivid with the fresher rather than the riper apple notes. The mousse is fine and lively, supporting and underlining the fruit-driven yet-elegant style of this wine. The wood influence is beyond subtle and beautifully handled. An ideal, understated and refreshing aperitif.”
More Reviews +
90/100
Josh Reynolds,
vinous.com,
Jan 2015
“Bright yellow-gold. Ripe orange, poached pear and vanilla on the deeply perfumed nose. Fleshy and open-knit, offering pliant orchard and pit fruit flavors braced and lifted by juicy acidity. At once rich and lively, with the vanilla note repeating on the smooth, toasty finish. Just over one-third of this blend is barrel-fermented reserve wine.”
93/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2022
“Attractive nose of caramelised apples, dried apricots, pastries, shortbread, praline and some roasted vanilla bean. Some saline notes, too. Medium-to full-bodied with bright acidity and silky bubbles. Sleek and well integrated.”
90/100
Roger Voss,
wineenthusiast.com,
Dec 2020
“The five years of aging in bottle and the 40% reserve wine have given this rich blend of Pinot Noir and Champagne great balance as well as intensity and ripeness. The wine is ready to drink.”
“In keeping with Devaux's dry style, this crisp rosé is bone dry, with a strong mineral edge as well as red-currant flavors that are now shining through. With a little bottle age, it is now softening while retaining all its fruitiness.”
“This 2019-based wine comes from two lieux-dits in Cramant, La Garennes and Les Longues Verges. There is an attractive shyness to the nose, promising a lot. The chalky toned peach and yellow-plum nose handle the oaky notes very well. There is a fine toastiness waiting to emerge with time in the glass. Quite the powerhouse on the palate, with such tightness speaking of longevity. This is fresh and feisty but at the same time superbly concentrated and gourmand. There is a chalky bite to the texture and a tickly sensation from the creamy-energetic mousse, refreshing the dense whole. This is a complete and characterful wine with an even finer future ahead.”
More Reviews +
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit and mirabelle plum mingle with notions of freshly baked bread, almond paste and white flowers in an inviting bouquet that introduces Dhondt's NV Extra-Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cramant (2019), a full-bodied, ample and pillowy Champagne that unites texture, generous racy acids and a chalky structure. Seamless and complete, it concludes with a long, mineral finish.”
“Adrien’s Cramant cuvée always comes with such packed fruitiness, and more so in the lush, sun-kissed 2020 vintage. Here, there are none of the vegetal markers common to the base year, which makes up 80 percent of the blend. Instead, there is bursting fruitiness, with plenty of ripe orange fruit charm. Mirabelle plums alongside kumquat, tropical fruit and marmalade. The oak stands rather prominent on this wine. Boldly expressive on the voluminous palate with oily generosity to the texture. The sensation of freshness increases towards the back palate, with the wine ending on a lovely saline lemony bite.”
More Reviews +
94+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“The NV Extra-Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cramant (2020) was disgorged this year with less than one gram per liter dosage. Exhibiting aromas of pear, orange zest, toasted hazelnuts and dried white flowers, it's medium to full-bodied, ample and fleshy, with a seamless, enveloping profile and a long, saline finish. It's another brilliant wine from Adrien Dhondt.”
“The NV Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cramant is sourced from two lieux-dits: La Garenne (planted in 1969 and 1970), defined by deep sandy-clay topsoil, and Les Longues Verges (planted in 1985), with chalkier soil but reduced yields due to le court-noué virus. The stricter, more incisive profile of La Garenne is balanced by the concentration and broad-shouldered musculature of Les Longues Verges. Disgorged in July 2024 with 2.5 grams per liter dosage, this new release is based on the 2021 vintage, complemented by 30% of a historical blend. Concentrated and textural, it’s framed by a patina from maturation in barrels (around one-third new). Despite the high-acid vintage base, the wine is expressive and harmonious, offering notes of lemon zest, cedar nut, smoke and toast. It has a bright, lively personality, concluding with an immensely long, saline finish. Its quality and potential are a testament both the judicious élevage and the visionary work in the vineyards.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Feb 2025
“The 2021 edition of Adrien Dhondt’s Cramant gets replenished with 30% of reserve wines from a perpetual reserve. A blend of two vineyard sites and wholly fermented in oak as all his wines, it comes with fruity power and supporting savouriness. Predominantly appley, there is a whiff of toffee, smoke and lemon peel adding to its complexities. Equally pronounced on the palate, there is velvety vinosity to its texture as well as a strong acid line of the harvest year. Base vintage: 2021.”
“Disgorged in January 2020 with three grams per liter dosage, the NV Extra-Brut Dans un Premier Temps (2018) is excellent, bursting with aromas of peach, citrus oil, white flowers, fresh bread and stone fruit. Medium to full-bodied, ample and layered, with a demonstrative core of fruit and succulent acids, it's vinous and enveloping, drinking especially well out of the gates.”
“Chardonnay for this cuvée was grown in the Sézannais, while the Pinot Noir originates in Avenay-Val-d'Or and the Meunier in Cuis. A third from the house's perpetual reserve initiated in 1986 complements the 2019 base wine. The nose is beautifully expressive, with cool and crunchy appley fruitiness alongside emerging toastiness and a touch of wood. The palate plays less on fruit than on mineral notes, being well built, structured and full of character. Well balanced by fresh acidity and a fleshy, dense texture, the wine ends on a dry, chalky finish.”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Bursting with aromas of freshly baked bread, green apple, pear, warm biscuits and wet stones, Dhondt's NV Extra-Brut Dans un Premier Temps (2019) is medium to full-bodied, broad and textural, with a gourmand, enveloping core of fruit, lively acids and a long, sapid finish. A layered, vinous wine, animated by a pinpoint mousse, it's the finest rendition of this cuvée to date.”
“The 2018 Blanc de Blancs Premier Cru Les Nogers is vinous and demonstrative, bursting from the glass with aromas of peach, white flowers, honeycomb, warm bread and toasted hazelnuts. Full-bodied, broad and fleshy, it's ample and enveloping, with a layered core of fruit, impressive depth at the core and a resonant but precise finish. The open, giving style of the vintage makes this release especially charming, but it doesn't come at the expense of intensity of energy.”
“The 2012 Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Premier Cru Les Nogers goes from strength to strength, unfurling in the glass with scents of preserved lemon, walnut oil, dried white flowers, iodine and toasted bread. Full-bodied, vinous and textural, with an enveloping core of fruit, superb concentration and bright girdling acids, this is a brilliant Champagne that meets the high expectations I formed of it several years ago.”
More Reviews +
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“2013 | Disgorged in Decmember 2018 with 2.8 grams per liter dosage, the 2013 Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Premier Cru Les Nogers displays notes of fresh peach, crushed chalk, beeswax and walnut oil. On the palate, it's full-bodied, deep and multidimensional, with racy acids, chalky structuring extract and a long, mineral finish. From a Cuis lieu-dit that segues from sandy to chalky soils as one ascends the slope, this is a formidable Blanc de Blancs in the making.”
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2020
“2014 | Disgorged in October 2019 with 2.5 grams per liter dosage, the 2014 Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Premier Cru Les Nogers is showing beautifully, offering up an expressive bouquet of fresh peach, ripe lemons, golden orchard fruit and hazelnuts. Full-bodied, rich and fleshy, it's vinous and enveloping, with a concentrated core of ripe fruit, elegantly muscular structure and a fine, pinpoint mousse. Long and expansive, this derives from 50-year-old vines from a northeast-exposed lieu-dit in Cuis, characterized by chalky soils with pockets of sand. It's another brilliant Champagne from Adrien Dhondt.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2018
“The 2012 Extra Brut Les Nogers Premier Cru Blanc de Blancs, 100% old-vine Chardonnay from Cuis, is fabulous. The radiance of the vintage and the natural richness these 55 year-old vines confer yields a super-expressive, structured Champagne full of personality and character. Dense and voluptuous on the palate, yet also nuanced, the 2012 has a lot to offer. In this tasting, it is superb. Tropical overtones, chamomile and honey add closing shades of complexity to this deep, vertical Champagne. Disgorged: March, 2018.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2019
“2013 | A positively stunning Champagne, the 2013 Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Premier Cru Les Nogers emerges from 55-year-old vines in Cuis. In the glass, the 2013 is explosive and just drenched with all sorts of mineral-infused citrus/floral notes. There is a translucency to the 2013 that is absolutely beguiling. Disgorged: December, 2018.”
“This is Adrien Dhondt’s biggest production cuvee originating in a number of plots in Cuis and the nearby Grauves. Deep golden hued colour. The nose is open and expressive with peachy fruit enriched by candied citrus and patisserie, the rich whole being supported by a fine woody undertone. The wine’s most impressive feature is the superbly creamy mousse, which lingers persistently until a salty saline sensation takes over, cleansing and energizing the palate. Base vintage: 2021.”
“50% Pinot Noir, 50% Chardonnay. Disgorged April 2013.
Deeper straw than the regular 1996 vintage Dom P. Much more expressive on the nose, although with lots of evidence of age. Complete and fresh on the palate – much more youthful than the regular 1996. For perfection I’d choose the nose of this and the palate of the regular! Masses of acidity still in evidence. Exuberant, creamy wine with no hurry to drink it. 12%
Drink 2016-2030”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2015
“This bottle seemed to have broadened out and to taste almost rich - although admittedly it had spent a year or two in slightly warm storage conditions. Some crème patissière quality though with lots of acidity too. Even a hint of marzipan. To drink rather than hold, I think.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Oct 2014
“The 1996 Dom Pérignon Oenothèque has really turned a corner over the last six months or so. When it was originally introduced the 1996 was hard as nails, today it is an exquisite Champagne that captures the essential brightness and energy of the year. Lemon, slate, oyster shells and white flowers stain the palate in an intense, beautifully sculpted Champagne of the highest level.”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2014
“Deluxe Brut Blend. 50% Pinot Noir, 50% Chardonnay. The densest wine we tasted at this presentation of World Champions. So dense it's almost rigid! Yet it is wonderfully racy. Beautiful balance, very vibrant and reverberant with the most extraordinary persistence. Lovely lacy texture. Bravo! Dosage was apparently 6.5 g/l.”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2014
“Superbly toasty, highly expressive nose packed with sweet gunpowder, aromatic wood, ginger and mineral notes. Long and linear structure coming with super high, perfectly lined acidity. Lean, zesty and expansive. Highly youthful still, full of unreleased energy. Constantly improving. At CSWWC we awarded it as the World Champion Deluxe brut. I have come across several corked bottles, which makes me recommend this less whole-heartedly as I would based on a perfect bottle.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“The 1996 Dom Pérignon Oenothèque has really come around since I last tasted it some months ago. Up until recently, the 1996 was hard as nails. Over the last few months things have developed for the better, as the fruit is now much more expressive, within the context of the year, of course. The 1996 Oenothèque remains compact, but today there is great beauty to be found in the yellow stone fruit, slate, white flowers and lightly honeyed overtones that grace the finish.”
100/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Sep 2013
“This shows amazing freshness and depth of fruit while remaining agile and very clean. Full body, dense and layered on the palate. Goes on for minutes with each sip. Lots of mineral and chalk character too. A fabulous Champagne. A blend of half Pinot Noir and half Chardonnay.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Dec 2010
“The 1996 Dom Pérignon Œenothèque offers up layers of pastry, lemon, smoke and toastiness. At first deceptively understated, the wine turns positively explosive and layered on the palate, showing remarkable tension, elegance and power, all wrapped around a seriously intense frame. The balance between fruit and acidity is awesome. This is a marvelous DP Œeno. The Œeno is the same juice as the regular Dom Pérignon, except the Œeno is aged on the cork while the regular DP is aged in crown-sealed bottles. Once disgorged, the Œenos get a slightly lower dosage than is typical for the original release DP. This bottle was disgorged in 2008.”
96/100
Bruce Sanderson,
Wine Spectator,
Oct 2011
“Its complexity was immediately apparent on the bouquet, offering butterscotch, toast and mineral elements. An extremely well-balanced ’96, without the high-acid profile of the vintage, the flavours evoked candied citrus, seashore and smoke, reminding me of a great Corton-Charlemagne”
99/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2010
“A magnificent Champagne, one that is light, delicate, yet packed with character. It is beautifully balanced, with a bone-dry character, just softened by the toastiness that is developing. Expect this to age for many years”
“50% Pinot Noir, 50% Chardonnay. Disgorged April 2013.
Deeper straw than the regular 1996 vintage Dom P. Much more expressive on the nose, although with lots of evidence of age. Complete and fresh on the palate – much more youthful than the regular 1996. For perfection I’d choose the nose of this and the palate of the regular! Masses of acidity still in evidence. Exuberant, creamy wine with no hurry to drink it. 12%
Drink 2016-2030”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2015
“This bottle seemed to have broadened out and to taste almost rich - although admittedly it had spent a year or two in slightly warm storage conditions. Some crème patissière quality though with lots of acidity too. Even a hint of marzipan. To drink rather than hold, I think.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Oct 2014
“The 1996 Dom Pérignon Oenothèque has really turned a corner over the last six months or so. When it was originally introduced the 1996 was hard as nails, today it is an exquisite Champagne that captures the essential brightness and energy of the year. Lemon, slate, oyster shells and white flowers stain the palate in an intense, beautifully sculpted Champagne of the highest level.”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2014
“Deluxe Brut Blend. 50% Pinot Noir, 50% Chardonnay. The densest wine we tasted at this presentation of World Champions. So dense it's almost rigid! Yet it is wonderfully racy. Beautiful balance, very vibrant and reverberant with the most extraordinary persistence. Lovely lacy texture. Bravo! Dosage was apparently 6.5 g/l.”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2014
“Superbly toasty, highly expressive nose packed with sweet gunpowder, aromatic wood, ginger and mineral notes. Long and linear structure coming with super high, perfectly lined acidity. Lean, zesty and expansive. Highly youthful still, full of unreleased energy. Constantly improving. At CSWWC we awarded it as the World Champion Deluxe brut. I have come across several corked bottles, which makes me recommend this less whole-heartedly as I would based on a perfect bottle.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“The 1996 Dom Pérignon Oenothèque has really come around since I last tasted it some months ago. Up until recently, the 1996 was hard as nails. Over the last few months things have developed for the better, as the fruit is now much more expressive, within the context of the year, of course. The 1996 Oenothèque remains compact, but today there is great beauty to be found in the yellow stone fruit, slate, white flowers and lightly honeyed overtones that grace the finish.”
100/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Sep 2013
“This shows amazing freshness and depth of fruit while remaining agile and very clean. Full body, dense and layered on the palate. Goes on for minutes with each sip. Lots of mineral and chalk character too. A fabulous Champagne. A blend of half Pinot Noir and half Chardonnay.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Dec 2010
“The 1996 Dom Pérignon Œenothèque offers up layers of pastry, lemon, smoke and toastiness. At first deceptively understated, the wine turns positively explosive and layered on the palate, showing remarkable tension, elegance and power, all wrapped around a seriously intense frame. The balance between fruit and acidity is awesome. This is a marvelous DP Œeno. The Œeno is the same juice as the regular Dom Pérignon, except the Œeno is aged on the cork while the regular DP is aged in crown-sealed bottles. Once disgorged, the Œenos get a slightly lower dosage than is typical for the original release DP. This bottle was disgorged in 2008.”
96/100
Bruce Sanderson,
Wine Spectator,
Oct 2011
“Its complexity was immediately apparent on the bouquet, offering butterscotch, toast and mineral elements. An extremely well-balanced ’96, without the high-acid profile of the vintage, the flavours evoked candied citrus, seashore and smoke, reminding me of a great Corton-Charlemagne”
99/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2010
“A magnificent Champagne, one that is light, delicate, yet packed with character. It is beautifully balanced, with a bone-dry character, just softened by the toastiness that is developing. Expect this to age for many years”
“In 2008 there was no clear dominance for Pinot Noirs origins and Hautvillers only contributes a small proportion to the blend. For Chardonnays, Chouilly, Cramant and Le Mesnil play a big role alongside Sillery, which is unusually prominent this year. The nose is captivating with glorious yeasty, reductive complexity and notes of sweet lemon-curd pastry, vanilla, and a touch of crunchy pineapple. The palate is rich and silken, lifted by a beam of laser-like acidity and a sizzling sensation of minerality. It stretches beautifully across the palate, concluding with a mouth-watering citrus twist. A glorious Dom Pérignon, where the extra time on lees has contributed exceptional fullness and texturedness.
”
More Reviews +
100/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jun 2026
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon P2 is a stunning, riveting wine. Bright, crystalline and focused, the 2008 dazzles from start to finish. Crushed rocks, slate, mint, dried herbs, lemon oil and oyster shell sizzle with tension. A Champagne of linear focus and cut, the 2008 is absolutely stunning. The original release of the 2008 was a total knockout; now, some years later, the P2 edition takes all of its inherent qualities and amplifies them, while also adding new layers of complexity. This is unforgettably profound.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon P2 is another sublime Champagne from Dom Pérignon. Long lees-aging on the cork softened the edges that the original 2008 release showed as a young Champagne. The two 2008s (original release and P2) paint two very different but equally compelling portraits of the vintage. The P2 possesses notable textural density and a level of mid-palate intensity that the 2008 does not offer. The P2 is not necessarily better than the original release, but it is quite contrasting in style. It may be that in a very high-quality vintage, extended time in bottle does not add as much as it does in slightly lesser years.”
97+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“A wine I’m inclined to call “long-range,” the 2008 Dom Pérignon Pleenitude 2—an equal blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, disgorged in March 2024 with a dosage of five grams per liter—has fulfilled its considerable promise. Born of a cool, slow-ripening season that endowed the wine with its incisive acid spine and raciness, perfected through the selection of origins that contribute the texture and plenitude only real maturity can impart, it wafts from the glass with aromas of orange, nashi pear, honeysuckle and toasted hazelnut, mingling with brioche and a touch of smoky reduction. On the palate, it is full-bodied, multifaceted and vividly bright, with a layered, concentrated core of fruit, its ripe yet racy acids and pinpoint mousse carrying it to a long, searingly chalky finish.
If the 1996 Plenitude 2 was a success at Dom Pérignon, then the 2008 Plenitude 2 appears to surpass that, ranking among the greatest achievements of Richard Geoffroy, the house’s former cellar master. All in all, it is more energetic and incisive than the 2002 Plenitude 2 was on release, and anyone fortunate enough to secure a bottle will have no difficulty finishing it.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2025
“This late-release version of the magnificent 2008 is to be put on the market commercially in 2026. Disgorged in 2024 with a dosage of less than 5 g/l – like all four of these 2026 releases. A famous 'classic' vintage. The product of a season that saw cloudy weather for much of it with considerable mildew pressure. Then there was a great September that saved the vintage – a Champagne miracle. A sunny last three weeks changed the mood in Champagne. 'Climate change has been giving more flesh and length to the wines', according to Vincent Chaperon who said that he and the then chef de cave Richard Geoffroy used to liken this wine's muscle to the athlete Usain Bolt.
Greenish hue. Very concentrated and evolved, lightly smoky and creates an immediate impression. Dry, serious finish. Extremely tight bead. Very bright fruit. Citrus, even lime. A wine that is tightening up, a bit like a drawstring with tension – like when a bow is drawn back by an arrow. A very grown-up Dom Pérignon. (JR)”
98/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
Oct 2025
“The extra seven years of ageing on lees under cork versus the original Dom Pérignon 2008 release has wrapped up all the
year's innate tension and brightness in an unabashedly decadent, enveloping richness of toasted nuts, fresh dough and
gentle oyster cream, although the precision and integrity of the vintage is absolutely present too. There are beautiful
aromas of pure red strawberry and bergamot with some darker mocha notes emerging, both Chardonnay linearity and a
surprisingly fragrant Pinot finding a perfect equilibrium. The palate carries the buzzing acidity of 2008 on a time-softened,
ultra-silky mousse, with new details of umami savour tucked in subtly to the overall impression of glacial freshness.
Perhaps unsurprisingly given the reputation of the original release, this is among the most memorable and energetic of The
Plénitude released made since the program of late releases took the name in 2014.”
“The 2006 Dom Pérignon P2 is magnificent. Rich and soaring in its intensity, the P2 is absolutely stunning. What comes through most is the style of the year more than the style of the P2 series. Tangerine, apricot, mint, white pepper, passionfruit and spice all race out of the glass. The ripeness of the year is evident, but all the elements are so masterfully balanced. The balance of exoticness and freshness is just mind-blowing. ”
More Reviews +
99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“Gloriously toasty nose on this Dom Pérignon, which has a slight Pinot Noir dominance over Chardonnay. Coconut, mocha, fireworks – there are lots of complex layers to this fruity number. Pristine, sumptuous fresh orchard fruit, but also exotic nuances. So smooth and caressing on the textured palate. The perfect silky flow drives this structured wine to its long finish. Here, the long time on lees has really done miracles in adding incredible richness and texture. This wine is so delicious that you just want to drink it, but it has ageing potential, too, in all its phenolic structure, plush fruitiness and balancing freshness. Dosage: 5g/l”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
Decanter.com,
May 2024
“The 2006 Dom Pérignon P2, crafted from a blend of 55% Pinot Noir and 45% Chardonnay with a modest dosage of 4.5 grams, is presenting exceptionally well at this stage. It unfurls a complex, deep bouquet of smoke, ripe orchard fruits, mango, exotic fruits and spices. Medium to full-bodied, rich and expressive, it’s harmonious and enveloping and has gained structure and tension compared to the initial 2006 Dom Pérignon, while the palate is perfectly balanced with delicate gastronomic bitterness and chalky dry extracts that contribute to its long, mineral-driven finish. It should go well with delicate fare. P2 is the acronym for the Plénitude 2 series, Dom Pérignon’s second life, indicating that bottles are kept by the house to let them age on the lees and to obtain different expressions of the same wine throughout its life, letting time work its magic and thus acquiring additional complexity.”
99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“The magic of extended lees ageing is on full display in the 2006 P2, a wine that radiates Dom Perignon’s signature elegance. The nose is infused with an stunning yeasty richness, finely tuned on the reductive side, its maturity expressed through refined tertiary nuances yet free from any sign of fatigue. Beneath, a core of vibrant fruit still pulses with energy, the exotic spectrum of mango and pineapple gaining prominence. On the palate, the mousse is feather-light and cushiony, lending breath and vivacity to the wine’s opulent depth. Caressing in texture and crafted to seduce, it is irresistibly drinkable now, yet fully capable of evolving with grace for years to come. Dosage:5g/l.”
97/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“The 2006 Dom Perignon Pleenitude 2, disgorged in early 2023 with a dosage of five grams per liter, is showing beautifully today. It wafts from the glass with a deep bouquet of toasted hazelnut, tangerine, peach and dried flowers, mingling with wheat toast, mocha and subtle inflections of passion fruit, all framed by a smoky reduction. On the palate, the wine is full-bodied and ample yet vibrant, with a generous core of fruit, ripe but lively acids and a pinpoint mousse. It concludes with a long, delicately phenolic finish in which attractive aromatic bitters assert themselves.
This is a charming vintage that has often been overlooked, yet in its P2 iteration, it is considerably less evolved today than some might assume, also presenting drier and more aromatically defined than the original release. It delivers the structural presence one associates with the season while also offering appreciable cut—and it is also a wine that can age. It is less nakedly chalky than the 2008 Plenitude 2, yet it remains appealing in its own distinct register.”
“This hot-weather vintage was received with scepticism, but the winemaking team always believed in its greatness and longevity. The super-soft, harmonious nose has a subtle caffe latte toasty whiff that perfectly complements the luscious fruit. Extraordinary yeasty complexity brings on spicy hay and honey layers. The whole is so smooth and caressing yet perfecly pure and bright, still full of energy. There is a slight touch of tannin on the back palate, bringing grip and the potential for ageing. It all carries into the extended finish, with all the elements remaining plentiful and in harmony. In bloom today, this will take time very well. Dosage 5g/l”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“The notoriously daring vintage of Dom Pérignon at 18 years old in recently disgorged form. Rich, broad nose with notes of candied mandarin – not instantly recognizable as Dom P on the nose. Toasty palate entry and still quite rich on the palate, thanks to lower than usual acidity presumably. Again, there was no fear of phenolics when making this wine as the logic was that the phenolics would make up for the softness of the acidity. This is now a gentle wine with very much its own personality. Soft and smoky at the start and then saline and refreshing on the finish. It's more like a bit of told-you-so evidence than, necessarily, the one Dom P you would choose from the current range available. But, boy, does it persist!”
98/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Apr 2021
“This is a very thick, dense Dom Pérignon with layers of ripe fruit. Dried apple, pineapple and pie crust with some nougat undertones. Dense and layered with chewy tannins and a juicy finish. Umami undertone. This has the highest percentage of Pinot Noir ever. 15 years on the lees in bottle. 62% Pinot Noir and 38% Chardonnay.”
96-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2021
“This vintage is the one Richard Geoffroy is the proudest of as it was such a challenging and unprecedentedly hot year. There is nothing heavy in Dom Pérignon of the year. The nose is stunningly toasty with sweet, vanilla laden fruit, hay, cookie dough and cream. On the palate it is exuberant, round and textured with a touch of firming phenolics on the back palate. Finely bubbling energetic palate finishing on a pure mineral freshness. ”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“The 2003 Dom Pérignon P2 takes all the natural intensity of the first release and turns the dial up to eleven. Power, generosity and volume are all exalted. The P2 balances richness with a greater sense of creaminess that comes through extended time on the cork. Readers should expect a ample, heady Champagne that is very much built for the dinner table. I can't say I am especially surprised by how well the P2 shows, even in this freakishly hot, dry year, as the first release continues to be terrific.”
“The 2002 Dom Pérignon P2 is wonderfully open in its aromatics, but a bit less giving on the palate, especially next to the regular release. Lemon confit, white flowers, mint and white pepper open up first, followed by hints of apricot, honey, chamomile and light tropical notes. Interestingly, the P2 is quite a bit less tropical than the original release. Chef de Caves Vincent Chaperon told me he thinks the original release shows more of a buttery character because of the combination of the ripeness of the vintage and the natural evolution of the wine post-disgorgement under crown seal, as opposed to the P2 which stayed much longer on its lees. It is hard to know if that is an exact explanation, but the reality is that the two 2002s are quite far apart stylistically.”
More Reviews +
97-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2020
“Stunningly rich and pristinely fruity leesy and toasty nose with plenty of age impact. Multi-faceted showing hay, honey, candied lemon and butter. Fine intense creaminess on the sumptuous but linear and persistent finish that shows increasing minerality towards the end. Soft and caressing. At a lovely drinking phase in 75cl bottle, highly youthful in magnum.”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“To be released later in 2019.
Deep straw. Very much in its mature phase with intense Dom P character, as though a tincture of Dom P! Creamy and round without a single edge to it, Almost spherical in impression and shape. Where lemon meets bergamot on the nose, and both delicate in texture and rich in flavour on the palate. Pure pleasure. Exceptionally long. A bit of a triumph really. A great legacy.”
20/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“This was a preview of a wine soon to be released. Richard Geoffroy was told P2 was ‘beyond champagne’ which he didn’t like – he feels it’s Dom Pérignon but more so. Great drive and line. A really linear wine that initially seemed like a corseted version of 2002 but is actually so intense and concentrated that is tastes like Dom Pérignon squared.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2019
“The 2002 Dom Pérignon P2 is still a youthful wine, but it is beginning to develop appreciable complexity, wafting from the glass with notes of of iodine, warm bread, ripe orchard fruit, peach, citrus oil, smoke and peat, which in Geoffroy's words "are on the verge of aromatic over-ripeness." On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, broad and fleshy, with a textural, voluminous profile, pinpoint bubbles and a chalky, phenolic finish. This is a ripe and powerful Dom Pérignon that finds its closest stylistic analogy in the 1990 vintage, and it is considerably less evolved than the more tertiary 2000 P2 today. While the P2 is a bit drier and more precise on the finish than the original release, given the wine's slow evolution the difference between the two is less pronounced than it has been for any vintage since 1996.”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Now this is Dom P at its most classic! Biscuity nose with butter and biscuit dough but with great freshness and delicacy too. Really lovely. Great poise and – still – lots of tension!”
“The nose hooks you from the first sniff. So much going on there with DP’s hallmark fragrant toastiness running the show. Lovely layers of freshly ground coffee and grilled almonds. Underneath the ripe and mature fruity layers open up with honey, peach marmalade, orange peel and baked apple. There is leesy richness to the plushy texture but it is beautifully complemented by the wine’s energy and freshness. The finish is long, harmonious and invigorating. Truly a complete wine. ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“The 2000 Dom Pérignon P2 is striking. More importantly, it is absolutely delicious right now. Baked apple tart, brioche, spice, vanillin, ripe pear and crushed rocks all flesh out. Creamy, layered and inviting, with soft, voluptuous curves, the 2000 offers a lot of sheer pleasure. Although, perhaps not quite as complex or structured as the very best P2s, the 2000 is wonderfully alluring. Interestingly, in 2000, the Blanc and P2 are not as different as they typically are. The P2 has a bit more volume and freshness than the Blanc, but both wines share a distinct toasty, slightly reductive character. ”
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jan 2019
“The 2000 Dom Pérignon P2 is drinking beautifully, wafting from the glass with complex and gently reductive aromas of iodine, lemon oil, tangerine and oyster shell that have begun to develop appreciable tertiary nuance. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, deep and expansive, with a broad attack, incisive acids, a classy mousse and a long, precise and mouthwateringly saline finish. The year 2000 delivered a precocious Dom Pérignon, and this recently disgorged rendition has really benefited from the additional time sur lattes, acquiring notably more complexity—while retaining more energy—than the original disgorgement. Given its maturing profile I would plan to drink bottles within the next decade.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2017
“This late ‘Plenitude/P2’ release is a category for the house that is apparently ‘not flying but has decent recognition’. This release was disgorged in 2014, so had at least 12 years’ yeast maturation. It was launched in May 2017. ‘Yeast maturation is crucial to Dom Pérignon’, avows Geoffroy, who confessed he was a bit frustrated by the previous P2 release, of 1998, ‘but it’s come a long way’. (See my tasting note in this article on a bottle tasted recently).
A little darker than the regular 2000. Richer than the regular 2000 on the nose – and on the palate too. Smoky nose. Pungent. Very long and vibrating on the palate. Highly luxurious finish.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“Slate, crushed rocks, apricot jam, mint, honeysuckle and mint are some of the notes that run through the 2000 Dom Pérignon P2. Open-knit, racy and seductive, the 2000 is a rare P2 that will drink well right out of the gate. The reductive character from long aging on the lees that is such a P2 signature adds nuance without overpowering the wine. There is wonderful breadth and amplitude here. In sum, the 2000 presents a striking interplay of the maturity that develops over extended time on lees and freshness. The creamy, seamless finish only adds to the wine’s considerable immediacy and sheer appeal. Baked apple, toast, brioche, pear, smoke, slate and lemon confit add nuances throughout. What a gorgeous wine this is.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The 2000 Dom Pérignon P2 is decidedly exuberant. Ripe apricot, orange peel, pastry, baked apple, butter and vanillin all flesh out in this beautifully resonant, toasty edition of the P2. Soft curves and voluptuous fruit add to the wine’s immediacy and sheer appeal. The 2000 is not hugely complex or layered, but it has plenty of palate presence and overall intensity. The 2000 P2 is a terrific choice for readers who enjoy Champagnes that show the more advanced aromas, flavors and textures that develop in bottle. Tasted two times with consistent notes.”
“The 1998 Dom Pérignon P2 is clearly heading into its next plateau of maturity, as evidenced by a host of coffee, roasted almond, butter, brioche, caramel, lemon confit and pastry notes. Even so, there is a good bit of freshness to play off a generally mature set of aromas and flavors. Readers who enjoy mature Champagne will find quite a bit to like in the 1998. Today, it is especially open-knit and giving. Two recent bottles have been terrific. ”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Richard Geoffroy calls this ‘athletic’ and is proud of having picked later than most. Released in 2014.
Delicate but very concentrated too. Round and rich. Quite opulent. Broad and muscular; meaty.
Drink 2014-2024”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The 1998 Dom Pérignon P2 is superb. Just starting to soften, the 1998 is beautifully layered in the glass, with a translucent, vertical sense of structure that is compelling and an attractive top note of reduction that adds freshness. Vibrant and yet wonderfully complex, the 1998 is a gorgeous wine for drinking now and over the next two decades or so. This is a very strong showing. With more and more time, the 1998 seems to have acquired an additional dimension of nuance. This is an especially majestic bottle of the 1998. ”
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2016
“An absolute charmer. Rich, open, generous, notably evolved nose. Honeycomb, sweet spices, ripe fruit and créme brûlée. Big, fleshy but crisp, mouth-filling palate with caressing, fluffy mousse. But so much energy! Long, concentrated, mellow yet driven length. Here and now, already surprisingly developed but post-disgorgement time seems to be doing it good, as my points have risen by every tasting. Still, it is a surprise the 1998 was released after the 1996 and not the other way around.”
18.5/10
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2016
“Chef de cave, Richard Geoffroy: 'The wine-growing season was marked by extremes, with a few grapes burned by the sun in a spectacularly hot August, and especially grey, rainy weather during the first two weeks of September. Postponing the harvest allowed us to take advantage of the miraculous spell of good weather that followed. That decision defined the creation of the vintage. When the harvest began on 21 September, the grapes were perfectly ripe and healthy.' Disgorged late 2009 and early 2010.
Rich and vanilla and broad now, the nose has really opened out. Creamy. Tiny bead and still lots of acidity but now it’s lime sherbet and dancing away. Quite an impact on the palate. Neat, firm impact on the finish. Very long and vibrant. Really builds towards the end. Hint of putty. Definitely firm.
Drink 2015-2030”
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2015
“Medium-deep golden colour. Rich, open, generous, notably evolved nose. Honeycomb, sweet spices, ripe fruit and créme brûlée. Big, fleshy but crisp, mouth-filling palate with caressing, fluffy mousse. Long, concentrated, mellow length. Here and now, already surprisingly developed but post-disgorgement time seems to be doing it good, as my points have risen by every tasting. Still, it is a surprise the 1998 was released after the 1996 and not the other way around.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“The 1998 Dom Pérignon P2 is open and beautifully expressive today. Unusually open for a young P2, the 1998 drinks well upon release, especially compared to the 1996, which was virtually unapproachable for the first few years after release. That is not at all the case with the 1998, which is quite open at this stage. Hints of apricot, almond, white flowers and chamomile add texture on the fleshy, resonant finish. The added time on the lees has given the P2 an added dimension of texture.”
18/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2014
“Disgorged end of 2013. 55% Chardonnay, 45% Pinot Noir. Dosage 6.5 g/l.
Slightly paler than the earlier disgorged version of the 1998. Light hint of torrefaction on the nose but not that struck-match reduction, and actually smells fresher, more citrus and orange peel and it is definitely fuller, broader in the mouth and has more power (as the P in P2 might suggest since it is an abbreviation for plénitude). Creamier and yet the acidity shoots through the middle. A much more extreme wine. Not sure if it is better, just different. Less well integrated, for now. Acidity seems higher. Very long finish.”
97/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Aug 2014
“A P2 release indicating it has been matured to the 2nd Plenitude, the middle stage of Dom Perignon's three-phase life as defined by Richard Geoffroy. This is a wine with some real tension between complexity and freshness that makes for incredibly engaging drinking. The nose offers up a little white peppery edge from the pinot; oyster shell saline freshness, red florals, sweet smelling woody spices and brioche, spiced biscuits and subtle roasted coffee notes - impressively complex. The phenolics register on the palate as a discreetly mineral, saline character, there's sorbet-like texture through the middle before finishing with comet-like line and length.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“The 1998 Dom Pérignon P-2 (formerly Oenothèque) is quite reticent today. What else is new? These second-plenitude wines are often very tight when they are first released, which is very much the case here. Still, it is quite evident the 1998 is a bit more tender and pliant than the 1996. Today, the 1998 still hasn't turned the corner, but it is quite pretty and expressive. This is a terrific offering.”
“The 2002 Dom Pérignon Rosé P2 is classic 2002: rich, opulent and exotic from start to finish. Ripe red-toned fruit, spice and floral notes abound. There's gorgeous textural density and layers of flavor that build effortlessly over time. The 2002 can be enjoyed now or cellared. It's a magical Champagne in every way. ”
“The 1996 Dom Pérignon Rosé P2 is breathtaking. Vibrant and yet also wonderfully ethereal, the 1996 proves to be utterly captivating from the very first taste. Scents of orange peel, rose petal and wild flowers all waft from the glass. In recent vintages, the Rosé is often decidedly vinous in style. The 1996 speaks to a high acid vintage where freshness prevails over textural richness. The 1996 Rosé P2 is not an obvious wine, rather it is a Champagne that speaks to understatement and pure class above all else. Because of its relatively delicate personality, I would prefer to drink the 1996 over the next decade or two at most.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“Dosage 6 g/l. Chardonnay, Pinot Noir (18% of which is red wine).
Creamy, spicy palate and vibrant red fruit. Still needs a bit of time for the nose to develop. Long and gradual to finish with a savoury, salty flavour. (RH)”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Very pale greyish salmon pink. Raspberry and cheesecake notes. Quite dramatic and edgy. The acidity is notable again – very typical of the vintage. Drier than most rosés on the finish, but mellower than the white 1996.
Drink 2018-2028”
“A totally breathtaking wine, the 1995 Dom Pérignon Rosé P2 is a fitting conclusion to this tasting. Crushed flowers, sweet tobacco, cedar and dried cherry give the 1995 fabulous aromatic complexity and nuance. Deceptive in its ethereal feel, the 1995 has lovely palate presence and tons of class. It is both mature and timeless, in the way only Champagne can be.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Rich and round. Very slightly toasty with great drive. More like 1996 rosé than it resembles the 1995 and 1996 whites.
Drink 2016-2025”
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2016
“There is a timeless feel to this beauty, which is unmistakeably Dom Pérignon in its pristinely pure, smoky mineral character. Beautiful Pinot aromas, underwood, cherry, spice and chocolate. Tight and first in the glass but builds up over time into an excuisitely refined yet endlessly layered whole. Seamless is the right word for this wine that has rested on its yeast lees for over 15 years bringing such harmony to it. Velvet-smooth, linear palate full of energy. Positively vinous, intense and lingering. Great exuberance of fruit. Even if the 1995 was a rich vintage, its Dom Pérignon Rosé P2 is a particularly elegant wine, which will go on and on.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2015
“This has just been released, in tiny quantities like all P2 rosés – for the moment anyway. Although I suppose this could change if the house decides to increase the production of Dom Pérignon rosé.
The colour is pale rose pink with just a hint of blue – in fact it almost looks younger than the 2004 first release tasted alongside it. Still reasonably vigorous bead. Haunting, warm nose - super-complex with rose petals and a hint of dill pickle - that gives way to a rather coy, super-fruity palate that ends bone dry. Smells of warm vegetables - tomatoes?! Masses of appetising development. Great, throat-warming finish. Delicate. Lacy texture. Very fine, though so delicate that it would need careful food matching. Very pretty and complex with strawberry notes. Textured and intellectual.”
95+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“The just-released 1995 Dom Pérignon Rosé P2 is stunning. Young, delicate and vibrant in the glass, the 1995 has it all; expressive aromatics, crystalline fruit and fabulous overall balance. Cranberry, mint, hard candy, cinnamon and dried rose petals are laced into the super-expressive finish. The 1995 P2 is sweet and layered, but with lovely veins of chalky minerality that give the wine its sense of energy. A delicate, floral finish rounds things out nicely.”
“Stunning. So rich and complex on the nose! With almonds, burgundy flavours and strong Pinot Noir character on the nose. Really exciting! No shortage of structure. It seems so rich that it kids you there is some sweetness but the dosage was less than 5 g/l. Food wine. Should be great with tonight's langoustines! Long and savoury on the end. If grand cru rosé burgundy existed, this is what it would taste like.
To be released commercially in 2026. Blend of 44% Chardonnay and 56% Pinot Noir in total (including 11% red wine). (In the mid 1990s it was 15–18% then in the mid 2000s, as a result of the focus Richard Geoffroy was putting on Dom P rosé, it reached 28% but has been reduced since then.) They invested in a new winery in 2006–2008 with very small vats and burgundy-style pigeage for the reds. They started a programme to re-select red wines for Dom P and the wine now comes from 30 or so hectares in Hautvillers, Aÿ and Bouzy. They've been busy identifying the best plots, best clones and best raw material so this 2010 is the result of long research.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Nov 2025
“Eleven percent of Pinot Noir red wine lends the cuvée its refined, gently peach-tinged hue, slightly paler than usual. The nose captivates with its understated elegance, offering a delicate interplay of spicy, woody nuances and expressive, crunchy red-cherry fruit. With air, notes of ripe pineapple emerge, bringing a subtle sweetness and charm. On the palate, the wine surprises with its poise and restraint. Light in touch, yet intricately structured, framed by super-fine tannins. While one might expect power from this solar harvest year challenged by late season rains, Dom Pérignon 2010 reveals instead a remarkably elegant expression, radiating instant, articulate complexity. Dosage:5g/l.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2010 Dom Pérignon Rosé is elegant, gracious and lifted. Cranberry, mint, white pepper and pink grapefruit open first. The 2010 is a total charmer, that much is obvious. It is also far more interesting and engaging than the Blanc in this vintage. Ethereal and delicate, with lovely understated depth, the 2010 has a ton to offer. Its long, sustained finish is exceptionally beautiful and inviting.”
18.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Oct 2025
“The pretty red fruits leap out the glass, a precocious rose demanding attention! Zingy bitter red cherry, dark plum and dried raspberry dominate, underneath you feel the CH dominance, with a core of velvety yellow fruit blending so well with the PN juicy red fruits. With time in glass you get a waft of something minty/eucalyptus like. The texture is of so very soft and velvety wrapping around the tongue and salinity gives it the most beautiful elegant light ending. Going back I saw a twist of spice and more darker cherry fruits coming forward. This is stunning, with a zippy fresh finish.
The red wine for the DP Rose is sourced from just 15 hectares of specifically trained vines in Ay, Bouzy and Hautvillers, three of the warmer south facing villages, restricted to small yields and where maturity is pushed to the edge!”
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Born from rigorous selection in a botrytis-pressured year, the 2010 Dom Pérignon Rosé is composed of 44% Chardonnay—sourced predominantly from Chouilly, Cramant and Avize—and 56% Pinot Noir, with the latter largely drawn from Verzenay, Mareuil-sur-Aÿ and Hautvillers. Eleven percent of the Pinot Noir was vinified as red wine, lending the wine its color, aromatic lift and textural nuance. Disgorged in March 2024 with a dosage of five grams per liter, it unfurls from the glass with aromas of bitter orange, wild raspberry and fresh strawberry, mingled with nuances of rooibos, Timut pepper and charred, buttered toast. On the palate, the wine is medium- to full-bodied, muscular and vinous, built around a rich yet vibrant core of fruit, complemented by structuring phenolics that impart its bitter qualities. Ample and textural, this is a commendable effort in a challenging Champagne vintage.”
“The 2009 Dom Pérignon Rosé marks a return to a richer style of Rosé following the more ethereal 2008 Rosé. Sweet red cherry, blood orange, spice and pomegranate all build in a creamy, sensual DP Rosé that hits all the right spots. Over the last few years, Chef de Caves Vincent Chaperon and his team have lowered the still Pinot portion of the Rosé down to about 10% from a high of 28% or so, reached around 2004 and 2005. In 2009, the Rosé gains considerable textural presence from the generosity of the year. It is a superb Champagne. I preferred it to the 2008, which was also part of this tasting.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2023
“In comparison to the charming, pure 2008 Dom Pérignon Rosé, the 2009 Dom Pérignon Rosé possesses a ripe, dense bouquet with aromas of dark berries, licorice, dried white flowers, toast and pastry, enhanced by delicate, racy smoky hints. Full-bodied, broad and rich, it’s dense and phenolic due to the approximately 15% still red wine sourced from grapes planted in the villages of Hautvilliers, Aÿ and Bouzy, culminating in a protracted, sapid and chalky finish. Although already thoroughly enjoyable, it should age well over the next 10 years. This blend of 56% Pinot Noir and 44% Chardonnay was disgorged in March 2022 with a dosage of five grams per liter.”
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2009 Dom Pérignon Rosé comes from a year of opulent, ripe and softly textured champagnes. As this cuvée always is a bold and surprising one, so is its 2009. Powerful cherry fruit on the nose that highlights black rather than red berry profile. Alongside berries, apricot jam, blood orange and stone fruit tones arise on top of the deep, softly spicy core. The palate is full of fruit too with both a vertical and horizontal sumptuousness. Soft but fresh acidity intermingles with the sturdy phenolics of the wine, bringing structure. A big, bold and immediately expressive Dom Pérignon has a lot of character to it. I am looking forward to seeing the path it takes with additional ageing, a wild one full of personality. ”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2025
“59% Pinot Noir (13% of which as red wine), 41% Chardonnay. Aged 12 years on lees. Dosage 5 g/l.
More orange than pink. Honey, caramel, wild raspberry which still has a fresh-picked tanginess to it. On the nose, the yeastiness is surprisingly subdued, but the palate comes through with bakery and brioche, especially on the long, toasty finish.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“The wine’s deep hue reveals the strong red-wine spirit at the heart of this Champagne. Since my tasting for this report a year ago, the wine has gained in savoury complexity, with its untamed Pinot Noir character now even more boldly expressed. The aromatic profile leans into the dried-fruit spectrum of apricot and mango, layered with dark berry nuances and a thread of refined char. On the palate, it glides in with silkiness before the warm-year phenolics rise with poised grip toward the back. While the bouquet shows a captivating sense of evolution, there is still a powerful structural core beneath, promising long-term cellaring potential. Dosage:5g/l.”
95/100
Tim Hewson,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2023
“Dom Pérignon Rosé 2009 arrives almost four years after the standard release, accordingly mature, expressive and open. Roughly equal proportions of Pinot Noir and Chardonnay, but with a still red wine addition normally in the region of 15%. It’s a huge contrast from the 2008, showing the warmth of the year with approachable, fleshy apricot and blood orange flavours, rounded and saturated with ripe fruit at its heart but beautifully detailed with hibiscus, liquorice and dried red berry fragrance. While structured, it is less firm and vinous than the comparably warm 2006; a supple, fluid and sweet kind of ripeness with a gently persistent citric length. While it will develop with interest in the medium term, this is a Dom Pérignon Rosé that can be enjoyed close to its release.”
94+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“The 2009 Dom Perignon Rose, disgorged in 2022 with a dosage of five grams per liter, continues to show nicely, unfurling in the glass with aromas of orange oil, raspberry, pomegranate and Timut pepper, mingled with notes of dried flowers and apricot. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and openly muscular—expansive and textural—built around a sweet core of fruit, its phenolic presence and vinous character informed by the inclusion of 13% still red wine. Its pinpoint mousse and ripe yet vibrant acidity lend energy, carrying the wine to a perfumed, resonant finish. While it appears to be marginally more harmonious and a longer-distance runner than the 2010 rendition, it currently shows considerably less depth than the white Dom Pérignon Plenitude 2 from the 2006 vintage that preceded it in the tasting, leading me to place my confidence in the latter.”
“The 2008 may be the best rosé ever… Incredible depth of fruit. Three-dimensional element to the wine. This is so transparent and dynamic…really savoury, fresh and incredibly Pinot Noir like”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Deep, developing orange-toned colour. The nose is still tight, holding back a lot, but there is a bright red and bitter cherry note, plus tulip, blood orange and an abundance of oriental spice and toast. Stylishly compact on the linear palate, which shows plenty of strength and fruity power. This is so slow-ageing that we can call it a prelude today; the wine shines with its sumptuous, pure fruitiness and Pinot power, a result of red wine from the Champs de Linotte plot in Hautvillers and Vauzelles in Aÿ. But it needs time for the wild side and fruity charms to surface. This is an extraordinary rosé for the future. Dosage 5g/l”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2021
“What to expect from a Dom Pérignon Rosé from the super dynamic Richard Geoffroy - Vincent Chaperon duo? To expect the unexpected, I have learned. I love how Vincent calls the 2008, ’untamed, carnal and magnetic’. There is nothing shy to it even if the vintage normally comes across coolly restrained. Boldly fruity, boldly Dom Pérignon, there is flesh and richness to support the zingy drive and spicy extravagance. So slow-ageing that we can call it a prelude today, the wine shines with its sumptuous pure fruitiness and Pinot power deriving from red wine from Champs de Linotte plot in Hautvillers and Vauzelles in Aÿ. An intriguing melange of delicious sweet cherry fruit, floral tulip whiffs, blood orange, coffee and saffron. The palate is firmly structured and tight for the time being, speaking of longevity. Still, there is at the same time immediate elegance and charm to it on the lingering, dancing palate. ”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Aug 2021
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon Rosé is magnificent. Rich and deep in the glass, the 2008 offers up an exotic mélange of aromas and flavors. Sweet red cherry, mint, orange peel and rose petal all grace this beguiling beauty. Bright acids and a little less still red Pinot (21%) than in most recent editions yields a Rosé that is delicate and light on its feet, with less of the vinous intensity that marked vintages such as 2006. There is a classic feeling of austerity in the 2008 that is mesmerizing.”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
decanter.com,
Apr 2021
“Offering up aromas of white flowers, red berries, toast and fresh pastry, Dom Pérignon Rosé 2008 is medium to full-bodied, tense and vibrant, with a vinous texture and sapid nuances”
93-96/100
Richard Juhlin,
Tastingbook.com,
Apr 2021
“The senses are overflowing with rich cocky broad-shouldered and loud chords in all sorts of colorful splendor”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“Pale to mid salmon pink (much deeper than a typical Provence Rosé). There's some note that's mineral or iodine or oyster shell on the nose of this. Then we segue into something floral – rose petals? Even candied rose petals.”
“The 2006 Dom Pérignon Rosé is every bit as captivating as it was last year, maybe even more so. At times powerful, but in other moments finessed, the 2006 constantly changes in the glass, revealing a different shade of its personality with every taste. Perhaps most importantly, the 2006 seems to have gained a level of precision and pure sophistication it did not show last year, when it was quite a bit less put together. Back then, the 2006 was a wine of tremendous potential; today that potential is starting to be realized. Quite simply, the 2006 Dom Pérignon Rosé is a magical Champagne. Don’t miss it.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Pale to mid salmon. A definite orange hue. Broad and rose-scented. Really quite extensive on the palate. Very nicely balanced. Lots of fruit and much softer than the 2008 and 2002 Blanc.”
95-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2019
“Already the colour strikes as light for the vintage. The nose kicks off with complex, fragrant top notes of smokiness, gunflint and mix of dark berries, notably black cherries. Stunning toastiness overlays the pristine ripe fruitiness. Blood orange and flowery notes support in the background. The palate plays even more with the fleshiness and Burgundian echos of Pinot Noir with attractive spiciness and licorice notes and firmness of structure. Rich without being heavy. Even if the acidity is slightly on the lower side, enhancing the feel of gentleness and harmony, the salinity kicks in towards the end palate driving it joyously until the delicately phenolic, appropriately dry finish (6g/l dosage). It has a completeness to it and plenty of elegance for the vintage. A genuine class act, which no doubt, is built to last. ”
95-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2018
“Stunningly concentrated and packed with succulent fruitiness, the wine already now shows a beautiful complexity of gunpowder, licorice and oriental spices complementing the plush yet firm Pinot fruit. Truly characterful but utterly sophisticated and packed with delicious, build-to-last fruit. ”
“A wine of pure and total pleasure, the 2004 Dom Pérignon Rosé is explosive and hedonistically rich, with tons of pure texture from the 28% still Pinot in the blend. In this tasting, the 2004 Rosé is especially fine. I imagine it will reward readers lucky enough to own it with several decades of exceptional drinking. In a word: sublime.”
More Reviews +
18.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“They wonder whether they included too much Pinot in this wine.
Cheesy nose, much more obvious acidity than the 2005 with a strong rose-petal aroma. Tight and tense. Very focused. Much more youthful than the 2005.
Drink 2017-2030”
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2015
“The 2004 DP Rosé is just as charming as one would have expected. The elegance and vivacity of the vintage take a leading role sublimely complemented by exuberantly toasty, smoky notes. Lovely pinot depth, spicy and vanilla-laden. Tight and linear, tense palate with satiny texture and refined, extensive length. A super elegant Dom Pérignon Rosé, in a classic cool style.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“The 2004 Dom Pérignon Rosé has put on remarkable weight over the last year or so. A rich, voluptuous wine, the 2004 Rosé hits the palate with stunning depth and resonance. The flavors are bold, rich and beautifully resonant from start to finish. Raspberry, cranberry, smoke, spice and crushed rocks build to the stunning, powerful finish. Vinous and ample, the 2004 Rosé will drink well for decades. The 2004 just keeps getting better with time in bottle.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2015
“Mid to pale orange rose (as in the flower) colour. Apparently the proportion of red wine was the highest ever, 27% of the blend. Notably opulent rose-petal nose. Very broadly fruity and deep flavoured with massive palate impact that surely has the power to mend sore throats. Beautiful smooth satin texture. ‘We squeezed everything out of this vintage', said Richard Geoffroy, ‘we really worked hard on it'. This is a great wine that happens to be pink. It’s not remotely sweet but is beautifully round and complete. I have suggested it was probably delicious two years ago but in fact it has only just been released.”
94+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“Relative to many other recent vintages, the 2004 Dom Pérignon Rosé comes across as quite delicate, feminine and graceful. Floral notes are woven throughout, adding to a very appealing and attractive sense of lift. It will be interesting to see if the 2004 puts on weight in bottle. At the moment, the 2004 is a bit understated, but I will not be surprised if at some point it takes off given the extremely positive way in which the 2004 blanc has developed over the last few years.”
“After all these years, the 2003 Dom Pérignon Rosé has finally started to be expressive. In this tasting, the 2003 is distinguished by its vertical build and a real sense of gravitas. The natural power of the year - once quite hidden - now comes through loud and clear.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Pale greyish salmon pink. Quite a bit of Pinot nectar on the nose. Very straightforward. Tight and a tiny bit phenolic on the end – a bit like the 2005. Maybe not quite as beautifully integrated as the 2005. Slightly sweet.
Drink 2013-2023”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2015
“Deeply fruity, beautifully spicy, and soothingly evolved nose screaming ripe Pinot plushness. Polished, pristinely fruity nose with a pretty gunpowdery touch. Strong, big palate coming with a notion of tannin. Blockbuster, winey, muscular style with the hallmark 2003 fluffy mousse. Less complexity than usual, a deep, winey vintage. Superb for 2003 but falls short to the greatest Dom Pérignon Rosés.”
93/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
May 2015
“An insanely awesome wine where Richard Geoffroy stretched the limits to the maximum. Can you really make such a burgundy scented Rosé champagne? Will not Rousseau and Ponsot become envious? The roundness and the velvety structure settles like the most wonderful Persian carpet on the palate. Buy and follow this historic wine which might constitute the eve of something new.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2015
“One of the positive surprises in this tasting, the 2003 Dom Pérignon Rosé is now finally beginning to put on a little weight, although it remains inward and very much tightly wound. It will be interesting to see how the Rosé develops. The 2003 Blanc has always been more impressive than the Rosé. This is the first time I have seen anything that suggests the gap between the two 2003 might narrow some day. Sweet exotic aromatics linger on a finish that remains marked by a slight element of astringency. Disgorged 2012.”
96/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Oct 2014
“Finely detailed in texture, with an expressive flavor profile of strawberry pâte de fruit, biscotti, ground anise and ginger, matched to vivid acidity and a rich, minerally character. Broad and creamy on the palate, featuring a long, echoing finish. Drink now through 2029.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2013
“The Dom Pérignon team continue to make a strong statement with their roses. And the 2003 vintage certainly helped them by providing relatively bumptious, full-on ingredients. This wine is a pale tomato red - much deeper than most other pink champagnes - with a distinctly orange tinge thanks to the wine's age. This wine, designed for drinking with food, is big and almost Grenache-like!!! The finish is dry but along the way there are some strawberry notes and a suggestion of long oak ageing. I keep thinking of Tondonia Rosado (another complex, long-aged pink, though from Rioja)! Not that persistent, this lip-smacking wine is a bit of a cheeky chappie. Almost more of a defiant statement that flies in the face of conventional rosé wisdom than a wine. Very full - definitely for the table rather than a refreshing aperitif style.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2013
“The 2003 Dom Pérignon Rosé is another wine that has come together quite nicely over the last few months. Given the exuberance and sheer vinosity of the 2000 and the 2002, along with the ripeness of the year, and the heft of the 2003 Blanc, I expected the 2003 Rosé to be a much bigger wine. Instead, it is surprisingly delicate and medium in body. Dried flowers, crushed raspberries and sweet herbs waft from the glass in a Rosé that is all about sensuality. With time in the glass, the richness of the fruit becomes more pronounced, while the tannin from the red grapes is also noticeable. I would prefer to cellar the 2000 and 2002, and drink the 2003 sooner rather than later.”
“The 2018 Dom Pérignon is a total stunner. Bright and crystalline in the glass, the 2018 sizzles with mineral-drenched tension. Citrus peel, chalk, white flowers and slate are some of the many nuances that open with a bit of coaxing. The 2018 will need a few years to start hitting its stride, but it is super-impressive in the early going. Stylistically, it reminds me of the 2004 (also a high-yielding vintage) in its slender, lithe build.”
More Reviews +
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2025
“The year unfolded under climatically ideal conditions, free from extremes, yielding a generous and balanced harvest. Chardonnay (54%) is anchored by fruit from Chouilly, while Verzenay and Aÿ provided the core of the Pinot Noir. This marks the inaugural vintage under Vincent Chaperon as Chef de Cave. The wine opens with striking aromatic purity and lush fruit tones of ripe peach, Madagascar vanilla, and lemon meringue pie. The nose remains somewhat reticent, hinting at further complexity to come. On the palate, it displays seamless harmony, textured yet precise, rich yet buoyed by a fine mineral tension. A subtle touch of phenolic grip firms the finish. Still holding much in reserve, this is a Dom Pérignon promising exceptional longevity.”
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2025
“Smoky, tense and taut with more marked acidity and depth than the 2017. But then the ripeness really shines through, too, though there's a touch of something saline or mineral. This should last well. Great fruit intensity. Really very glamorous indeed. A no-brainer for hedonists.
Full bottle 1,646 g. 54% Chardonnay, 46% Pinot Noir. Vincent Chaperon's first vintage, to be commercially released in the first half of 2026. The reverse of weather in 2017: the season started cool and wet and then became warmer and drier, which is ideal. Light water stress just before picking. According to Chaperon 2018 is 'in a way 2004++'. Both were perfect years for growing with no disease. But 2018 was warmer than 2004 with 25% more light in the spring. They both had high yields, even if 2018 was not quite as big as 2004. They produced much more than 12 months' stock, one of biggest volumes of Dom P ever, though less than 2004.”
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jan 2025
“Very floral aromas with jasmine, honeysuckle, lemons and subtle apples. Lavender as well. The medium-bodied palate has super-integrated bubbles, a touch of fine phenolics and a racy, lively finish. Weightless and refined for the vintage. The aftertaste includes ginger, dried apples, lychees, bitter lemons and minerals. 54% chardonnay and 46% pinot noir. A new style for Dom Pérignon?”
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“The 2018 Dom Pérignon, born of a dry, solar year and an August harvest, is a lighter-footed, less concentrated rendition when considered alongside the 2017. It opens with a moderately complex bouquet of clementine, fresh apricot and cardamom, mingling with notes of nectarine, iris and freshly baked bread, offering rather little in the way of reductive character. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, ample and enveloping, with a sweet, fleshy core of fruit and a pillowy mousse. Its acids are ripe—and softer than those of the 2017, yet racy—carrying the wine toward a long, delicately phenolic finish. Even if it starts its life somewhat less expressive, as it evolves on its fruit and the extract derived from its ripe skins, it may well, in time, render my initial assessment on the conservative side. A blend of 54% Chardonnay and 46% Pinot Noir, it was disgorged in March 2024 and finished with a dosage of about seven grams per liter.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2026
“The 2018 Dom Pérignon is explosive, bright and so vibrant in the glass. Medium in body, with layers of understated depth, the 2018 dazzles from start to finish. Lemon peel, chalk, mint and white pepper all open with a bit of coaxing. Readers will find a Dom Pérignon of unreal precision and class.”
“The 2017 Dom Pérignon is so impressive. A sort of mini-2002, the 2017 is a Champagne of textural richness and resonance above all else. Its creamy, voluptuous contours are so inviting. Production for the 2017 is tiny, about a three-month supply, so this wine will come and go pretty quickly. That represents a fairly dramatic shift in philosophy at Dom Pérignon. In the past, a wine like the 2017 would not have been commercially viable because of its small volume. Today, Chef de Caves Vincent Chaperon prefers to bottle Dom Pérignon in every vintage, if possible, as a document of the year, even if that means some releases will be very small. The 2017 is a wild, exotic Dom Pérignon. I loved it. ”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2025
“In 2017, pressure was on Chef de Cave Richard Geoffroy, who had decided not to produce the 2016 vintage for Dom Pérignon. Late August rainy weather destroyed the promising harvest year, and grapes needed to be collected rapidly under deteriorating conditions. Even with Dom Pérignon’s enviable sourcing and options for selection, 2017 ended up being the smallest harvest to date, worth a mere three months’ sales. Chardonnay, a big part from Chouilly. dominates this Dom Pérignon with its 61% share. In the remaining 39% Pinot Noir part, Bouzy rather unusually represents the biggest share. The nose opens beautifully with an inviting toasty and smoky twist over a ripe stone fruit profile. Laudably clean, with no signs of botrytis tones. The palate is held together by invigorating acidity and a bite of phenolics at the finish. Sensually textured and alluring, this is a Dom Pérignon that is ready to charm, with a somewhat shorter lifespan expected than for its most monumental iterations.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2025
“Full bottle 1,646 g. Richard Geoffroy's last vintage, to be released commercially at the beginning of 2026. He controversially decided that the 2016 base wines weren't concentrated enough so they skipped that year and more or less had to make a 2017, from a notoriously difficult growing season when many a grape was ruined by galloping acetic acid infection. One of the ripest vintages ever and, until storms on 15 August, everyone was touting it as the best vintage ever. Chardonnays were even riper than in 2003 but finding good Pinot Noir in the warm, wet conditions of late August and early September was a real challenge. This blend is 62% Chardonnay, 38% Pinot Noir and in terms of quantity is the smallest Dom P release ever, only three or four months' sales-worth. Even smaller than 2005. Described in-house as a 'radical' vintage, a bit like 2003 ie one that was not widely made.
Exceedingly rich nose with more crème pâtissière than lemon in this vintage – a less-citrus Dom than usual. Seems quite sweet and a little simpler and lighter than the 2018. And not as long. But perhaps it's suffering by comparison with the sheer intensity and obvious ripeness of 2018 tasted alongside. May even be a slow burner. There's a touch of bitterness at the end. (JR)”
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Of the two releases—the 2017 and the 2018—the 2017 Dom Perignon is the deeper and more structurally endowed wine, unfurling from the glass with a complex bouquet of orange peel, dried apricot and burnt buttered toast, mingling with nuances of dried flowers, toasted hazelnut and cacao bean, all strongly singed with the house’s signature smoky reduction. On the palate, it is full-bodied and concentrated, with a rich core of fruit. Its darker, open-knit profile is animated by a pillowy mousse, vibrant acidity and attractively bitter, structuring phenolics that assert themselves on a long, resonant finish.
This is a superb achievement for a vintage that required uncompromising selection, as acetic rot began to intrude upon the Pinot Noir grapes despite otherwise favorable conditions until mid-August. The fact that it represents the smallest Dom Perignon release by volume should not mislead readers into complacency; indeed, I would much sooner own several bottles of the 2017 than divide my allocation with the 2018. A blend of 61% Chardonnay and 39% Pinot Noir, it was disgorged in March 2024 with a dosage of five grams per liter and will offer considerable complexity and generosity out of the gates.”
“At first, the nose comes across soft and toasty, less on the gunpowder but more on the toasted bread side. A little shy perhaps, but the bouquet is impeccably pure and deliciously fruity once it reveals more of itself after a short while in the glass. There is ripe yellow plum fruit but also a brisk menthol breeze as well as some sweeter, even tropical aromas. All nuances are perfectly integrated and elegantly subtle for the time being, echoing a reservedness speaking of longevity. On the soft cushiony palate, the linearity and vivacity are first to be noted, but soon after one gets charmed by the creamy-caressing texture. The dosage is perfectly balanced at 5g/l. Much racier and perhaps a little more austere than most recent Dom Pérignon vintages, however, this coolly fruity, tight and focused wines has what true longevity takes. It has evolved slowly until now and will be one to defy time. ”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Intense, lightly spicy nose and then on the palate very smooth-textured, gentle and lifted, with light bitterness on the finish – grapefruit peel? Some lightly vegetal notes and very long. Seamless texture and already very agreeable.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2024
“The 2013 Dom Pérignon is pretty closed right now. Deep and layered, the 2013 shows quite a bit of density today. It's a typical wine for this vintage, a year marked by a warm summer but a late harvest because the growing season got off to a late start. The 2013 is finally starting to open a bit and show some textural breadth, but it remains on the reticent side.”
96/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
May 2022
“Vivid acidity and a chalky underpinning make a crystalline frame for finely detailed notes of ripe melon, mandarin orange, toasted brioche and candied ginger in this harmonious Champagne, which is expressive and expansive on the palate, but with a sense of finesse and restraint. Long and creamy on the mineral-laced finish. Drink now through 2037.”
18.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2023
“Tasted blind. Amidst a blind line-up of relatively big name champagnes (La Grande Dame 2015, Moët Grande Vintage 2015, Krug Grand Cuvée), this stood out head and shoulders above the rest. Lusty, guttural, uncompromising. Big, powerfully toasty nose! Here be fireworks. Tiny bubbles, like 3D lace running a matrix through the wine. Clementine, straw, yuzu, kumquat, sharp apples – so much fruit! And then long, hungry, lean savoury lines. Grilled sourdough toast, roasted walnuts. So much here. Very, very long and very, very persistent. This is outstanding. The bubbles are like tiny, glittering jewels stitched into silk. A seriously exciting, serious wine. For special occasions I could almost too easily be persuaded to part with £250 for a bottle of this.”
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
May 2022
“Disgorged in October last year, the 2013 Dom Pérignon is a lovely wine, defined by the long, cool growing season. Offering up aromas of crisp stone fruit, tangerine oil, buttered toast, pear, almonds and clear honey, it's medium to full-bodied, ample and seamless, with bright acids and a pillowy, enveloping profile, concluding with a long, saline finish. Vincent Chaperon recalls that shatter at fruit set moderated yields and that a drying east wind in the weeks before harvest helped to maintain the good sanitation necessary to wait to pick at full maturity.”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Apr 2023
“Disgorged in October 2022, the 2013 Dom Pérignon is a charming and elegant vintage for this cuvée. It reveals complex aromas of buttery pastry, spices, citrus oil, almonds, honey and, with aeration, a touch of smoke. The palate is medium to full-bodied, perfectly balanced, with a chiseled and tightly wound profile. The long, cool growing season has brought freshness and a delicate earthy note to the finish.”
98/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
May 2022
“A driven and serious DP with aromas of chalk, biscuits, apricot stones and lemons. Some spice and dried flowers, too. So sleek and sophisticated. Elegant. Yet, it’s long and powerful, with a sharp minerality. Tight and precise.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2022
“The 2013 Dom Pérignon is quite delicate and understated. It reminds me of the 2004, but with a bit more mid-palate richness and a bit less energy. Apricot, tangerine peel, white flowers, jasmine, mint and light honeyed notes all meld together. There’s lovely vinous intensity as well as a feeling of openness that make the 2013 a delight to taste today. The 2013 doesn’t look to be an epic DP, but it sure is delicious right now.”
“At first, the nose comes across soft and toasty, less on the gunpowder but more on the toasted bread side. A little shy perhaps, but the bouquet is impeccably pure and deliciously fruity once it reveals more of itself after a short while in the glass. There is ripe yellow plum fruit but also a brisk menthol breeze as well as some sweeter, even tropical aromas. All nuances are perfectly integrated and elegantly subtle for the time being, echoing a reservedness speaking of longevity. On the soft cushiony palate, the linearity and vivacity are first to be noted, but soon after one gets charmed by the creamy-caressing texture. The dosage is perfectly balanced at 5g/l. Much racier and perhaps a little more austere than most recent Dom Pérignon vintages, however, this coolly fruity, tight and focused wines has what true longevity takes. It has evolved slowly until now and will be one to defy time. ”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Intense, lightly spicy nose and then on the palate very smooth-textured, gentle and lifted, with light bitterness on the finish – grapefruit peel? Some lightly vegetal notes and very long. Seamless texture and already very agreeable.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2024
“The 2013 Dom Pérignon is pretty closed right now. Deep and layered, the 2013 shows quite a bit of density today. It's a typical wine for this vintage, a year marked by a warm summer but a late harvest because the growing season got off to a late start. The 2013 is finally starting to open a bit and show some textural breadth, but it remains on the reticent side.”
96/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
May 2022
“Vivid acidity and a chalky underpinning make a crystalline frame for finely detailed notes of ripe melon, mandarin orange, toasted brioche and candied ginger in this harmonious Champagne, which is expressive and expansive on the palate, but with a sense of finesse and restraint. Long and creamy on the mineral-laced finish. Drink now through 2037.”
18.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2023
“Tasted blind. Amidst a blind line-up of relatively big name champagnes (La Grande Dame 2015, Moët Grande Vintage 2015, Krug Grand Cuvée), this stood out head and shoulders above the rest. Lusty, guttural, uncompromising. Big, powerfully toasty nose! Here be fireworks. Tiny bubbles, like 3D lace running a matrix through the wine. Clementine, straw, yuzu, kumquat, sharp apples – so much fruit! And then long, hungry, lean savoury lines. Grilled sourdough toast, roasted walnuts. So much here. Very, very long and very, very persistent. This is outstanding. The bubbles are like tiny, glittering jewels stitched into silk. A seriously exciting, serious wine. For special occasions I could almost too easily be persuaded to part with £250 for a bottle of this.”
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
May 2022
“Disgorged in October last year, the 2013 Dom Pérignon is a lovely wine, defined by the long, cool growing season. Offering up aromas of crisp stone fruit, tangerine oil, buttered toast, pear, almonds and clear honey, it's medium to full-bodied, ample and seamless, with bright acids and a pillowy, enveloping profile, concluding with a long, saline finish. Vincent Chaperon recalls that shatter at fruit set moderated yields and that a drying east wind in the weeks before harvest helped to maintain the good sanitation necessary to wait to pick at full maturity.”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Apr 2023
“Disgorged in October 2022, the 2013 Dom Pérignon is a charming and elegant vintage for this cuvée. It reveals complex aromas of buttery pastry, spices, citrus oil, almonds, honey and, with aeration, a touch of smoke. The palate is medium to full-bodied, perfectly balanced, with a chiseled and tightly wound profile. The long, cool growing season has brought freshness and a delicate earthy note to the finish.”
98/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
May 2022
“A driven and serious DP with aromas of chalk, biscuits, apricot stones and lemons. Some spice and dried flowers, too. So sleek and sophisticated. Elegant. Yet, it’s long and powerful, with a sharp minerality. Tight and precise.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2022
“The 2013 Dom Pérignon is quite delicate and understated. It reminds me of the 2004, but with a bit more mid-palate richness and a bit less energy. Apricot, tangerine peel, white flowers, jasmine, mint and light honeyed notes all meld together. There’s lovely vinous intensity as well as a feeling of openness that make the 2013 a delight to taste today. The 2013 doesn’t look to be an epic DP, but it sure is delicious right now.”
“Once again, the 2012 Dom Pérignon is stellar. It's a potent, tightly-wound Champagne. That should serve it well in the future, but today, the 2012 is not terribly expressive. Time in the glass brings out striking aromatic top notes and plenty of energy to match. Low yields, down 30-40%, produced a wild, dynamic Champagne endowed with tremendous character. It's an exceptional Champagne from a year marked by frost, hail, mildew, oidium and botrytis. Pretty much everything, in other words.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“Classic lemon-zest and tension nose that I associate with Dom Pérignon, but with extra weight and depth. And quite marked phenolics on the end which suggest this will have a remarkably long life. And, as Vincent Chaperon readily admitted, will definitely show up as a P2 star. Clean and neat and with light smokiness on the finish. Dom P always plays the reduction card. Hugely impressive persistence. Still a baby.”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Some vintages are vine growers' vintages, but for the 2012, Dom Pérignon's chef de cave wore the blender's hat and had an amazing set of building blocks, especially on the Pinot Noir front: Aÿ, Verzenay, Bouzy and Hautvillers. Shiny lemon green colour. The abundantly toasty nose delivers instant 'wow' notes – so subtle yet at the same time full of character. Charred tones combine with sweet vanilla, coffee and cream notes. Since release, the toastiness has really built up, and finely so. At this stage, the fruitiness is left a little behind but is as pristine as ever, showing a perfectly ripe yet crunchy profile. The palate comes with soft charm and impressive intensity, managing to remain rather light and vibrant. This is smooth-textured and rich, with fascinatingly prickly bubbles that add tension to the wine. Dosage 5g/l”
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2021
“In a near-perfect year, following a truly challenging growing season, Dom Pérignon ended up being equipped with an amazing choice of exciting and versatile building blocks for the cuvée, especially on the Pinot Noir front: Aÿ, Verzenay, Bouzy, Hautvillers... Some other vintages were vinegrowers vintages but with this one the chef de cave really wore the blender’s hat. The 2012 was a vintage of both freshness and density. At Dom Pérignon they really played the density card, effortlessly compacting together so much delicious, crunchy, perfectly ripe fruit. The nose is welcoming, harmonious and deeply fruity with Dom Pérignon’s hallmark fragrant smoky layeres. But the elements of surprise catch up with you on the palate. At first the wine feels deceptively light but then comes the fruity power and sheer volume. The wine’s most unique feature is the scintillating or tingling sensation that takes over and energises the rich, round and compact palate. It is almost as electrically charged as this nervousness and vibrancy bring such an exciting dynamism on the long, deliciously succulent palate. Dom Pérignon have made it again, they surprised me by playing on their fortes of incomparable resources and audacious winemaking.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2012 Dom Pérignon is a dense, powerful wine. I am almost shocked by its vinous intensity and raw, unbridled power. The 2012 reminds me of the 2003, but with more finesse and not quite as pushed. Mildew, rain and frost were challenges and resulted in low yields, something that was further compounded by warm, dry weather that concentrated the fruit even more. Those qualities result in a dense Dom Pérignon endowed with real phenolic intensity. It is one of the most reticent young Doms I can remember tasting, I wouldn’t even think of opening a bottle for at least a few years.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“A powerful nose opens with grilled nuts, richness, hazelnut praline, and a smoky richness. There is something inherently generous, savoury, bold and rich. It expresses itself in the salty body with its smouldering hints. The bright streak of zesty lemon only serves to accentuate the richness. The finish is wonderfully long, salty, savoury and generous.”
96/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The 2012 Dom Pérignon is developing very nicely on cork, exhibiting a complex bouquet of pear, confit citrus fruits, honeycomb, buttered toast, iodine and nuts framed by a deft touch of youthful reduction. Full-bodied, rich and muscular, with a layered core of fruit and a pillowy mousse, it's a vinous, vibrant Champagne that concludes with a saline finish.”
98/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Apr 2021
“What a magnificent bouquet for this Dom Pérignon 2012! Pastry, a hint of smoke and autolytic notes provide a compelling counterpart to eager yet elegant aromas of citrus (lime, tangerine and kumquat) joined by those of fresh fruit, herbs, liquorice, and menthol. There is even a refreshing note of ivy. The palate is tense, vibrant, and very fresh despite its impressive density, which meets its match with an unending finish. This 2012 incarnates the very essence of Dom Pérignon with such a concentrated degree of intensity, along with a capacity for ageing, that it is surely destined for a second life in a P2 edition.”
97/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Apr 2021
“The 2012 Champagne is 51% Chardonnay and the rest Pinot Noir and has 4 grams per liter dosage. Its style is finessed and elegant, revealing a soft, smoky perfume of fresh white flowers, pear, and fresh bread dough. The palate is focused and long, with a polished mousse, and offers notes of lime blossom, white peach, and chalky minerality as well as long perfume resonating on the finish. Best after 2024.”
96/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Apr 2021
“This eloquent Champagne has an enticing waft of Mandarin orange on the nose that continues on the palate, which is layered with flavors of crushed blackberry and cassis, toast, chopped almond, graphite and oyster shell. A bright, finely-knit and harmonious version, with a lovely, raw silk-like mousse, and a lasting, expressive finish. Drink now through 2037.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Apr 2021
“Wonderful elegance and balance to this Dom Pérignon with cooked apple, lemon and hints of white pepper and salt. It’s medium-bodied with really fine bubbles and balance. Spicy at the end. So wonderfully fresh, linear and long. Racy and elegant. A Dom Pérignon that invites to drink right now. All about finesse. Tension, too, with precise phenolics and bright acidity on the back palate. Subtle energy. Drinkable now, but will develop beautifully in the bottle.”
“Once again, the 2012 Dom Pérignon is stellar. It's a potent, tightly-wound Champagne. That should serve it well in the future, but today, the 2012 is not terribly expressive. Time in the glass brings out striking aromatic top notes and plenty of energy to match. Low yields, down 30-40%, produced a wild, dynamic Champagne endowed with tremendous character. It's an exceptional Champagne from a year marked by frost, hail, mildew, oidium and botrytis. Pretty much everything, in other words.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“Classic lemon-zest and tension nose that I associate with Dom Pérignon, but with extra weight and depth. And quite marked phenolics on the end which suggest this will have a remarkably long life. And, as Vincent Chaperon readily admitted, will definitely show up as a P2 star. Clean and neat and with light smokiness on the finish. Dom P always plays the reduction card. Hugely impressive persistence. Still a baby.”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Some vintages are vine growers' vintages, but for the 2012, Dom Pérignon's chef de cave wore the blender's hat and had an amazing set of building blocks, especially on the Pinot Noir front: Aÿ, Verzenay, Bouzy and Hautvillers. Shiny lemon green colour. The abundantly toasty nose delivers instant 'wow' notes – so subtle yet at the same time full of character. Charred tones combine with sweet vanilla, coffee and cream notes. Since release, the toastiness has really built up, and finely so. At this stage, the fruitiness is left a little behind but is as pristine as ever, showing a perfectly ripe yet crunchy profile. The palate comes with soft charm and impressive intensity, managing to remain rather light and vibrant. This is smooth-textured and rich, with fascinatingly prickly bubbles that add tension to the wine. Dosage 5g/l”
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2021
“In a near-perfect year, following a truly challenging growing season, Dom Pérignon ended up being equipped with an amazing choice of exciting and versatile building blocks for the cuvée, especially on the Pinot Noir front: Aÿ, Verzenay, Bouzy, Hautvillers... Some other vintages were vinegrowers vintages but with this one the chef de cave really wore the blender’s hat. The 2012 was a vintage of both freshness and density. At Dom Pérignon they really played the density card, effortlessly compacting together so much delicious, crunchy, perfectly ripe fruit. The nose is welcoming, harmonious and deeply fruity with Dom Pérignon’s hallmark fragrant smoky layeres. But the elements of surprise catch up with you on the palate. At first the wine feels deceptively light but then comes the fruity power and sheer volume. The wine’s most unique feature is the scintillating or tingling sensation that takes over and energises the rich, round and compact palate. It is almost as electrically charged as this nervousness and vibrancy bring such an exciting dynamism on the long, deliciously succulent palate. Dom Pérignon have made it again, they surprised me by playing on their fortes of incomparable resources and audacious winemaking.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2012 Dom Pérignon is a dense, powerful wine. I am almost shocked by its vinous intensity and raw, unbridled power. The 2012 reminds me of the 2003, but with more finesse and not quite as pushed. Mildew, rain and frost were challenges and resulted in low yields, something that was further compounded by warm, dry weather that concentrated the fruit even more. Those qualities result in a dense Dom Pérignon endowed with real phenolic intensity. It is one of the most reticent young Doms I can remember tasting, I wouldn’t even think of opening a bottle for at least a few years.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“A powerful nose opens with grilled nuts, richness, hazelnut praline, and a smoky richness. There is something inherently generous, savoury, bold and rich. It expresses itself in the salty body with its smouldering hints. The bright streak of zesty lemon only serves to accentuate the richness. The finish is wonderfully long, salty, savoury and generous.”
96/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The 2012 Dom Pérignon is developing very nicely on cork, exhibiting a complex bouquet of pear, confit citrus fruits, honeycomb, buttered toast, iodine and nuts framed by a deft touch of youthful reduction. Full-bodied, rich and muscular, with a layered core of fruit and a pillowy mousse, it's a vinous, vibrant Champagne that concludes with a saline finish.”
98/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Apr 2021
“What a magnificent bouquet for this Dom Pérignon 2012! Pastry, a hint of smoke and autolytic notes provide a compelling counterpart to eager yet elegant aromas of citrus (lime, tangerine and kumquat) joined by those of fresh fruit, herbs, liquorice, and menthol. There is even a refreshing note of ivy. The palate is tense, vibrant, and very fresh despite its impressive density, which meets its match with an unending finish. This 2012 incarnates the very essence of Dom Pérignon with such a concentrated degree of intensity, along with a capacity for ageing, that it is surely destined for a second life in a P2 edition.”
97/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Apr 2021
“The 2012 Champagne is 51% Chardonnay and the rest Pinot Noir and has 4 grams per liter dosage. Its style is finessed and elegant, revealing a soft, smoky perfume of fresh white flowers, pear, and fresh bread dough. The palate is focused and long, with a polished mousse, and offers notes of lime blossom, white peach, and chalky minerality as well as long perfume resonating on the finish. Best after 2024.”
96/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Apr 2021
“This eloquent Champagne has an enticing waft of Mandarin orange on the nose that continues on the palate, which is layered with flavors of crushed blackberry and cassis, toast, chopped almond, graphite and oyster shell. A bright, finely-knit and harmonious version, with a lovely, raw silk-like mousse, and a lasting, expressive finish. Drink now through 2037.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Apr 2021
“Wonderful elegance and balance to this Dom Pérignon with cooked apple, lemon and hints of white pepper and salt. It’s medium-bodied with really fine bubbles and balance. Spicy at the end. So wonderfully fresh, linear and long. Racy and elegant. A Dom Pérignon that invites to drink right now. All about finesse. Tension, too, with precise phenolics and bright acidity on the back palate. Subtle energy. Drinkable now, but will develop beautifully in the bottle.”
“Once again, the 2012 Dom Pérignon is stellar. It's a potent, tightly-wound Champagne. That should serve it well in the future, but today, the 2012 is not terribly expressive. Time in the glass brings out striking aromatic top notes and plenty of energy to match. Low yields, down 30-40%, produced a wild, dynamic Champagne endowed with tremendous character. It's an exceptional Champagne from a year marked by frost, hail, mildew, oidium and botrytis. Pretty much everything, in other words.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“Classic lemon-zest and tension nose that I associate with Dom Pérignon, but with extra weight and depth. And quite marked phenolics on the end which suggest this will have a remarkably long life. And, as Vincent Chaperon readily admitted, will definitely show up as a P2 star. Clean and neat and with light smokiness on the finish. Dom P always plays the reduction card. Hugely impressive persistence. Still a baby.”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Some vintages are vine growers' vintages, but for the 2012, Dom Pérignon's chef de cave wore the blender's hat and had an amazing set of building blocks, especially on the Pinot Noir front: Aÿ, Verzenay, Bouzy and Hautvillers. Shiny lemon green colour. The abundantly toasty nose delivers instant 'wow' notes – so subtle yet at the same time full of character. Charred tones combine with sweet vanilla, coffee and cream notes. Since release, the toastiness has really built up, and finely so. At this stage, the fruitiness is left a little behind but is as pristine as ever, showing a perfectly ripe yet crunchy profile. The palate comes with soft charm and impressive intensity, managing to remain rather light and vibrant. This is smooth-textured and rich, with fascinatingly prickly bubbles that add tension to the wine. Dosage 5g/l”
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2021
“In a near-perfect year, following a truly challenging growing season, Dom Pérignon ended up being equipped with an amazing choice of exciting and versatile building blocks for the cuvée, especially on the Pinot Noir front: Aÿ, Verzenay, Bouzy, Hautvillers... Some other vintages were vinegrowers vintages but with this one the chef de cave really wore the blender’s hat. The 2012 was a vintage of both freshness and density. At Dom Pérignon they really played the density card, effortlessly compacting together so much delicious, crunchy, perfectly ripe fruit. The nose is welcoming, harmonious and deeply fruity with Dom Pérignon’s hallmark fragrant smoky layeres. But the elements of surprise catch up with you on the palate. At first the wine feels deceptively light but then comes the fruity power and sheer volume. The wine’s most unique feature is the scintillating or tingling sensation that takes over and energises the rich, round and compact palate. It is almost as electrically charged as this nervousness and vibrancy bring such an exciting dynamism on the long, deliciously succulent palate. Dom Pérignon have made it again, they surprised me by playing on their fortes of incomparable resources and audacious winemaking.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2012 Dom Pérignon is a dense, powerful wine. I am almost shocked by its vinous intensity and raw, unbridled power. The 2012 reminds me of the 2003, but with more finesse and not quite as pushed. Mildew, rain and frost were challenges and resulted in low yields, something that was further compounded by warm, dry weather that concentrated the fruit even more. Those qualities result in a dense Dom Pérignon endowed with real phenolic intensity. It is one of the most reticent young Doms I can remember tasting, I wouldn’t even think of opening a bottle for at least a few years.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“A powerful nose opens with grilled nuts, richness, hazelnut praline, and a smoky richness. There is something inherently generous, savoury, bold and rich. It expresses itself in the salty body with its smouldering hints. The bright streak of zesty lemon only serves to accentuate the richness. The finish is wonderfully long, salty, savoury and generous.”
96/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The 2012 Dom Pérignon is developing very nicely on cork, exhibiting a complex bouquet of pear, confit citrus fruits, honeycomb, buttered toast, iodine and nuts framed by a deft touch of youthful reduction. Full-bodied, rich and muscular, with a layered core of fruit and a pillowy mousse, it's a vinous, vibrant Champagne that concludes with a saline finish.”
98/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Apr 2021
“What a magnificent bouquet for this Dom Pérignon 2012! Pastry, a hint of smoke and autolytic notes provide a compelling counterpart to eager yet elegant aromas of citrus (lime, tangerine and kumquat) joined by those of fresh fruit, herbs, liquorice, and menthol. There is even a refreshing note of ivy. The palate is tense, vibrant, and very fresh despite its impressive density, which meets its match with an unending finish. This 2012 incarnates the very essence of Dom Pérignon with such a concentrated degree of intensity, along with a capacity for ageing, that it is surely destined for a second life in a P2 edition.”
97/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Apr 2021
“The 2012 Champagne is 51% Chardonnay and the rest Pinot Noir and has 4 grams per liter dosage. Its style is finessed and elegant, revealing a soft, smoky perfume of fresh white flowers, pear, and fresh bread dough. The palate is focused and long, with a polished mousse, and offers notes of lime blossom, white peach, and chalky minerality as well as long perfume resonating on the finish. Best after 2024.”
96/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Apr 2021
“This eloquent Champagne has an enticing waft of Mandarin orange on the nose that continues on the palate, which is layered with flavors of crushed blackberry and cassis, toast, chopped almond, graphite and oyster shell. A bright, finely-knit and harmonious version, with a lovely, raw silk-like mousse, and a lasting, expressive finish. Drink now through 2037.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Apr 2021
“Wonderful elegance and balance to this Dom Pérignon with cooked apple, lemon and hints of white pepper and salt. It’s medium-bodied with really fine bubbles and balance. Spicy at the end. So wonderfully fresh, linear and long. Racy and elegant. A Dom Pérignon that invites to drink right now. All about finesse. Tension, too, with precise phenolics and bright acidity on the back palate. Subtle energy. Drinkable now, but will develop beautifully in the bottle.”
“A vintage Vincent Chaperon is convinced has been misguidedly overlooked. 54% Chardonnay, 46% Pinot Noir. Dosage 5g/l. This bottle was disgorged February 2019. For the background see this article.
Amazingly, obviously, Dom P on the nose – the powerful lemon-mousse nose came soaring out of the glass long before my nose got anywhere near it. Massive intensity of complex aroma hints that this might be a little blowsy on the palate but not a bit of it. It's really tense and tight on the palate and has a certain fumey smokiness to the very concentrated palate. But its most marked feature is the persistence of the finish. This, along with the concentration, makes me confident we will be seeing this in a P2 version, even though 15% of the potential Pinot Noir was left on the ground. Definitely not a weak vintage of Dom P.”
More Reviews +
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2020
“Gorgeous, amply toasty and smoky nose, still holding back. The fruit is impeccably crisp and appetising but still the palate carries the best surprises. There is such volume and generosity but look at the acidity rolling in complementing the exciting textural dynamics. It comes with a superbly saline and perfectly pristine finish, leaving the mouth satisfyingly refreshed, yet yearning for more. There is an appetising fluffiness to the mousse and the wine takes its 5g/l dosage effortlessly. This undoubtedly is a Dom Perignon that will keep on giving. ”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The 2010 Dom Pérignon is hard to get a read on today. I have tasted it four times over the last few months, and my feeling is that it is still not totally put together. Apricot, pastry, chamomile, mint and light tropical notes are all signatures of a hot vintage with a very fast final phase of ripening that trails only 2002 and 2003 in terms of sugars. Of course, the year had plenty of challenges. The first part of the year was marked by cold and very dry weather during the winter and spring. June saw heat and some stress in the vines. July and August were quite warm, with heavy rains on August 15 and 16 that caused a widespread outbreak of botrytis that accelerated rapidly in the days leading up to harvest. Chef de Caves Vincent Chaperon explained that Chardonnay was favored over Pinot because better aeration within the clusters helped fend off rot, while parcels that had been less stressed by the June heat also suffered less from the effects of botrytis. Perhaps because of the unevenness in the season, there is also something disjointed about the 2010. While sugars were high, so were acidities, just behind 2008 in the decade of the 2000s. It will be interesting to see where the 2010 goes over time. It is the first vintage made under the direction of Vincent Chaperon, who worked alongside outgoing Chef de Caves Richard Geoffroy for many years.”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
May 2020
“The 2010 Dom Pérignon is already expressive, wafting from the glass with aromas of crisp green apple, peach, iodine, freshly baked bread, orange oil and smoke. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and charming, it's soft and round, with ripe acids, a moderately concentrated core of fruit and a pearly mousse, concluding with a saline finish. Open-knit and pretty, this is a giving Dom Pérignon that readers might think of as reminiscent of a less reductive version of the 2000 vintage.”
“‘We’re trying to understand ripeness and put even more depth and density into the wines’, according to Chef de cave, Richard Geoffroy. For the first time they decided to switch the order of release, and release this before the 2008 – mostly because the 2008 was not ready. Rich and exuberant. This is a wine that’s already approachable, has integrated considerably since it was launched, and is so extrovert it’s almost doing a cancan.
Drink 2017-2025”
More Reviews +
93-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2017
“There is a striking easiness to this seductively fruity and soft vintage of Dom Pérignon that from first sight might come across obvious. Overt, inviting nose of pristine, sunkissed fruit with exotic fruit nuances. At this early stage it comes with a delicately toasty undertone with ripe peach, lemon sorbet and yellow apple. Plush, rounded and succulent palate with caressing mousse. Plenty of appeal on the intense, crisp-enough, wide open palate that is beautifully textured. At a closer look there is in-built power underneath the first impression of a charm and warmth. Highly enjoyable already now with many more nuances waiting to be revealed over time. ”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“The 2009 Dom Pérignon is a gorgeous, totally seductive Champagne that will drink well right out of the gate. Medium in body and unusually open-knit at this stage, the 2009 is one of the most accessible young Dom Pérignons I can remember tasting. It is an excellent choice to drink while waiting for the release of the stellar 2008 and some recent vintages that remain very young, including the 2006. Despite the warm, ripe personality of the 2009 Dom Pérignon is quite gracious, but there is plenty of depth underpinning the fruit. With each successive tasting, the 2009 seems to have gained more power and breadth, especially on the finish. Above all else, the 2009 is decidedly restrained for a warm, radiant vintage. It is not as overtly flamboyant as the 2002 nor as phenolically intense as years like 2003 and 2006. Instead, the 2009 is a beautifully balanced Champagne, with all of its elements in the right place.”
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2020
“Aromas of fresh brioche, green pear, waxy citrus rind, iodine and subtly autolytic top notes mingle in an inviting bouquet, introducing the 2009 Dom Pérignon. It's a medium to full-bodied, broad and fleshy wine that's rich and textural, with good concentration and lively acids despite being the ripest rendition in the history of this cuvée. As I wrote earlier this year, while the wine is open and enveloping, there's also enough energy and structure here to promise good mid-term aging potential, something that becomes more apparent as the wine loses a little puppy fat.”
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon remains one of the all-time greats here. No longer a young Champagne, the 2008 has begun moving into its first plateau of maturity. Baked apple tart, citrus confit, marzipan and lightly honeyed overtones are front and center. A touch of reduction—always present in 2008—adds freshness and energy.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Dec 2024
“Rich, complex nose with a certain almost-sweet lemon-cream sensation before great texture of freshness and zip. Very complete with so much going on and an extraordinarily long aftertaste. A really lovely champagne. Another great 2008”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Aug 2021
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon is a huge, powerful Champagne and also clearly one of the wines of the vintage. This is one of the most reticent bottles I have tasted. So much so that I am thinking about holding off opening any more bottles! The 2008 has always offered a striking interplay of fruit and structure. Today, the richness of the fruit is especially evident. Readers who own the 2008 should be thrilled, but patience is a must.”
98/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Oct 2024
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon is the first time the estate has released a wine out of order (the 2009 was released before the 2008) but the estate loved the wine so much they felt it warranted additional aging. This is a rich, powerful wine that still shows incredible purity and elegance, with a stacked, concentrated feel on the palate. It’s rare to find such a mix of ripe, pure, concentrated fruit paired with this level of purity, focus, and precision. This is a legendary Dom that surpasses all the great vintages of Dom I have experience with, including the 1990, 1996, and 2002.”
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2018
“There is a striking easiness to this seductively fruity and soft vintage of Dom Pérignon that from first sight might come across obvious. Overt, inviting nose of pristine, sunkissed fruit with exotic fruit nuances. At this early stage it comes with a delicately toasty undertone with ripe peach, lemon sorbet and yellow apple. Plush, rounded and succulent palate with caressing mousse. Plenty of appeal on the intense, crisp-enough, wide open palate that is beautifully textured. At a closer look there is in-built power underneath the first impression of a charm and warmth. Highly enjoyable already now with many more nuances waiting to be revealed over time. ”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Unquestionably the finest Dom Pérignon of the decade, the 2008 Dom Pérignon is drinking brilliantly today, wafting from the glass with notes of citrus oil, ripe orchard fruit, peach, buttered toast, pastry cream, iodine and smoky reduction. Full-bodied, rich and fleshy, it's vinous and layered, with a deep core of sweet fruit, racy acids and a long, saline finish. The 2008 is aging very gracefully.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“This keenly-anticipated wine has deliberately been held back to be released after the Dom Pérignon 2009 and in fact will not be released commercially until towards the end of 2018 (although it already seems pretty good to me). Geoffroy reminded me that the growing season was no picnic - in fact he described all but the end of it as 'miserable' because it was so overcast and the disease pressure was so high. Fine weather at the end finally ripened the grapes though acid levels were notably high. I wondered whether, since the grapes were harvested just as the global financial crisis was beginning to bite, they reduced the quantity made of Dom P, but no. 'We made lots!', he assured me.
Brisk, tiny mousse. Notably rich nose - very Dom P! There's a hint of something marine on the nose (Michael Broadbent's oyster shells?) and then extremely tight and lacy - it somehow reminded me of a sponge because of springy texture. Masses of energy here, as well as the usual flirtatiousness. It will continue to open out, I'm sure. I tasted it very cool and then went back to it at almost room temperature a couple of hours later and it stood up extremely well. The official Geoffroy description of this vintage is 'athletic' and 'vertical'. 'All 2008s are bright in terms of fruit; we want ours to shine white light. We have deliberately warmed it up a bit, working on the muscle to better integrate the acidity.'”
18.5++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Really complex nose. Tight and layered. Very much a 2008 with very high acidity but much more undertow and embroidery than the Grande Dame 2008. Still very youthful. I’d be tempted to decant this, almost!”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon is fabulous, but quite remarkably, it was even more open when I tasted it a year ago. Bright, focused and crystalline in its precision, the 2008 is going to need a number of years before it is at its best. Lemon peel, white flowers, mint and white pepper give the 2008 its chiseled, bright profile. Several recent bottles have all been magnificent. What I admire most about the 2008 is the way it shows all the focus, translucence and energy that is such a signature of the year, and yet it is also remarkably deep and vertical. In other words, the 2008 is a Champagne that plays in three dimensions.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon is once again stunning. More than anything else, I am surprised by how well the 2008 drinks given all the tension and energy it holds. Then again, that is precisely what makes 2008 such a unique vintage – namely that the best wines are so chiseled and yet not at all austere. Lemon peel, almond, mint, smoke and crushed rocks are all finely sculpted, but it is the wine’s textural feel, drive and persistence that elevate it into the realm of the sublime. The 2008 will be even better with time in the cellar, but it is absolutely phenomenal even today, in the early going. Three recent bottles have all been nothing short of magnificent. ”
“Richard Geoffroy lost sleep this year that was characterised by rain then sun. A terrible August was rescued by a fine September – a little like 2008. Worryingly high pH. The vintage could easily have been written off. Released after nine years on the lees. M Geoffroy says it needed at least six or seven years ‘and the wine was nowhere before that’.
Some evolution on the nose with real interest. Smells so much older than either the 2008 or the 2009. Flirtatious. Clean and fresh. Very zesty in flavour but with a lovely creamy texture.
Drink 2016-2024”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“Powerful, dense and tightly wound, the 2006 Dom Pérignon is fabulous today. To be sure, the 2006 is a broad, virile Champagne, but I find it compelling because of its phenolic depth and overall intensity. Chef de Caves Richard Geoffroy adds that August was quite cold and wet, and that ripening only happened at the very end of the growing season. Although numbers alone can never explain a wine, I find it interesting that the 2006 has more phenolics than the 2003. Readers will have to be patient, as the 2006 is easily the most reticent Dom Pérignon in the years spanning 2002 and 2009. I am confident the 2006 will have its day, but in its youth, it is not especially charming or easy to drink.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“One of the real surprises in this tasting, the 2006 Dom Pérignon comes across as very tightly wound and intense, which is probably a very good thing for its potential longevity. The sensation of tannins is quite present today. Ripe and intense but also held in check by its tannic heft, the 2006 is in no mood to show all of its cards. Stylistically, the 2006 is similar to the 2003 in its phenolic intensity, but more finessed. Readers should be in no rush with the 2006, a Champagne that has closed down quite a bit since it was first released.”
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2016
“Chef de Cave Richard Geoffroy is at ease, even exited about Champagne’s warming vintages for Dom Pérignon. He is not shy to demonstrate a broader scope of vintage expressions being increasingly comfortable at extremes. The 2006 is a bold and ripe Dom Pérignon full of exuberant tropical fruit and vanilla notes, topped up with the hallmark fragrant, gunpowder and toast character. It has a broad, rich mid-palate and a truly dry, salient finish with a phenolic touch of a ripe year. The fruitiness is polished and bright and there is fine, balanced freshness to it. This vintage is built to last, it is still tight but packed with fleshy fruitiness. 94 points today with potential for 96 points.”
92/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2016
“Stylish glittering pale gold with tiny flowing bubbles. Chardonnay scents lead into citrus fruits with floral lilac and snow drop aromas. The Pinot Noir is starting to stir amongst the ripe pear and peach flavours that are healthily tight. A fine acidity in a year lacking some. As always you need to be patient with Dom Pérignon, the supreme reductive style. This is still a baby with much potential.
”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2016
“Back label says this is the ‘First Plénitude’ of Dom P, having been aged for nine years. 55% Pinot Noir, 45% Chardonnay.
Bright pale slightly greenish straw. Rich, very tightly laced nose with many layers and great density – on the nose. Real excitement here with some tension. Some unashamed richness underneath but excellent freshness too. Something quite electric about this. Almost unfurled. You could certainly drink this with pleasure already but there is clearly lots tucked away here for future development. Impressively long and reverberant. 12%”
96/100
Robert Parker Jr,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“The 2006 Dom Pérignon comes from a very rich vintage with an early ripeness that brought a lot of aromatic maturity. The white-golden prestige cuvée contains a bit more Chardonnay than Pinot Noir and opens with a deep and seductive, pretty accessible nose with intense yet fresh fruit aromas of pineapples, with peaches and tangerines. Lively and elegant on the palate, this is a full-bodied, unusually aromatic and fruity DP with a long and tension-filled expression.”
93/100
Andrew Jefford,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2016
“A genuinely outstanding effort with the sometimes over-rich 2006 vintage, the light-gold DP is classy, fresh, refined and floral, with an intense, vivacious, darting palate with a weave of green lime and sea-shore pungency through it. Not many 06s can truly be said to be ‘chalky’ but this, weighed and filtered on the tongue, does indeed suggest the powdery dust which falls from the blackboard as you wipe it. Perhaps pure-steel handling helps the drinker perceive this? ”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Oct 2015
“The 2006 Dom Pérignon is a beautifully balanced, harmonious Dom Pérignon that strikes an incredibly appealing stylistic middle ground. Rich, voluptuous and creamy, the 2006 shows off fabulous intensity in a style that brings together the ripeness of 2002 with the greater sense of verve and overall freshness that is such a signature of the 2004. Bass notes and a feeling of phenolic grip on the finish recall the 2003, as the Pinot Noir is particularly expressive today. After an irregular summer that saw elevated temperatures in July followed by cooler, damp conditions in August, more favorable weather returned in September, pushing maturation ahead and leading to a long, protracted harvest. The 2006 falls into the family of riper, more voluptuous Dom Pérignons, but without veering into the level of opulence seen in vintages such as 2002.”
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“Tasted blind. Pale greenish gold. Intense youthful nose. Dense and tense. Youthful with some sweetish creaminess. Slightly chewy on the end. 2006? ”
96/100
Assi Evellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2015
“The 2006 is a bold and ripe Dom Pérignon full of exuberant tropical fruit and vanilla notes, topped up with the hallmark fragrant, gunpowder and toast character. It has a broad, rich mid-palate and a truly dry, salient finish with a phenolic touch of a ripe year. The fruitiness is polished and bright and there is fine, balanced freshness to it. This vintage is built to last, it is still tight but packed with fleshy fruitiness. ”
“Tasted blind. Notably sweet – icing sugar? – nose. More serious on the palate. Great tightly drawn texture suggests Dom P. But not enormous undertow, just a little loose. A 2004?”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Quite a youthful greenish straw. But with some reductive evolution on the nose. Very lively palate. Just a bit short and bitter. Racy and filigree. Lots of finesse.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“Another stellar wine, the 2004 Dom Pérignon is just starting to show the first signs of aromatic development, as well as a bit of added weight it did not have as a young wine. The 2004 remains a bright, mid-weight DP built on persistence and length more than overt volume. I have always had a soft spot for the 2004. This tasting does nothing to dampen that enthusiasm.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Three-litre Jéroboam. A vintage described by Richard Geoffroy as ‘a no-brainer – you just had to be wise enough to step back’. The biggest ever vintage – still.
Real richness of age on the nose – even a suggestion of crème pâtissière. This is a real classic with massive edge and excitement. Lovely neat, saline finish.
Drink 2015-2030”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“A wine of nuance, precision and understatement, the 2004 remains all grace. Time has softened some of the contours, but the flavors remain fresh and vibrant. Medium in body, the 2004 can be enjoyed now or cellared for several decades. This is a gorgeous showing from the 2004, a wine that has been captivatingly beautiful from the first time I tasted it years ago. There is something effortless about the 2004 that is hard to capture with words. The 2004 doesn't quite have the obvious breeding of the 2008 and 2002, nor the obvious power of the 2003 or 2006, and yet it is harmonious, sublime and totally sensual. ”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“One of the stars in this tasting, the 2004 Dom Pérignon is starting to express the potential it hinted at as a young wine. Specifically, the 2004 has gained quite a bit of volume and overall depth within the last few years. The first signs of aromatic nuance are starting to develop, which suggests the 2004 will soon enter its first plateau of maturity.”
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2016
“Elegantly toasty sweet patisserie nose with coffee, perfume and flowers. Lively, mineral, racy, crisp palate with great fruit purity. On the reductive side but beautifully so. Still young with tight, compact palate. A ballerina. A classic, super fresh and delightfully light Dom Pérignon with a green note and a cool breeze to it. I will love to follow up how this one ages. Very much a DP and very much a 2004.”
92+/100
Robert Parker Jr,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“The 2004 Dom Pérignon is from a classic vintage and a very generous year in terms of yields. White-golden in color, the clear, discreet and subtle nose gives way to dried white rather than yellow fruits, raisins and hazelnuts, as well as to floral and herbal aromas. Less generous and concentrated in the mouth than the 2005 and austerely dry at the moment, the 2004 shows its great finesse and characteristic minerality. There should be a better point of time to praise its class, so trust and keep it!”
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2016
“Elegantly toasty sweet patisserie nose with coffee, perfume and flowers. Lively, mineral, racy, crisp palate with great fruit purity. On the reductive side but beautifully so. Still young with tight, compact palate. A ballerina. A classic, super fresh and delightfully light Dom Pérignon with a green note and a cool breeze to it. I will love to follow up how this one ages. Very much a DP and very much a 2004.”
18.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“Tasted blind. Very minerally nose. Excellent acidity. Very well structured. Still a little bit of framework here as well as fruit. Quite a youthful wine. But broad and exotic on the nose. 2004? ”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“Racy, silky and vibrant in the glass, the 2004 Dom Pérignon is all about energy. Here the flavors are bright and delineated throughout, with veins of acidity and minerality that give the wine its sense of drive. Mint, rosemary and yellow-fleshed fruits linger on the finish with the classic DP reductive overtones that are such a signature. Once again, the 2004 Dom Pérignon truly shines. The 2004 Dom Pérignon is a wine to treasure over the next thirty or so years.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“This tasting only serves to highlight just how great the 2004 Dom Pérignon is. A wine that has totally blossomed in bottle, the 2004 is firing on all cylinders right now. Rich, ample and beautifully nuanced, the 2004 has it all; expressive aromatics, deep fruit and more than enough structure to age well for decades. I have been tasting the 2004 since before it was released and it just keeps getting better and better. Today, it is stunning. It is amazing to consider that in 2004, yields were the largest ever recorded in Champagne.”
94/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Nov 2013
“Vivid yellow. High-pitched, mineral-accented aromas of pear, Meyer lemon, quince and jasmine, with smoke and toasted grain qualities adding bass notes. Spicy, penetrating and pure, boasting impressive vivacity to its fresh orchard and citrus fruit flavors. Gains weight and breadth with air while maintaining vivacity, picking up a gingery nuance that carries through a long, smoky finish. I'd bet on this taut, youthful Champagne rewarding many more years of patience.”
95/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“Lily-of-the-valley perfume and scents of lightly toasted brioche and almond rise from the glass of Moet’s 2004 Brut Dom Perignon, along with hints of the apricot, pear and grapefruit that then inform a luscious and creamy yet strikingly delicate as well as consummately refreshing palate. Sweet-saline savor of scallop – also already intimated in the nose – lends compulsive saliva-inducement to a ravishingly rarified and persistent finish, joined by alkaline, nutty, liquid-floral, and nori seaweed notes for a performance of head-scratching subtlety and intrigue. (In case my description hasn’t already made clear, we have here inter alia a fantastic sushi wine.) This will be worth following for at least the next 6-8 years, in the course of demonstrating that iconic status as a luxury brand, and elevated (albeit secret) production numbers by no means preclude a wine of understated as well as profound beauty.”
95/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Sep 2013
“There’s a sense of tension paired with grace in this deftly balanced version, with a rich and smoky vein of minerality underscoring the flavors of poached apple, honey, financier and sun-dried black cherry, showing hints of roasted almond, coffee liqueur and ground spice. Drink now through 2029”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2013
“Very pale straw gold with surely the most discreet bubbles in the champagne world. Very different from the 2003. A much more recognisable Dom Pérignon sort of nose with fairly intense classic toastiness. Minerals and raciness rather than fruit and body. Marked acidity and even a little lean but very fine. There are notes of iodine and bitter orange peel. This wine really gets saliva flowing. The finish is not massively persistent but overall this is a very well mannered wine. A Chablis of a champagne - which 2003 definitely wasn't! (It was more of a Pouilly-Fuissé.)”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2013
“The 2004 Dom Pérignon continues to develop beautifully. A vibrant, focused Champagne, the 2004 clearly reflects the personality of the year. Freshly cut flowers, white peaches and pears are woven together in a Champagne that impresses for its focus and energy. Chiseled saline note support the crystalline finish. I imagine the 2004 will always remain relatively bright and linear, but at the same time, each time I have tasted it over the last two years the 2004 seems to have a little more body and broader shoulders. The 2004 will appeal most to readers who find the 2002 and 2003 too exuberant. There is a lot to like in the glass.”
“Tasted blind. Notably sweet – icing sugar? – nose. More serious on the palate. Great tightly drawn texture suggests Dom P. But not enormous undertow, just a little loose. A 2004?”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Quite a youthful greenish straw. But with some reductive evolution on the nose. Very lively palate. Just a bit short and bitter. Racy and filigree. Lots of finesse.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“Another stellar wine, the 2004 Dom Pérignon is just starting to show the first signs of aromatic development, as well as a bit of added weight it did not have as a young wine. The 2004 remains a bright, mid-weight DP built on persistence and length more than overt volume. I have always had a soft spot for the 2004. This tasting does nothing to dampen that enthusiasm.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Three-litre Jéroboam. A vintage described by Richard Geoffroy as ‘a no-brainer – you just had to be wise enough to step back’. The biggest ever vintage – still.
Real richness of age on the nose – even a suggestion of crème pâtissière. This is a real classic with massive edge and excitement. Lovely neat, saline finish.
Drink 2015-2030”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“A wine of nuance, precision and understatement, the 2004 remains all grace. Time has softened some of the contours, but the flavors remain fresh and vibrant. Medium in body, the 2004 can be enjoyed now or cellared for several decades. This is a gorgeous showing from the 2004, a wine that has been captivatingly beautiful from the first time I tasted it years ago. There is something effortless about the 2004 that is hard to capture with words. The 2004 doesn't quite have the obvious breeding of the 2008 and 2002, nor the obvious power of the 2003 or 2006, and yet it is harmonious, sublime and totally sensual. ”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“One of the stars in this tasting, the 2004 Dom Pérignon is starting to express the potential it hinted at as a young wine. Specifically, the 2004 has gained quite a bit of volume and overall depth within the last few years. The first signs of aromatic nuance are starting to develop, which suggests the 2004 will soon enter its first plateau of maturity.”
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2016
“Elegantly toasty sweet patisserie nose with coffee, perfume and flowers. Lively, mineral, racy, crisp palate with great fruit purity. On the reductive side but beautifully so. Still young with tight, compact palate. A ballerina. A classic, super fresh and delightfully light Dom Pérignon with a green note and a cool breeze to it. I will love to follow up how this one ages. Very much a DP and very much a 2004.”
92+/100
Robert Parker Jr,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“The 2004 Dom Pérignon is from a classic vintage and a very generous year in terms of yields. White-golden in color, the clear, discreet and subtle nose gives way to dried white rather than yellow fruits, raisins and hazelnuts, as well as to floral and herbal aromas. Less generous and concentrated in the mouth than the 2005 and austerely dry at the moment, the 2004 shows its great finesse and characteristic minerality. There should be a better point of time to praise its class, so trust and keep it!”
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2016
“Elegantly toasty sweet patisserie nose with coffee, perfume and flowers. Lively, mineral, racy, crisp palate with great fruit purity. On the reductive side but beautifully so. Still young with tight, compact palate. A ballerina. A classic, super fresh and delightfully light Dom Pérignon with a green note and a cool breeze to it. I will love to follow up how this one ages. Very much a DP and very much a 2004.”
18.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“Tasted blind. Very minerally nose. Excellent acidity. Very well structured. Still a little bit of framework here as well as fruit. Quite a youthful wine. But broad and exotic on the nose. 2004? ”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“Racy, silky and vibrant in the glass, the 2004 Dom Pérignon is all about energy. Here the flavors are bright and delineated throughout, with veins of acidity and minerality that give the wine its sense of drive. Mint, rosemary and yellow-fleshed fruits linger on the finish with the classic DP reductive overtones that are such a signature. Once again, the 2004 Dom Pérignon truly shines. The 2004 Dom Pérignon is a wine to treasure over the next thirty or so years.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“This tasting only serves to highlight just how great the 2004 Dom Pérignon is. A wine that has totally blossomed in bottle, the 2004 is firing on all cylinders right now. Rich, ample and beautifully nuanced, the 2004 has it all; expressive aromatics, deep fruit and more than enough structure to age well for decades. I have been tasting the 2004 since before it was released and it just keeps getting better and better. Today, it is stunning. It is amazing to consider that in 2004, yields were the largest ever recorded in Champagne.”
94/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Nov 2013
“Vivid yellow. High-pitched, mineral-accented aromas of pear, Meyer lemon, quince and jasmine, with smoke and toasted grain qualities adding bass notes. Spicy, penetrating and pure, boasting impressive vivacity to its fresh orchard and citrus fruit flavors. Gains weight and breadth with air while maintaining vivacity, picking up a gingery nuance that carries through a long, smoky finish. I'd bet on this taut, youthful Champagne rewarding many more years of patience.”
95/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“Lily-of-the-valley perfume and scents of lightly toasted brioche and almond rise from the glass of Moet’s 2004 Brut Dom Perignon, along with hints of the apricot, pear and grapefruit that then inform a luscious and creamy yet strikingly delicate as well as consummately refreshing palate. Sweet-saline savor of scallop – also already intimated in the nose – lends compulsive saliva-inducement to a ravishingly rarified and persistent finish, joined by alkaline, nutty, liquid-floral, and nori seaweed notes for a performance of head-scratching subtlety and intrigue. (In case my description hasn’t already made clear, we have here inter alia a fantastic sushi wine.) This will be worth following for at least the next 6-8 years, in the course of demonstrating that iconic status as a luxury brand, and elevated (albeit secret) production numbers by no means preclude a wine of understated as well as profound beauty.”
95/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Sep 2013
“There’s a sense of tension paired with grace in this deftly balanced version, with a rich and smoky vein of minerality underscoring the flavors of poached apple, honey, financier and sun-dried black cherry, showing hints of roasted almond, coffee liqueur and ground spice. Drink now through 2029”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2013
“Very pale straw gold with surely the most discreet bubbles in the champagne world. Very different from the 2003. A much more recognisable Dom Pérignon sort of nose with fairly intense classic toastiness. Minerals and raciness rather than fruit and body. Marked acidity and even a little lean but very fine. There are notes of iodine and bitter orange peel. This wine really gets saliva flowing. The finish is not massively persistent but overall this is a very well mannered wine. A Chablis of a champagne - which 2003 definitely wasn't! (It was more of a Pouilly-Fuissé.)”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2013
“The 2004 Dom Pérignon continues to develop beautifully. A vibrant, focused Champagne, the 2004 clearly reflects the personality of the year. Freshly cut flowers, white peaches and pears are woven together in a Champagne that impresses for its focus and energy. Chiseled saline note support the crystalline finish. I imagine the 2004 will always remain relatively bright and linear, but at the same time, each time I have tasted it over the last two years the 2004 seems to have a little more body and broader shoulders. The 2004 will appeal most to readers who find the 2002 and 2003 too exuberant. There is a lot to like in the glass.”
“The 2003 Dom Pérignon is in a gorgeous place right now. To be sure, it is a powerful Champagne that reflects the personality of a year marked by frost, that took out 70% of the Chardonnay, and then record heat and drought over the summer. The 2003 is just starting to head into its first plateau of maturity. Brioche, baked apple tart, lemon confit and marzipan build into the rich, layered finish.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Richard Geoffroy is particularly fond and defensive of this because so few people managed a fine wine in this heatwave vintage and he describes it as ‘a triumph of winemaking! Most exhilarating and satisfying. And it really created a team spirit that has continued to this day’. Yield was only 20 hl/ha. He admits it was released too early. ‘Wait for P2 2003!’ he assures us.
Much less expressive nose than the 2004 so I suggested people tasted it beforehand so that it would not be overwhelmed by the 2004. Great tension. There was some suggestion of a dry spice – a hint of a cinnamon stick. Great balance. It just falls away a little on the end.
Drink 2013-2024”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“Once again, the 2003 Dom Pérignon shows its pedigree. Ample, powerful and beautifully resonant in the glass, the 2003 is built on a core of huge fruit and serious phenolic structure, both of which make it resemble a still wine, perhaps a fine white Burgundy with a bit of bottle age. There is more than enough density to allow the 2003 to age well for a number of decades. ”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2017
“Pale greenish gold. Lively and very fresh. Really zippy, I thought it could have been Salon! Vindication of Richard Geoffroy's faith in this wine.”
93-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2016
“Fresh and fragrant straw and lemon nose, mellow in style with less precision and lower on its usual toasty impact. Lately, it has been developing an exquisite charred complexity. Ripe, fleshy, honeyed fluffy palate with a touch of phenolic bitterness, however, none of the overripe characters of the vintage. Soft acidity and approachable style. Today, overt, monumental and beautifully textured. One of the finest champagnes of the vintage.”
“The 2015 Dom Pérignon is terrific. Bright and poised, the 2015 shows terrific energy. Citrus peel, white flowers, mint, white pepper and slate all race across the palate. There's gorgeous tension and backbone here, with bright saline notes that extend the mid-palate and finish. This is a fine showing in a vintage that has proven to be tricky. I am intrigued to see how the 2015 develops in the coming years. ”
More Reviews +
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2024
“Pale honey colour and some notes of green leafiness. Still very tight and tense, as though it still has to relax and breathe out. Hints of orange peel but less of the rich citrus creaminess that so often characterises Dom Pérignon than usual. This seems a little longer than the bottle tasted last month.”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
May 2024
“Disgorged in January 2023, the 2015 Dom Pérignon shows a singular, ethereal profile with aromas of white pepper, iodine, ripe orchard fruits, toast, smoke, herbs and spices. Medium to full-bodied, layered, and structured, it’s enveloping and round with a delicate phenolic mid-palate that underlines chalky dry extracts, concluding with a sapid, penetrating finish with gastronomic bitterness. This iteration of Dom Pérignon, though replete with the customary charm and vinous generosity that typify the label, distinguishes itself by its structural delicate austerity and a notably phenolic profile, giving rise to a remarkably linear and well-defined style that diverges markedly from the more familiar expressions of Dom Pérignon. This is a blend of 51% Pinot Noir and 49% Chardonnay with a dosage of 4.5 grams per liter; it will age wonderfully and can be enjoyed now or over the next 20 years.”
“Unquestionably the finest Dom Pérignon of the decade, the 2008 Dom Pérignon is drinking brilliantly today, wafting from the glass with notes of citrus oil, ripe orchard fruit, peach, buttered toast, pastry cream, iodine and smoky reduction. Full-bodied, rich and fleshy, it's vinous and layered, with a deep core of sweet fruit, racy acids and a long, saline finish. The 2008 is aging very gracefully.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Aug 2021
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon is a huge, powerful Champagne and also clearly one of the wines of the vintage. This is one of the most reticent bottles I have tasted. So much so that I am thinking about holding off opening any more bottles! The 2008 has always offered a striking interplay of fruit and structure. Today, the richness of the fruit is especially evident. Readers who own the 2008 should be thrilled, but patience is a must.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon is once again stunning. More than anything else, I am surprised by how well the 2008 drinks given all the tension and energy it holds. Then again, that is precisely what makes 2008 such a unique vintage – namely that the best wines are so chiseled and yet not at all austere. Lemon peel, almond, mint, smoke and crushed rocks are all finely sculpted, but it is the wine’s textural feel, drive and persistence that elevate it into the realm of the sublime. The 2008 will be even better with time in the cellar, but it is absolutely phenomenal even today, in the early going. Three recent bottles have all been nothing short of magnificent. ”
18.5++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Really complex nose. Tight and layered. Very much a 2008 with very high acidity but much more undertow and embroidery than the Grande Dame 2008. Still very youthful. I’d be tempted to decant this, almost!”
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2018
“There is a striking easiness to this seductively fruity and soft vintage of Dom Pérignon that from first sight might come across obvious. Overt, inviting nose of pristine, sunkissed fruit with exotic fruit nuances. At this early stage it comes with a delicately toasty undertone with ripe peach, lemon sorbet and yellow apple. Plush, rounded and succulent palate with caressing mousse. Plenty of appeal on the intense, crisp-enough, wide open palate that is beautifully textured. At a closer look there is in-built power underneath the first impression of a charm and warmth. Highly enjoyable already now with many more nuances waiting to be revealed over time. ”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“This keenly-anticipated wine has deliberately been held back to be released after the Dom Pérignon 2009 and in fact will not be released commercially until towards the end of 2018 (although it already seems pretty good to me). Geoffroy reminded me that the growing season was no picnic - in fact he described all but the end of it as 'miserable' because it was so overcast and the disease pressure was so high. Fine weather at the end finally ripened the grapes though acid levels were notably high. I wondered whether, since the grapes were harvested just as the global financial crisis was beginning to bite, they reduced the quantity made of Dom P, but no. 'We made lots!', he assured me.
Brisk, tiny mousse. Notably rich nose - very Dom P! There's a hint of something marine on the nose (Michael Broadbent's oyster shells?) and then extremely tight and lacy - it somehow reminded me of a sponge because of springy texture. Masses of energy here, as well as the usual flirtatiousness. It will continue to open out, I'm sure. I tasted it very cool and then went back to it at almost room temperature a couple of hours later and it stood up extremely well. The official Geoffroy description of this vintage is 'athletic' and 'vertical'. 'All 2008s are bright in terms of fruit; we want ours to shine white light. We have deliberately warmed it up a bit, working on the muscle to better integrate the acidity.'”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The 2008 Dom Pérignon is fabulous, but quite remarkably, it was even more open when I tasted it a year ago. Bright, focused and crystalline in its precision, the 2008 is going to need a number of years before it is at its best. Lemon peel, white flowers, mint and white pepper give the 2008 its chiseled, bright profile. Several recent bottles have all been magnificent. What I admire most about the 2008 is the way it shows all the focus, translucence and energy that is such a signature of the year, and yet it is also remarkably deep and vertical. In other words, the 2008 is a Champagne that plays in three dimensions.”
“Disgorged in April 2019, the 2009 Dom Ruinart Blanc de Blancs continues to drink very well, bursting with aromas of crisp stone fruit, confit citrus, wheat toast, bee pollen and smoky reduction. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and charming, it's a pillowy, giving Champagne with excellent depth at the core, tangy structuring acids and a saline finish. Admirers of the Ruinart style will love it.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“The 2009 Dom Ruinart has been absolutely fabulous on two separate occasions. Chef de Caves Frédéric Panaïotis turned out a brilliant edition of this tête de cuvée that offers a compelling balance of richness and vibrancy. Citrus, mineral, spice and dried flowers are all beautifully delineated throughout. In 2009 Dom Ruinart has a bit less fruit from the Montagne de Reims and more from the Côte des Blancs (specifically Cramant, Avize, Chouilly and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger) than has often been the case. This approach gives the wine more tension and steeliness than readers might expect in a vintage known for generally forthcoming Champagnes. I would not be in any rush to open the 2009, as it very clearly needs time. The only question is how much. Superb.”
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2021
“Despite having three years post-disgorgement ageing (disgorged 3/2018), upon release it is still elegantly reserved and smoky-mineral in aromatics. The year was dry and sunny but the wine had managed to keep its crunchy fruit profile with lemon, yellow apple and ripe apricots. Takes some time to open in the glass and a large-bowled burgundy shape works particularly well at its youth. On the palate it comes with ample, attractive fruitiness and fleshy mouth-feel, less on the oily side. But by no means is it soft in the way many wines of the vintage are, instead it is surprisingly crisp and invigoratingly feisty. The slow aging curve it seems to be on promises great longevity.”
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The 2009 Dom Ruinart Blanc de Blancs is showing very well out of the gates, wafting from the glass with aromas of stone fruits, wheat toast, blanched almonds and white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and incisive, with an ample core of fruit, bright acids and chalky grip, it's complemented by a pretty pinpoint mousse. This is a charming, generous Dom Ruinart, yet it's also quite structured for the vintage and should enjoy a long life.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“The first whiff is softly floral, think narcissus, and entirely creamy – very perfumed and intense. This is followed by insistent notes of wet chalk and pure lemon freshness along with a kind of savouriness, reminiscent of almond paste. With air, it becomes more and more pronounced. The palate has something joyful and generous, luminous and fresh, sinuous and poised. The intense concentration reveals profound flavour, a savoury saltiness that refers back to the almond paste, to cool, chalky, lemony depth. The length is astonishing and while delicious now, this will evolve beautifully. ”
“The first Dom Ruinart crafted by chef de cave Frédéricic Panaïotis. Wide open, buttery nose with ripe Chardonnay profile with apple, lemon, liquorice and mild toastiness. Behind the ripe tones there is also a cool touch of green fruit. Full-bodied, succulent palate with a touch of firming phenolics on the richly fruity back palate of yeasty fullness. Lovely, athletic acid structure backing up the generosity of the fruit. A Dom Ruinart with mid-term potential.
In July 2023 magnums were showing brilliant, albeit youthful. Fine toasty richness to the nose. Blooming with lots of delicious fruit underneath. Silky smooth and super elegant on the long lingering fruit-packed finish. 95->98”
More Reviews +
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“Magnum - The 2007 Dom Ruinart is in a gorgeous spot right now where it is just starting to open. If anything, the magnum lags the 750ml bottle at this stage in terms of its development, which is of course to be expected. I admire the textural resonance here. ”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The 2007 Dom Ruinart is a stunning, stunning wine. It is also incredibly tight today. Bright acids and beams of minerality infuse the 2007 with remarkable energy and pure cut that carries through to the impossibly long finish. Lemon confit, marzipan, dried flowers, white pepper and a touch of reduction all develop with a bit of time in the glass. The 2007 Dom Ruinart is the first vintage made entirely by Chef de Caves Frédéric Panaïotis. In his debut vintage, Panaïotis took Dom Ruinart, which has traditionally relied on a relatively high percentage of Chardonnay from the Montagne de Reims and tilted the balance to 75% Côtes des Blancs and 25% Montagne de Reims fruit, while also lowering the dosage significantly. As for the wine, it is breathtaking. That's the good news. Readers will have to be patient, though, as the 2007 needs time to be at its very best. Disgorged: November, 2017.”
96/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2020
“Light golden yellow, silver reflections, delicate mousse. A hint of biscuit on the nose with fragrant white peach, hints of blossom honey and candied orange zest. Juicy yellow tropical fruit, delicate nutty caramel touch, balanced by a sturdy structure, green apple, lemony-saline nuances on the finish, harmonious and easy to drink, has further potential for ageing. ”
“The Blanc de Blancs from the warm 2006 vintage, a year patronisingly rated by some as a ripe pleasure-giver, has a surprise in store. It has grip and backbone for a longer life than anyone thought it would.
2006 displayed extremes of a continental growing season: a very cold winter followed by a hot summer, complicated by a cool August and sunny September, then rain calling for fast picking. No surprise then that the hardier Chardonnay was the unsung saviour for non-oxidative winemaking.
From 100% grand cru Chardonnay. Flowing bubbles and gorgeous aromas, inherently rich but with aristocratic poise akin to a fine Puligny Montrachet. Magically opulent yet with a firm grip and core, a vegetative structure in the best sense. Long, youthful finale. Disgorged January 2016.”
More Reviews +
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2017
“Light and creamy-textured. Rather flattering even if slightly soft. Definitely not rapier-like - more like a kiss on the cheek.”
96+/20
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Aug 2016
“One of the highlights among this year's new tête de cuvée releases, 2006 the Brut Blanc de Blancs Dom Ruinart is a powerful, almost tannic Champagne built on structure and intensity. Then again, much of the Chardonnay here comes from the Montagne de Reims, where wines tend to naturally be quite broad. Even though it's now ten years old, the 2006 is much less expressive than either the 2002 or 2004 at a similar stage. I expect it will be quite a few years before the 2006 is truly ready to drink. Over the years I have been fortunate to taste Dom Ruinart back to the 1970s, and while I don't think the 2006 will need decades to be at its best, it certainly does look like a long distance runner. There is plenty of citrus and floral driven intensity, although the bouquet is less toasty and open than it often is. In short, the 2006 Dom Ruinart is a wine for those who can be patient. It will be a fine investment for those looking for a wine to cellar to commemorate special occasions. Lot L AJSXAC.”
“Very pale indeed. Light, delicate and flirtatious but with considerable evolution on the nose. Feather-light and a little suggestion of dosage. A little chewy on the end.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2019
“Tasted blind. Round, sweetly broad nose. Rather loose and flirtatious. Light and quite delicate. Lacy. Pretty. Comtes?”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Dec 2014
“Showing an impressive backbone of acidity, this is dense and powerful, yet harmonious overall. The fine, creamy mousse swathesthe statuesque frame in a silky texture, with honeysuckle, graphite and hazelnut notes lending fragrant accents to the rich palate of baked white peach, toasted brioche, lemon confit and smoke. Drink now through 2030”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Light, youthful nose. Much less evolved than the 2002 vintage. Still in the bloom of youth and with more to give.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“The 2004 Dom Ruinart is just as brilliant and viscerally thrilling as it has always been. If anything, the 2004 has shut down considerably over the last six months. Tightly coiled and exceptionally beautiful, the 2004 boasts fabulous intensity, class and pedigree. The flavors are vibrant, chiseled and crystalline in their precision. Time in bottle is doing wonders for the 2004. This is a tremendous showing. Disgorged June 2013.”
17/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2014
“Disgorged June/July 2013. Tiny bubbles, not much aroma, just a hint of citrus. Light and delicate and with immense tension at the core, the freshness verging on sour apple and a slightly woody note but with those fine fine bubbles.”
96+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“The 2004 Dom Ruinart is seriously beautiful. A vivid, captivating Champagne, the 2004 flows across the palate with gorgeous, crystalline fruit and superb balance. Lemon, pastry, apple and white flowers are all layered into the finish. A model of total elegance, the 2004 is a wine for the patient. It won't be ready to deliver maximum pleasure for a number of years, even though it is absolutely dazzling today. The 2004 is 69% Chardonnay from the Côtes des Blancs and 31% Chardonnay from the Montagne de Reims.”
“The second-released vintage of Dom Ruinart has aged on the lees under natural cork, contributing to the wine’s harmonious ageing. There is immense refinement to the nose, such delicacy and detail of toast and fireworks. Pure and bright fruit of the crunchy kind, layer upon layer. The lacy palate has both airiness and texture, silky and refined with a never-ending finish. This wine is a marathon not a sprint. Dosage: 5.5g/l”
More Reviews +
97/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
Jul 2024
“Dom Ruinart 2013 is a blanc de blancs of lithe, satin-smooth beauty already upon release, very much built around the reserved, cool energy of the 2013 vintage. This cuvée's new aromatic range, amplified since the 2010 release by toasty, spicy energy brought on by bottle fermentation under cork (sous liège), is very much at play. However, with undertones of roasting coffee, honey and fresh walnut playing with smoky gunflint and nougat richness as the gentle lemon, lime and even tropical fruit eases out with time in the glass. It's narrow rather than austere, gently sea-salt- savoury rather than lip-smackingly mineral or chalky - a Dom Ruinart with a long, long life ahead, but an equally rewarding window already opening up. Chardonnay from Le Mesnil, Avize, Chouilly, Bergères-les-Vertus, Sillery, Verzenay and Taissy, disgorged after nine years on lees.”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“This cool-vintage Dom Ruinart is a marathoner, not a sprinter. Crafted exclusively from Grand Cru Chardonnay, 70% from the Côte des Blancs (Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Avize, Chouilly, Bergères-les-Vertus) and 30% from the Montagne de Reims (Verzenay, Sillery, Taissy, Villers-Marmery), it epitomises crystalline finesse. The nose, increasingly toasty with time in the glass, reveals pristine lime, white flowers, and a teasing twist of kiwi and vanilla. On the palate, it is at once silky and lithe, yet brimming with intensity. This is a tightly-woven Dom Ruinart built for the long haul, with years of beauty ahead. Dosage: 5.5g/l.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2013 Dom Ruinart is a very pretty, delicate Champagne. Light on its feet, airy and gracious, the 2013 is all about understatement. Citrus confit, white truffle, mint, spice and baked pastry inflections add to its exquisite finesse. There is a touch of lees reduction from aging on the cork, but that note dissipates over time. Delayed flowering set the stage for a harvest that started on September 30, about twenty days later than what has become the norm since. The 2013 is the second vintage aged on cork. Interestingly, Chef de Caves Frédéric Panaïotis commented that the move towards aging on cork necessitated changes in vineyard sites as well. As a result, the 2013 is the first Dom Ruinart to include fruit from Bergères-lès-Vertus, at the very southern tip of the Côte de Blancs. The final blend is 70% Côte de Blancs and 30% Montagne de Reims across eight villages. This will be a fascinating Champagne to follow over the coming years and decades. Today, I find it on the quiet, hushed side. Dosage is 5.5 grams per liter. Disgorged: February 2023.”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“Bursting with ripe lemon richness and hints of patisserie and hints of tropical notes like pineapple and guarva. Quite different to the 2010, the first release with 2nd fermentation on cork, this 2nd in the series is looking like my new favourite, finishes with a waft of a minty fresh breeze. Silky smooth texture and a lightness to the palate, very elegant.”
17.5/20
Andy Howard MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2025
“100% Chardonnay. Dating back to 1729, Ruinart is the oldest ‘house’ in Champagne. 70% Côte des Blancs, 30% Montagne de Reims. Aged in vat, with malolactic conversion, aged a minimum 9 years on the lees. Dosage 5.5 g/l.
Wonderfully complex vintage Blanc de Blancs with complex biscuity notes. Zesty citrus, notable acidity. Concentrated and very fine.”
“Overall 2010 was not a great year in Champagne, but it was for some Chardonnays, as this brilliant Dom Ruinart showcases. For this Dom Ruinart vintage, the speciality is closing with natural cork for lees ageing. This is the first time for Dom Ruinart in the recent era and based on the superb results, the way it will continue. It has resulted in fabulous ageing, with stunning reductive toasty layers. The sweet coffee-and-cream nose has yeasty complexities melanging with soft, spicy tones like coconut and vanilla. The fruitiness is as pristine as it gets. Lemon curd, lime zest, orange blossom... Beautifully reductive in the aroma profile, almost like having the magnum effect in a 75cl bottle! So fine and delicious on the silky-smooth and seemingly feather-light palate. This wine shows that Chardonnay really had what it takes in that difficult year. A stunning wine that is blooming already but comes with such cool refinement and tightness that longevity is easy to predict.”
More Reviews +
18.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“A few years now post launch it is interesting to see this champagne again. It oozes smoky charm, that reductive gunflint is more fire-like than I have seen before. Underneath it oozes the bright citrus fruits, like lemon and lime with hints of pastry richness emerging. This is ageing very slowing, super young still and so precise, I feel we will need to wait until at least 2026 to see the dried fruit charm. Amazing acidity and lingers long on the palate.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2022
“Really deep flavoured. Very obviously more depth of flavour and tension than the 2009 Dom Ruinart. The cork ageing does seem to enhance the savoury, reduced character reminiscent of white burgundy. Very long with lemon notes. A truly exciting wine that is still extremely youthful.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“Dinner starts with a fresh, briny oyster and a glass of 2010 Dom Ruinart. It’s a beautiful pairing. I have always loved the 2010 for the way it straddles the worlds of Champagne and still wine. It is absolutely glorious on this night. In fact, I could have had it for the entire meal. A deep, luscious morel broth and Brittany scallops are other highlights among the amuse-bouches.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The first vintage since the 1960s to see tirage under natural cork in lieu of crown caps, the 2010 Dom Ruinart Blanc de Blancs was disgorged in November 2021. It's showing nicely, over-performing for the vintage, displaying aromas of yellow orchard fruit, toasted nuts, spices, smoke, dried white flowers and iodine. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and layered, with impressive concentration and chalky structure, it concludes with a long, saline finish.”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Aug 2022
“A mineral-driven Champagne, creamy and compact, this deftly meshes a layer of smoke, chalk and saline with detailed flavors of glazed apple and apricot, roasted hazelnut and ginger-infused pastry cream carried on a raw silky mousse. The fine texture softens the firm spine of chiseled acidity that structures the wine, and hints of white blossoms, Meyer lemon and oyster shell play on the finish.”
94/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“Almost like a white, with a smoky and flinty nose. Dried lemons, cedar, smoked almonds, spiced apples, hazelnuts, salted butter and toast. Tangy and sharp, yet creamy and buttery, too, with fine bubbles. Hazelnuts at the end. ”
“Medium-deep peachy colour. Highly reductive glorious Pinot nose. Spicy with vanilla, cherries and gunpowder, a beautiful mélange. Vinous, caressingly silky palate with a touch of tannin on the firm back palate. Charming despite being youthful for the time being. I look forward to see this one evolve and develop grandiose Burgundian characters. Very low 4g/l dosage. ”
More Reviews +
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“The Dom Ruinart Rosé from this warm and ripe year is opening up with gorgeously complex Pinot tones. Sous-bois, liquorice, smoke and exotic spices line the cherry fruit. There are woody notes reminiscent of oak, even if the wine has not seen any. Fleshy and voluminous; the tannins are perfectly ripe, and the whole is smooth and caressing. The long-lasting finish holds back and promises more to come. Dosage: 4g/l”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“Crafting Dom Ruinart demands patience, this edition stands as a tribute to the sadly departed, already legendary chef de cave Frédéric Panaiotis, who worked wonders with Ruinart’s wines. A graceful 15% of Ay red wine infuses the blanc de blancs core with a Burgundian soul. The wine’s evolved orange-tinged peach colour hints at its maturity. The nose unfolds with graceful evolution, refined reductive notes perfectly framing its spicy cherry and vanilla fruit. On the palate, supple and rounded textures meld with silky vinosity, finishing on a long, persistent, and spicy aftertaste. Dosage:4g/l.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2023
“A blend of 85% Chardonnay and 15% Pinot Noir from Aÿ and a dosage of four grams per liter, the 2009 Dom Ruinart Rosé possesses a complex, vibrant bouquet with aromas of cherry, spring flowers, gooseberry, tangerine, almonds, pastry and slightly reductive elegant notes. Full-bodied, fleshy and vinous, the palate is perfectly balanced, dense and concentrated, with a delicate mousse and a long, saline, penetrating finish. There’s plenty of structure and substance here. There is no reason to wait, but it will age beautifully for another five to eight years.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2009 Dom Ruinart Rosé is a very pretty, understated Champagne. Bright red fruit, blood orange, mint, rose petal, dried flowers and cinnamon are nicely lifted. This is an especially quiet, subtle Rosé, especially for the year. The blend is 85% Chardonnay, mostly from Grand Crus in the Côte des Blancs (Cramant, Avize, Chouilly, Mesnil-sur-Oger) with a touch of Montagne de Reims (Sillery), plus 15% still Pinot from Aÿ. Disgorged in 2018, dosage is 4 grams per liter. ”
“The 2007 was chef de cave Frédéric Panaïotis’ first go at this iconic cuvée and despite the vintage’s challenges for Pinot Noir he truly mastered it. The evolving colour has copper hues and the complex nose also shows fine, maturing Pinot notes. Alongside the usual apricot and spice aromas, the wine comes with a stylish gunpowdery toastiness, vanilla and layered melange of citrus fruit ranging from candied mandarin to orange peel. On the light-weight and beautifully energetic palate the Chardonnay body is evident and the wine comes across as a particularly elegant Dom Ruinart Rosé.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“For the rosé 2007, Dom Ruinart’s white base is coloured with 20% Pinot Noir red wine, entirely from the grand cru vineyard in Aÿ. The glossy, deep orange colour speaks of evolution. Disarmingly delicious, the coffee-complexed nose has dark, spicy tones meeting savoury orange fruitiness. Quince jelly, orange peel, cranberry and even leather and chocolate. Truly complex and ever-changing in the glass, this is firm and structured, with a lovely touch of tannin coming across towards the back palate. Super-smooth and silky, with a fine acid line running along the intense fruitiness. It's already showing outstanding complexity now, with no need to wait, but surely more of the wild, savoury and spicy Burgundian side will surface with time. It certainly has the structure for prolonged ageing. Disgorged 2/18; dosage 5g/l”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The 2007 Dom Ruinart Rosé is fabulous. The Rosé has all of the energy of the Blanc, with the extra richness that comes from the Pinot in the blend. Rose petal, mint, blood orange and cinnamon are some of the many aromas and flavors that are laced throughout. There is a feeling of translucence in the Rosé that is impossible to miss. I would cellar it for a few years. This is another magnificent wine from Chef de Caves Frédéric Panaïotis in his first vintage at Ruinart. Disgorged: February, 2018.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“The 2007 Dom Ruinart Rosé is showing brilliantly, bursting from the glass with exuberant aromas of blood orange, tangerine and raspberries, mingled with hints of buttered toast, brioche and spices. Full-bodied, deep and vinous, it's layered and elegantly muscular, with terrific concentration and a racy spine of acidity, enlivened by a pillowy mousse. Concluding with a long and sapid finish, it's aromatically open but structurally tightly wound, so I suspect it will reward another few years' age on cork, even if it's hard to resist today. In any case, it deserves to participate in any discussion of the 2007 Champagne vintage's high points.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2019
“The 2007 Dom Ruinart Rosé is another brilliant wine from Chef de Caves Frédéric Panaiotis in his first vintage at the house. Delicate, nuanced and wonderfully polished, the 2007 is airy and gracious in feel, with superb aromatic intensity and exceptional balance. Sweet floral notes, mint, spice and crushed red berries are all laced together in this very pretty, gracious Rosé. More finesse than power, the 2007 is positively sublime.”
“The 2007 was chef de cave Frédéric Panaïotis’ first go at this iconic cuvée and despite the vintage’s challenges for Pinot Noir he truly mastered it. The evolving colour has copper hues and the complex nose also shows fine, maturing Pinot notes. Alongside the usual apricot and spice aromas, the wine comes with a stylish gunpowdery toastiness, vanilla and layered melange of citrus fruit ranging from candied mandarin to orange peel. On the light-weight and beautifully energetic palate the Chardonnay body is evident and the wine comes across as a particularly elegant Dom Ruinart Rosé.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“For the rosé 2007, Dom Ruinart’s white base is coloured with 20% Pinot Noir red wine, entirely from the grand cru vineyard in Aÿ. The glossy, deep orange colour speaks of evolution. Disarmingly delicious, the coffee-complexed nose has dark, spicy tones meeting savoury orange fruitiness. Quince jelly, orange peel, cranberry and even leather and chocolate. Truly complex and ever-changing in the glass, this is firm and structured, with a lovely touch of tannin coming across towards the back palate. Super-smooth and silky, with a fine acid line running along the intense fruitiness. It's already showing outstanding complexity now, with no need to wait, but surely more of the wild, savoury and spicy Burgundian side will surface with time. It certainly has the structure for prolonged ageing. Disgorged 2/18; dosage 5g/l”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The 2007 Dom Ruinart Rosé is fabulous. The Rosé has all of the energy of the Blanc, with the extra richness that comes from the Pinot in the blend. Rose petal, mint, blood orange and cinnamon are some of the many aromas and flavors that are laced throughout. There is a feeling of translucence in the Rosé that is impossible to miss. I would cellar it for a few years. This is another magnificent wine from Chef de Caves Frédéric Panaïotis in his first vintage at Ruinart. Disgorged: February, 2018.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“The 2007 Dom Ruinart Rosé is showing brilliantly, bursting from the glass with exuberant aromas of blood orange, tangerine and raspberries, mingled with hints of buttered toast, brioche and spices. Full-bodied, deep and vinous, it's layered and elegantly muscular, with terrific concentration and a racy spine of acidity, enlivened by a pillowy mousse. Concluding with a long and sapid finish, it's aromatically open but structurally tightly wound, so I suspect it will reward another few years' age on cork, even if it's hard to resist today. In any case, it deserves to participate in any discussion of the 2007 Champagne vintage's high points.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2019
“The 2007 Dom Ruinart Rosé is another brilliant wine from Chef de Caves Frédéric Panaiotis in his first vintage at the house. Delicate, nuanced and wonderfully polished, the 2007 is airy and gracious in feel, with superb aromatic intensity and exceptional balance. Sweet floral notes, mint, spice and crushed red berries are all laced together in this very pretty, gracious Rosé. More finesse than power, the 2007 is positively sublime.”
“Alexandre Bonnet's blanc de blancs is a rare blend of equal amounts of Chardonnay and Pinot Blanc. Originating exclusively from Les Riceys, it is fruit-forward, with plenty of floral fragrance. A melange of white and yellow fruit, baked pear and yellow apple leads the way, with a touch of lime supporting. There is good volume on a perky palate that comes with a touch of austerity towards the very end. Youthful for the time being, but there is fruity suppleness from the 2018 base year. ”
“Fresh lemon zest and red apple skins on the nose, following through with honey, pine forest and bright russet apple. Linear, elegant and structured, it shows vibrant citrus with fine bubbles and a refreshing finish.”
More Reviews +
16.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2023
“Delicate aromas of dried hay-meadow flowers and warm, sweet hay. Great chalky texture which gives the wine a firm, fine focus but also feels somehow porous, as if the bright citrus is seeping through every molecule. Loose, lacy bubbles. Those lovely aromas are very persistent through the palate, adding graceful lift and a savoury veil to the ripe, yellow fruit.”
92/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2019 Extra Brut Blanc de Noirs Vigne des Riceys is a pure Pinot Noir, made in stainless steel with full malolactic fermentation. A shy nose does not want to give much away. The palate, however, comes with an immediate notion of fresh redcurrant, a pure highlight of ripe but pristine fruit. The mousse is surprisingly fine and creamy. The palate has the generosity of the south but comes with clear contour and delineation, providing a classy, taut and bright wine with lovely substance, structure and length with a lasting and fresh finish. Dosage is 6gr/L. Disgorged: April 4, 2023. - Anne Krebiehl MW”
“A wine with Alexandre Bonnet's signature regal carriage and sweep of richness and drama, shimmer and depth, tapestry and broider. Sumptuous with fruit; ripe peaches, nectarines, mandarin, raspberries. But also fragrant with the night perfume of iris and daphne. And a spine of stone, of finely carved stone. The flavours amplify on approach, and then ripple slowly into a finish of moonlit creaminess. Commanding and captivating.”
“For this rare blend, Les Riceys’ Pinot Noir gets complemented by the other six grape varieties of Champagne, Chardonnay, Meunier, Pinot Blanc, Pinot Gris and Arbane. The lemon-gold colour starts to show some evolution. Expressive nose with cardamom and smoke complementing lush ripe fruit profile of peach, lychees, and pear compote. Full and voluminous on the palate, that feels fresh and vinous at the same time.”
“The 2019 Extra Brut Rosé Les Contrées is a blend of 90% Pinot Noir and 10% Pinot Blanc grown in the La Géande and La Forêt vineyards in Les Riceys. The deeply pink color of the wine could be mistaken for red. A whiff of wild strawberry fills the nose, edged with iron oxide. The palate is a picture of ripe red currant, tart and rounded, adding more strawberry fruit, corralled in very fine, spiderweb-like tannins, lending a lovely tartness and astringency. A most sophisticated, intense and compelling wine. Dosage is 5gr/L. Disgorged: June 22, 2023. - Anne Krebiehl MW”
“With another single-vineyard blanc de noirs release from Alexandre Bonnet, they are lifting Les Riceys terroirs into the limelight. The nose comes with floral charms and a cool, crunchy orchard fruit profile. Truly crisp and vivacious on the brightly fruity, direct palate with rare freshness and reservedness for Pinot Noir. Long-lingering, very dry finish with pencil shaving twist to it. ”
“Pale peach toned color. Mild, purely fruity nose with stylish restraint. Little disturbed and drying on the palate, contrasting the nose. Austere finish coming with a phenolic bite. ”
“De quoi te mêles-tu? from Neuville-sur-Seine, from a north facing slope is so linear and driven with lots of cool, crisp fruit. Bright and deliciously fragrant with red cherries and yellow plums, so creamy, so fine but elegantly restrained. ”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Mar 2025
“De Quoi Te Meles-tu? is a steep north-facing slope bearing a name that translates to ’mind your own business’ or ‘what’s it to you?’, and actually comes with a question mark. A cool profile Pinot Noir thanks to its North exposure and the 2021 vintage further accentuates that profile. Scented peachy fruitiness with strawberry and fruit drop complexity. Its palate is silky yet linear and a feisty acidity energizes it all. Base vintage: 2021”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2021
“Simon and Marie Normand, brother and sister, reprised their family’s pressoir in the Côte des Bar, Aube, after a century, and this is their first vintage. 100% Pinot Noir on a north-facing slope. 15% barrel-fermented, 85% tank-fermented. No malo. Aged on lees 30 months. Disgorged 30 November 2020. Dosage 3 g/l.
Tasted blind. Greenish straw. Clean. Putty notes and interesting on the nose. Just a little loose-textured but the flavour is good – vibrant and revitalising. Quite long.”
“The rose is made in the saignee method, so the red grapes skins are in contact with the juice for 36 to 48 hours to gain the desired colour and fruit. Fermented in stainless steel the champagne has red fruit purity and a strong rose colour. You see fruits like raspberry, blackcurrant, morello cherry, dark plum and a really expressive nose that broadens on the palate, it has a creamy texture, all the fruits combine with a chalky mineral element from the soils and a freshness from the acidity. Delicious with or without food. ”
“The 2010 Brut Grande Sendrée has turned out very well indeed, unwinding in the glass with youthful aromas of citrus oil, white flowers, white peach and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, bright and concentrated, it's youthfully tightly wound, with a racy spine of acidity, an elegant pinpoint mousse and a penetrating, chalky finish.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Dec 2020
“A quietly elegant Champagne, with a lovely soft, laciness to texture, and a minerally underpinning of smoke and saline accents. It displays a creamy mesh of crushed black cherry, grilled nut, kumquat and dried apricot and a refine, subtle finish”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2021
“Really quite evolved on the nose. Very piercing and dense! Extremely intense. With a very fine bead. Extremely long. Almost more of a wine than a champagne.”
“Deep and complex, showing candied fruit, quince and lanolin with chalky minerality, strawberries and a bit of horseradish, slightly honeyed. Medium-bodied. Fine bubbles are tight, intense and long. Savory and tasty, pure and energetic.”
“Every time I lift this glass, I smell something else. At first it was toasted oats; then nectarines; then lemongrass. It's instantly obvious that it's more powerful, driven, intentional than Les Prémices. The timbre drops from alto to tenor, on the cusp of baritone. The cadence lengthens. The dynamics intensify. The wine is dramatically creamy with deep caramelised undertones, an adagio of brûlée swirled through the cream, through the peach purée of fruit, past the toasted-hazelnut crunch. It's complex and magnificent, demanding time, attention, and preferably a rare, marbled steak (from regeneratively farmed, pasture-raised beef).”
More Reviews +
92+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Feb 2024
“Based on the 2018 vintage, Egly's newly released NV Brut Grand Cru offers up inviting aromas of honeyed pear and white flowers mingled with hints of mint and praline. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and chiseled, it's an especially fine-boned, precise rendition of this immensely dependable cuvée, formerly known as the domaine's "Tradition" bottling.”
93-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2024
“The name change from Brut Tradition to Brut Grand Cru has certainly given the wine the prestige it deserves. Truly the essence of Egly, here Ambonnay, Bouzy and Verzenay fruit mix in harmony with a third of Chardonnay bringing freshness and lift to the intense whole. Here we experience another level of power with a fragrant juniper wood tone marrying perfectly with complex pencil shaving, fruit salad, apple compote and spicy aromatics. The rich and textured palate is enlivened by the wine’s brisk acidic backbone and salivating minerality. This 2018 based blend is almost chewy in its impressive concentration, overt and enjoyable already but it comes with all the building blocks of ageing.”
17/20
Tamlyn Currin,
Jancis Robinson.com,
May 2023
“Much more toasty than Les Prémices. There is an interesting tango on the palate between papaya fruit and a powerful oily spiciness, a bit like toasted papaya seeds and linseed oil. But the ripeness of the fruit through this wine is massive and all-encompassing and has the roiling substance of a storm. Olive oil and oranges. Quince and membrillo. Gripping and delicious, in an idiosyncratic way.”
92+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
May 2025
“Based on the generously structured 2019 vintage defined by a concentrated and small yield, with 50% reserve wines from 2018 and 2017, Egly's latest NV Grand Cru was disgorged in October 2024 with two grams per liter dosage. As always, it was sourced mainly from Ambonnay, complemented by 20% of fruit from Bouzy, Verzenay and Verzy. Soaring from the glass with scents of pear, pastries, peach and honeysuckle mingling with orange zest, it is medium- to full-bodied, concentrated and rich, supported by tangy acidity and concluding with a long, saline finish. It is vinified entirely in wood.”
“From a sunny vintage in which the harvest—commencing relatively late, on September 20—proved ultimately rewarding, Egly’s 2015 Grand Cru Millésime has turned out remarkably elegant. A classic blend of 70% Pinot Noir and 30% Chardonnay from Ambonnay, it was disgorged in October 2024 with a dosage of one gram per liter—significantly lower than the 2008 edition, when Egly needed to temper the pronounced acidity. The wine bursts from the glass with an evocative bouquet of pear, red plum and fresh bread, mingling with vibrant citrus nuances. On the palate, it is deep, full-bodied and layered, showcasing remarkable concentration and a crystalline core of fruit. A bright spine of acidity and abundant chalky extract provide both structure and sensation of freshness, culminating in a persistent, reverberating finish. While this vintage is occasionally marked by subtle vegetal tones—attributable to incomplete ripening under hydric stress—this cuvée exhibits none of those elements. As Francis Egly notes, “It was all about the harvest date, and we certainly didn’t rush to pick the grapes.” Fine-boned and effortlessly graceful, this small release possesses all the attributes necessary for a long evolution.”
“Deep gold. There’s a whole lotta flavour going on here! Very lightly beery with some hoppy notes (these two impressions arrived in my brain separately and I didn’t realise there could be some connection between them). Lots of serious impact with good balance – not too sweet, not too austere.”
“I just loved this wine. It's one of those wines about which I don't want to talk about flavours or acidity or bubble size or length. It's a wine that feels like walking with a friend on a warm day across the fields and along quiet paths. It's a wine that is comforting, like a hand pressed to your hand just when you need contact. It's a wine that is bright and yellow splashed like the dandelions on the side of the path, and it's lacy and elegant and floral snowflakes like the cow parsley frothing from the hedgerows. It has the golden warmth of sunshine on your cheeks and the soft freshness of a cool breeze on your neck. It's effortless, comfortable, quietly rhythmic. Without artifice, without maquillage. And it's beautiful.”
More Reviews +
16.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
Jancis Robinson.com,
May 2023
“Tastes like irises pressed into hot old-stone walls and moss and spicy slices of sweet white peaches. The wine has a plump warmth, ripe Cape gooseberries, but also a stoniness that reminds me of crumbling lime. Creamy and languid and 'purple' tasting on the finish, its acid backbone well-hidden in flesh.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2023
“The NV (2018) Les Prémices is soft and open-knit, which makes it a fine choice for drinking now and over the next decade. Orchard fruit, mint and yellow flowers open effortlessly in the glass. Vinification and aging in steel keeps the flavors brisk. Les Prémices, one of the recent additions in this range, is equal parts Pinot Noir, Meunier and Chardonnay.”
94/100
Natalie Earl,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2022
“Toasty and yeasty aromas dominate on the first nose, with swirling smoky intrigue. It’s full and rich on the tongue, with grilled brioche and creamy intensity paired with bruised apple skin and mashed apple flesh. Custard and viennoiserie characters give weight and body, while the finish perks up with bitter nut skin and greengage freshness. This is a Brut NV to stock up on, as the complexity is impressive for the price. An all-round winner.”
“The NV (2020) Extra Brut Les Prémices is bold and expressive in the glass. Dried apricot, ginger, lemon oil and light exotic overtones confer notable flair throughout. In this release, Prémices is open-knit and engaging, qualities that will serve it well over the coming years. This is one of the best editions I can remember tasting. Dosage is 1 gram per liter. Disgorged: July 2024.”
More Reviews +
90/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
May 2025
“Based on the 2020 vintage (50%) and incorporating reserve wines from 2019 and 2018, Egly's latest release of the NV Les Prémices was disgorged in September 2024 with one gram per liter dosage. As ever, it was entirely vinified in tank and derives from the village of Trigny in Massif de Saint-Thierry, not far from Vrigny. It is the vineyard that the Egly family took over in 2016 from Clémence’s mother’s side, and the vines today are 40 years old, facing southeast and growing in sandier soils than those in Ambonnay. Opening in the glass with aromas of orange zest, red apple and spices, it is full-bodied, ample and textural, with succulent acidity and a rich core of fruit. The one cuvée in the range that could ever be described as straightforward, it is, stylistically, somewhat weighty in comparison to the rest of the range.”
17.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2024
“I just loved this wine. It's one of those wines about which I don't want to talk about flavours or acidity or bubble size or length. It's a wine that feels like walking with a friend on a warm day across the fields and along quiet paths. It's a wine that is comforting, like a hand pressed to your hand just when you need contact. It's a wine that is bright and yellow splashed like the dandelions on the side of the path, and it's lacy and elegant and floral snowflakes like the cow parsley frothing from the hedgerows. It has the golden warmth of sunshine on your cheeks and the soft freshness of a cool breeze on your neck. It's effortless, comfortable, quietly rhythmic. Without artifice, without maquillage. And it's beautiful.”
16.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
Jancis Robinson.com,
May 2023
“Tastes like irises pressed into hot old-stone walls and moss and spicy slices of sweet white peaches. The wine has a plump warmth, ripe Cape gooseberries, but also a stoniness that reminds me of crumbling lime. Creamy and languid and 'purple' tasting on the finish, its acid backbone well-hidden in flesh.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2023
“The NV (2018) Les Prémices is soft and open-knit, which makes it a fine choice for drinking now and over the next decade. Orchard fruit, mint and yellow flowers open effortlessly in the glass. Vinification and aging in steel keeps the flavors brisk. Les Prémices, one of the recent additions in this range, is equal parts Pinot Noir, Meunier and Chardonnay.”
94/100
Natalie Earl,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2022
“Toasty and yeasty aromas dominate on the first nose, with swirling smoky intrigue. It’s full and rich on the tongue, with grilled brioche and creamy intensity paired with bruised apple skin and mashed apple flesh. Custard and viennoiserie characters give weight and body, while the finish perks up with bitter nut skin and greengage freshness. This is a Brut NV to stock up on, as the complexity is impressive for the price. An all-round winner.”
“Nicely bright, showing lovely and delicious fruit, this is medium-bodied and round with melons and pears. From a vineyard in Trigny. Base wine 2021. Three years on the lees. A blend of one-third each of chardonnay, pinot noir and pinot meunier.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Audrey Frick,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Dec 2025
“The NV Champagne Cuvée Les Prémices Extra Brut pours a straw color and offers notes of ripe peach, orchard fruit, fresh nuts, and a powdery texture. Medium-bodied, it has a fine mousse with a zesty crispness on the finish. Salty and bright on the finish, I like the structure of this vintage, which has a more chiseled feel. This is Egly-Ouriet’s entry-level wine, but it has structure. Made from seven hectares of vineyard, the blend is a third of each grape (Pinot Noir, Chardonnay, and Meunier), aged for 3 years on the lees, base vintage 2021.”
“The NV Champagne Premier Cru Les Vignes De Vrigny Extra Brut (100% Meunier with a 2021 base) is a bright straw color, and the nose is very pure. I love this vintage, which has focus and refinement, with a fine texture, refreshing acidity, and a clean lift on the finish. Medium-bodied, it has a fine mousse, hints of white grapefruit citrus, and a mineral-textured finish.”
“Paul Girard was certainly born under lucky stars inheriting a fantastic domaine of 12 hectares, largely Grand Cru. For this stunning cuvée 50% of the grapes originate in the Girard family vineyards in Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and the other half in the Bonnet properties in Oger. A child of the 2021 vintage, it comes with 30% reserve wines added from the two preceding harvest years. Again, the oak impact is subtly played, never dominant but adding a refined Burgundian twist to the wine, further supported by the fine whiff of reductive toastiness. The great concentration of fruit can be appreciated on the linear, driven palate of chalky refinement and caressing softness of the mousse. A beautifully crafted wine from great Côte des Blancs terroirs.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The NV Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Au Bout du Chemin (2021), 100% Chardonnay from Vertus, is steely, vibrant and full of tension. Grapefruit, white flowers, slate and mint all race across the palate. Chalky mineral notes enliven the saline-drenched finish. This release is based on 2021, with reserve wines. Dosage is 3 grams per liter. Disgorged: December 11, 2023.”
16.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2024
“Lemon and caramel. A broad plane of yellow-white fruit, crisp, disciplined, transparent. Touch of toasted hemp heart and flax, but it’s the piercing citric acidity that shapes this wine into an arrow on the end. ”
91/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2024
“From one of Mesnil's most promising young winegrowers, Girard-Bonnet’s NV Blanc de Blancs A Mi-Chemin is a blend of nine lieux-dits scattered around Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oger. Based on the 2021 vintage and complemented by 30% reserve wines from 2018 to 2020, it was matured on the lees in 350- and 500-liter barrels and steel, in nearly equal parts, and disgorged in February 2024 with two grams per liter dosage. Slightly high-toned, it unfurls from the glass with scents of apple peel, oyster shell and citrus fruit. It’s a wine with a taut profile, but not without flesh on its bones. It’s medium-bodied and pillowy, with a profile that combines a touch of sweetness with a saline, savory character. Informed by the cooler season, it’s lighter in structure than the 2022-based rendition tasted alongside.”
“This tiny-volume experimental cuvée comes from a single vat of co-pressed and co-fermented Oger and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger Chardonnay. One senses some nutty evolution on the spicy and chalky-mineral nose of peachy fruit. The creamy-caressing mousse is the wine’s best quality alongside its profound mineral soul. The ending feels a little edgy and dry at 1,5 g/l. A fine bottling, but considering where Paul Girard is now in his winemaking, this wine does not yet carry quite the same perfectionist precision. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2018 Extra Brut Recueil Extrait No. 1 Grand Cru is a pure Chardonnay from Les Mesnil sur Oger and Oger in equal parts, from two plots, co-harvested and co-fermented, resulting in just one tank. The nose shows a lift of lemony honeycomb that translates directly onto the palate, where the light body, pervaded by a fine, creamy mousse of exquisitely tiny bubbles, presents a show of saltiness. Blonde, cold shortcrust and oatmeal provide the autolytic backdrop of this svelte, elegant and salty wine with its subtle finish. Disgorged: December, 2023. - Anne Krebiehl MW”
17/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2024
“Smells of jasmine tea, to begin with. Silver-tip tea and peaches. Something somehow silvery about this wine: the tang of an old pewter tine, the gleam of an old sugar spoon. Green peppercorns and purslane. Green walnuts. Very unusual. Linear horizontal bitterness forms a spine and defines the finish.”
93/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Dec 2024
“A medium bright yellow hue, the 2018 Champagne Recueil Extrait No. 1 Blanc De Blancs Grand Cru Extra Brut comes from Les Mesnil sur Oger and Oger in equal parts and is a cuvée that changes year to year from different plots. This is an impressive wine in that it's approachable and ripe but also has the structure to age over the coming 8-10 years. Medium bodied, it fills the palate with notes of citrus oils, savory salinity, green apples, and a hint of crystalline honey. It is a charmer but has a good deal of mineral texture and a pillowing mousse. Aged in a single tank, it saw 1.5 grams per liter dosage and was disgorged in December 2023.”
“This stylish, complex and elegantly powerful Champagne is the pinnacle of Gosset’s range and delivers such layered, fresh and complex style. The palate has a super smooth-honed, long and plush feel with a wealth of grilled almonds and grapefruit. Long, succulent draw through the finish. Magnificent. Drink now.”
More Reviews +
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com ,
Apr 2019
“The 2007 Celebris Extra Brut is the latest rendition of this cuvée, which cellar master Odilon de Varine describes as "not a vintage Gosset but a Gosset vintage"—meaning that it's produced only in years adapted to the house's powerful but austere style. Unwinding in the glass with aromas of lemon oil, marzipan, warm biscuits and wet stones, it's full-bodied, with a deep and concentrated core of ripe but racy fruit, a tangy spine of acidity and an elegant pinpoint mouse, displaying terrific purity and precision.”
“Disgorged August 2013. RS 5 g/l. 52% Chardonnay, 48% Pinot Noir. From Louis Latour Agencies UK.
Tasted blind. Some oak? Severe and dry on the end. Bollinger or Clos des Goisses? Lots of raciness and very dry (which should have led me to this, one of only two Extra Bruts in the tasting). Almost severe.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“The 2002 Celebris Vintage Extra Brut displays a noble, clear, fresh and subtle bouquet with white fruit and brioche flavors intertwined with mineral aromas. Silky textured and highly elegant, this full-bodied yet delicate blend of 48% Pinot Noir and 52% Chardonnay is clear and straight on the palate, revealing a ripe and intense, yet refined fruit. It has a persistent and complex, firmly structured, stimulatingly pure and salty finish. Great finesse and ethereal lightness here, with great purity and mineral tension. It also has the intensity of perfect fruit in the long and persistent finish. A great Champagne for the next ten and probably many more years.”
90/100
Decanter,
Decanter.com,
Jan 2016
“An impressive evolved nose with hints of mushroom and bonfire. Elegant, with plenty of life but showing tertiary characters, such as truffle, yet balanced by crisp acidity; it lingers delicately.
”
94/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2015
“A deep, rich and toasty nose that has a wealth of cashewy, nutty aromas and dried lemon pith, nougat and bright dried cherry fruits too. The palate's bold, assertive and full of flavor with really expansive orchard fruits. It's pared back to reveal a dry, essence-like finish with length and poise aplenty. Drink now.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2015
“Extremely dense and dry - most impressive, though verging on austere without anything to eat with it.”
96/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Jan 2015
“Aged for 10 years before disgorging and a further time before release, this is Gosset's top wine from a great vintage year. Extra Brut means it is dry, although the age of this wine has softened the intense acidity and turned it into an elegant, mature wine of great complexity as well as immediate attraction. It will age further at least until 2022, although it is totally drinkable now.”
“The 2016 Brut Grand Cru Aÿ Argonne stands as the pinnacle of superb releases from Champagne Henri Giraud. Evoking aromas of apricot, mirabelle, licorice, anise, ripe orchard fruits and spices, it's full-bodied, rich and vinous, with a deep, concentrated core of fruit and sappy acids, concluding with a long, penetrating, racy finish enhanced by aromas of gentian and sweet spices. A blend of 90% Pinot Noir and 10% Chardonnay from the grand cru village of Aÿ, vinified and matured in barrels, it was disgorged in February 2023. Kudos! Drinking window: 2024-2050”
More Reviews +
99/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“This is a powerful but elegant wine with a wealth of citrus-fruit freshness, blood orange and grapefruit, as well as toast, dried citrus blossom, white lavender, clove, cardamom and spices. Tense and driven, with so much mineral freshness and focus. Very tight bead of bubbles. Endless finish. This will age incredibly well, but you are want to drink it right away.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2016 Argonne is terrific. What a surprise. For a vintage that was once seen very dimly, the 2016 Argonne is superb. This is essentially a white wine with bubbles completely enrobed within its frame. Apricot, orange peel, crème brulée, pastry and a kiss of French oak unfurl in the glass. Readers will find a voluptuous, vinous Champagne that hits all the right notes. Disgorged: March 25, 2024”
“Elegant, tapered bottle. To be launched by UK importer New Generation on 19 July 2024. I assume the usual blend of 80% Pinot Noir, 20% Chardonnay, some of it vinified and raised in small Argonne oak barrels for one year. MV stands for 'multi-vintage'. This is based on 2019 with the addition of one-third older wine from a perpetual reserve (solera system) begun in 1990. Annoying agrafe clip over the cork. Pale gold. Rich nose. but with sufficient life and freshness…very nice balance. Complete and quite a feat to make a wine so interesting from such relatively young wine. Great depth and persistence. Drink: 2024-2030.”
More Reviews +
98/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“What makes this wine is the fine, velvet texture at the end that rolls off the finish. Dried-citrus, pastry and light walnut aromas here. I like the subtle, woodsy undertones, more of a deep-forest kind than toastiness. It’s powerful, broad and intense, with a solid structure and framing, but a very fine texture with seamless bubbles. So textural. 80% pinot noir and 20% chardonnay. One third perpetual reserve and two thirds of 2019. Try after 2025.”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“A blend of 80% Pinot Noir and 20% Chardonnay, the NV Brut Grand Cru Aÿ Fût de Chêne MV19, based two-thirds on the 2019 vintage and one-third on réserve perpétuelle or soléra, exudes a delicate, pure bouquet of spices, pear, white peach and mirabelle mingled with delicate touches of vanilla pod and licorice. Medium to full-bodied, concentrated and layered, rich and perfectly balanced, it's seamless with bright acids and a long, delicate, white-pepper finish. Vinified and matured 50% in new barrels and 50% in one-year-old barrels, the oak is barely noticeable. Dosage: five grams per liter.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The MV 19 is a very sexy wine. Radiant and enveloping in feel, the 2019 shows plenty of the ripeness of the vintage, but also a good bit of energy. Lemon confit, marzipan, fresh white flowers, mint, tangerine peel and dried flowers lend nuance throughout. There’s terrific presence here, in the more laid-back style that has become the norm. Dosage is 5 grams per liter. Disgorged: November 22, 2023.”
“Magnum - The aromatics leap out the glass a combination of smoky charm and rich citrus and topical yellow fruits and that rich buttery pastry character so charming. The power of this champagne really amazed me, it has freshness from all those top Grand Cru Chardonnay villages, richness from the warmer locations like Montgueux and the Côte de Sézanne combining to give a delicate balance of power and texture from five years on the lees. Has great length, a love the lightness and fresh finish, great balance and long length.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This Henriot classic is a blend from 12 villages. Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Chouilly and Avize play an important role, but there are also grapes from outside the Côte des Blancs - Trépail, Montgueux and Vitryat - enriching the blend. The overt nose is beautifully toasty, with soft vanilla notes combining to toasted bread, lemon curd, lime peel and green apple. The creamy palate comes with a cushiony mousse and a zingy, driven acid line leading to a gunpowdery mineral finish. Complexity and richness meeting invigorating freshness. Dosage <8g/l”
90+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Henriot's NV Blanc de Blancs is showing well, opening in the glass with notes of nectarine, citrus oil, toasted bread and light reduction. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a generous core of fruit, lively acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse, it concludes with a saline finish. This is a comparatively rich iteration of this cuvée, and it should pick up additional complexity with age.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2020
“Pale greenish straw. Powerfully aromatic and then bracingly crisp – actually quite surprisingly in view of the rather evolved nose. A real wake-up call of a wine with a certain electric minerality. Bone dry. Very much a superior aperitif style. Seriously zesty – lime zest? But it's admirably long. And the mousse is well judged. Young winemaker Alice Tétienne presented this online with impressive conviction.”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2015 vintage, the new release of Henriot's NV Blanc de Blancs bursts with expressive aromas of white peach, tangerine, sweet orchard fruit and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and nicely concentrated, with tangy acids and a pearly mousse, this new disgorgement is showing particularly well.”
“(Jeroboam) Incredible and immediate florality hovers above notes of ripe lemon peel and luminous Mirabelle plum. The palate presents purest chalkiness, inherent coolness and soothing, salty depth. Wonderful.”
More Reviews +
92-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“The Henriot Blanc de Blancs is a real representation of Chardonnay in Champagne as the grapes come from all key Chardonnay regions from Côte des Blancs to Trepail, Sézanne, Vitryat and Montgueux. Gentle, clean and precise soft white fruit nose with peach, lemon and melon nuances. Beautiful leesy depth and toasty complexity deriving from long ageing on the lees. Light-bodied yet intense, fresh palate with a gunpowdery mineral finish. Classic, toasty blanc de blancs with 40% reserve wines. Top-performing non-vintage blanc de blancs. The magnums are real treats.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2020
“Pale greenish straw. Powerfully aromatic and then bracingly crisp – actually quite surprisingly in view of the rather evolved nose. A real wake-up call of a wine with a certain electric minerality. Bone dry. Very much a superior aperitif style. Seriously zesty – lime zest? But it's admirably long. And the mousse is well judged. Young winemaker Alice Tétienne presented this online with impressive conviction.”
90+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Henriot's NV Blanc de Blancs is showing well, opening in the glass with notes of nectarine, citrus oil, toasted bread and light reduction. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a generous core of fruit, lively acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse, it concludes with a saline finish. This is a comparatively rich iteration of this cuvée, and it should pick up additional complexity with age.”
“Representing a snapshot of the Henriot grape sourcing, the core of this broad blend is in Côte des Blancs Chardonnay, with Pinot Noir from the Montagne de Reims supporting and Meunier playing a minor role (5%). There's a lovely complexity building up already on the nose: coffee-laden toastiness alongside sweet fruity notes, even of the tropical kind. Yellow apple, yellow plums and lemon juice. The intense palate is bursting with pristine fruit, the silky-smooth palate refreshed by perky acidity. Long, lingering finish of deliciousness. Dosage <8g/l”
More Reviews +
17.5+/20
Richard Hemming MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“Lovely milky nose with sweet coffee and rich pastry aromas. Rich apple fruit on the palate and a soft, smooth palate that finishes with a smoky, flinty persistence. Precise, rounded, classic.”
90/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2015 vintage, the latest release of Henriot's NV Brut Souverain offers up inviting aromas of white peach, apple blossom, nectarine and pastry cream. Medium-bodied, bright and fleshy, with a pretty core of fruit, tangy acids and a pillowy mousse, it's drinking well on release.”
“Representing a snapshot of the Henriot grape sourcing, the core of this broad blend is in Côte des Blancs Chardonnay, with Pinot Noir from the Montagne de Reims supporting and Meunier playing a minor role (5%). There's a lovely complexity building up already on the nose: coffee-laden toastiness alongside sweet fruity notes, even of the tropical kind. Yellow apple, yellow plums and lemon juice. The intense palate is bursting with pristine fruit, the silky-smooth palate refreshed by perky acidity. Long, lingering finish of deliciousness. Dosage <8g/l”
More Reviews +
17.5+/20
Richard Hemming MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“Lovely milky nose with sweet coffee and rich pastry aromas. Rich apple fruit on the palate and a soft, smooth palate that finishes with a smoky, flinty persistence. Precise, rounded, classic.”
90/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2015 vintage, the latest release of Henriot's NV Brut Souverain offers up inviting aromas of white peach, apple blossom, nectarine and pastry cream. Medium-bodied, bright and fleshy, with a pretty core of fruit, tangy acids and a pillowy mousse, it's drinking well on release.”
“(Jeroboam) The nose opens with salty, almost miso-like savouriness. With air a real sense of ripe Mirabelle comes through. The palate is rich and fresh and quite a few notches up from your normal brut sans année. A lovely autolytic depth, elegant foam and real savouriness pervade this. Bravo.”
More Reviews +
88-90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2016
“Pronounced toasty-mineral nose with confectionary-style sweetness of fruit of tropical fruit, marmalade, cardamom and candied tones.Very clean fruitiness and ample, balanced dosage. Fresh and salivating. Soft and silky, refined palate. A fine, solid, stylish non-vintage where the quality of the grapes (2/3 grand cru!) and impact of reserve wines (30%, 1-5 year-old + a touch of top böanc de blancs from their perpetual cuvée). Divine in magnum, 90 points and up. The base year for bottles sold at the end of 2016 was 2012.”
17.5+/20
Richard Hemming MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“Lovely milky nose with sweet coffee and rich pastry aromas. Rich apple fruit on the palate and a soft, smooth palate that finishes with a smoky, flinty persistence. Precise, rounded, classic.”
90/100
Josh Reynolds,
vinous.com,
Jan 2015
“Light gold. Lees-accented orchard and citrus fruit aromas are complicated by sweet butter, iodine and smoky minerals. Dry and expansive on the palate, offering lively pear and melon flavors and a refreshingly bitter touch of orange pith. Ample but lithe brut, with very good finishing punch and repeating smoke and pear qualities.”
“There is a tightness to the aromatics, a lightly smoky haze, gives way to an abundance of dried lemon and charred pineapple. The palate has real richness and a silky smooth texture. After time in the glass its Côte des Blancs heritage shines with a distinct chalky note on palate and aromatics. The more time in the glass the bigger it grows, these reserve wines are bringing intensity of dried fruits, dried grass, toast and more smoke. Delicious and really influenced by the 10% of 2012 added a year before bottling.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“This is the 6th edition of Henriot’s Cuve 38, a hedonistic wine crafted by Joseph Henriot from the house’s perpetual reserve of Chardonnay. Here, a total of 1,000 magnums were drawn from Tank 38, which contains wines spanning the 1990–2012 vintages. The colour shows a light golden evolution. The nose is utterly uplifting, layered with stunning toasty richness over pristine Chardonnay fruit. The reserve wine influence adds a distinct textural oiliness, enhancing the wine’s appeal. Hugely concentrated, the palate reveals complex notes of dried banana, ginger, peach, nectar, and honey, yet remains seamless. Enjoyable now and aged to perfection, there is no need to cellar it further. Disgorgement date:01/04/22. Dosage:5g/l.”
96/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Feb 2024
“Avize dominates over Oger, Le Mesnil and Chouilly from 23 vintages between 1990-2012 with a dosage of 5 grams and aging on the lees in bottle for 8 years in this lovely magnum. Unfortunately, the wine was a little too young and freshly disgorged the first time I tasted the wine while filming on the sea cliffs of the Isle of Skye. Partly it was the low temperature and the more Pinot-friendly location that dampened the impressions, but at the same time it is a sign of quality that the oldest wines in the famous mind do not show the slightest sign of fatigue. Drink 2026 onward”
“When Gilles de Larouzière took the reins chez Henriot and tasted the vins clairs of the 2016 vintage with his team, one cuvée from Avize stood out from the crowd enough that it seemed to merit a tirage of its own. The result is the 2016 Brut L'inattendue, disgorged after four years on the lees with four grams per liter dosage. It's a demonstrative, expressive Champagne, bursting with aromas of white peach, crisp orchard fruit and confit lemon mingled with subtle hints of buttery pastry, followed by a medium to full-bodied, satiny and attractively vinous palate, its fleshy core of fruit complemented by a pretty pinpoint mousse. Already drinking well, it's testimony to the exciting things happening at this historic house.”
More Reviews +
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2022
“As opposed to the Henriot’s traditional culture of blending, in 2016 Gilles de Larouzière decided to capture the beauty of the year by bottling one of its best expressions as a single-varietal, single-village wine. L’Inattendue 2016 from four vineyards in Avize is a great first tribute to ‘The Unexpected’ terroirs of Henriot in a series that will from now on highlight similar memorable terroir expressions each year: Very fine nose with chalky restraint underneath extremely pure and transparent fruitiness. Ripe lemon and lemon confit notes meet the richness of tropical nuances, licorice and vanilla. On the palate the lazer-like precision is further accentuated by the wine’s fine, focused acid line and scintillatingly energetic feel. Youthful still yet there is further richness building up. The wine’s freshness, intensity and perfectly pure aromatics promise it a fine future. ”
17.5++/20
Tamlyn Currin,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2022
“Not the most powerful, or linear, or focused of the Henriot wines tasted in this line-up, but it is the one that stole my heart. It has that childlike delight and in-the-momentness of lemon sherbet dancing on the tongue and space dust popping in the mouth and a chain of daisies on fine blonde hair catching summer sunlight. It's a wine that wants to play. And yet it's serious, too. It has millefeuille layers of brioche, chalk, walnut, pith, grapefruit and apple.”
94/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“Amalfi lemon and butter combine on the nose just as they do in raw, buttery shortcrust pastry with grated lemon zest. More air and more temperature simply amplify that wonderfully ripe, sunny, buttery lemon scent and suffuse it with ozone. The palate then adds drive that is bedded in buttery generosity and cool, cool chalk, accentuated by lively mousse. This is rich and linear at the same time, informed by lemony energy and backed by rich, creamy autolysis. The finish is very clean and zesty and reveals the depth and richness of the wine.”
“This wine impresses with the 2012 charms of bright yet super intense fruit and lovely energetic vibrancy. The style is decadently generous with delicious creme brulee and toast complexity alongside heaps and heaps of ripe white and exotic fruit. On the palate it is age-mellowed yet it ends on a pure, dry, saline and spicy note. Drinking beautifully already.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This ageworthy vintage cuvée is blended from six villages: Trépail, Mailly-Champagne, Verzenay and Avenay on the Montagne de Reims, and Avize and Chouilly in the Côtes des Blancs. Age-derived complexities are already emerging on the overt and richly fruity nose. It has a lovely aromatic depth, with dark, spicy and roasted coffee notes mixing with fruitcake and crystallised fruits of the exotic kind. A complex mix of red and yellow fruit. If the nose is showing evolution, the palate remains remarkably youthful. Concentrated and fruity, with a very tight, saline acid line bringing focus to the rich whole. Already delightful, but this will age tremendously well. Dosage 6g/l”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Very pale gold, plenty of lively mousse on pouring. Intense, rich and inviting toasty aroma, deep and yeasty with ripe lemon and clementine freshness of fruit. Terrific combination of intensity and freshness on the palate, the marked autolytic character giving an impression of sweetness even though it tastes dry. Toasty on the palate and there's still lovely citrus fruit at the core. Fine mousse, vibrant freshness through the deep and long flavours.”
92+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jan 2022
“With the 2012 Brut Millésimé, Henriot's positive evolution begins to become apparent. A blend of 54% Chardonnay and 46% Pinot Noir, disgorged with less than six grams per liter dosage, it offers up aromas of citrus zest, white flowers, freshly baked bread and green apple, followed by a medium-bodied, brisk and precise palate. Built around a bright spine of acidity and enlivened by a pillowy mousse, it will take on additional depth and dimension with a few years on cork.”
95/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“A beautifully reductive nose smoulders with hints of flint, smoke and molten candlewax but also gives glimpses of ripe stone fruit and lemon. The palate carries on in this rich vein that suggests sumptuousness but is in fact rather sculpted. Yes, this manages to present a beautifully profound, rich but utterly precise vision of the 2012 vintage that shows off freshness, sinuousness and beautiful ripeness. Still dew fresh. Lay down or enjoy now.”
94/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Nov 2021
“A fragrant nose with aromas of apples, pears, brioche and candied citrus. Round, silky and balanced with fine bubbles and a flavorful, minerally finish. Full-bodied with a creamy texture and wonderfully soft fruit. Highlights the balance of the 2012 vintage. A blend of 54% chardonnay and 46% pinot noir.”
“This wine impresses with the 2012 charms of bright yet super intense fruit and lovely energetic vibrancy. The style is decadently generous with delicious creme brulee and toast complexity alongside heaps and heaps of ripe white and exotic fruit. On the palate it is age-mellowed yet it ends on a pure, dry, saline and spicy note. Drinking beautifully already.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This ageworthy vintage cuvée is blended from six villages: Trépail, Mailly-Champagne, Verzenay and Avenay on the Montagne de Reims, and Avize and Chouilly in the Côtes des Blancs. Age-derived complexities are already emerging on the overt and richly fruity nose. It has a lovely aromatic depth, with dark, spicy and roasted coffee notes mixing with fruitcake and crystallised fruits of the exotic kind. A complex mix of red and yellow fruit. If the nose is showing evolution, the palate remains remarkably youthful. Concentrated and fruity, with a very tight, saline acid line bringing focus to the rich whole. Already delightful, but this will age tremendously well. Dosage 6g/l”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Very pale gold, plenty of lively mousse on pouring. Intense, rich and inviting toasty aroma, deep and yeasty with ripe lemon and clementine freshness of fruit. Terrific combination of intensity and freshness on the palate, the marked autolytic character giving an impression of sweetness even though it tastes dry. Toasty on the palate and there's still lovely citrus fruit at the core. Fine mousse, vibrant freshness through the deep and long flavours.”
92+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jan 2022
“With the 2012 Brut Millésimé, Henriot's positive evolution begins to become apparent. A blend of 54% Chardonnay and 46% Pinot Noir, disgorged with less than six grams per liter dosage, it offers up aromas of citrus zest, white flowers, freshly baked bread and green apple, followed by a medium-bodied, brisk and precise palate. Built around a bright spine of acidity and enlivened by a pillowy mousse, it will take on additional depth and dimension with a few years on cork.”
95/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“A beautifully reductive nose smoulders with hints of flint, smoke and molten candlewax but also gives glimpses of ripe stone fruit and lemon. The palate carries on in this rich vein that suggests sumptuousness but is in fact rather sculpted. Yes, this manages to present a beautifully profound, rich but utterly precise vision of the 2012 vintage that shows off freshness, sinuousness and beautiful ripeness. Still dew fresh. Lay down or enjoy now.”
94/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Nov 2021
“A fragrant nose with aromas of apples, pears, brioche and candied citrus. Round, silky and balanced with fine bubbles and a flavorful, minerally finish. Full-bodied with a creamy texture and wonderfully soft fruit. Highlights the balance of the 2012 vintage. A blend of 54% chardonnay and 46% pinot noir.”
“A gently scented nose promises a subtle wine. Air brings a distinct notion of red fruit, evocative of plum and candied cherry. The palate sweeps in with exquisite balance and a three-dimensionality that gives as much room to fruity heights and chalky depths. The mousse is elegant, creamy and carries beautiful length.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Feb 2019
“Delicate and flirtatious. Gentle. Very successful though not that assertive on the nose.”
95/100
Roger Voss,
wineenthusiast.com,
Dec 2018
“Packed with fruit while hinting at mature toastiness, this wine is now in perfect balance. Its white fruits are from half-and-half Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, shot through with acidity while having a ripe character. Rich while also crisp, it is ready to drink.”
94/100
Andreas Larsson,
Andreaslarsson.org,
Dec 2018
“Medium deep golden colour with a gentle mousseux. Ripe nose with some development, autolytic brioche, butter notes with red berries, ripe pear and pain d’épices notes, rather Pinot it feels. Dense palate, ample with layers of fruit like raspberry, pear, mild spices, ginger, clove and a creamy mousse, very vibrant freshness giving a lift to the unctuous fruit with a very long and balanced finish. ”
17/20
Tim Jackson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jan 2020
“Biscuity with a hint of marmite. Crisp, dry, layered and spicy. Toasted brioche finish with good length.”
93/100
Allen Meadows,
Burghound.com,
Oct 2018
“There is ample petrol character to the cool, pure and beautifully fresh nose that combines notes of citrus and yeast with those of green apple and a whiff of pain grillé. I really like the sense of tension and energy to the intense, delineated and solidly complex flavors that are supported by a firm and reasonably fine effervescence before culminating in a very dry, highly complex and superbly persistent finish. The outstanding 2008 vintage in Champagne can count another winner as this is a wine to buy and age in quantity. Note that while this could certainly be enjoyed now, I would continue to hold it for another 2 to 5 years.”
91+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2019
“Henriot's 2008 Brut Millésimé spent eight years sur lattes before disgorgement with six grams per liter dosage and is a blend of equal parts Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. The wine displays a gently reductive nose with notes of citrus and stone fruit mingling with suggestions of freshly baked bread, oyster shell and smoke. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, with a voluminous but notably fine mousse, bright acids and an elegantly chalky finish that's delicate but penetrating. This is a comparatively supple, open-knit example of the taut 2008 vintage, but I suspect it will gain appreciably with bottle age.”
“The lemon sherbet notes are subtle at first but soon start filling the nose. The palate hits on a bright shaft of linearity, taut and vivid, shimmering with Mirabelle and Amalfi lemon, bedding 96's searing freshness in fruit. An elixir of youth.”
“Medium-deep salmon colour. Rich pinot nose with pencil shavings, licorice and pepper alongside delicious cherry and strawberry fruit. A lot on the palate but not heavy. Gastronomic style with character. Ready to drink but can keep. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Pretty orange-toned salmon colour, with depth gained by a 10% Aÿ red wine addition. The key crus of this refined yet powerful rosé are Aÿ, Mareuil-sur-Aÿ, Avenay and Mutigny, on the Montagne de Reims. The rich Pinot nose seems highly youthful for the time being, not having moved much beyond primary fruitiness. Full of ripe cherry fruit, with pencil shavings and exotic spices. The palate comes with equal Pinot power and even a firming bite of tannin. There's lots of volume here, but freshness too. This has moved very little since I tasted it 18 months ago, which promises extreme longevity. Dosage 7g/l”
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“Offering up attractive aromas of blood orange, red berries, peach, orchard fruit and brioche, Henriot's just-released 2012 Brut Rosé Millésimé is medium to full-bodied, satiny and enveloping, with fine concentration, ripe but racy acids, a delicate mousse and a long, saline finish. This is one of the more intense, vinous wines to emerge from Henriot in some time, and it's very promising.”
94/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Confit lemon holds notes of fresh strawberry on the nose. The palate is taut, slender, chiselled and precise with exuberant citrus. A grown-up rosé with a beautiful structure that will allows this to evolve.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Nov 2021
“An elegant rosé Champagne, layering flavors of ripe cherry, blood orange sorbet and orchard blossom on the delicate, finely detailed mousse, with lightly mouthwatering acidity and a zesty underpinning lending focus through to the lightly spiced finish. Drink now through 2027. 400 cases imported.”
18.5/20
Bettane & Desseauve,
bettanedesseauve.fr,
Nov 2021
“Pinots Noirs paired with Chardonnays offer a luxurious ruby. Very fleshy and fruity, the nose is crunchy, we touch very closely and faithfully the skin and the pulp of a blood orange, a strawberry, a raspberry or even a cherry. The feeling is spherical, carnal and natural. The extent of the complexity is affirmed by the appearance of oriental spices, balsamic effects and soy sauce. The palate translates this abundant fruity fleshiness with a slightly candied acid line. An admirable budding plant is grafted instinctively, thus creating relief and structure, the aging of this perfect architecture will be splendid...”
93/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Nov 2021
“Aromas of sliced ripe strawberries with pomegranate. Some granite and earth, too. Full-bodied and very vinous with firmness to the texture and fine bubbles. Mushroom, berry and earth in the aftertaste with some citrus fruit. Very vinous. Pinot noir and chardonnay.”
“Sourced from a different parcel each year, the 2018 Blanc de Blancs Le Grain de Beauté originates from Clos Sainte-Sophie and matured for four years in 500-liter barrels from the Mâconnais. Bottled in 2022 and disgorged à la volée for our July 2025 tasting, it stands as the crowning achievement of this year’s portfolio, soaring from the glass with a striking bouquet of physalis, nashi pear and spring flowers, mingling with green tea and a faint hint of almond, all subtly framed by the light reduction of its recent disgorgement. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, savory and textural, with a taut core of fruit that preserves remarkable brightness and vibrancy despite its protracted élevage in wood. Unusually chiseled in the context of the vintage, it is animated by racy acids and concludes with a long, chalky finish. While it may appear aromatically less flamboyant than Autour du Minuit, it ultimately reveals itself as the more harmonious and complete wine this year.”
“The 2009 Extra-Brut Grand Cru Avize - Champ Caïn is showing beautifully, wafting from the glass with aromas of pear, blanched almonds, freshly baked bread and mandarin. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and precise, it's elegant and refined, with a pinpoint mousse, discreet depth at the core and a long, chalky finish. Beautifully balanced with minimal dosage, it shows the results the Jacquesson brothers' viticulture were already delivering over a decade ago.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This wine comes from the 1.3ha Champ Caïn plot in Avize, planted in 1962. The colour is deep lemon gold. The sumptuously soft nose has lovely creamy-toasty layers adding complexity to the fruit. The ripe fruit is sweet in style, even tropical, with pineapple, apple jam and pear tart. The oakiness is well blended in the rich fruitiness, not masking anything. The age comes across more on the palate, which feels a little too dry with its tiny dosage cutting the finish short, bringing a degree of austerity. Still a glorious, vinous and concentrated Champagne at the perfect drinking age. Disgorged 6/19; dosage 1.5g/l”
“Disgorged in February 2021 with 0.75 grams per liter dosage, the NV Extra-Brut Cuvée No. 744 is based on the 2016 vintage. Exhibiting complex aromas of orange oil, crisp stone fruit, fenugreek and subtle hints of yellow Chartreuse, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and seamless, with terrific depth at the core, lively acids and a pinpoint mousse. Simultaneously vivid but replete with sapid nuance, this new release throws into relief all the work the Jacquesson brothers have made in the vineyards and cellar over the last two decades.”
More Reviews +
91+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“The NV Cuvée No. 744 Grand Vin is a bright, taut Champagne that is going to need at least a few years to come together. This is one of the more reticent editions of the Cuvée I have tasted in a very long time. Citrus, crushed rocks and white flowers add an attractive upper register. The Chardonnay feels quite expressive today. Disgorged: January, 2021.”
16.5++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“There’s a real green vegetal energy about the nose of this. And I don’t mean it’s unripe! Very distinctive indeed with a briskness and pace that is rare in champagne. Though it’s not a comfortable pair of slippers to slip on but a dry wine that demands attention.”
“Tight and tightly laced with some putty aromas. So savoury and mineral! Very distinctive. Should be long-lived. Admirably persistent.”
More Reviews +
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the challenging 2017 vintage, this has a deeply fruity, developing nose, with earthy-spicy and woody tones taking the lead. Beyond, there is plentiful fruitiness of the apple kind: apple jam and cider, and peardrops. At first, a note of oxidation prevails, but after some time in the glass, it shows more of the fruit. The palate is a little lighter than usual for Jacquesson, but there is still a great degree of vinosity to the voluptuous palate. The long taste does not feel as dry as its dosage would suggest.”
93/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Mar 2022
“A little more bright and vibrant than the 744, with notes of poached pear, baked apple, grapefruit, lemon rind and pistachio. Fine bubbles with crisp acidity and a pure, fruity core. Very drinkable. 0.75g/L dosage. ”
“Based on the 2019 vintage, the NV Extra-Brut Cuvée No. 747 reveals a lively, delicate bouquet of white pepper, tangerine, lemon oil, herbs and red berries mingled with lovely menthol notes. Medium to full-bodied, tense and sappy, it's layered with a vinous core of fruit and a delicately saline finish. This is not the most opulent iteration from this house but rather an edition that closely reflects the character of the vintage, marked by its tension and phenolic complexity.”
“Bursting from the glass with aromas of orange oil, pear, dried flowers and wheat toast mingled with bread dough, Prévost’s NV Champagne Grand Cru (2023 base)—a wine that incorporates some 20% reserve wines—is medium- to full-bodied, ample and chalky, with tangy acids and a distinctly vinous profile. Produced largely from purchased fruit, it is a blend of some 80% Chardonnay from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Pinot Noir from Puisieulx and was disgorged in October 2025 with a dosage of 2.5 grams per liter.”
“The 2013 Vintage is a wild, exotic beauty. Apricot, passion fruit, lemon confit, marzipan, baked apple tart and a kiss of French are all amplified in a dramatic, vivid Champagne that captures all the pedigree of this great vintage. The 2023 is wonderfully complex and dynamic from the very first taste. Time in the glass brings out layers of dimension and captivating nuance. This is a fabulous effort. Krug ID: 124011”
More Reviews +
19++/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Feb 2026
“Tasted in a Lehmann Synergie 60cl to help bring out the fruit expression because of the style of the vintage, late harvest, warm September days lead to cool October nights bringing bright acidity with ripeness, yet real subtlety. There is a burst of citrus, real concentrated ripe lemon, with grapefruit coming forward on the palate, the core of Pinot Noir shows as zingy bitter orange which on the palate becomes like juicy tangerine. With a little time in glass you notice the attractive bright red cherry and redcurrant touch from the Meunier. The oak influence from barrel fermentation is just a touch of textural volume. What is noticeable is the freshness from a touch of saline and bright acidity and what I feel on the palate is a real density and long length. This is super young and will give much more over time. Today is a pleasure to see the primary fruit in buckets and the weight on the palate. All in all I would expect this Krug 2013 to bring us pleasure for the next 20 years. I suspect in a few years this champagne has the potential to get an even greater score.”
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2026
“Originating from an October harvest, Krug’s 2013 Brut has turned out very well, delivering—against the backdrop of the slow, late-ripening season and another high-acid test, qualities rendered all the more evident by the house’s methods—the requisite aromatic plenitude and textural properties. Disgorged in early 2024 with a dosage of five grams per liter, the wine emerges from the glass with a deep bouquet of lemon oil, fresh apricot and quince mingled with nashi pear and brioche crust, complemented by a top note of lightly burnt buttered toast. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, chiseled and racy-fresh, structured around a spine of incisive acidity and chalky extract, concluding with a long, citrus-driven, saline-tinged finish.”
“Krug went out on a limb and created a rare grande marque prestige cuvée from the challenging 2011 harvest. This is unmistakably Krug on the nose, with a sweet peachy fruitiness, plus dried apples, apricot tart and pretty floral tones. It all comes lined with savoury oaky tones that are well in balance with the wine’s fruitiness. The palate seems sweet, with more stewed fruit and candied fruit expressing itself. Fleshy and juicy, this is rather light but delightfully airy for Krug Vintage. A fine effort for 2011, but this will be an early bloomer. Krug ID 322038 tasted.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2011 Vintage is a very pretty wine in this highly challenging vintage. Apricot, mint, dried herbs and a kiss of French oak open nicely in the glass. There is some of the savory character of 2011, but it is nicely woven into the wine’s fabric. To be sure, the 2011 is a slender vintage at Krug. That is especially evident in the wine's light-ish mid-palate and overall feel, yet all the elements are impeccably balanced. I expect the 2011 to be a relatively early maturing Vintage and would not push my luck on aging. Disgorged: Summer 2022. Krug ID: 322038.”
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“The aromatics are vibrant today, I tasted it a week ago and it wasn't this expressive, today's bottle is full of citrus, a twist of clementine, dried apricot and lime and a delicious saline finish. The palate has the trademark texture, rich, almost oily and acidity for Krug is soft, more like the 2003. With very careful selection of grapes this is a 2011 to show a solid wine can emerge from a year with many climatic challenges. If you are not worried about vintage reputation you will enjoy this champagne.”
“Krug 2006 Vintage is bright, tense and full of energy. Lemon confit, pastry, chamomile, dried flowers and tangerine oil all race out of the glass. The breadth of the Pinot comes through on the mid-palate and finish, as the 2006 gains power and resonance with a bit of aeration. Light tropical inflections, along with hints of almond and spice, open up later, adding further shades of nuance. Although it has just been released, the 2006 is unusually open and a real pleasure to taste today. In most vintages, Krug demands cellaring, but in the 2006 readers will find a Krug Vintage that is superb, even in the early going.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Jane Anson,
Decanter.com,
Jul 2020
“From the first whiff, the Krug 2006 has an alluring array of delectable scents, ranging from subtle notes of smoked almonds and flowers to gentle spices including curry and caraway. On the palate, the mouthfeel is generous and plush but has an underlying tannic tension to it, and finishes with a refreshing, nuanced bitter note. Its combination of freshness and power provide the right material to stay the distance of a decade or two. The blend comprises 48% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay and 17% Pinot Meunier. Disgorged end of 2018. Dosage: 4g/l. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“ID 118014. To be released in October 2019. (With potential stress because the 2019 harvest is likely to be so late.) Saved by a fine August. This was assistant winemaker Julie Cavil’s first tasting of the still base wines and is therefore her first known vintage on the market! Chef de Caves Eric Lebel was ill that summer. Outstanding Pinot Noir.
Quite rich and polished. No hint of astringency. But zesty on top and with lots of undertow. (I’ve never heard anyone say of a Krug vintage that it shouldn’t have been released.) Long with a particularly rich finish.”
“Krug 2006 Vintage is bright, tense and full of energy. Lemon confit, pastry, chamomile, dried flowers and tangerine oil all race out of the glass. The breadth of the Pinot comes through on the mid-palate and finish, as the 2006 gains power and resonance with a bit of aeration. Light tropical inflections, along with hints of almond and spice, open up later, adding further shades of nuance. Although it has just been released, the 2006 is unusually open and a real pleasure to taste today. In most vintages, Krug demands cellaring, but in the 2006 readers will find a Krug Vintage that is superb, even in the early going.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Jane Anson,
Decanter.com,
Jul 2020
“From the first whiff, the Krug 2006 has an alluring array of delectable scents, ranging from subtle notes of smoked almonds and flowers to gentle spices including curry and caraway. On the palate, the mouthfeel is generous and plush but has an underlying tannic tension to it, and finishes with a refreshing, nuanced bitter note. Its combination of freshness and power provide the right material to stay the distance of a decade or two. The blend comprises 48% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay and 17% Pinot Meunier. Disgorged end of 2018. Dosage: 4g/l. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“ID 118014. To be released in October 2019. (With potential stress because the 2019 harvest is likely to be so late.) Saved by a fine August. This was assistant winemaker Julie Cavil’s first tasting of the still base wines and is therefore her first known vintage on the market! Chef de Caves Eric Lebel was ill that summer. Outstanding Pinot Noir.
Quite rich and polished. No hint of astringency. But zesty on top and with lots of undertow. (I’ve never heard anyone say of a Krug vintage that it shouldn’t have been released.) Long with a particularly rich finish.”
“Tasted blind. Greenish hint. Intellectual, intriguing nose that’s more evolved than its pair (the 2002). Really classy stuff on the nose. Hint of mushrooms. Great energy, lift and zest. Tight and fresh. A little richness. Very delicate mousse. Dry finish. Krug? ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2017
“Fresh, zesty spiced lemon and citrus notes of top Meunier and elegantly built Chardonnay, with a hint of honeysuckle and spice. Supremely subtle mouthfeel, showing textural quince and plum flavours.Optimally ripe, not heavy, with magical, very Krug-like acidity. It's so fresh. From a fine Chardonnay year, it has the ideal blend of 39% Chardonnay, 37% Pinot Noir and 24% Pinot Meunier. Great potential.
”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Deep straw. Lots of energy here. This is obviously a very fine champagne. Tight bead and more youthful than the 2002 vintage. Slightly unevolved. Lots of energy. Some oak ageing?”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TheFinestBubble.com,
Sep 2017
“Slightly light on the nose right after pouring; with few minutes in the glass it comes more forward with grapefruit, concentrated lemon and apricot. On the palate lots of depth and weight of fruit, great mouth-feel with fresh acidity and fruit-forward flavour and wow, what a backbone! Feel like its holding back at present has great weight of fruit and loveliness; apricots and nuttiness just starting to open and just hints of those brioche notes that come out with age. Great length, real subtlety and a hint of salinity on the finish. You can see this champagne ageing for 15-20 years. ”
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“ID 216022. 39% Chardonnay, 24% Meunier, 37% Pinot Noir. They thought this would be ready before the 2002, so they had some bottles disgorged in 2014. The 2004 growing season benefited from 2003 when there was such a small yield post frost that the vines built up reserves, meaning that 2004 was a very generous crop and selection was permitted.
Very pure and greenish straw. Savoury nose. Very dense but flyaway linseed nose. Quite rich on the palate. Tight knit. Very solid with baked-apple flavours. Lots of density. Called ‘luminous freshness’ by the Krug team. Masses of energy.
Drink 2017-2030”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2017
“Krug's 2004 Vintage is absolutely mesmerizing. Layers of bright, chiseled fruit open up effortlessly as the wine fleshes out with time in the glass. Persistent and beautifully focused, with a translucent sense of energy, the 2004 captures all the best qualities of the year. Moreover, the 2004 is clearly superior to the consistently underwhelming 2002 and the best Krug Vintage since 1996. Readers who can find it should not hesitate, as it is a magical bottle.”
“Tasted blind. Greenish hint. Intellectual, intriguing nose that’s more evolved than its pair (the 2002). Really classy stuff on the nose. Hint of mushrooms. Great energy, lift and zest. Tight and fresh. A little richness. Very delicate mousse. Dry finish. Krug? ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2017
“Fresh, zesty spiced lemon and citrus notes of top Meunier and elegantly built Chardonnay, with a hint of honeysuckle and spice. Supremely subtle mouthfeel, showing textural quince and plum flavours.Optimally ripe, not heavy, with magical, very Krug-like acidity. It's so fresh. From a fine Chardonnay year, it has the ideal blend of 39% Chardonnay, 37% Pinot Noir and 24% Pinot Meunier. Great potential.
”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Deep straw. Lots of energy here. This is obviously a very fine champagne. Tight bead and more youthful than the 2002 vintage. Slightly unevolved. Lots of energy. Some oak ageing?”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TheFinestBubble.com,
Sep 2017
“Slightly light on the nose right after pouring; with few minutes in the glass it comes more forward with grapefruit, concentrated lemon and apricot. On the palate lots of depth and weight of fruit, great mouth-feel with fresh acidity and fruit-forward flavour and wow, what a backbone! Feel like its holding back at present has great weight of fruit and loveliness; apricots and nuttiness just starting to open and just hints of those brioche notes that come out with age. Great length, real subtlety and a hint of salinity on the finish. You can see this champagne ageing for 15-20 years. ”
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“ID 216022. 39% Chardonnay, 24% Meunier, 37% Pinot Noir. They thought this would be ready before the 2002, so they had some bottles disgorged in 2014. The 2004 growing season benefited from 2003 when there was such a small yield post frost that the vines built up reserves, meaning that 2004 was a very generous crop and selection was permitted.
Very pure and greenish straw. Savoury nose. Very dense but flyaway linseed nose. Quite rich on the palate. Tight knit. Very solid with baked-apple flavours. Lots of density. Called ‘luminous freshness’ by the Krug team. Masses of energy.
Drink 2017-2030”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2017
“Krug's 2004 Vintage is absolutely mesmerizing. Layers of bright, chiseled fruit open up effortlessly as the wine fleshes out with time in the glass. Persistent and beautifully focused, with a translucent sense of energy, the 2004 captures all the best qualities of the year. Moreover, the 2004 is clearly superior to the consistently underwhelming 2002 and the best Krug Vintage since 1996. Readers who can find it should not hesitate, as it is a magical bottle.”
“Tasted blind. Definitely more youthful with probably more potential than its pair (the 2004) but it's very tricky to guess the vintage. Hint of veginess and punch. Very long indeed. A real peacock’s tail on the finish. Impressive.”
More Reviews +
100/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Oct 2016
“The much-anticipated 2002 has impeccable detail and depth with a lot of chalky, stony and flinty elements on the nose as well as a very fresh edge. The nose is very complex and wound up tight but presents itself as very integrated and compressed. There are aromas of lemon rind, lime juice and lime custard all at once, complemented in turn by a super-restrained hazelnut-like edge. Undertones of brown mushrooms, chalky minerals and lemon leaf. The palate has a core of sizzlingly intense, concentrated chardonnay framed within a powerful phenolic structure that will underpin the future of this Champagne. There's also plenty of acidity for the future and this will no doubt continue to evolve and blossom; it will be merely an act of refining its already impressive focus, linearity and magical finish. This is really a great, great vintage for Krug. Flawlessly fresh and as perfect as it gets. Give this time as it needs to settle: best from 2020 and then for another decade beyond.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Deep orangey straw. Very mature, mushroomy nose. Really interesting wine that throbs with vitality and is not too sweet (which some of these are). Racy and dry.”
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Sep 2023
“Here is an impressive Krug, fruit-packed with vitality and finesse. Deep gold in colour. The stunningly toasty nose perfectly integrates the stylish oaky nuances of coconut and baking spices. The fruit is sun-kissed and ripe but pristine, with concentration and textural charm. The mouth-coating, oily vinosity fits the wine’s exuberant style. From the mid-palate onwards, the bold, laser-precise acidity tightens the whole, creating an overall impression of great class and finesse.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2016
“Disgorged Autumn 2014. 40% Pinot Noir, 39% Chardonnay, 21% Pinot Meunier. From Moët Hennessy UK.
Tasted blind. Pale gold. Oak and coconut. And masses of acidity. Very dry and Bollinger-esque? A bit uncompromising. Only one taster, Nick Baker of The Finest Bubble, guessed this wine as the lauded Krug 2002.”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“ID 415064. Great combination of freshness and density. Explosively powerful. Un-ignorable. Kerpow! Pungent.
Drink 2016-2036”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2016
“Powerful, sweet fruity, charred, buttery nose with immense depth. A mild oaky-spicy note floats over the opulent fruity burst. Wide and winey even oily palate, caressingly smooth-textured and voluptuous. Beautiful acid line and long, concentrated length. A classic, monumental keeper yet delivers a lot of pleasure already.”
98/100
Daniele Cernilli,
DoctorWine.It,
Feb 2016
“The character of the 2002 harvest exuberantly explodes in the glass with a lucent, pale-golden color and a bouquet of fresh fruit, hazelnut and slightly toasted almonds. All this on a cushion of tropical fruit, freshly cut pineapple, fresh ginger and red currant with a veil of linden honey in the finish. The mouthfeel is generous and full with charismatic intensity, vital tension and a vibrant richness of fruit which complement a lovely saline streak and an almost smoky hint. The finish has an exciting persistence, invigorated by an incessant and dynamic alternation of depth and acuteness. A Champagne with great energy that has only just begun to build a reputation.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“A blend of 40% Pinot Noir, 39% Chardonnay, 21% Pinot Meunier from a warm, dry, generous, homogenous year, with 11 years' ageing on the lees.
This was tasted immediately after Krug 2003 and was so much more discreet and savoury than the 2003 on the nose. It is chock-full of acidity and life, is really muscular and much more intellectual. For the moment the 2002 is less obviously fruity than the 2003 - clearly a champagne for long ageing - like many other 2002s - but much more backward than any I can think of immediately. There is nothing in excess; a great example of the Krug art of assemblage. Very solid and concentrated but not heavy at all. The finish is notably dry. This may be an intellectual wine but it's certainly not hard work! For Julie Cavil of the Krug blending team, this wine is 'a racehorse'. 'You were still riding regularly then', winemaker Eric Lebel reminds her with a smile. For them '2002 is about the generosity of Nature. We had to work hard to limit the yield a bit. There was lots of richness in the base wines; each sample had great generosity'. I look forward very much to following the development of this exceptional wine.
Drink 2016-2030”
95/100
Jamie Goode,
wineanorak.com,
Jan 2016
“ID: 414071, disgorged 4th quarter of 2014. Fine, multidimensional, focused aromatic nose with some toasty notes. Complex pear, peach and citrus flavours with lovely complexity. Real breadth but also some focus. It’s certainly very rich in style and a bit showy, with complex grapefruit, lemon, toast and hazelnut characters at its core. Showy but ultimately quite serious.”
98/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Jan 2016
“The Krug 2002 vintage Champagne is a mix of bright Welsh gold and pale green lights and has a perfect flow of tiny bubbles. What aromatics – spring flowers from well-sited Pinot Meunier, and exoticism in the Chardonnay. The beating heart of the wine is powerful, poised and very complex Pinot Noir, still biding its time to majestically unfold. Magnificent.”
“Magnum - This is one my favourite Krugs of the recent years in its macho richness and muscular structure. The stylish oaky note is finely integrated to the intense fireworks of aromas ranging from coffee and patisserie to vanilla, oriental spice and dried fruits. Sits beautifully on the reductive side, aging slowly. Never-ending, impressively concentrated finish full of succulent fruit. Great ageing potential but blooming already. A glorious, glorious magnum (Krug ID 115008, Disgorged Winter 2015) was tasted in December 2019: Beautifully clean maturing fruitness and super stylish toasty richness. Still, its best features is the stunningly creamy, caressing texture on the long, well-built palate.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2016
“This is one my favourite Krugs of the recent years in its macho richness and muscular structure. The stylish oaky note is finely integrated to the intense fireworks of aromas ranging from coffee and patisserie to vanilla, oriental spice and dried fruits. Sits beautifully on the reductive side, aging slowly. Never-ending, impressively concentrated finish full of succulent fruit. Great ageing potential but blooming already.”
95/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“The Krug vintage 2000 Brut smells strikingly redolent of sea breeze, kelp, and piles of oyster and mussel shells, allied to lemon oil and toasted hazelnuts. On the palate, the aforementioned elements serve for compulsive salivation, while a lusciously juicy amalgam of lime, grapefruit and apple tinged with piquancy of their pips buoys the salty wave of mineral matter into a profoundly protracted finish that bursts with brightness and at the same time reveals mouthwateringly savory crab shell reduction and a hitherto largely hidden dark side of smoky Latakia tobacco, dark-roasted coffee, and toasted grains. Expect this to merit following for 12-15 years.
”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“ID 114009. 42% Pinot Noir, 43% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Meunier.
Tense, complex nose. Exotic smoked notes of lapsang souchong tea. Really urgent and energetic with a rich finish. ”
94/100
Richard Juhlin,
Decanter,
Dec 2015
“In its current condition, extremely mineral-driven and sea-splashed, showing iodine, oyster shells and a light, pleasant bready aroma. Crispy-clean and beautifully balanced flavour. Impressive acidity and lively elegance.”
96/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Sep 2015
“A very young and delicate wine that will require long time before you ease the cork. In the current situation extremely mineral-driven and sea-splashed. Iodine, iodine, oyster shells, and small nice bready tone in the fragrance. Crispy clean and beautiful balanced flavor. Impressive acidity and lovely elegance.”
98/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Sep 2015
“Very fragrant. This has developed bright, ripe red cherry fruit aromas, vanilla cream, sweet roasted almond biscuits, some marzipan, tobacco, lemon meringue and chalky minerals. The palate has an assertive core of fine acidity with more yellow fruits expressed on entry, like peaches and nectarines. Good ripeness, superfine acidity. The redder fruits build as it goes; cherries and raspberries, yellow plums to close. Full of life. Drink now or up to 20 years, it will go the distance.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“Brioche, dried pear, smoke, almonds, chamomile and wild herbs are all laced together in Krug's 2000 Vintage. A wine of striking depth and resonance, the 2000 is absolutely gorgeous today. The first signs of very early tertiary complexity have begun to appear while the acidity is softening, both of which make the 2000 delicious today. At the same time, there is no hurry. I imagine the 2000 will still be gorgeous 20 years from now. Slight elements of reduction linger on the close. The blend is 43% Chardonnay, 42% Pinot Noir and 15% Pinot Meunier, a rare vintage in which Chardonnay is quite high. ID 313041.”
96/100
Allen Meadows,
Burghound.com,
Oct 2014
“(Krug decided to create a vintage wine for the last year of the millennium and dubbed this ""Gourmandise Orageuse"" or Stormy Indulgence, since it culminated from a challenging year in the vineyard.) A wonderfully layered and nuanced nose features an intense yeasty character to the maturing fruit that displays interesting phenolic characters, in particular petrol, along with aromas of apple, pear and soft citrus hints. In contrast to the nascent maturity expressed by the nose the flavor profile is still tight and backward with a genuinely gorgeous texture, all wrapped in a strikingly persistent and highly complex finish. For my taste the 2000 Brut is at an inflection point as the nose does offer enough maturity so that it's really quite pretty whereas the palate impression is substantially younger. As such it really just depends on how you prefer your Champagne because I suspect that the nose will be very mature by the time the still very youthful flavors attain their majority. For my taste preferences it would be no vinous crime to begin enjoying this now but be aware that this will age for a very long time. The best approach is probably to buy 6, or even 12, bottles and enjoy them over a longer period of time.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2014
“Dense and wonderfully complex. Still extremely tight-knit. Classic Krug vintage and a big contrast with the more open and oleaginous 2003. Extremely vivacious. This was a hot year but not excessively so - with storms mid August. Lighter and fresher than the 2003 and surely with a very long life.”
“Magnum - This is one my favourite Krugs of the recent years in its macho richness and muscular structure. The stylish oaky note is finely integrated to the intense fireworks of aromas ranging from coffee and patisserie to vanilla, oriental spice and dried fruits. Sits beautifully on the reductive side, aging slowly. Never-ending, impressively concentrated finish full of succulent fruit. Great ageing potential but blooming already. A glorious, glorious magnum (Krug ID 115008, Disgorged Winter 2015) was tasted in December 2019: Beautifully clean maturing fruitness and super stylish toasty richness. Still, its best features is the stunningly creamy, caressing texture on the long, well-built palate.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2016
“This is one my favourite Krugs of the recent years in its macho richness and muscular structure. The stylish oaky note is finely integrated to the intense fireworks of aromas ranging from coffee and patisserie to vanilla, oriental spice and dried fruits. Sits beautifully on the reductive side, aging slowly. Never-ending, impressively concentrated finish full of succulent fruit. Great ageing potential but blooming already.”
95/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“The Krug vintage 2000 Brut smells strikingly redolent of sea breeze, kelp, and piles of oyster and mussel shells, allied to lemon oil and toasted hazelnuts. On the palate, the aforementioned elements serve for compulsive salivation, while a lusciously juicy amalgam of lime, grapefruit and apple tinged with piquancy of their pips buoys the salty wave of mineral matter into a profoundly protracted finish that bursts with brightness and at the same time reveals mouthwateringly savory crab shell reduction and a hitherto largely hidden dark side of smoky Latakia tobacco, dark-roasted coffee, and toasted grains. Expect this to merit following for 12-15 years.
”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“ID 114009. 42% Pinot Noir, 43% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Meunier.
Tense, complex nose. Exotic smoked notes of lapsang souchong tea. Really urgent and energetic with a rich finish. ”
94/100
Richard Juhlin,
Decanter,
Dec 2015
“In its current condition, extremely mineral-driven and sea-splashed, showing iodine, oyster shells and a light, pleasant bready aroma. Crispy-clean and beautifully balanced flavour. Impressive acidity and lively elegance.”
96/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Sep 2015
“A very young and delicate wine that will require long time before you ease the cork. In the current situation extremely mineral-driven and sea-splashed. Iodine, iodine, oyster shells, and small nice bready tone in the fragrance. Crispy clean and beautiful balanced flavor. Impressive acidity and lovely elegance.”
98/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Sep 2015
“Very fragrant. This has developed bright, ripe red cherry fruit aromas, vanilla cream, sweet roasted almond biscuits, some marzipan, tobacco, lemon meringue and chalky minerals. The palate has an assertive core of fine acidity with more yellow fruits expressed on entry, like peaches and nectarines. Good ripeness, superfine acidity. The redder fruits build as it goes; cherries and raspberries, yellow plums to close. Full of life. Drink now or up to 20 years, it will go the distance.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“Brioche, dried pear, smoke, almonds, chamomile and wild herbs are all laced together in Krug's 2000 Vintage. A wine of striking depth and resonance, the 2000 is absolutely gorgeous today. The first signs of very early tertiary complexity have begun to appear while the acidity is softening, both of which make the 2000 delicious today. At the same time, there is no hurry. I imagine the 2000 will still be gorgeous 20 years from now. Slight elements of reduction linger on the close. The blend is 43% Chardonnay, 42% Pinot Noir and 15% Pinot Meunier, a rare vintage in which Chardonnay is quite high. ID 313041.”
96/100
Allen Meadows,
Burghound.com,
Oct 2014
“(Krug decided to create a vintage wine for the last year of the millennium and dubbed this ""Gourmandise Orageuse"" or Stormy Indulgence, since it culminated from a challenging year in the vineyard.) A wonderfully layered and nuanced nose features an intense yeasty character to the maturing fruit that displays interesting phenolic characters, in particular petrol, along with aromas of apple, pear and soft citrus hints. In contrast to the nascent maturity expressed by the nose the flavor profile is still tight and backward with a genuinely gorgeous texture, all wrapped in a strikingly persistent and highly complex finish. For my taste the 2000 Brut is at an inflection point as the nose does offer enough maturity so that it's really quite pretty whereas the palate impression is substantially younger. As such it really just depends on how you prefer your Champagne because I suspect that the nose will be very mature by the time the still very youthful flavors attain their majority. For my taste preferences it would be no vinous crime to begin enjoying this now but be aware that this will age for a very long time. The best approach is probably to buy 6, or even 12, bottles and enjoy them over a longer period of time.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2014
“Dense and wonderfully complex. Still extremely tight-knit. Classic Krug vintage and a big contrast with the more open and oleaginous 2003. Extremely vivacious. This was a hot year but not excessively so - with storms mid August. Lighter and fresher than the 2003 and surely with a very long life.”
“This is one my favourite Krugs of the recent years in its macho richness and muscular structure. The stylish oaky note is finely integrated to the intense fireworks of aromas ranging from coffee and patisserie to vanilla, oriental spice and dried fruits. Sits beautifully on the reductive side, aging slowly. Never-ending, impressively concentrated finish full of succulent fruit. Great ageing potential but blooming already.”
More Reviews +
95/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“The Krug vintage 2000 Brut smells strikingly redolent of sea breeze, kelp, and piles of oyster and mussel shells, allied to lemon oil and toasted hazelnuts. On the palate, the aforementioned elements serve for compulsive salivation, while a lusciously juicy amalgam of lime, grapefruit and apple tinged with piquancy of their pips buoys the salty wave of mineral matter into a profoundly protracted finish that bursts with brightness and at the same time reveals mouthwateringly savory crab shell reduction and a hitherto largely hidden dark side of smoky Latakia tobacco, dark-roasted coffee, and toasted grains. Expect this to merit following for 12-15 years.
”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“ID 114009. 42% Pinot Noir, 43% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Meunier.
Tense, complex nose. Exotic smoked notes of lapsang souchong tea. Really urgent and energetic with a rich finish. ”
94/100
Richard Juhlin,
Decanter,
Dec 2015
“In its current condition, extremely mineral-driven and sea-splashed, showing iodine, oyster shells and a light, pleasant bready aroma. Crispy-clean and beautifully balanced flavour. Impressive acidity and lively elegance.”
96/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Sep 2015
“A very young and delicate wine that will require long time before you ease the cork. In the current situation extremely mineral-driven and sea-splashed. Iodine, iodine, oyster shells, and small nice bready tone in the fragrance. Crispy clean and beautiful balanced flavor. Impressive acidity and lovely elegance.”
98/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Sep 2015
“Very fragrant. This has developed bright, ripe red cherry fruit aromas, vanilla cream, sweet roasted almond biscuits, some marzipan, tobacco, lemon meringue and chalky minerals. The palate has an assertive core of fine acidity with more yellow fruits expressed on entry, like peaches and nectarines. Good ripeness, superfine acidity. The redder fruits build as it goes; cherries and raspberries, yellow plums to close. Full of life. Drink now or up to 20 years, it will go the distance.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“Brioche, dried pear, smoke, almonds, chamomile and wild herbs are all laced together in Krug's 2000 Vintage. A wine of striking depth and resonance, the 2000 is absolutely gorgeous today. The first signs of very early tertiary complexity have begun to appear while the acidity is softening, both of which make the 2000 delicious today. At the same time, there is no hurry. I imagine the 2000 will still be gorgeous 20 years from now. Slight elements of reduction linger on the close. The blend is 43% Chardonnay, 42% Pinot Noir and 15% Pinot Meunier, a rare vintage in which Chardonnay is quite high. ID 313041.”
96/100
Allen Meadows,
Burghound.com,
Oct 2014
“(Krug decided to create a vintage wine for the last year of the millennium and dubbed this ""Gourmandise Orageuse"" or Stormy Indulgence, since it culminated from a challenging year in the vineyard.) A wonderfully layered and nuanced nose features an intense yeasty character to the maturing fruit that displays interesting phenolic characters, in particular petrol, along with aromas of apple, pear and soft citrus hints. In contrast to the nascent maturity expressed by the nose the flavor profile is still tight and backward with a genuinely gorgeous texture, all wrapped in a strikingly persistent and highly complex finish. For my taste the 2000 Brut is at an inflection point as the nose does offer enough maturity so that it's really quite pretty whereas the palate impression is substantially younger. As such it really just depends on how you prefer your Champagne because I suspect that the nose will be very mature by the time the still very youthful flavors attain their majority. For my taste preferences it would be no vinous crime to begin enjoying this now but be aware that this will age for a very long time. The best approach is probably to buy 6, or even 12, bottles and enjoy them over a longer period of time.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2014
“Dense and wonderfully complex. Still extremely tight-knit. Classic Krug vintage and a big contrast with the more open and oleaginous 2003. Extremely vivacious. This was a hot year but not excessively so - with storms mid August. Lighter and fresher than the 2003 and surely with a very long life.”
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2019
“Magnum - This is one my favourite Krugs of the recent years in its macho richness and muscular structure. The stylish oaky note is finely integrated to the intense fireworks of aromas ranging from coffee and patisserie to vanilla, oriental spice and dried fruits. Sits beautifully on the reductive side, aging slowly. Never-ending, impressively concentrated finish full of succulent fruit. Great ageing potential but blooming already. A glorious, glorious magnum (Krug ID 115008, Disgorged Winter 2015) was tasted in December 2019: Beautifully clean maturing fruitness and super stylish toasty richness. Still, its best features is the stunningly creamy, caressing texture on the long, well-built palate.”
“35% Pinot Noir, 46% Chardonnay, 19% Pinot Meunier. Known as ‘a tribute to Chardonnay’. A particularly hot August, breaking a record set in 1962. This was Eric Lebel’s first vintage and 1998 is remembered as a year of quantity as well as high quality grapes. Second time since 1981 that Chardonnay dominated a Krug vintage.
Both bottles tasted blind. Deep amber-tinged straw. Mushroomy nose at first made me wonder whether there wasn’t a touch of TCA? Just a hint of decay – perhaps because it’s very old. Not that long. We tasted a second bottle but it had the same nose, and tasted possibly just a little more acid. I wondered whether it was perhaps the 1988?”
More Reviews +
20/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Oct 2025
“Jeroboam: I wasn’t ready for this, the power & density of the fruit was quite something, sitting in this layer of flinty smoke. 1998 was a ripe fruit year and you see that, so much of the PN upfront stone fruit, particularly apricot, peach and pear, all drippingly ripe in their personality amongst some dried citrus. The palate stretches you further, the hints of bitter orange on the aromatics bursts into life on the palate adding further complexities and juiciness. The texture is so seductive, velvetiness envelopes your tongue as the sweet fruit, soft bubbles and salinity interact giving the palate its savoury and sweet workout! I have always loved Krug 1998, it was after all one of the founding champagnes of my business. This is the first #Jeroboam I have tasted, it is exquisite and feels like we are drinking it at a perfect time; though with much energy, this will develop for another 10-20 years, at least. It well deserves its perfect score. 20/20”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“(Magnum) Tasted blind. Disgorged spring 2010.
Very different nose – extremely dense and layered. But good freshness. Youthful. Some yeasty beeriness. Lots of layers. Jeroboam? No, this very fine wine was the magnum. ”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“(Bottle) Tasted blind. Disgorged October 2007.
Meaty and interesting. Savoury and very dry. Tight texture but with lots of evolution on the nose. Bone-dry end. Sweet and more delicate than most. Magnum? No, it's the bottle!”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“(Jeroboam) Tasted blind. Disgorged autumn 2013.
Quite a different nose from the first sample (which turned out to be the magnum): herbs and damp furniture webbing. Open. The lightest in terms of weight. The simplest of the three samples of this wine so I assumed it came from a bottle but in fact it was the jeroboam, disgorged very much recently than the other two samples – not a level playing field! ”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2015
“Deep, evolved, ripe fruity nose of toast, dried fruit, nuts and bruised apple complexity. Concentrated, vinous and powerful palate, which comes with the smoothest mousse. Open, accessible and impressively well built palate that comes with an accentuated ripe appley fruit character. Shows already signs of evolution but there is of fruit left for ageing.”
17/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2014
“47% Chardonnay, 37% Pinot Noir, 16% Pinot Meunier – unusual for Krug to be Chardonnay dominant but it was very successful in this vintage. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged Dec 2007.
Mid gold. Very yeasty nose, the most toasty so far in this line up of 04s and 98s, lightly honeyed, chamomile, dried fruit, buttery baked apples. Delicious aromas and so different from the DP 98. Broad but surprisingly tart on the palate. As if the flavour and the structure have started to diverge with the acidity starting to spike. Tart aftertaste.”
98/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Nov 2012
“This harmonious Champagne offers luxurious texture and powerful, focused acidity, showing aromatic accents of spring blossom, crushed thyme and chai, with rich notes of lemon meringue, hazelnut, black currant and fresh porcini mushroom. The full package. Impressive.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Oct 2012
“Krug's 1998 Brut Vintage is an excellent choice for drinking today, as the classic Krug style is rich, alive and totally vivid. Honey, almonds, smoke, graphite and dried apricots are some of the many aromas and flavors found in this rich, enveloping Champagne. A wine of texture and depth, the 1998 impresses for its vinous personality and terrific balance. Lively veins of underlying acidity suggest the 1998 will drink well for many years to follow. This is one of the best bottles of the 1998 I have ever tasted. ”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2011
“Very, very fine bead. Very discreet and beautifully constructed. Very dense. Like a ship, constructed bit by bit. Dry finish. Needs food! A great rarity: a Krug with more Chardonnay than Pinot Noir.”
94/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Nov 2015
“Enormously fascinating to see how Krug has succeeded in avoiding a single oxidated grape this risky year, despite their extensive procuration of grapes from different sources. This wine is fantastically focused and unmistakeably stamped with the Krug trademark. Seductively mellow right through the elegant, classical flavour that is as united as a well-trimmed Russian machine team from the 70s. Somewhere between 89, 95 and 96 in character.”
“35% Pinot Noir, 46% Chardonnay, 19% Pinot Meunier. Known as ‘a tribute to Chardonnay’. A particularly hot August, breaking a record set in 1962. This was Eric Lebel’s first vintage and 1998 is remembered as a year of quantity as well as high quality grapes. Second time since 1981 that Chardonnay dominated a Krug vintage.
Both bottles tasted blind. Deep amber-tinged straw. Mushroomy nose at first made me wonder whether there wasn’t a touch of TCA? Just a hint of decay – perhaps because it’s very old. Not that long. We tasted a second bottle but it had the same nose, and tasted possibly just a little more acid. I wondered whether it was perhaps the 1988?”
More Reviews +
20/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Oct 2025
“Jeroboam: I wasn’t ready for this, the power & density of the fruit was quite something, sitting in this layer of flinty smoke. 1998 was a ripe fruit year and you see that, so much of the PN upfront stone fruit, particularly apricot, peach and pear, all drippingly ripe in their personality amongst some dried citrus. The palate stretches you further, the hints of bitter orange on the aromatics bursts into life on the palate adding further complexities and juiciness. The texture is so seductive, velvetiness envelopes your tongue as the sweet fruit, soft bubbles and salinity interact giving the palate its savoury and sweet workout! I have always loved Krug 1998, it was after all one of the founding champagnes of my business. This is the first #Jeroboam I have tasted, it is exquisite and feels like we are drinking it at a perfect time; though with much energy, this will develop for another 10-20 years, at least. It well deserves its perfect score. 20/20”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“(Magnum) Tasted blind. Disgorged spring 2010.
Very different nose – extremely dense and layered. But good freshness. Youthful. Some yeasty beeriness. Lots of layers. Jeroboam? No, this very fine wine was the magnum. ”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“(Bottle) Tasted blind. Disgorged October 2007.
Meaty and interesting. Savoury and very dry. Tight texture but with lots of evolution on the nose. Bone-dry end. Sweet and more delicate than most. Magnum? No, it's the bottle!”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“(Jeroboam) Tasted blind. Disgorged autumn 2013.
Quite a different nose from the first sample (which turned out to be the magnum): herbs and damp furniture webbing. Open. The lightest in terms of weight. The simplest of the three samples of this wine so I assumed it came from a bottle but in fact it was the jeroboam, disgorged very much recently than the other two samples – not a level playing field! ”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2015
“Deep, evolved, ripe fruity nose of toast, dried fruit, nuts and bruised apple complexity. Concentrated, vinous and powerful palate, which comes with the smoothest mousse. Open, accessible and impressively well built palate that comes with an accentuated ripe appley fruit character. Shows already signs of evolution but there is of fruit left for ageing.”
17/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2014
“47% Chardonnay, 37% Pinot Noir, 16% Pinot Meunier – unusual for Krug to be Chardonnay dominant but it was very successful in this vintage. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged Dec 2007.
Mid gold. Very yeasty nose, the most toasty so far in this line up of 04s and 98s, lightly honeyed, chamomile, dried fruit, buttery baked apples. Delicious aromas and so different from the DP 98. Broad but surprisingly tart on the palate. As if the flavour and the structure have started to diverge with the acidity starting to spike. Tart aftertaste.”
98/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Nov 2012
“This harmonious Champagne offers luxurious texture and powerful, focused acidity, showing aromatic accents of spring blossom, crushed thyme and chai, with rich notes of lemon meringue, hazelnut, black currant and fresh porcini mushroom. The full package. Impressive.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Oct 2012
“Krug's 1998 Brut Vintage is an excellent choice for drinking today, as the classic Krug style is rich, alive and totally vivid. Honey, almonds, smoke, graphite and dried apricots are some of the many aromas and flavors found in this rich, enveloping Champagne. A wine of texture and depth, the 1998 impresses for its vinous personality and terrific balance. Lively veins of underlying acidity suggest the 1998 will drink well for many years to follow. This is one of the best bottles of the 1998 I have ever tasted. ”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2011
“Very, very fine bead. Very discreet and beautifully constructed. Very dense. Like a ship, constructed bit by bit. Dry finish. Needs food! A great rarity: a Krug with more Chardonnay than Pinot Noir.”
94/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Nov 2015
“Enormously fascinating to see how Krug has succeeded in avoiding a single oxidated grape this risky year, despite their extensive procuration of grapes from different sources. This wine is fantastically focused and unmistakeably stamped with the Krug trademark. Seductively mellow right through the elegant, classical flavour that is as united as a well-trimmed Russian machine team from the 70s. Somewhere between 89, 95 and 96 in character.”
“ID 105095. Disgorged winter 2004-05. 48% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay, 17% Pinot Meunier. Known as ‘harmonious, generous and serene’. A mild winter, serious frosts and extreme heat.
Tasted blind. Pale apricot colour. Very appealing caramel nose. Most intriguing and complex on the nose. Beautiful. Much less severe than some with real depth and savour and some green vegetal notes. Great balance. Very tense. Dry but not drying end.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Apr 2014
“I am allocating slightly fewer marks here than for example to the 90, to be sure, but a more classical Krug still feels positive after the monstruous giants of 89 and 90. The most striking thing about it is the razorsharp acid that guarantees an extremely long life. Probably the most long-lived of all the 95's in Champagne. At present the acid has the same efficacy as a fantastic breeze of bracing alpine air. The complexity and elegance are unmistakeable. Most strongly reminiscent of Bollinger's fabulous 95, but somewhat harder at the present stage.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2018
“The 1995 Krug is gorgeous. I chose it because one of my guests loves Krug and I thought the 1995 would have the right amount of complexity to pair beautifully with the smokiness in Saison’s caviar. Although the 1995 Krug is not a truly epic wine, it is in a sweet spot right now.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Feb 2012
“Krug's 1995 Vintage continues to grow in bottle. It showed fabulous focus and definition in a vibrant, refreshing style that was perfect with hors d'oeuvres. Surprisingly, the 1995 remains one of the more under the radar recent released from Krug.”
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2010
“A beautiful Krug, balanced to perfection. The nose is a seductive blend of toastiness, ripe sweet fruitiness, aromatic wood, apricots and perfume. Rich and oily mouth-feel with impeccably well-integrated acidic backbone. Superb now but it is still climbing toward its peak.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2009
“Pale straw. Rather languid bead. Firm, almost vegetal nose with just a hint of lemon cream. Dense and tight knit. Uncompromisngly dry and still pretty tight. Very long.It's all on the finish, like some great white burgundies. Wonderfully long. But I would still ideally wait for this to unwind further. It is slowly opening out from the tense state in which it was released...”
95/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Dec 2006
“Light yellow. Rich and powerful, with leesy pear and white truffle aromas accented by gentle notes of white pepper and cinnamon. Extremely powerful Krug, with rich orchard fruit flavors, a velvety texture and warm, rich, inviting notes of brioche and creme brulee Finishes with intense pear and peach flavors and lingering notes of smoke, iodine and toffee. One of the most concentrated Champagnes I tried this year.”
98/100
Bruce Sanderson,
Wine Spectator,
May 2006
“A very youthful '95. Delicate. Intense aromas of ginger, citrus, candied berry and multigrain bread turn to honey, roasted almonds and graphite on the palate. It's all underscored by creamy texture and a precise structure that keeps it persistent through the long finish. A picture of precision and intensity. Drink now through 2025.”
“ID 105095. Disgorged winter 2004-05. 48% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay, 17% Pinot Meunier. Known as ‘harmonious, generous and serene’. A mild winter, serious frosts and extreme heat.
Tasted blind. Pale apricot colour. Very appealing caramel nose. Most intriguing and complex on the nose. Beautiful. Much less severe than some with real depth and savour and some green vegetal notes. Great balance. Very tense. Dry but not drying end.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Richard Juhlin,
ChampagneClub.com,
Apr 2014
“I am allocating slightly fewer marks here than for example to the 90, to be sure, but a more classical Krug still feels positive after the monstruous giants of 89 and 90. The most striking thing about it is the razorsharp acid that guarantees an extremely long life. Probably the most long-lived of all the 95's in Champagne. At present the acid has the same efficacy as a fantastic breeze of bracing alpine air. The complexity and elegance are unmistakeable. Most strongly reminiscent of Bollinger's fabulous 95, but somewhat harder at the present stage.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2018
“The 1995 Krug is gorgeous. I chose it because one of my guests loves Krug and I thought the 1995 would have the right amount of complexity to pair beautifully with the smokiness in Saison’s caviar. Although the 1995 Krug is not a truly epic wine, it is in a sweet spot right now.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Feb 2012
“Krug's 1995 Vintage continues to grow in bottle. It showed fabulous focus and definition in a vibrant, refreshing style that was perfect with hors d'oeuvres. Surprisingly, the 1995 remains one of the more under the radar recent released from Krug.”
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2010
“A beautiful Krug, balanced to perfection. The nose is a seductive blend of toastiness, ripe sweet fruitiness, aromatic wood, apricots and perfume. Rich and oily mouth-feel with impeccably well-integrated acidic backbone. Superb now but it is still climbing toward its peak.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2009
“Pale straw. Rather languid bead. Firm, almost vegetal nose with just a hint of lemon cream. Dense and tight knit. Uncompromisngly dry and still pretty tight. Very long.It's all on the finish, like some great white burgundies. Wonderfully long. But I would still ideally wait for this to unwind further. It is slowly opening out from the tense state in which it was released...”
95/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Dec 2006
“Light yellow. Rich and powerful, with leesy pear and white truffle aromas accented by gentle notes of white pepper and cinnamon. Extremely powerful Krug, with rich orchard fruit flavors, a velvety texture and warm, rich, inviting notes of brioche and creme brulee Finishes with intense pear and peach flavors and lingering notes of smoke, iodine and toffee. One of the most concentrated Champagnes I tried this year.”
98/100
Bruce Sanderson,
Wine Spectator,
May 2006
“A very youthful '95. Delicate. Intense aromas of ginger, citrus, candied berry and multigrain bread turn to honey, roasted almonds and graphite on the palate. It's all underscored by creamy texture and a precise structure that keeps it persistent through the long finish. A picture of precision and intensity. Drink now through 2025.”
“ID 407001. Disgorged autumn 2007. 48% Pinot Noir, 31% Chardonnay, 21% Pinot Meunier from 17 villages. Known as ‘extreme and charismatic’. Contrary to what people believe, 1996 was not an easy vintage: to deal with this extreme freshness is always a challenge. Harvest took place between 20 September and 30 September.
Tasted blind. Deep orangey apricot colour with a sluggish bead. Fully mature nose with notes of dried apricots and nuts. Wholly enveloping pleasure on the nose! Hint of caramel and also something very exotic indeed. Something you wouldn’t find in any other champagne, surely. Dry, clean finish. ”
More Reviews +
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2016
“ID 407001. 42% Pinot Noir, 32% Chardonnay, 26% Pinot Meunier.
Deep golden straw. Less intense nose than the Grande Cuvée ID 313054. Edge of bread dough. Firm with masses of acidity. Quite demanding. The acidity of the year dominates this wine for the moment. Very dry impression. Almost austere. I would age this wine longer to allow it to soften a bit. Very much less flattering than the Grande Cuvée based on 2006 tasted alongside. 12%”
“A powerhouse, with a dense and expressive core of toasted brioche, candied kumquat, espresso crème, crystallized honey and salted pistachio flavors. The fine, creamy mousse and well-meshed acidity lend a sense of finesse that cloaks the firm structure and exuberance of this impressive Champagne. Disgorged spring 2010. Drink now through 2030.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2013
“Dense and wonderfully complex. Still extremely tight-knit. Classic Krug vintage and a big contrast with the more open and oleaginous 2003. Extremely vivacious. This was a hot year but not excessively so - with storms mid August. Lighter and fresher than the 2003 and surely with a very long life.”
95/100
Robert Parker Jr,
Robertparker.com,
Nov 2013
“The Krug vintage 2000 Brut smells strikingly redolent of sea breeze, kelp, and piles of oyster and mussel shells, allied to lemon oil and toasted hazelnuts. On the palate, the aforementioned elements serve for compulsive salivation, while a lusciously juicy amalgam of lime, grapefruit and apple tinged with piquancy of their pips buoys the salty wave of mineral matter into a profoundly protracted finish that bursts with brightness and at the same time reveals mouthwateringly savory crab shell reduction and a hitherto largely hidden dark side of smoky Latakia tobacco, dark-roasted coffee, and toasted grains. Expect this to merit following for 12-15 years. ”
“A powerhouse, with a dense and expressive core of toasted brioche, candied kumquat, espresso crème, crystallized honey and salted pistachio flavors. The fine, creamy mousse and well-meshed acidity lend a sense of finesse that cloaks the firm structure and exuberance of this impressive Champagne. Disgorged spring 2010. Drink now through 2030.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2013
“Dense and wonderfully complex. Still extremely tight-knit. Classic Krug vintage and a big contrast with the more open and oleaginous 2003. Extremely vivacious. This was a hot year but not excessively so - with storms mid August. Lighter and fresher than the 2003 and surely with a very long life.”
95/100
Robert Parker Jr,
Robertparker.com,
Nov 2013
“The Krug vintage 2000 Brut smells strikingly redolent of sea breeze, kelp, and piles of oyster and mussel shells, allied to lemon oil and toasted hazelnuts. On the palate, the aforementioned elements serve for compulsive salivation, while a lusciously juicy amalgam of lime, grapefruit and apple tinged with piquancy of their pips buoys the salty wave of mineral matter into a profoundly protracted finish that bursts with brightness and at the same time reveals mouthwateringly savory crab shell reduction and a hitherto largely hidden dark side of smoky Latakia tobacco, dark-roasted coffee, and toasted grains. Expect this to merit following for 12-15 years. ”
“Krug’s 2006 Clos d’Ambonnay is superb. It offers a beguiling interplay of richness from the warm, solar year and strong mineral underpinnings that wrap it all together. Hints of apricot, plum, baked apple tart and spice soar out of the glass. Soft, curvy and exceptionally well-balanced, the 2006 is the most sensual young Clos d’Ambonnay I have tasted. This is a magnificent showing from Krug. That’s pretty much all there is to it. Best of all, the 2006 is a rare Clos d’Ambonnay that can be enjoyed upon release. Harvest took place over two days and wrapped up on September 22, considered late at the time.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Entirely crafted from Pinot Noir sourced in a single parcel of Clos d'Ambonnay, Krug's 2006 Blanc de Noirs Brut Clos d’Ambonnay is one of my favorite vintages at this address. Evoking aromas of spices, smoke, white fruits, brioche, pastry, dried herbs, plum and ripe orchard fruits, it possesses a full-bodied, round and charming mid-palate framed by a crystalline and pure texture. It has a delicately phenolic mid-palate and pinpoint mousse that leads to a long, mineral and saline finish marked by subtle iodine notes and gastronomic bitterness. Classic and precise, this is purity and elegance incarnate. Though already superb, readers should be patient to enjoy this Champagne at its peak.”
16.5++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2023
“The nose is till a bit solid and stodgy rather than exhibiting the ethereal nature of so many fine champagnes. It finishes a bit suddenly too. Perhaps I am prejudiced against it because the combination of its rarity and Krug's reputation has resulted in such a high price. Compare and contrast with Krug 2006 and the Grande Cuvée based on the same vintage …”
“And greatness verified a year or so later... Stunning complexity and lots of way to go. Juicy, mellow, silky and energetic. Sheer perfection.”
More Reviews +
97-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
Mar 2022
“Krug’s magnificent Clos d’Ambonnay plot produced a stunning wine in 2002, so full of fruit and gloriously topped with toasty notes. Bright lemon-yellow colour. The sweetly fruity nose is evolving gracefully, joined by layers of dried fruit and roasted coffee. Its well-structured and persistent palate is equally impressive. The fruity richness is enlivened by the wine’s fine acid structure that carries it from its lush beginning to an extremely long finish.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The 2002 Clos d’Ambonnay is another spectacular Champagne from Krug. In fact, the 2002 may very well be the most sensual Clos d’Ambonnay yet. Opulent, intense and yet light on its feet, the 2002 has it all. Hints of ash, graphite and smoke wrap around a core of rich Pinot fruit in a powerful, riveting wine of the highest level. Chef de Caves Eric Lebel describes 2002 as a perfect growing season. “We had sun we wanted it and rain we needed it,” he told me recently. The Krug team captured everything the vintage had to offer, certainly to a far greater degree than they did with the 2002 Clos du Mesnil or Vintage. Readers who can find the 2002 Clos d’Ambonnay and who can look past the price will experience a seriously phenomenal Champagne. That’s all there is to it. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“ID 415067. Bottled when Clos d’Ambonnay was still an unreleased experiment. The first vintage, 1995, was released in 2007. Half of the 0.34-ha (0.84-acre) plot, hardly enough to fill a full press, has been replanted ‘the Krug way’.
Quite a bit of age, though more on the side of big and bold than subtle nuance. Firm finish. Very long indeed.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“ID 415067. Bottled when Clos d’Ambonnay was still an unreleased experiment. The first vintage, 1995, was released in 2007. Half of the 0.34-ha (0.84-acre) plot, hardly enough to fill a full press, has been replanted ‘the Krug way’.
Quite a bit of age, though more on the side of big and bold than subtle nuance. Firm finish. Very long indeed.”
“ID 413063. Bottle number 1008 disgorged in 2013. When this was made, it was still an experiment. The 1995 was the first vintage but it had still not been released. This 2000 was released in early 2015.
Deep gold. Very deep-flavoured - chestnuts? - on the nose. Extremely persistent. Massive dimension; the bubbles almost seemed to struggle to escape. Still remarkably fresh with masses of aromatic development. Big, bold and bright.”
More Reviews +
95-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2015
“Deep, super rich nose of sweet figs, apricots, freshly ground coffee, vanilla, cloves, oriental spices and nuts. Ripe and sweet potpourri of fruits and spices. Calm, massively intense palate with the mousse texturing mild and gentle. Fantastic hit of acidity at the end, bringing a fresh salivating effect. A tight, invigorating finish promising long age (Bottle no. 1007 of 5158). ”
“The 1998 Brut Clos d'Ambonnay appears to have arrived at an early plateau of maturity. Hints of white truffle, orange peel, licorice, honey and roasted almonds are woven together in a super-appealing mélange of aromas, flavors and textures.”
More Reviews +
95-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2013
“Deep golden colour with a peachy hue. Layered nose that opens in the glass. Deep and multidimensional: spices, wood, honey and burned sugar. Powerful on the palate that shows oaky tones. Superbly fine mousse. Smooth, calm and concentrated. The best Clos d’Ambonnay so far. ”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2011
“This is only the third release of this luxury wine. Really quite a dark coppery gold. Very big and bold on the nose. Heady, mushroomy, almost beery! Lovely fine, tiny bead. Like Clos du Mesnil, this has a bone-dry finish and is very forcibly real wine rather than evanescent champagne. Real vinosity; very different in build from other Krug wines.”
“This flight of 1996s provided plenty of context. The 1996 Clos d'Ambonnay is very similar to the Clos du Mesnil in this vintage. It has the same piercing purity and minerality with the heft of the Pinot still to fully emerge. Hints of menthol, spices and berries wrap around the eternal finish. Clos d'Ambonnay, from a single, walled-in parcel in the village of Ambonnay, is in many ways the red equivalent of Clos du Mesnil. ”
More Reviews +
98+/100
Lisa Perrotti-Brown MW,
RobertParker.com,
Apr 2011
“Medium straw in color, the nose is profoundly scented of apple tart, lightly toasted hazelnuts, orange blossom, brioche, and granola with subtle nuances of crushed stones, musk and honeycomb. The palate is incredibly concentrated, crisp and taut with great richness matched by very fine bubbles and a very long, steely finish. There's definitely a lot more to come from this wine but it's looking very fine now.”
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2010
“Overt and expressive nose of toast, honey, red apple, earthy spiciness and finely integrated touch of oak. Some oxidative nuances too. Explosively fruity palate that is lifted by a remarkable acidic back bone. Great vivacity, intensity and near-eternal length. The palate takes the oak very well, merging it into the seamless complexity of super intense flavours.”
99/100
James Halliday,
Wine Companion,
Feb 2010
“This is an intensely aromatic champagne, with a spiced plum, citrus and vanilla bouquet leading into what at first seems an astonishingly fine (almost to the point of delicate) palate. On re-tasting, the explosive power on the back-palate and finish takes over, with a pyrotechnic display of the racy acidity of the ‘96 vintage. It is at the opposite end of the universe to the Bollinger Vieilles Vignes Françaises, also 100 per cent pinot noir. If kept in a humidified 12ºC to 14ºC cellar, d’Ambonnay will live for 50 years, and will need not less than 20 to start to display all its secrets.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Oct 2014
“Krug’s 1996 Clos d’Ambonnay comes across as quite nuanced and understated, with precise, crystalline fruit and tons of detail.”
“The 2009 Clos du Mesnil is total stunner. Rich, ample and exotic, it stains the palate with a mélange of lemon confit, chamomile, dried flowers, chamomile and tangerine peel. It is the most concentrated and explosive young Clos du Mesnil I have ever tasted. The 2009 sits on the edge between the citrus and tropical sides of the fruit spectrum. That duality makes it complex and beguiling. Even with all of its radiance, the 2009 finishes with a bit of tightness that suggests it needs time in bottle to be at its finest. Magnificent. Krug ID: 124001.”
More Reviews +
97+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Disgorged in May 2024 with a dosage of 4.5 grams per liter, Krug’s 2009 Blanc de Blancs Clos du Mesnil is performing very well. Though the 2009 vintage was defined by a sunny growing season, it no longer appears all that extreme when viewed in context with more recent years such as 2018, 2019, 2020, and 2022. Harvest commenced on September 10, with the team conducting five to six separate pickings to capture optimal ripeness, plot by plot. Each parcel was pressed and vinified individually. In the glass, the wine unfolds with a bouquet of lemon oil, green apple, peach and oyster juice, interwoven with the delicate aroma of early-blooming white blossoms. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, elegantly muscular and tightly wound. Produced without malolactic fermentation—contributing to its pronounced acidity—this rendition underscores Le Mesnil’s electric character, asserting its identity over the vintage in the most flattering sense. Chiseled and taut and complemented by a pillowy mousse, it culminates in a long, saline finish delicately tinged with lemon. This release also marks a commitment to a more thoughtful agronomy: since 2009, Krug has eschewed the use of herbicides in its estate-owned vineyards. ”
“Once again, the 2008 Blanc de Blancs Clos du Mesnil is performing well today. Offering up a complex, dense and delicately spicy bouquet of citrus oil, hazelnuts, marzipan, pastry, ripe apricot and confit citrus, it's full-bodied, perfectly balanced and layered, with a crystalline, chiseled texture framed by racy acids, leading to a long, mineral and lovely iodine-inflected finish. Despite its austerity and structure, this Chardonnay, entirely sourced from Mesnil-sur-Oger, possesses a charming character that promises to age gracefully for 20-30 years.”
More Reviews +
99/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2022
“Krug Clos du Mesnil 2008 | Tasted from two bottles, is a very, very special Champagne. Soaring aromatics, fine, chiseled fruit and understated depth are the signatures of a Champagne that is immediately captivating. Bright, salivating acids run through a core of citrus fruit, lemon oil, slate, chalk, mint and white pepper. A touch of reduction and a superb, fine mousse move the 2008 into a realm that straddles Champagne and a distinctly Burgundian expression of Chardonnay. The 2008 is going to be expensive, and I am already hearing that allocations will be miniscule. For readers who can find it, the 2008 is an essential Clos du Mesnil that will take its place among the greatest vintages made here, specifically the 1979, 1988 and 1996. If anyone wants to organize a comparative tasting of the four, plus maybe the 2004, I’m game! The 2008 Clos du Mesnil is a magnificent Champagne to savor over the next several decades.”
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jun 2022
“This is a powerful, sensual and intense Blanc de Blancs with lots of chalk, lemon, apricot stone, walnut, flint, biscuit, toast, white grapefruit and quince. Vibrant, tight and structured. Tight bubbles and a sharp backbone of acidity. Very long and persistent.”
98+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jun 2022
“Krug Clos du Mesnil 2008 | Disgorged a year ago, Krug's 2008 Blanc de Blancs Clos du Mesnil unwinds in the glass with notes of citrus oil, nougat, honeycomb, white flowers and a discreet hint of buttered toast and hazelnuts. Full-bodied, layered and chiseled, it's a taut, concentrated wine with a tightly wound core that's underpinned by a racy spine of acidity, complemented by a pretty pinpoint mousse and concluding with a long, chalky finish. Austerity without asperity is how I'd characterize this wine; and interestingly, though Krug likens their monovarietal single-vineyard cuvées to soloists vis-à-vis the orchestra of Grande Cuvée, in 2008 it's the Clos du Mesnil-sur-Oger—the soloist—that has produced the house's most complete wine. Given its structure and tension, it goes without saying that this will richly reward bottle age.”
“The 2006 Clos du Mesnil was harvested over three days, which is remarkable for a tiny parcel measuring 1.84 hectares divided into five blocks that are often picked over a wider timeframe. Soaring in the glass, the 2006 is stratospheric in its beauty. The richness of the year contrasts so beautifully with the flintiness and energy of Mesnil. With time in the glass the mousse softens, releasing layers of vinous intensity. Tangerine oil, pastry, lemon confit and marzipan all build effortlessly. The 2006 is sumptuous, racy and exotic to the core, with all of that richness supported by a phenolic, intense frame. This is Krug ID: 319030.”
More Reviews +
97/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2020
“Slated for release later this year, Krug's 2006 Blanc de Blancs Clos du Mesnil unwinds in the glass with aromas of buttered citrus fruit, crisp green pear, warm pastry, freshly baked bread, apricot and licorice. Full-bodied, layered and concentrated, the 2006's comparatively extroverted and gourmand bouquet is in contrast to its deep, chiseled and tightly wound palate, and it's here that the site really dominates the vintage signature. Long, sapid and penetrating, complemented by a pillowy pinpoint mousse, this is a brilliant Blanc de Blancs that has been well worth the wait. By the standards of young Clos du Mesnil, it's already quite approachable and can already be drunk with considerable satisfaction.”
“The 2004 Clos du Mesnil captures all the pedigree of this epic Blanc des Blancs vintage. A soaring, majestic Champagne, the 2004 dazzles from the very first taste with its crystalline purity and brightness. In two tastings so far, the 2004 has been nothing less than a total showstopper. The vertical structure and pure, tightly-coiled power are the stuff dreams are made of. There is little doubt the 2004 is one of the very finest Clos du Mesnils in recent memory. Will it join the 1979, 1988 and 1996 as one of the all-time greats? Now, that is a tasting I would love to do!”
More Reviews +
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2018
“ID 416040. Particularly generous harvest after the heatwave vintage of 2003 then a long winter and late budbreak. Saved by an Indian summer. Picked 24 and 25 September (Krug usually start with Clos du Mesnil).
Bright gold. Intense nose – very Chardonnay. Bone dry and dense. Saline. There's a whiff of mature Chablis about this. The usual Krug intellectual intrigue and slight austerity. Still a bit of a challenge.”
“Even in this bad-tempered vintage, the earth-shaking minerality of Krug’s single-vineyard Clos du Mesnil could not be dampened. It utterly trumps the phenolic grip of the season, which fades into complete oblivion. It wields a shining white citrus sabre that slices through its core with razor precision. This is not just the best Champagne of 2003, it is an entrancing wine by any standards, vintage aside.
”
More Reviews +
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“ID 314058. Less explosive on the nose than the Clos du Mesnil 1999 (tasted but not released because not deemed up to scratch) but with real presence on the palate. Lots to bite on. Neat and a little more obviously exuberant than the 2000 Clos du Mesnil tasted the previous evening. Certainly no shortage of acidity. And lots of potential to age.
Drink 2013-2025”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2015
“Strong, oaky, charred, super intense nose showing beautiful evolution and yeasty and toasty depth. Really powerful with mild oxidative notes but backed up with plenty of acidity and vibrancy. Still very soft and overt for Clos du Mesnil. This is still youhful and the oak will get better integrated over time.”
97/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Dec 2014
“Incredibly fresh and vibrant, this stunning Champagne weaves a tightly knit skein of ripe pear and tangy yellow plum fruit flavors together, with accents of rich pastry cream, toasted brioche, elderflower, ground cardamom and coffee liqueur. Shows a beautiful texture. A thread of salinity winds through to the lasting finish. Disgorged fall 2013. Drink now through 2029.”
94+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“The 2003 Clos du Mesnil is insanely beautiful. Vivid, resonant and textured in the glass, the 2003 boasts magnificent depth and pure breed. Since I last tasted it a few months ago, the 2003 has begun to shut down, which is probably a great sign for its future and overall longevity. Hints of smoke, slate and dried pear gradually open up in the glass, but the 2003 mostly stands out for its exceptional finesse.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2014
“2003 was especially difficult in Mesnil, because the frost in early April halved the crop. 8,671 bottles and 659 magnums were made. Harvested 27 and 29 August. Really impressive nose -- very broad, creamy, and flinty, with a little bit of reductiveness combining with a smoky flavour and a lovely dairy yoghurt character. Dry and savoury, fabulous length and intensity on the palate. The reputation of this cuvée is deserved in the sense of the sheer quality of flavours and the massive depth on display. It doesn’t seem clumsy in the way that some 2003s do --but it isn’t doesn't have the defining acidity of, say, Salon 2002. In fact it is quite soft. The real attraction, though, is the range and power of the nose.”
“Even in this bad-tempered vintage, the earth-shaking minerality of Krug’s single-vineyard Clos du Mesnil could not be dampened. It utterly trumps the phenolic grip of the season, which fades into complete oblivion. It wields a shining white citrus sabre that slices through its core with razor precision. This is not just the best Champagne of 2003, it is an entrancing wine by any standards, vintage aside.
”
More Reviews +
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“ID 314058. Less explosive on the nose than the Clos du Mesnil 1999 (tasted but not released because not deemed up to scratch) but with real presence on the palate. Lots to bite on. Neat and a little more obviously exuberant than the 2000 Clos du Mesnil tasted the previous evening. Certainly no shortage of acidity. And lots of potential to age.
Drink 2013-2025”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2015
“Strong, oaky, charred, super intense nose showing beautiful evolution and yeasty and toasty depth. Really powerful with mild oxidative notes but backed up with plenty of acidity and vibrancy. Still very soft and overt for Clos du Mesnil. This is still youhful and the oak will get better integrated over time.”
97/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Dec 2014
“Incredibly fresh and vibrant, this stunning Champagne weaves a tightly knit skein of ripe pear and tangy yellow plum fruit flavors together, with accents of rich pastry cream, toasted brioche, elderflower, ground cardamom and coffee liqueur. Shows a beautiful texture. A thread of salinity winds through to the lasting finish. Disgorged fall 2013. Drink now through 2029.”
94+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“The 2003 Clos du Mesnil is insanely beautiful. Vivid, resonant and textured in the glass, the 2003 boasts magnificent depth and pure breed. Since I last tasted it a few months ago, the 2003 has begun to shut down, which is probably a great sign for its future and overall longevity. Hints of smoke, slate and dried pear gradually open up in the glass, but the 2003 mostly stands out for its exceptional finesse.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2014
“2003 was especially difficult in Mesnil, because the frost in early April halved the crop. 8,671 bottles and 659 magnums were made. Harvested 27 and 29 August. Really impressive nose -- very broad, creamy, and flinty, with a little bit of reductiveness combining with a smoky flavour and a lovely dairy yoghurt character. Dry and savoury, fabulous length and intensity on the palate. The reputation of this cuvée is deserved in the sense of the sheer quality of flavours and the massive depth on display. It doesn’t seem clumsy in the way that some 2003s do --but it isn’t doesn't have the defining acidity of, say, Salon 2002. In fact it is quite soft. The real attraction, though, is the range and power of the nose.”
“At first, this exhibited alluring tropical passion fruit notes. But five years ago, it was transformed into a more honed and classical Clos du Mesnil. Now, it is even more beautiful, having developed buttery, almost fudge-scented notes which complement the stunning acidity.
”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“Originally released in 2012 but this bottling was not from the first release.
Much tighter, fresher and leaner than the Clos d'Ambonnay 2000 once served in a decent champagne glass. Very complex and serious on the nose. Brightly fruited and finely etched. Thrilling tension. This wine was originally served in wide burgundy bowls and these made the wine taste much broader and more developed than the Clos d'Ambonnay 2000.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2015
“This wine has been on a consistent rise ever since its launch. It has taken some time for the reserved tightness to vanish but now the wine is already showing plenty of what is to come. It impresses from the first sniff onwards until its super long and intense ending. There is a searing acid line beneath ripe fruity opulence leading to a dry mineral finish. The oaky notes are now perfectly harmonized to the generous, honey and fudge toned fruitness. The wine comes together so beautifully at the end. Still holding back plenty so hold on to the bottles you have. A grand Clos du Mesnil.”
97/100
Alison Napjus,
WineSpectator.com,
Sep 2014
“Silky and fine like featherweight cashmere, this vibrant blanc de blancs is nonetheless laden with ample, expressive flavors. Rich hints of XO cognac and coffee liqueur underscore bergamot and glazed apricot fruit, while smoky minerality, spun honey, grilled nut and exotic spices impart further complexity and linger on the lasting finish. Disgorged spring 2012. Drink now through 2030. ”
100/100
Tyson Stelzer,
The Champagne Guide 2014-15,
Dec 2013
“There is no fingerprint of place more pronounced than the mineral voice of the soil that resonates in the most distinctive champagnes. In all Champagne I have not tasted a wine of such earth-shaking minerality as Clos du Mesnil 2000. It rumbles to the very core of the earth deep below the mesmerising site, then rises on the finish, like a shard of pure chalk erupting from the surface of the Clos itself.”
97/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Nov 2013
“A vibrant and expressive version, showing a pleasing tension to the interplay of mouthwatering acidity and fleur de sel-tinged minerality, with fine layers of poached quince, peach skin, ground coffee, toasted hazelnut, clover honey and cumin flavors. Spice and mineral notes ring out on the finish. Drink now through 2030.”
96/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Nov 2013
“Vibrant yellow-gold. Smoke- and mineral-accented pear and Meyer lemon on the deeply scented nose, with notes of ginger, vanilla bean and white flowers adding complexity and lift. Sappy, deeply pitched orchard and pit fruit flavors are braced by juicy acidity, picking up sweet butter and anise nuances with air. Chewy and mineral-driven, with superb clarity and slow-building spiciness. An exotic touch of iodine emerges on the finish, which shows outstanding focus and toasty persistence. The combination of power and energy here is really impressive.”
96+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2013
“Krug's 2000 Brut Blanc de Blancs Clos du Mesnil keeps getting better and better. The flavors are starting to develop lovely layers of complexity, while the wine is also fleshing out a bit, releasing gorgeous layers of texture. Lemon oil, jasmine, white flowers, almonds and spices wrap around the deep, resonant finish in a striking Clos du Mesnil with a bright, bright future. This was bottle N. 6617.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2012
“There was no heatwave in 2000 but overall the summer was quite warm. This will be the next Clos du Mesnil to be released, but actually I found it a little more generous on the palate than the 1998, even if less developed on the nose. More discreet nose but impressively introvert. Broad on the palate but still very dry on the finish. Austere at the moment but very promising.”
“Originating from a late September harvest and disgorged at the end of 2023 with a dosage of six grams per liter, Krug’s 1996 Brut Collection presents itself with a golden-yellow hue, offering up a rich bouquet of honeycomb, espresso roast and dried apricot mingled with quince and lemon oil, followed by a medium- to full-bodied palate that is layered and structured around a vintage-typical incisive spine of acidity. Though more civilized than is often the case in this vaunted vintage, it concludes with a saline, lemon-tinged finish. It represents an aromatically mature bottle that will delight lovers of older Champagne and serves its purpose by offering a wine of impeccable provenance; yet even if one might reasonably expect its evolution to have followed a somewhat different trajectory from that of the original release owing to its late disgorgement, there is little reason to defer opening it, as it is already drinking at great generosity.”
“Full-on – typical Krug style with the anticipated wood-influenced, mature characters. Almost orange/amber in hue. Marmalade and toast! Distinct mushroom, savoury flavours on the finish. Certainly intriguing but more of an intellectual exercise to taste, rather than one primarily about enjoyment.”
“Tasted blind. Pale tawny. Masses of evolution and depth. Bruised apples and some tarte-Tatin juice on the nose. Rich on the palate. Really broad and majestic with relatively low acid. This was a bit soft and was disgorged some time ago. It was in the comforting rather than energising spectrum. ”
More Reviews +
97/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Nov 2013
“Very racy and tightly knit, this shows beautiful focus on the details, from the lacy texture to the vibrant acidity to the notes of cardamom and tea rose accenting finely meshed flavors of freshly ground coffee, honeycomb, kumquat, oyster shell and a hint of dried apricot.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2015
“It’s Friday, and that can only mean one thing. Champagne. This bottle of the 1989 Krug Collection is one of the very best I have had. The 1989 Collection is variable in quality, and quite a few examples have been on the mature side. Not this bottle. Its flavors are bright, focused and fresh for a Champagne of this age, with the classic super-fine Krug texture that invites a second glass and then a third as we look over the menu.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Oct 2016
“The 1989 Krug Collection is a wine with an uneven track record. This bottle is one of the finer examples I have had. Fully mature flavors of hazelnut, tobacco, smoke, licorice and dried fruits all make an appearance, while some of the more mushroomy elements found in some bottles are, thankfully, missing. At its best, the 1989 is a delicious Champagne, but it is not built for too much more aging from here on out.”
95/100
Roger Voss,
Wineenthusiast.com,
May 2014
“This is a classic food Champagne, hugely rich, toasty, generous. Yes, there is acidity and minerality, but these individual factors are less important than the overall opulence of this intense wine. It is still amazingly young, fresh and vibrant, but also so powerful.”
96/100
David Schildknecht,
Thewineadvocate.com,
Nov 2013
“The mingling of saline, nutty, and caramelized notes in the nose – adumbrating this wine’s entire performance – is gorgeous. Butter-toasted hazelnuts, dried wild mushrooms, kelp, and cocoa mingle in a silken, mouthwateringly saline and savory matrix reminiscent of oyster liquor laced with fresh lemon juice (because, there is still a youthfully citric store of energy here). This finishes with correspondingly pronounced umami and with tangy vibrancy of citrus and salt. After a day open, the nutty elements become more piquant and walnut-like, but the smoky hints of oxidation remain balanced by citric and mineral elements and positively integrated into a mysteriously diverse show. The palate becomes plusher (perhaps in part due to diminishing mousse) and creamy in an almost whipped-cream fashion, yet the long finish continues to offer uncanny refreshment. ”
“The 1988 Collection is at that magical place where Champagne starts to become more vinous and wine-like. Apricot, chamomile, graphite, mint and lightly honeyed notes gradually open with a bit of time in the glass. Gracious and understated, with silky contours and exceptional finesse, the 1988 is a total knock-out. Krug ID: 417035.”
“ID 212018. Disgorged spring 2016. 44% Pinot Noir, 33% Chardonnay, 23% Pinot Meunier. Named ‘Luminous Freshness’. Based on 2004. The beautiful weather in harvest time from mid September to early October made 2004 a generous year following the challenging extremes and limited yields of 2003. This is a blend of 121 wines from 12 different years, the oldest from 1990 and the youngest from 2004.
Very broad and ripe. Much less tense than most. Very accessible. Masses of bruised fruit pleasure. Much less freshness than most. And a little shorter? This tasted relatively mature.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“ID 214031. This will be re-released this year along with Krug 2004. The re-release will have had longer on the lees than the original release. The re-release may be disgorged later than the sample on which this very enthusiastic tasting note is based.
Smooth and jazzy and utterly swallowable. Long and richly savoury. Fabulous! Open. Perfect now. Rich and exciting.
Drink 2014-2024”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Lightly floral nose. Dry and a little chewy and austere. Very Krug! Quite intellectual and demanding.
Drink 2016 - 2024”
96/100
Michael Edwards ,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2017
“A real firework of a Grande Cuvée set around the 2004 base, with intricacy from 12 different vintages in total dating back to 1990. A panoply of toasted bread, apple blossom, fresh peach, pear and dried apricot, followed by sensuous notes of almond, ginger and sweet spices. Beautiful mature Chardonnay and multiple expressions of Meunier beyond earthiness, richness with delicacy and vibrant freshness. Perfect now. The Champion today. Disgorged Spring 2012.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“This is the 160th creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 212018, based on the 2004 vintage. The oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2004 with 121 wines from 12 vintages. Reserve wines this year lend harmony, completing the blend without modifying the predominant characteristics of the year. 44% Pinot Noir, 33% Chardonnay, 23% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged spring 2012.
Tasted blind. Really exciting nose. Deep gold. Lots of evolution. Mellow, burnished, savoury gold. Great balance. Smoky. Racy. But broader than wine number 5 (which was the Krug vintage 2002 in this blind line-up). Solid but not inspiring. Not that long. Lots of pace. And length. Vintage wine. Savoury end. ”
“ID 312036. 134 wines. Original disgorgement. Kept on cork for re-release.
Complex, intellectual nose with a sort of burnished gold impression.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“This is the 161st creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 312036, based on the 2005 vintage, the oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2005 with 134 wines from 12 vintages to make the Krug signature Grande Cuveé. Reserve wines this year bring brightness, richness and depth to the year's blend, mainly through very beautiful old Chardonnays and multiple expressions of Meunier from different years. 44% Pinot Noir, 37% Chardonnay, 19% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged summer 2012.
Tasted blind. Fizzy and tight. But not one of the densest or finest. Based on 2005? Neat bead. Well sculpted rather than dramatic. Lots of youth and acidity. But good balance.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“The NV Grande Cuvée is absolutely stellar. This is one of the very best Grande Cuvées I can remember tasting. The flavors are bright, focused and beautifully delineated throughout, all of which make me think the wine will age well for many, many years. Lemon peel, white flowers, crisp pears, smoke and crushed rocks race across the palate in a vibrant, tense Champagne that epitomizes finesse. This release is based on the 2005 vintage and was disgorged in winter 2012/2013. The blend is: 44% Pinot Noir, 37% Chardonnay and 19% Meunier. Krug ID: 113001.”
95/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“Krug’s NV Brut Grande Cuvee ID 112001 -- disgorged already over the winter of 2011-2012 but then further aged before release -- reinforces the belief that, thankfully, even wine lovers of modest means who occasionally splurge on Krug Grande Cuvee will be rewarded with a wine that need not fear comparison with this house’s more limited and far more expensive bottlings, nor for that matter with any other wines of Champagne. The harmonious juxtaposition of creaminess and lees enrichment with bright, juicy citricity and of expansive richness with levity is stunning....Citrus zest notes segue seamlessly into the fine stream of CO2 without bitterness, while succulent white peach garlanded in lily-of-the-valley is laced with rich, subtly piquant nut oils and saliva-liberating salinity. Emerging suggestions of shitake and shrimp shell reduction compound the sense of capital-'U' umami in a vibrantly interactive and refreshing finish. A day after opening, this is even more vividly complex than it had been initially, with hints of fresh red raspberry lending an invigorating tang and sensation of berry seed-crunching that delivers strikingly harmonious counterpoint to both the luscious brightness of fruit and the nutty low-tones....The team at Krug has long taken pains to emphasize that the task of assembling their Grande Cuvee from a hundred or more lots reflecting reserves of widely varying ages is mind-bogglingly complex. So is the result.”
“ID 416037.
Very direct and flirtatious – this goes straight up the nose. Solid, fine and very firm, correct and well integrated.”
More Reviews +
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“This is the 162nd creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 214032, which is based on the 2006 vintage. The oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2006, with 142 wines from 11 vintages. Reserve wines lend structure and depth to this season's harvest, which seemed to be somewhat too homogeneous. It is this year's wines of many plots from the villages of Mesnil-sur-Oger, Avize and Villers Mamery which proved the shine and minerality to the blend. 44% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay, 21% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged spring 2014.
Tasted blind. Rich nose, really quite creamy and opulent on the nose. Very slight edge of decay, but in a nice way. A tad soft; relatively low acid. Slightly lazy bead. Medium persistence. ”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2016
“ID 313054. Magnum. Disgorged summer 2013. 44% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay, 21% Pinot Meunier. Based on 2006 with reserves going back to 1990. 142 different wines!
Mid straw. Intense nose demands attention. Savoury. Pretty explosive texture. Bone-dry finish. This is so different from – more complex than – most champagnes! A wine to contemplate that works towards the finish like a great burgundy, but it’s definitely not mouthwash for a big reception. Very long. 12%”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2014
“The code on this bottle is 213018, meaning it was the 18th disgorgement of the second quarter of 2013 (obvious, innit?!). And those disgorgements are not necessarily just of Grande Cuvée. This blend is apparently based on the 2006 vintage and contains no fewer than 142 different ingredients back to a drop of 1990. Very steely and 'mineral' on the nose. Tight and very dense. Still very uptight - even slightly austere at this early point in its evolution. Drink 2015-2022.”
17.5/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2014
“ID code: 413073, disgorged Oct 2013. Immensely rich on the nose, verging on apricot and quince but with the sweetness of brioche. Opens up to gingerbread. Big and bold and creamy on the palate, tasting softer than the Dom Pérignon 2004 that preceded it. Bright and crisp and zesty on the finish, fresher than I expected from the nose.”
“ID 215031. A blend of 183 wines.
Broad, putty nose with real spice and interest. Middle-aged. Rich. I will resist anthropomorphism here.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“The is the 163rd creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 315051, which is based on the 2007 vintage. The oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2007 with 183 wines from 12 vintages. In this early-harvest year aromas were more impressive than taste. Thus the reserve wines lend the complexity, roundness, body and length which were missing. 37% Pinot Noir, 32% Chardonnay, 31% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged spring 2014.
Tasted blind. Mellow nose. Savoury and almost meat and two vegy. Very firm. Marked acidity. Throat-warming finish. Very fine peacock’s tail finish. Edgy and youthful and very good. A second taste suggests it falls away a little. And it’s a tad dry on the end. Could this be based on 2006?”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Quite a mature nose with less drive than some other Éditions. Fully evolved without obvious acidity. Good for now, fully mature. Long.
Drink 2020– 2028”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“The NV Grand Cuvée 163 Edition is wonderfully open-knit and giving, qualities that make it a terrific choice for drinking now and over the next 30 or so years. Pastry, apricot, lemon confit, chamomile and white flowers, along with soft contours, give the wine its inviting, alluring personality. There is more than enough energy and overall freshness to support several decades of fine drinking. Even so, the 163 is virtually impossible to resist at this early stage.”
94/100
Jamie Goode,
WineAnorak.com,
Nov 2016
“12% alcohol. Disgorged summer 2014, oldest wine 1990, base wine 2007, seven years on lees, 12 different vintages. Complex and intense; lemony, appley and herby. Lots of flavour here with bracing freshness and notes of toast, citrus pith, grapefruit and herbs. There’s a sweet toffee and toast note adding richness, but the core of this wine is linear, intense, citrussy fruit. Still quite primary, this will blossom into all out toasty richness with a bit of time in bottle. Very tight now, and tighter than I’d expect from Krug. ”
95/100
Alison Napjus ,
WineSpectator.com,
Oct 2016
“This mouthwatering Champagne shows a lovely sense of finesse, with firm acidity deftly married to a rich profile of crème de cassis, toasted brioche and lime blossom, accented by hints of café au lait, singed orange peel and exotic spice. Long and plush on the finish. Disgorged 2014. Drink now through 2024. ”
95/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2016
“Beguiling complex colour of twinkling green/gold lights. Inimitably Krug, masterly blending. The Chardonnay scents are at once refined yet dripping in the aroma of crunchy Williams pears. Discreet notes of vanilla, crème pâtissière, spiced lemon and brioche. Then a mouthfeel of body and heft; great Pinot Noir that is miraculously filigreed and ethereal, plus Pinot Meunier succulence. Like no other Champagne.”
“A stellar Champagne, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 164ème Édition, (2008 base vintage) is painfully tight. The 164 is a fabulous wine, but readers should not fall into the temptation of opening a bottle anytime soon. Crushed rocks, slate, mint, sage and white pepper lend striking aromatic brightness. The 164 is just as compelling as it has always been. Even so, it needs time to be at its very best. The 164 is a blend based on 2008, with reserve wines back to 1990. Krug ID: 316031.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Lovely now – in cool, calm middle age. Very complete. Just right at this point in its development, being very relaxed and confident.
Drink 2019– 2030”
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Based on the 2008 vintage complemented by some 22% reserve wines, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 164ème Édition opens in the glass with notes of warm bread, crisp yellow orchard fruit, mandarin, buttered toast and smoke. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and textural, it's rich and vinous but incisive, with fine depth at the core, tangy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. More complete than its vintaged sibling in 2008, it does share some of the latter's reserve and is still a few years from its peak, even if it's already approachable with great pleasure now.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Based on 2008. Very dense mouthful with a significantly dry finish. Decidedly intellectual rather than a wine for glugging.
Drink 2017-2025”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Tasted blind. Strange coconut/Hawaiian Tropic smell. Mouth-filling, serious, savoury wine. Earnest – trying hard early. Well balanced and very youthful with lots of interest and detail. Good stuff.
Drink 2017-2025”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
essiavellan.com,
Apr 2017
“Deep, brilliant gold-hued colour. Expressive, stylishly oak-lined, brioche, apple, and honey nose with luscious vanilla and perky spicy complexity. Voluptious and intense the palate is particularly firm and feisty with beautiful vivacity and tight acid line. Elegant, detailed and packed with life.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“Krug's NV Grand Cuvée 164 Edition is a total knockout. Based on the 2008 vintage, the 164th Edition shows all the crystalline tension and energy that is such a signature of the year. At times, the 164 reminds me of the 2008 vins clairs I tasted after harvest. The flavors are brisk, delineated and pulsing with energy, while the more oxidative notes that are such a signature of Krug Champagnes are not especially evident. A wine of total pedigree and class, the 164 reminds me of some of the great Grand Cuvées of the 1960s and 1970s I have been lucky to taste over the years. No Champagne lover will want to be without this spectacular, captivating wine. All that said, readers should be patient, as the 164 is painfully young, austere and in need of serious cellaring.”
“A stellar Champagne, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 164ème Édition, (2008 base vintage) is painfully tight. The 164 is a fabulous wine, but readers should not fall into the temptation of opening a bottle anytime soon. Crushed rocks, slate, mint, sage and white pepper lend striking aromatic brightness. The 164 is just as compelling as it has always been. Even so, it needs time to be at its very best. The 164 is a blend based on 2008, with reserve wines back to 1990. Krug ID: 316031.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Lovely now – in cool, calm middle age. Very complete. Just right at this point in its development, being very relaxed and confident.
Drink 2019– 2030”
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Based on the 2008 vintage complemented by some 22% reserve wines, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 164ème Édition opens in the glass with notes of warm bread, crisp yellow orchard fruit, mandarin, buttered toast and smoke. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and textural, it's rich and vinous but incisive, with fine depth at the core, tangy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. More complete than its vintaged sibling in 2008, it does share some of the latter's reserve and is still a few years from its peak, even if it's already approachable with great pleasure now.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Based on 2008. Very dense mouthful with a significantly dry finish. Decidedly intellectual rather than a wine for glugging.
Drink 2017-2025”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Tasted blind. Strange coconut/Hawaiian Tropic smell. Mouth-filling, serious, savoury wine. Earnest – trying hard early. Well balanced and very youthful with lots of interest and detail. Good stuff.
Drink 2017-2025”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
essiavellan.com,
Apr 2017
“Deep, brilliant gold-hued colour. Expressive, stylishly oak-lined, brioche, apple, and honey nose with luscious vanilla and perky spicy complexity. Voluptious and intense the palate is particularly firm and feisty with beautiful vivacity and tight acid line. Elegant, detailed and packed with life.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“Krug's NV Grand Cuvée 164 Edition is a total knockout. Based on the 2008 vintage, the 164th Edition shows all the crystalline tension and energy that is such a signature of the year. At times, the 164 reminds me of the 2008 vins clairs I tasted after harvest. The flavors are brisk, delineated and pulsing with energy, while the more oxidative notes that are such a signature of Krug Champagnes are not especially evident. A wine of total pedigree and class, the 164 reminds me of some of the great Grand Cuvées of the 1960s and 1970s I have been lucky to taste over the years. No Champagne lover will want to be without this spectacular, captivating wine. All that said, readers should be patient, as the 164 is painfully young, austere and in need of serious cellaring.”
“Based on 2009. ID 416036. To be launched at the end of 2017 in the UK, US and France and embargoed until December 2017. This is the smallest, rarest batch ever for Grande Cuvée because of caution instilled by the economic crisis. In one year they will have three editions (163, 164 and 165) because 2008 and 2009 won’t be enough for one year’s sales! (They ensured that the 163rd edition will last longer.) Some of the 166th, made in much bigger quantity, is already being prepared for next year. Wines are from 2009 back to 1990. 127 wines from 12 different years.
Very pale with a heady nose and some richness. Firm and flirtatious with a really solid, ripe undertow. More hedonistic than many Krugs.”
“ID 217017. A blend of 140 wines.
Savoury, rather Puligny-like nose. Very, very fresh, real zest on the palate which seems more youthful than the nose. Very punchy and fresh. Seems more youthful than the 167th Edition.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Neal Martin,
Vinous.com,
Jan 2019
“The sommelier team is led by the excellent Gareth Ferreira MS, ex-67 Pall Mall. Upon arrival, he kindly pours a glass of Krug Grand Cuvée 166ème Édition, based on the 2010 vintage and blended from 13 harvests from 1998 onwards. It is the perfect way to begin. The nose of vibrant citrus fruit, brioche and yellow flowers is slightly yeasty in style but beautifully defined. That yeastiness transfers across to a weighty but balanced palate, which offers depth and grip with a bit of viscosity, and richness reined in by acidity. A touch of orange zest and hazelnut emerges on the finish, along with sufficient salinity to urge you back for another sip.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2018
“100% grand cru vineyards. 45% Pinot Noir, 39% Chardonnay, 16% Pinot Meunier. Base vintage 2010 and 42% reserve wine. Seven years' ageing on lees. Disgorged winter 2017. Dosage 6 g/l.
Tasted blind. Lemon yellow. Putty note. Deep straw. Rather yeasty nose with quite a bit of age in evidence. A little loosely textured with a very savoury note. Finishes very dry. Tense.
Drink 2017-2029”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The MV Grande Cuvée 166ème, based on the 2010 vintage, offers good depth, but it also comes across as a bit angular and in need of time in bottle to soften. Certainly, next to the 2008 and 2009 editions, the 2010 is a touch rough around the edges. Even so, there is good freshness and verve to the bright citrus, mineral and floral flavors. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Strongly citrus – smells of lemon. Really rich underneath with a suggestion of burnished metal. Lots of personality! Julie Cavil acknowledged that it was difficult to get the blend right. It’s tasting really well now. Positively mellow in fact!”
18+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
The Finest Bubble,
May 2018
“A forward aromatic of orange blossom along with ripe apple and lemon fruits and hints of spice and ginger. The palate is an abundance of flavour with multi layers of hazelnut, almonds, dried lemon, almonds and just starting to show some of that creamy brioche with hints of honey. Strong and fresh mouth-feel that distinctive creamy Krug mouth-feel. All in all another great edition showing champagne based on a weak harvest can with careful selection and high quality reserves wines be very good.”
“ID 217017. A blend of 140 wines.
Savoury, rather Puligny-like nose. Very, very fresh, real zest on the palate which seems more youthful than the nose. Very punchy and fresh. Seems more youthful than the 167th Edition.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Neal Martin,
Vinous.com,
Jan 2019
“The sommelier team is led by the excellent Gareth Ferreira MS, ex-67 Pall Mall. Upon arrival, he kindly pours a glass of Krug Grand Cuvée 166ème Édition, based on the 2010 vintage and blended from 13 harvests from 1998 onwards. It is the perfect way to begin. The nose of vibrant citrus fruit, brioche and yellow flowers is slightly yeasty in style but beautifully defined. That yeastiness transfers across to a weighty but balanced palate, which offers depth and grip with a bit of viscosity, and richness reined in by acidity. A touch of orange zest and hazelnut emerges on the finish, along with sufficient salinity to urge you back for another sip.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2018
“100% grand cru vineyards. 45% Pinot Noir, 39% Chardonnay, 16% Pinot Meunier. Base vintage 2010 and 42% reserve wine. Seven years' ageing on lees. Disgorged winter 2017. Dosage 6 g/l.
Tasted blind. Lemon yellow. Putty note. Deep straw. Rather yeasty nose with quite a bit of age in evidence. A little loosely textured with a very savoury note. Finishes very dry. Tense.
Drink 2017-2029”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The MV Grande Cuvée 166ème, based on the 2010 vintage, offers good depth, but it also comes across as a bit angular and in need of time in bottle to soften. Certainly, next to the 2008 and 2009 editions, the 2010 is a touch rough around the edges. Even so, there is good freshness and verve to the bright citrus, mineral and floral flavors. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Strongly citrus – smells of lemon. Really rich underneath with a suggestion of burnished metal. Lots of personality! Julie Cavil acknowledged that it was difficult to get the blend right. It’s tasting really well now. Positively mellow in fact!”
18+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
The Finest Bubble,
May 2018
“A forward aromatic of orange blossom along with ripe apple and lemon fruits and hints of spice and ginger. The palate is an abundance of flavour with multi layers of hazelnut, almonds, dried lemon, almonds and just starting to show some of that creamy brioche with hints of honey. Strong and fresh mouth-feel that distinctive creamy Krug mouth-feel. All in all another great edition showing champagne based on a weak harvest can with careful selection and high quality reserves wines be very good.”
“The NV Grande Cuvée 167ème Édition, based on the 2011 vintage, shows just how much can be accomplished in Champagne through the art of the blend. This release includes 191 wines back to 1995 and a relatively low presence (42%) of the base year. But its the whole that counts more than the sum of the parts. In fact, I prefer this wine to the 2011 Vintage. All the elements are so nicely balanced. Citrus, white flowers, mint, white pepper and slate are some of the many notes that build in the glass. Disgorged: Summer 2018. Krug ID: 318036.”
More Reviews +
94+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“Krug’s NV Grande Cuvée 167ème Edition is positively brilliant. Chef de Caves Eric Lebel and his team have always put tremendous emphasis on the craft of blending. Never has that discipline been more critical than here, with the 167, which is based on 2011, one of the most challenging harvests in Champagne in many years. Brisk and racy in the glass, the 167 is laced with a range of lemon peel, baked apple, brioche and floral notes. Readers should plan on giving the 167 at least a few years in bottle, as it is presently tightly wound and not at all expressive. The flavors are beautifully articulated. In many releases, the Grande Cuvée is richer and more overt. The 167, on the other hand, is airy, weightless and sublime. Most importantly, it is an unqualified success. This release is based on 2011, with reserve wines back to 1995.”
18.5+
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jul 2024
“Having tasting this champagne a few times in the last year I am again blown away with how bright, fresh and unctuous it shows. The fruit is transitioning to all those dried fruit characters, the full spectrum of citrus, especially grapefruit and bitter orange interlaced with that soft creamy aroma that is like toasted and lightly cinnamoned buttered bread. The texture is velvety soft, real rich fruits on the palate, with the balance of intensity yet a floaty lightness on the finish. Based on 58% wines from 2011, an awkward climate year, a perfect example of Joseph’s vision that with careful selection you can make fabulous champagne every year even when the weather isn’t kind. Those 42% reserve wines bring power and density, yet with a lightness of touch. Excellent!”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“ID 118008. This is the wine reaching the market now. A blend of 191 different wines.
Definitely richer than many Grandes Cuvées. Very appealing and approachable. Those many elements are already admirably well integrated. Hugely complex but still quite substantially chewy on the end. Very long.”
95+/100
William Kelley,
WineAdvocate.com,
Apr 2019
“Making its debut this year is Krugs NV Grande Cuvée 167ème Édition, a beautiful wine that wafts from the glass with aromas of yellow orchard fruit, peach and waxy citrus rind, complemented by complex notes of freshly baked bread, walnuts and smoke. On the palate, the wine is full-bodied and muscular but incisive, with a deep and concentrated core, a pinpoint mousse and a long, complex finish. Built around the 2011 vintage, the wine includes reserve wines dating back to 1995 and was disgorged in the winter of 2017-2018. Readers are advised to give it at least a couple years of bottle age before popping corks. 2020 - 2045”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
Mar 2024
“In the challenging 2011 it took the winemaking team 191 individual wines to create Grand Cuvée. Thus, truly a full expression, 13 years’ wines were assembled together with 1995 being the oldest component in the blend. With some five years after disgorgement, this wine shows beautifully fragrant with honey-toned orchard fruit and lemon nose with a cool menthol breeze. It is truly detailed with rare a delicacy to it. The palate continues on the same elegant path or airy seamlessness and lively persistence. A master piece of blending. Krug ID 318034 tasted.”
“A blend of 52% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay and 13% Meunier, it took 198 different wines from 11 years to craft Joseph Krug’s dream wine, ‘the fullest expression of Champagne in one glass’. Chef de cave Julie remembers following the great 1996 Verzenay reserve wine in the tanks since the onset of her Krug career in 2006, and she says she felt emotional when the time came to include it in the 2012 blend as its oldest component among the 42% of reserve wines. She feels that some of the wine’s beeswax richness originates from that special wine. My first taste was from bottle with Krug ID 219012 (so disgorged in the spring of 2019). Refined yet expressive nose with richness of ripe stone fruits, candied lemon, baked apple and ginger reaching the nose first, followed by a gentle spiciness for fresh oak wood. Time in the glass brings forward layers of charismatic and complex brioche, yeast and honeycomb tones. On the palate it is even surprisingly tight and focused, with its brisk, saline acidity lining the fine, ripe and pure fruitiness. Less approachable upon launch than some editions, but it’s every drop just oozes ageing capacity. A keeper. ”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2020
“This is the latest cuvée launched in the UK in May 2020 but has already been available in the US and Japan. A blend of 198 wines from 11 different years, with the youngest the acclaimed 2012, back to a precious, powerfully aromatic lot of Verzenay Pinot Noir 1996. The final blend – 52% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay and 13% Meunier – was bottled in 2013 and aged for seven years in Krug’s cellars in Reims. Yields in 2012 were 20% lower than usual because of a succession of meteorological events including frost, rain, storms and hail in winter and spring 2012, followed by the driest ripening season since 1974.|
Notably intense aroma with crème pâtissière dominant. Masses of extract and remarkable acidity underpinned by great depth of flavour and beautiful balance on the finish. I think this is going to be a really great, glamorous Grande Cuvée that will continue to develop in bottle for many years to come. I suspect it will be even more enjoyable from the end of 2020. The length on the palate is remarkable. This is magnificently precise, a great tribute to the work of the old cellarmaster Eric Lebel, who is still in the background, and a wonderful welcome to his successor Julie Cavil, who has been learning from him since 2006.”
98/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2020
“Light golden yellow, silver reflections; very fine, persistent mousse. Multi-faceted bouquet of yellow stone fruit, brioche, candied orange zest, blossom honey and almond cake, floral nuances in the background. Substantial on the palate, silky, pronounced in fruit texture, fine hazelnut nuances, light chocolate, finesse, rich acidity, very elegant and well-balanced; on the finish accents of oranges and nougat, mineral-salty touch on the back palate with echoes of fine honey. A versatile food wine with great development potential.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
May 2020
“Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 168ème Édition is a classic in the making, wafting from the glass with aromas of dried fruits, pear, toasted nuts, orange zest, honeycomb and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, generous but incisive, it's deep and elegantly fleshy, with a beautifully refined mousse and an enveloping core of fruit that's complemented by the characteristic Krug patina of nutty complexity imparted by barrel fermentation. Even if this is more open out of the gates than the 2011-based 167ème edition, the 168ème edition is also the more concentrated and intense of the two. It's based on the 2012 harvest, complemented by fully 42% reserve wines—a blend of 198 wines from 11 different vintages dating back to 1996.”
96/100
Roger Voss,
wineenthusiast.com,
Nov 2020
“In line with the producer's practice of numbering each bottling of its flagship Grande Cuvée, this is the latest release. Following the house style, there is some marvelously impressive Pinot Noir in this rich, full blend. That gives the Champagne its luxurious feel, contrasting with the tension from the dryness and minerality. This bottling, which shows maturity, is ready to drink.”
97/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Nov 2020
“A beautiful Champagne, yet one that needs bottle age, the NV Grand Cuvee 168ème Edition comes mostly from the 2012 vintage (a good vintage) and has gorgeous apple blossom and stone fruits intermixed with classic Krug toasted brioche, toasted almond, white flowers, and honeysuckle aromatics. Just gorgeous on the palate as well, it's concentrated and has a rich, backward texture, bright acidity, and great finish. It takes lots of air to show at its best today, but do your best to hide bottles for 3-4 years. You'll be rewarded and it will evolve gracefully for another two decades or more.”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Nov 2020
“A seamless Champagne, effortlessly integrating a powerful spine of racy acidity with the detailed range of crème de cassis, raw almond, toasted saffron and candied ginger flavors. This is fine and silky in texture, with a tang of salty mineral and rich hints of coffee, toasted brioche and mandarin orange peel expanding on the finish. Disgorged winter 2018. Drink now through 2030.”
“Candied lemon on the nose comes with a spicy, lovely overtone of oak moss, ozone and lifted lemon brightness. The palate comes in with briskness, with a kind of slenderness that seems to open up into depth rather then breadth. There is an incisive, beautiful vein of vivid citric freshness, a well of brightness, but also with a real sense of pithiness. Absolutely streamlined, taut, vivid with a real sense of cool, profound chalkiness and that enduring lemon zest and savoury nori seaweed note. Beautiful and very long.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“Deep copper gold. Tiny, tiny bead. Much more obvious acidity, age and (lightly oaky?) savour on the nose than Cristal 2013. Aérien with blossomy notes with a little mandarin. Very marked acidity on the palate. A real wake-up call! Sleek and fresh and truly spring-like with a light yeasty note on the very long finish. The most pleasure to be had initially is in the nose and the finish. The palate is still a bit of shock. This should have a long life. Bone-dry finish and playing the intellectual card. Throbs on the palate with all its vibrancy. Long. Tighter than the 168ème Édition. Structure dominates fruit.”
96+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Based on the 2013 vintage and complemented by some 40% reserve wines dating back to 2000, Krug's newly released NV Grande Cuvée 169ème Édition is showing very nicely, unfurling in the glass with notes of citrus oil, buttered toast, dried apricot, warm biscuits and marmalade. Medium to full-bodied, deep and incisive, it's a tauter, more chiseled rendition of Grande Cuvée by comparison with the richer, more textural and more demonstrative 168ème Édition (based on the 2012 vintage) that preceded it; but its bright spine of acidity is nicely cloaked in fruit. Concluding with a long and sapid finish, this is a very classically balanced Champagne that will reward bottle age”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 169ème Édition is brisk and finely cut, with terrific energy driving the citrus, floral and light tropical notes. Even with all of its energy, the 169 balances the vibrancy of the late-ripening 2013 vintage it is built on, with the depth that the reserve wines added to the blend. The 169 drinks well now but clearly has the potential to age. The 169 is a blend of 146 separate wines back to 2000. Krug ID: 120003. ”
17++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Still pretty tight and introvert but a bit more advanced than a year ago – though still extremely youthful. An embryonic wine with a great future. Massively dense and complex.”
96-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2021
“Based on the 2013 vintage, Grande Cuvée really wears the year’s signature with its radiant and racy fruit profile and amplified, saline length. The fine base year is supported by 40% of reserve wines from 10 different vintages all the way down to 2000. The expressive, stylishly oak lined nose comes with delicious fresh fruity profile. Complex and overt already upon launch. The palate is tighter with real vibrancy to it. Pure fruitiness and firm structure of tension, this edition is a keeper.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2026
“One of the greatest hits of this label, Krug’s NV Grande Cuvée 169ème Édition continues to drink beautifully. Built around the 2013 harvest and incorporating 40% reserve wines dating back to 2000, it emerges from the glass with an aromatic spectrum of lemon oil, nashi pear and fresh apricot mingled with notions of almond paste, crème brûlée and burnt buttered toast. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, ample yet incisive, with a deep core of fruit, a bright spine of acidity and chalky structuring extract, concluding with a long, saline finish. Disgorged in early 2021 with a dosage of five grams per liter, it is beginning to pay the dividends that bottle age brings and should continue to develop very nicely. It is also—unsurprisingly, given the inclusion of a substantial reserve-wine component—more demonstrative than the 2013 Brut bottling.”
“Candied lemon on the nose comes with a spicy, lovely overtone of oak moss, ozone and lifted lemon brightness. The palate comes in with briskness, with a kind of slenderness that seems to open up into depth rather then breadth. There is an incisive, beautiful vein of vivid citric freshness, a well of brightness, but also with a real sense of pithiness. Absolutely streamlined, taut, vivid with a real sense of cool, profound chalkiness and that enduring lemon zest and savoury nori seaweed note. Beautiful and very long.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“Deep copper gold. Tiny, tiny bead. Much more obvious acidity, age and (lightly oaky?) savour on the nose than Cristal 2013. Aérien with blossomy notes with a little mandarin. Very marked acidity on the palate. A real wake-up call! Sleek and fresh and truly spring-like with a light yeasty note on the very long finish. The most pleasure to be had initially is in the nose and the finish. The palate is still a bit of shock. This should have a long life. Bone-dry finish and playing the intellectual card. Throbs on the palate with all its vibrancy. Long. Tighter than the 168ème Édition. Structure dominates fruit.”
96+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Based on the 2013 vintage and complemented by some 40% reserve wines dating back to 2000, Krug's newly released NV Grande Cuvée 169ème Édition is showing very nicely, unfurling in the glass with notes of citrus oil, buttered toast, dried apricot, warm biscuits and marmalade. Medium to full-bodied, deep and incisive, it's a tauter, more chiseled rendition of Grande Cuvée by comparison with the richer, more textural and more demonstrative 168ème Édition (based on the 2012 vintage) that preceded it; but its bright spine of acidity is nicely cloaked in fruit. Concluding with a long and sapid finish, this is a very classically balanced Champagne that will reward bottle age”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 169ème Édition is brisk and finely cut, with terrific energy driving the citrus, floral and light tropical notes. Even with all of its energy, the 169 balances the vibrancy of the late-ripening 2013 vintage it is built on, with the depth that the reserve wines added to the blend. The 169 drinks well now but clearly has the potential to age. The 169 is a blend of 146 separate wines back to 2000. Krug ID: 120003. ”
17++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Still pretty tight and introvert but a bit more advanced than a year ago – though still extremely youthful. An embryonic wine with a great future. Massively dense and complex.”
96-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2021
“Based on the 2013 vintage, Grande Cuvée really wears the year’s signature with its radiant and racy fruit profile and amplified, saline length. The fine base year is supported by 40% of reserve wines from 10 different vintages all the way down to 2000. The expressive, stylishly oak lined nose comes with delicious fresh fruity profile. Complex and overt already upon launch. The palate is tighter with real vibrancy to it. Pure fruitiness and firm structure of tension, this edition is a keeper.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2026
“One of the greatest hits of this label, Krug’s NV Grande Cuvée 169ème Édition continues to drink beautifully. Built around the 2013 harvest and incorporating 40% reserve wines dating back to 2000, it emerges from the glass with an aromatic spectrum of lemon oil, nashi pear and fresh apricot mingled with notions of almond paste, crème brûlée and burnt buttered toast. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, ample yet incisive, with a deep core of fruit, a bright spine of acidity and chalky structuring extract, concluding with a long, saline finish. Disgorged in early 2021 with a dosage of five grams per liter, it is beginning to pay the dividends that bottle age brings and should continue to develop very nicely. It is also—unsurprisingly, given the inclusion of a substantial reserve-wine component—more demonstrative than the 2013 Brut bottling.”
“A subtle nose of maple syrup and candied lemon opens up to reveal a hint of maize meal and shiitake. It leads onto a palate that is utterly streamlined and lemon-scented. This is serene but it comes with beautiful depth and a lovely note of autolysis, expressed as lemony, creamy polenta, enhanced by fine mousse. There are highlights of grapefruit zestiness with the lovely signature savouriness of Krug, expressed in just a hint of salty, grilled shiitake mushroom, revealed on the long and mouth-watering finish. A most brisk, taut, bright, but also rather subtle and profound iteration of Krug. ”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Lots of acidity! Extremely lively and brisk. But it’s actually readier than most young Grandes Cuvées I have tasted at this relatively early stage with sumptuous texture actually. Very clean and fresh. Bone dry but broachable and quite charming within the Krug ethos. Really quite friendly. One of my favourites of this line-up!”
“The NV Grande Cuvée 170ème Édition, (2014 base vintage) is rich, ample and explosive. Wonderfully fresh and vibrant, the 170 offers an exotic mélange of dried orchard fruit, pear, spice and crushed flowers. Chef de Caves Eric Lebel was not especially excited about 2014 when I saw him a few months after the harvest, as yields in Pinot Noir and Meunier were adversely affected. Perhaps for that reason the 170 contains more reserve wines than most editions. Regardless, the Krug team crafted an absolutely brilliant Grande Cuvée. The blend is 51% Pinot Noir, 38% Chardonnay and 11% Meunier, vintages 2014 through 1998. Disgorged: Autumn 2021. Krug ID: 421062.”
More Reviews +
97-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Sep 2023
“Glorious bottle with beautiful toastiness melanging perfectly with the wine's creamy qualities and oaky undernote.
Tasting note below from 01/08/2022 | 96-97/100
This Grande Cuvée Edition is a blend of 195 wines from 12 different years spanning from 1998 to 2014. The colour is rich, lemon-gold; the nose already generous, with a complex melange of apricot jam and dried fruits, sweet pastries and baking spices. The oak is notable but neatly in the background and with no oxidative tones; it lends only sweet, spicy tones and charred-wood whiffs. This is the child of a cool year, and the acidity feels accentuated, the overall impression a little lighter than on most vintages. But there is a welcome freshness cutting all that concentration and vinosity, leading to a super-long, driven and mouthwateringly fresh finish. Even if it comes with great potential, the wine is generous, laudable and already approachable now. Krug ID 221037. Dosage 6g/l”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Lots of acidity! Extremely lively and brisk. But it’s actually readier than most young Grandes Cuvées I have tasted at this relatively early stage with sumptuous texture actually. Very clean and fresh. Bone dry but broachable and quite charming within the Krug ethos. Really quite friendly. One of my favourites of this line-up!”
95/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Apr 2022
“A subtle nose of maple syrup and candied lemon opens up to reveal a hint of maize meal and shiitake. It leads onto a palate that is utterly streamlined and lemon-scented. This is serene but it comes with beautiful depth and a lovely note of autolysis, expressed as lemony, creamy polenta, enhanced by fine mousse. There are highlights of grapefruit zestiness with the lovely signature savouriness of Krug, expressed in just a hint of salty, grilled shiitake mushroom, revealed on the long and mouth-watering finish. A most brisk, taut, bright, but also rather subtle and profound iteration of Krug. ”
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2022
“Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 170ème Édition is based on the 2014 vintage, complemented by some 45% reserve wines dating back to 1998, with the house drawing on, among many others, 2013 for structure and 2012 and 2003 for generosity. Opening in the glass with aromas of pastry cream, dried fruits, pear, warm spices, freshly baked bread and vanilla pod, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and fine-boned, with excellent concentration, racy acids and a precise, chiseled profile. But if the latter adjective could be applied to the 2013-base 169ème édition equally felicitously, the 2014-base 170ème is more giving and less tightly wound out of the gates and will offer more demonstrative drinking young.”
“Light golden yellow in colour with silver reflections and a fine, delicate mousse. On the nose hints of orange zest, fine yellow apple fruit, some greengage, underpinned by fine smoky herbal spices. The palate is full-bodied with racy acidity, white peach fruit, a touch of nashi pear, and lime with a subtle salinity on the lingering finish. A balanced food wine that certainly has the potential for ageing.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Jun 2023
“The NV Grande Cuvée 171ème Edition is a delightful blend of 45% Pinot Noir, 37% Chardonnay and 18% Pinot Meunier and boasts an attractive and captivating aroma of dried fruits, pastry, lemon oil, marzipan, spring flowers and ginger, with hints of almond and vanilla notes that become more pronounced over time. This medium to full-bodied wine is precise and well-structured, with a fleshy core of fruit and a sapid, incisive finish. Crafted around the 2015 vintage, the blend comprises 131 reserve wines from as far back as 2000 (42% of the total blend) and is expected to age beautifully over the next decade.”
“The NV Grande Cuvée 172ème Édition is a gracious, sublime Champagne. Light citrus notes, white flowers, spice, marzipan and chamomile inflections all run through this delicate, nuanced Grande Cuvée. The 172eme is a Champagne of understatement and class that is very much a reflection of the base year. Brisk acids pull it all together. The Grande Cuvée is often quite accessible on release, but this is an Edition I would cellar for at least another year or two. It’s a fine effort from Krug. The 172ème Édition is a blend of 44% Pinot Noir, 30% Chardonnay and 20% Meunier based on 2016 with reserve wines back to 1998. Disgorged: Winter 2022-2023. Krug ID: 123003.”
More Reviews +
97/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Mar 2024
“Beautiful notes of dried citrus fruit, lemon curd and dried apples with hints of spices, dried flowers and subtle brioche. I like the polished and caressing texture and steady, refreshing acidity. It’s fresh and even austere, with notes of ground spices. So vertical and firm. Structured and long. Drink or hold.”
95/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“The new Krug release, the NV Grande Cuvée 172ème Édition, based on the 2016 vintage and comprising 11 vintages in total (the oldest is 1998), is outstanding. It reveals a complex, slightly spicy bouquet of white fruits, beeswax, marzipan, hazelnuts, dried herbs, ripe orchard fruits and white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, rich and concentrated on the palate, it has a subtly spicy entry, an enrobing and layered texture and a fleshy core of fruit framed around a perfectly balanced, fresh and mineral finish. Crafted primarily from Pinot Noir (44%) and complemented with 30% Chardonnay and the rest Pinot Meunier, it was disgorged in the first quarter of 2023 with a dosage of 4.5 grams per liter. Keep it for 5-10 years.”
“Based on 2017, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 173ème Édition is superb. It is an especially rich, almost opulent Grande Cuvée that very much reflects the personality of the base year in its tropical flavor profile. Lemon confit, baked apple tart, passion fruit, tangerine oil and spice are all beautifully amplified. The Krug team, led at the time by Chef de Caves Eric Lebel and current Chef de Caves Julie Cavil, did an exceptional job here. Krug ID: 124003. ”
More Reviews +
94+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2026
“Revisiting Krug’s NV Grande Cuvée 173ème Édition, it continues to evolve at a glacial pace. As I’ve written before, the base of this edition is the 2017 harvest, which makes up 69% of the blend, and the wine was disgorged in early 2024 with a dosage of 4.5 grams per liter. It opens in the glass with aromas of lemon confit, pear and golden apple mingled with notes of freshly baked bread, buttered toast and a hint of nutmeg. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, with a slightly darker-fruited profile than the 174ème Édition, underpinned by racy acids and animated by a pillowy mousse, before concluding with a long, citrus-inflected finish. It is already offering very attractive drinking.”
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Krug’s recently unveiled NV Grande Cuvée 173ème Édition—accounting for approximately 80% of the house’s total production—performs well, particularly considering the challenges of the base vintage, 2017. That year saw considerable rot pressure in red varieties, making meticulous sorting essential; some lots deemed unfit for Krug’s standards were even diverted to distillation. The conceptual cornerstone of the Grande Cuvée is the use of the house’s vast library—drawing from some 500 options—to complement the base vintage and moderate the extremes of any given growing season. The 173ème Édition comprises 150 wines across 13 vintages, with the 2017 base making up 69% of the final assemblage. Disgorged in January 2024 with a dosage of 4.5 grams per liter, it opens with aromas of pear, golden apple, lemon curd and early white blossoms interlaced with a distant hint of nutmeg. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, textural and charming, laden with tangy acidity and animated by a pillowy mousse, and it concludes with a long, saline finish. Compared with its immediate predecessor, the 173ème Édition is broader and more giving, while the 172ème Édition tauter and more incisive. As experienced Krug aficionados will recognize, the inclusion of reserve wines—which may have undergone malolactic fermentation—renders the Grande Cuvée more immediately approachable than the house’s vintage-dated Champagnes, offering a more generous drinking experience on release.”
17.5
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2025
“Based on 2017 vintage. Lots of sorting required due to a rainy harvest. Blended from 150 wines across 13 vintages back to 2001. 44% Pinot Noir, 34% Chardonnay, 22% Pinot Meunier. 31% reserve wine. Dosage 4 g/l.
Nutty, saline, yeasty nose with equal parts fresh apple and umami soy/mushroom flavours. Not yet fully expanded on the nose, with more development yet to come. The palate is more typically Krug in style, with weight, intensity and length all in place, as well as ample toastiness. Dry but not austere, with dosage doing its job to give ripeness.”
ID 212018. Disgorged spring 2016. 44% Pinot Noir, 33% Chardonnay, 23% Pinot Meunier. Named ‘Luminous Freshness’. Based on 2004. The beautiful weather in harvest time from mid September to early October made 2004 a generous year following the challenging extremes and limited yields of 2003. This is a blend of 121 wines from 12 different years, the oldest from 1990 and the youngest from 2004.
Very broad and ripe. Much less tense than most. Very accessible. Masses of bruised fruit pleasure. Much less freshness than most. And a little shorter? This tasted relatively mature.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“ID 312036. 134 wines. Original disgorgement. Kept on cork for re-release.
Complex, intellectual nose with a sort of burnished gold impression.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Based on the 2003 vintage, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 159ème Édition offers up generous aromas of toasted bread, yellow orchard fruit, mandarin oil, almond paste and candied citrus peel. Medium to full-bodied, rich and open-knit, it's elegantly fleshy, with ripe acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse, concluding with a sapid finish. Readers habituated to Krug's calling-card cut and intensity may find it a little soft and one-dimensional, but it's a creditable effort in a challenging year.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“ID 214031. This will be re-released this year along with Krug 2004. The re-release will have had longer on the lees than the original release. The re-release may be disgorged later than the sample on which this very enthusiastic tasting note is based.
Smooth and jazzy and utterly swallowable. Long and richly savoury. Fabulous! Open. Perfect now. Rich and exciting.
Drink 2014-2024”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“This is the 161st creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 312036, based on the 2005 vintage, the oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2005 with 134 wines from 12 vintages to make the Krug signature Grande Cuveé. Reserve wines this year bring brightness, richness and depth to the year's blend, mainly through very beautiful old Chardonnays and multiple expressions of Meunier from different years. 44% Pinot Noir, 37% Chardonnay, 19% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged summer 2012.
Tasted blind. Fizzy and tight. But not one of the densest or finest. Based on 2005? Neat bead. Well sculpted rather than dramatic. Lots of youth and acidity. But good balance.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“ID 215040. Made from the very small crop of 2003 back to 1988 from 120 wines. 51% Pinot Noir, 30% Chardonnay, 19% Pinot Meunier.
Pale, pungent and smoky. Great undertow, and proof that they did not get rid of their heavy wines in the Grande Cuvée.
Drink 2014-2024”
96/100
Michael Edwards ,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2017
“A real firework of a Grande Cuvée set around the 2004 base, with intricacy from 12 different vintages in total dating back to 1990. A panoply of toasted bread, apple blossom, fresh peach, pear and dried apricot, followed by sensuous notes of almond, ginger and sweet spices. Beautiful mature Chardonnay and multiple expressions of Meunier beyond earthiness, richness with delicacy and vibrant freshness. Perfect now. The Champion today. Disgorged Spring 2012.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2014
“The NV Grande Cuvée is absolutely stellar. This is one of the very best Grande Cuvées I can remember tasting. The flavors are bright, focused and beautifully delineated throughout, all of which make me think the wine will age well for many, many years. Lemon peel, white flowers, crisp pears, smoke and crushed rocks race across the palate in a vibrant, tense Champagne that epitomizes finesse. This release is based on the 2005 vintage and was disgorged in winter 2012/2013. The blend is: 44% Pinot Noir, 37% Chardonnay and 19% Meunier. Krug ID: 113001.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“This is the 159th creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 211021, which is based on the 2003 vintage. The oldest wine is from 1988 and the youngest 2003 with 120 wines from 10 vintages. Reserve wines this year, particularly ones from 1996, as well as other truly great white wines from more recent years, give spark and vitality to this year's blend. Disgorged spring 2011. Dosage 6 g/l. 51% Pinot Noir, 30% Chardonnay, 19% Pinot Meunier.
Tasted blind. Stern and extremely intense, slightly floral, lightly spicy nose. Then it faded a little soon on the end. Just slightly less vital than the others. 2005 base?”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“This is the 160th creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 212018, based on the 2004 vintage. The oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2004 with 121 wines from 12 vintages. Reserve wines this year lend harmony, completing the blend without modifying the predominant characteristics of the year. 44% Pinot Noir, 33% Chardonnay, 23% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged spring 2012.
Tasted blind. Really exciting nose. Deep gold. Lots of evolution. Mellow, burnished, savoury gold. Great balance. Smoky. Racy. But broader than wine number 5 (which was the Krug vintage 2002 in this blind line-up). Solid but not inspiring. Not that long. Lots of pace. And length. Vintage wine. Savoury end. ”
95/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“Krug’s NV Brut Grande Cuvee ID 112001 -- disgorged already over the winter of 2011-2012 but then further aged before release -- reinforces the belief that, thankfully, even wine lovers of modest means who occasionally splurge on Krug Grande Cuvee will be rewarded with a wine that need not fear comparison with this house’s more limited and far more expensive bottlings, nor for that matter with any other wines of Champagne. The harmonious juxtaposition of creaminess and lees enrichment with bright, juicy citricity and of expansive richness with levity is stunning....Citrus zest notes segue seamlessly into the fine stream of CO2 without bitterness, while succulent white peach garlanded in lily-of-the-valley is laced with rich, subtly piquant nut oils and saliva-liberating salinity. Emerging suggestions of shitake and shrimp shell reduction compound the sense of capital-'U' umami in a vibrantly interactive and refreshing finish. A day after opening, this is even more vividly complex than it had been initially, with hints of fresh red raspberry lending an invigorating tang and sensation of berry seed-crunching that delivers strikingly harmonious counterpoint to both the luscious brightness of fruit and the nutty low-tones....The team at Krug has long taken pains to emphasize that the task of assembling their Grande Cuvee from a hundred or more lots reflecting reserves of widely varying ages is mind-bogglingly complex. So is the result.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2016
“ID 313054. Magnum. Disgorged summer 2013. 44% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay, 21% Pinot Meunier. Based on 2006 with reserves going back to 1990. 142 different wines!
Mid straw. Intense nose demands attention. Savoury. Pretty explosive texture. Bone-dry finish. This is so different from – more complex than – most champagnes! A wine to contemplate that works towards the finish like a great burgundy, but it’s definitely not mouthwash for a big reception. Very long. 12%”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“ID 406001. The blend of 45% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay, 20% Pinot Meunier was based on 2000 but includes 118 wines from 10 different vintages, the oldest being 1990, the youngest 2000. Disgorged 2006.
Fresh, floral tension. Focused thought reticent on the nose. Dense with lots to chew on. A little sweetness and lots of depth.
Drink 2010-2020”
95/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2016
“Beguiling complex colour of twinkling green/gold lights. Inimitably Krug, masterly blending. The Chardonnay scents are at once refined yet dripping in the aroma of crunchy Williams pears. Discreet notes of vanilla, crème pâtissière, spiced lemon and brioche. Then a mouthfeel of body and heft; great Pinot Noir that is miraculously filigreed and ethereal, plus Pinot Meunier succulence. Like no other Champagne.
”
93/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Dec 2013
“Light yellow-gold. Highly aromatic bouquet of fresh tangerine, candied fig, pear skin and ginger, plus a smoky mineral overtone. Tangy, precise and concentrated, offering a complex blend of citrus and orchard fruit and floral flavors underscored by chalky minerality. Juicy, tightly focused, youthfully angular Champagne, with nervy acidity adding cut to the long, sappy finish. I can see why some long-time Krug fans might be perplexed by this bottling but I think that it will be a really outstanding bottle with another five-plus years of cellaring.”
“The NV Grande Cuvée is absolutely stellar. This is one of the very best Grande Cuvées I can remember tasting. The flavors are bright, focused and beautifully delineated throughout, all of which make me think the wine will age well for many, many years. Lemon peel, white flowers, crisp pears, smoke and crushed rocks race across the palate in a vibrant, tense Champagne that epitomizes finesse. This release is based on the 2005 vintage and was disgorged in winter 2012/2013. The blend is: 44% Pinot Noir, 37% Chardonnay and 19% Meunier. Krug ID: 113001.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2014
“ID code: 413073, disgorged Oct 2013. Immensely rich on the nose, verging on apricot and quince but with the sweetness of brioche. Opens up to gingerbread. Big and bold and creamy on the palate, tasting softer than the Dom Pérignon 2004 that preceded it. Bright and crisp and zesty on the finish, fresher than I expected from the nose.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2014
“The code on this bottle is 213018, meaning it was the 18th disgorgement of the second quarter of 2013 (obvious, innit?!). And those disgorgements are not necessarily just of Grande Cuvée. This blend is apparently based on the 2006 vintage and contains no fewer than 142 different ingredients back to a drop of 1990. Very steely and 'mineral' on the nose. Tight and very dense. Still very uptight - even slightly austere at this early point in its evolution. Drink 2015-2022.”
93/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Dec 2013
“Light yellow-gold. Highly aromatic bouquet of fresh tangerine, candied fig, pear skin and ginger, plus a smoky mineral overtone. Tangy, precise and concentrated, offering a complex blend of citrus and orchard fruit and floral flavors underscored by chalky minerality. Juicy, tightly focused, youthfully angular Champagne, with nervy acidity adding cut to the long, sappy finish. I can see why some long-time Krug fans might be perplexed by this bottling but I think that it will be a really outstanding bottle with another five-plus years of cellaring.”
95/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“Krug’s NV Brut Grande Cuvee ID 112001 -- disgorged already over the winter of 2011-2012 but then further aged before release -- reinforces the belief that, thankfully, even wine lovers of modest means who occasionally splurge on Krug Grande Cuvee will be rewarded with a wine that need not fear comparison with this house’s more limited and far more expensive bottlings, nor for that matter with any other wines of Champagne. The harmonious juxtaposition of creaminess and lees enrichment with bright, juicy citricity and of expansive richness with levity is stunning....Citrus zest notes segue seamlessly into the fine stream of CO2 without bitterness, while succulent white peach garlanded in lily-of-the-valley is laced with rich, subtly piquant nut oils and saliva-liberating salinity. Emerging suggestions of shitake and shrimp shell reduction compound the sense of capital-'U' umami in a vibrantly interactive and refreshing finish. A day after opening, this is even more vividly complex than it had been initially, with hints of fresh red raspberry lending an invigorating tang and sensation of berry seed-crunching that delivers strikingly harmonious counterpoint to both the luscious brightness of fruit and the nutty low-tones....The team at Krug has long taken pains to emphasize that the task of assembling their Grande Cuvee from a hundred or more lots reflecting reserves of widely varying ages is mind-bogglingly complex. So is the result.”
97/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Sep 2013
“This is all about balance and the integration of power and finesse, with finely honed acidity supporting flavors of quince paste, dried black cherry, spun honey and candied orange zest, while rich notes of roasted walnut, coffee liqueur and toasted cardamom resonate on the finish. Hard to stop sipping. Drink now through 2028. ”
“ID 416037.
Very direct and flirtatious – this goes straight up the nose. Solid, fine and very firm, correct and well integrated.”
More Reviews +
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“ID 217017. A blend of 140 wines.
Savoury, rather Puligny-like nose. Very, very fresh, real zest on the palate which seems more youthful than the nose. Very punchy and fresh. Seems more youthful than the 167th Edition.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“A stellar Champagne, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 164ème Édition, (2008 base vintage) is painfully tight. The 164 is a fabulous wine, but readers should not fall into the temptation of opening a bottle anytime soon. Crushed rocks, slate, mint, sage and white pepper lend striking aromatic brightness. The 164 is just as compelling as it has always been. Even so, it needs time to be at its very best. The 164 is a blend based on 2008, with reserve wines back to 1990. Krug ID: 316031.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“The is the 163rd creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 315051, which is based on the 2007 vintage. The oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2007 with 183 wines from 12 vintages. In this early-harvest year aromas were more impressive than taste. Thus the reserve wines lend the complexity, roundness, body and length which were missing. 37% Pinot Noir, 32% Chardonnay, 31% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged spring 2014.
Tasted blind. Mellow nose. Savoury and almost meat and two vegy. Very firm. Marked acidity. Throat-warming finish. Very fine peacock’s tail finish. Edgy and youthful and very good. A second taste suggests it falls away a little. And it’s a tad dry on the end. Could this be based on 2006?”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“This is the 161st creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 312036, based on the 2005 vintage, the oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2005 with 134 wines from 12 vintages to make the Krug signature Grande Cuveé. Reserve wines this year bring brightness, richness and depth to the year's blend, mainly through very beautiful old Chardonnays and multiple expressions of Meunier from different years. 44% Pinot Noir, 37% Chardonnay, 19% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged summer 2012.
Tasted blind. Fizzy and tight. But not one of the densest or finest. Based on 2005? Neat bead. Well sculpted rather than dramatic. Lots of youth and acidity. But good balance.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Based on 2009. ID 416036. To be launched at the end of 2017 in the UK, US and France and embargoed until December 2017. This is the smallest, rarest batch ever for Grande Cuvée because of caution instilled by the economic crisis. In one year they will have three editions (163, 164 and 165) because 2008 and 2009 won’t be enough for one year’s sales! (They ensured that the 163rd edition will last longer.) Some of the 166th, made in much bigger quantity, is already being prepared for next year. Wines are from 2009 back to 1990. 127 wines from 12 different years.
Very pale with a heady nose and some richness. Firm and flirtatious with a really solid, ripe undertow. More hedonistic than many Krugs.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2017
“The NV Grand Cuvée 163 Edition is wonderfully open-knit and giving, qualities that make it a terrific choice for drinking now and over the next 30 or so years. Pastry, apricot, lemon confit, chamomile and white flowers, along with soft contours, give the wine its inviting, alluring personality. There is more than enough energy and overall freshness to support several decades of fine drinking. Even so, the 163 is virtually impossible to resist at this early stage.”
“2011 | The 2011 Vintage is a very pretty wine in this highly challenging vintage. Apricot, mint, dried herbs and a kiss of French oak open nicely in the glass. There is some of the savory character of 2011, but it is nicely woven into the wine’s fabric. To be sure, the 2011 is a slender vintage at Krug. That is especially evident in the wine's light-ish mid-palate and overall feel, yet all the elements are impeccably balanced. I expect the 2011 to be a relatively early maturing Vintage and would not push my luck on aging. Disgorged: Summer 2022. Krug ID: 322038.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“2011 | The aromatics are vibrant today, I tasted it a week ago and it wasn't this expressive, today's bottle is full of citrus, a twist of clementine, dried apricot and lime and a delicious saline finish. The palate has the trademark texture, rich, almost oily and acidity for Krug is soft, more like the 2003. With very careful selection of grapes this is a 2011 to show a solid wine can emerge from a year with many climatic challenges. If you are not worried about vintage reputation you will enjoy this champagne.”
95+/100
William Kelley,
WineAdvocate.com,
Apr 2019
“167 | Making its debut this year is Krugs NV Grande Cuvée 167ème Édition, a beautiful wine that wafts from the glass with aromas of yellow orchard fruit, peach and waxy citrus rind, complemented by complex notes of freshly baked bread, walnuts and smoke. On the palate, the wine is full-bodied and muscular but incisive, with a deep and concentrated core, a pinpoint mousse and a long, complex finish. Built around the 2011 vintage, the wine includes reserve wines dating back to 1995 and was disgorged in the winter of 2017-2018. Readers are advised to give it at least a couple years of bottle age before popping corks. 2020 - 2045”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2019
“167 | Krug’s Grande Cuvée 167ème Édition continues to impress for its depth, richness and sheer beauty, all of which are made especially remarkable given that this release is based on the highly challenging 2011 harvest. The 167ème Édition is gorgeous.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“167 | ID 118008. This is the wine reaching the market now. A blend of 191 different wines.
Definitely richer than many Grandes Cuvées. Very appealing and approachable. Those many elements are already admirably well integrated. Hugely complex but still quite substantially chewy on the end. Very long.”
“Exceptional freshness with aromas of flinty white stones, flowers, almonds and lemons. There’s hazelnut and strawberry here, too. Complex. The palate has a long, powerful and smooth-honed feel with very assertive citrus flavors, driven by long acidity. A perfect 2008.”
More Reviews +
94+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“Krug's 2008 Brut is slated to be released at the end of 2021, but any readers who purchase the wine will need to exercise considerably more patience if they are to enjoy it in its prime, as it is very tightly wound out of the gates. Unwinding in the glass with a youthfully discreet bouquet of clear honey, dried fruit, walnut oil, Meyer lemon and rock salt, it's medium to full-bodied, deep and incisive, with a racy spine of acidity, a pretty pinpoint mousse and a penetrating, saline finish. The polar stylistic opposite of the rich, demonstrative 2006, the 2008 is a rather understated, taut vintage from Krug that isn't as liberally endowed with the house's characteristic toasty patina as its immediate predecessor.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Aug 2021
“The 2008 Vintage is a nervy, electrifying Champagne, the likes of which has not emerged from Krug's cellars since the magical 1996. Bright and sculpted, with tremendous precision, the 2008 dazzles from start to finish. Stylistically, the 2008 doesn't have the toastiness or explosive breadth often found in young Krug, but that in no way detracts from its magnificent beauty.”
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“Pale greenish coppery colour. Intense evolved nose. A certain nuttiness and lots of lime flavour. Masses of acidity still but real depth too. Light bitterness. Lack of flesh. Structure dominates the filling. Mineral, almost wet cement on nose! Very dry finish. This one should run and run. Extremely zesty. Krug 2008. ”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“A stellar Champagne, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 164ème Édition, (2008 base vintage) is painfully tight. The 164 is a fabulous wine, but readers should not fall into the temptation of opening a bottle anytime soon. Crushed rocks, slate, mint, sage and white pepper lend striking aromatic brightness. The 164 is just as compelling as it has always been. Even so, it needs time to be at its very best. The 164 is a blend based on 2008, with reserve wines back to 1990. Krug ID: 316031.”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
essiavellan.com,
Apr 2017
“Deep, brilliant gold-hued colour. Expressive, stylishly oak-lined, brioche, apple, and honey nose with luscious vanilla and perky spicy complexity. Voluptious and intense the palate is particularly firm and feisty with beautiful vivacity and tight acid line. Elegant, detailed and packed with life.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Based on 2008. Very dense mouthful with a significantly dry finish. Decidedly intellectual rather than a wine for glugging.
Drink 2017-2025”
95/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Based on the 2008 vintage complemented by some 22% reserve wines, Krug's NV Grande Cuvée 164ème Édition opens in the glass with notes of warm bread, crisp yellow orchard fruit, mandarin, buttered toast and smoke. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and textural, it's rich and vinous but incisive, with fine depth at the core, tangy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. More complete than its vintaged sibling in 2008, it does share some of the latter's reserve and is still a few years from its peak, even if it's already approachable with great pleasure now.”
“Tasted blind. Greenish hint. Intellectual, intriguing nose that’s more evolved than its pair (the 2002). Really classy stuff on the nose. Hint of mushrooms. Great energy, lift and zest. Tight and fresh. A little richness. Very delicate mousse. Dry finish. Krug? ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2017
“Fresh, zesty spiced lemon and citrus notes of top Meunier and elegantly built Chardonnay, with a hint of honeysuckle and spice. Supremely subtle mouthfeel, showing textural quince and plum flavours.Optimally ripe, not heavy, with magical, very Krug-like acidity. It's so fresh. From a fine Chardonnay year, it has the ideal blend of 39% Chardonnay, 37% Pinot Noir and 24% Pinot Meunier. Great potential.”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TheFinestBubble.com,
Sep 2017
“Slightly light on the nose right after pouring; with few minutes in the glass it comes more forward with grapefruit, concentrated lemon and apricot. On the palate lots of depth and weight of fruit, great mouth-feel with fresh acidity and fruit-forward flavour and wow, what a backbone! Feel like its holding back at present has great weight of fruit and loveliness; apricots and nuttiness just starting to open and just hints of those brioche notes that come out with age. Great length, real subtlety and a hint of salinity on the finish. You can see this champagne ageing for 15-20 years. ”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2017
“Krug's 2004 Vintage is absolutely mesmerizing. Layers of bright, chiseled fruit open up effortlessly as the wine fleshes out with time in the glass. Persistent and beautifully focused, with a translucent sense of energy, the 2004 captures all the best qualities of the year. Moreover, the 2004 is clearly superior to the consistently underwhelming 2002 and the best Krug Vintage since 1996. Readers who can find it should not hesitate, as it is a magical bottle.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2017
“ID 212018. Disgorged spring 2016. 44% Pinot Noir, 33% Chardonnay, 23% Pinot Meunier. Named ‘Luminous Freshness’. Based on 2004. The beautiful weather in harvest time from mid September to early October made 2004 a generous year following the challenging extremes and limited yields of 2003. This is a blend of 121 wines from 12 different years, the oldest from 1990 and the youngest from 2004. Very broad and ripe. Much less tense than most. Very accessible. Masses of bruised fruit pleasure. Much less freshness than most. And a little shorter? This tasted relatively mature.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“ID 214031. This will be re-released this year along with Krug 2004. The re-release will have had longer on the lees than the original release. The re-release may be disgorged later than the sample on which this very enthusiastic tasting note is based.
Smooth and jazzy and utterly swallowable. Long and richly savoury. Fabulous! Open. Perfect now. Rich and exciting.
Drink 2014-2024”
96/100
Michael Edwards ,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2017
“A real firework of a Grande Cuvée set around the 2004 base, with intricacy from 12 different vintages in total dating back to 1990. A panoply of toasted bread, apple blossom, fresh peach, pear and dried apricot, followed by sensuous notes of almond, ginger and sweet spices. Beautiful mature Chardonnay and multiple expressions of Meunier beyond earthiness, richness with delicacy and vibrant freshness. Perfect now. The Champion today. Disgorged Spring 2012.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“This is the 160th creation of Krug Grande Cuvée, code 212018, based on the 2004 vintage. The oldest wine is from 1990 and the youngest 2004 with 121 wines from 12 vintages. Reserve wines this year lend harmony, completing the blend without modifying the predominant characteristics of the year. 44% Pinot Noir, 33% Chardonnay, 23% Pinot Meunier. Dosage 6 g/l. Disgorged spring 2012.
Tasted blind. Really exciting nose. Deep gold. Lots of evolution. Mellow, burnished, savoury gold. Great balance. Smoky. Racy. But broader than wine number 5 (which was the Krug vintage 2002 in this blind line-up). Solid but not inspiring. Not that long. Lots of pace. And length. Vintage wine. Savoury end. ”
“The 2007 base rosé is delightfully firm and fresh showing its usual ripe red fruit opulence complemented by a charming spicy edge. The long after taste echoes dried fruit sweetness, vanilla and subtle oaky spiciness. Charming already today but will develop into a beautifully Burgundian richness and satin smoothness. Krug ID 413067”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Mid salmon colour. Light nose, but much fruitier than the 26ème Édition. Good, positive dry finish. This would be a great pleasure to drink with food now. Clean and brisk finish but sufficient fruit on the way there. Lively – not to say playful.
Drink 2020 – 2026
”
95/100
The Wine Spectator,
thewinespectator.com,
Oct 2015
“The silky texture of this vivid Rosé Champagne draped the palate, offering an aromatic panoply of flavors, from pure raspberry and white peach fruit to ground cumin and anise, violet, graphite, spun honey and toasted almond. Delivers a long, mouthwatering finish.”
“Krug ID 316033: Light orange-toned colour. Refined, savoury nose showing charred characters, smoke, orange blossom and apricot. The wild, animally side of the wine starting to raise its head. Linear, fresh and long, still holding back a lot on the refined and airy palate.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2023
“The broad nose of a fully mature wine. There is considerable evolution here but it's still in good shape. The (agreeable) bitterness on the end is more pronounced than in the 26th and 27th editions.”
95/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
May 2023
“Light salmon pink in colour with gold reflections and a fine mousse. Somewhat shy on the nose, with aromas of fine cherry compote. subtle peach and candied orange zest, with some subtle tobacco and herbal spice. The palate has medium complexity, with integrated acidity, subtle sweetness and fine yellow tropical fruit, peach, and a touch of red berries. Already developed, this has a rather uncomplicated style, which is not showing its full potential at the moment.”
96/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Sep 2023
“Super fresh and bright with musky red fruit aromas as well as gently marzipan scented biscuits on the nose; spices all here too. Great complexity and depth, really elegant, assertive and deep. Long and even, superb depth through the finish. Great wine. Drink young and precocious. Krug ID 313042”
“The NV Rosé 25ème Édition is surprisingly pale in tonality for a Rosé that is predominantly Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier. Readers will find a serious, nervy Rosé built on tension, energy and persistence. There is a ton of vibrancy driving the red berry chalk and floral flavors. The 25éme is based on the 2013 vintage, with reserve wines back to 2008. Krug ID: 419035.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Mid salmon colour. Light nose, but much fruitier than the 26ème Édition. Good, positive dry finish. This would be a great pleasure to drink with food now. Clean and brisk finish but sufficient fruit on the way there. Lively – not to say playful.
Drink 2020
– 2026
”
“A deep copper hue on the eye leads onto a subtle nose that opens with a hint of rose petal and rosehip tisane, supported and transported by a lemony lift. There is a sense of zesty brightness and a note of finely ground white pepper comes through before it lifts into a serene sense of pink grapefruit. The palate has all the verve and freshness one could wish for, almost electric. This is incisive and precise, flirting shyly and still closed but giving away just enough of its undoubted depth and a sense of glorious, peppery savouriness. Long, peppery, serene, incisive. A dream as well as a promise for the future.”
More Reviews +
95-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2022
“This Krug Rosé 26ème Édition is based on the cool 2014 vintage, comprising 67% of the blend. Reserve wines come from six different years, the oldest of which is 2005. The 11% red wine component is Pinot Noir blended from plots in Aÿ and Taissy. Deep, orange-toned salmon colour. The nose delivers an instant 'wow' in its complex toastiness and fragrant, sweet Pinot Noir aromatics. Ripe cherries, crushed raspberries, orange peel, rose petals, oriental spices and even high-quality leather notes. The palate is still a little more reserved than the generous nose, but it's beautifully fresh and lively, bringing an exciting edge of delicacy to this fruit-packed wine. Really a great edition, full of delicious summer flavours and ready to impress. Krug ID 121017. Dosage 6g/l ”
96/100
Decanter,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2022
“An exotic, bright and freshly crushed raspberry nose, which persists. An exhilarating and fine wine. A fruit lolly note, but refined and smokily luxurious too.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2014 vintage, complemented by some 33% reserve wines from six other vintages, Krug's new NV Brut Rosé 26ème Édition is showing beautifully, offering up aromas of tart red berries and plums mingled with notions of warm biscuits, dried fruits, flowers and orange zest. Medium to full-bodied, taut and incisive, with terrific concentration, racy acids and a long, penetrating finish, it's an intensely flavored, electric wine that stands out as a particularly good recent release from this storied house.”
16.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2022
“Deep rose pink with an orange note. Lightly smoky, rosy notes on the nose. Then quite dry and severe on the palate. Rather hard, sudden finish.”
“Offering aromas of peonies, orange peel, cinnamon, dried herbs, rose petals and ripe red berries, the NV Rosé 28ème Edition possesses a medium to full-bodied, rich and concentrated palate with a vinous, creamy core of fruit framed by a vibrant, enrobing mid-palate that leads into a nicely phenolic, long, salty and mineral finish. This rendition—a blend of 58% Pinot Noir, 25% Chardonnay and 17% Pinot Meunier—is one of this house's most powerful and well-executed Champagne rosé ever produced. It comprises 32 wines from vintages spanning 2010 to 2016, with the latter as the base, and red wine sourced from Aÿ.”
More Reviews +
97/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Mar 2024
“Beautiful peach-pink color with a copper hue and a lot of floral nuances on the nose, offering dried cherries, peach skin and spices. It shows intensity and power, yet with elegance and precision. Full-bodied with a fine texture and phenolic tension. Bright and already delicious with some zesty, dried orange peel character at the end.”
“Pale gold. Pungent nose. Very tight. Hint of putty on the nose. Opens out on the palate. Masses to chew on. Real concentration. Perfect for drinking now. Dry but complete. Intellectual and great balance. Very impressive.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Tyson Stelzer,
Decanter.com,
Feb 2016
“Even in this bad-tempered vintage, the earth-shaking minerality of Krug’s single-vineyard Clos du Mesnil could not be dampened. It utterly trumps the phenolic grip of the season, which fades into complete oblivion. It wields a shining white citrus sabre that slices through its core with razor precision. This is not just the best Champagne of 2003, it is an entrancing wine by any standards, vintage aside.
”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“ID 215040. Made from the very small crop of 2003 back to 1988 from 120 wines. 51% Pinot Noir, 30% Chardonnay, 19% Pinot Meunier.
Pale, pungent and smoky. Great undertow, and proof that they did not get rid of their heavy wines in the Grande Cuvée.
Drink 2014-2024”
95/100
Jamie Goode,
wineanorak.com,
Jan 2016
“ID: 114002, which means this was disgorged in the first quarter of 2014. Tight, still, with bright acidity and some pithy notes. This is not what you’d expect from 2003. Distinctive toast and citrus, a bit of white peach and some hazelnut, with nice brightness. This is taut and direct with a crisp, somewhat clipped finish. ”
18+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2016
“ID 314058. Less explosive on the nose than the Clos du Mesnil 1999 (tasted but not released because not deemed up to scratch) but with real presence on the palate. Lots to bite on. Neat and a little more obviously exuberant than the 2000 Clos du Mesnil tasted the previous evening. Certainly no shortage of acidity. And lots of potential to age.
Drink 2013-2025”
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2015
“Strong, oaky, charred, super intense nose showing beautiful evolution and yeasty and toasty depth. Really powerful with mild oxidative notes but backed up with plenty of acidity and vibrancy. Still very soft and overt for Clos du Mesnil. This is still youhful and the oak will get better integrated over time.”
95/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2016
“Beguiling complex colour of twinkling green/gold lights. Inimitably Krug, masterly blending. The Chardonnay scents are at once refined yet dripping in the aroma of crunchy Williams pears. Discreet notes of vanilla, crème pâtissière, spiced lemon and brioche. Then a mouthfeel of body and heft; great Pinot Noir that is miraculously filigreed and ethereal, plus Pinot Meunier succulence. Like no other Champagne.
”
“Aged for at least five years in the Lanson cellars before disgorgement, this is a blend of Grand Cru wines from the Côte des Blancs. It has signs of maturity in the hints of toast and almonds while showing a crisp, tightly mineral texture. It’s a great food wine, very fresh with good depth of flavor. The acidity at the end is bright and refreshing.”
More Reviews +
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2012
“Lots of age and character and a very dry finish. Solid and meaty – sort of Bollinger style. Winston Churchill-like with a certain appley flavour.”
“Disgorged in November 2017 after a decade sur lattes, the latest release of Lanson's NV Brut Extra Age is based upon the 2004, 2005 and 2006 vintages, and it's showing very well, offering up a youthfully tight-knit bouquet of warm brioche, pear, confit citrus and praline. On the palate, the wine is deep, full-bodied and incisive, with the racy spine so typical of Lanson's non-malo style, excellent concentration and a long, saline finish. Muscular and penetrating, this is an excellent wine that still flies somewhat below the radar.”
More Reviews +
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2016
“The second (2004/2002/2000) blend of Extra Age is such a beautiful cuvée literally bringing together all the fine features of the three great vintages. There is the broadness and creaminess of 2000 and the structure and opulent fruit of the 2002. Finally the 2004 gives an impeccable freshness and vivacity to it. The aroma spectrum ranges from tropical fruit to apple, spices, marmalade and viennoiserie. This blend really convinced of this cuvée's potential, so I hope in the future we will see the vintages written on the label so that we can better follow and benefit from its ageing capacity. ”
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Jan 2015
“(60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay; 6 g/l dosage; L7500S80A): Pale gold. Fresh citrus fruit and honeysuckle aromas are complemented by chalky minerals and toasty lees. Dry and precise, offering energetic Meyer lemon and pear flavors and a hint of anise that builds with air. Finishes stony and very long, with resonating spiciness, firm minerality and a suave, building floral quality.”
“Lanson's expertise in making rosé d'assemblage dates back to 1833. Today the key villages for red wine production in Le Rosé include Bouzy and Les Riceys. The resulting colour is pale peachy. The deliciously sweet fruity nose has peach, orange blossom, rose petals and liquorice. There is a nice mix of both primary fruit, but also more complex spicy and pastry tones. The palate is intense and well built, but the texture is silky-rich and the taste long and juicy. A really pleasant, hugely enjoyable style. Here the Lanson recipe works perfectly, the bright acidity bringing such vibrancy and radiance to the fruit. Disgorged 1/22; dosage 8g/l ”
More Reviews +
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
May 2024
“With 71% of this champagne being from the highly regarded 2019 harvest then you are in for a treat with the fruit profile. It is expressive, delicious ripe red fruits dominate, like cherry, raspberry, red grapefruit and zingy citrus backbone, there is real purity in this champagne, hints of bitter orange coming through on the palate with a richly texture palate aided by the red wine, which brings colour but juicy raspberry fruit. The best Lanson Rose in years!”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Notes of rose petals, raspberries and blood orange introduce the NV Le Rosé Création 67, a moderately weighted, elegantly vinous and charming Champagne rosé with a tense, delicate mid-palate and a mouthwatering finish enhanced by delicate mousse. This blend of 52% Pinot Noir, 34% Chardonnay and the rest Pinot Meunier, including 6.6% red wine, was disgorged with eight grams per liter dosage.”
“This magnum really shines bright, that smoky charm draws you in, then you see layers of bright red fruit, similar to the bottle, but feels way more sophisticated. The fact 71% of this champagne is from 2019, a vintage to look out for, then you are in for a treat with the fruit profile. It is expressive, delicious ripe red fruits dominate, like cherry, raspberry, red grapefruit and zingy citrus backbone, there is real purity in this champagne, hints of bitter orange coming through on the palate with a richly texture palate aided by the red wine, which brings colour but juicy raspberry fruit. The best Lanson Rose in years and you get more than just two bottle worth in the magnum, it is a better champagne.”
More Reviews +
91-91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2022
“Lanson's expertise in making rosé d'assemblage dates back to 1833. Today the key villages for red wine production in Le Rosé include Bouzy and Les Riceys. The resulting colour is pale peachy. The deliciously sweet fruity nose has peach, orange blossom, rose petals and liquorice. There is a nice mix of both primary fruit, but also more complex spicy and pastry tones. The palate is intense and well built, but the texture is silky-rich and the taste long and juicy. A really pleasant, hugely enjoyable style. Here the Lanson recipe works perfectly, the bright acidity bringing such vibrancy and radiance to the fruit. Disgorged 1/22; dosage 8g/l ”
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
May 2024
“With 71% of this champagne being from the highly regarded 2019 harvest then you are in for a treat with the fruit profile. It is expressive, delicious ripe red fruits dominate, like cherry, raspberry, red grapefruit and zingy citrus backbone, there is real purity in this champagne, hints of bitter orange coming through on the palate with a richly texture palate aided by the red wine, which brings colour but juicy raspberry fruit. The best Lanson Rose in years!”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Notes of rose petals, raspberries and blood orange introduce the NV Le Rosé Création 67, a moderately weighted, elegantly vinous and charming Champagne rosé with a tense, delicate mid-palate and a mouthwatering finish enhanced by delicate mousse. This blend of 52% Pinot Noir, 34% Chardonnay and the rest Pinot Meunier, including 6.6% red wine, was disgorged with eight grams per liter dosage.”
“Full and rich nose showing evolution: bread and patisserie tones over sweet appley fruit. Full-on winey palate with sweetness and a long carry. Balanced dosage at 7g/l. ”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2023
“Creamy and assertive, and admirably persistent. A really exciting combination of zestiness and ripeness. Some citrus, some smokiness. This one should be a keeper. Great stuff! Makes the 2013 seem a little wan.”
91/100
Yohan Castaing,
Decanter.com,
Nov 2023
“A blend of 52% Pinot Noir and 48% Chardonnay, the 2012 Brut Le Vintage was disgorged in September 2020 with a dosage of seven grams per liter. It reveals a delicate, perfumed bouquet with aromas of lemon oil, pastry, spring flowers and mandarin orange. Medium to full-bodied, lively and energetic with bright acids, it’s tensile and chiseled, displaying a searing intensity and an acid-driven finish.”
93/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
JebDunnuck.com,
Nov 2023
“Pouring a youthful yellow-silver hue, the 2012 Champagne Le Vintage Brut takes things to another level of complexity while retaining good freshness. Lovely aromatics lift from the glass with a perfume of pastry dough and lemon custard, and although it’s medium-bodied, it offers more richness on the palate as well, with a silky texture and a fine, pillowy mousse. It’s rounded and balanced through the palate and has a long finish.”
“This blend of Chardonnay, exclusively from the Côte des Blancs grands crus of Avize, Cramant, Oger, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Chouilly, has a developed toffee and vanilla-laden nose of white fruit. There is some acacia and hazelnut complexity. The palate is light but rather sweet, showing a more youthful face than the nose. There is a lovely, playful, dancing lightness to it, but aroma-wise it could have been released earlier to maximise on the fruity deliciousness. The palate is really super delicious in its creamy lightness.
Drinking window 2022 - 2030”
More Reviews +
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Disgorged in September 2021, Lanson's 2004 Brut Blanc de Blancs Noble Cuvée Millésime is showing beautifully, offering up aromas of buttery pastry, beeswax, dried white flowers and crisp orchard fruit. Medium to full-bodied, ample and pillowy, with a vibrant and enveloping core of fruit, racy acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse, it's a charming wine that's evolving slowly.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Lemon-fruited and extremely crisp. Definitely an aperitif style.
Drink 2022–2025”
“Highly perfumed nose of crushed stone, lavender and ginger. Rich, dense, creamy and fine-grained, with very ripe flavors of apricot and peach nectar. Harmonious, round and seamless, with a fairly substantial dosage This shows the thickness and richness of the vintage without coming across as heavy. Finishes ripe and long.”
“70% Chardonnay, 30% Pinot Noir. Disgorged June 2016. Dosage 6 g/l.
Light nose and lots of both apparent sweetness and acidity. Not yet married but certainly ambitious. A tad astringent on the finish. A little simple but perhaps it will take on more interest. Tense but promising. Very lacy and fine with real breadth of exotic flavour.
Drink 2018-2028”
More Reviews +
90/100
Decanter,
Decanter.com,
Jan 2017
“Bright and clear with a gentle effervescence of fine bubbles. The nose shows attractive almond, lemon and floral notes. The palate is crispy dry and elegant with granny smith apples, medium toasty notes and good minerality.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2016
“Disgorged June 2015. RS 6 g/l. Supplied by Lanson UK.
Tasted blind. Great energy. Real interest on the nose and pretty high acid still on the palate (which should have led me to Lanson). A little astringent on the end. Slightly loose textured. And not that long. But it improved in the glass. According to The Finest Bubble’s scorekeeper, I gave this wine 18 but I was too busy to keep a record of it on my laptop.”
92/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“Lanson's 2002 Noble Cuvée Blanc des Blancs Millésime Brut is 100% Chardonnay from Grand Cru villages. It is a rich, ripe and round Blanc de Blancs that combines its smooth opulence with freshness, elegance, finesse and purity. Excellent and still on its way.”
88-90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2016
“Tight, sulphuric smoky-mineral nose with tropical fruit underneath. Firm, zesty, well focused palate with long succulent length with a hefty yet balanced dosage. Highly youthful still. Hopefully the reductive sulphuric note will settle.”
“Nuanced fruity nose of French pastry, confectionary, acacia, vanilla and ripe apple. Tight and focused palate with elegant cool fruit impression, juicy texture and a long fruity length. Appealing but with good degree of personality and depth. Drinking now but is still on its way up. A fine effort from Lanson this year. ”
“Disgorged 2018. In magnum.
Bright yellow straw colour. More reticent nose than the 2005. Lots of creamy vitality with a hint of lemon pastilles. The fruit is just starting to fade but there is admirable punch. Intense.”
“Disgorged 2015.
Deep gold. Smells of Peking duck! Very rich and broad on the palate. Vibrant and a little richer than refreshing but admirable lasting quality. Though it does fall apart a bit in the glass.”
More Reviews +
93-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Glorious, remarkably fruity nose with Coteaux du Layon reminicent botrytised tones of dried apricots, honey, orange marmalade and wool. Really sweetly fruity on both nosr and palate. Superb viscosity and generosity on the concentrated palate, stylishly lined with perky acidity. Seems ageless. ”
“Magnum. Mid pinkish pale copper. Bought direct from Lanson around 2005. Rich and broad. But then tight and not at all heavy. The acidity seems quite high enough. Was the heatwave year of 1976 a year to buy a wine with no malolactic fermentation such as Lanson? Though not the most complex or refined.”
“Disgorged on 28 June 2022 with dosage of 3 g/l and pressure at 1.06. Explosive aromatics with rich honey and toasted brioche with dried apricots pineapple, ginger and mango and subtle nuances of truffle and mocha - very complex and refined and with time in glass developed more of the mocha and coffee and even liquorice and toasted hazelnuts. Delicate fine mousse with vibrant acidity and intense citrus flavours. Linear and long with a great silky texture and a pleasant bitter Seville orange nuance on the finish. Excellent - a harmonious and mouth-watering Champagne. ”
“Disgorged in 2020 with a dosage of three grams per liter, Lanson's 1964 Vintage Collection is showing brilliantly, revealing a complex bouquet of dried apricot, beeswax, mocha and toasted nuts. Medium- to full-bodied, concentrated and intense, it possesses a rich, deep core of fruit underpinned by racy acidity and an enlivening, pinpoint mousse. This pristine magnum numbers among the most seamless and harmonious wines I've tasted from Lanson, displaying remarkable vitality for its age. Produced from what was, by the standards of the time, a hot growing season, with harvest commencing on September 16, it is a slightly Pinot Noir-dominant blend, the remainder comprising 43% Chardonnay.”
“Disgorged in January 2020. In individual original presentation cases. Levels: just below foil - Tasting note: Disgorged in 2019 with a pressure of 1.28 and three grams per litre of dosage. Explosive nose with intense dried orange peel, honey, saffron and subtle vanilla pod nuances. Creamy textured mouthfeel with mouth-watering acidity with a long saline citric, pineapple and ripe apple flavoured finish. Perfectly judged dosage. Broad textured with concentration and intensity of flavours. A superb Champagne!”
More Reviews +
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2026
“Disgorged in 2020 with a dosage of three grams per liter, Lanson's 1964 Vintage Collection is showing brilliantly, revealing a complex bouquet of dried apricot, beeswax, mocha and toasted nuts. Medium- to full-bodied, concentrated and intense, it possesses a rich, deep core of fruit underpinned by racy acidity and an enlivening, pinpoint mousse. This pristine magnum numbers among the most seamless and harmonious wines I've tasted from Lanson, displaying remarkable vitality for its age. Produced from what was, by the standards of the time, a hot growing season, with harvest commencing on September 16, it is a slightly Pinot Noir-dominant blend, the remainder comprising 43% Chardonnay.”
“From a year of small volume and big concentration, the color is deep but rather youthful for the time being. In 2012, the color and flavors extracted quickly, and 48 hours’ maceration was enough. A super stylish and expressive nose with licorice and juniper wood giving spicy tones to the sweetly fruity, bitter cherry and strawberry candy nose. On the palate there is an explosion of flavors with wild, even animally tones supporting the intense fruitiness. It is still holding back so much with its tight, fine tannin structure, energizing tension and sleek acid line. This is a keeper with ages ahead of it. ”
More Reviews +
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Aug 2022
“A blend of 80% Pinot Noir and 20% Chardonnay that are pressed together, Laurent-Perrier's new 2012 Brut Alexandra Grande Cuvée Rosé was disgorged in January 2022. Wafting from the glass with rich aromas of orange oil, macerated red berries, stone fruits and petals, it's medium to full-bodied, bright and pillowy, with a fleshy core of fruit and delicate phenolic structure that enlivens its sapid finish.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2023
“Pale tomato red. Alexandra, after whom the wine is named, describes it as the colour of sky on a winter morning. Interesting, distinctive nose that's a bit like a vermouth – some herbs and slight bitterness. More interesting than the average pink champagne. Quite a bite on the end. Some cheese notes too. Liquorice, toasted bread and black fruits – bitter cherries? This is definitely a food wine. It might even go with some cheese and griotte cherries – perhaps that Basque combo? Serious wine. By no means a run-of-the-mill rosé.”
96/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Magnum. Made uniquely by the cofermentation of macerated Pinot Noir and Chardonnay , leading to a rose with intense aroma and depth in colour and flavour. The 2012 vintage has plenty of fresh fruits including crushed strawberry, cherry and raspberry, with some notes of liquorice, plus vanilla and cinnamon. Firmly structured with concentration of fruits and refreshing acidity. Delicious now with potential for long ageing.”
“Tasted from magnum, the 2004 Grande Cuvée Rosé Alexandra, Laurent-Perrier’s flagship Rosé is a blend of 80% Pinot Noir (on the skins) and 20% Chardonnay vinified together that has only been bottled seven times since 1982. From the very first taste, the 2004 is utterly spectacular. Rich, ample and vertical in feel, the 2004 is dazzling. Dried rose petal, star anise, tobacco, dried flowers, red berry fruit and earthy notes all grace this utterly exquisite Champagne. As good as the 2004 is today – and it is fabulous – it will be even better in another few years’ time. The 2004 has been nothing short of magnificent on both occasions I have tasted it so far. ”
More Reviews +
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2016
“Elegantly berried with Volney-like refined Pinot note. On the reductive side with stylish toasty-gunpowdery notes. Raspberry and peach, forest floor. Light-weight, vivacious, tense palate. Super sophisticated style of rosé. Youthful still, and especially the magnums should be left for later.”
95/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Dec 2014
“First produced in the 1987 vintage to celebrate the marriage of owner Bernard de Nonancourt's eldest daughter, this bottling is now mature. Ripe, it still retains plenty of red fruits while also allowing the toasty character to show through. It's a rosé that calls for food, a rich and balanced wine that is just perfect to drink now.”
94/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2013
“(80% pinot noir and 20% chardonnay): Light, bright orange-pink. High-pitched red berry, orange zest and floral scents are underscored by an intense mineral nuance. Taut, linear and strikingly pure, offering deeply concentrated redcurrant and strawberry scents and hints of allspice, smoky lees and jasmine. Powerful yet lithe rose with superb finishing power, focus and mineral-driven persistence.”
“Tasted from magnum, the 2004 Grande Cuvée Rosé Alexandra, Laurent-Perrier’s flagship Rosé is a blend of 80% Pinot Noir (on the skins) and 20% Chardonnay vinified together that has only been bottled seven times since 1982. From the very first taste, the 2004 is utterly spectacular. Rich, ample and vertical in feel, the 2004 is dazzling. Dried rose petal, star anise, tobacco, dried flowers, red berry fruit and earthy notes all grace this utterly exquisite Champagne. As good as the 2004 is today – and it is fabulous – it will be even better in another few years’ time. The 2004 has been nothing short of magnificent on both occasions I have tasted it so far. ”
More Reviews +
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2016
“Elegantly berried with Volney-like refined Pinot note. On the reductive side with stylish toasty-gunpowdery notes. Raspberry and peach, forest floor. Light-weight, vivacious, tense palate. Super sophisticated style of rosé. Youthful still, and especially the magnums should be left for later.”
95/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Dec 2014
“First produced in the 1987 vintage to celebrate the marriage of owner Bernard de Nonancourt's eldest daughter, this bottling is now mature. Ripe, it still retains plenty of red fruits while also allowing the toasty character to show through. It's a rosé that calls for food, a rich and balanced wine that is just perfect to drink now.”
94/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2013
“(80% pinot noir and 20% chardonnay): Light, bright orange-pink. High-pitched red berry, orange zest and floral scents are underscored by an intense mineral nuance. Taut, linear and strikingly pure, offering deeply concentrated redcurrant and strawberry scents and hints of allspice, smoky lees and jasmine. Powerful yet lithe rose with superb finishing power, focus and mineral-driven persistence.”
“Very fine bead. Savoury nose – almost like white burgundy – lightly smoky. Quite explosive on the palate! Citrus peel and even a little grapefruit peel. Olivier Vigneron thinks that, like 2004, it is not especially expressive but will last forever. Very introvert currently with great tension. Even a little chewy on the end. It really opened out in the glass – mellowed! – however.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2026
“Silky, aromatic and impeccable in its balance, the 2018 Millésimé is a gorgeous, elegant wine. Dried pear, ginger, spice and crushed flowers caress the palate. Silky tannins frame the delicate, polished finish.”
“Very fine bead. Savoury nose – almost like white burgundy – lightly smoky. Quite explosive on the palate! Citrus peel and even a little grapefruit peel. Olivier Vigneron thinks that, like 2004, it is not especially expressive but will last forever. Very introvert currently with great tension. Even a little chewy on the end. It really opened out in the glass – mellowed! – however.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2026
“Silky, aromatic and impeccable in its balance, the 2018 Millésimé is a gorgeous, elegant wine. Dried pear, ginger, spice and crushed flowers caress the palate. Silky tannins frame the delicate, polished finish.”
“Beautifully judged 2015 vintage wine. Precise and focused, with a winning combination of concentration, density and freshness. Dosage 8 grams.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2024
“The 2015 Brut Millésimé, a blend of half Chardonnay from the Côte des Blancs and half Pinot Noir from the Montagne de Reims, spent at least seven years on lees. Supple smokiness and a sense of rye bread with distant plum create a subtle nose. The palate continues with that lovely smokiness, wrapping it around aromatic plum and taut lemon, which are delicious counter poles in this elegant wine. The bubbles are a little frothy, but it acquits itself well for a 2015 vintage with all its freshness. Dosage is 6 grams per liter. (Lot LP33UK01624E)”
93/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“As usual, this latest release of the 2015 Brut Millésimé is a blend of equal parts Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. Offering up aromas of confit citrus, blanched almonds, spices and a delicate smoky reduction, it's medium to full-bodied, layered and enrobing, with good depth at the core and a slightly smoky, phenolic finish. Dosage: eight grams per liter.”
“The magnum shows great smoky reductive notes, underneath are layers of ripe yellow fruits, lots of lemon, apple and some tropical notes with the BBQ’d pineapple quite distinctive. On the palate it fills out with green plum, hint of dried grass and touch of gooseberry. The lees texture is smooth really filling the mid palate which is fresh from the 2012 acidity and after 5 minutes you start to see the evolution of a touch of the creamy vanilla character that is just emerging. Finishes bright and fresh with hint of saline. This has a long life ahead, there is freshness and intensity, great now will age several decades.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“A blend of equal parts Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, the 2012 Brut Millésimé offers up aromas of lemon oil, confit citrus, spices, almonds, spring blossoms and warm biscuits. Medium to full-bodied, enrobing and charming, it's precise and layered, with good depth at the core, resulting from the 2012 vintage, enhanced by bright acids and concluding with a delicate, vanilla-inflected finish. Dosage: eight grams per liter.”
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“A Laurent-Perrier Vintage is one of the Champagne world's safest bets. Therefore, there is no reason why the great 2012 should be anything but outstanding. It is a classic 50/50 blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, with the former originating in the Côte des Blancs communes of Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Cramant and Chouilly, and the latter from Montagne de Reims's Bouzy, Aÿ, Verzy, Mailly and Rilly-la-Montagne. The nose is opening up beautifully, with sweet spicy tones and classy toasty whiffs complexing the radiant and intense fruit. A fruit salad in all its sweet nuances, but there are also some deeper and darker shades of aromatic wood and berries. Really intense on the palate, too, simply bursting with fruit. The texture is viscous, almost oily; due to the phenomenal concentration, it comes across almost winey. The mousse is soft. Despite the beautiful acid line and citric quality, the overall impression remains calm and mellow. This will take time beautifully.”
94/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“Elegant array of lemons, slate, biscuits, oyster shells, croissants and brioche. Precise and focused on the palate, with sharp acidity and tight, fine bubbles. Pure and youthful for now. 50% chardonnay and 50% pinot noir. Dosage 8g/L.”
94/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Aug 2022
“The 2012 Champagne Brut is equal parts Chardonnay and Pinot Noir and has 8 grams per liter dosage. Since the 1950s, only 30 vintages have been produced by the house. The aromatics are reminiscent of a Burgundian feel, with pleasant flinty reduction, smoke, and vibrant green fruits of pear and citrus blossoms. Offering an energetic mousse with green apple, yellow plum, lemon curd, and wet stone, this wine is well-balanced and should continue to improve over the coming 15-20 years. Best after 2022.”
93/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2022
“Laurent-Perrier 2012 possesses gorgeous aromas of orchard fruits, herbs, lemon and spices, with a hint of menthol. Calcareous on the palate, the structure is medium- to full-bodied, with a laser-like texture and a long and penetrating finish. It is undeniably one of the frank successes of the vintage, and while it has no need for further ageing, it may surprise us even further in the future.”
“A blend of equal parts Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, the 2012 Brut Millésimé offers up aromas of lemon oil, confit citrus, spices, almonds, spring blossoms and warm biscuits. Medium to full-bodied, enrobing and charming, it's precise and layered, with good depth at the core, resulting from the 2012 vintage, enhanced by bright acids and concluding with a delicate, vanilla-inflected finish. Dosage: eight grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“A Laurent-Perrier Vintage is one of the Champagne world's safest bets. Therefore, there is no reason why the great 2012 should be anything but outstanding. It is a classic 50/50 blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, with the former originating in the Côte des Blancs communes of Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Cramant and Chouilly, and the latter from Montagne de Reims's Bouzy, Aÿ, Verzy, Mailly and Rilly-la-Montagne. The nose is opening up beautifully, with sweet spicy tones and classy toasty whiffs complexing the radiant and intense fruit. A fruit salad in all its sweet nuances, but there are also some deeper and darker shades of aromatic wood and berries. Really intense on the palate, too, simply bursting with fruit. The texture is viscous, almost oily; due to the phenomenal concentration, it comes across almost winey. The mousse is soft. Despite the beautiful acid line and citric quality, the overall impression remains calm and mellow. This will take time beautifully.”
94/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“Elegant array of lemons, slate, biscuits, oyster shells, croissants and brioche. Precise and focused on the palate, with sharp acidity and tight, fine bubbles. Pure and youthful for now. 50% chardonnay and 50% pinot noir. Dosage 8g/L.”
94/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Aug 2022
“The 2012 Champagne Brut is equal parts Chardonnay and Pinot Noir and has 8 grams per liter dosage. Since the 1950s, only 30 vintages have been produced by the house. The aromatics are reminiscent of a Burgundian feel, with pleasant flinty reduction, smoke, and vibrant green fruits of pear and citrus blossoms. Offering an energetic mousse with green apple, yellow plum, lemon curd, and wet stone, this wine is well-balanced and should continue to improve over the coming 15-20 years. Best after 2022.”
93/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2022
“Laurent-Perrier 2012 possesses gorgeous aromas of orchard fruits, herbs, lemon and spices, with a hint of menthol. Calcareous on the palate, the structure is medium- to full-bodied, with a laser-like texture and a long and penetrating finish. It is undeniably one of the frank successes of the vintage, and while it has no need for further ageing, it may surprise us even further in the future.”
“The 2008 Brut Millésimé is a gorgeous wine that expresses all of the pedigree of the vintage beautifully. Complex and nuanced, with tons of class, the 2008 has so much to offer. Dried pear, mint, chamomile, crushed rock, dried flowers and pastry overtones are all laced together in this finely-knit, resonant Champagne. At $75.00 a bottle, Laurent-Perrier’s Brut Millésimé is one the best widely available vintage Champagne readers find from this historic harvest.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Very high acidity, pH under 3 in some cases. 50/50 Chardonnay/Pinot Noir. Dosage 8 g/l – not higher because Chef de Cave Michel Fauconnet didn’t want to hide the character of the vintage. ‘1988 was also very austere.’ Disgorged June 2018.
Greenish gold. Very fine bead. Attractive mixture of ripeness and smokiness on the nose. Extremely different from the easy 2007. Fauconnet thinks this tastes as though it’s all Chardonnay because of the austerity of the vintage. I wouldn’t actually describe it as austere. Fine-boned, rather, with lots of fruit. Tense but fine with lots to chew on. Much richer than the Blanc de Blancs.”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Amazing purity of Chardonnay dominates this precise, extremely vivacious wine of notable nervosity of freshness. Lot of green apple, pear and apricot notes alongside emerging reductive toasty charm. Truly classy and built to last. ”
93/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“A blend of equal parts Pinot Noir and Chardonnay that was disgorged with eight grams per liter dosage, the 2008 Brut Millésimé is showing nicely today, unwinding in the glass with aromas of green apple, pear, orange oil, spices and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, bright and precise, with tangy acids and a pillowy mousse, it concludes with a penetrating finish. This is aging very gracefully.”
“The 2008 Brut Millésimé is a gorgeous wine that expresses all of the pedigree of the vintage beautifully. Complex and nuanced, with tons of class, the 2008 has so much to offer. Dried pear, mint, chamomile, crushed rock, dried flowers and pastry overtones are all laced together in this finely-knit, resonant Champagne. At $75.00 a bottle, Laurent-Perrier’s Brut Millésimé is one the best widely available vintage Champagne readers find from this historic harvest.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Very high acidity, pH under 3 in some cases. 50/50 Chardonnay/Pinot Noir. Dosage 8 g/l – not higher because Chef de Cave Michel Fauconnet didn’t want to hide the character of the vintage. ‘1988 was also very austere.’ Disgorged June 2018.
Greenish gold. Very fine bead. Attractive mixture of ripeness and smokiness on the nose. Extremely different from the easy 2007. Fauconnet thinks this tastes as though it’s all Chardonnay because of the austerity of the vintage. I wouldn’t actually describe it as austere. Fine-boned, rather, with lots of fruit. Tense but fine with lots to chew on. Much richer than the Blanc de Blancs.”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Amazing purity of Chardonnay dominates this precise, extremely vivacious wine of notable nervosity of freshness. Lot of green apple, pear and apricot notes alongside emerging reductive toasty charm. Truly classy and built to last. ”
93/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“A blend of equal parts Pinot Noir and Chardonnay that was disgorged with eight grams per liter dosage, the 2008 Brut Millésimé is showing nicely today, unwinding in the glass with aromas of green apple, pear, orange oil, spices and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, bright and precise, with tangy acids and a pillowy mousse, it concludes with a penetrating finish. This is aging very gracefully.”
“50:50 Chardonnay:Pinot Noir. Picked end of August, very ripe but with good acid. Michel Fauconnet seeks vintage character too. Disgorged February 2017. Dosage 8 g/l.
Greenish lemon colour. Very tight knit and introvert on the nose – this does remind me of Grand Siècle! Lime structure and tense but tastes a little sweeter than 8 g/l. Perhaps that’s the year. Chalky finish. Fan of flavour on the end. Very easy to drink already but with the potential to age. Quite flirtatious.”
“50:50 Chardonnay:Pinot Noir. Picked end of August, very ripe but with good acid. Michel Fauconnet seeks vintage character too. Disgorged February 2017. Dosage 8 g/l.
Greenish lemon colour. Very tight knit and introvert on the nose – this does remind me of Grand Siècle! Lime structure and tense but tastes a little sweeter than 8 g/l. Perhaps that’s the year. Chalky finish. Fan of flavour on the end. Very easy to drink already but with the potential to age. Quite flirtatious.”
“Beautiful deep orange and copper toned colour. Evolved, soft, toasty nose with depth. Ripe cherry fruit, gentle spiciness. Quite winey, clean fruit and evolved style. Velvety texture and really harmonious character. A consistently great effort with the maceration method. Always a delight. I have also grown to be a great fan of the magnum, which ages in a grand fashion developing great winey qualities and Burgundian notions. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Bright salmon in colour, with orange tones, this wine is produced by the maceration method using Pinot Noirs from 10 Montagne de Reims villages, including Ambonnay, Bouzy, Louvois and Tours-sur-Marne. The beautifully expressive nose oozes Pinot Noir's sweet and spicy strawberry and blood orange fruit. Laurent-Perrier truly does master the maceration method of making rosé, achieving an amazing textural silkiness and structural tension without ever showing too much tannin or bitterness. This is truly one of Champagne's most unique premium non-vintage rosés, and ageworthy, too. I love how, with time, it starts to show a wilder side of itself, with lovely dark, spicy tones and sous-bois undernotes.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“There are no clues about disgorgement date or base vintage on the label – I couldn't even spot a lot number – but Nick Baker of The Finest Bubble kindly provided the lot code of the current cuvée – LP53UK35219E – and managed to persuade the chef de cave to divulge the background to it. This particular cuvée of the famous rosé champagne in the flask bottle is based on 2013. It's made from Pinot exclusively from 10 of the finest villages including Ambonnay, Bouzy, Louvois, Aÿ and the house's home patch of Tours-sur-Marne. It also includes 15% of reserve wine back to 2010 and spends all of 5.5 years on the lees, much longer than most NV rosés. Disgorged in September 2019 with a dosage of 10 g/l. They cold-macerate the grapes for two to three days, depending on the year, with the aim of extracting red-berry fruit flavours specifically rather than being concerned about the colour.
Pretty deep intensity of a colour that looks like pale tomato juice. Rose-petal aromas. Pretty aggressive mousse and light tannins on the end. This is quite an assertive pink champagne. It's not going to keep quiet as you enjoy your Valentine's dinner but may do a certain amount of interrupting. Red-berry fruit certainly in evidence before the tannins. Not my personal favourite style but it's certainly true to the ordained style and a lot of care goes into making it.
Drink 2021 – 2024”
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
VinousMedia.com,
Jan 2015
“Vivid orange-pink. An expressive, spice-accented bouquet evokes fresh raspberry, orange pith, white flowers and ginger, with a hint of rhubarb adding an earthy flourish. Sappy and broad in the mouth, offering intense red fruit and bitter citrus flavors underscored by chalky mineral and white pepper notes. Rich yet lively rosé with excellent closing thrust and floral persistence.”
16/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2016
“Light, simple red fruit, perky and tart. Precious little flavour development on the palate though. (RH)”
92/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Dec 2013
“Bright orange-pink. Toasty strawberry and raspberry aromas are accented by iodine, floral oils and dusty minerals. Broad and supple in texture, with sappy red berry and blood orange flavors supported by a firm spine of minerality. Finishes spicy, silky and long, with a late rose pastille note adding an exotic twist.”
96/100
Connoisseurs Guide,
wine.com,
Dec 2013
“Elegant and fruity at the same time with a quick invitation from bright, pure cherryish notes and then filled out handsomely by whiffs of chalky soils and well-integrated, rich and uplifting yeast-driven scents, this wine manages to be both vigorous and layered at one and the same time. Its bubbles are insistent, finely carved and add to the early sensations of lightness and energy yet also carry the wine long into a balanced, refined finish. And its latter palate grip is exactly what one should expect from the genre. While service with light foods would be our first choice, this one has the beauty to stand alone.”
16.5/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2017
“First released in 1968. Laurent-Perrier wanted to show that rosé could be a serious wine. 100% Pinot Noir – unusually not a blend of white and red wines. Crushed for 36 hours. RS 8 g/l.
Wild-salmon pink. Raspberries, freshness, a hint of tarragon on the nose. Lacy mousse. Tart raspberries, peppery green herbs, a small but intense sweet-salty-dark-sharp note of balsamic vinegar. Juicy yet composed. Dry. (TC)”
92/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Nov 2013
“Shows fine balance, with a vibrant tanginess to the flavors of black currant, strawberry, licorice and candied ginger. Features a fine, creamy bead, revealing a lasting note of smoky mineral on the finish. Drink now through 2018. Tasted twice, with consistent notes.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2011
“Very pretty pale salmon. Extremely, exuberantly fruity (as opposed to fine). This comes in the smartest conceivable pink box. Dead classy. Suggestions of strawberries. Nice level of fizz but not one of the most sophisticated pink champagnes in my view.”
“The NV Grande Cuvée Grand Siècle No. 22 (magnum), Laurent-Perrier’s current release of the flagship cuvée in magnum, is striking. Blending of vintages 2004, 2002 and 1989 results in an incredibly harmonious and well-balanced Champagne that has so much to offer. Candied lemon peel, mint, wild flowers, spice, baked apple and brioche are some of the many notes that run through a Grand Siècle built on silkiness, vinous depth and textural resonance. Of course, the magnum format helps, but the Grande Cuvée No. 22 is just gorgeous. I expect the No. 22 will age effortlessly for years based on its richness.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Magnum. The 22nd iteration of Grand Siècle. Disgorged July 2018. Base 2004. Chef de Cave Michel Fauconnet: ‘2004 was such a big harvest we didn’t realise it had such good ageing potential’.
Very deep gold. Almost sweet nose but still with the texture and lightness of Grand Siècle. Delicate texture and lift. Real finesse of texture and palate with just a little more chewiness. Very creamy.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“Plaster/putty sort of aromas with a bit of green vegetation. This took a little time to express itself but it really blossomed in the glass to be quite bewitching and beautifully complex and dense.
Drink 2021
– 2032
”
95/100
William Kelley,
WineAdvocate.com,
Apr 2019
“A blend of the 2004, 2002 and 1999 vintages, the NV Brut Grand Siècle #22 is about to be released in magnum, and it will be well worth seeking out, as this is a complex, gastronomic Champagne at the peak of its powers. Wafting from the glass with aromas of delicately honeyed peaches, woodsmoke, iodine and musk, the wine is full-bodied, broad and concentrated, with considerable savory complexity to complement its maturating fruit tones, a delicate mousse, chalky structuring dry extract and a sapid, mouthwatering finish. 2018 - 2030”
98/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2020
“A blend of the three vintages 2004, 2002 and 1999: medium greenish-yellow, silver reflections, fine, very persistent mousse. Notes of biscuit, ripe yellow tropical fruit, a hint of English fruit cake and nuances of honey, mineral background. Juicy and complex on the palate, nuances of peach, fresh, vivid structure, lemony-lime finesse on the long finish. Already very gluggable, has very good future potential. Unmistakable Laurent-Perrier at its best.”
“Blend of 2006 with 2004 and 2002. Magnum – which is always aged several years longer than the wine that is released in bottle. This is the current magnum (late release) that is just launched in the UK. Aged 14 years on lees. Disgorged in 2021.
Deep colour. Pungent – this wine really whisks up the nose! Very fresh. Really vivacious. Lots of energy. Very expressive. Fantastic!”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This blend combines the generosity and voluptuousness of 2006 and 2002 with the racy finesse of 2004. On the nose, it is rich and honeyed, with opulent, sun-kissed fruit: dried apricots, nectarine, white pepper, vanilla, white flowers, mint and gunpowder, alongside sumptuous pear and apple fruitiness. The 2006 vintage features speak the loudest here, bringing vinosity and generosity to it. There is even a touch of hot-year phenolics to the palate. Not the smokiest or tightest of the Grand Siècle magnums, but a caressing one that sits at that perfect place between youth and maturity. Dosage 7g/l”
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2021
“Fabulous aromas of brioche, pie crust, lemon tart and fresh apple. Full-bodied, very dense and layered with freshness and energy that couples well with the palate. Powerful acidity gives great structure to this. Goes on for minutes. Extremely structured. Three vintages – 2006 (65%), 2004 (20%) and 2002 (15%). Blend of 58% chardonnay and 42% pinot noir. From 11 grand crus. Aged in magnums. One for the cellar. Available only magnum. In Europe from mid-October 2021. Drink or hold.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Aug 2020
“The NV Brut Grande Cuvée Grand Siècle No. 23 (Magnum) is fascinating to taste within the context of the other wines in the series. The No. 23 is a decidedly vinous, ample Grande Siècle built on texture and resonance more than anything else. Lemon confit, lemon oil, marzipan, dried flowers and spice all flesh out as the wine opens up with air. The blend is 2006 (65%), 2004 (20%) and 2002 (15%). Disgorged May 27, 2019. (Originally published in August 2020)”
94/100
Simon Field MW,
Cluboenologique.com,
Nov 2022
“The first magnum was a little more evolved (a hint of bruised apple) than anticipated, so a second was opened; the difference was incredible. Blur became focus, and normal service was resumed. Mid-palate richness with notes of umami, then benchmark freshness on the finish, large-format quality writ large, with hints of grapefruit and sea salt to keep one on one’s toes.”
18/20
Tamlyn Currin,
Jancis Robinson.com,
Jun 2017
“This is the 17th release of this wine (1959 being the first). Blend of 3 vintages: 1999, 2002 and 2004. (Interestingly, 2000 was the only vintage declared that has never appeared in a Grand Siècle – not good enough?) 50% Chardonnay, 50% Pinot Noir. Made from 11 of the 17 grands crus.
Very slight tinge of gold. Cheesy nose – distinctly leesy/dairy. But gloriously unfettered and wild and spinning with flavour on the palate. Herbal. Wild honey. Chamomile, lemon zest, walnut and ginger. Coruscating edges. A geometric wine into which the bubbles seem to have been etched with a diamond tip. (TC) ”
92-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jan 2017
“A fresh and mellow, supple Grand Siècle with understated elegance. Highly balanced in 75cl bottles even if not one of the most impressive blends. Starting to show signs of evolution. A wholly different story in magnum, which showed majestically at the 2014 CSWWC. The complexity and refinement was just mind-blowing. World Champion Deluxe Magnum, 96 points with further potential.”
95/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“The NV Grand Siècle Grande Cuvée is a Grand Cru Brut based on 55% Chardonnay and 45% Pinot Noir from a total of eleven villages. The youngest release is a blend of the (declared) vintages 2002, 1999 and 1998, and has a yellow-golden color that opens beautifully with a clear, deep and complex bouquet. It is pure, ripe and very elegant, mixing pain-aux-raisin and honey flavors with pure chalk. Ample, highly elegant, beautifully matured and fruit-intense, with fine caramel, honey and torrone flavors, this is a well-structured Grand Siècle with great finesse and delicate freshness. Awesome.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Deep straw colour but still with amazing tension on the palate. This is explosive and minerally on the nose and definitely with less obvious acidity than the Grand Siècle No 25 in bottle at this point. In fact, it's almost warm and round! Definitely creamy-textured with strong lemon-syllabub (lemon-cream) notes. Very much part of the Grand Siècle family with just a lightly bitter note on the end. Maturing very nicely.
Drink 2022–2034”
17.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2015
“Creamy, yoghurt, peach, dried herbs and baked apple - lots going on here. Substantial and fragrant.”
93/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Nov 2013
“A subtle version, focused more on delicate acidity and texture than the finely layered flavors of creamed apple, marzipan, pastry dough and black currant, with hints of lemon curd and ground spice. Delivers a lasting, smoke-tinged finish. Drink now through 2020.”
92/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Dec 2012
“Light, bright gold. Mineral-accented scents of pear skin, orange pith and white flowers are lifted by a gingery nuance. Pliant, dense and rich, with palate-coating orchard fruit and spicecake flavors and a smoky mineral quality building with air. Weighty and broad but energetic, with bright minerality adding lift and cut to a strikingly persistent finish.”
96/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2009
“Laurent-Perrier’s prestige cuvée is always non-vintage, a blend of top years. The latest bottling is so elegant, definitely maturing from bottle aging and older vintages in the blend, but still worthy of aging in itself. It is dry, in the L-P style, but has richness, an intense pink grapefruit character, hints of cilantro, the final acidity a great shaft of light.”
“Magnum release (always four to five years later than the bottle release). Blend of 60% 2007 with 20% each of 2006 and 2004. 55% Chardonnay and 45%
Pinot Noir. What a difference from the No 24 in bottle, released in 2019 and tasted two years ago! Much, much more evolved on the nose than the bottle release. Golden-creamy somehow. Just gorgeous! Tight-knit, like all Grands Siècles, with strong citrus notes, a certain toastiness and a richness on the mid palate that tightens to a dry, appetising finish. Really vigorous and assertive without being too showy. Long and the most luxurious aperitif imaginable.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“Magnum It. No. 24 - This has smoky reductive charm that layer of gunflint sits above the fruit, bundles of citrus, ripe lemon & grapefruit, some orange and lime. The PN comes more in the palate structure, some great bright dried strawberry, dried plum and bright citrus finish. The orange lingers, attractive candied orange skin, which adds a bitter twist. The dried fruits really come forward with a few minutes in the glass and hints of buttery pastry just starting to show. Very classy, super refreshing. Drink now to 2035+”
97+/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Mag | Laurent-Perrier’s NV Itération 24 Magnum Brut reveals a complex, deep bouquet of white flowers, confit citrus, mirabelle, spices, menthol and warm biscuits. This full-bodied, enveloping and fleshy Champagne offers a deep, dense mid-palate that is invigorated by racy acidity and concludes with a long, endless and ethereal finish. Slightly more austere and tense than the Brut Grand Siècle #24 released in a bottle, this magnum blend consists of 60% Chardonnay and 40% Pinot Noir, with vintages from 2007 (60%), 2006 (20%) and 2004 (20%).”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“Mag | The NV Grande Cuvée Grand Siècle No. 24. (magnum) is fascinating to taste next to the 750ml bottle, both disgorged in June 2024. It is fresher in its aromatics and flavor profile and also silkier in texture. Tasting the two formats side by side is illuminating. Citrus confit, white flowers, chalk, mint and dried herbs are all beautifully delineated. I won't be surprised if this improves with more time on the cork, as it was disgorged less than a year ago.”
98/100
Anthony Rose,
The Real Review UK,
Sep 2024
“Consisting of 60% of the 2007 vintage, 20 % each of the 2006 and 2004 vintages, it is a mature-"ie gold in colour, with a fabulously intense bouquet that's lightly smoky and truffly, seriously complex and savoury. You could keep sniffing ad nauseam but the bubbles beckon, and in them you find a mousse that's fresh and expansive, whose textural quality brings a remarkable persistence of flavour, dissolving on the tongue in a flourish of citrus, a hint of honey and mature, savoury, truffly notes. It remains remarkably fresh, especially noting that the trio of vintages are 17, 18 and 20 years old”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Bottle. The 24th iteration of Grand Siècle since the 1960s, now signalled with a ‘24’ on the bottle neck. 60% 2007, 20% 2006, 20% 2004, launched now. Mostly Chardonnay (55%) and Pinot Noir (45%), all grand cru. Disgorged October 2018 after 10 years on lees. Dosage 7 g/l.
Deep greenish yellow. Creamy, oaked Chardonnay sort of nose recalls white burgundy. Much richer than the Blanc de Blancs of course but with the same tight texture and filigree mousse. Firm and noble.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“Laurent-Perrier's NV Grande Cuvée Grand Siècle No. 24 is just starting to show the first signs of aromatic and flavor complexity, which makes it a very satisfying Champagne for current drinking. Hints of apricot, lemon confit, white flowers and marzipan grace this wonderfully vibrant, inviting edition of Grand Siècle built on the 2007, 2006 and 2004 vintages. The Grande Cuvée No. 24 is silky, perfumed and classy all the way. Time in the glass brings out the wine's freshness and energy.”
17.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2022
“A tiny bit less powerful on the nose than the No 25. And then richer on the palate. It came out on the nose in the end but needs time. It should have a nice long life because the relatively austere 2007 is dominant. Drink 2023– 2032
”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jun 2019
“Laurent-Perrier's NV Grande Cuvée Grand Siècle No. 24 is just starting to show the first signs of aromatic and flavour complexity, which makes it a very satisfying. Champagne for current drinking. Hints of apricot, lemon confit, white flowers and marzipan grace this wonderfully vibrant, inviting edition of Grand Siècle built on the 2007, 2006 and 2004 vintages. The Grande Cuvée No. 24 is silky, perfumed and classy all the way. Time in the glass brings out the wine's freshness and energy.”
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“Classic L-P benchmark fragrant gunpowdery toastiness on the nose that opens up with honey, ginger, lemon, lilies and marengue notes. Still reserved and highly youthful in magnum and keeping very fresh and zingy in 75cl bottle too. Lovely evolution and integrated richness on the refined, creamy-caressing palate. A class act.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
RichardJuhlin.com,
Jun 2019
“Glass clear and sublime, with a classic Grand Siècle repertoire of aromas and textures. Despite the fact that 2007 is a less interesting year, one has got a fantastic genuine balance and sober style.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jun 2019
“A blend of the 2007, 2006 and 2004 vintages, beginning to drink well, offering up a complex and already maturing bouquet of dried flowers, mandarin orange, iodine, gingerbread, clear honey and smoke. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, fleshy and vibrant, with an ample core of fruit complemented by abundant sapid nuances, bright acids and a fine but youthfully frothy mousse. This is an expressive rendition of Grand Siècle that will drink well on release”
“Bottle. The 24th iteration of Grand Siècle since the 1960s, now signalled with a ‘24’ on the bottle neck. 60% 2007, 20% 2006, 20% 2004, launched now. Mostly Chardonnay (55%) and Pinot Noir (45%), all grand cru. Disgorged October 2018 after 10 years on lees. Dosage 7 g/l.
Deep greenish yellow. Creamy, oaked Chardonnay sort of nose recalls white burgundy. Much richer than the Blanc de Blancs of course but with the same tight texture and filigree mousse. Firm and noble.”
More Reviews +
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Apr 2025
“60% 2007, 20% 2006, 20% 2004. 58% Chardonnay from Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Cramant, Avize, Chouilly and Oger. 42% Pinot Noir from Bouzy, Ambonnay, Mailly, Verzy, Verzenay, Tours-sur-Marne. 17 years on lees. Disgorged June 2024. Dosage less than 7 g/l. From magnum.
Broad and sweeter than the version from 75-cl bottle but lots of energy too. Long lees ageing! 2007 has given freshness. More lively and transparent than the 2024 from 75-cl bottle. Very long and smoky. Tighter than in the bottle! ”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“Laurent-Perrier's NV Grande Cuvée Grand Siècle No. 24 is just starting to show the first signs of aromatic and flavor complexity, which makes it a very satisfying Champagne for current drinking. Hints of apricot, lemon confit, white flowers and marzipan grace this wonderfully vibrant, inviting edition of Grand Siècle built on the 2007, 2006 and 2004 vintages. The Grande Cuvée No. 24 is silky, perfumed and classy all the way. Time in the glass brings out the wine's freshness and energy.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jun 2019
“Laurent-Perrier's NV Grande Cuvée Grand Siècle No. 24 is just starting to show the first signs of aromatic and flavour complexity, which makes it a very satisfying. Champagne for current drinking. Hints of apricot, lemon confit, white flowers and marzipan grace this wonderfully vibrant, inviting edition of Grand Siècle built on the 2007, 2006 and 2004 vintages. The Grande Cuvée No. 24 is silky, perfumed and classy all the way. Time in the glass brings out the wine's freshness and energy.”
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“Classic L-P benchmark fragrant gunpowdery toastiness on the nose that opens up with honey, ginger, lemon, lilies and marengue notes. Still reserved and highly youthful in magnum and keeping very fresh and zingy in 75cl bottle too. Lovely evolution and integrated richness on the refined, creamy-caressing palate. A class act.”
93-95/100
Richard Juhlin,
RichardJuhlin.com,
Jun 2019
“Glass clear and sublime, with a classic Grand Siècle repertoire of aromas and textures. Despite the fact that 2007 is a less interesting year, one has got a fantastic genuine balance and sober style.”
94/100
William Kelley,
,
Jun 2019
“A blend of the 2007, 2006 and 2004 vintages, beginning to drink well, offering up a complex and already maturing bouquet of dried flowers, mandarin orange, iodine, gingerbread, clear honey and smoke. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, fleshy and vibrant, with an ample core of fruit complemented by abundant sapid nuances, bright acids and a fine but youthfully frothy mousse. This is an expressive rendition of Grand Siècle that will drink well on release”
“65% 2008, 25% 2007, 10% 2006. 60% Chardonnay from Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Cramant and Avize. 40% Pinot Noir from Ambonnay, Bouzy, Verzy, Tours-sur-Marne and Mailly. 12 years’ ageing on lees. Disgorged September 2022. Dosage 7 g/l.
Especially rich on the nose and palate. Very pleasing creaminess now. With some muscularity rather than tightness.”
“65% 2012, 25% 2008, 10% 2007. 58% Chardonnay from Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Cramant and Avize. 42% Pinot Noir from Tours-sur-Marne, Ambonnay, Bouzy, Verzy. 10 years’ ageing on lees. Disgorged February 2024.
Pale greenish straw. Very sweet and intense nose. Masses of intense character on the palate. Lemon and pastry cream. Dry, tight finish. Tighter than when it was released. At this point it’s less opulent. Very youthful, more youthful than I remember!”
More Reviews +
100/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“This is really something. Electric on the palate. The aromas are so complex with sliced fresh and dried ginger, subtle pie crust, tarte tatin and hints of nutmeg with some salted caramel. Toasted bread, too. Always subtle. The palate is full- to medium-bodied yet hemmed-in with a freshness and balance that draws you back. Savory and vibrant. It’s full of energy. Spectacular. Fascinating. Symphonic blend of 2012, 2008 and 2007. 65% of the 2012, 25% of the 2008 and 10% of the 2007. Eight grand cru. Chardonnay 58% and 42% pinot noir. Disgorged February 2023. 10 years on the lees. 7g/L dosage. Drink or hold”
19.5/100
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2023
“Powerful aroma of orange peel and something in the putty/chalk spectrum. It somehow manages to be both tight yet approachable, dense in terms of flavour concentration yet filigree in terms of texture. As usual, it's so Chardonnay! Overriding citrus character and quite amazingly long, a mouthful tingling on the palate for minutes not seconds. Enormous finesse. Massive pleasure. This would make the most luxurious aperitif. Michel Fauconnet, having welcomed the new chef de cave in January 2023, must be especially proud of this wine.”
96+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“A blend of the 2012, 2008 and 2007 vintages, the NV Brut Grand Siècle #26 is just coming onto the market. Wafting from the glass with notes of nectarine, peach and ripe citrus fruits mingled with notions of freshly baked bread, buttered toast, nougat, white flowers and clear honey, it's medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a deep and rather broad-shouldered core of fruit that's girdled by racy acids and animated by a classy pinpoint mousse. This suave, complex three-vintage blend is the Grande Marque prestige cuvée par excellence. This bottle was disgorged in February 2023 with seven grams per liter dosage.”
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
Jun 2023
“This iteration of Grand Siècle leans heavily on the Chardonnay side with its 58% proportion. Two great vintages, 2012 and 2008, compose a lion’s share of the blend with 2007 supporting. The overall impression is one of ripe and exuberant fruitiness. Upon release this February 2022 disgorgement shows rather open and expressive already in all its honey and floral tones. Taking into account the varietal proportion, Pinot Noir’s presence can be felt strongly on both the nose and palate. There is ample power and body to the richly textured palate, the 2012 vintage seems to be driving the wine at the moment. Lots of concentration here, which no doubt will reward cellaring.”
96+/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“The NV Brut Grand Siècle #26 is a stunning Champagne, revealing a complex, dense bouquet of confit citrus, white peach, white flowers, honey, beeswax and menthol. Medium to full-bodied, enveloping and layered, it has a deep, fleshy core of fruit, bright acids, a vinous texture and broad shoulders, segueing into a long, mineral and delicately saline finish. Chardonnay remains the majority, making up 58% of the blend (sourced mainly from Le Mesnil), while Pinot Noir, primarily from Tours-sur-Marne, comprises 42%. This is a blend of the 2012 (65%), 2008 (25%) and 2007 (10%) vintages and was disgorged with a dosage of seven grams per liter.”
“Impressively aromatic, showing honeysuckle, violets and lavender with bread dough and just a hint of light caramel as well as dried apples, cooked pears and tarte tatin. Reductive with graphite, stone and iodine. Some chalk too. Full-bodied but not at all heavy, turning almost weightless. Nine years on the lees and 7 g/L dosage give energy, length and form. Goes on for minutes. This will age beautifully but is already fascinating, evolving in the glass.”
More Reviews +
18.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2025
“Great raciness and intensity on the nose! This is an early-developing iteration apparently. Richly nuanced and explosive. Attention-grabbing. On the finish it’s really salivatory. Bone-dry end. Tense again. Very rewarding. Takes you on a journey and eventually develops into a persistent whole.”
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2025
“Disgorged in January 2025 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, the forthcoming NV Grand Siècle N°27 already demonstrates considerable promise. A blend of the 2015, 2013 and 2012 vintages—predominantly anchored in the youngest—it draws from eight villages, comprising 60% Chardonnay and 40% Pinot Noir, with an intentional emphasis on Chardonnay to counterbalance the concentration of Pinot Noir. The 2015 imparts expressiveness, echoing the 2012, while the cool, late-ripening 2013 contributes freshness and cut. Unfurling in the glass with aromas of pear, peach, lemon confit and freshly baked bread, framed by a subtle smoky reduction, it is full-bodied and concentrated, built around a generous and charming core of fruit, underpinned by tangy acidity driving toward a long, resonant finish. Slightly fleshier and broader shouldered than the Grand Siècle N°24 tasted alongside, it indicates yet another distinguished Grand Siècle in the making.”
“After more than a 10-year wait since the previous Les Réserves, Laurent-Perrier has now decided to release the Grand Siècle iteration No.20 as a late-disgorged version. Benefiting from more than 20 years on lees, this magnum combines the soft lushness of 1999 (60%) with the freshness of the 1997 (20%) and the explosive fruitiness and acid line of the 1996 (20%). Composed of grapes from 11 of Champagne's 17 grands crus, this wine is only available in magnums and Jéroboams. It truly shines in magnum, with a flirtatious nose of freshly roasted coffee and sweet lemon tones. Beautifully evolved aromatics with lots of layers and plenty of fruity power left. So cool, crisp and fine on the palate, with the softest mousse. Superbly vivacious, caressingly creamy and lingering. At a wonderful drinking age now, but there is plenty of improvement potential left.”
More Reviews +
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Les Réserves was born when Bernard de Nonancourt's daughter, Lucie Pereyre's mother, found some magnums and jeroboams of Grand Siècle No 17 in the Laurent-Perrier cellar after her father died in 2010 and they wanted to celebrate the house's bicentenary in 2012. This release, available in magnums only, is essentially long-aged Grand Siècle No 20, which was 60% 1999 and roughly 20% apiece of 1997 and 1996. The final blend was 54% Chardonnay, 46% Pinot Noir, made up of eight grands crus.
Drink 2022–2030
I was lucky enough to taste Laurent-Perrier's vintage champagnes 1999 and 1997 not that long before tasting this blend which is so much more complex and intense – as well as much fresher. Quite a feat! The wine is just this side of toasty but has massive impact and almost suggests some torrefaction. This is extremely vivacious while still being bone dry. Pungent with a hint of caramel but also lime – that's how broad the spectrum of flavours is. Very, very complete. Satisfying, revitalising – what I'd call a sore-throat wine, so intense is its finish. Difficult to see how anyone would be disappointed by this, the essence of Grand Siècle.”
19.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2022
“Grand Siecle Iteration 20 Les Reserves (tasted 17th June 2022 from Lehmann Grand Champagne Mouth Blown 45 cl Glass) The smoky charm cant be missed #MagnumEffect then an incredible intensity of yellow fruit with super ripeness, grilled pineapple, mango, plum and blood grapefruit, bitter orange and under all that you see the dusting of the Chalk "direct from the vineyard." The texture is soft and creamy and with the yellow fruits you start to see the emergence of patisserie richness on the end of the palate. With all this fruit intensity the champagne has great freshness with with that expected saline finish. The bitter orange really lingers with grilled pineapple and in the background there is a slight minty haze. Today it is 19.5+/20 and with more post disgorgement time this may well be a 20/20 - Absolutely amazed at how much you can get in one glass of champagne and I cant wait to taste this in a few more years. Drink now til 2035+
”
98/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Decanter.com,
Jun 2022
“Subtle chamomile and dried bergamot peel notes appear first on the nose, followed by a lift of lemon and stone. Unusually fragrant, this is clearly evolved but far removed from the usual tertiary flavours of mature Champagne. This is a sublimation of citrus, herb and chalk. The palate has edges of beeswax but with an incredibly sprightly and fine mousse and utter freshness. It is a picture of ageless grace, so zesty, creamy, bright and so very chalky. Lemon shines long on this complete outlier with its profound, light and tonic-like body and uncommonly fragrant nature. Sourced from grands crus only, this Chardonnay-dominant wine is a blend of the 1996, 1997 and 1999 vintages, aged under cork for 21 years and disgorged with a dosage of 7g/L.”
100/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jun 2022
“This is a beautifully complex wine. Flinty, even smoky on the nose, with preserved lemon, quince, smoked almond, sea urchin, olive and white pepper, as well as some mushroom, pie crust and salted caramel. Energetic, yet with a dense and oily palate. Lots of power. Sleek bubbles. So many layers to ponder over, with a long, umami finish. It’s Montrachet in nature and greatness. Love the roundness to the texture. Unique. 54% chardonnay and 46% pinot noir. Blend of 1999, 1997, 1996. 21 years on the lees. 7g/L dosage. Only a few 100 magnums. Drink on release or hold.”
“Bright perfumed aromatics, hints of Turkish delight, lychee, zingy lemon and hints of tropical fruit. The texture is super silky, those reserve wines have real personality, rich fruits grow on the palate, bitter lemon, dried tangerine, really rather lovely and a hint oily. Great length ending light and fresh. A great example of the elegance of reserve wines, all four vintages in the blend are ripe fruit years and two of them have great freshness, giving this very elegant and sexy champagne. Drink 2024 to 2034.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2024
“Definite echoes of Grand Siècle here but a bit less dense and persistent, though there is the same sort of admirable tension. An excellent addition to the Laurent-Perrier family.”
94/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“The inaugural NV Héritage from Laurent-Perrier is a new cuvée composed of 40 different crus, including grands crus and premiers crus, entirely crafted from vins de réserve. A tribute to the heritage and expertise of Grand Siècle, it offers up aromas of blanched almonds, spices, brioche, spring flowers and lemon oil, mingled with a lovely, smoky reduction. Medium to full-bodied, enveloping and round, with a sappy, layered texture, it has a fleshy core of fruit enhanced by bright acids and a long, mineral finish. Chef de Cave Michel Fauconnet has crafted a stunning wine.”
“Bright perfumed aromatics, hints of Turkish delight, lychee, zingy lemon and hints of tropical fruit. The texture is super silky, those reserve wines have real personality, rich fruits grow on the palate, bitter lemon, dried tangerine, really rather lovely and a hint oily. Great length ending light and fresh. A great example of the elegance of reserve wines, all four vintages in the blend are ripe fruit years and two of them have great freshness, giving this very elegant and sexy champagne. Drink 2024 to 2034.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2024
“Definite echoes of Grand Siècle here but a bit less dense and persistent, though there is the same sort of admirable tension. An excellent addition to the Laurent-Perrier family.”
94/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“The inaugural NV Héritage from Laurent-Perrier is a new cuvée composed of 40 different crus, including grands crus and premiers crus, entirely crafted from vins de réserve. A tribute to the heritage and expertise of Grand Siècle, it offers up aromas of blanched almonds, spices, brioche, spring flowers and lemon oil, mingled with a lovely, smoky reduction. Medium to full-bodied, enveloping and round, with a sappy, layered texture, it has a fleshy core of fruit enhanced by bright acids and a long, mineral finish. Chef de Cave Michel Fauconnet has crafted a stunning wine.”
“This is the new and improved version of the house's previous non-vintage, Brut LP, first released in 2017. The elegantly floral, sensuous nose of lemon and orchard fruit has a light toasty whiff, alongside a touch of cardamom spiciness. Even lovely yeasty complexity is coming through. The palate is seamless and silky, very fine, with this flowing sensation enhancing the quaffing character. A drinkable, charming even if lightweight wine, with laudable fruit purity and impeccable balance.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Evoking aromas of menthol, white fruits, lemon oil and warm biscuits, the NV Brut La Cuvée possesses a medium to full-bodied, round and supple palate with good depth at the core and a charming, fresh, ethereal finish. For this release, the percentage of Chardonnay in this cuvée has been slightly increased, making it a blend of 52% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 13% Pinot Meunier. Based on the 2018 vintage, complemented with 2016 and 2015, it was disgorged with a dosage of nine grams per liter.”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2016 vintage and disgorged in December 2022, the latest release of Laurent Perrier's NV Brut La Cuvée is showing nicely, delivering notes of sweet stone fruits, white flowers, nougat and buttery pastry, followed by a medium-bodied, ample and pillowy palate that's charming and expressive.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2017
“Smoky reductive nose with real depth and lively age. Serious champagne, though at the full price it's quite expensive. ”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2018 vintage, the NV Brut Collection 243 bursts with aromas of honeyed peaches, citrus oil, toasted nuts, white flowers and buttery pastry. Medium to full-bodied, broad and fleshy, it's an open, giving iteration of Roederer's reimagined non-vintage Brut.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2017
“'La Cuvée' is a rebrand for their non-vintage, I gather. There’s a lot of savoury umami character on the nose and chewy green citrus fruit. Long and fragrant to finish. (RH)”
“La Cuvée is the new, shiny, rebranded Brut NV, only just launched. In 2004 Laurent-Perrier got access to quite a large bit of good Chardonnay vineyards, and this set in motion a 13-year plan to adapt and 'enhance' the LP Brut. 55% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir, 10% Pinot Meunier from 110 growers. Base vintage 2012 with 30% reserve wine. They've dropped the dosage from 12.5 g/l to 9 g/l, and the wine spends four years on the lees.
Pale colour. Lemon shortbread nose, the tiniest hint of marzipan, verbena. Needle-fine mousse and intense, sharpened, lemon-sherbet acidity. Very pointed, with a bit of lemon-bon-bon sweetness on the finish. Razor-sharp finish. Elegant, angular, classic. (TC)”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This is the new and improved version of the house's previous non-vintage, Brut LP, first released in 2017. The elegantly floral, sensuous nose of lemon and orchard fruit has a light toasty whiff, alongside a touch of cardamom spiciness. Even lovely yeasty complexity is coming through. The palate is seamless and silky, very fine, with this flowing sensation enhancing the quaffing character. A drinkable, charming even if lightweight wine, with laudable fruit purity and impeccable balance.”
91/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Evoking aromas of menthol, white fruits, lemon oil and warm biscuits, the NV Brut La Cuvée possesses a medium to full-bodied, round and supple palate with good depth at the core and a charming, fresh, ethereal finish. For this release, the percentage of Chardonnay in this cuvée has been slightly increased, making it a blend of 52% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 13% Pinot Meunier. Based on the 2018 vintage, complemented with 2016 and 2015, it was disgorged with a dosage of nine grams per liter.”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2016 vintage and disgorged in December 2022, the latest release of Laurent Perrier's NV Brut La Cuvée is showing nicely, delivering notes of sweet stone fruits, white flowers, nougat and buttery pastry, followed by a medium-bodied, ample and pillowy palate that's charming and expressive.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2017
“Smoky reductive nose with real depth and lively age. Serious champagne, though at the full price it's quite expensive. ”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2018 vintage, the NV Brut Collection 243 bursts with aromas of honeyed peaches, citrus oil, toasted nuts, white flowers and buttery pastry. Medium to full-bodied, broad and fleshy, it's an open, giving iteration of Roederer's reimagined non-vintage Brut.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2017
“'La Cuvée' is a rebrand for their non-vintage, I gather. There’s a lot of savoury umami character on the nose and chewy green citrus fruit. Long and fragrant to finish. (RH)”
“This is the new and improved version of the house's previous non-vintage, Brut LP, first released in 2017. The elegantly floral, sensuous nose of lemon and orchard fruit has a light toasty whiff, alongside a touch of cardamom spiciness. Even lovely yeasty complexity is coming through. The palate is seamless and silky, very fine, with this flowing sensation enhancing the quaffing character. A drinkable, charming even if lightweight wine, with laudable fruit purity and impeccable balance.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Evoking aromas of menthol, white fruits, lemon oil and warm biscuits, the NV Brut La Cuvée possesses a medium to full-bodied, round and supple palate with good depth at the core and a charming, fresh, ethereal finish. For this release, the percentage of Chardonnay in this cuvée has been slightly increased, making it a blend of 52% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 13% Pinot Meunier. Based on the 2018 vintage, complemented with 2016 and 2015, it was disgorged with a dosage of nine grams per liter.”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2016 vintage and disgorged in December 2022, the latest release of Laurent Perrier's NV Brut La Cuvée is showing nicely, delivering notes of sweet stone fruits, white flowers, nougat and buttery pastry, followed by a medium-bodied, ample and pillowy palate that's charming and expressive.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2017
“Smoky reductive nose with real depth and lively age. Serious champagne, though at the full price it's quite expensive. ”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2018 vintage, the NV Brut Collection 243 bursts with aromas of honeyed peaches, citrus oil, toasted nuts, white flowers and buttery pastry. Medium to full-bodied, broad and fleshy, it's an open, giving iteration of Roederer's reimagined non-vintage Brut.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2017
“'La Cuvée' is a rebrand for their non-vintage, I gather. There’s a lot of savoury umami character on the nose and chewy green citrus fruit. Long and fragrant to finish. (RH)”
“This is the new and improved version of the house's previous non-vintage, Brut LP, first released in 2017. The elegantly floral, sensuous nose of lemon and orchard fruit has a light toasty whiff, alongside a touch of cardamom spiciness. Even lovely yeasty complexity is coming through. The palate is seamless and silky, very fine, with this flowing sensation enhancing the quaffing character. A drinkable, charming even if lightweight wine, with laudable fruit purity and impeccable balance.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Evoking aromas of menthol, white fruits, lemon oil and warm biscuits, the NV Brut La Cuvée possesses a medium to full-bodied, round and supple palate with good depth at the core and a charming, fresh, ethereal finish. For this release, the percentage of Chardonnay in this cuvée has been slightly increased, making it a blend of 52% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 13% Pinot Meunier. Based on the 2018 vintage, complemented with 2016 and 2015, it was disgorged with a dosage of nine grams per liter.”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2016 vintage and disgorged in December 2022, the latest release of Laurent Perrier's NV Brut La Cuvée is showing nicely, delivering notes of sweet stone fruits, white flowers, nougat and buttery pastry, followed by a medium-bodied, ample and pillowy palate that's charming and expressive.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2017
“Smoky reductive nose with real depth and lively age. Serious champagne, though at the full price it's quite expensive. ”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2018 vintage, the NV Brut Collection 243 bursts with aromas of honeyed peaches, citrus oil, toasted nuts, white flowers and buttery pastry. Medium to full-bodied, broad and fleshy, it's an open, giving iteration of Roederer's reimagined non-vintage Brut.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2017
“'La Cuvée' is a rebrand for their non-vintage, I gather. There’s a lot of savoury umami character on the nose and chewy green citrus fruit. Long and fragrant to finish. (RH)”
“Lightly gun-flinty, purity assured, bundles of citrus, with lemon and grapefruit the most prominent. The palate broadens out with ripe peach and apricot with dark cherry and raspberry underneath. This is a solar year, pretty warm, yet there is plenty of freshness showing on the palate, after long lees time this has balanced out beautifully where the ripeness of the fruit is held up perfectly with salinity and the acidity. Another texture delight, the trademark of great champagne. Enjoy now and will improve for 5-10 years.”
“Beautifully smoky, with that reductive charm that always seduces me as you know there is no loss due to oxygen. This has power of ripe yellow fruits, loads of stone fruit, charred pineapple, grapefruit, super ripe peaches and lemon and lime. Feels like some of those fresh fruit are beginning to show as dried/candied fruit. This has a very elegant texture, rich and velvety and the chardonnay element is giving it a kiss of vanilla custard. This is sensational, I love the 2004 vintage purity you see in so many from the vintage. This champagne is showing super youthful, enjoy it now and will improve for 10 +years.”
“Less gun-flinty than 2004, you can see in this 2002 you have more of the dried citrus character coming through as it begins to transition from fresh zippy citrus fruits to more of the dried and candied citrus. Initially it is Chardonnay dominating, drippingly succulent charred pineapple and lime, with a core of bitter orange and apricot and hints of dried grass. Not surprisingly this has the gentlest and most velvety texture, quite sublime, bubbles have softened with time and brings a super relaxed feel on the palate. Very beautiful phase to drink and enjoy where as 2004 is much tighter and younger. Drink now for 6-8 years.”
“Fairly wet summer but saved by a fine September. Deep honeyed gold. Clearly fully mature with a deep, resonant, somehow mineral/burnished metal nose. Very serious. A rich start but a super-appetising dry finish. Complex with a note of lime and yet richness too. Utterly beguiling. Long. Just the right amount of appetising mousse.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2025
“This is even more tight and reductive than my last tasting a few months ago. You are allured into the champagne by its hazy gunflint and richness of stone fruit. The palate shows some of the patisserie and dried citrus fruit and zingy orange. The acidity perks up the palate and more CH shows off on the palate. Extraordinarily great!”
“Honeyed straw colour. Tingly, vibrant nose with great energy even if without a massively deep undertow. Real grip and presence on the palate. And impressive persistence. But it's a sprightly wine rather than one in which pronounced autolysis has been sought.”
More Reviews +
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2025
“Seems more ripeness here than 2000, light smoky gunflint leads you into to an abundance of dried fruits, apple, citrus and ripe peaches. I see more bitter orange here and apricot and lime on the finish. Some patisserie notes add a lovely creamy texture and finished bright and dry. Lovely example of an old champagne, recently disgorged.”
“Magnum. Intense lemon yellow colour. Really quite mature, candified nose yet with marked citrus acidity on the palate. It tastes more marked by Chardonnay than by Pinot. Zesty and refreshing. Medium finish that does build to quite a sweet note on the very end, but it's perhaps just a little too austere at this point to be truly seductive. Drink 2022-34”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2025
“For not a classic vintage in champagne, overshadowed by its immediate two previous years of 1995 and 1996, this '97 is looking very good. There is plenty of ripe fruit more now showing as dried citrus, grapefruit and orange and a layer of smoky gunflint. The palate is rich in citrus and stone fruits like apricot and peach. Not as complex as the 2000, but this has a lightness and delicacy that makes it very drinkable.”
“Crafted from equal parts Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier and Chardonnay and aged underwater during the summer of 2022, the 2018 Abyss reveals aromas of maritime notes, white fruits, spices, smoke and herbs. Medium to full-bodied, tense and ethereal, it's perfectly balanced with a pinpoint mousse and a lovely gastronomic bitterness. Disgorged with one gram per liter dosage.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2024
“The 2018 Brut Nature Abyss, made from one-third each of Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier and Chardonnay, was disgorged in Winter 2022 and submerged in the sea off the coast of Brittany for ten months at a depth of 60 meters, the bottle reassuringly encrusted in barnacles. A subtle touch of red plum and tender smoke carry breeziness on the nose, while the slender palate comes with fine mousse and lovely verve and spright for 2018. This is tightly meshed and beautifully plummy, uniting the best of 2018 fruit and uncommon freshness. That beautiful notion of smoky plum shines on the lasting finish. Zero dosage. - Anne Krebiehl MW”
“From the depths of the sea, invigorated by nature’s energy with a bottle decorated by mother nature herself, Leclerc Briant Abyss is something truly unique. The house’s Abyss project, which commenced with the 2012 vintage, sees bottles submerged in the sea near Brittany to a 60-meter depth for nearly a year to enhance the bioenergy. The 2017 was disgorged in July 2021, sunk in the sea and taken back to the surface 10 months later. Beautifully soft, ripe fruity nose with red and yellow fruits intermingling. The bone-dry palate is super fresh yet textured, with the plushness meeting energising nervosity. Impressively creamy mousse. Outstanding effort for the notorious 2017 vintage. Disgorged 7/21; dosage 0g/l”
“This wine matured for over 15 months at a depth of 60 metres in the Atlantic Ocean. Light golden yellow, silver reflections. On the bouquet, initially a breeze of salt and iodine, underlaid with ripe fruit, nuances of verbena and a little cassis; a multilayered bouquet. Substantial, closely meshed palate, juicy fruit, integrated acidity, shows good length, mineral and taut, ethereal aromas on the back palate. A truly exceptional Champagne.”
“This pure Meunier from Chamery gains gravitas from fermentation in oak. The brightly fruity, fragrant nose has beautiful yellow raspberry and blood orange tones, plus a light touch of toast. The oaky whiff is well married to the sweet fruitiness. On the palate, it is silky smooth and driven, ending on a super-dry but invigoratingly fresh mineral note.”
“The same intense florality on the nose as on their Brut Rosé NV but this time much tighter and drier on the palate with some phenolics on the end. Made to demonstrate the quality of Pinot Meunier. Very much part of the Leclerc Briant family in style. Intense, and the concentration makes up for lack of dosage. Gentle mousse.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Wine & Spirits,
Wineandspiritsmagazine.com,
Jul 2019
“Hervé Jestin ferments this pinot meunier in oak barrels where it then ages for nine months. One taster compared the smokiness of this wine to a peaty Highland Scotch, even if that aspect is a highlight. It’s the ripe red fruit that drives the wine, cushioned by oak tannins, its delicate strawberry notes lasting with finesse. The flavors would meld with the sweetness of broiled unagi.”
93/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Jul 2019
“This silky, polished champagne is produced from certified organic grapes grown in the premier cru village Chamery (Petite Montagne), fermented in cask and aged ten months on the lees before bottling. The wine was disgorged in June 2019 and finished with no dosage. The result is arrestingly pure and elegant, with aromas that range from lime peel to ripe apple and toast, a discreet, well-integrated autolysis, and an impressively lingering finish.”
“Based on the 2017 vintage. Disgorged in August 2021. Dosage 4.54 g/l. Very deep copper colour. A really glorious array of wild, floral aromas. Hugely distinctive and the opposite of formulaic with a tiny little bead. Mouth-filling. Tingly on the (dry) finish. So amazingly long with some lemon notes on the end! This is superior champagne that I would recommend to any serious champagne lover. So full of life!”
More Reviews +
93/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2020
“Medium golden yellow, silver reflections, fine mousse. Delicate white nougat, hints of yellow tropical fruit, floral touch, tangerine zest. Juicy, integrated acid structure, fine tobacco savouriness, apple fruit on the finish. Easy to drink.”
90/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“A blend of 40% Pinot Noir, 40% Pinot Meunier and 20% Chardonnay, the NV Réserve Brut from Champagne Leclerc Briant is showing well today, evoking a lively, fresh bouquet of pear, verbena, lime tree, herbs and menthol. Moderately weighted and tense, it's vinous and energetic with an incisive mid-palate and a mouthwatering, fresh finish. Based on the 2020 vintage with only 5% vins de réserve, it was disgorged in October 2023 with 4.5 grams per liter dosage.”
“Based on the 2017 vintage. Disgorged in August 2021. Dosage 4.54 g/l. Very deep copper colour. A really glorious array of wild, floral aromas. Hugely distinctive and the opposite of formulaic with a tiny little bead. Mouth-filling. Tingly on the (dry) finish. So amazingly long with some lemon notes on the end! This is superior champagne that I would recommend to any serious champagne lover. So full of life!”
More Reviews +
93/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2020
“Medium golden yellow, silver reflections, fine mousse. Delicate white nougat, hints of yellow tropical fruit, floral touch, tangerine zest. Juicy, integrated acid structure, fine tobacco savouriness, apple fruit on the finish. Easy to drink.”
90/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“A blend of 40% Pinot Noir, 40% Pinot Meunier and 20% Chardonnay, the NV Réserve Brut from Champagne Leclerc Briant is showing well today, evoking a lively, fresh bouquet of pear, verbena, lime tree, herbs and menthol. Moderately weighted and tense, it's vinous and energetic with an incisive mid-palate and a mouthwatering, fresh finish. Based on the 2020 vintage with only 5% vins de réserve, it was disgorged in October 2023 with 4.5 grams per liter dosage.”
“This rich and exuberant Chardonnay is grown on a 0.4ha plot surrounding Leclerc Briant's villa in Villers-Allerand on the Montagne de Reims. The nose is clean and pronounced, with high-quality oak expressing itself clearly and stylishly. In addition to crunchy orchard fruit, there is also a tropical pineappley edge to the frutiness. Really racy on the intense palate, which starts energetic but quickly turns into something more mellow and vinous. A joyfully fruity wine, bursting with energy.”
“While tasting with Chef de Cave Herve Jestin, he let slip, they never use new oak barrels because its impact would be too great, but they buy 225 litre barrels from two chateau in Bordeaux; “Haut-Brion and D’Yquem!” What great pedigree! This is a text book Blanc de Noirs champagne; dark cherry fruit combine with the spicy oak, leading to layers of peach, cranberry, blackberry and there is real juiciness here. This is sexy #PinotNoir in its most precise way, elegant fruit that although weighty on the palate has a lightness. This is a big champagne from a single vineyard showing great tension and a saline finish. The 2 g/l dosage balances well. Finishes with that trade mark hint of oak tannin, very flattering. If you haven’t discovered 2019’s yet you have some wonderful discoveries to make!”
“Greenish tinge. Very vibrant and high-toned. Zest incarnate! Real energy. No decay evident. Really racy.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Yohan Castaing,
Decanter.com,
Jun 2020
“Disgorged June 2019. 100% Chardonnay. Zero dosage. With notes of pear, menthol, gentle spices, and a hint of smoke, the bouquet impresses from the start thanks to its powerful aromatic complexity. With its dense, fleshy texture, this is a superbly flavourful Champagne propelled by very fine bubbles. Here again, there is a hint of reduction on the palate just after opening, but freshness soon comes to the fore, enhanced by a touch of mint on the finish. Power and length underpin this very great Champagne. Bravo!”
“This old vineyard is shared by two owners, Leclerc Briant & Jacques Selosse! The still wine underwent long lees ageing in 225 litre ex Chateau d’Yquem oak barrels, all the way post harvest to the next years summer equinox. Something Herve and his biodynamic practices believes is an important influencer on the wine. Another power house from Herve Jestin, the toasty nose leaps out the glass, combines with lots of yellow fruit, bit of lemon and grapefruit, though going quite tropical; char grilled pineapple, this is a big mouthful! Luckily the Mesnil chalk kicks in and bring a real core of salinity and freshness that keeps the palate light and fresh on the finish. You can see the texture has real weight from its long barrel time on the lees, this adds a velvety layer that is so attractive. The oak notes linger long with tropical hints and lemon peel zest giving a bitter twang on the end. I like how both these single vineyard release in 2025 show great precision and are as clean as a whistle, showing us biodynamic practices and low sulphites are producing some amazing champagnes. If you look at Leclerc's Grand Blanc, now with enough history that we can see low sulphites is no issue to the ageing ability.
Drink Now to 2034”
“The 2019 Extra Brut Millésime is a blend of 70% Pinot Noir and 30% Chardonnay that was raised in oak. The wine spent 4.5 years on lees. A lovely sense of buttery apple tart spreads gently and shyly on the nose, with fresh, tart apple overtones. The palate is beautifully fine, fresh and balanced, again recalling apple tart with superb freshness and a textural, creamy element that is wonderfully pliable. Everything comes together beautifully. Dosage is 1.8 grams per liter. Disgorged: January 2025.”
“In the Leclerc Briant fashion, this vintage cuvée shows fine vinosity of oak-fermented wine, but there is always an impeccable freshness and sensation of energy and tension, thanks no doubt to the bioenergetic approach of chef de cave Hervé Jestin. On the deliciously fruity nose, sweet raspberries meet ripe apple, kumquat and yellow plums. A fruit basket, really, but there are also peach stones and earthy-spicy qualities. The palate is rather structured, and you can feel the oak impact a little more. Lovely vinosity and freshness continuing until the long, dry finish. Disgorged 3/22; dosage 3g/l”
“The 2017 Brut Blanc de Blancs, derived from four plots in the mid-slopes of Avize and vinified tw-thirds in stainless steel with the remainder in oak, is a considerable effort in the comparatively challenging year. “Unlike the red grapes, Chardonnay did not have issues with rot,” recalls Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon. Disgorged with seven grams per liter dosage, it soars from the glass with aromas of grapefruit zest, pear and toasted almonds. On the palate, it’s medium to full-bodied, ample and textural, with a low-pressure mousse, vibrant acidity and a long, chalky finish. It’s derived from their estate, which has been farmed organically since 2017 (and certified as such in 2020). For its richness, 2017 reminds one of the 2010 vintage with less exoticism.”
“Produced from four plots in Avize, the 2016 Brut Blanc de Blancs was disgorged in February 2022 with seven grams per liter dosage. Unwinding in the glass with aromas of citrus oil and peach mingled with toasted almonds, buttery pastry, iodine and white flowers, it's medium to full-bodied, ample and fleshy, with a deep and layered core of fruit, racy acids and a long, succulent finish, it stands out once again as the insider's choice in the Roederer range.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2023
“Intensely perfumed, the Champagne has great citrus fruit and minerality that has now intensified and matured into a perfect age. Drink now.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2016 Brut Blanc de Blancs Vintage is laced with hints of tropical fruit, lime, mint, passionfruit and crushed rocks. Intensely aromatic and light on its feet, the 2016 impresses with its gracious, understated personality. Sourced from plots in the mid-slope Grand Cru vineyard of La Côte in Avize, readers will find a Blanc de Blancs endowed with tons of energy and nuance. Dosage is 8 grams per liter.”
“The 2015 Blanc de Blancs is a fabulous choice for drinking now and over the next decade or so. Soft and creamy, the 2015 is immediately caressing in its embrace. Citrus confit, white flowers, spice and a hint of pastry all meld together. There is something effortless about the 2015 that is hard to describe. The 2015 is not the last word in complexity, but it is supremely delicious. Terrific for the year.”
“Disgorged with just over seven grams per liter dosage, Roederer's 2014 Brut Blanc de Blancs is showing brilliantly, wafting from the glass with aromas of citrus oil, orchard fruit, freshly baked bread and white flowers, framed by subtly reductive top notes. Medium to full-bodied, ample and fleshy, it's pillowy and enveloping, with lively acids and a pearly, lower-pressure mousse, concluding with a long, chalky finish. Derived entirely from Avize, it's one of the great sleeper cuvées in contemporary Champagne.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“Roederer's 2014 Brut Blanc de Blancs sizzles with tension and energy. Citrus, white flowers, crushed rocks and white pepper race across the palate. Most of the attention at Roederer falls to other wines, most notable the Cristals and the NV, but the Blanc de Blancs is a quiet wine that often overachieves, as it does in 2014. Superb.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“There’s a lot here on the nose – real intrigue and layers. This is wine! Do I detect a little oak influence? And there is certainly refreshment but intellectual stimulation too. A very complete package, with a little more obvious acidity than the regular 2014 Brut.”
“Chardonnay from the Côte des Blancs forms the backbone of this still-young vintage. Crisp apple and ripe lemon flavors go together with a taut, nervy texture that has a steely edge. The wine needs to age, so drink from 2021.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Sep 2020
“Lemon curd and star fruit flavors provide a citrusy overtone to notes of apricot, biscuit and thyme in this well-knit, racy Champagne, which offers a lively bead and a subtle streak of salinity. Well-balanced and mouthwatering. Drink now through 2030.”
93+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs wafts from the glass with aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, warm biscuits, freshly baked bread and dried white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, it's the most tightly wound and introverted of these new vintages released from Roederer, and it really needs some time on cork to digest its dosage and develop additional complexity. Seamless and elegant, it's nicely balanced, with fine depth at the core: the only missing ingredient is time.”
95/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Light yellow-green, silver reflections; fine, discreet mousse. White toast notes underlaid with a delicate herbal savouriness and a hint of white peach, lime zest; a lively bouquet. Mineral, taut, integrated acidity, refined savoury finish.”
“The 2010 Brut Blanc de Blancs shows just how compelling this cuvée can be in more favorable years, and 2010 had its share of challenges as well. Brisk, fresh and wonderfully nuanced, the 2010 exudes energy as well as a sense of transparency that is compelling. Time in bottle since release has only added flavor complexity and texture. Light on its feet and super-expressive, the 2010 Blanc de Blancs is one of the highlights in this range from Roederer.”
More Reviews +
91-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2016
“Fragrant, bright white fruits on the nose lined by pretty toasty note. Round palate with fresh acidity but not very long. The fruitiness is ample, ripe and delicious.”
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles. The 2012 based cuvée is beautifully creamy and lacey with ripe, plush fruitiness but comes with enough acidity. ”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Aug 2026
“MAGNUM - Tasted in August 2026 and was amazed how young and energetic it was tasting and came across as a little tight and needing more time before we see full aromatic development. I believe this one is base 2015, full of ripe yellow fruits and the texture was super silky and full of stone fruit charm. I would imagine these will hit a peak in perhaps mid 2030's.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“There's a QR code on the back. If you have the app you can scan it and learn full details. Based on 2015 (they have just moved on from 2014).
A greenish tinge to deep straw colour. Some real depth on this nose with all the elements building on each other. Really is superior! Great harmony and nothing out of place. Incredibly persistent. Bravo!”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, 20% Meunier. Partial malo, 10% of the wine aged in oak casks, based on 2013 vintage, reserve wine spends up to 10 years in large neutral French oak barrels. 3 years on lees. Dosage 9 g/l.
Pungent and fine – goes straight up the nose! Great balance and completeness. Not sweet but sweet-er. Good texture and unobjectionable. Not the tightest textured but lots of fun.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Based on 2013. Disgorged early 2017. This cuvée is just starting out on the market now. Cool year with an October harvest, so a 150-day growing season. 2013 and the next two years were all glorious for Pinot Noir so there is lots of Pinot in this – 65%, of which 52% is Pinot Noir. 35% Chardonnay. Highest malo ever: 56%. Reserve wines constitute 25% (which is the norm). This includes 7% really old wines. Usually there are eight vintages, in this case back to 2004 maybe aged in old oak plus 18% from the year before in stainless steel. Their role is to add consistency. Typically, there will be 120 different batches of wine in Brut Premier.
Flirtatious and lively. Mouth-filling and satisfying. Dancing and lively. A very superior NV champagne.
Drink 2017-2024”
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2016
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles.”
86/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“The NV Brut Premier is bold, powerful and intense. Hazelnut, smoke, dried pear, mint and savory herbs are all pushed forward. In this release, the Brut Premier is a bit brash and unpolished, with less of its typical finesse. Let's just say I was not surprised to scan the back label and learn that this release is based on the 2011 vintage. Even Roederer could not overcome the significant challenges presented by the 2011 vintage.”
92/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Aug 2015
“A vivacious Champagne, finely knit and elegant overall. This is creamy and satiny in texture, with layers of yellow plum, chalk, toast, glazed apricot and lemon curd. Offers a lingering, smoke- tinged finish. Drink now through 2020.”
92/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2013
“This is a particularly good bottling of Brut Premier. Drawing on Roederer’s famed reserve wines, it has a touch of toast that adds a round character to well as fresh, vivid lemon and grapefruit flavors. Drink this delicious, rich wine now.”
91/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2013
“A smoky note of minerality complements the flavors of dried cherry and black currant, almond financier and gumdrop in this refined, creamy version. The delicate yet persistent acidity is well-integrated, leading to a mouthwatering finish. Drink now through 2018”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Sep 2013
“Roederer is one of my go-to champagne. It was a real pleasure to drink - not taste- a glass of the NV Brut Premier to start off this delicious lunch. The mushroom soup was perfect and a great match to the warm, nutty nuances of the Champagne. Sometimes simple is best, and that was certainly the case here.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2013
“Nutty nose. Some great savour. Bone dry and serious. Though not concentrated enough for a very long life.”
94/100
Tyson Stelzer,
TysonStelzer.com,
Dec 2012
“The true star of Roederer, and by far the cheapest, this is quintessential winter champagne. Three-fifths pinots, some old oak maturation and bottle aged for three years add honeyed richness, butterscotch, brioche and cinnamon, finessed with a cut of lemon.”
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles. The 2012 based cuvée is beautifully creamy and lacey with ripe, plush fruitiness but comes with enough acidity. ”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Aug 2026
“MAGNUM - Tasted in August 2026 and was amazed how young and energetic it was tasting and came across as a little tight and needing more time before we see full aromatic development. I believe this one is base 2015, full of ripe yellow fruits and the texture was super silky and full of stone fruit charm. I would imagine these will hit a peak in perhaps mid 2030's.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“There's a QR code on the back. If you have the app you can scan it and learn full details. Based on 2015 (they have just moved on from 2014).
A greenish tinge to deep straw colour. Some real depth on this nose with all the elements building on each other. Really is superior! Great harmony and nothing out of place. Incredibly persistent. Bravo!”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, 20% Meunier. Partial malo, 10% of the wine aged in oak casks, based on 2013 vintage, reserve wine spends up to 10 years in large neutral French oak barrels. 3 years on lees. Dosage 9 g/l.
Pungent and fine – goes straight up the nose! Great balance and completeness. Not sweet but sweet-er. Good texture and unobjectionable. Not the tightest textured but lots of fun.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Based on 2013. Disgorged early 2017. This cuvée is just starting out on the market now. Cool year with an October harvest, so a 150-day growing season. 2013 and the next two years were all glorious for Pinot Noir so there is lots of Pinot in this – 65%, of which 52% is Pinot Noir. 35% Chardonnay. Highest malo ever: 56%. Reserve wines constitute 25% (which is the norm). This includes 7% really old wines. Usually there are eight vintages, in this case back to 2004 maybe aged in old oak plus 18% from the year before in stainless steel. Their role is to add consistency. Typically, there will be 120 different batches of wine in Brut Premier.
Flirtatious and lively. Mouth-filling and satisfying. Dancing and lively. A very superior NV champagne.
Drink 2017-2024”
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2016
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles.”
86/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“The NV Brut Premier is bold, powerful and intense. Hazelnut, smoke, dried pear, mint and savory herbs are all pushed forward. In this release, the Brut Premier is a bit brash and unpolished, with less of its typical finesse. Let's just say I was not surprised to scan the back label and learn that this release is based on the 2011 vintage. Even Roederer could not overcome the significant challenges presented by the 2011 vintage.”
92/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Aug 2015
“A vivacious Champagne, finely knit and elegant overall. This is creamy and satiny in texture, with layers of yellow plum, chalk, toast, glazed apricot and lemon curd. Offers a lingering, smoke- tinged finish. Drink now through 2020.”
92/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2013
“This is a particularly good bottling of Brut Premier. Drawing on Roederer’s famed reserve wines, it has a touch of toast that adds a round character to well as fresh, vivid lemon and grapefruit flavors. Drink this delicious, rich wine now.”
91/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2013
“A smoky note of minerality complements the flavors of dried cherry and black currant, almond financier and gumdrop in this refined, creamy version. The delicate yet persistent acidity is well-integrated, leading to a mouthwatering finish. Drink now through 2018”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Sep 2013
“Roederer is one of my go-to champagne. It was a real pleasure to drink - not taste- a glass of the NV Brut Premier to start off this delicious lunch. The mushroom soup was perfect and a great match to the warm, nutty nuances of the Champagne. Sometimes simple is best, and that was certainly the case here.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2013
“Nutty nose. Some great savour. Bone dry and serious. Though not concentrated enough for a very long life.”
94/100
Tyson Stelzer,
TysonStelzer.com,
Dec 2012
“The true star of Roederer, and by far the cheapest, this is quintessential winter champagne. Three-fifths pinots, some old oak maturation and bottle aged for three years add honeyed richness, butterscotch, brioche and cinnamon, finessed with a cut of lemon.”
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles. The 2012 based cuvée is beautifully creamy and lacey with ripe, plush fruitiness but comes with enough acidity. ”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Aug 2026
“MAGNUM - Tasted in August 2026 and was amazed how young and energetic it was tasting and came across as a little tight and needing more time before we see full aromatic development. I believe this one is base 2015, full of ripe yellow fruits and the texture was super silky and full of stone fruit charm. I would imagine these will hit a peak in perhaps mid 2030's.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“There's a QR code on the back. If you have the app you can scan it and learn full details. Based on 2015 (they have just moved on from 2014).
A greenish tinge to deep straw colour. Some real depth on this nose with all the elements building on each other. Really is superior! Great harmony and nothing out of place. Incredibly persistent. Bravo!”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, 20% Meunier. Partial malo, 10% of the wine aged in oak casks, based on 2013 vintage, reserve wine spends up to 10 years in large neutral French oak barrels. 3 years on lees. Dosage 9 g/l.
Pungent and fine – goes straight up the nose! Great balance and completeness. Not sweet but sweet-er. Good texture and unobjectionable. Not the tightest textured but lots of fun.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Based on 2013. Disgorged early 2017. This cuvée is just starting out on the market now. Cool year with an October harvest, so a 150-day growing season. 2013 and the next two years were all glorious for Pinot Noir so there is lots of Pinot in this – 65%, of which 52% is Pinot Noir. 35% Chardonnay. Highest malo ever: 56%. Reserve wines constitute 25% (which is the norm). This includes 7% really old wines. Usually there are eight vintages, in this case back to 2004 maybe aged in old oak plus 18% from the year before in stainless steel. Their role is to add consistency. Typically, there will be 120 different batches of wine in Brut Premier.
Flirtatious and lively. Mouth-filling and satisfying. Dancing and lively. A very superior NV champagne.
Drink 2017-2024”
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2016
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles.”
86/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“The NV Brut Premier is bold, powerful and intense. Hazelnut, smoke, dried pear, mint and savory herbs are all pushed forward. In this release, the Brut Premier is a bit brash and unpolished, with less of its typical finesse. Let's just say I was not surprised to scan the back label and learn that this release is based on the 2011 vintage. Even Roederer could not overcome the significant challenges presented by the 2011 vintage.”
92/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Aug 2015
“A vivacious Champagne, finely knit and elegant overall. This is creamy and satiny in texture, with layers of yellow plum, chalk, toast, glazed apricot and lemon curd. Offers a lingering, smoke- tinged finish. Drink now through 2020.”
92/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2013
“This is a particularly good bottling of Brut Premier. Drawing on Roederer’s famed reserve wines, it has a touch of toast that adds a round character to well as fresh, vivid lemon and grapefruit flavors. Drink this delicious, rich wine now.”
91/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2013
“A smoky note of minerality complements the flavors of dried cherry and black currant, almond financier and gumdrop in this refined, creamy version. The delicate yet persistent acidity is well-integrated, leading to a mouthwatering finish. Drink now through 2018”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Sep 2013
“Roederer is one of my go-to champagne. It was a real pleasure to drink - not taste- a glass of the NV Brut Premier to start off this delicious lunch. The mushroom soup was perfect and a great match to the warm, nutty nuances of the Champagne. Sometimes simple is best, and that was certainly the case here.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2013
“Nutty nose. Some great savour. Bone dry and serious. Though not concentrated enough for a very long life.”
94/100
Tyson Stelzer,
TysonStelzer.com,
Dec 2012
“The true star of Roederer, and by far the cheapest, this is quintessential winter champagne. Three-fifths pinots, some old oak maturation and bottle aged for three years add honeyed richness, butterscotch, brioche and cinnamon, finessed with a cut of lemon.”
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles. The 2012 based cuvée is beautifully creamy and lacey with ripe, plush fruitiness but comes with enough acidity. ”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Aug 2026
“MAGNUM - Tasted in August 2026 and was amazed how young and energetic it was tasting and came across as a little tight and needing more time before we see full aromatic development. I believe this one is base 2015, full of ripe yellow fruits and the texture was super silky and full of stone fruit charm. I would imagine these will hit a peak in perhaps mid 2030's.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“There's a QR code on the back. If you have the app you can scan it and learn full details. Based on 2015 (they have just moved on from 2014).
A greenish tinge to deep straw colour. Some real depth on this nose with all the elements building on each other. Really is superior! Great harmony and nothing out of place. Incredibly persistent. Bravo!”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, 20% Meunier. Partial malo, 10% of the wine aged in oak casks, based on 2013 vintage, reserve wine spends up to 10 years in large neutral French oak barrels. 3 years on lees. Dosage 9 g/l.
Pungent and fine – goes straight up the nose! Great balance and completeness. Not sweet but sweet-er. Good texture and unobjectionable. Not the tightest textured but lots of fun.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Based on 2013. Disgorged early 2017. This cuvée is just starting out on the market now. Cool year with an October harvest, so a 150-day growing season. 2013 and the next two years were all glorious for Pinot Noir so there is lots of Pinot in this – 65%, of which 52% is Pinot Noir. 35% Chardonnay. Highest malo ever: 56%. Reserve wines constitute 25% (which is the norm). This includes 7% really old wines. Usually there are eight vintages, in this case back to 2004 maybe aged in old oak plus 18% from the year before in stainless steel. Their role is to add consistency. Typically, there will be 120 different batches of wine in Brut Premier.
Flirtatious and lively. Mouth-filling and satisfying. Dancing and lively. A very superior NV champagne.
Drink 2017-2024”
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2016
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles.”
86/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“The NV Brut Premier is bold, powerful and intense. Hazelnut, smoke, dried pear, mint and savory herbs are all pushed forward. In this release, the Brut Premier is a bit brash and unpolished, with less of its typical finesse. Let's just say I was not surprised to scan the back label and learn that this release is based on the 2011 vintage. Even Roederer could not overcome the significant challenges presented by the 2011 vintage.”
92/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Aug 2015
“A vivacious Champagne, finely knit and elegant overall. This is creamy and satiny in texture, with layers of yellow plum, chalk, toast, glazed apricot and lemon curd. Offers a lingering, smoke- tinged finish. Drink now through 2020.”
92/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2013
“This is a particularly good bottling of Brut Premier. Drawing on Roederer’s famed reserve wines, it has a touch of toast that adds a round character to well as fresh, vivid lemon and grapefruit flavors. Drink this delicious, rich wine now.”
91/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2013
“A smoky note of minerality complements the flavors of dried cherry and black currant, almond financier and gumdrop in this refined, creamy version. The delicate yet persistent acidity is well-integrated, leading to a mouthwatering finish. Drink now through 2018”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Sep 2013
“Roederer is one of my go-to champagne. It was a real pleasure to drink - not taste- a glass of the NV Brut Premier to start off this delicious lunch. The mushroom soup was perfect and a great match to the warm, nutty nuances of the Champagne. Sometimes simple is best, and that was certainly the case here.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2013
“Nutty nose. Some great savour. Bone dry and serious. Though not concentrated enough for a very long life.”
94/100
Tyson Stelzer,
TysonStelzer.com,
Dec 2012
“The true star of Roederer, and by far the cheapest, this is quintessential winter champagne. Three-fifths pinots, some old oak maturation and bottle aged for three years add honeyed richness, butterscotch, brioche and cinnamon, finessed with a cut of lemon.”
“A grand pinnacle and dependable bargain in the non-vintage Champagne stakes.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Robert Parker Jr,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2020
“This is a beautiful Brut Premier that will age in style.”
90-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2019
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles. The 2012 based cuvée is beautifully creamy and lacey with ripe, plush fruitiness but comes with enough acidity. ”
17.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Aug 2026
“MAGNUM - Tasted in August 2026 and was amazed how young and energetic it was tasting and came across as a little tight and needing more time before we see full aromatic development. I believe this one is base 2015, full of ripe yellow fruits and the texture was super silky and full of stone fruit charm. I would imagine these will hit a peak in perhaps mid 2030's.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“There's a QR code on the back. If you have the app you can scan it and learn full details. Based on 2015 (they have just moved on from 2014).
A greenish tinge to deep straw colour. Some real depth on this nose with all the elements building on each other. Really is superior! Great harmony and nothing out of place. Incredibly persistent. Bravo!”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“40% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, 20% Meunier. Partial malo, 10% of the wine aged in oak casks, based on 2013 vintage, reserve wine spends up to 10 years in large neutral French oak barrels. 3 years on lees. Dosage 9 g/l.
Pungent and fine – goes straight up the nose! Great balance and completeness. Not sweet but sweet-er. Good texture and unobjectionable. Not the tightest textured but lots of fun.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Based on 2013. Disgorged early 2017. This cuvée is just starting out on the market now. Cool year with an October harvest, so a 150-day growing season. 2013 and the next two years were all glorious for Pinot Noir so there is lots of Pinot in this – 65%, of which 52% is Pinot Noir. 35% Chardonnay. Highest malo ever: 56%. Reserve wines constitute 25% (which is the norm). This includes 7% really old wines. Usually there are eight vintages, in this case back to 2004 maybe aged in old oak plus 18% from the year before in stainless steel. Their role is to add consistency. Typically, there will be 120 different batches of wine in Brut Premier.
Flirtatious and lively. Mouth-filling and satisfying. Dancing and lively. A very superior NV champagne.
Drink 2017-2024”
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2016
“Soft, subdued white fruit character with a classy charred toasty nose underneath. Lovely mineral touch. Zesty, seamlessly intertwined lean and compact palate of lovely acid line. Delicate and silky with the softest mousse. Always benefits from post-disgorgement ageing. The most elegant of the Grand Marque non-vintages. 10 year-old bottles can be stunning but already 1-2 years makes miracles.”
86/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“The NV Brut Premier is bold, powerful and intense. Hazelnut, smoke, dried pear, mint and savory herbs are all pushed forward. In this release, the Brut Premier is a bit brash and unpolished, with less of its typical finesse. Let's just say I was not surprised to scan the back label and learn that this release is based on the 2011 vintage. Even Roederer could not overcome the significant challenges presented by the 2011 vintage.”
92/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Aug 2015
“A vivacious Champagne, finely knit and elegant overall. This is creamy and satiny in texture, with layers of yellow plum, chalk, toast, glazed apricot and lemon curd. Offers a lingering, smoke- tinged finish. Drink now through 2020.”
92/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2013
“This is a particularly good bottling of Brut Premier. Drawing on Roederer’s famed reserve wines, it has a touch of toast that adds a round character to well as fresh, vivid lemon and grapefruit flavors. Drink this delicious, rich wine now.”
91/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2013
“A smoky note of minerality complements the flavors of dried cherry and black currant, almond financier and gumdrop in this refined, creamy version. The delicate yet persistent acidity is well-integrated, leading to a mouthwatering finish. Drink now through 2018”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Sep 2013
“Roederer is one of my go-to champagne. It was a real pleasure to drink - not taste- a glass of the NV Brut Premier to start off this delicious lunch. The mushroom soup was perfect and a great match to the warm, nutty nuances of the Champagne. Sometimes simple is best, and that was certainly the case here.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2013
“Nutty nose. Some great savour. Bone dry and serious. Though not concentrated enough for a very long life.”
94/100
Tyson Stelzer,
TysonStelzer.com,
Dec 2012
“The true star of Roederer, and by far the cheapest, this is quintessential winter champagne. Three-fifths pinots, some old oak maturation and bottle aged for three years add honeyed richness, butterscotch, brioche and cinnamon, finessed with a cut of lemon.”
“Extremely intense nose with an explosion of life. Light smokiness and crème patissière. By no means bone dry, in fact the fruit is positively exuberant. Like a rich lemon mousse. I like it!
Full bottle 1,602 g. Early harvest from 27 August to 8 September. The main component, 80% of the blend, is Pinot Noir from Verzy, supplemented by 20% Chardonnay from Chouilly. 28% of the base wine saw oak, 20% of it went through malo. The 2018 is described as ‘the end of an era’ because the Pinot Noir on north-facing vines in Verzy now achieves such phenolic ripeness that it is possible to make a wine entirely from these grapes. The 2019 vintage is a Blanc de Noirs, something Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon has wanted to do for many years. ‘La Montagne’ is cited on the back label, a reference to the fact that all the grapes came from their vineyards on the Montagne de Reims (as opposed to ‘La Côte’ for the Côte des Blancs vineyards and ‘La Rivière’ for their vineyards in the Vallée de la Marne). Dosage 7 g/l.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
Feb 2026
“Louis Roederer's vintage cuvée is 80% hailing from the northern Montagne de Reims in Pinot Noir in the ripe, approachable 2018 vintage, with the remaining 20% in Chardonnay from Chouilly. The inherent freshness of these northern slopes really benefits the style in such a vintage, with a little more precision and restraint than is sometimes present in 2018 even if the sunny cherry, sweet apple and clementine fruit is still aromatically very ripe. This is polished, silken and gently warmed-up with almond macaron richness and toasted brown bread notes, persistent rather than hugely intense but still standing to benefit from further ageing and integration of the brut dosage.”
94/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Mar 2026
“Coming from Verzy and Chouilly, the 2018 Champagne Vintage Brut has 80% Pinot Noir from Verzy and is the last vintage to include Chardonnay from Chouilly. Historically, the Chardonnay was included in the blend to soften the austerity of the Pinot Noir; however, with these recent vintages and warming conditions, this is no longer necessary, as the Pinot Noir is fully ripe and appealing on its own. In the glass, it offers aromas of pure red cherries, fresh flowers, bright spice, and wild raspberries. Medium to full-bodied, it has compact definition, a pillowy mousse, a chalky texture, and mouthwatering tangerine notes on the finish. While I am eagerly anticipating the 2019 release, this holds a fantastic place in the range to enjoy now or over the next 15 or so years.”
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2026
“Definite chalky notes on the aromatics and palate and a rich textural delight, this has “big mouthfeel” and builds on and on. The citrus palate dominates the entry, then you get grapefruit, hints of pineapple and super delicious red fruit, like ripe raspberry and dark plum. This is going to develop into a very classy champagne as the tension and attractive fruit are only just showing its greatness at this age.”
“Louis Roederer's 2016 Brut Vintage is derived primarily from Pinot Noir from Verzy and incorporates 32% Chardonnay from Chouilly, though this is about to change with the 2019 release, when it will become a pure Verzy, giving stronger identity to the village. The soil here is rich in clay, and the slopes face east, explains Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon. Disgorged in June 2024 with seven grams per liter dosage, it wafts from the glass with a bouquet of juicy pear, red berries, hazelnut and smoke. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and textural, it has a slightly richer core of fruit compared to the more delicate and citrusy Blanc de Blancs and will richly reward a few additional years under cork.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2016 Vintage is terrific. Rich, creamy and super-expressive, the 2016 is an absolute delight. All this fruit is from Roederer’s La Montagne estate, with Pinot Noir very much driving the blend. That comes through in a Champagne of notable textural resonance and breadth that grows with air. Hints of apricot, plum, spice and dried flowers caress the palate, all framed by a discreet touch of oak and an extra kick of texture from a few lots (5%) that underwent malolactic fermentation. This is a superb edition of the Vintage. The blend is 68% Pinot Noir and 32% Chardonnay. Here, the richness of the warm summer very much comes through. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. ”
96/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“Complex nose of restrained strawberries and lemon zest, with macerated flowers and shortbread. Full body and plenty of concentration, with pinprick mousse, long and chewy, integrated acidity and amazing length. Pinot noir and chardonnay. Drink or hold.”
95+/100
Lisa Perrotti-Brown MW,
Thewineindependent.com,
Aug 2024
“The 2016 Vintage Brut is a blend of 68% Pinot Noir and 32% Chardonnay with 7 grams per liter of dosage. Only 5% of the blend underwent malo-lactic, and 33% of the base wines were aged in French oak. Showy notes of Red Delicious apples, ripe pears, hon- eycomb, and cashews prance out of the glass, giving way to underlying orange blossom and fresh ginger scents. To its credit, the palate is on the dry side, with its sweetness coming from ripe fruit as opposed to added dosage, offset by supportive yet skillfully bal- anced acidity, showcasing the ripe, nuanced, seductive fruit, finishing long and creamy. More gregarious than its 2016 Cristal counterpart, this is a flamboyant yet age-worthy Vintage Brut. Love it.”
“Louis Roederer's 2016 Brut Vintage is derived primarily from Pinot Noir from Verzy and incorporates 32% Chardonnay from Chouilly, though this is about to change with the 2019 release, when it will become a pure Verzy, giving stronger identity to the village. The soil here is rich in clay, and the slopes face east, explains Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon. Disgorged in June 2024 with seven grams per liter dosage, it wafts from the glass with a bouquet of juicy pear, red berries, hazelnut and smoke. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and textural, it has a slightly richer core of fruit compared to the more delicate and citrusy Blanc de Blancs and will richly reward a few additional years under cork.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2016 Vintage is terrific. Rich, creamy and super-expressive, the 2016 is an absolute delight. All this fruit is from Roederer’s La Montagne estate, with Pinot Noir very much driving the blend. That comes through in a Champagne of notable textural resonance and breadth that grows with air. Hints of apricot, plum, spice and dried flowers caress the palate, all framed by a discreet touch of oak and an extra kick of texture from a few lots (5%) that underwent malolactic fermentation. This is a superb edition of the Vintage. The blend is 68% Pinot Noir and 32% Chardonnay. Here, the richness of the warm summer very much comes through. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. ”
96/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“Complex nose of restrained strawberries and lemon zest, with macerated flowers and shortbread. Full body and plenty of concentration, with pinprick mousse, long and chewy, integrated acidity and amazing length. Pinot noir and chardonnay. Drink or hold.”
95+/100
Lisa Perrotti-Brown MW,
Thewineindependent.com,
Aug 2024
“The 2016 Vintage Brut is a blend of 68% Pinot Noir and 32% Chardonnay with 7 grams per liter of dosage. Only 5% of the blend underwent malo-lactic, and 33% of the base wines were aged in French oak. Showy notes of Red Delicious apples, ripe pears, hon- eycomb, and cashews prance out of the glass, giving way to underlying orange blossom and fresh ginger scents. To its credit, the palate is on the dry side, with its sweetness coming from ripe fruit as opposed to added dosage, offset by supportive yet skillfully bal- anced acidity, showcasing the ripe, nuanced, seductive fruit, finishing long and creamy. More gregarious than its 2016 Cristal counterpart, this is a flamboyant yet age-worthy Vintage Brut. Love it.”
“Pale lemon color. Soft, fruity nose, with creamy-leesy tones and some toast and hay adding on the secondary aromatics. A mélange of ripe orchard fruit, with apple and peach at the fore. A faint vegetal tone is well-hidden under the pristine fruitiness. The palate matches the nose, with appealing, sweet fruitiness and its creamy textural qualities in the refined, cushiony mousse. Long, juicy length of softness and pristine fruit. An appealing whole, with good freshness and energy. Pleasurable already but worth cellaring further.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“This is the most focussed and best 2015 I have tasted, delicious fruit, hints of chalky charm, and a velvety smooth texture. Best wine of the tasting for me today and such great value. Goes without saying lie down some magnums, they age very slowly and bring and even more rewarding texture.”
“Pale lemon color. Soft, fruity nose, with creamy-leesy tones and some toast and hay adding on the secondary aromatics. A mélange of ripe orchard fruit, with apple and peach at the fore. A faint vegetal tone is well-hidden under the pristine fruitiness. The palate matches the nose, with appealing, sweet fruitiness and its creamy textural qualities in the refined, cushiony mousse. Long, juicy length of softness and pristine fruit. An appealing whole, with good freshness and energy. Pleasurable already but worth cellaring further.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“This is the most focussed and best 2015 I have tasted, delicious fruit, hints of chalky charm, and a velvety smooth texture. Best wine of the tasting for me today and such great value. Goes without saying lie down some magnums, they age very slowly and bring and even more rewarding texture.”
“Roederer's 2014 Brut Vintage is beautiful, offering up aromas of pear, mirabelle plum, red berries, warm biscuits and smoke. Full-bodied, layered and elegantly muscular, it's seamless and complete, with terrific mid-palate depth and amplitude. Framed by bright acids and enlivened by a pinpoint mousse, it concludes with a penetrating finish. The blend is 70% Pinot Noir, emphasizing Verzy, and pressure is a touch higher than in its more ethereal Blanc de Blancs counterpart. As I wrote of its 2013 predecessor, this is a wine that puts many prestige cuvées to shame.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Already the nose impresses with its fruity depths: smoke-complexed, powerful red-fruit tones, baked peach and fragrant flowers. Here, the racy and intense Verzy Pinot Noir is complemented by the fresh yet supple Chouilly Chardonnay, creating something powerful, brisk yet delicious. This vintage is so inviting and open from day one. Pure pleasure. Dosage 8g/l”
“Roederer's 2014 Brut Vintage is beautiful, offering up aromas of pear, mirabelle plum, red berries, warm biscuits and smoke. Full-bodied, layered and elegantly muscular, it's seamless and complete, with terrific mid-palate depth and amplitude. Framed by bright acids and enlivened by a pinpoint mousse, it concludes with a penetrating finish. The blend is 70% Pinot Noir, emphasizing Verzy, and pressure is a touch higher than in its more ethereal Blanc de Blancs counterpart. As I wrote of its 2013 predecessor, this is a wine that puts many prestige cuvées to shame.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Already the nose impresses with its fruity depths: smoke-complexed, powerful red-fruit tones, baked peach and fragrant flowers. Here, the racy and intense Verzy Pinot Noir is complemented by the fresh yet supple Chouilly Chardonnay, creating something powerful, brisk yet delicious. This vintage is so inviting and open from day one. Pure pleasure. Dosage 8g/l”
“To be launched October 2019. Disgorged January to March 2019. 80% Verzy Pinot Noir. Plus 20% Chardonnay from an east-southeast-facing site in Chouilly. This was the last October harvest and the malic was quite high so they did 25% malo. Lécaillon described this 80:20 as his favourite blend.
Very winning and glamorous. Beautifully balanced. A powerful thread running through it. Creamy texture.”
More Reviews +
94-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“Pale lemon green colour. Stunningly pure nose of cool, restrained fruitiness. Highly refined toastiness mingles with the juicy yuzy and floral tones. The fruit is just as crisp and crunchy on the palate as it was on the nose. Feels light but there is plenty of focused intensity to it. Mouthwatering acidity with succulent and energetic feel to the palate but the soft, creamy mousse balances the raciness beautifully. ”
95/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Roederer's newly released 2013 Brut Vintage is showing brilliantly, unwinding in the glass with a youthfully reserved but incipiently complex bouquet of crisp yellow orchard fruit, citrus zest, fresh bread and honeycomb. Medium to full-bodied, deep and concentrated, this is a tightly coiled, elegantly muscular Champagne, its layered core of fruit built around an incisive spine of acidity. Seamless and complete, this is an over-performing vintage that puts many prestige cuvées to shame. Built to age, it will reward patience.”
“70% Pinot Noir, 30% Chardonnay. 16% malo and 8% oak fermentation. Disgorged in early 2017. Picked very ripe at 11.3-11.5% potential alcohol, and deliberately reductive.
Smoky nose and then quite rich and dense. Masses of hedonistic pleasure.”
More Reviews +
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2017
“Layered complexity of subdued toastiness over bright, fragrant fruitness. Light-weight yet intense, ripe fruity profile. Beautifully racy acidity on the linear, driven palate. Focused, creamy and long. ”
97/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2020
“Medium greenish-yellow, silver reflections; exquisite, vital mousse. Delicate brioche, a hint of yellow tropical fruit underlaid with white flower scent and a light caramel note. Good complexity, juicy, integrated acidity, animated style, fine melon touch on the finish, lovely savoury echo. Certainly has potential.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“70% Verzy Pinot Noir. Plus Chardonnay from Chouilly, east-southeast-facing. No malo because it was such a ripe harvest.
Pale straw gold. Explosive nose. Rich and explosive. Lécaillon’s best Pinots since 1990, he says ('but both are beaten by 2018'). Lots to chew on. Tight but rich and generous on the mid palate at the moment. This may shut down, Lécaillon thinks.”
93+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“Roederer’s 2012 Brut Vintage will give readers a very good idea of what to expect in this vintage. Racy and voluptuous, with striking resonance, the 2012 is ample, creamy and wonderfully inviting. Baked apple, brioche, pastry, spice and light tropical notes all flesh out in a radiant Champagne that drinks well right out of the gate. There is plenty of vintage 2012 concentration and ripeness, and yet the Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon managed to retain considerable energy here as well. This is such a compelling Champagne.”
“Aromas of cooked apple, bread dough and lemon tart follow through to a full body with round, delicious fruit and a rich, flavorful finish. Yet, it remains tight and fine with lovely, compressed bubbles. New energy and freshness. Medium-to full-bodied with layers of fruit and vivid intensity. 42% chardonnay, 36% pinot noir and 22% pinot meunier. 8 grams dosage. Four years on the less. A new-format non-vintage that designates the year of the 242nd harvest, 2017, plus reserve wine of 2009, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2016. Drink or hold.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The new climate and era have led Louis Roederer to replace its Brut Premier with 'Collection'. The new cuvée’s resilience derives from the perpetual reserve of previous vintages. In the challenging 2017 vintage, Chardonnay was blended to play an important role. The result is a rich Champagne of fine depth. The delicious, brightly fruity nose with peach, lemongrass, green apple, vanilla, hazelnut and ginger turns beautifully toasty. The taste is softly lush, but fresh and elegantly layered. It comes with Roederer's hallmark soft mousse, and a pure, invigoratingly fresh finish. Dosage 8g/l”
93+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Roederer's Brut Premier was created in the 1980s to prove to consumers that we could deliver consistent quality with a blend that compensated for less than perfectly ripe vintages," explains Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon. "We were blending in pursuit of maturity, of ripeness. The concept behind the Brut Collection is the opposite: we're looking for freshness—and we are embracing singularity, something we're emphasizing by enumerating each year's blend." This project has been in the making since 2012, when Lecaillon set aside 21,000 liters of wine to constitute a perpetual reserve aged in large tanks without malolactic fermentation. Sourcing has evolved too: less must is coming from cooperatives, and only vineyards cultivated without the use of herbicides inform the blend. A dedicated team oversees all this, visiting every grower three times per year. And vinification is parcel by parcel to deliver a maximum of blending components. Iteration 242 is based on the 2017 vintage (56%), supplemented by 34% reserve wines from the perpetual reserve established in 2012 and 10% foudre-aged reserve wines.
So much for the composition and concept of the new NV Brut Collection 242, but how does it taste? This debut release is very impressive indeed, wafting from the glass with notes of pear, peach, ripe citrus fruit, toasted almonds, fresh pastry and white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and textural, it's concentrated and layered, with lively acids, an enlivening pinpoint mousse and a long, sapid finish. Brut Premier was already a very persuasive wine, but the new Brut Collection nevertheless represents a step up.”
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“The nose is a trio of Mirabelle plum, salted shortbread and freshly-cut yellow apple flesh, suggesting ripest fruit. The palate immediately dials this impression back with vivid briskness and a lovely, salty edge along with the scant bitterness of the pillowy citrus pith you find on thick-skinned pink grapefruit. But there is roundness and generosity at the heart, beautiful depth and lively, fine, brisk mousse. That enticing and rather mouth-watering edge of bitterness re-emerges seductively on the finish.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2021
“The NV Collection 242 is a new wine from Roederer that replaces the Brut Premier in the range. The Collection (which now will be numbered by harvest) is a blend of three components: a perpetual reserve done in the classic non-malo Roederer style, reserve wines in oak with a touch of malo, and a base vintage, in this case 2017. That blend results in a NV Champagne that offers lovely richness and resonance, with plenty of yellow orchard fruit and floral character. Whereas Brut Premier was typically a focused, nervy wine that, while consistently excellent, also was not always in line with the Roederer house style, the 242 tastes more like a Roederer Champagne in terms of its complexity. Incidentally, there is no Vintage, Cristal or Cristal Rosé in 2017, so all the best lots went into this bottling. Dosage is 8 grams per liter, so lower than the 9 or so that was typical for recent Brut Premier and much lower than the 12-13 that was once customary. The 242 was also bottled with a bit less sugar than the norm, which results in lower atmospheres of pressure in the bottle and silkier texture.
“Brut Premier was created in the late 1970s and 1980s, when we struggled to ripen,” Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon explained. “It was our way of compensating for lack of ripeness in the field and the variability of quality across vintages. Because of climate change, achieving ripeness is not an issue today. Instead, our challenge is maintaining freshness and precision. For that reason, we decided to re-think our NV and start from a place of positive rather than negative selection.””
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2021
“New substitute for Brut Premier NV taking its name from Roederer's 242nd harvest with this debut bottling based on 2017 but containing 10% reserve wines aged in oak from 2009, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2016 plus 34% wine from a perpetual reserve (sort of solera) that has been built up since 2012, for 242 made up of equal parts from every vintage from 2012 to 2016 inclusive. The packaging is extremely similar to that of Brut Premier. Scannable QR code on the back label for more information. Roederer's notes: '2017, the base vintage for Collection 242, was a year of living dangerously! An exceptionally warm and dry winter and spring, but the latter brought severe frosts from 17 to 29 April, setting the sorry record for 12 nights of frost. These were followed by a dull, wet and not particularly hot summer, which ended in an almost tropical (hot and humid) spell at the end of August. This sudden change led to a significant increase in grey rot on the ripening Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier grapes. The harvest was fast-paced and completed very quickly, demanding precise and methodical selection work, of an unprecedented level even for Roederer. The harvest took place from 31 August to 9 September 2017. A third each from the Vallée de la Marne, the Côte des Blancs and the Montagne de Reims. 42% Chardonnay (the most successful variety in 2017), 36% Pinot Noir, 22% Pinot Meunier. Only 34% went through malo.' Dosage is 8 g/l (whereas Brut Premier used to be 9 g/l).
"Deep straw colour and tiny, tiny bead. Really satisfying, complete, beautifully balanced nose with some evolution and richness. A little bit of toastiness and it tastes pretty ripe. Very different indeed from a Brut Zéro champagne! Firm. Some tasters may object to the dosage. But it's a beautiful wine."”
91-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“The new climate and era have made Louis Roederer replace its Brut Premier with Collection. The new cuvée’s resilience derives from the “perpetual reserve” (Réserve perpétuelle) of previous vintages. In the challenging 2017 vintage, Chardonnay was made to play an important role. The result is rich with fine depth. It comes with nicely toasted, ripe fruity aroma with vanilla, lemon and hazelnut. The taste is softly lush but fresh and elegantly layered.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2017 vintage, Roederer's NV Brut Collection 242 continues to drink very well, offering up aromas of pear, orange zest, white flowers, almonds and hazelnuts. Medium to full-bodied, ample and fleshy, with racy acids and a bright, saline finish, it's a great success in a challenging base year.”
“Aromas of cooked apple, bread dough and lemon tart follow through to a full body with round, delicious fruit and a rich, flavorful finish. Yet, it remains tight and fine with lovely, compressed bubbles. New energy and freshness. Medium-to full-bodied with layers of fruit and vivid intensity. 42% chardonnay, 36% pinot noir and 22% pinot meunier. 8 grams dosage. Four years on the less. A new-format non-vintage that designates the year of the 242nd harvest, 2017, plus reserve wine of 2009, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2016. Drink or hold.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The new climate and era have led Louis Roederer to replace its Brut Premier with 'Collection'. The new cuvée’s resilience derives from the perpetual reserve of previous vintages. In the challenging 2017 vintage, Chardonnay was blended to play an important role. The result is a rich Champagne of fine depth. The delicious, brightly fruity nose with peach, lemongrass, green apple, vanilla, hazelnut and ginger turns beautifully toasty. The taste is softly lush, but fresh and elegantly layered. It comes with Roederer's hallmark soft mousse, and a pure, invigoratingly fresh finish. Dosage 8g/l”
93+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Roederer's Brut Premier was created in the 1980s to prove to consumers that we could deliver consistent quality with a blend that compensated for less than perfectly ripe vintages," explains Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon. "We were blending in pursuit of maturity, of ripeness. The concept behind the Brut Collection is the opposite: we're looking for freshness—and we are embracing singularity, something we're emphasizing by enumerating each year's blend." This project has been in the making since 2012, when Lecaillon set aside 21,000 liters of wine to constitute a perpetual reserve aged in large tanks without malolactic fermentation. Sourcing has evolved too: less must is coming from cooperatives, and only vineyards cultivated without the use of herbicides inform the blend. A dedicated team oversees all this, visiting every grower three times per year. And vinification is parcel by parcel to deliver a maximum of blending components. Iteration 242 is based on the 2017 vintage (56%), supplemented by 34% reserve wines from the perpetual reserve established in 2012 and 10% foudre-aged reserve wines.
So much for the composition and concept of the new NV Brut Collection 242, but how does it taste? This debut release is very impressive indeed, wafting from the glass with notes of pear, peach, ripe citrus fruit, toasted almonds, fresh pastry and white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and textural, it's concentrated and layered, with lively acids, an enlivening pinpoint mousse and a long, sapid finish. Brut Premier was already a very persuasive wine, but the new Brut Collection nevertheless represents a step up.”
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“The nose is a trio of Mirabelle plum, salted shortbread and freshly-cut yellow apple flesh, suggesting ripest fruit. The palate immediately dials this impression back with vivid briskness and a lovely, salty edge along with the scant bitterness of the pillowy citrus pith you find on thick-skinned pink grapefruit. But there is roundness and generosity at the heart, beautiful depth and lively, fine, brisk mousse. That enticing and rather mouth-watering edge of bitterness re-emerges seductively on the finish.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2021
“The NV Collection 242 is a new wine from Roederer that replaces the Brut Premier in the range. The Collection (which now will be numbered by harvest) is a blend of three components: a perpetual reserve done in the classic non-malo Roederer style, reserve wines in oak with a touch of malo, and a base vintage, in this case 2017. That blend results in a NV Champagne that offers lovely richness and resonance, with plenty of yellow orchard fruit and floral character. Whereas Brut Premier was typically a focused, nervy wine that, while consistently excellent, also was not always in line with the Roederer house style, the 242 tastes more like a Roederer Champagne in terms of its complexity. Incidentally, there is no Vintage, Cristal or Cristal Rosé in 2017, so all the best lots went into this bottling. Dosage is 8 grams per liter, so lower than the 9 or so that was typical for recent Brut Premier and much lower than the 12-13 that was once customary. The 242 was also bottled with a bit less sugar than the norm, which results in lower atmospheres of pressure in the bottle and silkier texture.
“Brut Premier was created in the late 1970s and 1980s, when we struggled to ripen,” Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon explained. “It was our way of compensating for lack of ripeness in the field and the variability of quality across vintages. Because of climate change, achieving ripeness is not an issue today. Instead, our challenge is maintaining freshness and precision. For that reason, we decided to re-think our NV and start from a place of positive rather than negative selection.””
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2021
“New substitute for Brut Premier NV taking its name from Roederer's 242nd harvest with this debut bottling based on 2017 but containing 10% reserve wines aged in oak from 2009, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2016 plus 34% wine from a perpetual reserve (sort of solera) that has been built up since 2012, for 242 made up of equal parts from every vintage from 2012 to 2016 inclusive. The packaging is extremely similar to that of Brut Premier. Scannable QR code on the back label for more information. Roederer's notes: '2017, the base vintage for Collection 242, was a year of living dangerously! An exceptionally warm and dry winter and spring, but the latter brought severe frosts from 17 to 29 April, setting the sorry record for 12 nights of frost. These were followed by a dull, wet and not particularly hot summer, which ended in an almost tropical (hot and humid) spell at the end of August. This sudden change led to a significant increase in grey rot on the ripening Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier grapes. The harvest was fast-paced and completed very quickly, demanding precise and methodical selection work, of an unprecedented level even for Roederer. The harvest took place from 31 August to 9 September 2017. A third each from the Vallée de la Marne, the Côte des Blancs and the Montagne de Reims. 42% Chardonnay (the most successful variety in 2017), 36% Pinot Noir, 22% Pinot Meunier. Only 34% went through malo.' Dosage is 8 g/l (whereas Brut Premier used to be 9 g/l).
"Deep straw colour and tiny, tiny bead. Really satisfying, complete, beautifully balanced nose with some evolution and richness. A little bit of toastiness and it tastes pretty ripe. Very different indeed from a Brut Zéro champagne! Firm. Some tasters may object to the dosage. But it's a beautiful wine."”
91-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“The new climate and era have made Louis Roederer replace its Brut Premier with Collection. The new cuvée’s resilience derives from the “perpetual reserve” (Réserve perpétuelle) of previous vintages. In the challenging 2017 vintage, Chardonnay was made to play an important role. The result is rich with fine depth. It comes with nicely toasted, ripe fruity aroma with vanilla, lemon and hazelnut. The taste is softly lush but fresh and elegantly layered.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2017 vintage, Roederer's NV Brut Collection 242 continues to drink very well, offering up aromas of pear, orange zest, white flowers, almonds and hazelnuts. Medium to full-bodied, ample and fleshy, with racy acids and a bright, saline finish, it's a great success in a challenging base year.”
“Aromas of cooked apple, bread dough and lemon tart follow through to a full body with round, delicious fruit and a rich, flavorful finish. Yet, it remains tight and fine with lovely, compressed bubbles. New energy and freshness. Medium-to full-bodied with layers of fruit and vivid intensity. 42% chardonnay, 36% pinot noir and 22% pinot meunier. 8 grams dosage. Four years on the less. A new-format non-vintage that designates the year of the 242nd harvest, 2017, plus reserve wine of 2009, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2016. Drink or hold.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The new climate and era have led Louis Roederer to replace its Brut Premier with 'Collection'. The new cuvée’s resilience derives from the perpetual reserve of previous vintages. In the challenging 2017 vintage, Chardonnay was blended to play an important role. The result is a rich Champagne of fine depth. The delicious, brightly fruity nose with peach, lemongrass, green apple, vanilla, hazelnut and ginger turns beautifully toasty. The taste is softly lush, but fresh and elegantly layered. It comes with Roederer's hallmark soft mousse, and a pure, invigoratingly fresh finish. Dosage 8g/l”
93+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“Roederer's Brut Premier was created in the 1980s to prove to consumers that we could deliver consistent quality with a blend that compensated for less than perfectly ripe vintages," explains Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon. "We were blending in pursuit of maturity, of ripeness. The concept behind the Brut Collection is the opposite: we're looking for freshness—and we are embracing singularity, something we're emphasizing by enumerating each year's blend." This project has been in the making since 2012, when Lecaillon set aside 21,000 liters of wine to constitute a perpetual reserve aged in large tanks without malolactic fermentation. Sourcing has evolved too: less must is coming from cooperatives, and only vineyards cultivated without the use of herbicides inform the blend. A dedicated team oversees all this, visiting every grower three times per year. And vinification is parcel by parcel to deliver a maximum of blending components. Iteration 242 is based on the 2017 vintage (56%), supplemented by 34% reserve wines from the perpetual reserve established in 2012 and 10% foudre-aged reserve wines.
So much for the composition and concept of the new NV Brut Collection 242, but how does it taste? This debut release is very impressive indeed, wafting from the glass with notes of pear, peach, ripe citrus fruit, toasted almonds, fresh pastry and white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and textural, it's concentrated and layered, with lively acids, an enlivening pinpoint mousse and a long, sapid finish. Brut Premier was already a very persuasive wine, but the new Brut Collection nevertheless represents a step up.”
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“The nose is a trio of Mirabelle plum, salted shortbread and freshly-cut yellow apple flesh, suggesting ripest fruit. The palate immediately dials this impression back with vivid briskness and a lovely, salty edge along with the scant bitterness of the pillowy citrus pith you find on thick-skinned pink grapefruit. But there is roundness and generosity at the heart, beautiful depth and lively, fine, brisk mousse. That enticing and rather mouth-watering edge of bitterness re-emerges seductively on the finish.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2021
“The NV Collection 242 is a new wine from Roederer that replaces the Brut Premier in the range. The Collection (which now will be numbered by harvest) is a blend of three components: a perpetual reserve done in the classic non-malo Roederer style, reserve wines in oak with a touch of malo, and a base vintage, in this case 2017. That blend results in a NV Champagne that offers lovely richness and resonance, with plenty of yellow orchard fruit and floral character. Whereas Brut Premier was typically a focused, nervy wine that, while consistently excellent, also was not always in line with the Roederer house style, the 242 tastes more like a Roederer Champagne in terms of its complexity. Incidentally, there is no Vintage, Cristal or Cristal Rosé in 2017, so all the best lots went into this bottling. Dosage is 8 grams per liter, so lower than the 9 or so that was typical for recent Brut Premier and much lower than the 12-13 that was once customary. The 242 was also bottled with a bit less sugar than the norm, which results in lower atmospheres of pressure in the bottle and silkier texture.
“Brut Premier was created in the late 1970s and 1980s, when we struggled to ripen,” Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon explained. “It was our way of compensating for lack of ripeness in the field and the variability of quality across vintages. Because of climate change, achieving ripeness is not an issue today. Instead, our challenge is maintaining freshness and precision. For that reason, we decided to re-think our NV and start from a place of positive rather than negative selection.””
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2021
“New substitute for Brut Premier NV taking its name from Roederer's 242nd harvest with this debut bottling based on 2017 but containing 10% reserve wines aged in oak from 2009, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2016 plus 34% wine from a perpetual reserve (sort of solera) that has been built up since 2012, for 242 made up of equal parts from every vintage from 2012 to 2016 inclusive. The packaging is extremely similar to that of Brut Premier. Scannable QR code on the back label for more information. Roederer's notes: '2017, the base vintage for Collection 242, was a year of living dangerously! An exceptionally warm and dry winter and spring, but the latter brought severe frosts from 17 to 29 April, setting the sorry record for 12 nights of frost. These were followed by a dull, wet and not particularly hot summer, which ended in an almost tropical (hot and humid) spell at the end of August. This sudden change led to a significant increase in grey rot on the ripening Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier grapes. The harvest was fast-paced and completed very quickly, demanding precise and methodical selection work, of an unprecedented level even for Roederer. The harvest took place from 31 August to 9 September 2017. A third each from the Vallée de la Marne, the Côte des Blancs and the Montagne de Reims. 42% Chardonnay (the most successful variety in 2017), 36% Pinot Noir, 22% Pinot Meunier. Only 34% went through malo.' Dosage is 8 g/l (whereas Brut Premier used to be 9 g/l).
"Deep straw colour and tiny, tiny bead. Really satisfying, complete, beautifully balanced nose with some evolution and richness. A little bit of toastiness and it tastes pretty ripe. Very different indeed from a Brut Zéro champagne! Firm. Some tasters may object to the dosage. But it's a beautiful wine."”
91-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“The new climate and era have made Louis Roederer replace its Brut Premier with Collection. The new cuvée’s resilience derives from the “perpetual reserve” (Réserve perpétuelle) of previous vintages. In the challenging 2017 vintage, Chardonnay was made to play an important role. The result is rich with fine depth. It comes with nicely toasted, ripe fruity aroma with vanilla, lemon and hazelnut. The taste is softly lush but fresh and elegantly layered.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2017 vintage, Roederer's NV Brut Collection 242 continues to drink very well, offering up aromas of pear, orange zest, white flowers, almonds and hazelnuts. Medium to full-bodied, ample and fleshy, with racy acids and a bright, saline finish, it's a great success in a challenging base year.”
“Wonderfully complex aroma rises from the glass as soon as this is poured. So complex on the nose and uncompromisingly dry but well balanced on the palate. Lightly smoky but with no shortage of fine, ripe fruit in an interesting honeysuckle and lime spectrum. Clean and fresh and extremely long. This definitely deserves to be priced above regular non-vintage champagne. Not quite delicate. Not quite creamy. Just hits the right note for a superior blend.
Drink 2022–2030”
More Reviews +
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jan 2022
“Juicy Mirabelle plum and salty citrus pith have immediate impact on the nose. The palate is equally immediate and generous. Fine, lively mousse rises with esprit and highlights the appetising phenolic structure that is reminiscent of grapefruit pith that is as mouthwatering as the bright line of acidity that pervades the wine. A touch riper than its predecessor 242, but with wonderful dimensions. Most seductive.”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2018 vintage and complemented by reserve wines from a solera established in 2012, as well as younger foudre-aged reserve wines, Roederer's newly released NV Brut Collection 243 is a pillowy, enveloping Champagne evocative of crisp stone fruits, honeycomb, white flowers and buttery pastry. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and generous, with an ample core of fruit, bright acids and a saline finish, it will offer demonstrative drinking on release.”
“Wonderfully complex aroma rises from the glass as soon as this is poured. So complex on the nose and uncompromisingly dry but well balanced on the palate. Lightly smoky but with no shortage of fine, ripe fruit in an interesting honeysuckle and lime spectrum. Clean and fresh and extremely long. This definitely deserves to be priced above regular non-vintage champagne. Not quite delicate. Not quite creamy. Just hits the right note for a superior blend.
Drink 2022–2030”
More Reviews +
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jan 2022
“Juicy Mirabelle plum and salty citrus pith have immediate impact on the nose. The palate is equally immediate and generous. Fine, lively mousse rises with esprit and highlights the appetising phenolic structure that is reminiscent of grapefruit pith that is as mouthwatering as the bright line of acidity that pervades the wine. A touch riper than its predecessor 242, but with wonderful dimensions. Most seductive.”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2018 vintage and complemented by reserve wines from a solera established in 2012, as well as younger foudre-aged reserve wines, Roederer's newly released NV Brut Collection 243 is a pillowy, enveloping Champagne evocative of crisp stone fruits, honeycomb, white flowers and buttery pastry. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and generous, with an ample core of fruit, bright acids and a saline finish, it will offer demonstrative drinking on release.”
“Wonderfully complex aroma rises from the glass as soon as this is poured. So complex on the nose and uncompromisingly dry but well balanced on the palate. Lightly smoky but with no shortage of fine, ripe fruit in an interesting honeysuckle and lime spectrum. Clean and fresh and extremely long. This definitely deserves to be priced above regular non-vintage champagne. Not quite delicate. Not quite creamy. Just hits the right note for a superior blend.
Drink 2022–2030”
More Reviews +
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jan 2022
“Juicy Mirabelle plum and salty citrus pith have immediate impact on the nose. The palate is equally immediate and generous. Fine, lively mousse rises with esprit and highlights the appetising phenolic structure that is reminiscent of grapefruit pith that is as mouthwatering as the bright line of acidity that pervades the wine. A touch riper than its predecessor 242, but with wonderful dimensions. Most seductive.”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Based on the 2018 vintage and complemented by reserve wines from a solera established in 2012, as well as younger foudre-aged reserve wines, Roederer's newly released NV Brut Collection 243 is a pillowy, enveloping Champagne evocative of crisp stone fruits, honeycomb, white flowers and buttery pastry. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and generous, with an ample core of fruit, bright acids and a saline finish, it will offer demonstrative drinking on release.”
“Collection 244 is based on the fine 2019 harvest year, which makes up 54% of the blend. The complex blending pattern from the house’s perpetual reserve and oak vat aged single-vineyard reserve wines fine-tune the complexity and refinement. There is disarming delicacy ot the pristinely fruity nose of peachy charm. A lovely touch of toast lines the candied orange and pear fruit. Softly caressing mousse on the fleshy and juicy palate ads to the deliciousness and drinkability of it all. A really strong effort - best so far - for cuvée Collection.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2019 vintage, Roederer's NV Brut Collection 244 is the finest release of the house's reimagined non-vintage Brut to date. Offering up aromas of pear, peach and nectarine mingled with notions of white flowers, beeswax, freshly baked bread and buttery pastry, it's medium to full-bodied, layered and fleshy, with a pretty pinpoint mousse, racy acids and a long, chalky finish. The quality of the base vintage really shines through.”
94/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Jun 2024
“Very pale yellow green, silver reflections. Delicate meadow herbs, some walnut, a hint of pineapple and mango, candied grapefruit zest. Juicy, elegant, ripe fruit nuances, silky, already very well developed and creamy, lingers for a long time, a generous food companion, clear chalky character, the vintage of the base comes into its own.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2024
“Collection is a new Champagne from Roederer, essentially the former Brut Premier reinterpreted with a focus on freshness and verve. Those qualities come alive in the glass. Brisk acids cut through a core of orchard fruit, chamomile and crushed rocks. What a beautiful and expressive wine this is.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2024
“Light nose but the palate fights back with plenty of mature, dried fruit, yeastiness and a very savoury umami style with dosage on the trendily low side. If anything, I'd prefer a gram or two more sugar, but that more austere style is very much on trend. ”
“Collection 244 is based on the fine 2019 harvest year, which makes up 54% of the blend. The complex blending pattern from the house’s perpetual reserve and oak vat aged single-vineyard reserve wines fine-tune the complexity and refinement. There is disarming delicacy ot the pristinely fruity nose of peachy charm. A lovely touch of toast lines the candied orange and pear fruit. Softly caressing mousse on the fleshy and juicy palate ads to the deliciousness and drinkability of it all. A really strong effort - best so far - for cuvée Collection.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2019 vintage, Roederer's NV Brut Collection 244 is the finest release of the house's reimagined non-vintage Brut to date. Offering up aromas of pear, peach and nectarine mingled with notions of white flowers, beeswax, freshly baked bread and buttery pastry, it's medium to full-bodied, layered and fleshy, with a pretty pinpoint mousse, racy acids and a long, chalky finish. The quality of the base vintage really shines through.”
94/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Jun 2024
“Very pale yellow green, silver reflections. Delicate meadow herbs, some walnut, a hint of pineapple and mango, candied grapefruit zest. Juicy, elegant, ripe fruit nuances, silky, already very well developed and creamy, lingers for a long time, a generous food companion, clear chalky character, the vintage of the base comes into its own.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2024
“Collection is a new Champagne from Roederer, essentially the former Brut Premier reinterpreted with a focus on freshness and verve. Those qualities come alive in the glass. Brisk acids cut through a core of orchard fruit, chamomile and crushed rocks. What a beautiful and expressive wine this is.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2024
“Light nose but the palate fights back with plenty of mature, dried fruit, yeastiness and a very savoury umami style with dosage on the trendily low side. If anything, I'd prefer a gram or two more sugar, but that more austere style is very much on trend. ”
“Collection 244 is based on the fine 2019 harvest year, which makes up 54% of the blend. The complex blending pattern from the house’s perpetual reserve and oak vat aged single-vineyard reserve wines fine-tune the complexity and refinement. There is disarming delicacy ot the pristinely fruity nose of peachy charm. A lovely touch of toast lines the candied orange and pear fruit. Softly caressing mousse on the fleshy and juicy palate ads to the deliciousness and drinkability of it all. A really strong effort - best so far - for cuvée Collection.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Based on the 2019 vintage, Roederer's NV Brut Collection 244 is the finest release of the house's reimagined non-vintage Brut to date. Offering up aromas of pear, peach and nectarine mingled with notions of white flowers, beeswax, freshly baked bread and buttery pastry, it's medium to full-bodied, layered and fleshy, with a pretty pinpoint mousse, racy acids and a long, chalky finish. The quality of the base vintage really shines through.”
94/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Jun 2024
“Very pale yellow green, silver reflections. Delicate meadow herbs, some walnut, a hint of pineapple and mango, candied grapefruit zest. Juicy, elegant, ripe fruit nuances, silky, already very well developed and creamy, lingers for a long time, a generous food companion, clear chalky character, the vintage of the base comes into its own.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2024
“Collection is a new Champagne from Roederer, essentially the former Brut Premier reinterpreted with a focus on freshness and verve. Those qualities come alive in the glass. Brisk acids cut through a core of orchard fruit, chamomile and crushed rocks. What a beautiful and expressive wine this is.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2024
“Light nose but the palate fights back with plenty of mature, dried fruit, yeastiness and a very savoury umami style with dosage on the trendily low side. If anything, I'd prefer a gram or two more sugar, but that more austere style is very much on trend. ”
“Roederer’s specialty multi-vintage house blend is the annual Collection creation, and this year’s Collection 245 is a finely woven, mineral-laced beauty. Composed of 41% Chardon- nay, 35% Pinot Noir, and 24% Pinot Meunier, the backbone (55%) is from the 2020 harvest, while 35% comes from a Perpetual Reserve of 2012-2019 vintages, and 10% is Reserve Wines aged in oak (2010, 2013, 2015, 2017, 2018, and 2019). The dosage is just 7 grams per liter. Notes of citron blossom, lemon tart, and lime leaves slowly emerge from the glass, leading to hints of raising bread dough, fresh ginger, and sea spray, with a touch of coriander seed. The light-bodied, very dry, beautifully poised palate is elegantly crafted with intense citrus and mineral layers and a lively yet well-knit backbone, finishing long and chalky. I love the restraint here—unmistakably Roederer. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Apr 2025
“The bright straw-colored NV Champagne Collection 245 is juicy and ripe, revealing notes of ripe, fresh peaches and bread, with a chalky, elegant texture and a pinpoint, refined mousse. This medium-bodied Champagne continues to impress and is an outstanding”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The NV Collection 245 is another stellar Champagne from Roederer. Apricot, white flowers, spice, white pepper and tangerine oil all open in the glass. This is a more open-knit style from Roederer. The blend is 41% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 24% Meunier based in 2020, but with 35% reserve wines from a perpetual reserve of previous editions and 10% reserve wines in oak, meaning the base vintage is not particularly evident. Dosage is 7 grams per liter, but it feels a bit higher than that.”
92/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“Based on the 2020 vintage, Louis Roederer’s NV Brut Collection 245 is stylistically somewhat comparable to the two previous editions, which were based on the 2018 and 2019 vintages. Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon explains that the personality of the wine will change depending on the base year. By identifying the wine with a number, they do not intend to produce the same profile year in and year out, but rather, they will embrace the singularity of each vintage, accepting the different personalities of the base year. It is complemented by a perpetual reserve initiated in 2012, which is stored in large tanks without lees; the reserve provides balance to the warm years like this, as the perpetual component did not go through malolactic fermentation. While a considerable portion of the fruit comes from Louis Roederer's own estates, for this bottling, the blend incorporates purchased fruit as well, particularly Pinot Meunier, which they do not own. Including approximately 43% Chardonnay, the new Brut Collection offers notes of pear, peach and candied orange zest. On the palate, it is medium to full-bodied, textural and fleshy, laden with vibrant acidity and concluding with a nicely defined, delicately saline finish, even with 7.5 grams per liter dosage.”
“75cl - Roederer’s specialty multi-vintage house blend is the annual Collection creation, and this year’s Collection 245 is a finely woven, mineral-laced beauty. Composed of 41% Chardon- nay, 35% Pinot Noir, and 24% Pinot Meunier, the backbone (55%) is from the 2020 harvest, while 35% comes from a Perpetual Reserve of 2012-2019 vintages, and 10% is Reserve Wines aged in oak (2010, 2013, 2015, 2017, 2018, and 2019). The dosage is just 7 grams per liter. Notes of citron blossom, lemon tart, and lime leaves slowly emerge from the glass, leading to hints of raising bread dough, fresh ginger, and sea spray, with a touch of coriander seed. The light-bodied, very dry, beautifully poised palate is elegantly crafted with intense citrus and mineral layers and a lively yet well-knit backbone, finishing long and chalky. I love the restraint here—unmistakably Roederer. ”
More Reviews +
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“75cl - The NV Collection 245 is another stellar Champagne from Roederer. Apricot, white flowers, spice, white pepper and tangerine oil all open in the glass. This is a more open-knit style from Roederer. The blend is 41% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 24% Meunier based in 2020, but with 35% reserve wines from a perpetual reserve of previous editions and 10% reserve wines in oak, meaning the base vintage is not particularly evident. Dosage is 7 grams per liter, but it feels a bit higher than that.”
92/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“75cl - Based on the 2020 vintage, Louis Roederer’s NV Brut Collection 245 is stylistically somewhat comparable to the two previous editions, which were based on the 2018 and 2019 vintages. Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon explains that the personality of the wine will change depending on the base year. By identifying the wine with a number, they do not intend to produce the same profile year in and year out, but rather, they will embrace the singularity of each vintage, accepting the different personalities of the base year. It is complemented by a perpetual reserve initiated in 2012, which is stored in large tanks without lees; the reserve provides balance to the warm years like this, as the perpetual component did not go through malolactic fermentation. While a considerable portion of the fruit comes from Louis Roederer's own estates, for this bottling, the blend incorporates purchased fruit as well, particularly Pinot Meunier, which they do not own. Including approximately 43% Chardonnay, the new Brut Collection offers notes of pear, peach and candied orange zest. On the palate, it is medium to full-bodied, textural and fleshy, laden with vibrant acidity and concluding with a nicely defined, delicately saline finish, even with 7.5 grams per liter dosage.”
94/100
Lisa Perrotti-Brown MW,
Thewineindependent.com,
Apr 2024
“Roederer’s specialty multi-vintage house blend is the annual Collection creation, and this year’s Collection 245 is a finely woven, mineral-laced beauty. Composed of 41% Chardon- nay, 35% Pinot Noir, and 24% Pinot Meunier, the backbone (55%) is from the 2020 harvest, while 35% comes from a Perpetual Reserve of 2012-2019 vintages, and 10% is Reserve Wines aged in oak (2010, 2013, 2015, 2017, 2018, and 2019). The dosage is just 7 grams per liter. Notes of citron blossom, lemon tart, and lime leaves slowly emerge from the glass, leading to hints of raising bread dough, fresh ginger, and sea spray, with a touch of coriander seed. The light-bodied, very dry, beautifully poised palate is elegantly crafted with intense citrus and mineral layers and a lively yet well-knit backbone, finishing long and chalky. I love the restraint here—unmistakably Roederer. ”
93/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Apr 2025
“The bright straw-colored NV Champagne Collection 245 is juicy and ripe, revealing notes of ripe, fresh peaches and bread, with a chalky, elegant texture and a pinpoint, refined mousse. This medium-bodied Champagne continues to impress and is an outstanding”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The NV Collection 245 is another stellar Champagne from Roederer. Apricot, white flowers, spice, white pepper and tangerine oil all open in the glass. This is a more open-knit style from Roederer. The blend is 41% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 24% Meunier based in 2020, but with 35% reserve wines from a perpetual reserve of previous editions and 10% reserve wines in oak, meaning the base vintage is not particularly evident. Dosage is 7 grams per liter, but it feels a bit higher than that.”
92/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“Based on the 2020 vintage, Louis Roederer’s NV Brut Collection 245 is stylistically somewhat comparable to the two previous editions, which were based on the 2018 and 2019 vintages. Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon explains that the personality of the wine will change depending on the base year. By identifying the wine with a number, they do not intend to produce the same profile year in and year out, but rather, they will embrace the singularity of each vintage, accepting the different personalities of the base year. It is complemented by a perpetual reserve initiated in 2012, which is stored in large tanks without lees; the reserve provides balance to the warm years like this, as the perpetual component did not go through malolactic fermentation. While a considerable portion of the fruit comes from Louis Roederer's own estates, for this bottling, the blend incorporates purchased fruit as well, particularly Pinot Meunier, which they do not own. Including approximately 43% Chardonnay, the new Brut Collection offers notes of pear, peach and candied orange zest. On the palate, it is medium to full-bodied, textural and fleshy, laden with vibrant acidity and concluding with a nicely defined, delicately saline finish, even with 7.5 grams per liter dosage.”
“The NV Brut Collection 246 is positively stellar. It’s a terrific example of where Roederer is going with this cuvée stylistically. Brisk saline notes cut through a core of orchard fruit, mint, white pepper and slate. There are no hard angles or awkward contours. The 246 is based on 2021, an extremely tricky vintage for Champagne. Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon bumped up the percentage of Chardonnay considerably and focused on Pinots from the Montagne de Reims. About 30% of the lots underwent malolactic fermentation to soften the edges. Twenty-four percent of the wines were fermented in oak, the rest in tank. The 246 is a blend of 55% base 2021 vintage wines described above, plus 30% perpetual reserve going back to 2012 (mostly from Cumières, Vertus and Verzy) in tank and 10% young-vine juice from Cristal plots aged in cask. The final blend is 54% Chardonnay (as opposed to the more typical 44%), 35% Pinot Noir and 11% Meunier. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. More importantly, the 246 is impeccably done and absolutely delicious.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2025
“This has pretty and elegant aromas of pears, apple blossoms, grapefruit and chalk. It’s silky, fresh and beautifully balanced on the palate, with very soft bubbles.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Sep 2025
“A harmonious Champagne that shows impeccable balance, with depth and focus to its flavors of white cherry, Honeycrisp apple, tangerine peel and biscuit, while retaining vibrancy and grace. A chalky underpinning comes to the fore on the creamy finish, joining delicate spice and floral accents. Chardonnay, Pinot Noir and Meunier. Drink now through 2030.”
17.5/20
Andy Howard MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2026
“A beautifully weighted and pure NV Champagne from Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon. Hits all the right spots. Plenty of weight and creamy texture, balanced by precise, focused fruit flavours, a super-fine mousse and freshening, lingering acidity on the finish. The Collection project goes from strength to strength.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2026
“Sweet apple-pie scent, light yeastiness but there’s a long and sophisticated finish with excellent balance and no bitterness whatsoever. You can taste the mature elements here, underpinning the apple fruit with a more savoury, dried-apricot character. Silky froth. Well-integrated yeastiness.”
93+/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Feb 2026
“The NV Champagne Collection 246 is fantastic and has refreshing nerve, with more citrus, pure lemon curd, white grapefruit, and white peach. Medium-bodied, it floats through the palate, with a refined mousse and fantastic fresh acidity.”
“The NV Brut Collection 246 is positively stellar. It’s a terrific example of where Roederer is going with this cuvée stylistically. Brisk saline notes cut through a core of orchard fruit, mint, white pepper and slate. There are no hard angles or awkward contours. The 246 is based on 2021, an extremely tricky vintage for Champagne. Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon bumped up the percentage of Chardonnay considerably and focused on Pinots from the Montagne de Reims. About 30% of the lots underwent malolactic fermentation to soften the edges. Twenty-four percent of the wines were fermented in oak, the rest in tank. The 246 is a blend of 55% base 2021 vintage wines described above, plus 30% perpetual reserve going back to 2012 (mostly from Cumières, Vertus and Verzy) in tank and 10% young-vine juice from Cristal plots aged in cask. The final blend is 54% Chardonnay (as opposed to the more typical 44%), 35% Pinot Noir and 11% Meunier. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. More importantly, the 246 is impeccably done and absolutely delicious.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Claire Nesbitt,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2025
“This has pretty and elegant aromas of pears, apple blossoms, grapefruit and chalk. It’s silky, fresh and beautifully balanced on the palate, with very soft bubbles.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Sep 2025
“A harmonious Champagne that shows impeccable balance, with depth and focus to its flavors of white cherry, Honeycrisp apple, tangerine peel and biscuit, while retaining vibrancy and grace. A chalky underpinning comes to the fore on the creamy finish, joining delicate spice and floral accents. Chardonnay, Pinot Noir and Meunier. Drink now through 2030.”
17.5/20
Andy Howard MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2026
“A beautifully weighted and pure NV Champagne from Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon. Hits all the right spots. Plenty of weight and creamy texture, balanced by precise, focused fruit flavours, a super-fine mousse and freshening, lingering acidity on the finish. The Collection project goes from strength to strength.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2026
“Sweet apple-pie scent, light yeastiness but there’s a long and sophisticated finish with excellent balance and no bitterness whatsoever. You can taste the mature elements here, underpinning the apple fruit with a more savoury, dried-apricot character. Silky froth. Well-integrated yeastiness.”
93+/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Feb 2026
“The NV Champagne Collection 246 is fantastic and has refreshing nerve, with more citrus, pure lemon curd, white grapefruit, and white peach. Medium-bodied, it floats through the palate, with a refined mousse and fantastic fresh acidity.”
“The 2018 Cristal opens a new chapter for Roederer. The Cristal estate is composed of 45 parcels. In better vintages, most of the 45 parcels are used for the blend. The 2018 vintage brought with it elevated ripeness and generally low acids. Longtime Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon was forced to cast his gaze wider, to look for parcels that offered a touch of freshness. Lécaillon expanded his palette to 57 parcels. The result is a Cristal unlike any other I have tasted. Orchard fruit, dried flowers, spice, chalk and herbs are some of the many notes that take shape in the glass. Floral and savory overtones are quite distinctive. Lécaillon reduced oak ferments, racked very quickly after fermentation and used all his best Chardonnay lots for Cristal, so much so that there is no Blanc de Blancs. He bottled earlier than normal and chose a crown capsule with a liner that allows less oxygen transfer than the norm here. Taken together, those choices paid off handsomely. In tasting, the 2018 is positively stunning. Its linear energy and brilliance are a bit reminiscent of the 2014, but its flavor profile is completely different from any Cristal I can remember tasting. Dosage is 7 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
97-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2026
“In this vintage of ripeness and volume, Louis Roederer sought freshness and vivacity by exceptionally incorporating into the cuvée wines from 12 plots that are not usually part of Cristal. Chardonnays from the house’s Blanc de Blancs estate and Pinot Noirs from slightly younger vines lend their energy to this fruit-bomb Cristal. The colour shows a deep golden hue. The nose is soft, exuberantly fruity and fragrant, oozing floral, candy and orchard fruit tones. Open and accessible, it conveys a sense of transparency and crystalline fruit purity. On the lush, textured palate, it is almost chewy, yet perfectly lifted by the brisk backbone of Chardonnay freshness and chalky finesse. Rather horizontal in character, it is highly expressive, showing a personality of its own with a strong vintage imprint. ”
“The 2016 Cristal is a blend of 58% Pinot Noir and 42% Chardonnay with 7 grams per liter of dosage. No malo-lactic was performed here, and 31% of
the base wines were aged in French oak. The nose begins with bright red berry notes of fresh raspberries and strawberries before opening out to a complex undercurrent of saffron, white chocolate, talc, baker’s yeast, and emerging wafts of citron blossom and pear tart. The palate is very dry and spicy, not needing even a touch more sweetness thanks to the abundance of ripe berry and citrus flavors, delivering beautifully knit acidity and typically tiny, persistent bubbles. It finishes with notes of effervescent chalkiness and saffron flowers, leaving you reaching for another sip.”
More Reviews +
97/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2024
“The 2016 Cristal is a taut, incisive rendition of this benchmark bottling, unwinding in the glass with youthfully reserved aromas of citrus oil, white flowers, wet stones and subtle hints of sweet, buttery pastry. Medium to full-bodied, chiseled and racy, it's almost as electric as the brilliant 2013, with serious concentration, a pure core of fruit, chalky structuring dry extract and a long, intensely mineral finish. Given its tightly wound profile, my advice is to forget it in the cellar for a few years and work on the more open, outgoing 2014 in the meantime.”
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“The finest rendition since 2013, the 2016 Cristal has turned out beautifully. A vintage that Lecaillon describes as “difficult in the vineyards but beautiful in the cellar,” it had suffered slightly in reputation due to the gloomy mood during the challenging growing season, but the results are indeed impressive. The fifth edition produced entirely from organically farmed and certified fruit, and heavily based on Pinot Noir, the 2016 represents the contemporary quality of Cristal, combining the concentration of 2002 with the precision and cut of 2013. Disgorged in July 2024 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, it opens in the glass to reveal a bouquet of lemon zest, white flowers and peeled almond, framed by youthful reduction. On the palate, it is bright and electric, with a pure core of fruit, pinpoint mousse and a textural attack, concluding with a long, saline finish. Drink it alongside the 2015, and it will illuminate its clarity and integration.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2025
“58% Pinot Noir, 42% Chardonnay from grand cru villages. The dominant ingredient is Pinot Noir from a north-facing vineyard in Verzenay. Cristal is usually made up of 45 of 70 plots that are at least 20 years old, all fermented as single-vineyard wines and during the winter they select the best. Only 32 of these 45 plots made it into this selection because, according to chef de cave Lécaillon, 2016 was tricky because of the wet spring (as were the early 2012 and late 2013 vintages). There was lots of mildew in their organic vineyards although a beautiful August mitigated the situation. Low crop picked throughout the second half of September. Concentrated fruit. He believes that the vines were more settled into an organic protocol by 2016. 31% oaked wine. No malo, no chaptalisation. Dosage 7 g/l. There will be no Cristal 2017. The 2018 will be released in 2026.
Very, very concentrated and dense with some salinity and really juicy. 'We call it the Chevalier-Montrachet of Champagne because it's discreet rather than showy', according to Lécaillon. Markedly savoury, and indeed not entirely unlike modern, slightly austere white burgundy. Definite chewiness on the end and a bottle that should ideally be kept awhile. But, presumably thanks to warmer summers and organically grown vines, it's more open than Cristal used to be on release”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Aug 2024
“The 2016 Cristal is bright, aromatic and nicely lifted. Citrus peel white flowers, mint and a touch of chamomile all grace this understated, wonderfully refined edition of Cristal. Light on its feet and super-refined, the 2016 is exquisite in its understated beauty. I can’t wait to see how the 2016 ages and won’t be surprised it gains a bit of weight in bottle, as Cristal so often does. The blend is 58% Pinot Noir and 42% Chardonnay, so a touch more Char- donnay than the norm. Of the 45 parcels that make up the Cristal domaine, just 32 were used for the blend. Verzy and Verzenay dominate the Pinots, then Aÿ. Avize takes the lead in the Chardonnays, followed by Mesnil and Cramant. Dosage is 7 grams per liter.”
“The 2014 Cristal is another in a long line of gorgeous wines from Roederer and long-time Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon. A dazzling, vibrant Champagne, the 2014 impresses with a stunning combination of fruit density and linear energy that brings to mind a hypothetical blend of 2012 and 2008. At times, the bubbles feel totally wrapped up in waves of creamy, resonant fruit to the point the mousse is barely perceptible, especially with aeration. The flavors are bright and finely sculpted, leaning very much into the citrus, floral and mineral end of the spectrum.”
More Reviews +
18.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2022
“Tiny bead. Seriously impressive tension in this bottle whose flavour (but not mousse) is explosive. It starts tight and taut, opens out to breadth of fruit on the mid palate, and then offers a positive fan of flavour on the bone-dry finish, all the time titillating every taste bud. Firm and a delightfully serious wine. Drink 2022 – 2040”
99/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Feb 2022
“An initially faint but distinct hint of freshly cut green but ripe apple, of lemon. Subtle florality, a mere touch of freesia, hints at more nuance to come. More time in the glass reveals a sense of still briny oyster shell. The palate is like a summer breeze, caressing the palate with finest, creamiest foam – and again that saltiness that is utterly seductive and appetising. There is immense vertical richness in that creamy but svelte texture. Despite the generosity, the creaminess, there is nothing superfluous to obscure the wine’s essential and clear-cut luminosity. This is a model of sleekness, understatement and depth, an utterly compelling combination of briskness and emollience. Irresistible now but guaranteed to evolve. A.K.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This has a charmingly fragrant, even playful, fruity nose with ripe peach, vanilla and orange blossom intermingling with fruit drops, chalky mineral notes and toasted bread. The irresistible transparency of pure, perfect fruit continues on the lush, sweet palate. Then the whip of acidity hits, bringing on a burst of energy and fine mineral salinity, refreshing the whole. The finish is salty-tangy, immediately readying one's palate for the next sip. An instant charmer of a Cristal. Dosage 7g/l”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2022
“The 2014 Cristal is a terrific effort that transcends the vintage. Bursting from the glass with expressive aromas of ripe citrus fruit, nectarine, white flowers, freshly baked bread and subtle hints of honeycomb, it's medium to full-bodied, vinous and fleshy, with an exuberant core of fruit that's girdled by racy acids, resulting in a wine that's simultaneously chiseled and demonstrative, meaning that early appeal doesn't come at the expense of the requisite tension for long-term cellaring. Concluding with a long, aromatic and intensely chalky finish, it is a brilliant Champagne that will offer a broad drinking window. This bottle was disgorged in June 2021 with seven grams per liter dosage.”
17.5++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jan 2022
“Rather a wet summer followed by a usefully drying wind and picked, after a few days' shrivel time, from 20 September over a week. 39 of the usual 45 plots went into this 'composition' with three Aÿ Pinot lots and three from Avize excluded. 32% oak-fermented. No malo. As usual 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay from Roederer's own 100% organically grown vineyards from some of the best sites. Disgorged in June 2021, dosage 7 g/l. ”
“If Cristal 2013 is already magnificent in the 75cl format, the magnum takes the wine to another dimension of reductive finesse and slowly unfurling elegance. The bouquet is cool and precise, with crisp peach and vibrant lemon underpinned by profound layers of gunpowder and chalk. Few Champagnes capture such luminosity and purity. Beneath the seemingly weightless frame lies remarkable intensity. Thrillingly energetic and strikingly saline today, it promises a long, graceful evolution.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“One of the greatest wines of Louis Roederer’s contemporary chapter, the 2013 Cristal continues to impress. Tasted from magnum, which was disgorged in September 2024 with a dosage of 7.5 grams per liter, it wafts from the glass with a bouquet of white flowers, lemon zest and toasted hazelnut, mingling with iodine and smoke. Qualitatively speaking, it's “a copy of 2012 with a month longer growing cycle,” summarizes Lecaillon, and it's indeed true that these two wines represent the high points of the of the decade so far—as only time will tell what Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon will achieve with 2019. Expecting a crystalline, electric wine, given the cool, late-ripening season, the 2013 indeed delivers a Champagne that is bright, with incredible clarity and concentration, even if it’s undeniably a leaner version than its immediate predecessor. Since its release, I've enjoyed the 2013 Cristal several times from my own cellar, but having the opportunity to appreciate it from a magnum delivered an even more textural and seamless experience, emphasizing its chalky personality and laser precision.”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The heart of Cristal Rosé is in lush Aÿ Pinot Noir. The maceration of these grapes sees the addition of juice from the Cristal Rosé estate plots in Avize and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger. Biodynamically farmed, but not yet certified at the time of harvest. The nose is as pretty and elegant as it gets, with a fair amount of restraint for Cristal. White peach, mandarin and vanilla meet some cool herbaceous notes, like a minty breeze, enhancing the sensation of coolness. The palate comes across deliciously fleshy and caressing, with the subtlest creamy mousse carrying the wine to infinity. Bright, vibrant and racy, this has untamed qualities of the utmost charm. As driven, polished and effortlessly delicious as only Cristal Rosé can be. Dosage 7g/l”
98/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“I've revisited Roederer's 2013 Cristal four times since I reviewed it in April of this year—including several times from my own cellar—and I had to admit that even my lavish praise didn't do it full justice. Combining the cool-vintage cut of 2008 with the more completely mature fruit of 2012, the 2013 Cristal might well be said to represent the perfect combination of the two from a purist's perspective. The wine unwinds in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, white flowers, almond paste and citrus oil, followed by a medium to full-bodied, seamless and multidimensional palate that's intense but weightless, with racy acids, a pinpoint mousse and a long, penetrating finish. Drink the 2008 Cristal on its own, and you're unlikely—to put it mildly—to have any complaints; but compare it directly with the 2013 and you'll see Roederer's rapid progress in the vineyards writ large.”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2021
“The 2013 Cristal is a wine of extraordinary precision and tension. Searing acids drive a bold, racy Champagne that won’t be ready to offer its best drinking anytime soon. In recent vintages, Cristal has been quite open on release. That is far from the case with the 2013. Readers should plan on being quite patient. The blend is 60% Pinot Noir (from Aÿ, Verzy, Verzenay, Beaumont-sur-Vesle) and 40% Chardonnay (Mesnil, Avize, Cramant). Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon was especially selective and used only 30 out of the potential 45 plots that are typically available for Cristal. About 32% of the lots were done in oak, the rest in steel, with the malolactic fermentation blocked across the board. It was an October harvest, the sort of harvest that has become increasingly rare in Champagne. Lecaillon describes the summer as similar to 2012, but adds the vines were a month behind in their development. In tasting, the 2013 reminds me of the 1996 in its austerity, even more so than the epic 2008.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2021
“Very late growing cycle with flowering delayed until the beginning of July but this was followed by a warm, dry summer – although the October harvest was relatively cool. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay from 45 'exceptional lieux-dits', a third in each of Vallée de la Marne, Côte des Blancs and Montagne de Reims. 32% of the wine was aged in oak. None went through malo. Dosage 8 g/l.
Pale gold. Tiny bead. Intense nose of fresh almonds, lemon zest and blossom. Tight and tense with masses of acidity and freshness but not painfully so. Neat and a little introvert. This is clearly made up of many layers and is extremely persistent. A fine mix of intellectual and pleasurable. Pretty gorgeous.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2021
“The 2013 vintage was sculpted by its late season with grapes ending up harvested in October. But ripe they became with heaps of delicious cool and crunchy fruit. Cristal Blanc is so racy and pure with huge, salty mineral tanginess at the fore. But look beyond and get bedazzled by its fruity power. Lemon, lime, white currant and Granny Smith apple with chalky tones and gunpowder whiffs arising over time. Focused and saline on the mouthwateringly zingy palate.”
99/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“An immediate sense of creaminess comes with an unusually intense perfume of fruit. Despite all this time on lees, a very pure sense of ripe, juicy Mirabelle plum is evident. This segues effortlessly into a creamy chalkiness. The palate strikes with immediate presence and inherent balance. Concentration and freshness complete each other, are heightened by the finest, smoothest foam. There is luminosity, body, and a salty depth that draws you in. The sense of sleekness and elegance is extraordinary. While it will be hard to resist this deliciousness now, graceful ageing is guaranteed.”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TFB Founder,
Nov 2023
“Cristal 2013 is still the youngster, tightly wound with a pure fruit profile, dominant citrus and rich stone fruit with a twist of spice. The texture is mouth filling it wraps around the palate and then the bright and crisp minerality finish the champagne delicate and crisp. It is very young and very little of the dried fruit and bottle aged character are yet showing. This we imagine is likely to start showing itself in 3 to 5 years. Drink 2025 to 2035. ”
“For the first time entirely from certified organic grapes. Mid greenish-yellow hue with silver reflections; persistent, fine bubbly mousse. Typical Cristal nose with white apple, fresh peach, fine biscuit, a touch of orange marmalade, also lime; an attractive bouquet. Very rich, tropical fruit nuances, a little more broad-shouldered than the finely chiselled 2008, supported by lively acidity, mineral and balanced on the finish. Has something immediately appealing, but will still improve with further bottle maturation. Once again a candidate for "Champagne of the Vintage".”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“The 2012 Cristal is another absolutely stellar wine this flight of recent releases. Rich, vinous and beautifully textured, the 2012 has been nothing short of magnificent on the three occasions I have tasted it so far. In the glass, the 2012 is radiant and luscious, yet it possesses remarkable transparency and striking aromatic depth. Light tropical notes develop in the glass, giving the 2012 a real feeling of exotic beauty. The 2012 is the first vintage of Cristal done with 100% organically-farmed fruit, an approach introduced gradually starting with the 2007 that has profoundly changes Cristal, especially in its aromatic breadth. Two thousand twelve is the vintage where endless trials and experiments in farming and winemaking are fully realized. The 2012 is just stunning. It’s as simple as that. Dosage is just over 7 grams per liter, the lowest it has even been for Cristal.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“2012 marks the very first Cristal fully crafted from biodynamically farmed fruit. This difficult growing season managed to turn the challenges into assets. It resulted in a deeply fruity, Pinot driven Cristal that is exceptionally expressive already upon launch. The ripe, sweetly fruity aromatics come with bright red apple and baked apricot hints and even some tropical fruit notes. It feels slightly more Pinot driven that what the 60% share would suggest and Pinot indeed was the years best performer, excelling to chef de cave Lécaillon like no other since 1990. The rounded palate goes hand in hand with the soft nose generating a beautifully textured palate that turns refreshingly saline towards the very finish. Despite its early generosity, no doubt a Cristal built to last. ”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2019
“It will be the average age for Cristal launch. It was 2008 that was late. This will be the first 100% biodynamic Cristal.
Rich and ripe, like 2002. Pungent nose – straight up the nose. Gorgeous and seductive. Complex and embroidered. Already lovely. The next chapter – all viticulture.”
97+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Dec 2019
“Aromas of clear honey, crisp green orchard fruit, white peach, pastry cream and dried white flowers introduce the 2012 Cristal, a full-bodied, concentrated and powerful wine that's built for the cellar. Broader, more textural and more muscular than the 2008 Cristal, with seemingly even greater reserves of structuring dry extract, the 2012 is incisive and searingly chalky. This is the first Cristal produced exclusively from organically farmed fruit, and it marks the opening of a new chapter for Louis Roderer.”
19+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TFB Founder,
Nov 2023
“Cristal 2012 in contrast was the precocious kid, on release the fruit was super forward and generous, with a bright acid and fruit concentration from citrus, stone fruit to touches of tropical; easy to fall in love with this! With time, the champagne is currently lightly reductive, that smokiness adding another layer of complexity, some of the dried citrus and stone fruit are emerging and it is building into a very powerful and complex champagne. The vineyards are really showing here, with that chalk footprint showing on the palate. Amazing now, but is going to grow with complexity. Drink now to 2035 ”
“For the first time entirely from certified organic grapes. Mid greenish-yellow hue with silver reflections; persistent, fine bubbly mousse. Typical Cristal nose with white apple, fresh peach, fine biscuit, a touch of orange marmalade, also lime; an attractive bouquet. Very rich, tropical fruit nuances, a little more broad-shouldered than the finely chiselled 2008, supported by lively acidity, mineral and balanced on the finish. Has something immediately appealing, but will still improve with further bottle maturation. Once again a candidate for "Champagne of the Vintage".”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“The 2012 Cristal is another absolutely stellar wine this flight of recent releases. Rich, vinous and beautifully textured, the 2012 has been nothing short of magnificent on the three occasions I have tasted it so far. In the glass, the 2012 is radiant and luscious, yet it possesses remarkable transparency and striking aromatic depth. Light tropical notes develop in the glass, giving the 2012 a real feeling of exotic beauty. The 2012 is the first vintage of Cristal done with 100% organically-farmed fruit, an approach introduced gradually starting with the 2007 that has profoundly changes Cristal, especially in its aromatic breadth. Two thousand twelve is the vintage where endless trials and experiments in farming and winemaking are fully realized. The 2012 is just stunning. It’s as simple as that. Dosage is just over 7 grams per liter, the lowest it has even been for Cristal.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“2012 marks the very first Cristal fully crafted from biodynamically farmed fruit. This difficult growing season managed to turn the challenges into assets. It resulted in a deeply fruity, Pinot driven Cristal that is exceptionally expressive already upon launch. The ripe, sweetly fruity aromatics come with bright red apple and baked apricot hints and even some tropical fruit notes. It feels slightly more Pinot driven that what the 60% share would suggest and Pinot indeed was the years best performer, excelling to chef de cave Lécaillon like no other since 1990. The rounded palate goes hand in hand with the soft nose generating a beautifully textured palate that turns refreshingly saline towards the very finish. Despite its early generosity, no doubt a Cristal built to last. ”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2019
“It will be the average age for Cristal launch. It was 2008 that was late. This will be the first 100% biodynamic Cristal.
Rich and ripe, like 2002. Pungent nose – straight up the nose. Gorgeous and seductive. Complex and embroidered. Already lovely. The next chapter – all viticulture.”
97+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Dec 2019
“Aromas of clear honey, crisp green orchard fruit, white peach, pastry cream and dried white flowers introduce the 2012 Cristal, a full-bodied, concentrated and powerful wine that's built for the cellar. Broader, more textural and more muscular than the 2008 Cristal, with seemingly even greater reserves of structuring dry extract, the 2012 is incisive and searingly chalky. This is the first Cristal produced exclusively from organically farmed fruit, and it marks the opening of a new chapter for Louis Roderer.”
19+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TFB Founder,
Nov 2023
“Cristal 2012 in contrast was the precocious kid, on release the fruit was super forward and generous, with a bright acid and fruit concentration from citrus, stone fruit to touches of tropical; easy to fall in love with this! With time, the champagne is currently lightly reductive, that smokiness adding another layer of complexity, some of the dried citrus and stone fruit are emerging and it is building into a very powerful and complex champagne. The vineyards are really showing here, with that chalk footprint showing on the palate. Amazing now, but is going to grow with complexity. Drink now to 2035 ”
“For the first time entirely from certified organic grapes. Mid greenish-yellow hue with silver reflections; persistent, fine bubbly mousse. Typical Cristal nose with white apple, fresh peach, fine biscuit, a touch of orange marmalade, also lime; an attractive bouquet. Very rich, tropical fruit nuances, a little more broad-shouldered than the finely chiselled 2008, supported by lively acidity, mineral and balanced on the finish. Has something immediately appealing, but will still improve with further bottle maturation. Once again a candidate for "Champagne of the Vintage".”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“The 2012 Cristal is another absolutely stellar wine this flight of recent releases. Rich, vinous and beautifully textured, the 2012 has been nothing short of magnificent on the three occasions I have tasted it so far. In the glass, the 2012 is radiant and luscious, yet it possesses remarkable transparency and striking aromatic depth. Light tropical notes develop in the glass, giving the 2012 a real feeling of exotic beauty. The 2012 is the first vintage of Cristal done with 100% organically-farmed fruit, an approach introduced gradually starting with the 2007 that has profoundly changes Cristal, especially in its aromatic breadth. Two thousand twelve is the vintage where endless trials and experiments in farming and winemaking are fully realized. The 2012 is just stunning. It’s as simple as that. Dosage is just over 7 grams per liter, the lowest it has even been for Cristal.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“2012 marks the very first Cristal fully crafted from biodynamically farmed fruit. This difficult growing season managed to turn the challenges into assets. It resulted in a deeply fruity, Pinot driven Cristal that is exceptionally expressive already upon launch. The ripe, sweetly fruity aromatics come with bright red apple and baked apricot hints and even some tropical fruit notes. It feels slightly more Pinot driven that what the 60% share would suggest and Pinot indeed was the years best performer, excelling to chef de cave Lécaillon like no other since 1990. The rounded palate goes hand in hand with the soft nose generating a beautifully textured palate that turns refreshingly saline towards the very finish. Despite its early generosity, no doubt a Cristal built to last. ”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2019
“It will be the average age for Cristal launch. It was 2008 that was late. This will be the first 100% biodynamic Cristal.
Rich and ripe, like 2002. Pungent nose – straight up the nose. Gorgeous and seductive. Complex and embroidered. Already lovely. The next chapter – all viticulture.”
97+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Dec 2019
“Aromas of clear honey, crisp green orchard fruit, white peach, pastry cream and dried white flowers introduce the 2012 Cristal, a full-bodied, concentrated and powerful wine that's built for the cellar. Broader, more textural and more muscular than the 2008 Cristal, with seemingly even greater reserves of structuring dry extract, the 2012 is incisive and searingly chalky. This is the first Cristal produced exclusively from organically farmed fruit, and it marks the opening of a new chapter for Louis Roderer.”
19+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TFB Founder,
Nov 2023
“Cristal 2012 in contrast was the precocious kid, on release the fruit was super forward and generous, with a bright acid and fruit concentration from citrus, stone fruit to touches of tropical; easy to fall in love with this! With time, the champagne is currently lightly reductive, that smokiness adding another layer of complexity, some of the dried citrus and stone fruit are emerging and it is building into a very powerful and complex champagne. The vineyards are really showing here, with that chalk footprint showing on the palate. Amazing now, but is going to grow with complexity. Drink now to 2035 ”
“2009 Cristal has really shut down since I tasted it this past spring, which is probably a very good thing for its potential longevity. The radiance and richness the 2009 showed just a few months ago is not all evident. Instead, the 2009 comes across as tightly wound and in need of considerable cellaring. I expect it will drink well for a period measured in decades rather than years. The 2009 has always been quite exuberant, but for now, it looks the wine is going to need a bit of time before it is at its best. Readers should note that Roederer has decided to release the 2009 ahead of the 2008. ”
More Reviews +
95+/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
robertparker.com,
May 2018
“Released two years ago, the 2009 is just starting another, more "Burgundian" life. Tasted in May 2018, the bouquet was pretty reductive, with flinty and toasty/nutty notes and some potted ginger flavors. Full-bodied, round and rich on the palate, this is a stunningly pure, fresh and salty 2009 that is driven by its chalky terroir and the lingering salinity. Is it really 2009? It is ripe, yes, but driven by the strength of chalk. The finish is pure, clean, fresh, very complex and long yet delicate and endlessly salty. However, two years after disgorgement, the 2009 Cristal is closing down and in a pretty reductive stage right now.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Tasted blind. A little more evolved on the nose [than the 2008 tasted alongside] – a bit like white burgundy. Creamy and fine. And layered. Long. Gorgeous. Creamy without being at all fat.”
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2019
“An open, soft and welcoming nose with sweet lemony fruit, pastry tones, vanilla and a faint spicy edge. There is a ripe, generously fruity character behind the reserved subtlety of the nose. Bright fruit of exemplary polish. The opulent, fruit-packed palate is smooth-textured and round. The generosity turns into beautiful focus as the wine advances on the palate. Salivating, energetic, chalky-mineral and tight, promising great potential. ”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Jul 2017
“Rich, creamy and radiant, the 2009 Cristal captures all of the natural generosity of the vintage while also retaining a good bit of freshness and aromatic intensity. Immediate and totally sensual in its allure, the 2009 will drink well with minimal cellaring. All things considered, at this stage, the 2009 comes across as relatively restrained for a wine from a warm year. ”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Tense and lifted on the nose. So very different from the vintage: much more finesse. Racy and elegant. Masses of acidity and tension. Lighter in texture than the vintage. A racy thoroughbred. So refined but very youthful.”
“2009 Cristal has really shut down since I tasted it this past spring, which is probably a very good thing for its potential longevity. The radiance and richness the 2009 showed just a few months ago is not all evident. Instead, the 2009 comes across as tightly wound and in need of considerable cellaring. I expect it will drink well for a period measured in decades rather than years. The 2009 has always been quite exuberant, but for now, it looks the wine is going to need a bit of time before it is at its best. Readers should note that Roederer has decided to release the 2009 ahead of the 2008. ”
More Reviews +
95+/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
robertparker.com,
May 2018
“Released two years ago, the 2009 is just starting another, more "Burgundian" life. Tasted in May 2018, the bouquet was pretty reductive, with flinty and toasty/nutty notes and some potted ginger flavors. Full-bodied, round and rich on the palate, this is a stunningly pure, fresh and salty 2009 that is driven by its chalky terroir and the lingering salinity. Is it really 2009? It is ripe, yes, but driven by the strength of chalk. The finish is pure, clean, fresh, very complex and long yet delicate and endlessly salty. However, two years after disgorgement, the 2009 Cristal is closing down and in a pretty reductive stage right now.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Tasted blind. A little more evolved on the nose [than the 2008 tasted alongside] – a bit like white burgundy. Creamy and fine. And layered. Long. Gorgeous. Creamy without being at all fat.”
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2019
“An open, soft and welcoming nose with sweet lemony fruit, pastry tones, vanilla and a faint spicy edge. There is a ripe, generously fruity character behind the reserved subtlety of the nose. Bright fruit of exemplary polish. The opulent, fruit-packed palate is smooth-textured and round. The generosity turns into beautiful focus as the wine advances on the palate. Salivating, energetic, chalky-mineral and tight, promising great potential. ”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Jul 2017
“Rich, creamy and radiant, the 2009 Cristal captures all of the natural generosity of the vintage while also retaining a good bit of freshness and aromatic intensity. Immediate and totally sensual in its allure, the 2009 will drink well with minimal cellaring. All things considered, at this stage, the 2009 comes across as relatively restrained for a wine from a warm year. ”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Tense and lifted on the nose. So very different from the vintage: much more finesse. Racy and elegant. Masses of acidity and tension. Lighter in texture than the vintage. A racy thoroughbred. So refined but very youthful.”
“2009 Cristal has really shut down since I tasted it this past spring, which is probably a very good thing for its potential longevity. The radiance and richness the 2009 showed just a few months ago is not all evident. Instead, the 2009 comes across as tightly wound and in need of considerable cellaring. I expect it will drink well for a period measured in decades rather than years. The 2009 has always been quite exuberant, but for now, it looks the wine is going to need a bit of time before it is at its best. Readers should note that Roederer has decided to release the 2009 ahead of the 2008. ”
More Reviews +
95+/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
robertparker.com,
May 2018
“Released two years ago, the 2009 is just starting another, more "Burgundian" life. Tasted in May 2018, the bouquet was pretty reductive, with flinty and toasty/nutty notes and some potted ginger flavors. Full-bodied, round and rich on the palate, this is a stunningly pure, fresh and salty 2009 that is driven by its chalky terroir and the lingering salinity. Is it really 2009? It is ripe, yes, but driven by the strength of chalk. The finish is pure, clean, fresh, very complex and long yet delicate and endlessly salty. However, two years after disgorgement, the 2009 Cristal is closing down and in a pretty reductive stage right now.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Tasted blind. A little more evolved on the nose [than the 2008 tasted alongside] – a bit like white burgundy. Creamy and fine. And layered. Long. Gorgeous. Creamy without being at all fat.”
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2019
“An open, soft and welcoming nose with sweet lemony fruit, pastry tones, vanilla and a faint spicy edge. There is a ripe, generously fruity character behind the reserved subtlety of the nose. Bright fruit of exemplary polish. The opulent, fruit-packed palate is smooth-textured and round. The generosity turns into beautiful focus as the wine advances on the palate. Salivating, energetic, chalky-mineral and tight, promising great potential. ”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Jul 2017
“Rich, creamy and radiant, the 2009 Cristal captures all of the natural generosity of the vintage while also retaining a good bit of freshness and aromatic intensity. Immediate and totally sensual in its allure, the 2009 will drink well with minimal cellaring. All things considered, at this stage, the 2009 comes across as relatively restrained for a wine from a warm year. ”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Tense and lifted on the nose. So very different from the vintage: much more finesse. Racy and elegant. Masses of acidity and tension. Lighter in texture than the vintage. A racy thoroughbred. So refined but very youthful.”
“The 2008 Cristal is one of the most complete, most dazzling Champagnes I have ever tasted. A stunning wine from any and all perspectives, the 2008 simply has it all. Spherical in construction, with superb persistence. The 2008 takes hold of all the senses and never gives up. One of the many things that makes the 2008 special is a combination of ripe fruit and bright, piercing acidity. Marzipan, lemon confit, dried flowers and orchard fruit all build into the explosive, resonant finish. “We learned from the mistakes of 1996, when we picked more on acid than ripeness, as was the norm in Champagne back then” Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon told me recently. “In 1996, the best fruit turned out to be the last picks, where the fruit was physiologically ripe. Today, we aim to pick all our fruit with that criteria.””
More Reviews +
19.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“16% malo, only on Pinot Noir from the Montagne de Reims. ‘There were lots of similarities with 1996, which gave us the possibility to replay the 1996 vintage! Maybe we picked 1996 a bit early so in 2008 we waited longer, by at least a week, than in 1996. Lots of tasting – far more than in 1996 when Roederer based picking only on analysis – and there was no malo in 1996.’ For the first time ever, they decided to release it later than the younger vintage, 2009 – so 2008 had nine years on lees. The last batch of 2008 will be disgorged in March 2019. (Scan the back label via the Roederer app to get the disgorgement year.) Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon is coy about the assemblage. ‘I’m looking for chalkiness.’ In 2008 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, which reflects perfectly the balance of their plantings. 40% of the estate was biodynamic then.
Really dense nose with lots of evolution but still extreme freshness. Some apple-skin character. Bone dry but wonderful lift and freshness. Long and super-lively. Real undertow, but very racy on the nose. Lots to chew on. Really elegant!
Drink 2018-2038”
98/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2020
“The finest young Cristal in decades, the wine wafts from the glass with a pure and vibrant bouquet of crisp orchard fruit, clear honey, warm brioche, citrus zest and white flowers. On the palate, it's full-bodied, intense and incisive, with superb concentration, racy acids and a long, searingly chalky finish. Pristinely balanced, there are some 500,000 bottles of this legend-in-the-making.”
96-100/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2017
“Tight, hugely promising nose still with restraint. There is immaculat purity and radiance to the chalk and toast nuanced nose full of cool, crisp fruit and baking spices complexity. A lovely feather light feeling yet fruit packed palate of fabulous electric vivacity. The finish is so long and mineral with a chalky bite promising great longevity. A wine that puts a big smile on my face. ”
19+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“All grands crus. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. Some large (600-litre) oak. Aged for nine years on the lees. Disgorged 2018. Dosage 8 g/l. Longer in bottle than any other Cristal. More malo and a little more oak on this wine that Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon claims is all the better for the lessons learnt with the similarly high-acid 1996 vintage.
Tasted blind. Restrained, tight-knit nose. Savoury and tight. Very youthful – almost painful. Masses of acidity. Not yet ready. A certain greenness and very dry. Marmalade. 2008?
Drink 2019-2034”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“It is a tribute to the special qualities of the 2008 vintage that this Cristal has benefitted from longer in bottle than any other Cristal: 10 years. More malo and a little more oak on this wine that Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon claims is all the better for the lessons learnt with the similarly high-acid 1996 vintage. Just one sniff and you're assailed by the most extraordinary combination of density and lift. There's a hint of lime and it's extremely tight (I'd guess it has only just been deemed ready to release) and firm on the finish. But there is just so much pleasure to be had already. Super-fresh but so concentrated that there is no question of austerity. So much to dig into here. It will surely slowly unfurl but is already gorgeous. Hedonistic rather than intellectual. Very special.”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2018
“I tasted a trial sample of a wine that is not yet disgorged. This will be the first time a Cristal has been launched at 10 years old. Dosage was just 8 g/l, the lowest ever. Lécaillon thinks 2008 is even better than 2002 potentially. Very persistent. This is a marvellous wine that is incredibly complete but obviously still youthful. Cristal followers are in for a major treat.
”
98+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The 2008 Cristal is a real head-turner. Powerful, ample and explosive in all of its dimensions, the 2008 takes hold of the sense and never lets up. There is a crystalline purity to the flavors that is simply remarkable. Although still a baby, the 2008 looks like it will soon take its place alongside the greatest Cristals. Today, it is breathtaking. ”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Much cooler year than 2012. From 45 different parcels.
Deep golden straw. Surprisingly reticent nose but massive spread on the palate. Masses of acidity. Not as obviously appealing as the 2012 but it grows towards the peacock’s tail end. Then it really opened out in the glass, promising a long life and even greater complexity.”
“The 2008 Cristal is one of the most complete, most dazzling Champagnes I have ever tasted. A stunning wine from any and all perspectives, the 2008 simply has it all. Spherical in construction, with superb persistence. The 2008 takes hold of all the senses and never gives up. One of the many things that makes the 2008 special is a combination of ripe fruit and bright, piercing acidity. Marzipan, lemon confit, dried flowers and orchard fruit all build into the explosive, resonant finish. “We learned from the mistakes of 1996, when we picked more on acid than ripeness, as was the norm in Champagne back then” Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon told me recently. “In 1996, the best fruit turned out to be the last picks, where the fruit was physiologically ripe. Today, we aim to pick all our fruit with that criteria.””
More Reviews +
19.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“16% malo, only on Pinot Noir from the Montagne de Reims. ‘There were lots of similarities with 1996, which gave us the possibility to replay the 1996 vintage! Maybe we picked 1996 a bit early so in 2008 we waited longer, by at least a week, than in 1996. Lots of tasting – far more than in 1996 when Roederer based picking only on analysis – and there was no malo in 1996.’ For the first time ever, they decided to release it later than the younger vintage, 2009 – so 2008 had nine years on lees. The last batch of 2008 will be disgorged in March 2019. (Scan the back label via the Roederer app to get the disgorgement year.) Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon is coy about the assemblage. ‘I’m looking for chalkiness.’ In 2008 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, which reflects perfectly the balance of their plantings. 40% of the estate was biodynamic then.
Really dense nose with lots of evolution but still extreme freshness. Some apple-skin character. Bone dry but wonderful lift and freshness. Long and super-lively. Real undertow, but very racy on the nose. Lots to chew on. Really elegant!
Drink 2018-2038”
98/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2020
“The finest young Cristal in decades, the wine wafts from the glass with a pure and vibrant bouquet of crisp orchard fruit, clear honey, warm brioche, citrus zest and white flowers. On the palate, it's full-bodied, intense and incisive, with superb concentration, racy acids and a long, searingly chalky finish. Pristinely balanced, there are some 500,000 bottles of this legend-in-the-making.”
96-100/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2017
“Tight, hugely promising nose still with restraint. There is immaculat purity and radiance to the chalk and toast nuanced nose full of cool, crisp fruit and baking spices complexity. A lovely feather light feeling yet fruit packed palate of fabulous electric vivacity. The finish is so long and mineral with a chalky bite promising great longevity. A wine that puts a big smile on my face. ”
19+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“All grands crus. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. Some large (600-litre) oak. Aged for nine years on the lees. Disgorged 2018. Dosage 8 g/l. Longer in bottle than any other Cristal. More malo and a little more oak on this wine that Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon claims is all the better for the lessons learnt with the similarly high-acid 1996 vintage.
Tasted blind. Restrained, tight-knit nose. Savoury and tight. Very youthful – almost painful. Masses of acidity. Not yet ready. A certain greenness and very dry. Marmalade. 2008?
Drink 2019-2034”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2018
“It is a tribute to the special qualities of the 2008 vintage that this Cristal has benefitted from longer in bottle than any other Cristal: 10 years. More malo and a little more oak on this wine that Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon claims is all the better for the lessons learnt with the similarly high-acid 1996 vintage. Just one sniff and you're assailed by the most extraordinary combination of density and lift. There's a hint of lime and it's extremely tight (I'd guess it has only just been deemed ready to release) and firm on the finish. But there is just so much pleasure to be had already. Super-fresh but so concentrated that there is no question of austerity. So much to dig into here. It will surely slowly unfurl but is already gorgeous. Hedonistic rather than intellectual. Very special.”
19.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
May 2018
“I tasted a trial sample of a wine that is not yet disgorged. This will be the first time a Cristal has been launched at 10 years old. Dosage was just 8 g/l, the lowest ever. Lécaillon thinks 2008 is even better than 2002 potentially. Very persistent. This is a marvellous wine that is incredibly complete but obviously still youthful. Cristal followers are in for a major treat.
”
98+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“The 2008 Cristal is a real head-turner. Powerful, ample and explosive in all of its dimensions, the 2008 takes hold of the sense and never lets up. There is a crystalline purity to the flavors that is simply remarkable. Although still a baby, the 2008 looks like it will soon take its place alongside the greatest Cristals. Today, it is breathtaking. ”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Much cooler year than 2012. From 45 different parcels.
Deep golden straw. Surprisingly reticent nose but massive spread on the palate. Masses of acidity. Not as obviously appealing as the 2012 but it grows towards the peacock’s tail end. Then it really opened out in the glass, promising a long life and even greater complexity.”
“With a first course of scallops and chestnut velouté at Pichon Lalande. Smoky nose. Extremely tight and lemony. Very definitely for the long term. Hold!”
More Reviews +
93-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2016
“Early approachability is a main feature of this Cristal, which is laudably open and friendly upon release. Truly Cristal in style, bright and discreetly intense, feeling even light in its focused, taut acidity. Still, there is caressing roundness on the palate of exemplary silky smoothness. Not the most obviously impressive of vintages but an intriguing one, one that has hidden depths. Dosed at 9.5g/l”
95/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon calls Cristal "the first terroir cuvée of the Champagne." He furthers, "It’s not just Chardonnay or Pinot Noir, but the chalk that brings the ultimate finesse, length and precision of Cristal." Forty-five blocks with averaging age of 43-years-old, low-yielding vines form the base of Cristal, which is usually made of approximately 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay. Due to an early bud break (end of March) and the wet summer, the 2007 was picked at the end of August, so almost 100 days after the flowering instead of the normal 93-95 days. There is a bit less Pinot Noir than usual (57%) and accordingly, more Chardonnay (43%) in the 2007 Cristal. This Champagne comes along in a golden color and with a deep and matured, yet well-defined bouquet of ripe yellow fruits and honey notes. Full-bodied, round and very complex, the generous 2007 is a perfect mix of ripe fruit and precise minerality. It is a silky textured, pure and precise, as well as powerful and expressive Champagne. It has great tension and grip in the very long and persistent finish. Great expression of chalk. The 2007 was disgorged in 2015. The 2009 is to be released in September; the 2008 won't be in the market earlier than January 2018. Neither a 2010 nor a 2011 will be released, but a 2012.”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“Long-time Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon has produced yet another in a string of superb Champagnes with the 2007 Cristal. Rich, powerful and enveloping, the 2007 takes hold of all the senses and never lets up. The aromatics alone are captivating, but then the wine opens on the palate, revealing layer after layer of flavor to match a multi-dimensional, kaleidoscopic personality that will leave Champagne lovers weak at the knees. The 2007 is 58% Chardonnay and 42% Pinot Noir, which is to say a bit more Chardonnay-leaning than is the norm. The 2007 is striking today, but it should also age effortlessly for several decades. It is also without question one of the very finest new releases of the year.”
“60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay.
Complex but very youthful nose. So tight and coiled. Still so tight it’s almost metallic on the finish. What a shame it is that people are drinking this already. There is massive density here but not – yet – that much flavour and development. Lots going on in the finish. Very long. Wait!!!! 12%”
More Reviews +
18/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2015
“Lovely broad nose with buttered toast and popcorn and creamy baked apple fruit. Long, dense finish – lifted yet concentrated with some lovely bitter umami character too. More open than previous vintages but undoubtedly ageworthy too. ”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“Broad, ample and resonant on the palate, the 2006 Cristal dazzles with its pure richness and volume. Readers need to give the 2006 another 4-5 years in bottle, perhaps longer, as the wine appears to be shutting down a bit. Tasted next to the 2002, today the 2006 is a bit less opulent but just as intense, layered and deep. This is a fabulous showing.”
17++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2014
“2006 was a very warm year, characterised by contrasting rainfall patterns. Following on from an unusually cold and rainy August, a warm, dry September hastened up the ripening process producing distinctive, rich, complex grapes. Disgorged January 2013.
Current vintage. Quite rich, powerful nose. Intense and powerful Still very high in acidity. Tightly wound. I'd almost decant this! Throbs with future possibility. Great potential but not yet reality.”
95/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2013
“Although it is still young, this vintage of Cristal promises great things. There’s an impressive balance between ripe fruit and crisp acidity, rich and food friendly, but also a fine apéritif. Apricot and grape- fruit flavors are round and rich, but with considerable minerality as well”
93/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“Roederer’s 2006 Brut Cristal is striking in its sense of lift and delicacy, serving as one of many instances where those bringing preconceptions of this vintage’s warmth and ripeness of fruit to their experience may be pleasantly surprised. A nose of fresh apple, fennel and cucumber sets up associations with a slaw or salad that are crisply, lusciously and refreshingly redeemed on the palate. A garland of honeysuckle and heliotrope complements subtle suggestions of raw almond and vanilla, while alkaline and iodine notes as well as cooling but pungent green herbal notes add to the soothing yet stimulating finish. This exceptionally poised, refined, and buoyant performance is apt to gain depth with a few years’ bottle age.
Owners of vast vineyards (totally some 500 acres) that supply the majority of their fruit, Roederer also presides – by design as well as due to that vastness – over a mind-bending number of micro-vinifications, divided entirely between tanks and foudres, supplemented by a concomitantly deep and diverse range of reserve wines. But for all of the variety that these phenomena entail, scarcely any lots undergo malo-lactic transformation.
”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2013
“This elegant version shows beautiful texture and a sense of finesse despite the underlying power of vibrant acidity and smoky minerality. The palate offers a finely layered mesh of blackberry, poached pear, almond pastry, lemon zest and pickled ginger flavors”
96+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2013
“The 2006 Cristal is one of the most towering, structured young Cristals I can remember tasting. Roederer is among the first, if not the first, major house to release its tete de cuvees. Young Cristal can often deceive with its open, seductive personality, but that is not at all the case here. The 2006 is majestic, powerful Cristal that is going to need bottle age. Today it is massive, tightly coiled and imposing, with tons of structure, phenomenal balance and plenty of potential for the future.”
“The 2008 Cristal Late-Released is a special cuvée bottled to celebrate Cristal’s 150th Anniversary. It spent an added four years on the lees, which places it between the regular release and the Vinothèque in terms of aging. Explosive in the glass, the 2008 possesses off-the-charts textural richness and density, much of that coming from the shaking of the bottles during élevage (poignettage). That extra mid-palate resonance fills out the layers, resulting in a Cristal that is utterly profound. Unforgettable. Disgorged: 2020.”
More Reviews +
100/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
May 2026
“MAGNUM - This is perfect. Aromas of bread dough, pie crust, dried lemons, apricots, flint, French toast and caramel. Medium- to full-bodied with spices, iodine, oysters and similar flavors on the palate. Endless and seamless. I remember tasting it on release, and it’s softening and giving a caressing mouthfeel after being so structured. A late release of this glorious wine in magnum. From organically grown grapes. Drink or hold.”
“60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay.
Complex but very youthful nose. So tight and coiled. Still so tight it’s almost metallic on the finish. What a shame it is that people are drinking this already. There is massive density here but not – yet – that much flavour and development. Lots going on in the finish. Very long. Wait!!!! 12%”
More Reviews +
18/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2015
“Lovely broad nose with buttered toast and popcorn and creamy baked apple fruit. Long, dense finish – lifted yet concentrated with some lovely bitter umami character too. More open than previous vintages but undoubtedly ageworthy too. ”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2014
“Broad, ample and resonant on the palate, the 2006 Cristal dazzles with its pure richness and volume. Readers need to give the 2006 another 4-5 years in bottle, perhaps longer, as the wine appears to be shutting down a bit. Tasted next to the 2002, today the 2006 is a bit less opulent but just as intense, layered and deep. This is a fabulous showing.”
17++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2014
“2006 was a very warm year, characterised by contrasting rainfall patterns. Following on from an unusually cold and rainy August, a warm, dry September hastened up the ripening process producing distinctive, rich, complex grapes. Disgorged January 2013.
Current vintage. Quite rich, powerful nose. Intense and powerful Still very high in acidity. Tightly wound. I'd almost decant this! Throbs with future possibility. Great potential but not yet reality.”
95/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2013
“Although it is still young, this vintage of Cristal promises great things. There’s an impressive balance between ripe fruit and crisp acidity, rich and food friendly, but also a fine apéritif. Apricot and grape- fruit flavors are round and rich, but with considerable minerality as well”
93/100
David Schildknecht,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2013
“Roederer’s 2006 Brut Cristal is striking in its sense of lift and delicacy, serving as one of many instances where those bringing preconceptions of this vintage’s warmth and ripeness of fruit to their experience may be pleasantly surprised. A nose of fresh apple, fennel and cucumber sets up associations with a slaw or salad that are crisply, lusciously and refreshingly redeemed on the palate. A garland of honeysuckle and heliotrope complements subtle suggestions of raw almond and vanilla, while alkaline and iodine notes as well as cooling but pungent green herbal notes add to the soothing yet stimulating finish. This exceptionally poised, refined, and buoyant performance is apt to gain depth with a few years’ bottle age.
Owners of vast vineyards (totally some 500 acres) that supply the majority of their fruit, Roederer also presides – by design as well as due to that vastness – over a mind-bending number of micro-vinifications, divided entirely between tanks and foudres, supplemented by a concomitantly deep and diverse range of reserve wines. But for all of the variety that these phenomena entail, scarcely any lots undergo malo-lactic transformation.
”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2013
“This elegant version shows beautiful texture and a sense of finesse despite the underlying power of vibrant acidity and smoky minerality. The palate offers a finely layered mesh of blackberry, poached pear, almond pastry, lemon zest and pickled ginger flavors”
96+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2013
“The 2006 Cristal is one of the most towering, structured young Cristals I can remember tasting. Roederer is among the first, if not the first, major house to release its tete de cuvees. Young Cristal can often deceive with its open, seductive personality, but that is not at all the case here. The 2006 is majestic, powerful Cristal that is going to need bottle age. Today it is massive, tightly coiled and imposing, with tons of structure, phenomenal balance and plenty of potential for the future.”
“Magnum. So powerfully scented that it perfumed the room on opening. Meaty, savoury nose. Not at all sweet. Bone dry and upright somehow. Very appetising - not at all rich. A seriously good aperitif champagne though not one of the most concentrated Cristals. Impressive persistence though.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2012
“(L036332A109909): Bright yellow-gold. Heady floral-accented citrus and orchard fruits on the nose, with smoky mineral and floral overtones adding complexity. Velvety and chewy in texture, offering deep, juicy orange and poached pear flavors and suave honey and chamomile nuances. Blends precision with power, finishing with a distinct mineral quality and excellent persistence.”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2013
“Pale lemon colour. Round and ripe yet fresh nose with stone fruits, spice, lemon and mild herb notes. Soft palate without the usual driven spine of Cristal, fluffy mousse and yet a good acidity for the vintage. Long with some bitter notes. Much more open than the 2006 today and with very little rot characters, however not as pure and precise as Cristal at its best. One of the stars of this difficult year. Cristal for mid-term drinking. ”
“Pale salmon. Fragrant, floral, flattering with a dry finish after an exceedingly rich nose and a little chew. After a lovely friendly start there is lots of grip and this is glorious wine that is clearly set for a long life. In my experience Cristal Rosé can last and last.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Jul 2025
“The 2015 Cristal Rosé is superb. Rich and dense, the 2015 possesses terrific depth and textural resonance from start to finish. Time in the glass brings out notable creaminess and volume. Kirsch, red plum, blood orange and dried rose petal infuse the 2015 with captivating, palate-staining depth. Cristal Rosé is certainly one of the very finest wines in this uneven vintage. I find it a touch more complete than the Blanc. Of course, the volume for the Rosé is much smaller, but the best sites clearly had the potential to be quite successful. The blend is 56% Pinot Noir from Bonotte Pierre Robert (Aÿ) and 44% Chardonnay from Montmartin (Mesnil-sur-Oger) and Pierre Vaudon (Avize).”
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
wineadvocate.com,
Jul 2025
“Disgorged in March 2024 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, the 2015 Cristal Rosé has turned out very well. As always, it originates from the south-facing yet windswept slopes of Aÿ, where Pinot Noir thrives, and is complemented by Chardonnay from Avize and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, imparting freshness and lightness to the infused Pinot Noir. The wine unfurls from the glass with a bouquet of orange zest, red currant, raspberry and spices interwoven with citrus notes. On the palate, it is medium to full-bodied, fleshy and intense, brimming with bright acidity and ample dry extract, culminating in a long, saline-tinged finish. The 2015 rendition is neither as tightly coiled as the 2013 nor as concentrated as the 2012, yet it exhibits the hallmark precision expected from this house—shaped by intelligent viticulture and a cellar master who refuses to rest on his laurels. True to tradition, it is crafted without malolactic fermentation, a choice that aligns with Roederer’s approach to dosage.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2025
“Filigreed elegance, showing subtle red fruit over buttery toasted bread, white chocolate and lemon zest with essential oils. Fine pinprick mousse with medium to full body and zesty yet integrated acidity. The long, strawberry-pie finish is mineral and precise, not without grip yet still refined. Drink or hold.”
“MAGNUM - A rollercoaster vintage of shifting weather conditions, yet the wines surprise with their brightness and charm. This magnum opens with finely smoky restraint, hinting at longevity, before revealing abundant crunchy peach and raspberry fruit, delicately laced with vanilla spiciness. The palate is juicy and airy, almost lacy in texture, underpinned by chalky mineral drive. A saline tang on the finish adds precision and length.”
More Reviews +
97-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2014 vintage of Cristal Rosé is a pure and vivacious delight. It comes with attractive, exuberant fruit, that is open and accessible upon launch. Despite its fruity richness the overall impression is of cool and crunchy fruit. Wild strawberries, sweet peach and red currants. I am loving the smoky-toasty layer bringing reservedness and a notion of minerality. On the palate it is dancingly vibrant, saline and comes with an inviting easiness and deliciousness to it. A vintage ready to charm and… keep on charming. ”
97/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Roederer's 2014 Cristal Rosé has turned out beautifully, unwinding in the glass with aromas of sweet cherries, almonds, citrus fruit and red berries mingled with notions of white flowers and wet chalk. Full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a layered core of fruit and a pillowy mousse, it's deep, racy and electric, concluding with a long, mineral finish. Comparatively open out of the gates, it's no slight to the 2014's seriousness to say that it will drink well while its 2013 counterpart sleeps in the cellar. Deriving from just a handful of the over 39 blocks that inform the regular Cristal 2014, I suspect that its origins have even more to do with the extra dimension it possesses above and beyond its white counterpart than the subtle infusion of Pinot Noir phenolics that give it its delicate pink hue.”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“A rollercoaster vintage of shifting weather conditions, yet the wines surprise with their brightness and charm. This magnum opens with finely smoky restraint, hinting at longevity, before revealing abundant crunchy peach and raspberry fruit, delicately laced with vanilla spiciness. The palate is juicy and airy, almost lacy in texture, underpinned by chalky mineral drive. A saline tang on the finish adds precision and length.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2025
“The 2014 Cristal Rosé is fascinating to taste next to the 2015 and a few older vintages, as it is decidedly linear and taut, signatures that are typical of the year. Cranberry, chalk, mint, white pepper and blood orange are all finely sculpted. This is an especially fine showing. I imagine the 2014 will flesh out beautifully with time in bottle. It's not an immediate Cristal Rosé, but more of a long distance runner. Readers should be in no rush here. Dosage is 8 grams per liter. Disgorged: February 2024.”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2014 Cristal Rosé sizzles with energy. Finely cut and crystalline to the core, the 2014 is laced with striking vibrancy. Chalk, mint, white flowers, cranberry and blood orange all race across the palate. Deceptively understated and nuanced, the 2014 possesses tons of energy and captivating inner perfume. The 2014 is at the beginning of what is sure to be a very long life. I would not plan on opening a bottle for at least a few years. The style of the vintage is one built on linear intensity more than opulence, like say 2004, with captivating aromatics and a sort of inner tension that needs to resolve. As always, the Rosé is done in the classic Roederer infusion style in which Pinot Noir is vinified on the skins and then blended with Chardonnay to complete the fermentation. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. Disgorged: June 2022.”
“The 2014 vintage of Cristal Rosé is a pure and vivacious delight. It comes with attractive, exuberant fruit, that is open and accessible upon launch. Despite its fruity richness the overall impression is of cool and crunchy fruit. Wild strawberries, sweet peach and red currants. I am loving the smoky-toasty layer bringing reservedness and a notion of minerality. On the palate it is dancingly vibrant, saline and comes with an inviting easiness and deliciousness to it. A vintage ready to charm and… keep on charming. ”
More Reviews +
97/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“Roederer's 2014 Cristal Rosé has turned out beautifully, unwinding in the glass with aromas of sweet cherries, almonds, citrus fruit and red berries mingled with notions of white flowers and wet chalk. Full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a layered core of fruit and a pillowy mousse, it's deep, racy and electric, concluding with a long, mineral finish. Comparatively open out of the gates, it's no slight to the 2014's seriousness to say that it will drink well while its 2013 counterpart sleeps in the cellar. Deriving from just a handful of the over 39 blocks that inform the regular Cristal 2014, I suspect that its origins have even more to do with the extra dimension it possesses above and beyond its white counterpart than the subtle infusion of Pinot Noir phenolics that give it its delicate pink hue.”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“A rollercoaster vintage of shifting weather conditions, yet the wines surprise with their brightness and charm. This magnum opens with finely smoky restraint, hinting at longevity, before revealing abundant crunchy peach and raspberry fruit, delicately laced with vanilla spiciness. The palate is juicy and airy, almost lacy in texture, underpinned by chalky mineral drive. A saline tang on the finish adds precision and length.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2025
“The 2014 Cristal Rosé is fascinating to taste next to the 2015 and a few older vintages, as it is decidedly linear and taut, signatures that are typical of the year. Cranberry, chalk, mint, white pepper and blood orange are all finely sculpted. This is an especially fine showing. I imagine the 2014 will flesh out beautifully with time in bottle. It's not an immediate Cristal Rosé, but more of a long distance runner. Readers should be in no rush here. Dosage is 8 grams per liter. Disgorged: February 2024.”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2014 Cristal Rosé sizzles with energy. Finely cut and crystalline to the core, the 2014 is laced with striking vibrancy. Chalk, mint, white flowers, cranberry and blood orange all race across the palate. Deceptively understated and nuanced, the 2014 possesses tons of energy and captivating inner perfume. The 2014 is at the beginning of what is sure to be a very long life. I would not plan on opening a bottle for at least a few years. The style of the vintage is one built on linear intensity more than opulence, like say 2004, with captivating aromatics and a sort of inner tension that needs to resolve. As always, the Rosé is done in the classic Roederer infusion style in which Pinot Noir is vinified on the skins and then blended with Chardonnay to complete the fermentation. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. Disgorged: June 2022.”
“Magnum | The 2013 Cristal Rosé from Louis Roederer is one of the most complete wines to be found in Champagne in this vintage, so utterly pure and precise that I would run the risk of exhausting superlatives trying to express its clarity. Displaying a pale hue, it soars from the glass with a bouquet of kaleidoscopic complexity, featuring notes of tangerine zest, raspberry and rose petals mingling with peeled almonds and spices. Enjoyed from magnum, disgorged in February 2024, the wine’s persistent palate offers a bright, vibrant core of fruit, refined mousse and fine-boned structure, with racy and fresh acidity and a long, chalky finish. “With 2013, I was confident from day one, which was not the case with 2008,” recalls Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon, and the result in the glass precludes any argument about it—the 2013 Cristal Rosé is a wine that’s structurally complete, deep and multifaceted, even more spectacular than the white 2013 Cristal. When I asked William Kelley why he gave 99 points to 2013 if he rated the 2008 Cristal Rosé with 100, he for a moment insisted to me that it was the other way around.”
More Reviews +
97-100/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Apr 2021
“The palest peachy hue guides you to the seductive ripe and soft nose which comes with all the Cristal charms. Delicate peach and vanilla scented nose with cool rhubarb and floral notes speaking of supreme sophistication. On the palate it is fleshy and creamy with its crisp, driven acidity perfectly in balance with the pure fruity deliciousness. Stunningly polished and complete. ”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Aug 2021
“The 2013 Cristal Rosé is searingly intense right out of the glass, just like the Blanc, except it has a bit more fleshiness because of the skin contact on the Pinot. Cristal Rosé has one of the best track records for aging in Champagne. I suspect the 2013 will join the ranks of the epic vintages, but it is painfully tight today. The blend is 55% Pinot Noir (from Aÿ) and 45% Chardonnay (from Avize and Mesnil) done in the classic Roederer infusion style in which Pinot Noir is vinified on the skins and then blended with Chardonnay to complete the fermentation. About 25% of the lots were done in oak, while malolactic fermentation was blocked.”
99/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Apr 2021
“A candidate for wine-of-the-vintage honors in Champagne, Roederer's 2013 Cristal Rosé is showing brilliantly, unfurling in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, white flowers, red berries, stone fruit, freshly baked bread and tangerine oil. Full-bodied, layered and multidimensional, the vintage's bright girdling acids are amply cloaked in exuberant, expressive and notably concentrated fruit; so while this Cristal is as tensile and age-worthy as one would expect, it's also impressively fleshy and generous given the year. Concluding with an intensely sapid finish, the 2013 isn't as overtly structured as the muscular, tightly wound 2012: rather, it's the 2013's alliance of cut and flesh, precision and charm that's so compelling this year. This is another banner vintage for what I consider the reigning champion of the region's tête de cuvée bottlings, and it will be worth an effort to acquire.”
“Already upon launch this rosé shows rare harmony and seamlessness. It is opulently fruity and exuberantly Pinot-packed yet at the same time seductively silky-textured. The voluminous palate is perfectly integrated to the wine’s superb freshness that carries it to a great length. Structured whilst soft and comes with Cristal Rosé’s hallmark elegance and radiance. Highly enjoyable already but with great long-term ageing capacity. A perfect reflection of the vintage’s best qualities. Tasted 11/20.
Magnificent albeit super youthful in magnum, it is seductively classy and ultra refined with lots of hidden power. This intense, fruit-packed wine will defy time. 7/2023.”
More Reviews +
98-100/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2019
“Already upon launch this rosé shows rare harmony and seamlessness. It is opulently fruity and exuberantly Pinot-packed yet at the same time seductively silky-textured. The voluminous palate is perfectly integrated to the wine’s superb freshness that carries it to a great length. Structured whilst soft and comes with Cristal Rosé’s hallmark elegance and radiance. Highly enjoyable already but with great long-term ageing capacity. A perfect reflection of the vintage’s best qualities. Tasted 11/20.
Magnificent albeit super youthful in magnum, it is seductively classy and ultra refined with lots of hidden power. This intense, fruit-packed wine will defy time. 7/2023.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Disgorged January 2019.
Paler than the 2008 rosé. Straight up the nose with raciness and transparency. Some Riesling energy! Long and hugely impressive. Lowest dosage ever. Great stuff. Tastes sweet and already flirtatious.”
“Already upon launch this rosé shows rare harmony and seamlessness. It is opulently fruity and exuberantly Pinot-packed yet at the same time seductively silky-textured. The voluminous palate is perfectly integrated to the wine’s superb freshness that carries it to a great length. Structured whilst soft and comes with Cristal Rosé’s hallmark elegance and radiance. Highly enjoyable already but with great long-term ageing capacity. A perfect reflection of the vintage’s best qualities. Tasted 11/20.
Magnificent albeit super youthful in magnum, it is seductively classy and ultra refined with lots of hidden power. This intense, fruit-packed wine will defy time. 7/2023.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Disgorged January 2019.
Paler than the 2008 rosé. Straight up the nose with raciness and transparency. Some Riesling energy! Long and hugely impressive. Lowest dosage ever. Great stuff. Tastes sweet and already flirtatious.”
“Already upon launch this rosé shows rare harmony and seamlessness. It is opulently fruity and exuberantly Pinot-packed yet at the same time seductively silky-textured. The voluminous palate is perfectly integrated to the wine’s superb freshness that carries it to a great length. Structured whilst soft and comes with Cristal Rosé’s hallmark elegance and radiance. Highly enjoyable already but with great long-term ageing capacity. A perfect reflection of the vintage’s best qualities. Tasted 11/20.
Magnificent albeit super youthful in magnum, it is seductively classy and ultra refined with lots of hidden power. This intense, fruit-packed wine will defy time. 7/2023.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Disgorged January 2019.
Paler than the 2008 rosé. Straight up the nose with raciness and transparency. Some Riesling energy! Long and hugely impressive. Lowest dosage ever. Great stuff. Tastes sweet and already flirtatious.”
“A wine of sublime delicacy and finesse, the 2009 Cristal Rosé is simply magnificent. The 2009 is surprisingly refined, silky and nuanced for a wine from a warm vintage. The red and floral-infused overtones are quite attractive, but it is the wine's exceptional balance that places it among the best new releases of the year. Over the years, I have had the chance to taste many vintages of Cristal Rosé, a Champagne that needs bottle age to be at its very best. I suspect that will be the case here as well. Don't miss it.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2017
“Typically delicate, pretty orange-hued colour. The detailed nose reveals layers after layers. Friendly with soft, ripe, ample yet fine-tuned fruitiness. In addition to the conventional peachy, spicy, creamy and toasty notes there is an element of wildness in the aromas. Lovely fleshy and super creamy palate with its bright but soft acidity fitting perfectly with the mellow yet radient style of the wine. Perfectly pure and supple with exemplary persistance and an a lovely freshness at the finish.”
“Truly pale, youthful peachy colour. Highly elegant, toast-complexed, promising nose. There is rare delicacy on the pristine, vibrantly fruity nose. Crisp, lively, and elegant, the palate is feather-light yet intense. Sheer pleasure, the palate is dancingly playful with great energy and drive. Finely crafted with the purest fruit and perfect balance of autolytic characters and fruit ”
More Reviews +
98+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2015
“Still a baby, the 2004 Cristal Rosé has begun to put on considerable weight over the last few years, which only serves to balance the focus and tension that have always been present. Even at eleven years of age, the 2004 Cristal Rosé remains tightly wound and a touch austere at times. Hints of orange peel, white pepper and cranberry add an exotic flair on the deeply expressive finish. Readers who can find the 2004 should not hesitate, as it is simply stunning by any measure. ”
96/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Nov 2018
“With red berry and currant aromas on the pure and salty, complex and delicately vinous nose, the 2004 Cristal Rosé is a juicy but structured, vibrantly fresh and energetic cuvée with very fine tannins, great lightness, finesse and elegance. Tasted in New York, November 2018.”
18/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2014
“Looks similar in colour to a pale Provence rosé. Initial impression is toasty, struck-match notes. Then the Victoria plum fruit shows more on the palate but it is not so much the flavour as the intensity and strident freshness that dominates at the moment. Power and class combined. Goes on and on. But still way overpriced in terms of pleasure/price ratio. ”
“As hard as it may seem to believe, the 2002 Cristal Rosé (Re-Release) is even better than the Blanc. Utterly explosive in the glass, with soaring aromatics and tremendous palate presence, the 2002 dazzles from the very first taste. With time in the glass the 2002 grows effortlessly, showing myriad shades of nuance with each successive taste. I am reminded of the vertical I did of Cristal Rosé here a few years ago. Yes, the Rosé is expensive and rare. But it also delivers the goods. And then some.”
“The 2004 Cristal Vinotheque (magnum) takes thinks to another level. Two thousand-four has long been one of my favorite Champagne vintages for the top wines. It was a controversial year, one marked by record yields. Long aging on the lees fills out the wine while adding layers of dimension that enhance the essential qualities of the year. The 2004 Vinotheque is so timeless, so classy. ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“Disgorged in 2019 with a dosage of six grams per liter, the 2004 Cristal Vinothèque spent 20 years in the Louis Roederer cellars. This aging process involved the bottles being stacked horizontally on their sides, followed by a period stored neck-down to limit oxygen exposure while also reducing the surface area of lees in contact with the wine. After this, the Champagne underwent an additional six years of aging post-disgorgement. Lecaillon explains that this effort is to “push the wine with longer maturation into a more generous expression, not sacrificing salinity in the process.” Bursting from the glass with a deep bouquet of roasted nuts, candied lemon peel and brioche mingling with aromas of smoke and honeysuckle, it is richer and more dramatic aromatically, while simultaneously retaining a cool, racy profile. Medium to full-bodied, textural and multidimensional, it concludes with a long, chalky finish. With only 2,000 bottles available, it will be rather difficult to find; but those with disposable income who want to experience Cristal at its most generous expression should not hesitate to track down a bottle, as it stands as one of the most precise releases of the Vinothèque program so far and surpasses the regular 2004 Cristal in its depth and completeness.”
“Intense nose of preserved lemons, salted yellow plums, walnuts, toast, salted caramel, roasted chestnuts and dried pineapple. Beautiful and complex, from 15 years, 5 years en pointe, before disgorgement in 2018. Delicious, salty toffee character. Soft, silky bubbles. Long and powerful. Thought-provoking. Unique.”
More Reviews +
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The 1997 Cristal Vinothèque spent 15 years sur lattes and four years sur pointes (where bottles are stored neck-down to minimize contact between the lees and the wine, as well as ensuring a hermetic seal to the bottle) before disgorgement. It has shown brilliantly both times I've encountered it this year, unwinding in the glass with scents of sweet citrus fruit, peach, spices, iodine and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, racy and incisive, it's a precise, chiseled wine with a deep core and a long, saline finish.”
“Intense nose of preserved lemons, salted yellow plums, walnuts, toast, salted caramel, roasted chestnuts and dried pineapple. Beautiful and complex, from 15 years, 5 years en pointe, before disgorgement in 2018. Delicious, salty toffee character. Soft, silky bubbles. Long and powerful. Thought-provoking. Unique.”
More Reviews +
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The 1997 Cristal Vinothèque spent 15 years sur lattes and four years sur pointes (where bottles are stored neck-down to minimize contact between the lees and the wine, as well as ensuring a hermetic seal to the bottle) before disgorgement. It has shown brilliantly both times I've encountered it this year, unwinding in the glass with scents of sweet citrus fruit, peach, spices, iodine and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, racy and incisive, it's a precise, chiseled wine with a deep core and a long, saline finish.”
“The 2000 Cristal Rosé Vinothèque is similarly striking, soaring from the glass with notes of confit orange and stone fruit mingled with honeycomb, freshly baked bread and subtle hints of fresh field mushrooms. Full-bodied, vinous and multidimensional, it's ample and layered, with a concentrated core of fruit, lively acids and a long, sapid finish. It's a remarkable wine in its prime today.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jan 2021
“This Cristal Rosé Vinothèque has a slightly deeper colour than most vintages. It offers a mature wine’s complexity on the ripe fruity, spicy nose with blood orange, dried apricot, honey and black tea. Full-bodied, vinous and silky on the round palate with calmly bubbling mousse and long, pronounced aftertaste. ”
“The most compelling rendition of this bottling that Roederer has produced to date, the 2015 Brut Nature exhibits inviting aromas of golden orchard fruit, clear honey, dried white flowers and wet stones. Medium to full-bodied, layered and vinous, with a fleshy, concentrated core of fruit, chalky structure and a long, precise finish, it's a Pinot Noir-dominant blend from Cumières that's slightly lower in pressure, making for a more delicate mousse.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Aug 2022
“The 2015 Champagne Starck Brut Nature is forward with vinous and spicy aromas of saline and red currant, orange blossom, and smoke. It is expansive on the palate while maintaining a core of fresh acidity, with peach, dried flowers, and wet stone. This complex and unique expression is full of energy and has great gastronomic appeal. Best after 2022.”
95/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“This is very minerally and stony, with chalk and salt and oyster-shell undertones. It’s full-bodied and layered, yet remains intense with a lively finish. Done dry. Umami. No dosage. From biodynamically grown grapes with Demeter certification. Field blend from a single plot in Cumieres. Better in a few years. Drink or hold.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Aug 2022
“A fresh, mineral-driven Champagne, this swathes a firm frame of acidity in a raw silklike texture and finely meshed flavors of crunchy pear, mandarin orange peel, salted almond, dried raspberry and pickled ginger. Chardonnay, Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier. Best from 2023 through 2033.”
““This has a very fresh and pure, lemony nose and is completely mouth-filling. Then it freshens and composes and takes a fine, flinty, acidity-chiseled and dry ride to the finish. Super refreshing and saline. From biodynamically grown grapes – 55% pinot noir, 25% chardonnay and 20% pinot meunier. Drink or hold.””
More Reviews +
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“The 2012 Brut Nature is rich, powerful and incredibly expressive. It is also the most complete Brut Nature Roederer has made, as it has less of the austerity of previous releases and more creaminess. Powerful and yet gracious, the 2012 has so much to offer. Dried flowers, chamomile, dried pear and mint are all laced throughout this sublime, wonderfully nuanced Champagne. The Brut Nature is a field bend of 50% Pinot Noir, 30% Chardonnay and 20% Meunier taken from three parcels in Cumières and vinified together. ”
93/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2019
“Light golden yellow, silver reflections; fine pearly persistent mousse. Delicate white peach, nutty touch, fresh meadow herbs, smoky minerality, yellow plum fruit in the background. Crisp, tight-knit, white pear fruit, racy structure, salty note to the finish, linear and precise, accented acidity still dominates at the moment. Will benefit from further bottle ageing. (Deg. 2019). ”
“To produce the 2015 Brut Nature Rosé, Lécaillon and his team picked the ripest Pinot Noir in Roederer's holdings in lieu-dit Les Chèvres a week before the rest of their fruit there, macerating it at low temperature for four to five days before adding some 20% of this Pinot Noir to the same base that produces the regular Brut Nature. Delivering aromas of peach, clear honey, freshly baked bread and almond paste, it's medium to full-bodied, ample and fleshy, with a rich, vinous profile, racy acids and a long, chalky finish. This has always been a structured wine, but in 2015, that structure is cloaked in more flesh and texture.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Aug 2022
“A vivacious rosé, with a minerally overtone and a well-meshed range of crunchy pear, peach skin, pickled ginger and blood orange zest flavors set on a refined, lacy mousse. Ends with a long, creamy finish. Pinot Noir, Chardonnay and Pinot Meunier. ”
93/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“Crisp, tangy and focused, with aromas of raspberries, biscuits, watermelon, seashells, lemons and pink grapefruit. Sharp acidity with very fine bubbles. Field blend from a single plot in Cumieres. 80% field blend of chardonnay, pinot meunier, pinot noir, pinot blanc, arbanne and petit meslier, with 20% of cold-soaked pinot noir. Mineral and bone dry. Dosage 0g/L. From biodynamically grown grapes with Demeter certification. Drink or hold.”
““The fresh strawberries here are so clear and alluring. Some peaches, too. The palate offers pink grapefruit and fresh cherries, laced with lemons and yellow grapefruit. Deep, mineral backbone with a smooth resolve. Buoyed with pink fruit. Drink now.””
More Reviews +
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“The 2012 Brut Nature Rosé is rich, explosive and pulsing with energy. Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon adds an infusion of 25% cold soaked Pinot Noir into the same base wine as the 2012 Brut Nature, an approach that works beautifully in bringing out the energy and focus that make Champagnes from Cumières so distinctive. Even with all of its power, the 2012 is delicate, airy and full of nuance. This is such a gorgeous wine. I would prefer to drink it on the younger side”
“A true umami expression & hints of smoky charm, love the creaminesss & dried summer fruits, hint of bitter orange & charcuterie. The Roederer rose texture is always velvety.”
“Bursting with energy, influenced by the solar vintage, delicious fruit between zesty & dried fruit & is the most vinous of the five late releases. Some concentrated dried bitter orange with wild strawberry and hints of guava. Elegant texture & long length. Drink now and enjoy at least another 5+ years. Absolutely delicious.”
“A light haze of smoky charm, bright pink grapefruit & dried orange going like a mature marmalade; harmonious between fruit power and a mix of juicy sweet fruit, especially those dried raspberry, plum & cranberry. Intense and long length, super fresh and saline.”
“Amazing power, richness of Chardonnay fruits filling the palate, supported by the soft & rich dried red fruits and super velvety texture. Wow! Such elegance & length. My favourite of the five late release rose launched in autumn 2024. This gives the impression you can enjoy it now and will hold for at least another 5-10 years.”
“60% Chardonnay, 40% Pinot Noir. Sourced from Roederer’s ‘La Rivière’ estate in Cumières and Chouilly. 29% aged in oak, 24% malolactic conversion. Dosage 8 g/l.
Very subtle rosé hue, almost a brut non-rosé in colour. Leafy, soft and silky on the palate. Raspberry/strawberry cut with lemon acidity and a mineral streak. A fine vintage rosé.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2025
“Incorporating “the survivors of 2017,” as Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon notes, Roederer’s 2017 Brut Vintage Rosé is a fine effort in a year that was particularly challenging for red grapes, which were pressured by gray rot come harvest time. Heavily based on Pinot Noir, with fruit carefully selected during picking in Cumières, complemented by Chardonnay sourced from Chouilly, it offers a bouquet of strawberries, candied orange zest and spices. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, textural and ample, with a delicate infusion of Pinot Noir phenolics, vibrant acidity and a sapid finish. Disgorged with eight grams per liter dosage, it does not quite match the precision of its immediate predecessor.”
“As usual this cuvée is a blend of Cumières Pinot Noir and Chouilly Chardonnay. The pale colour comes with a orange tinge. The nose is perfectly pure with sweet red berry fruit intermingling with ripe apricot and baked peach tones. There is broadness to the juicy and zingy palate that has a satiny flow to it. An attractive, fresh and driven rosé with innate elegance. ”
“The 2015 Brut Vintage Rosé is generous and demonstrative, bursting with aromas of peach, orange and pear mingled with hints of red berries, fresh bread and ginger. Full-bodied, layered and vinous, it's rich and enveloping, its textural attack segueing into an ample, fleshy core that's girdled by bright acids and enlivened by a pillowy mousse. Long and expansive, it's more generous and gourmand than its racier 2014 predecessor, but just as good.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The delicate peachy colour is attained by the method Roederer likes to call 'infusion'. Here, the Chardonnay juices from Chouilly are added to the Cumières Pinot Noir maceration before being fermented. The nose is beautifully fruity, with sweet white peach and tangerine fruit complexed by a touch of toast, ginger and pencil shavings. The nose comes with the mildest vegetal edge typical of the vintage. The warm harvest year provided richness and roundness to this wine, which feels light and energetic once the brilliant, brisk acidity kicks in. A delightful wine, but not one of this iconic rosé's best vintages. Dosage 8g/l”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2021
“Pale (but not very pale) strawberry pink. Quite an opulent nose. This is going the super-fruity route! Good perhaps to have it very distinct from the Brut rather than just a Brut with a bit of colour? But it does finish dry and I could well imagine enjoying this with salmon and tuna and – hey – maybe chicken and white fish??! Very clean finish. Very slight bitterness on the end which I’m sure is intentional.”
“Wafting from the glass with notes of pear, raspberries and honeycomb, mingled with hints of white flowers and brioche, Roederer's 2014 Brut Vintage Rosé is medium to full-bodied, deep and complete, with fine concentration, brisk acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. Long and penetrating, this is a fabulous cuvée that punches well above its weight, and it comes warmly recommended.”
More Reviews +
17++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“63% Pinot Noir, mainly from Cumières, and 37% Chardonnay, mainly from Chouilly – all from Roederer's own vineyards, many of them biodynamically farmed. Roederer is the only champagne house making rosé via 'infusion'. Because Roederer are looking for fruit rather than colour or tannins, they cold-macerate the Pinot grapes for five or six days before fermentation and some Chardonnay juice is added to the cold maceration as chef de cave Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon believes this helps integration of this portion of the blend when it is later blended with the fermented Chardonnay in the spring following harvest. 17% of the wine is fermented in large oak fermenters. The wine spent 5.5 years in bottle on the lees and was disgorged in September 2019 with a dosage of 8 g/l.
It's hardly pink at all! I'd call this colour very pale apricot. Great vitality on the nose and excellent integration so that neither grape component is obvious. Very zesty with a hint of orange peel – definite citrus. More obvious acidity than on the Charles Heidsieck Réserve Rosé NV described in this selection. It's still quite youthful and should have a long life. Complex and almost liqueur-like in its intensity (not in terms of sweetness of which it has hardly any apparently). Perhaps tincture is a better word than liqueur. Bone-dry finish. A fascinating wine that would be worth cellaring for future Februarys. Not a ridiculous price for this quality.
Drink 2020 – 2030”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“The 2014 Brut Rosé Vintage is a wine of real power and intensity. Finely cut and also deep, the 2014 packs tons of vigor into its mid-weight frame. Dried pear, spice, licorice and red berry fruit begin to emerge with a bit of air, but the 2014 really needs a bit of time in bottle to be at its best. This is an impressive showing, to say the least.”
“The 2013 Vintage shows the compelling interplay of ripeness and high acids that are so typical of the year. The Vintage is built on a core of Pinot from Verzy, with Chardonnay from Chouilly, on the Cramant border. Constantly changing in the glass, the 2013 is a fabulous Champagne will reward readers with many years of exceptional drinking. The saltiness of Chouilly Chardonnay is a wonderful foil for Pinot here. Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon continues to bump up the Pinot here, as he takes the Vintage back to the blend that was used in the 1840s. Dosage is 8.5 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2019
“Light salmon pink, orange reflections; fine mousse. Fine red berry and cherry fruit underlaid with hints of tobacco, savouriness, meadow herbs, delicate orange zest and honeydew melon notes. Juicy, elegant, finely-meshed, balanced and round, fine acidity, red berry fruit on the finish; tight, a little stone fruit on the aftertaste. Versatile, good potential.”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
essiavellan.com,
May 2019
“Pale salmon colour. Pure and pristine, for the time being youthful, toast-laden fresh berry nose. The palate is perfectly fresh, vibrant and radient and full of delicious cool fruit.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“The 2013 Brut Rosé Vintage is gracious, perfumed and lifted. Sweet floral notes and red berry fruit are finely sketched in a Rosé that emphasizes energy and persistence. There is plenty of depth to the 2013, but it is more implied rather than overtly stated, as is the case with the 2012. Readers who enjoy subtle, nuanced Roses will find much to admire.”
92+/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
May 2018
“The Roederer 2013 Brut Vintage Rosé has a lovely light pink color and opens with highly delicate red fruit and flowery aromas. The wine is light, fresh, pure, very delicate and stimulatingly salty. Very energetic and at the same time caressing. The finish displays pink grapefruit, blood orange and lime zest flavors. Highly stimulating in its purity, freshness and citrus character. Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon finds it less vinous than the 2012, but he thinks the 2013 has huge aging potential. Disgorged in January 2018, tasted at the domaine in May.”
93/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Jul 2020
“This wine is already mature, with layers of toast over the crisp texture. There is a happy contrast between fruit and more complex, secondary flavors. This ripe, elegant wine is now ready to drink.”
93/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Jul 2020
“The 2013 Champagne Brut Rose is a more elegant, medium bodied Champagne that shines for its balance and seamless texture. Beautiful caramelized cherry, orange blossom, and strawberry notes all emerge from the glass, and it gains richness and depth with time. With its bright, lively style and a great finish, this is another beautiful wine from this estate.”
“The 2012 Brut Rosé Vintage is another compelling wine in this range from Roederer. Creamy, open-knit and radiant, the 2012 captures the natural radiance and generosity of this vintage beautifully. Red berry, chalk, white flowers and mint build in a wonderfully inviting, layered Champagne. Floral overtones add freshness and perfume to play off the rich fruit. Dense and racy, but not at all heavy, the Rosé Vintage is positively stellar in 2012.”
More Reviews +
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2017
“Pale peach-toned colour. Elegant, delicate style, lots of racy peachy fruitiness. Crisp and super young, and holds back a lot still. Linear and focused with plenty of interesting tension and dynamism. ”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“62% Cumières Pinot Noir, 38% north-facing Chardonnay in Chouilly. Disgorged early 2017. They keep the Pinot Noir at 4 °C and encourage a long maceration so it’s still juice. When the colour is right they rack and add the Chardonnay juice and then ferment them together. Lécaillon says they don’t make a non-vintage rosé because the colour is not consistent.
Subtle with a dry finish. Very readable already for such a young wine. ”
“Delicate peach hued colour. The subdued, pure fruity nose has fresh peaches, light pastyr and toasty nose alongside perky orange blossom notes. Fresh, light feeling palate with accentuated, driven acidity making the fruit shine. Medium-long, pure fruity finish. ”
“Like a more laid back version of 2006, great fruit and just further along the journey so more dried fruit and more rich pastry notes. Wonderful freshness, perhaps this 1998 is about at its peak of some age while beautifully fresh.”
“Fresh, youthful white flower nose with lovely gunpowdery depth. Stunning nose: lemon meringue tart, straw and apple. Delicate, subdued, elegant aromas. Fine palate on the reductive side. Still youthful and energetic, slightly tight. Fine, crisp acidity, purity and precision. On its way up. ”
More Reviews +
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2013
“(38% chardonnay, 33% pinot noir and 29% pinot meunier; aged on its lees for seven years, with a relatively low 5 g/l dosage; LAHFU): Bright yellow. Heady, complex bouquet of fresh nectarine, pear and melon, with notes of smoky lees and white flowers adding complexity. Bright, mineral-driven orchard and pit fruit flavors show impressive depth and focus, picking up notes of iodine, lemon pith and anise with air. Finishes on a chalky note, with excellent focus and lingering sweet butter, citrus fruit and smoke nuances. It's a great pleasure to see this iconic house return to strong form.”
16.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Mid gold. Firm, somehow ‘burnished gold’ nose. Not too sweet, very direct and ready. Long and neat. An excellent drink for now.”
91/100
David Schildknecht,
Robertparker.com,
Nov 2013
“Assembled from surprisingly close to one-third each of Champagne’s trio of major cepages, Moet & Chandon’s 2004 Brut Grand Vintage delivers a delightful aroma mingling chamomile and honeysuckle, pear and white peach, green tea and quinine, all anticipating the lusciously juicy, refreshingly tart and subtly piquant but also silken and buoyant palate impression that follows. As with the corresponding rose, I was surprised to find a decided sense of sweetness from just five grams residual sugar, but the ripe generosity of the vintage no doubt goes far toward explaining this, and I don’t find it at all misplaced, much less obtrusive. Its soothing texture complements this wine’s invigorating vivacity, levity, and transparence to herbal and floral nuances in a lingering finish. I would not be surprised to witness it offering some additional – or at least, new – delights over the next couple of years in bottle.”
“Gorgeous soft toastiness to the nose. Refined and beautifully reductive. Full, richly textured palate. Concentrated with the creamiest mousse and long length. Ready to please.”
More Reviews +
18.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
Thefinestbubble.com,
Aug 2023
“A great example showing in solar years fabulous champagne can emerge; having now tasted a few late disgorged 2006’s it really changes the champagne, extraordinary pure fruit, loads of dried fruits emerging, chalky fresh palate that has all that richness and complexity that comes with time. These Grand Vintage Collection releases since 2000 have all undergone tirage on cork and that really broadens the texture and slows down the ageing. ”
“Bright fruity, toasty and gunpowdery nose. Still youthful at this point with its reservations. However, pronounced, round and long promising great keeping potential. ”
“The recently disgorged 1998 Grand Vintage Rosé Collection is in a great place today. In 1998, the blend leans more heavily towards Chardonnay, which is felt in the wine’s lithe, delicate personality and brilliance. Dried flowers, mint, dried cherries, licorice and sweet red berries are all finely-knit in this super-attractive, open-knit Champagne. The 1998 is not super-complex, but it is absolutely delicious and also close to fully mature, all of which make it an excellent choice for drinking now and over the next handful of years. The blend is 43% Pinot Noir, 35% Chardonnay, and 22% Pinot Meunier. Disgorged in April 2013. ”
“Disgorged with five grams per liter dosage, Moët's 2013 Extra Brut Grand Vintage is a real success, wafting from the glass with aromas of pear, fresh bread, Meyer lemon, nougat and white flowers. Medium to full-bodied, chiseled and fine-boned, with an enveloping core of bright, vibrant fruit and a pretty pinpoint mousse, it concludes with a precise, penetrating finish. Incisive but not austere, it's an impressive effort, reflecting good levels of maturity in this cool, late harvest. It's as fine a rendition of this cuvée as I can remember tasting.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“A slowly ageing Champagne of a great, cool Chardonnay year. The stylishly toast-lined nose comes with a fruit salad of aromas: lime, green melon, pineapple and lemon pie. The palate has such tension and energy. It is not the friendliest of vintages: there is a degree of austerity for the time being; even the mousse feels a little nervous right now. Quite lean and juicy, with a lovely feeling of minerality on the long, lingering finish. This one will go far. Disgorged 9/21; dosage 5g/l”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“41% Chardonnay, 38% Pinot Noir, 21% Pinot Meunier. Dosage just 5 g/l. The back label also tells us 'the date mentioned hereafter is the disgorgement date' but there is no date on my back label – perhaps it's an early sample.
Pale lemon yellow. Attractive evolution on the nose without its being at all heavy aromatically. Pretty aggressive mousse but nicely judged blend that is quite elegant and certainly not aggressively sweet. Though this of course belongs in a completely different bracket from the army of fine and more idiosyncratic single-estate champagnes.”
91/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2013 Blanc Grand Vintage is bright, focused and wonderfully vibrant. Lemon peel, crushed rocks, mint and white pepper lend notable brightness to this chiseled, finely cut Champagne. The 2013 is just a bit compact today. Perhaps it will gain body with time in bottle.”
“Disgorged in February 2018 with five grams per liter dosage, Moët's 2012 Extra Brut Grand Vintage is showing well, unfurling in the glass with an expressive bouquet of ripe yellow orchard fruit, peaches, toasted nuts, warm bread and honeycomb. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, broad and fleshy, with a tangy but ripe core of fruit, nicely integrated acids and a pinpoint mousse, concluding with an attractively fruit-driven finish. The 2012 reflects both the concentration of the vintage and Moët's push for riper fruit, and it is already quite accessible.”
More Reviews +
91+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“The 2012 Grand Vintage is a very pretty, high-toned Champagne. Surprisingly nervous for this radiant vintage, the 2012 is going to need a bit of time to be at its best. Some of that may be attributable to early release of the 2012, which was bottled after only five years on its lees rather than the more customary seven or so because the house did not bottle either a 2010 or 2011 Grand Vintage, and the necessities of the market are what they are. Lemon confit, white flowers, and mint gradually open up in the glass. This is an especially taut style for the Grand Vintage, which is usually creamier and more open-knit in the early going. The blend is 41% Chardonnay, 36% Meunier and 33% Pinot Noir. Dosage is 5 grams per liter. Disgorged: February, 2018. ”
92/100
Jamie Goode,
WineAnorak.com,
Nov 2018
“12.5% alcohol. 41% Chardonnay, 26% Pinot Meunier, 33% Pinot Noir. Dosage 5 g/litre. Disgorged February 2018. The 74th release from this house. Lovely finesse here. Fruity with sweet citrus and pear notes, as well as some ripe peach and apricot hints. This has depth and generosity, and it’s really accessible, but there’s also some fine toast and bread complexity, and fine nuttiness. There’s a touch of nougat, too. Finishes long and fresh with a lemony tail. It’s rare that Chardonnay and Pinot Meunier are this high in the blend, but they work well here with the relatively low dosage.”
16.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“More Meunier than usual, with 26%, also 41% Chardonnay and 33% Pinot Noir. Disgorged February 2018. They also specify this date and the dosage on the back label nowadays. For a long time they didn’t claim the Extra Brut category but since the 2009 vintage they have printed Extra Brut on the front label.
Really quite a rich nose with very light smokiness. Then very bright fruit with tangerine notes on the nose and then strong acidity. Very punchy and nice dry finish, 5 g/l.”
93/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2020
“Light yellow-green, silver reflections; lively, persistent mousse. Juicy, white peach, a hint of mango and lime, soft smoky minerality, discreet biscuit. Taut, white stone fruit notes on the palate, fresh acidity, fine pear fruit expression on the finish, persistent, has ageing potential. An elegant food wine. (Deg. 10.2018).”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Disgorged in October 2018 – and we're very grateful for this information! 42% Pinot Noir, of which 13% was still, plus 35% Chardonnay and 23% Pinot Meunier. Five years on the lees and a relatively low dosage of 5 g/l.
Quite a deep bronzey-pink. Smells much richer than you expect from such a low-dosage wine. It also tastes richer. Opulent wine that's quite ready now. No real need to age this. Though the balance is fine for now. Mouth-filling and creditable.”
“Disgorged in February 2018 with five grams per liter dosage, Moët's 2012 Extra Brut Grand Vintage is showing well, unfurling in the glass with an expressive bouquet of ripe yellow orchard fruit, peaches, toasted nuts, warm bread and honeycomb. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, broad and fleshy, with a tangy but ripe core of fruit, nicely integrated acids and a pinpoint mousse, concluding with an attractively fruit-driven finish. The 2012 reflects both the concentration of the vintage and Moët's push for riper fruit, and it is already quite accessible.”
More Reviews +
16.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“More Meunier than usual, with 26%, also 41% Chardonnay and 33% Pinot Noir. Disgorged February 2018. They also specify this date and the dosage on the back label nowadays. For a long time they didn’t claim the Extra Brut category but since the 2009 vintage they have printed Extra Brut on the front label.
Really quite a rich nose with very light smokiness. Then very bright fruit with tangerine notes on the nose and then strong acidity. Very punchy and nice dry finish, 5 g/l.”
91+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2019
“The 2012 Grand Vintage is a very pretty, high-toned Champagne. Surprisingly nervous for this radiant vintage, the 2012 is going to need a bit of time to be at its best. Some of that may be attributable to early release of the 2012, which was bottled after only five years on its lees rather than the more customary seven or so because the house did not bottle either a 2010 or 2011 Grand Vintage, and the necessities of the market are what they are. Lemon confit, white flowers, and mint gradually open up in the glass. This is an especially taut style for the Grand Vintage, which is usually creamier and more open-knit in the early going. The blend is 41% Chardonnay, 36% Meunier and 33% Pinot Noir. Dosage is 5 grams per liter. Disgorged: February, 2018. ”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Disgorged in October 2018 – and we're very grateful for this information! 42% Pinot Noir, of which 13% was still, plus 35% Chardonnay and 23% Pinot Meunier. Five years on the lees and a relatively low dosage of 5 g/l.
Quite a deep bronzey-pink. Smells much richer than you expect from such a low-dosage wine. It also tastes richer. Opulent wine that's quite ready now. No real need to age this. Though the balance is fine for now. Mouth-filling and creditable.”
92/100
Jamie Goode,
WineAnorak.com,
Nov 2018
“12.5% alcohol. 41% Chardonnay, 26% Pinot Meunier, 33% Pinot Noir. Dosage 5 g/litre. Disgorged February 2018. The 74th release from this house. Lovely finesse here. Fruity with sweet citrus and pear notes, as well as some ripe peach and apricot hints. This has depth and generosity, and it’s really accessible, but there’s also some fine toast and bread complexity, and fine nuttiness. There’s a touch of nougat, too. Finishes long and fresh with a lemony tail. It’s rare that Chardonnay and Pinot Meunier are this high in the blend, but they work well here with the relatively low dosage.”
93/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2020
“Light yellow-green, silver reflections; lively, persistent mousse. Juicy, white peach, a hint of mango and lime, soft smoky minerality, discreet biscuit. Taut, white stone fruit notes on the palate, fresh acidity, fine pear fruit expression on the finish, persistent, has ageing potential. An elegant food wine. (Deg. 10.2018).”
“Moët’s 2009 Extra Brut Grand Vintage is radiant, supple and voluptuous, with all of the generosity of the year front and center. Candied lemon, almond, chamomile, brioche and baked apple tart develop in a rich, inviting champagne that will drink beautifully upon release. A wine of pure and total pleasure, the 2009 is one of those Champagnes that disappears in an instant. ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“There is a stunning reductive toastiness to this wine, which has enjoyed prolonged time on the lees. It does so under natural cork instead of crown cap, which greatly inhibits oxidative development. Coffee with cream, dark chocolate, apricots, dried apple and marzipan. It is creamy-rich on the palate, too, with sumptuous and textured leesy tones. Velvet smooth and mellow yet perfectly fresh, this gorgeous wine is in full bloom. Disgorged: 2023; Dosage: 5g/l”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Beautiful fruity nose with ripe, lush Pinot Noir taking the lead role but there is also a strong presence of tropical Chardonnay fruit. Pristinely clean fruitiness and charmingly creamy texture on the easy to approach, soft palate, which comes with both length and width. A friendly, fruity vintage, which also has the structure to age. ”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“50% Pinot Noir, 36% Chardonnay, 14% Pinot Meunier (highest proportion of Pinot Noir since 1996), from predominantly grand and premier crus. Aged for seven years on the lees. Dosage 5 g/l. Disgorged January 2017. Mytik Diam technological cork closure.
Tasted blind. A certain amount of tension on the nose. Pear juice and round and satiny. Quite similar in quality to the other vintage of Moët tasted alongside [the 2008]. Long. Rich. But chewy on the end. More obvious acidity [than the 2008]. ”
17-/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Magnum. The year was full of excesses in all directions. Lush, fruit-driven vintage with the highest proportion of Pinot Noir since 1996.
Fine and rather majestic with an attractive savoury spine. Lots of fun and bumptious fruit and attraction. Lightly bitter finish. Quite long. A very good Grand Vintage. Melon-like fruit.”
“Gastronomic in style. Balanced overall, with richness and power. The 2016 vintage is its 46th edition. The nose includes rose, hibiscus flowers and fresh fruits of ripe raspberries, apple and nectarine. It also offers cherries in syrup, tarte tatin and buttered bread. Citrusy, nicely refreshing finish. The solid structure suggests good potential for ageing.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“Salmon colour with orange hues. The added red wine brings a lovely fresh and confected berry fruit to the wine. Add to it a spicy twist and a flick of vanilla, the wine gives immediate pleasure. Yet, firmly built with a cool vintage profile, there is more complexity to be gained for this age-worthy rosé. Disgorgement date: 2023. Dosage: 5g/l.”
“The 2015 Extra-Brut Rosé Grand Vintage is one of the best Champagnes I have tasted from Moët & Chandon in some time. Rich and vinous in the glass, with terrific persistence, the 2015 exudes class from start to finish. All the elements are so well balanced. Hints of crushed raspberry, rose petal and blood orange lend a beguiling air of exoticism. The Rosé is at once deep and yet also light on its feet. I loved it. ”
“The 2013 Rosé Grand Vintage is effusive and full of character. Crushed berries, rose petal and orange peel, lend energy to this wonderfully expressive Rosé Champagne from Moët & Chandon. I very much like the energy here.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Deep orange-toned colour. The reserved nose is holding back a lot for the time being. Plenty of powerful Pinot notes of strawberry, raspberry and cranberry via the 14% addition of red wine. Some soft woody spiciness and a whiff of fragrant toastiness emerging. Lots of fruity muscle on the body too, with the tannins finely managed letting the mouthfeel come across silky smooth. There is a great acid line cutting through all that intensity. A fine baby but this one craves time. Dosage 5g/l”
90/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Disgorged in September 2019 with five grams per liter dosage, Moët's 2013 Extra Brut Grand Vintage Rosé offers up notes of red berries, mandarin orange, cherries and hazelnuts, complemented by subtle hints of spice. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and seamless, it's a sapid, elegantly vinous wine that contains an unusually high proportion of Chardonnay (35%) by the standards of this bottling.”
“Moet’s 1992 Grand Vintage is a very pretty wine for readers who enjoy Champagnes with a bit more of the natural evolution that develops in bottle. Baked apple tart, brioche, smoke, apricot, honey and lemon confit are all laced together. The 1992 possesses terrific energy and verve, even if it comes across as a bit compact for a wine of its age. The blend is 45% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay and 15% Meunier. Disgorged: February, 2004.”
More Reviews +
95-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2012
“Generous toasty and fragrant nose full of coffee, gunpowder and opulent fruit. Simply delicious. Fresh, lively, light yet intense at the same time. A polished and perfected wine. In a very fine drinking form now, but with a long life ahead of it. Superb. ”
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“Open, inviting, sweetly fruity, maturing nose with fine pastry, grilled almond notes but also a vegetal edge. Concentrated, mouth-filling palate of great generosity and textural smoothness. Long-lingering sweet finish full of toast laden tropical fruit. Highly enjoyable today. ”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2019
“26% Pinot Noir, 51% Chardonnay, 23% Meunier. Dosage 5.5 g/l. This is not the original release but is a late release disgorged in May 2017. 15 years on lees: 'a pretty sweet spot'.
Very complex nose. Meaty, rich and (just) sufficient acidity. Long and complete. Chewy finish. Needs food! Very similar analytical profile at harvest as the 2012, apparently.”
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2019
“Disgorged in May 2017, the 2002 Extra Brut Grand Vintage Collection has acquired appreciable complexity from its 15 years sur lattes, offering up aromas of honeyed citrus fruit that mingle with nuances of smoke, iodine and brown butter. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, broad and impressively vinous, with a textural attack, good depth at the core and a pinpoint mousse, concluding with a sapid, saline finish. It should drink well for another decade.”
“Moët’s 2009 Extra Brut Grand Vintage is radiant, supple and voluptuous, with all of the generosity of the year front and center. Candied lemon, almond, chamomile, brioche and baked apple tart develop in a rich, inviting champagne that will drink beautifully upon release. A wine of pure and total pleasure, the 2009 is one of those Champagnes that disappears in an instant. ”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“Open, inviting, sweetly fruity, maturing nose with fine pastry, grilled almond notes but also a vegetal edge. Concentrated, mouth-filling palate of great generosity and textural smoothness. Long-lingering sweet finish full of toast laden tropical fruit. Highly enjoyable today. ”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2018
“Beautiful fruity nose with ripe, lush Pinot Noir taking the lead role but there is also a strong presence of tropical Chardonnay fruit. Pristinely clean fruitiness and charmingly creamy texture on the easy to approach, soft palate, which comes with both length and width. A friendly, fruity vintage, which also has the structure to age. ”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“50% Pinot Noir, 36% Chardonnay, 14% Pinot Meunier (highest proportion of Pinot Noir since 1996), from predominantly grand and premier crus. Aged for seven years on the lees. Dosage 5 g/l. Disgorged January 2017. Mytik Diam technological cork closure.
Tasted blind. A certain amount of tension on the nose. Pear juice and round and satiny. Quite similar in quality to the other vintage of Moët tasted alongside [the 2008]. Long. Rich. But chewy on the end. More obvious acidity [than the 2008]. ”
91-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2019
“There is an attractive grilled note to the vanilla laden ripe apricot nose with wine gums, lingonberries, roses and menthol. Super fruity and rather open upon launch. Rich, candy-toned palate of lush fruit and succulence. There is a gentle bite of tannin towards the back palate. Eager to impress but has the structure to age too. ”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2019
“26% Pinot Noir, 51% Chardonnay, 23% Meunier. Dosage 5.5 g/l. This is not the original release but is a late release disgorged in May 2017. 15 years on lees: 'a pretty sweet spot'.
Very complex nose. Meaty, rich and (just) sufficient acidity. Long and complete. Chewy finish. Needs food! Very similar analytical profile at harvest as the 2012, apparently.”
17-/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Magnum. The year was full of excesses in all directions. Lush, fruit-driven vintage with the highest proportion of Pinot Noir since 1996.
Fine and rather majestic with an attractive savoury spine. Lots of fun and bumptious fruit and attraction. Lightly bitter finish. Quite long. A very good Grand Vintage. Melon-like fruit.”
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2019
“Disgorged in May 2017, the 2002 Extra Brut Grand Vintage Collection has acquired appreciable complexity from its 15 years sur lattes, offering up aromas of honeyed citrus fruit that mingle with nuances of smoke, iodine and brown butter. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, broad and impressively vinous, with a textural attack, good depth at the core and a pinpoint mousse, concluding with a sapid, saline finish. It should drink well for another decade.”
“The 2012 Grand Vintage is a very pretty, high-toned Champagne. Surprisingly nervous for this radiant vintage, the 2012 is going to need a bit of time to be at its best. Some of that may be attributable to early release of the 2012, which was bottled after only five years on its lees rather than the more customary seven or so because the house did not bottle either a 2010 or 2011 Grand Vintage, and the necessities of the market are what they are. Lemon confit, white flowers, and mint gradually open up in the glass. This is an especially taut style for the Grand Vintage, which is usually creamier and more open-knit in the early going. The blend is 41% Chardonnay, 36% Meunier and 33% Pinot Noir. Dosage is 5 grams per liter. Disgorged: February, 2018. ”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“Open, inviting, sweetly fruity, maturing nose with fine pastry, grilled almond notes but also a vegetal edge. Concentrated, mouth-filling palate of great generosity and textural smoothness. Long-lingering sweet finish full of toast laden tropical fruit. Highly enjoyable today. ”
16.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“More Meunier than usual, with 26%, also 41% Chardonnay and 33% Pinot Noir. Disgorged February 2018. They also specify this date and the dosage on the back label nowadays. For a long time they didn’t claim the Extra Brut category but since the 2009 vintage they have printed Extra Brut on the front label.
Really quite a rich nose with very light smokiness. Then very bright fruit with tangerine notes on the nose and then strong acidity. Very punchy and nice dry finish, 5 g/l.”
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2019
“Deep rosé colour, showing quite youthful upon launch. Brightly fruity nose full of forest berries, summer fruit and marzipan, for the time being sweet primary fruitiness dominating. The palate has a touch of tannin and feels dry at 5g/l dosage. Structured and fresh possessing great ageing capacity. ”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Nov 2019
“26% Pinot Noir, 51% Chardonnay, 23% Meunier. Dosage 5.5 g/l. This is not the original release but is a late release disgorged in May 2017. 15 years on lees: 'a pretty sweet spot'.
Very complex nose. Meaty, rich and (just) sufficient acidity. Long and complete. Chewy finish. Needs food! Very similar analytical profile at harvest as the 2012, apparently.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Disgorged in October 2018 – and we're very grateful for this information! 42% Pinot Noir, of which 13% was still, plus 35% Chardonnay and 23% Pinot Meunier. Five years on the lees and a relatively low dosage of 5 g/l.
Quite a deep bronzey-pink. Smells much richer than you expect from such a low-dosage wine. It also tastes richer. Opulent wine that's quite ready now. No real need to age this. Though the balance is fine for now. Mouth-filling and creditable.”
92/100
Jamie Goode,
WineAnorak.com,
Nov 2018
“12.5% alcohol. 41% Chardonnay, 26% Pinot Meunier, 33% Pinot Noir. Dosage 5 g/litre. Disgorged February 2018. The 74th release from this house. Lovely finesse here. Fruity with sweet citrus and pear notes, as well as some ripe peach and apricot hints. This has depth and generosity, and it’s really accessible, but there’s also some fine toast and bread complexity, and fine nuttiness. There’s a touch of nougat, too. Finishes long and fresh with a lemony tail. It’s rare that Chardonnay and Pinot Meunier are this high in the blend, but they work well here with the relatively low dosage.”
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2019
“Disgorged in May 2017, the 2002 Extra Brut Grand Vintage Collection has acquired appreciable complexity from its 15 years sur lattes, offering up aromas of honeyed citrus fruit that mingle with nuances of smoke, iodine and brown butter. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, broad and impressively vinous, with a textural attack, good depth at the core and a pinpoint mousse, concluding with a sapid, saline finish. It should drink well for another decade.”
“This Brut NV is all about textural feel, in a comparable way to velvet and leather apparel. It takes a moment’s aeration in the glass for the discreet citrus, apple-ring and toasty character to emerge, so don’t rush this. The simultaneously mellow and lively balance and the harmoniously dry finish will appeal to a wide public. Drink now.”
More Reviews +
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The world's most popular Champagne comes with easiness and fruity charm, complexed by a nice flick of toast over sweet red fruit. It is composed as a broad blend from the entire region, complemented by a large proportion of young reserve wines. Juicy on the soft, lightweight palate. Pleasantly succulent, gently bubbling and effortlessly enjoyable. Dosage 9g/l”
93/100
The Somm Journal,
Thesommjournal.com,
May 2020
“When it comes to finesse, this classic—roughly equal parts Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier with a slightly smaller amount of Chardonnay—doesn’t miss: It’s comme il faut from the unending bead onward. Joined by biscuit and almond aromas, ripe golden apple on the nose turns to green on the palate, where citrus—lime, grapefruit, mandarin orange—cycles through high-flying acidity even as luscious pear adds weight and chalk conveys elegance through the finish.”
88/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2021
“Based on the challenging 2017 vintage, the current release of Moët & Chandon's NV Brut Imperial was disgorged with seven grams dosage (representing a reduction of around 50% in the last 20 years) and contains an unusually high proportion of reserve wines. Offering up aromas of pear, peach and citrus oil mingled with hints of fresh bread and white flowers, it's medium to full-bodied, ample and pillowy, with racy acids and an enveloping core of fruit, complemented by a pinpoint mousse and concluding with a nicely defined finish. Impressively seamless, it's a fine rendition of one of Champagne's largest bottlings.”
89/100
Wine Enthusiast,
WineMag.com,
Jan 2015
“Worldwide still the biggest-selling Champagne (28 million bottles a year), this well-made wine is ripe and full of fruit. Produced under the direction of chef de cave Benoît Gouez (Wine Enthusiast Winemaker of Year in 2013), it has flavors of almonds and toast, with crisp acidity. The aftertaste brings grapefruit freshness.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2015
“Distinctive, slightly bruised apple scent. Fleshy on the palate. Reassuringly good quality for a leading brand. (RH)”
“(roughly 45% Pinot Noir, 35% Pinot Meunier and 20% Chardonnay, with 9 g/l dosage; LAH9V): Dark, vivid pink. Ripe red berries, rose oil and tangerine on the nose, plus a subtle note of toasty lees. Bitter cherry and berry skin flavors give way to softer raspberry in the middle, with a tangy blood orange nuance adding cut and lift. Packs a punch but shows very good clarity and delineation, finishing round, smooth and quite long.”
More Reviews +
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The bright raspberry-pink colour is attained largely by the use of thermo-vinified Pinot Noir and Meunier red wines. Moët is the sole user of this method in Champagne, which allows the making of consistent, fruit-forward red wines with low tannin. This has a sweet nose of primary fruit, with candy tones and raspberry lemonade meeting a touch of spice. Very youthful aromatics. The palate is supple, sweetly fruity and silky, with absolutely no tannin. Simple candied finish. Needs time. Dosage 9g/l”
15.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“No clue as to principal vintage or disgorgement date but there is code LAL 84 on the back label. 40–50% Pinot Noir of which 10% is still; 30–40% Pinot Meunier and 10–20% Chardonnay. Aged for 21 months before disgorgement with dosage 9 g/l.
Quite a deep orangey pale strawberry colour. Not much nose but a lively mousse – fairly exuberant bubbles – that is just the right side of aggressive. Not too sweet with very lively acidity. Extremely fruity though, as I say, not too sweet. A little chewy on the end after a really mouth-filling palate. Respectable considering presumably the massive quantity.
Drink 2020 – 2022”
88/100
Jamie Goode,
WineAnorak.com,
Feb 2011
“12% alcohol. Pink with an orange hue. Bright, sweetly fruited nose is quite berryish with some taut toastiness. The palate has some herby notes as well as fruit sweetness and good balance. Very drinkable, this. ”
“There is an exceptional yet rather complicated concept of blending for Moët & Chandon's new, exiting prestige cuvée, so bear with me: The first cuvée is based on the 2003 vintage. To it they blended reserve wines from 2002 vintage for richness, 2000 for freshness and 1998 for elegance. Finally, aged, undisgorged Grand Vintages were added to crown the whole. 1999 was chosen for its richness, 1998 for its elegance and 1993 for its freshness. The first batch carries the code 001.14, with ‘001’ referencing the first cuvée, and ’.14’ the disgorgement year. The reserve wine element takes the leading role at first with their gourmand richness, aged honey-toned, walnut ant patisserie aromatics and a polished, mellow palate texture. Despite the aged elements it sits safely on the reductive side with fine coffee and gunpowder notes pushing through the mature wine exuberance, leaving behind a brisk overall impression. With the lemony fragrant and boosted toasty character, the wine comes with a clear Moët stamp it. Voluptuous by all measures, it is calm and caressingly soft. Particularly delightful is its peaking form just now, there is no need to wait. Tour de force, a masterpiece of Moët blending.”
More Reviews +
95+/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Jun 2016
“As MC-owned Dom Pérignon sails under its own flag, the NV MCIII is the new prestige cuvée of Moët & Chandon, and it is nothing but a unique assemblage of different vintages or what MC calls "the Champagne of the third millennium." With its ambitious MCIII, Moët seeks the perfect "balance between harmony and generous complexity" by blending young vintages aged in stainless steel vats (I), with matured vintages aged in oak casks (II), and rare vintages aged in glass bottles (III). Call it madness or the "icon of luxury for a new generation," but this is of what the inaugural assemblage NV MCIII 001.14 is made: steel-fermented vins clairs of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir from the vintage 2003, which were blended together in 2004 and comprise 40% of the cuvée (I); another 40% blends the declared vintages 2002, 2000 and 1998 that were mainly fermented in large oak vats and kept as vins clairs for Moët's Grand Vintage (II); and the final 20% assembles the Grand Vintage Collection Champagnes 1999, 1998 and 1993, which had already undergone the second fermentation, but had not been disgorged yet (III). The "ultimate expression of blending" was created in 2004 and kept for ten years on the lees of the second (respectively third) fermentation. The cuvée 001.14 was disgorged in 2014 as Brut with a dosage of four or five grams per liter. The expensive wine offers a fascinatingly deep and concentrated bouquet that is very clear and fresh in its fruit aromas, but also delivers complex secondary aromas of coffee, nougat, biscuits and many more flavors. Full-bodied, ripe and intense on the palate, this is a rich and powerful, yet round and highly elegant cuvée of great complexity and persistence. It is stunningly fresh and pairs fruity aromas with nutty and spicy flavors, revealing a delicate tannin structure and a very long, salty and mineral finish. The MCIII can age for many years and I would recommend not drinking it much earlier than 2020.”
“(roughly 45% Pinot Noir, 35% Pinot Meunier and 20% Chardonnay, with 9 g/l dosage; LAH9V): Dark, vivid pink. Ripe red berries, rose oil and tangerine on the nose, plus a subtle note of toasty lees. Bitter cherry and berry skin flavors give way to softer raspberry in the middle, with a tangy blood orange nuance adding cut and lift. Packs a punch but shows very good clarity and delineation, finishing round, smooth and quite long.”
More Reviews +
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The bright raspberry-pink colour is attained largely by the use of thermo-vinified Pinot Noir and Meunier red wines. Moët is the sole user of this method in Champagne, which allows the making of consistent, fruit-forward red wines with low tannin. This has a sweet nose of primary fruit, with candy tones and raspberry lemonade meeting a touch of spice. Very youthful aromatics. The palate is supple, sweetly fruity and silky, with absolutely no tannin. Simple candied finish. Needs time. Dosage 9g/l”
15.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“No clue as to principal vintage or disgorgement date but there is code LAL 84 on the back label. 40–50% Pinot Noir of which 10% is still; 30–40% Pinot Meunier and 10–20% Chardonnay. Aged for 21 months before disgorgement with dosage 9 g/l.
Quite a deep orangey pale strawberry colour. Not much nose but a lively mousse – fairly exuberant bubbles – that is just the right side of aggressive. Not too sweet with very lively acidity. Extremely fruity though, as I say, not too sweet. A little chewy on the end after a really mouth-filling palate. Respectable considering presumably the massive quantity.
Drink 2020 – 2022”
88/100
Jamie Goode,
WineAnorak.com,
Feb 2011
“12% alcohol. Pink with an orange hue. Bright, sweetly fruited nose is quite berryish with some taut toastiness. The palate has some herby notes as well as fruit sweetness and good balance. Very drinkable, this. ”
“This Brut NV is all about textural feel, in a comparable way to velvet and leather apparel. It takes a moment’s aeration in the glass for the discreet citrus, apple-ring and toasty character to emerge, so don’t rush this. The simultaneously mellow and lively balance and the harmoniously dry finish will appeal to a wide public. Drink now.”
More Reviews +
90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The world's most popular Champagne comes with easiness and fruity charm, complexed by a nice flick of toast over sweet red fruit. It is composed as a broad blend from the entire region, complemented by a large proportion of young reserve wines. Juicy on the soft, lightweight palate. Pleasantly succulent, gently bubbling and effortlessly enjoyable. Dosage 9g/l”
93/100
The Somm Journal,
Thesommjournal.com,
May 2020
“When it comes to finesse, this classic—roughly equal parts Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier with a slightly smaller amount of Chardonnay—doesn’t miss: It’s comme il faut from the unending bead onward. Joined by biscuit and almond aromas, ripe golden apple on the nose turns to green on the palate, where citrus—lime, grapefruit, mandarin orange—cycles through high-flying acidity even as luscious pear adds weight and chalk conveys elegance through the finish.”
16.5/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2015
“Distinctive, slightly bruised apple scent. Fleshy on the palate. Reassuringly good quality for a leading brand. (RH)”
“The 2012 Extra Brut Blanc de Noirs Premier Cru les Francs de Pied offers very clear, fresh, precise and delicate fruit on the nose. Fermented 100% in used oak barrels, this is a pure, highly finessed, very elegant and terribly salty Pinot Noir with a very long, complex yet pure, tensioned and very long finish. This is well structured and persistent.”
“The 2016 Extra-Brut Mont Martin reveals aromas of yellow orchard fruit, mirabelle plum, warm spices and honeycomb. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and sapid, with brisk acids and a pinpoint mousse, it's elegantly structured, concluding with chalky grip.”
“Has initial creamy character on the nose, good texture and balance on the palate. Slightly saline, freshness but with some age. Acidity seems up there which is keeping it refreshing and balanced. Some ripe apples, plums and pineapple come through with time in the mouth.”
More Reviews +
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2016
“Medium-deep lemon. Mild nose with gunpowdery charred characters. Super intense, invigorating, creamy palate. Good roundness and softness of texture. Fresh with charm. A benchmark reductive, toast-enriched blanc de blancs. ”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“Tasted from magnum, the latest release of Palmer's NV Blanc de Blancs Brut is showing very well indeed, bursting from the glass with a ripe and expressive bouquet of grapefruit, orange zest, toasted bread, white flowers and nectarines. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, with an elegantly textural attack, fine depth at the core, ripe but racy acids and a long, flavorful finish. This has always been one of Palmer's emblematic cuvées and this disgorgement—from early 2018—would appear to be a particular success.
Founded in 1947 under the name Producteurs des Grands Crus de Champagne, Palmer & Co is one of Champagne's best quality-focused cooperatives, and having recently selected a new importer, they are making a concerted effort to court the US market. Vinification is predominantly in stainless steel, and the proportion of reserve wines employed in Palmer's non-vintage blends ranges from 30% to 35%. Aging sur lattes is quite protracted. Their emblematic Blanc de Blancs was the highlight of this tasting, but all these releases showed well.
”
93/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Revisited from magnum with another year in bottle, the early 2018 disgorgement of Palmer's NV Blanc de Blancs Brut has continued to improve. Wafting from the glass with a toasty bouquet of citrus oil, orchard fruit, bee pollen, nectarines and iodine, it's medium to full-bodied and fleshy but precise, with fine depth at the core, racy acids and a pinpoint mousse. This comes warmly recommended.”
94-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“Bright lemon colour. Stunningly toasty and charmingly sweetly fruity nose. Such complexity and finesse. On the palate it is polished and creamy with licorice and vanilla layers. Long taste in perfect harmony. Succulently fruity with some evolution but youthful still. A benchmark reductive, toast-enriched blanc de blancs. ”
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“This needs a while to open up, but the rich, biscuity notes are absolutely worth the wait, perfectly tempered by vivd, brisk, pure lemon. The palate has a wonderful directness and a beautiful but sinuous concentration. The mousse is fine and persistent, rounded, fresh and with wonderful verve.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest release of Palmer's emblematic NV Blanc de Blancs Brut is showing very well, bursting from the glass with gently reductive aromas of crisp orchard fruit, toasted bread, nectarine and iodine. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with a pretty core of fruit, bright acids and an attractive pinpoint mousse, it's showing well today but will be even better with a little more bottle age.”
17/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2022
“Broad gunpowder-smoke and citrus-cream nose. A serious, competently balanced wine with sweetness that tastes deceptively higher than 6.5 g/l, full-sail fruit ending in a tight draw of sherbet-bright acidity. The Palmer Blanc de Blancs had a good track record of ageing well when it was a vintage wine, and this newer NV version tastes as if it will also take a good 10 years of cellar age.”
“Bright lemon colour. Stunningly toasty and charmingly sweetly fruity nose. Such complexity and finesse. On the palate it is polished and creamy with licorice and vanilla layers. Long taste in perfect harmony. Succulently fruity with some evolution but youthful still. A benchmark reductive, toast-enriched blanc de blancs. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“This needs a while to open up, but the rich, biscuity notes are absolutely worth the wait, perfectly tempered by vivd, brisk, pure lemon. The palate has a wonderful directness and a beautiful but sinuous concentration. The mousse is fine and persistent, rounded, fresh and with wonderful verve.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest release of Palmer's emblematic NV Blanc de Blancs Brut is showing very well, bursting from the glass with gently reductive aromas of crisp orchard fruit, toasted bread, nectarine and iodine. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with a pretty core of fruit, bright acids and an attractive pinpoint mousse, it's showing well today but will be even better with a little more bottle age.”
17/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2022
“Broad gunpowder-smoke and citrus-cream nose. A serious, competently balanced wine with sweetness that tastes deceptively higher than 6.5 g/l, full-sail fruit ending in a tight draw of sherbet-bright acidity. The Palmer Blanc de Blancs had a good track record of ageing well when it was a vintage wine, and this newer NV version tastes as if it will also take a good 10 years of cellar age.”
“Bright lemon colour. Stunningly toasty and charmingly sweetly fruity nose. Such complexity and finesse. On the palate it is polished and creamy with licorice and vanilla layers. Long taste in perfect harmony. Succulently fruity with some evolution but youthful still. A benchmark reductive, toast-enriched blanc de blancs. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“This needs a while to open up, but the rich, biscuity notes are absolutely worth the wait, perfectly tempered by vivd, brisk, pure lemon. The palate has a wonderful directness and a beautiful but sinuous concentration. The mousse is fine and persistent, rounded, fresh and with wonderful verve.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest release of Palmer's emblematic NV Blanc de Blancs Brut is showing very well, bursting from the glass with gently reductive aromas of crisp orchard fruit, toasted bread, nectarine and iodine. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with a pretty core of fruit, bright acids and an attractive pinpoint mousse, it's showing well today but will be even better with a little more bottle age.”
17/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2022
“Broad gunpowder-smoke and citrus-cream nose. A serious, competently balanced wine with sweetness that tastes deceptively higher than 6.5 g/l, full-sail fruit ending in a tight draw of sherbet-bright acidity. The Palmer Blanc de Blancs had a good track record of ageing well when it was a vintage wine, and this newer NV version tastes as if it will also take a good 10 years of cellar age.”
“Magnum-effect heaven! Over a decade on the lees has endowed this wine with layers of toasty glory and vanilla-laced fruit. A blend from Montagne de Reims and Coteaux Sezannais terroirs, this decadently delicious Chardonnay marries exotic fruit richness with a crunchy, lemony spine. The palate delivers on the promise of the nose, broad and textural yet linear, driven by zippy acidity. Its carry is long and poised, with plenty of further promise still ahead. Disgorgement date:23/11/22. Dosage:6.5g/l.”
More Reviews +
94-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“Bright lemon colour. Stunningly toasty and charmingly sweetly fruity nose. Such complexity and finesse. On the palate it is polished and creamy with licorice and vanilla layers. Long taste in perfect harmony. Succulently fruity with some evolution but youthful still. A benchmark reductive, toast-enriched blanc de blancs. ”
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“This needs a while to open up, but the rich, biscuity notes are absolutely worth the wait, perfectly tempered by vivd, brisk, pure lemon. The palate has a wonderful directness and a beautiful but sinuous concentration. The mousse is fine and persistent, rounded, fresh and with wonderful verve.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest release of Palmer's emblematic NV Blanc de Blancs Brut is showing very well, bursting from the glass with gently reductive aromas of crisp orchard fruit, toasted bread, nectarine and iodine. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with a pretty core of fruit, bright acids and an attractive pinpoint mousse, it's showing well today but will be even better with a little more bottle age.”
17/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2022
“Broad gunpowder-smoke and citrus-cream nose. A serious, competently balanced wine with sweetness that tastes deceptively higher than 6.5 g/l, full-sail fruit ending in a tight draw of sherbet-bright acidity. The Palmer Blanc de Blancs had a good track record of ageing well when it was a vintage wine, and this newer NV version tastes as if it will also take a good 10 years of cellar age.”
“Bright lemon colour. Stunningly toasty and charmingly sweetly fruity nose. Such complexity and finesse. On the palate it is polished and creamy with licorice and vanilla layers. Long taste in perfect harmony. Succulently fruity with some evolution but youthful still. A benchmark reductive, toast-enriched blanc de blancs. ”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest release of Palmer's emblematic NV Blanc de Blancs Brut is showing very well, bursting from the glass with gently reductive aromas of crisp orchard fruit, toasted bread, nectarine and iodine. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with a pretty core of fruit, bright acids and an attractive pinpoint mousse, it's showing well today but will be even better with a little more bottle age.”
16+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“100% 2013 vintage. L18135C. Tasted in bottle.
Deep straw. Rich nose, and rich palate with some sherbet qualities. Quite tight on the end. Lots of undertow. Chewy end, very racy.”
92/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2020
“Light golden yellow, silver reflections; fine, persistent mousse. Delicately nutty, hints of blood orange and white peach underlaid with a smoky minerality. Medium-bodied, taut, fresh apple, lively structure, mineral finish. A versatile food wine with ageing potential. (Lot L20028C).”
“Bright lemon colour. Stunningly toasty and charmingly sweetly fruity nose. Such complexity and finesse. On the palate it is polished and creamy with licorice and vanilla layers. Long taste in perfect harmony. Succulently fruity with some evolution but youthful still. A benchmark reductive, toast-enriched blanc de blancs. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“This needs a while to open up, but the rich, biscuity notes are absolutely worth the wait, perfectly tempered by vivd, brisk, pure lemon. The palate has a wonderful directness and a beautiful but sinuous concentration. The mousse is fine and persistent, rounded, fresh and with wonderful verve.”
92/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest release of Palmer's emblematic NV Blanc de Blancs Brut is showing very well, bursting from the glass with gently reductive aromas of crisp orchard fruit, toasted bread, nectarine and iodine. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with a pretty core of fruit, bright acids and an attractive pinpoint mousse, it's showing well today but will be even better with a little more bottle age.”
17/20
Tamlyn Currin,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2022
“Broad gunpowder-smoke and citrus-cream nose. A serious, competently balanced wine with sweetness that tastes deceptively higher than 6.5 g/l, full-sail fruit ending in a tight draw of sherbet-bright acidity. The Palmer Blanc de Blancs had a good track record of ageing well when it was a vintage wine, and this newer NV version tastes as if it will also take a good 10 years of cellar age.”
“50% Pinot Noir, 50% Pinot Meunier. Meunier brings fruity roundness. 2012 – a very healthy, charming vintage, ‘a compromise between 2002 and 2008’. Disgorged 20 months ago. L18134. Tasted in magnum.
The Pinot Noir brings powerful, spicy fruit. Slightly cheesy note. Some real richness, plus acidity. Palmer’s strongest suit?”
More Reviews +
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2017
“Beautifully toasty nose with some restraint. Yellow apple, patisserie, vanilla and lemon. Plush, round palate bursting with fruit. Fine creamy palate laudably without any oxidative tones. A super-smooth and stylish blanc de noirs.”
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“One of the newest cuvées in the Palmer range, this blanc de noirs is an equal blend of Meunier and Pinot Noir, with Verzy, Verzenay, Mailly-Champagne and Les Riceys being some of the key villages. Deep lemon gold colour. The beautifully fruity nose has sophisticated red cherry and strawberry notes and smart toasty layers. The clean, rich fruitiness is free of any melancholic autumnal aromatics. It's silky and lingering on the palate, which bursts with juicy fruitiness. Long, fresh and lively finish. Dosage 6g/l”
“50% Pinot Noir, 50% Pinot Meunier. Meunier brings fruity roundness. 2012 – a very healthy, charming vintage, ‘a compromise between 2002 and 2008’. Disgorged 20 months ago. L18134. Tasted in magnum.
The Pinot Noir brings powerful, spicy fruit. Slightly cheesy note. Some real richness, plus acidity. Palmer’s strongest suit?”
More Reviews +
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jun 2017
“Beautifully toasty nose with some restraint. Yellow apple, patisserie, vanilla and lemon. Plush, round palate bursting with fruit. Fine creamy palate laudably without any oxidative tones. A super-smooth and stylish blanc de noirs.”
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“One of the newest cuvées in the Palmer range, this blanc de noirs is an equal blend of Meunier and Pinot Noir, with Verzy, Verzenay, Mailly-Champagne and Les Riceys being some of the key villages. Deep lemon gold colour. The beautifully fruity nose has sophisticated red cherry and strawberry notes and smart toasty layers. The clean, rich fruitiness is free of any melancholic autumnal aromatics. It's silky and lingering on the palate, which bursts with juicy fruitiness. Long, fresh and lively finish. Dosage 6g/l”
“With the lion's share of Palmer's 350 growers' vineyards being located on the Montagne de Reims, its fruit forms the core of this broad blend. The rest of the grapes come from Côte de Sézanne and Côte des Bar. Bright lemon in colour, with some depth. The overall note is charmingly, sweetly fruity, with an impeccable ground coffee tone adding layers. A complex mix of yellow and red fruit, but there is also a dark spiciness giving an element of interest. The palate is generous, with an age-mellowed velvety texture. However, the overall feeling remains light due to a super-stylish acid line. A remarkable-value non-vintage in an age-complexed, radiantly fruity and luxuriously toasty style. Dosage 7g/l”
More Reviews +
89-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2021
“Complex, classy toast-lead nose. Plenty of pristine fruit, cream, vanilla, peach, marshmallow and candy. Soft, velvety palate with a fine mousse. Lively, playful, dancing palate with a lovely acid line. Long-lasting, pure, fruity finish. Compact and complete. Perfectly crafted and finely polished. Worth 93p in magnum in a great year such as the 2008 and 2013 based cuvées. ”
88/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Palmer's NV Brut Réserve is quite reserved out of the gates, unwinding with notes of crisp orchard fruit, citrus zest and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, taut and tangy, with bracing acids and a pinpoint mousse, it's not quite as generous as its immediate predecessors have been.”
90/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“A wonderfully fresh nose presents notions of ripe lemon flesh and zest, along with stone fruit. The palate has a zesty edge. The mousse is a bit on the frothy side but the flavours are fruity and brisk. Very much an aperitif style, enlivening but balanced.”
“Complex, classy toast-lead nose. Plenty of pristine fruit, cream, vanilla, peach, marshmallow and candy. Soft, velvety palate with a fine mousse. Lively, playful, dancing palate with a lovely acid line. Long-lasting, pure, fruity finish. Compact and complete. Perfectly crafted and finely polished. Worth 93p in magnum in a great year such as the 2008 and 2013 based cuvées. ”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“With the lion's share of Palmer's 350 growers' vineyards being located on the Montagne de Reims, its fruit forms the core of this broad blend. The rest of the grapes come from Côte de Sézanne and Côte des Bar. Bright lemon in colour, with some depth. The overall note is charmingly, sweetly fruity, with an impeccable ground coffee tone adding layers. A complex mix of yellow and red fruit, but there is also a dark spiciness giving an element of interest. The palate is generous, with an age-mellowed velvety texture. However, the overall feeling remains light due to a super-stylish acid line. A remarkable-value non-vintage in an age-complexed, radiantly fruity and luxuriously toasty style. Dosage 7g/l”
89-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2021
“Complex, classy toast-lead nose. Plenty of pristine fruit, cream, vanilla, peach, marshmallow and candy. Soft, velvety palate with a fine mousse. Lively, playful, dancing palate with a lovely acid line. Long-lasting, pure, fruity finish. Compact and complete. Perfectly crafted and finely polished. Worth 93p in magnum in a great year such as the 2008 and 2013 based cuvées. ”
88/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Palmer's NV Brut Réserve is quite reserved out of the gates, unwinding with notes of crisp orchard fruit, citrus zest and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, taut and tangy, with bracing acids and a pinpoint mousse, it's not quite as generous as its immediate predecessors have been.”
90/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“A wonderfully fresh nose presents notions of ripe lemon flesh and zest, along with stone fruit. The palate has a zesty edge. The mousse is a bit on the frothy side but the flavours are fruity and brisk. Very much an aperitif style, enlivening but balanced.”
“50–55% Chardonnay, 35–40% Pinot Noir, 10–15% Pinot Meunier. 25–35% reserve wines. Bottles spend three to four years on lees, magnums five to six years. Dosage 8 g/l. Date on label suggests it may have been disgorged 8 May 2017.
Mid lemon colour. Lemon-brioche nose. Much more low-key fizz than the Rosé. Just a suggestion of bubbles, despite a huge froth-up when the wine was poured. Chalky, chewy, lemon-zested palate. Spiky and angled – makes you hungry just to sip it. Proper appetite whetter. Bring on the oysters! (Or fish and chips…?) (TC)”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“With the lion's share of Palmer's 350 growers' vineyards being located on the Montagne de Reims, its fruit forms the core of this broad blend. The rest of the grapes come from Côte de Sézanne and Côte des Bar. Bright lemon in colour, with some depth. The overall note is charmingly, sweetly fruity, with an impeccable ground coffee tone adding layers. A complex mix of yellow and red fruit, but there is also a dark spiciness giving an element of interest. The palate is generous, with an age-mellowed velvety texture. However, the overall feeling remains light due to a super-stylish acid line. A remarkable-value non-vintage in an age-complexed, radiantly fruity and luxuriously toasty style. Dosage 7g/l”
89-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2021
“Complex, classy toast-lead nose. Plenty of pristine fruit, cream, vanilla, peach, marshmallow and candy. Soft, velvety palate with a fine mousse. Lively, playful, dancing palate with a lovely acid line. Long-lasting, pure, fruity finish. Compact and complete. Perfectly crafted and finely polished. Worth 93p in magnum in a great year such as the 2008 and 2013 based cuvées. ”
88/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Palmer's NV Brut Réserve is quite reserved out of the gates, unwinding with notes of crisp orchard fruit, citrus zest and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, taut and tangy, with bracing acids and a pinpoint mousse, it's not quite as generous as its immediate predecessors have been.”
90/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Jul 2022
“A wonderfully fresh nose presents notions of ripe lemon flesh and zest, along with stone fruit. The palate has a zesty edge. The mousse is a bit on the frothy side but the flavours are fruity and brisk. Very much an aperitif style, enlivening but balanced.”
“The aromatics leap out the glass, a light layer of smoky charm, a mix of dried citrus lemon, grapefruit, guava, roasted pineapple and layers of patisserie richness. The palate is full of energy, with peaches, many dried fruits, especially citrus and layers of toasty nuts. On second sip, the layers really build, dried fruits and chardonnay fruit giving flaky pastry richness. Great freshness and salinity on the finish.”
“Stunning nose packed with lush tropical fruit, ground coffee, lanolin, petrol and beeswax. There is imminent yeasty fullness to the velvet-smooth palate of languid mousse. Long, concentrated and perfect to drink now but still on its way up. A 24 months old disgorgement tasted. Points and note for magnum only. ”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Disgorged 2018. In magnum.
Bright yellow straw colour. More reticent nose than the 2005. Lots of creamy vitality with a hint of lemon pastilles. The fruit is just starting to fade but there is admirable punch. Intense.”
“Lots of lime and lemon and so much of that creamy soft texture from long lees contact. Has that peachy silk texture, perhaps a little soft on the finish but showing so well for its age.”
More Reviews +
95-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
essiavellan.com,
May 2015
“Beautifully tertiary, super toasty nose of coffee, cream, patisserie, grilled meat, tropical fruit and pepper. Stunning nose and almost as great a body, even if the evolution is more sensible there. Round and velvety with mellow bubbling left. ”
“Beautifully tertiary, super toasty nose of coffee, cream, patisserie, grilled meat, tropical fruit and pepper. Stunning nose and almost as great a body, even if the evolution is more sensible there. Round and velvety with mellow bubbling left. ”
“Palmer's 1996 Brut Collection Vintage is very typical of this vintage in Champagne, unfurling in the glass with aromas of iodine, smoky citrus oil, mandarin and honeycomb. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, bright and incisive, with a broad, delicately textural attack, good intensity at the core and a bright spine of tangy acidity that contributes considerable back-end drive and effectively plays off the wine's dosage. Drinking well today, this is the finest wine I have ever tasted from Palmer.”
“Palmer's 1996 Brut Collection Vintage is very typical of this vintage in Champagne, unfurling in the glass with aromas of iodine, smoky citrus oil, mandarin and honeycomb. On the palate, it's medium to full-bodied, bright and incisive, with a broad, delicately textural attack, good intensity at the core and a bright spine of tangy acidity that contributes considerable back-end drive and effectively plays off the wine's dosage. Drinking well today, this is the finest wine I have ever tasted from Palmer.”
“Quite different to Blanc de Blancs, more dark & red fruit here, chocolate, coffee, earl grey tea. Palate is tingly fresh. Stunning mag with dried plum, fantastic length.”
“A powerfully salty, iodized nose, the fruitiness is dominated, even with aeration. The mouth extends this impression, with radiance and a rare youth. Delicious, and so bright after such a long rest in the bottle. Surprising, atypical in its fragrances, tasty persistence on wood mushrooms, the bubbles remind us that we are in Champagne.”
“A subtle, cool note of wet chalk meets fresh lemon on the nose with zesty, bright overtones setting even fresher accents. The palate is concentrated, streamlined, sleek, showing power as much as elegance. The bubbles and tiny and soft on a medium body alive with freshness. The finish is long and brisk, this will really gain from bottle age.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2025
“50% Chardonnay, 38% Pinot Noir, 12% Meunier. Created in 1947 by seven grower families with grand and premier cru vineyards in the Montagne de Reims. Produced from grand cru fruit (Mailly/Verzenay) together with seven premiers crus. Bottled June 2016. Dosage 7 g/l.
A rich, powerful vintage wine proudly displaying its Montagne sourcing. 100% malolactic conversion, but there is still a strong underpinning acidity on show. I would be very happy to drink this.”
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This vintage cuvée celebrates Palmer's growers' mighty vineyard holdings in the premiers and grands crus of the Montagne de Reims. For the 2015, the key villages were Trépail, Villers-Marmery, Rilly-la-Montagne, Ludes, Chigny-les-Roses, Mailly and Verzenay. Bright, intense lemon colour. On the sweet and appetising nose, vanilla and coconut complement the lemon and apple. It has good aromatic purity for the vintage, with only the faintest touch of vegetal fruit. Beautifully intense fruit on the fresh and vibrant palate. A fine effort for the year. Dosage 7g/l”
“A small production year and without hesitation this is one of the best vintage releases from Palmer in a long time. Typical 2012 charm of rich forward fruit, with a wonderful smoky charm. Underneath you see layer upon layer of fruit, it has such purity, there is yellow fruit with tropical notes and underneath you see some dark red fruit, dried fruits and on the palate it is a mouthful. The texture is amazing from long lees ageing and the power of the fruit gives such length to the palate. With freshness in abundance, it ends with a lovely hint of salinity. This is good, when you see power yet lightness you are seeing a great champagne. I recommend enjoying it now, yet it will cellar for 1 -2 decades.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“There is a stunning toastiness of instant 'wow' on the nose of this sublime magnum from a top year. The pristine Montagne de Reims origins impress with the brightness and intensity of fruitiness, with grapes from Mailly and Verzenay forming the grand cru core, and villages like Trépail, Villers-Marmery and Rilly-la-Montagne supporting. Super-sweet but at the same time restrained yet powerful fruitiness. There is width and depth to this exuberant and beautifully structured wine. Rich, fresh and delicious now, yet equally ageworthy. A heavenly bottle. Dosage 7g/l”
“1,800 mags in extremely smart wooden boxes. Heatwave year. This was apparently closed for years and then in 2017 it opened up suddenly. The Montagne de Reims reacted well to the challenges of the vintage. L0169. In magnum.
Deep golden straw. Very different from most of Palmer’s wines. Heady, rich but with an undertow. It’s definitely not as fresh and crisp as most of their other wines, but it’s impressive that it’s still as drinkable as it is. Just a little chew on the end to add texture.”
More Reviews +
93-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2019
“On the special 2003 vintage Palmer decided to go magnum only with its vintage labelled Grands Terroirs, which was launched in 2018 after a long wait. A mere 1703 magnums were released as limited edition. Beautiful, ripe fruity maturing profile with creamy, waxy and toasty notes. Opulent tropical, quince and honey fruitiness with a warm year’s feel to it. Fleshy and round style with velvety texture and calm mousse. At a perfect drinking age now. November 2017 disgorgement dosed 7,5 g/l. ”
“Palmer's 2012 Brut Vintage continues to show beautifully, wafting from the glass with notes of citrus oil, buttered toast, smoke and crisp green orchard fruit. Medium to full-bodied, deep and concentrated, with a tightly wound core, tangy acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse, it's long and penetrating, concluding with a chalky finish. This is evolving very gracefully and will be even better with more time in the cellar: it's one of the finest vintage releases I've tasted from this address.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2021
“Tasted blind. Light coppery gold colour. Very persistent bead. Smells sweet, almost candified. But this is very nicely balanced by citrus acidity. Reminds me of Dom Pérignon! Lightly reductive and rather beautifully balanced.”
94-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“Medium lemon colour. Sophisticated nose with creamy-toasty complexity. Rich and expressive with lovely gunpowdery whiffs. Round palate with dried fruit profile getting emphasised. There is volume and freshness on the sweetly fruity, instantly impressive palate. Long, fruity, sweet finish. ”
93/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2020
“Disgorged in May 2018 with eight grams per liter dosage, Palmer's newly released 2012 Brut Vintage is showing very well indeed, offering up a deep bouquet of peach, yellow orchard fruit, buttered toast and iodine. Full-bodied, fleshy and vinous, it's a rich and muscular wine, reflecting the concentrated vintage, with racy acids and a classy pinpoint mousse. Drink 2020 - 2038”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Small crop. Dosage 7 g/l Lively mousse. Creamy nose, almost lactic. The Palmer CEO suggests pear. Transparent and very racy. Excellent attack. Still quite youthful but already approachable. A rather charming, easy drink. I could drink this all afternoon. Very friendly now.”
“All grand and premier crus. 50–55% Chardonnay, 40–45% Pinot Noir, 5–10% Pinot Meunier. Aged for 7.5 years on lees. Dosage 8–9 g/l. Disgorged July 2017.
Tasted blind. Neutral but well-balanced nose. Something a little umami/Japanese about this on the nose? Then quite rich on the palate – so quite high dosage? Chewy finish. Softer than the other vintage shown alongside [2008]. So 2009?
Drink 2016-2022”
“Very light nose and bone dry and racy. Quite an elegant style. Good balance and just about ready.”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2016
“Generous but refined, deep, fruity nose of beautiful toasty character. Plenty of bright succulent fruit. Round, fleshy, smooth muscular palate with good tension. Fine fruity length. Plenty of potential here.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“Exclusively made up of premiers and grands crus from the Montagne de Reims area. 50% Chardonnay premiers crus (Trepail and Villers-Marmery), 40% Pinot Noir grand crus (Verzy, Verzenay, Mailly) and 10% Pinot Meunier. Lees ageing for 7.5 years. Disgorged August 2016. Dosage 8 g/l.
Tasted blind. Richer, more concentrated nose [than the 2009 tasted alongside]. Broad and substantial – quite savoury. Even a little cheesy. Lots of acidity.
Drink 2017-2023”
“Stylish, positively reductive, gunpowdery nose. Lemon, tropical fruits and fine toastiness. Excellent, overt, fruit-laden palate. Rich, smooth and caressing, slightly fatter than the more classic vintages. ”
“Clean, soft, sweet stone fruit and green apple nose with fudge pudding. Elegantly reserved. Same style continues on the seemingly delicate palate that hides a lot of power and fruit. Fragrant with good balance between smoky minerality and fruit. Long and intense with outstanding freshness. The palate advances like a train. Sublime in magnum (95 points today).”
“The 2019 Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Minéral Grand Cru is fabulous. All it needs is time to unwind. Readers should be in no rush. Bright and packed with energy, the 2019 is so classy right out of the gate. Vibrant and intensely mineral, the 2019 is very closed in on itself. That won't be a problem in a few years' time, but for now, the Minéral is a wine for the cellar. Extended saline-inflected notes punctuate the sculpted finish, adding to the wine's alluring personality. Minéral, a blend of old-vine sites in Avize and Cramant, is slow to emerge, but it's a Champagne that rewards cellaring. Dosage is 2 grams per liter. Disgorged: June 2025; multiple disgorgements throughout the year.”
More Reviews +
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2026
“Disgorged in October 2025 with a dosage of two grams per liter, the 2019 Blanc de Blancs Minéral has turned out beautifully, unfurling from the glass with notes of orange peel, yellow apple, peach, and mirabelle plum. It is full-bodied, concentrated and muscular, with a layered, ample and textural palate that exhibits a rich core of fruit and ripe yet racy acidity. Charming in profile, this is one of the more generously structured renditions of the cuvée on record, attaining some 13.5% alcohol after the second fermentation.”
“The 2018 Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Minéral Grand Cru is impressive, especially for the year. As always, the Minéral is a blend from the Champboutons and Bionnes lieux-dits in Avize and Cramant, respectively. Creamy and resonant, with exquisite balance, the 2018 has so much to offer. Expressive floral, earthy and savory undertones frame a core of Chardonnay fruit. Vinification and aging in oak further softens the contours. Time in the glass amplifies the wine’s strong mineral accents. The 2018 is, quite simply, pristine. Dosage is 3 grams per liter. Disgorged: May 2024.”
More Reviews +
94+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2024
“The 2018 Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Minéral, disgorged in August 2024 with three grams per liter dosage, introduces the range of vintage wines. Defined by poor soils with just about 50 centimeters of topsoil, it comes from two chalk-based, old-vine parcels: Le Champ Bouton in Avize (vinified in tank) and Les Bionnes in Cramant (vinified in an old 600-liter barrel). “In 2017, we lost about 50% to 60% due to frost, then in 2018 we harvested three times the volume of 2017,” reveals Ambroise Agrapart, who is now making the wines, though his father is still very much present. More generously structured compared to the 2016 yet more precise than the 2017, it wafts from the glass with notes of tangerine zest, green apple and dried white flowers. Nakedly chalky with electric-like acidity, it maintains its reputation as the most tensile wine in the range, capturing the freshness much better than many other wines of this vintage.”
92-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
May 2025
“Lemon colour of depth. Soft and supple nose with cream-coated fruit. Peach candy, orange blossom and apricot. Crystaline fruit on the intense palate of linearity and drive. Some firming phenolics bring structure to the fleshy palate. Long aftertaste full of delicious fruit.”
“Medium-deep lemony colour. Expressive nose with spicy and woody undernotes and plentiful fruit. Yellow apple, pear compote, pineapple, dried flowers, curry, salted liquorice and juniper wood. Beautifully full and silky-textured on the palate with unusual vinous charm. Soft mousse and finely integrated, feisty acidity. Full of character, rich and flavourful, with new layers surfacing by the minute. Drink Dates: 2025 - 2032.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2024
“Aged entirely in 600-liter barrels and, for the first time in the history of this cuvée, released without dosage, the 2018 Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Avizoise is nevertheless the most demonstrative vintage wine in Agrapart’s cellar. Crafted from two plots in Avize (Les Robarts and Les Gros Yeux), located just 30 meters from each other and defined by deep, clay-limestone soils, it’s more giving and demonstrative compared to Minéral. Opening in the glass to reveal scents of walnut, pastries and ripe orchard fruit, it is full-bodied, ample and layered with excellent concentration, bright acidity and a long, sapid finish. Les Gros Yeux is one of the plots Agrapart farms with horse, to avoid soil compaction. With Ambroise now in charge of this historic domaine, style remains the same, but he undeniably refines the work.”
94/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
Jul 2025
“While the Minéral cuvée hails from some of the shallowest, poorest soils in Avize, Avizoise always shows some of the roundness and aromatics of the deeper soils of the Gros Yeux and Robarts parcels. It shows a little more of the heat of the year in 2018, too, with fleshy nectarine, lime and white pepper, deep and long with citrus oil yet retaining a beguiling, papery-delicate texture that all of Agrapart's wines seem to find. For a vintage when blanc de blancs can be a little simplistic, this is full of nerve and detail.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2024
“The 2018 Brut Nature Blanc de Blancs L’Avizoise Grand Cru is sourced from 50+ year-old vines in the Robarts and Gros Yeux lieux-dits. A Champagne of total precision, the Avizoise sizzles with energy and class. My impression is that it is still recovering from both its disgorgement a few months ago and the decision to bottle this with no dosage. There's gorgeous Côtes des Blancs tension and energy. Citrus, floral and light tropical notes build while time in the glass brings out the wine's breadth. Disgorged: May 2024.”
“The NV Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Terroirs is an excellent introduction to the estate’s Chardonnays. Disgorged in August 2024 with three grams per liter dosage, it’s composed of 20% from the 2021 vintage (vinified in tank), 50% from 2020 and 30% from 2019, with half of the reserve wines aged on the lees in approximately 30-year-old demi-muids. Heavily based on Oger (around 40% of the blend), with the remainder coming from Oiry, Cramant and Avize, it’s already expressive, offering aromas of honeysuckle, nectarine, bread and fresh hazelnut. Medium to full-bodied with bright acidity and complemented by a pillowy mousse, it concludes with a long, sapid finish.”
“Penet's NV Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Terroir & Sens Grand Cru is tense, powerful and tightly wound. Slate, chalk, lemon confit, chamomile and white flowers, along with a faint veil of reduction, give the wine its distinctive personality. This is an especially powerful, vinous expression of Chardonnay. All the elements are very nicely balanced. This release is 100% 2014 vintage. Disgorged on May 10, 2017. Dosage is 5.6 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
91/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jan 2022
“Based on the 2016 vintage and disgorged in October 2020 with 5.2 grams per liter dosage, the NV Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Terroir & Sens has turned out nicely, wafting from the glass with aromas of confit citrus mingled with hints of almond paste and vanilla pod. Medium to full-bodied, bright and pillowy, with a fleshy core of fruit, racy acids and a chalky finish, it's already drinking well.”
“This Clos des Goisses opens with a nose of sweet marmalade/quince jelly, fragrant flowers and ripe peach. The oak is perfectly in harmony with the lush, plentiful fruitiness. Rather open and inviting for a young Clos des Goisses, the juicy palate has a firming structure and a good degree of vinosity. Not one of this wine’s most monumental editions, by far – but I appreciate its early blooming, sweetly scented charm. Dosage: 4.25g/l”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“I tasted the 2014 Extra-Brut Clos des Goisses from a bottle disgorged a la volée, in other words with no dosage and no sulfur added. At this very early and unfinished stage, the 2014 appears to be a linear, focused Champagne built more on persistence and focus than body, which is to say very much in the style of the year. Of course, much can change with dosage. It will be interesting to see how things end up. The blend is 71% Pinot Noir and 29% Chardonnay, done 64% in oak, 36% in steel, with no malolactic fermentation in any of the lots.”
18.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2025
“71% Pinot Noir, 29% Chardonnay. Probably Champagne’s most famous single vineyard, measuring 5.83 ha. Chalky bedrock, steep slopes and a prime southerly aspect. 64% aged in wood with no malolactic conversion. 8 years’ ageing on the lees. Disgorged March 2023. Dosage 4.25 g/l.
Luxurious and luscious, plump stone-fruit flavours with white flowers on the nose. A touch of honey and spice. Extremely complex – still very early to be approaching this, but super-fine already.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“A Clos des Goisses from a classically cool vintage, this wine opens with finesse, offering a delicate bouquet of scented stone fruit and crisp apple. The pristine purity of the fruit is beautifully complemented by seamlessly integrated oak nuances. Complexity gradually unfolds in the glass, revealing layers of subtle depth. The palate delivers on the nose’s promise: energetic, playful, and airy. This charming vintage of Clos des Goisses excels in its delicate expression and vibrant, dancing energy. Disgorgement date:2024. Dosage:4.5g/l.”
96/100
Lisa Perrotti-Brown MW,
Thewineindependent.com,
Aug 2023
“The 2014 Clos des Goisses, 71% Pinot Noir and 29% Chardonnay, is Extra Brut at 4.5 g/L dosage and was disgorged in March 2023. It needs a little coaxing to bring out delicate scents of wet pebbles, lime blossom, and green apples plus emerging wafts of Marcona almonds, yuzu, and baking bread. Light-bodied and very dry, the palate is super-fine and delicately crafted, with a lively backbone supporting the intense flavors, finishing long and minerally.”
95/100
Jane Anson,
Janeanson.com,
Aug 2023
“The kind of dry that in Champagne puts the emphasis on all the right places - salt-scraping, pure citrus, quince, gooseberry and lemon grass, with chalky persistency, relaxing through the mid palate to show brioche, almonds, candied ginger, graphite, concentrated and scintillating, so good. Another cool vintage in Champagne that here puts the emphasis on finesse, but with higher yield than the 2013, all perfectly handled by the legendary 5ha of Clos des Goisses walled vineyard that is located on the slopes of Mareuil-sur-Aÿ. Thierry Garnier cellar master. 60% aged in Burgundy barrels, 40% in stainless steel tanks, no malo, 4.5g/l dosage.”
“This Clos des Goisses opens with a nose of sweet marmalade/quince jelly, fragrant flowers and ripe peach. The oak is perfectly in harmony with the lush, plentiful fruitiness. Rather open and inviting for a young Clos des Goisses, the juicy palate has a firming structure and a good degree of vinosity. Not one of this wine’s most monumental editions, by far – but I appreciate its early blooming, sweetly scented charm. Dosage: 4.25g/l”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Mar 2023
“I tasted the 2014 Extra-Brut Clos des Goisses from a bottle disgorged a la volée, in other words with no dosage and no sulfur added. At this very early and unfinished stage, the 2014 appears to be a linear, focused Champagne built more on persistence and focus than body, which is to say very much in the style of the year. Of course, much can change with dosage. It will be interesting to see how things end up. The blend is 71% Pinot Noir and 29% Chardonnay, done 64% in oak, 36% in steel, with no malolactic fermentation in any of the lots.”
18.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jul 2025
“71% Pinot Noir, 29% Chardonnay. Probably Champagne’s most famous single vineyard, measuring 5.83 ha. Chalky bedrock, steep slopes and a prime southerly aspect. 64% aged in wood with no malolactic conversion. 8 years’ ageing on the lees. Disgorged March 2023. Dosage 4.25 g/l.
Luxurious and luscious, plump stone-fruit flavours with white flowers on the nose. A touch of honey and spice. Extremely complex – still very early to be approaching this, but super-fine already.”
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“A Clos des Goisses from a classically cool vintage, this wine opens with finesse, offering a delicate bouquet of scented stone fruit and crisp apple. The pristine purity of the fruit is beautifully complemented by seamlessly integrated oak nuances. Complexity gradually unfolds in the glass, revealing layers of subtle depth. The palate delivers on the nose’s promise: energetic, playful, and airy. This charming vintage of Clos des Goisses excels in its delicate expression and vibrant, dancing energy. Disgorgement date:2024. Dosage:4.5g/l.”
96/100
Lisa Perrotti-Brown MW,
Thewineindependent.com,
Aug 2023
“The 2014 Clos des Goisses, 71% Pinot Noir and 29% Chardonnay, is Extra Brut at 4.5 g/L dosage and was disgorged in March 2023. It needs a little coaxing to bring out delicate scents of wet pebbles, lime blossom, and green apples plus emerging wafts of Marcona almonds, yuzu, and baking bread. Light-bodied and very dry, the palate is super-fine and delicately crafted, with a lively backbone supporting the intense flavors, finishing long and minerally.”
95/100
Jane Anson,
Janeanson.com,
Aug 2023
“The kind of dry that in Champagne puts the emphasis on all the right places - salt-scraping, pure citrus, quince, gooseberry and lemon grass, with chalky persistency, relaxing through the mid palate to show brioche, almonds, candied ginger, graphite, concentrated and scintillating, so good. Another cool vintage in Champagne that here puts the emphasis on finesse, but with higher yield than the 2013, all perfectly handled by the legendary 5ha of Clos des Goisses walled vineyard that is located on the slopes of Mareuil-sur-Aÿ. Thierry Garnier cellar master. 60% aged in Burgundy barrels, 40% in stainless steel tanks, no malo, 4.5g/l dosage.”
“Surpassing even the 2012 and 2008, Philipponnat's 2013 Extra-Brut Clos des Goisses looks to be the finest vintage of this cuvée in several decades, at least on first acquaintance. Deriving from only the six core parcels out of the 13 that make up the Clos des Goisses, it's a striking wine, evoking aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, Anjou pear, clear honey, bee pollen, stone fruit and iodine. Full-bodied, layered and vinous, its textural attack segues into a deep, concentrated and tightly wound mid-palate that's girdled by racy acids and chalky structure, before concluding with a long, saline finish. Why is it quite so good? It would appear that 2013 was the perfect storm: an early-ripening terroir in a cool, late vintage; moderately yielding Burgundian selections of Pinot Noir and Chardonnay that attained full maturity; and a willingness to make a strict selection have all come together to deliver a profound Clos des Goisses.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2022
“The 2013 Extra-Brut Clos des Goisses is fabulous. Readers will have to be patient, as the 2013 is in no mood to show all its cards. The late harvest produced a bristling, intensely saline Clos des Goisses that will require years to be at its best. Even so, its depth, textural resonance and finish are so evocative as to what the future holds. The 2013 is a positively stunning Champagne and one of the best Goisses in recent memory. I can’t wait to see how it develops. Dosage is 4.5 grams per liter.”
96/100
Lisa Perrotti-Brown MW,
Thewineindependent.com,
Nov 2022
“A blend of Pinot Noir and Chardonnay, the 2013 Clos des Goisses needs a little patience to allow ripe apple, candied ginger, and mandarin peel scents to emerge, followed by a toasty undercurrent and nuances of oyster shell and jasmine. The palate has exquisitely fine bubbles and electric, spine-tingling tension, with bags of subtle savory, toasty and citrusy flavors, finishing long and chalky.”
97/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
JebDunnuck.com,
Nov 2023
“Tasting this a year later alongside the new release of 2014, the 2013 Champagne Clos des Goisses Extra Brut seems to be coming into its own. Composed of 85% Pinot Noir and the rest Chardonnay, and pouring a rich straw/copper hue, it’s starting to show lovely, layered aromatics as it unfolds with scents of red berries, currant, toasted croissant, frangipane, and orgeat. Full-bodied, assertive, and long on the palate, it has driving, assertive energy with fantastic concentration and acidity. Though it has broad shoulders, it remains in check with itself and offers a long, fantastic finish. It has great structure and an angular feel, with notes of Meyer lemon preserves and orange rind, and delivers wonderful energy throughout. This can hold up through a meal of sweetbreads or other rich fare. 10,723 bottles were produced. Drink 2024-2055. Disgorged in March 2022, with 4.5 grams per liter dosage.”
“Deep golden straw colour. Real attack on the nose. Lots of impact and tightly laced. Impressive concentration. Not dry! Some honey and apple here. A good bottle … and still quite a way to go.”
More Reviews +
94+/100
Ian D'Agata,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“A wine of remarkable finesse rather than power, the 2007 Philipponnat Brut Clos de Goisses boasts laser-like acidity and accuracy of flavor that are memorable. One of my favorite Champagnes, Clos de Goisses is usually a powerful bubbly in its youth, but this 2007 is rather politely-styled, almost delicate in fact, in its white fruit and floral aromas and flavors. Best of all, it is still exceptionally young and will last for decades in a proper cellar. ”
93-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2017
“Bright golden colour with evolved depth already upon launch. Overt, ripe nose with earthy-spicy characters coming with orange marmalade, apple and oriental spice complexity. To date, the maturing nose contrasts the tight, restrained palate, and it needs time to open up in the glass. The palate comes with a superb acid line, enhancing the length and contributing a beautiful saline mineral quality to the wine. At first there is structural richness to the mouth-feel but it gains a beautifully focused and lean, dry finish due to the extraordinary acidity and low, 4,25g/l dosage. Fresh, nervy and vivacious despite the winey quality. This is a Clos des Goisses to keep (June 2016 disgorgement tasted). The September 2016 disgorgement tasted in November 2016 was even more convincing reassuring me to raise my points to 93. ”
“Ample, broad and dramatic in scale, the 2014 Brut Spécial Club Chouilly Grand Cru shows just how well many wines turned out in a vintage that was not highly regarded at the time. Lemon confit, marzipan, chamomile and light pastry open effortlessly in the glass. The Chouilly is a big wine, but it remains translucent in feel, with plenty of cut driving through to the finish. Didier Gimonnet makes the Chouilly from the Montaigu lieu-dit, which has vines that he planted as far back as 1951. Readers won't want to miss this super-distinctive, substantial Champagne. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. Disgorged: October 14, 2019.”
More Reviews +
94/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Disgorged in October 2019 with four grams per liter dosage, Gimonnet's 2014 Extra-Brut Special Club Chouilly Grand Cru is showing superbly, offering up aromas of crisp green orchard fruit, nougat, apple blossom and white peach. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, with a pillowy core of crisp, vibrant fruit that's complemented by a pinpoint mousse, this is elegant and concentrated, with a long, beautifully defined finish.”
“The 2014 Brut Spécial Club Cramant Grand Cru is another super-impressive wine in this range. It emerges from the Bateau, Gromonts, Buissons, Bauves, Bionnes, Champ du Prévôt and Briquettes lieux-dits. Orange confit, tangerine oil, white flowers, graphite and lightly tropical fruit infuse the Cramant with tremendous complexity to match its powerful personality. The Cramant is a rich, heady Champagne with a feeling of structure that leans towards the realm of Pinot. I loved it. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. Disgorged: October 14, 2019.”
More Reviews +
95/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Apr 2020
“The 2014 Brut Special Club Cramant Grand Cru derives from 14 parcels in nine different lieux-dits (above all Le Bateau), and Gimonnet feels that it's the most successful of his stand-alone single-village bottlings. Unfurling in the glass with aromas of peach, white flowers, fresh pastry and brioche, it's full-bodied, layered and textural, with a concentrated and multidimensional core, incisive acids and a long, chalky finish.”
“The richest and most exuberant of these lieux-dits bottlings—reflecting both site and vintage—is the 2015 Brut Special Club Oger Grand Cru, a dramatic wine that bursts with aromas of confit citrus, pear, peach and white flowers. Full-bodied, layered and enveloping, it's broad and fruit-driven, even if it isn't as fine-boned or elegant as the Cramant and Chouilly Special Clubs.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The 2015 Brut Spécial Club Oger Grand Cru is an attractive, powerful wine. Citrus peel, white flowers, chalk and the savory notes typical of so many 2015 are nicely laced together. I would give the 2015 a year or two in the cellar to come together, as it is a bit disjointed at present, but I would not wait too long, as flavors that are savory today may very well develop into more overpowering vegetal notes over time. The Oger is a blend taken from the Terres de Noël, Brulis, Champ Nérons and Fondy lieux-dits. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. Disgorged: October 14, 2019.”
“The NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuis 1er Cru is loaded with intense saline, mineral and savory inflections that play off the lemon and grapefruit flavors. Taut and nervy, with striking tension, the 1er Cru hits all the right notes. I love the energy here. Disgorged: November 15, 2019.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“he NV Blanc de Blancs Cuis 1er Cru is such a classic Gimonnet wine. Light on its feet and gracious, with soaring aromatics and tons of nuance, the 1er Cru is a winner. Bright floral overtones, citrus, brioche and apple are some of the many notes that are delineated in the glass. Among the entry-level wines in this range, the Cuis 1er Cru offers the best expression of the Gimonnet style at an affordable price. I loved it. Disgorged: March 16, 2019.”
“The 2018 Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuvée Gastronome is a dense, powerful wine. I would give it a few years in bottle to soften, as some of the edges are pretty angular at this point. I very much like the depth and vinous intensity of the Gastronome in 2018. Pear, dried flowers, chamomile, mint and spice build into the deep, potent finish. Dosage is 5 grams per liter. Disgorged: April 7, 2022.”
“The 2014 Cuvée Gastronome is already quite open, which makes it a good choice for drinking now and over the next few years. Dried pear, dried flowers, mint and savory notes all add character. The 2014 is quite attractive, even if it doesn’t have the persistence or energy of the very best wines in this range. Dosage is 5 grams per liter. Disgorged: July 20, 2018.”
“Released only in magnum, the 2008 Brut Millésime de Collection Vieilles Vignes is the same wine as Gimonnet's Special Club, bit it sees more than 10 years sur lattes before disgorgement. Unwinding in the glass with a deep and complex bouquet of pear, green apple, citrus zest, oyster shell, smoke and pastry cream, it's full-bodied, chalky and incisive, with terrific depth at the core, promising reserve and a long, resonant finish.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2022
“Really serious wine with a beginning, middle and end. Lovely balance between serious and hedonistic. Complete. Drink 2025 – 2029
”
“The 2006 Brut Millésime de Collection Vieilles Vignes de Chardonnay (Magnum) is powerful, masculine and also a touch austere, but offers tremendous thrust and overall intensity. This is an especially large-scaled, creamy old-vine Champagne from Gimonnet. From magnum it should drink well for another decade or so. The Vieilles Vignes de Chardonnay emerges from parcels in Cramant and Chouilly (both Grand Cru villages) and Cuis, a 1er Cru village. Dosage is 5 grams per liter. Disgorged: January 2016.”
“The 2005 Brut Millésime de Collection’ Vieilles Vignes de Chardonnay (Magnum) is intriguing, but it also comes across as quite powerful and a bit chunky next to so many wines in this lineup. There is plenty of brightness to the Chardonnay fruit, along with expressive aromatic top notes that provide lift, but at the same time slightly angular contours remain. Overall, though, this is a solid effort for the vintage. Fruit sources are 57% Cramant, 30% Chouilly and 13% Cuis. Dosage is 5 grams/liter. Disgorged: October 2014.”
“For an introduction into the range of Pierre Péters, the NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cuvée de Réserve is the perfect choice. It's based on the incisive 2021 vintage and completed by a 50% component of the perpetual blend, aged in a variety of vessels (stainless steel tanks, large oak casks and concrete). This is the most floral wine in the range, wafting from the glass with aromas of honeysuckle, citrus fruit, acacia and beeswax. Shaped by the high-acid vintage profile, expect a bright, lightly structured Champagne laden with racy acids and a focused finish. It was disgorged in May 2024 with a dosage of six grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“The NV Brut Cuvée de Réserve Grand Cru is fabulous. A Champagne of tension and energy, the Cuvée de Réserve has real presence, not to mention tons of class. Citrus, jasmine, mint and crushed rocks are some of the many nuances that race out of the glass. In this release, the Cuvée de Réserve has a light tropical quality that is both exotic and hugely appealing. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. Disgorged: March, 2021.”
92/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“Chardonnay from the Côte des Blancs Grands Crus of Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Avize and Cramant. Crucially this cuvée is almost based on a reserve system rather than a year, with 50% of the blend coming from Peters' perpetual reserve and the remainder from the 2019 vintage. It is in quite superb form, based on a vintage Rodolph Peters may be the best of the last 20 years. Delicate layers of fresh fruit – pear, pineapple, clementine – are far from obvious, tucked into a palate saturated with pure Côte des Blancs energy from the reserves. This remains one of the benchmark NV Blanc de Blancs, at its best with up to five years in the cellar.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2023
“Open, effusive and a real delight to taste. Soaring aromatics and soft curves give this 2019-base Champagne tons of sheer appeal. Apricot, tangerine peel, spice and dried flowers abound in this racy, open-knit Champagne. The Cuvee de Reserve is rarely this charming at this stage. The slightly lower dosage of 5 grams per litre works so well.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“A more friendly, approachable wine than the Extra Brut – and more tight knit. Very fine bead and great, sappy balance between the delicate fruit and something more substantial – presumably the reserve wines. Really quite fine and rewarding with this more mature undertow beneath the particularly zesty initial impression.”
91/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The NV Blanc de Blancs Cuvée de Réserve is such a gorgeous wine. Bright, mineral and savory, with attractive tropical accents, the Cuvée de Réserve offers striking nuance and tons of class. This release is based on 2016, with reserve wines that go back to 1988. Partially blocked malolactic fermentation helps preserve a measure of freshness, but what impresses most is the wine’s total sense of balance. For readers who want to know what the Côte des Blancs is all about, without spending the money for an elite cuvée, this is the place to start.”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jan 2022
“Based on the 2017 vintage and disgorged in May 2021, the latest release of Péters's NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cuvée de Réserve continues to show very nicely. Bursting with aromas of crisp orchard fruit, honeycomb, white flowers and fresh bread, it's medium-bodied, pillowy and generous, with a refined mousse and an elegantly fleshy core of fruit. This is a fine-boned, weightless blanc de blancs that's disarmingly easy to drink.”
“For an introduction into the range of Pierre Péters, the NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cuvée de Réserve is the perfect choice. It's based on the incisive 2021 vintage and completed by a 50% component of the perpetual blend, aged in a variety of vessels (stainless steel tanks, large oak casks and concrete). This is the most floral wine in the range, wafting from the glass with aromas of honeysuckle, citrus fruit, acacia and beeswax. Shaped by the high-acid vintage profile, expect a bright, lightly structured Champagne laden with racy acids and a focused finish. It was disgorged in May 2024 with a dosage of six grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2021
“The NV Brut Cuvée de Réserve Grand Cru is fabulous. A Champagne of tension and energy, the Cuvée de Réserve has real presence, not to mention tons of class. Citrus, jasmine, mint and crushed rocks are some of the many nuances that race out of the glass. In this release, the Cuvée de Réserve has a light tropical quality that is both exotic and hugely appealing. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. Disgorged: March, 2021.”
92/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“Chardonnay from the Côte des Blancs Grands Crus of Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Avize and Cramant. Crucially this cuvée is almost based on a reserve system rather than a year, with 50% of the blend coming from Peters' perpetual reserve and the remainder from the 2019 vintage. It is in quite superb form, based on a vintage Rodolph Peters may be the best of the last 20 years. Delicate layers of fresh fruit – pear, pineapple, clementine – are far from obvious, tucked into a palate saturated with pure Côte des Blancs energy from the reserves. This remains one of the benchmark NV Blanc de Blancs, at its best with up to five years in the cellar.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2023
“Open, effusive and a real delight to taste. Soaring aromatics and soft curves give this 2019-base Champagne tons of sheer appeal. Apricot, tangerine peel, spice and dried flowers abound in this racy, open-knit Champagne. The Cuvee de Reserve is rarely this charming at this stage. The slightly lower dosage of 5 grams per litre works so well.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“A more friendly, approachable wine than the Extra Brut – and more tight knit. Very fine bead and great, sappy balance between the delicate fruit and something more substantial – presumably the reserve wines. Really quite fine and rewarding with this more mature undertow beneath the particularly zesty initial impression.”
91/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The NV Blanc de Blancs Cuvée de Réserve is such a gorgeous wine. Bright, mineral and savory, with attractive tropical accents, the Cuvée de Réserve offers striking nuance and tons of class. This release is based on 2016, with reserve wines that go back to 1988. Partially blocked malolactic fermentation helps preserve a measure of freshness, but what impresses most is the wine’s total sense of balance. For readers who want to know what the Côte des Blancs is all about, without spending the money for an elite cuvée, this is the place to start.”
92/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jan 2022
“Based on the 2017 vintage and disgorged in May 2021, the latest release of Péters's NV Brut Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Cuvée de Réserve continues to show very nicely. Bursting with aromas of crisp orchard fruit, honeycomb, white flowers and fresh bread, it's medium-bodied, pillowy and generous, with a refined mousse and an elegantly fleshy core of fruit. This is a fine-boned, weightless blanc de blancs that's disarmingly easy to drink.”
“The 2018 Brut Cuvée Spéciale Les Chétillons is a super-classic Peters Champagne. Bright and beautifully sculpted in the glass, the 2018 sizzles with tension. Lemon peel, chalk, mint, dried flowers, sage and oyster shell are some of the many notes that emerge over time. I especially admire the energy here. An archetype for Mesnil. Disgorged: July 2025.”
“The 2018 Brut Cuvée Spéciale Les Chétillons is a super-classic Peters Champagne. Bright and beautifully sculpted in the glass, the 2018 sizzles with tension. Lemon peel, chalk, mint, dried flowers, sage and oyster shell are some of the many notes that emerge over time. I especially admire the energy here. An archetype for Mesnil. Disgorged: July 2025.”
“Derived from three old-vine parcels within the same lieu-dit, the 2017 Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuvée Spéciale Les Chétillons, disgorged in July 2024 with four grams per liter dosage, is structurally open today, but Rodolphe predicts it will tighten up with more time post disgorgement, as I’m sure it will. Opening in the glass to reveal notes of fresh almond, iodine, clams and citrus fruit, it is flamboyant and charming. Less youthfully austere and more demonstrative than the 2016 vintage rendition, it is Les Chétillons with a more powerful musculature, balanced by a bright spine of acidity and concluding with a long, saline finish. More mineral-laced than the Les Montjolys of the same year, one will want to consider laying down the bottles as they refine with age. It’s the first release where Péters decided to extend aging sur lattes for six more months (from six years to six and a half years), followed by a year post-disgorgement, a decision based on tasting.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2017 Brut Cuvée Spéciale Les Chétillons shows why this is such a great site and also illustrates the difference between chalk here and clay in Les Montjolys. Bright saline notes cut through a core of citrus peel, slate, chalk, mint and white pepper. This is classic Chétillons from start to finish. All of the Chétillons signatures are present, perhaps slightly attenuated in this vintage, but not by much. The long, sustained finish is another hallmark of this first-rate site in Mesnil. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. Disgorged: July 2024.”
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2025
“This has immediate charm, aromatics are bold and forward, some tropical hints on the core of citrus, grapefruit and hints of orange in the background. Chardonnay thrived in 2017 and this is likely going to be one of the stars of the vintage, quite a mineral and chalky fresh finish. These usually drink best 3-5 years after release.”
“Gorgeous. Light on its feet and intensely aromatic, the 2016 is an absolute delight. Dried lemon peel, almond, crushed flowers, tropical fruit and chamomile all grace this super-expressive Chetillons. Light inflections of botrytis linger. Slightly forward aromas and flavours suggest the 2016 will be an early-drinking Chetillons, but I doubt that will be an issue for most readers. If anything, the 2016 shows the kind of complexity that usually only comes with time. It's a fine effort in a challenging vintage.”
More Reviews +
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“The 2016 Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuvée Spéciale Les Chétillons is showing beautifully, wafting from the glass with aromas of yellow orchard fruit, crisp peaches, freshly baked bread, warm biscuits and hazelnuts. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and textural, it's layered, racy and fine-boned, with a bright spine of acidity, good concentration and a chalky finish. This comparatively approachable Les Chétillons was disgorged in November 2022 with four grams per liter dosage.”
“The 2014 Cuvée Spéciale Les Chétillons is fabulous. The 2014 is not as obvious as years like 2012 or 2013, but it presents a youthfully austere, classic personality that is absolutely beguiling. Readers will have to be patient here. There is certainly a lot to look forward to. The 2014 Les Chétillons is a Blanc de Blancs that sizzles with Mesnil tension and energy. Dosage is 3.5-4.5 grams per liter. Disgorged: May, 2021.”
More Reviews +
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jan 2022
“Disgorged in July 2021, Péters's just-released 2014 Brut Blanc de Blancs Cuvée Spéciale Les Chétillons is showing very well, unwinding in the glass with scents of ripe citrus fruits, crisp green and yellow orchard fruit, white flowers and subtle hints of freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, deep and incisive, it's seamless and concentrated, its elegantly fleshy core of fruit underpinned by a racy spine of acidity and animated by a pretty pinpoint mousse; it concludes with a long, mineral finish. Readers will have a lot of fun comparing the 2014 with the more tightly wound 2013 in a decade's time.”
“Chardonnay from the Côte des Blancs Grands Crus, 75% of which is the 'L'Esprit' blend of 2018 with the remainder formed of perpetual reserve of the Brut Réserve. This is quite superb, the reserves amplifying the ripe 2018 character, all generous pineapple and orange stone fruits, with layers of salty pastry, blossom and white butter. A stony, drying presence on the back end makes this fine extra-brut feel truly grounded in the central Côte des Blancs.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2018
“The NV Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Extra Brut is entirely from the 2014 vintage and was sourced in four parcels of the Côte des Blancs. Opening with potted ginger and white flowers on the clear, fresh, precise and chalky nose, this is a pure, fresh, elegant, beautifully dry and chalky grand cru with an expressive, stimulating iodine-inflected finish that reveals a persistent structure and freshness. This is a damned serious and chalky Blanc de Blancs that was disgorged in January 2018 with just two grams of dosage. Tasted at the domaine in April 2018.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“Light, transparent nose. Very readable and transparent wine. Lifted with an impact that builds on the finish but is almost unnoticeable on the nose initially. This is a sort of Chablis of Champagne … but is not uncomfortably dry and tart with a light yeastiness on the finish. There's something distinctly floral about it. Even pretty.”
95/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“A beautifully balanced wine with sliced fresh and cooked apple with hints of cream and some bread dough and brioche. Medium-bodied with a lovely creamy texture. Beautiful balance.”
“The 2021 L'Esprit de 2021 is a very pretty Champagne to drink now and over the next handful of years. Apricot, spice, chamomile, ginger and dried flowers lend notable aromatic complexity. Tropical overtones add character. I would not push my luck on aging. The 2021 is quite pleasant today, but not likely to improve materially. Dosage is 4.7 grams per liter. Disgorged: November 2025.”
“The 2020 L'Esprit de 2020 is vivid and finely cut. Orchard fruit, sage, mint, white pepper and slate lend notable brightness. There's a touch of angularity in the chiseled contours, along with the slightly drying character of the year. Even so, the 2020 is nicely balanced. This will be especially fine at the dinner table. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. Disgorged: October 2024.”
“The L'Esprit de 2019 is sublime. Silky contours are immediately arresting. Apricot, baked apple tart, spice, lemon confit and mint resonate with effortless grace. All of the natural concentration of the vintage comes through loud and clear. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. Disgorged: March 2024.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2024
“The L'Esprit de 2019 is one of the best versions of this wine I can remember tasting. Exuberant and racy, with tons of energy, the 2019 reflects the natural intensity of this great vintage while retaining the super-classic signatures of the Côtes des Blancs. This cuvée is a blend of fruit sourced from Grand Cru sites in Le Mesnil, Avize, Cramant and Oger. Readers who want to enjoy a top-flight Champagne without splurging will find so much to like here. Hints of tangerine peel, marzipan and dried flowers linger on the intensely saline finish. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. Disgorged: December 19, 2023.”
“Charming and pillowy, the 2018 Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Millésime L’Esprit de 2018 bursts with notes of peach, nectarine and white flowers mingled with freshly baked bread, warm biscuits and subtle hints of citrus zest. Medium-bodied, bright and racy, it's a fine-boned, elegant Champagne that concludes with a chalky finish.”
“The 2016 Brut Cuvée Millésime L'Esprit is laced with the essence of tropical fruit, exotic white flowers and lemon confit. Intensely perfumed and radiant, the 2016 offers tons of near and medium-term appeal. This is an especially racy, aromatic, weightless edition of the Esprit. Dosage is 4.5-5.5 grams per liter. Disgorged: February, 2021. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Jan 2022
“The 2016 Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Millésime L’Esprit de 2016 is lovely, wafting from the glass with aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, nectarine, white flowers, ripe citrus fruit and warm bread. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and precise, it's charming and fine-boned, with a pretty core of fruit, racy acids and a pearly mousse.”
“The 2019 L'Etonnant Monsieur Victor Edition TB.19 shows Rodolphe Péters' blending skills at their best. It's a riveting, dynamic Champagne. Passion fruit, tangerine peel, mint and chalky notes all run through a fabulous, dynamic Champagne built on layers of textural resonance. This opens beautifully with a bit of time in the glass. Superb. Disgorged: November 2025.”
“The 2018 Brut Cuvée Spéciale Les Montjolys is a gorgeous wine that shows the textural breadth that is such a signature of this site. Pear, dried flowers, ginger and mint all build nicely in the glass. As readers know, 2018 is a year with high yields, and that comes through in the wine's relatively delicate personality compared to many prior years. Even so, the Montjolys is wonderfully seductive. It will drink well right out of the gate. Disgorged: July 2025.”
“Aromas of red berries, spices, herbs and pear introduce the 2018 Brut Vintage from Piper-Heidsieck, a moderately weighted, tense and delicate Champagne with a well-balanced mousse and a mouthwatering, delicate finish. This is a classic, fresh and refined Champagne.”
More Reviews +
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2024
“Rich, spicy nose with real character. Notes of tropical flowers – lilies? Ripe and exuberant and certainly not austere, but with no desperately obvious sweetness.”
92/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2024
“The 2018 Brut Vintage, a blend of 50% Chardonnay, 47% Pinot Noir and 3% Pinot Meunier, has a golden tint. Powdery smokiness on the nose suggests pliability and generosity. The frothy, light palate foams with plum exuberance and lovely depth of ripe fruit. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. (Lot L2400673131)”
“Tasted from magnum, Piper-Heidsieck's 2018 Vintage opens with an aromatic medley of pear, freshly baked bread, orange zest and dried apricot mingling with white peach, wheat toast and a subtle trace of smoky reduction. Medium- to full-bodied, it is ample and textural, underpinned by ripe yet vibrant acidity and chalky structuring extract, culminating in a long, delicately toasty finish. Disgorged in January 2024, it carries a dosage of seven grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Aromas of red berries, spices, herbs and pear introduce the 2018 Brut Vintage from Piper-Heidsieck, a moderately weighted, tense and delicate Champagne with a well-balanced mousse and a mouthwatering, delicate finish. This is a classic, fresh and refined Champagne.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2024
“Rich, spicy nose with real character. Notes of tropical flowers – lilies? Ripe and exuberant and certainly not austere, but with no desperately obvious sweetness.”
92/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2024
“The 2018 Brut Vintage, a blend of 50% Chardonnay, 47% Pinot Noir and 3% Pinot Meunier, has a golden tint. Powdery smokiness on the nose suggests pliability and generosity. The frothy, light palate foams with plum exuberance and lovely depth of ripe fruit. Dosage is 7 grams per liter. (Lot L2400673131)”
“The 2014 Brut Vintage, a blend of 55% Pinot Noir and 45% Chardonnay with a dosage of seven grams per litre, has turned out nicely with aromas of pear, peach, almonds and smoky hints. Medium to full-bodied, supple and fruity with a delicate mousse, this is a structured, tension-filled but airborne Champagne with high acidity, the sign of a cool weather vintage. Although already thoroughly enjoyable, it should age well over the next five years.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Cluboenologique.com,
Oct 2023
“Deep lemon-gold color. Expressive, sweetly fruity nose, with fine, toasty, roasted coffee-bean and vanilla layers. Pineapple, apple, and apricot. Silky smooth on the palate, of good volume and with racy acidity bringing energy to it. Great fruit purity continues on the palate. A long-lasting, succulent, and dynamic whole, with more to come. ”
90+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“The 2014 Brut Vintage opens in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, freshly baked bread, lemon oil and light reduction. Medium to full-bodied, deep and tightly wound, with racy acids and chalky grip, it displays a pinpoint mousse and concludes with a long, dry finish. Bottled under Diam Mytik, it's a taut, structured wine that merits a bit of time in the cellar to show what exactly it's capable of.”
91+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Much as I wrote last year, the 2014 Brut Vintage opens in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, freshly baked bread, lemon oil and light reduction. Medium to full-bodied, deep and tightly wound, with racy acids and chalky grip, it continues to display a pinpoint mousse and concludes with a long, dry finish. As it unwinds with time in the cellar, it's revealing more potential.”
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This Piper vintage is a blend of 19 villages, with Pinot Noir coming from the Montagne de Reims, and Chardonnay from both the Côte des Blancs and the Montagne de Reims. Charmingly fruity and inviting nose, with soft vanilla-coated notes of red apple, peach, mirabelle plum and lemon curd, all enveloped in a complex toasty whole. Similarly joyful fireworks of fruit continue on the rich, rounded palate, which is beautifully silky and juicy, with a fine acid line leading to a long, sweetly fruity finish. A seductive vintage ready to impress. Dosage 7g/l”
93/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“55% Pinot Noir, 45% Chardonnay. Émilien Boutillat thinks of 2014 as somewhere in-between 2012 and 2008. There's an expressive golden yellow fruit profile with some pineapple/mango cream exuberance and plenty of Piper zest. The depth here is creamy, the autolytic richness bringing a measured savour to the sweet-natured fruit, the precision and acidity in place for medium term. Not quite the explosiveness of the brilliant 2012, but more approachable than 2008, it is a fine vintage and cements just how refined and coherent the Piper lineup is today. 94+ in magnum.”
93/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“Showing nicely complex notes of figs, red apples, golden pears, walnuts and lemon conserve on toast, with a touch of beeswax. It’s medium-bodied, with bright acidity and a textured, phenolic palate. Tight bubbles. Dry feel. 55% pinot and 45% chardonnay. 7g/L dosage. Delicious now.”
“The 2014 Brut Vintage, a blend of 55% Pinot Noir and 45% Chardonnay with a dosage of seven grams per litre, has turned out nicely with aromas of pear, peach, almonds and smoky hints. Medium to full-bodied, supple and fruity with a delicate mousse, this is a structured, tension-filled but airborne Champagne with high acidity, the sign of a cool weather vintage. Although already thoroughly enjoyable, it should age well over the next five years.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Cluboenologique.com,
Oct 2023
“Deep lemon-gold color. Expressive, sweetly fruity nose, with fine, toasty, roasted coffee-bean and vanilla layers. Pineapple, apple, and apricot. Silky smooth on the palate, of good volume and with racy acidity bringing energy to it. Great fruit purity continues on the palate. A long-lasting, succulent, and dynamic whole, with more to come. ”
90+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Sep 2021
“The 2014 Brut Vintage opens in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, freshly baked bread, lemon oil and light reduction. Medium to full-bodied, deep and tightly wound, with racy acids and chalky grip, it displays a pinpoint mousse and concludes with a long, dry finish. Bottled under Diam Mytik, it's a taut, structured wine that merits a bit of time in the cellar to show what exactly it's capable of.”
91+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Much as I wrote last year, the 2014 Brut Vintage opens in the glass with notes of crisp orchard fruit, freshly baked bread, lemon oil and light reduction. Medium to full-bodied, deep and tightly wound, with racy acids and chalky grip, it continues to display a pinpoint mousse and concludes with a long, dry finish. As it unwinds with time in the cellar, it's revealing more potential.”
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“This Piper vintage is a blend of 19 villages, with Pinot Noir coming from the Montagne de Reims, and Chardonnay from both the Côte des Blancs and the Montagne de Reims. Charmingly fruity and inviting nose, with soft vanilla-coated notes of red apple, peach, mirabelle plum and lemon curd, all enveloped in a complex toasty whole. Similarly joyful fireworks of fruit continue on the rich, rounded palate, which is beautifully silky and juicy, with a fine acid line leading to a long, sweetly fruity finish. A seductive vintage ready to impress. Dosage 7g/l”
93/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“55% Pinot Noir, 45% Chardonnay. Émilien Boutillat thinks of 2014 as somewhere in-between 2012 and 2008. There's an expressive golden yellow fruit profile with some pineapple/mango cream exuberance and plenty of Piper zest. The depth here is creamy, the autolytic richness bringing a measured savour to the sweet-natured fruit, the precision and acidity in place for medium term. Not quite the explosiveness of the brilliant 2012, but more approachable than 2008, it is a fine vintage and cements just how refined and coherent the Piper lineup is today. 94+ in magnum.”
93/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“Showing nicely complex notes of figs, red apples, golden pears, walnuts and lemon conserve on toast, with a touch of beeswax. It’s medium-bodied, with bright acidity and a textured, phenolic palate. Tight bubbles. Dry feel. 55% pinot and 45% chardonnay. 7g/L dosage. Delicious now.”
“Developing lemon-gold colour. Stunningly toasty nose with cofee and cream, sweet fruity opulence with dried apricots, ripe pear, golden delicious apples and crème brûlee. Generous palate with velvety texture of yeasty richness, which is energized by a fine acid line and mineral tension. Super charming already today but built to last.”
More Reviews +
93+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“Unfurling in the glass with incipiently complex aromas of citrus oil, wheat toast, fresh peach and crisp orchard fruit, the newly released 2012 Vintage Brut is full-bodied, deep and tightly wound, with excellent concentration, racy acids and a fine mousse, concluding with a long and penetrating finish. Even though it's still a little reserved after its recent disgorgement,”
89/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“The 2012 Vintage is bold, open-knit and very easy to like. Brioche, pastry, vanillin and warm, toasty notes all run through this rich, boisterous Champagne from Piper-Hiedsieck. Deep and racy, with good depth, the 2012 is a good choice for drinking now and over the next handful of years.”
“Lovely sweetly fruity charred pastry, honey and vanilla nose with opulent toasty generosity. Rich voluptuous body which surprises with its lovely energy and nervosity. Its superb intensity promises great future potential.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Decanter World Wine Awards,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2017
“Rich with noteworthy complexity and lovely red apple and ripe lemon fruit. Nice toastiness to the palate overlaid with nuts and brioche. ”
“The style of Piper brut is friendly, approachable and zesty, one of the more reliable widely available Grandes Marques NV wines lately. It's all about the play between bright yellow citrus zest – that Sézannais Chardonnay singing loudly? – playing with some sparky reductive grillé flourishes and just enough fleshy Pinot fruit, nougat and almond stuffing to support it. Impressive for a base year as tricky as 2017, so we might expect even more of 2018 and 2019 to come. Full of life!”
More Reviews +
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Piper-Heidsieck's Brut is one of the most red grape-dominant grande marque non-vintages, with the broad blend of 50% Pinot Noir bringing depth, body and delicious spicy and toasty layers. Lemon-green in colour. The inviting nose has creamy fruit, strawberry, blood orange, dried flowers, baking spices and crunchy red apple. A fine toastiness emerges stronger with time in the glass. Friendly, fleshy and round lightweight palate. This will also reward further cellaring. Sublime in magnum. Dosage 8g/l”
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2017
“Medium-deep lemon colour. Stylish, toasty and leesy nose. Lovely gunpowdery touch. Rather sweet palate but still in balance. Long, linear, succulent, finely focused palate. Super-stylish. This champagne has improved tremendously over the last years. Now it can sometimes challenge even Charles Heidsieck Brut Réserve. Outstanding in magnum.”
“The style of Piper brut is friendly, approachable and zesty, one of the more reliable widely available Grandes Marques NV wines lately. It's all about the play between bright yellow citrus zest – that Sézannais Chardonnay singing loudly? – playing with some sparky reductive grillé flourishes and just enough fleshy Pinot fruit, nougat and almond stuffing to support it. Impressive for a base year as tricky as 2017, so we might expect even more of 2018 and 2019 to come. Full of life!”
More Reviews +
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Piper-Heidsieck's Brut is one of the most red grape-dominant grande marque non-vintages, with the broad blend of 50% Pinot Noir bringing depth, body and delicious spicy and toasty layers. Lemon-green in colour. The inviting nose has creamy fruit, strawberry, blood orange, dried flowers, baking spices and crunchy red apple. A fine toastiness emerges stronger with time in the glass. Friendly, fleshy and round lightweight palate. This will also reward further cellaring. Sublime in magnum. Dosage 8g/l”
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2017
“Medium-deep lemon colour. Stylish, toasty and leesy nose. Lovely gunpowdery touch. Rather sweet palate but still in balance. Long, linear, succulent, finely focused palate. Super-stylish. This champagne has improved tremendously over the last years. Now it can sometimes challenge even Charles Heidsieck Brut Réserve. Outstanding in magnum.”
“Hors Serie | Strong golden yellow, silver reflections, very fine, persistent mousseux. Ripe bouquet, delicate blossom honey, ripe ringlet fruit, delicately nutty, fine minerality, ripe stone fruit, delicate nuances of oxidation that dissolve with air, nuances of brioche and almonds, candied orange zest. The bouquet opens with a little time, delicate white peaches, pineapple, orange marmalade, fine touch of nougat. Firm on the palate, white apple, very racy structure, salty, delicate Rancio nuances, tight-knit, very youthful, some almond biscuits on the finish, some Noutella, fine, good tropical fruit on the finish, hazelnut flour in the aftertaste, lingers for minutes.”
More Reviews +
94-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2022
“Hors Serie | For this second edition of Hors-Series special cuvées, chef de cave Emilien Boutillat went through his cellars and found us a gem to drink history by. Hors-Serie 1982 is a long lees-aged, January 2022 disgorged version of the original Piper Vintage. Thus, a blend lead by Pinot Noir from villages like Verzy, Verzenay, Tauxières and Ambonnay complemented by Côte des Blancs Chardonnay. Dosed at 4g/l with magnums of the same wine, the colour is golden but perfectly bright. Fruit shines also on the opulently toasty, deep and elegant nose. Coffee, dried apricots, yellow plums baked peach, cacao, dark spiciness, dried herbs and smoke. The age can be felt more on the palate which nevertheless comes with beautiful acid line and a sappy, juicy quality. A silky wine of mature elegance. Perfect to drink now.”
17.5+/20
Matthew Hayes,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Sep 2022
“Brut Sauvage | Deep gold; no bubbles again, but the same fine mousse in the mouth. Coffee, apricot and burnt honey on the nose; very torrified, but lovely depth and spice. Mushrooms and truffle, really quite spectacular for lovers of oxidative notes.”
93/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“Brut Sauvage | 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, mainly from the Montagne de Reims but with a little Côte des Blancs Chardonnay. Disgorged in 1991 and re-released with the Hors-Série 1982 (a late disgorged version of the same wine). Versus the Hors-Série, Sauvage 1982 shows an involved, developed profile with piles of lime marmalade, mango and eucalyptus flavours, wrapped in warming malt and honey richness. Firm still, the freshness of the vintage still in evidence, this is a fine mature Champagne worth savouring.”
“Piper-Heidsieck’s first blanc de noirs comes from the excellent 2019 vintage. No reserve wines were used for this first edition. Here, according to Piper tradition, a good dose, a fifth, of Meunier complements Pinot Noir. There is a lovely sweetly fruity nose of soft depth. Burned sugar complements the ripe peach and red fruit profile. There is also a soft spicy and delicately floral tone to the aromatics. The is no heaviness on the palate, that is fleshy yet energetic and saline. Very much Piper from day one, a brilliant new addition to the range. ”
More Reviews +
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TFB Founder,
Oct 2023
“A brand new release in October 2023, this 1st edition is all 2019 grapes, the next edition will have the 2019 as a reserve wine – Bundles of dark cherry and hints of chocolate, rich ripe peach, apricot and dark cherry dominate and the palate has all the weight of the fruit, yet is super elegant and a lightness on the finish. Dosage 5 g/l blends perfectly. I tasted with smoked salmon wrapped around potato on a cucumber & dill sauce, one of the greatest salmon dishes I have tasted, was super refreshing.
”
“The NV Extra Brut Essentiel, a blend of 44% Pinot Noir, 34% Pinot Meunier and 22% Chardonnay with 27% reserve wines, opens with smoky melted butter. This reductive smokiness continues on the palate, where licorice overtones add aromatic highlights. The fine smooth mousse is exemplary, providing a smooth texture to this balanced wine, which is quite a step up from the Cuvée. Dosage is 4 grams per liter. (Lot L2306893072)”
“Impressively toasty nose with lots of pastry nuances, both dried and fresh fruit, spice and charred notes. Fruity, boosted palate with fresh acidic backbone and soft expansive mousse. Lovely fleshy texture with perfectly soft, perky bubbles, Long, juicy finish. A charmer of richness and vivacity.”
More Reviews +
16.5+/20
Matthew Hayes,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Sep 2022
“Magnum - Mid lemon to pale gold. Extra couple of years immediately evident in the extra autolytic bite and depth. Quite substantial and refreshing. Good length and drive.”
“Piper-Heidsieck's premium non-vintage cuvée receives a stunning boost in a longer-aged magnum release, making it a terrific value cuvée that can give a few prestige cuvées a run for their money. Based on the 2013 vintage, it's full of the year's bright intensity in charry roasted limes and grapefruit marmalade, generous with fragrant raspberry and toasted nuts, and fleshed out beautifully by almost four years of ageing post-disgorgement. Smooth, long and polished, there's not a hair out of place here.”
More Reviews +
16.5+/20
Matthew Hayes,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Sep 2022
“Magnum - Mid lemon to pale gold. Extra couple of years immediately evident in the extra autolytic bite and depth. Quite substantial and refreshing. Good length and drive.”
“60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, mainly from the Montagne de Reims but with a little Côte des Blancs Chardonnay. The second release in Piper-Heidsieck's Hors-Série programme is the remarkable 1982, disgorged at the start of 2022 (also re-released as part of a twin set is the Sauvage 1982, the original disgorgement of this wine). Hors-Série 1982 is a time capsule of nuanced, age-defying freshness that displays both a clear-eyed view of the original vintage character and all the extraordinary effects of 40 years on lees. 1982 was the biggest harvest on record in Champagne at the time, ripe by contemporary standards with potential alcohol levels of around 10.5%. The lack of malolactic fermentation has helped the sense of fidelity here, the wine feeling clear and transparent rather than browned, butterscotchy or over-developed. The Chardonnay sings with dried lime, charred grapefruit peel and piles of toasted nut and lime cordial, the Pinot structure still holding firm, juicy with stone fruit and vanilla and wrapped in subtle nuances of pine, bay and orange blossom. So detailed and rewarding, this is just a fascinating bottle.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2022
“Strong golden yellow, silver reflections, very fine, persistent mousseux. Ripe bouquet, delicate blossom honey, ripe ringlet fruit, delicately nutty, fine minerality, ripe stone fruit, delicate nuances of oxidation that dissolve with air, nuances of brioche and almonds, candied orange zest. The bouquet opens with a little time, delicate white peaches, pineapple, orange marmalade, fine touch of nougat. Firm on the palate, white apple, very racy structure, salty, delicate Rancio nuances, tight-knit, very youthful, some almond biscuits on the finish, some Noutella, fine, good tropical fruit on the finish, hazelnut flour in the aftertaste, lingers for minutes.”
94-94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2022
“For this second edition of Hors-Series special cuvées, chef de cave Emilien Boutillat went through his cellars and found us a gem to drink history by. Hors-Serie 1982 is a long lees-aged, January 2022 disgorged version of the original Piper Vintage. Thus, a blend lead by Pinot Noir from villages like Verzy, Verzenay, Tauxières and Ambonnay complemented by Côte des Blancs Chardonnay. Dosed at 4g/l with magnums of the same wine, the colour is golden but perfectly bright. Fruit shines also on the opulently toasty, deep and elegant nose. Coffee, dried apricots, yellow plums baked peach, cacao, dark spiciness, dried herbs and smoke. The age can be felt more on the palate which nevertheless comes with beautiful acid line and a sappy, juicy quality. A silky wine of mature elegance. Perfect to drink now.”
94/100
Yohan Castaing,
Decanter.com,
Dec 2022
“The second rendition of this late-disgorged cuvée has a lively first nose of candied lemon, hints of lime and smoke, alongside quince, apple and spring flowers; with aeration, notes of almonds and almond flowers come to the fore. On the palate, there is a nervy tension that energises its fine, crystalline texture. This is an upright and elegant Champagne with a mouthwatering, long and airy finish. After some time in the glass, it evolves towards notes of smoke, flint, chalk and vanilla. A sumptuous Champagne, now at its peak, but which could be kept for another five years.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Jul 2023
“This is showing aromas of ginger snaps, jasmine tea, yellow plums, chamomile and golden pears. Preserved lemons. Fantastic freshness and energy, with lemony acidity from blocked malo. Medium-bodied. So alive, with very fine, very soft bubbles. Long and spicy finish. Hors-Serie is a limited edition collection, a tribute to a former vintage extra brut Champagne (Sauvage) made in the 1980s. 60% pinot noir and 40% chardonnay. Disgorged in January 2022. 4g/L dosage, using specific 1982 liqueur. Delicious now.”
“Disgorged early 2018. Stocks are just coming to an end. According to Chef de Cave Regis Camus 2002 is a vintage with lots of richness. Rich because of 2001. ‘In 2002 there were two vintages in one which explains its richness.’
The mousse seems less fine than the old Charles Heidsiecks we have just been tasting. Straw gold. Intense and rather Dom Pérignon-like on the nose. Then on the palate it’s amazingly rich and tropical. Before slimming down into the corset of freshness. Lots of potential and tight and tense.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2017
“Super stylish, toasty nose with lovely floral and gunpowdery tones as well as tropical fruit, orange peel and candy notes. Super linear, driven, energetic palate which huge intensity and richness. Drinking perfectly today with lot’s of delicious ageing elements but very much in the fresh and vibrant side.This is a serial winner, we chose it as the Best Champagne at FINE Champagne magazine in 2011. ”
99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Nov 2023
“Rare 2002 was commercialised for an extended period of time, so there are several disgorgements in existence. This one, from 2014, has had plenty of time on cork, allowing the wine to go from strength to strength. It is now showing a magnificent array of layers. Super-toasty nose, with sweet and roasted nutty notes and plenty of delicious exotic fruit, plus softly spicy cardamom and glorious caramel beneath. The charming mousse is softened with age and soothingly caressing. This picture-perfect bottle has fruity power and a great, muscular structure.”
94/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Dec 2012
“This is top Champagne from Piper-Heidsieck, offering the delicious airy quality that's the hallmark of this house, with crisp apple flavour, tangy acidity and the first signs of yeasty, toasty bottle age. Its fruit intensity has transformed into a splendid selection. It's worth aging for a few more years, though also delicious now.
”
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2010
“Light yellow-gold. Pungent aromas of lemon zest, orange and pear, complicated by sexy floral and gingerbread qualities and hints of toasty lees and honey. Lively on entry, with lively citrus flavors, then deeper and smokier in the middle palate, offering juicy orchard fruit and honeyed nut flavors and good mineral snap. The finish lingers with suave floral and spice notes and excellent persistence. ”
“Magnum. Régis Camus' favourite vintage and the current release!
Pale yellow. Nicely mature with some sweetness and lemon fruit. Clean and resolved though not that much evidence of autolysis. Complete, composed and fine and sophisticated rather than dramatic or showy. A hint of smokiness on the long finish.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Magnum. Current release. Regis Camus, Chef de Cave, adores this vintage.
Greenish pale gold. Intense and nourishing on the nose. Very pretty and zesty, complete and well balanced. Great for current drinking. Lovely!”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2016
“I can't get enough of this Rare only produced in magnum! Charming, fine-tuned nose with sweet fruit backed up by rich toasty notes. Impressive gunflint and coffee notes. Smooth and silky on the long palate. Same aromatics continue on the intensely fruity but refreshing and focused palate. Good degree of both finesse and harmony. Lovely subtlety and class of a magnum. It outdoes even the 2002 due to its magnum format! ”
93/100
Josh Reynolds,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2008
“(for a magnum) Bright green-straw. Pungent, pure, mineral-driven aromas of lime, melon, white peach and honeysuckle expand with air. Fresh and sharply focused, offering lively citrus flesh and zest flavors and a suave underpinning of smoky minerals. Turns creamier on the long, gently sweet finish. An impressive showing; this is balanced to reward patience. ”
“Evolved, orange-toned luminous colour. The fruitiness is deliciously sweet in a tropical genre with vanilla tones complemented but the classy, coffee and cream toastiness. There is a lovely butter biscuit and ginger complexity to the broad red fruit nose of cherries, figs and exotic spices. The palate is still youthful and sleek but impressively lacey coming with a degree of smooth vinosity. It finishes with cool crispiness, spicy minerality and a faint touch of tannin enhancing the notion of elegance. Perfectly dosed at 9,5g/l. ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Nov 2017
“The salmon colored 2007 Rosé Millesimé Rare has a clear, fresh, slightly oaky-nougat and pretty vinous bouquet. It is a rich and slightly sweetish yet pure, refined, elegant and well-structured Rosé Champagne with good grip and tension as well as a long, intensely aromatic and powerful finish. This is great and enormously complex Champagne with an extraordinary, complex finish. The 2007 is based on 56% Chardonnay and 44% Pinot Noir. Tasted in November 2017.”
96/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Nov 2017
“Another sensational Champagne, as well as the first vintage for the cuvee, the 2007 Rare Rosé (56% Chardonnay and 44% Pinot Noir) offers that beautiful complexity and nuance you only get from top rosé Champagnes. Orange blossom, strawberries, spice, dried flowers, toasted bread, and orange peel notes all emerge from this richly concentrated, medium to full-bodied, beautifully textured 2007. With a fine, yet layered mousse, incredible complexity, and a great finish, this blockbuster effort will be better with 2-3 years of bottle age and shine for 10-15 years or more.”
“This June 2024 disgorgement is showing perfectly the fruit purity and freshness of the 2016 harvest year. Tightly packed with fine intensity, the lemony fruit is complemented by a whiff of toast and fine white peach sweetness. Linear and driven on the palate of exemplary freshness and energizing tension. ”
More Reviews +
93+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Disgorged in June 2024 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, Pol Roger’s 2016 Brut Blanc de Blancs is a compelling expression of the vintage. It opens with an aromatic profile of crisp pear, lemon zest and freshly baked bread, mingling with notes of early white blossoms and a subtle reductive framing. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, taut and incisive—more tensile and linear than the richer, more rounded 2015 iteration. Bracing acidity drives the wine toward a long, saline finish. This is a quintessential Blanc de Blancs: precise, energetic and poised for graceful evolution, promising to develop further layers and toasty sophistication with age.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2016 Blanc de Blancs is a gorgeous wine from Pol Roger. Green apple, mint, white pepper and chalk all grace this understated, airy Champagne. Hints of pastry, tangerine peel and lemon curd appeal later, with a bit of time in the glass. This is a terrific showing. ”
“Pol Roger's newly released 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs is very appealing, unwinding in the glass with scents of crisp orchard fruit, citrus zest, sourdough bread, pastry cream and almonds. Medium to full-bodied, taut and incisive, it's more chiseled than the richer, more concentrated 2012, with racy acids and a gently reductive edge, concluding with chalky grip. This is a real classic in style and should develop beautifully with age on cork.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
TFB,
Apr 2021
“Initially the fruit is quite held back a few minutes later there is more of an explosion; ripe and rich creamy lemon pastry with bundles of grapefruit. After a few minutes tropical notes, there is a hint of lychee and the usual ripe pineapple. It is not as expected since the aromatics are tight, but the fruit really comes out on the palate. With 2013’s there is more acidity to be expected, but this doesn’t seem to stand out as the palate is richly texture that combination or ripe fruits and the lees ageing add a round going to velvet like texture. Finishes with a mineral saline lift which keeps it very fresh. The flavours linger long. This is right up there with the 2002 BdB which was simply stunning. I expected the 2013 to be "out shined" by the delicious 2012 fruit, but this isn’t the case, this has very attractive pure fruit with a lovely texture on the palate.”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2013 Blanc de Blancs is another terrific wine in this range from Pol Roger. It offers up a mélange of apricot, honey, chamomile, dried herbs. The ripeness of the Chardonnays comes through in burnished tropical accents that lend an exotic flair. Drink this over the next decade or so.”
“Pol Roger's 2012 Brut Blanc de Blancs is excellent, offering up aromas of crisp green apple, freshly baked bread, white flowers and blanched almonds. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and precise, with fine depth at the core, racy acids and a pinpoint mousse, it has shed some of the smoky, gently reductive top notes it displayed two years ago, but equally it hasn't yet arrived at its mature aromatic register—so I'd be inclined to cellar bottles for a few years before revisiting this.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Intense and minerally nose with real attack. Salted-lemons flavour. Very tight-knit and zesty. An excellent aperitif style. Complete but definitely not over-dosed!
Drink 2020–2030”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“Lively, piercing freshness and very lemon-zesty. Appetising and energetic. Just needs a little time to round out and gain a bit more persistence.”
95/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2020
“Medium greenish-yellow, silver reflections; fine, persistent mousse. Fresh vanilla sponge is underlaid with a herbal savouriness, hints of passion fruit, fine white stone fruit, walnut and orange zest. Good complexity, elegant, delicate wood savouriness, quince, mineral and floral touches. Has plenty of development potential.”
90/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“Pol Roger's 2012 Brut Blanc de Blancs is terrific. The natural ripeness of the year amps up the Chardonnay flavors. Rich and ample in the glass, with tons of depth, the 2012 really shines. Readers should expect a pretty big Champagne, but all the elements are nicely balanced. Disgorged: February, 2019.”
“Very densely textured, almost to be chewed rather than sipped. The finish is decidedly rich, almost sweet. Should age well. ”
More Reviews +
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Dec 2012
“White flowers, lemon, slate and chamomile are some of the notes that burst from the glass in Pol Rogers 2002 Brut Blanc de Blancs Extra Cuvee de Reserve. A bright, tightly coiled wine, the 2002 comes across as quite fresh and vibrant, especially within the context of the year. Sweet floral and minty notes run through the precise, crystalline finish. Although the 2002 is absolutely delicious today, I am intrigued to see how it might age. It is utterly brilliant today.””
93/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2012
“Pol Roger Blanc de Blancs 2002 - Firm, with a toasty base mixing with flavors of quince paste, pastry, dried apricot, raw almond and a hint of lemon curd. There's a clean -cut note of minerally salinity throughout, accompanied by a fine bead and a lingering finish.”
95/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Nov 2012
“Pol Roger Blanc de Blancs 2002 - Pale gold. Intense, mineral-dominated aromas of candied citrus fruits, pear, anise, smoky lees and chamomile, plus a sexy floral nuance and a hint of sweet butter. Palate-staining orchard and citrus fruit flavors show outstanding depth and energy, picking up chalky mineral and spice notes with air. Strikingly concentrated and precise wine with strong finishing punch and noteworthy persistence. This concentrated, deftly balanced Champagne is built for a long, graceful evolution.””
“The 2004 Blanc de Blancs Cuvée de Réserve Vinothèque opens with apricot, tangerine oil, mint, white pepper, tropical fruit, baked apple tart and a touch of reduction from long aging on the lees. The 2004 has aged impeccably. Readers who enjoy Champagnes with a bit of bottle age will adore this. Impressive.”
“The intensity of dried fruits leaping out the glass is quite astonishing! All those yellow fruits, like lemon, grapefruit and ripe charred pineapple, the fruit is between how we know it as fresh fruit, yet going to dried fruit, that concentration of aromatics and flavour. As you swirl in the glass you see the complexities of Chardonnay, going quite like chocolate and coffee. An amazing glass full, the texture wraps around the palate, super smooth and velvety with the bubbles, now oh so gentle. Something very special about Pol BdB 2002, the original release is pretty astonishing now, but this version cellared until recently at Pol brings a touch more freshness and precision. The perfect drink for Christmas morning with a touch of smoked trout.”
“The current release of Pol Roger's NV Brut Réserve is quite dramatic, bursting with aromas of mandarin oil, honeycomb, elderflower, fresh bread and musky peach. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, it's generous and textural, with a rich core of fruit, lively acids and a pillowy mousse.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Pale lemon colour. Fresh and bright, the nose shows white flowers, yellow apple, quince, tangerine and apricot tart. A subtle spicy note backs the fruit up. It's perky and energetic on the fleshy yet structured palate, a balanced blend of the three key Champagne varieties from some 30 crus. There is fruity muscle to this wine, which rewards mid-term cellaring. Dosage 8g/l”
17/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Cooked apple, biscuit, savoury and long. Delicious salted-bread aftertaste. The absolute prototype of champagne, and I appreciate the generous dosage.”
92/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2020
“Light greenish yellow, silver reflections, lively mousse. White fruit underlaid with biscuit, fresh farm apple, lemony nuances, a hint of peach and herbs. Full-bodied on the palate, ripe, discreet sweet fruit gives volume, pleasant acidity on the finish, will benefit from a few years of bottle ageing.”
91/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“The latest rendition of Pol Roger’s NV Brut Réserve is based on the 2021 vintage and includes 30% reserve wines from the 2020, 2019 and 2018 vintages. Disgorged in October 2024 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, the wine bursts from the glass with an expressive bouquet of crisp pear, orange zest, ripe peach and delicate pastry notes. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, with a vibrant core of fruit and admirable balance, despite what might sound like a relatively generous dosage. It is infused with bright acidity and culminates in a persistent, saline finish. Composed in equal parts of Pinot Noir, Chardonnay and Pinot Meunier, this cuvée is immediately appealing upon release yet possesses the structure to reward several years of cellaring, revealing the charm of a finely matured Champagne.”
“The current release of Pol Roger's NV Brut Réserve is quite dramatic, bursting with aromas of mandarin oil, honeycomb, elderflower, fresh bread and musky peach. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and enveloping, it's generous and textural, with a rich core of fruit, lively acids and a pillowy mousse.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Pale lemon colour. Fresh and bright, the nose shows white flowers, yellow apple, quince, tangerine and apricot tart. A subtle spicy note backs the fruit up. It's perky and energetic on the fleshy yet structured palate, a balanced blend of the three key Champagne varieties from some 30 crus. There is fruity muscle to this wine, which rewards mid-term cellaring. Dosage 8g/l”
17/20
Richard Hemming MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Cooked apple, biscuit, savoury and long. Delicious salted-bread aftertaste. The absolute prototype of champagne, and I appreciate the generous dosage.”
92/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Oct 2020
“Light greenish yellow, silver reflections, lively mousse. White fruit underlaid with biscuit, fresh farm apple, lemony nuances, a hint of peach and herbs. Full-bodied on the palate, ripe, discreet sweet fruit gives volume, pleasant acidity on the finish, will benefit from a few years of bottle ageing.”
91/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“The latest rendition of Pol Roger’s NV Brut Réserve is based on the 2021 vintage and includes 30% reserve wines from the 2020, 2019 and 2018 vintages. Disgorged in October 2024 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, the wine bursts from the glass with an expressive bouquet of crisp pear, orange zest, ripe peach and delicate pastry notes. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied, with a vibrant core of fruit and admirable balance, despite what might sound like a relatively generous dosage. It is infused with bright acidity and culminates in a persistent, saline finish. Composed in equal parts of Pinot Noir, Chardonnay and Pinot Meunier, this cuvée is immediately appealing upon release yet possesses the structure to reward several years of cellaring, revealing the charm of a finely matured Champagne.”
“The 1999 Brut Rosé Cuvée de Réserve Vinothèque has arrived at its 25th birthday in style. Crushed flowers, dried red cherry fruit, mint, spice, cedar and tobacco unfold in the glass. This is a quirky style, a bit fleeting and fragile especially in its aromatics, but also quite pretty, especially on the palate. There’s good depth here.”
More Reviews +
94/100
James Suckling,
jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“Hints of dust and mushroom with dried fruits. Dense and fresh, with peaches, cantaloupe, dried strawberry, pomegranate and ginger. Full and layered with fine bubbles that almost seem like fine tannins. Flavorful finish. Hint of salt at the end. Fascinating, just released, library rosé champagne.”
“This vintage cuvée marks the inaugural release of Damien Cambres as chef de cave. Fortuitously, his first vintage was 2019, a year he regards as the first truly great August harvest of recent times. The colour shows a luminous depth with lemony hues. The nose is gloriously toasty and exuberantly expressive, bursting with candied lemon, wild strawberry, and starfruit, all lifted by an elegant smoky nuance. An aromatic firework, the wine is both intense and tightly knit on the palate, driven by striking acidity. Bright, pristine, and finely poised, it reveals considerable ageing potential. ”
More Reviews +
94/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
May 2026
“Both the Rosé and the Brut excel in 2019 at Pol Roger, where the vintage's enticing mixture of plush ripeness, refreshing brightness and age worthy build combine to offer up some of the finest vintage releases of recent times at this house. Pol's appealing creamy generosity is already in play behind outgoing flavours of caramelised apricot tart and fragrant Pinot Noir red berries, but there's plenty of energising Chardonnay here of fine quality, almost explosively aromatic with pomelo and mandarin zestiness. Already far from tight and offering plenty of pleasure, time in the cellar will ramp up the complexity”
92+/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2026
“The 2019 Brut Vintage is soft, open-knit and very approachable. A Champagne of inner strength, the 2019 comes across as a bit closed today, which is surprising given the style of the vintage. Soft curves and silky contours add to the wine's considerable appeal. Floral and orchard fruit overtones linger. I have a feeling there is more here. This is rather quiet today.”
“Released rather young for a Pol Roger vintage, this wine is charmingly forward and lush, really epitomising its early blooming, supple harvest year. Red fruit leads the way, with some fruit drops and peachy tones. Fleshy and mouth-fillingly generous on the palate, and there is still good muscle behind all the richness. Delightfully fresh and airy, with sweet fruitiness, but there is more complexity to come. Dosage: 8g/l”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“Tasted at the Pol Roger 175th Birthday Celebration - Pol Roger Vintage 2018, disgorged summer 2023 is classic of the vintage. There was plenty of sunshine in the summer of 18 and you have this forward fruit and core of minerality that keeps it fresh and a lighter dosage than normal at 7 g/l. It oozes citrus and ripe red apples, bulked up on the palate with the #PinotNoir giving apricot and peach flavours. Lots of tropical notes and fresh pastry just emerging. The 4 years on lees works perfectly adding texture to the palate and such a lightness of touch on dosage. Excellent ”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2025
“Full bottle 1,581 g. 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay from 20 grand and premier cru villages in the Montagne de Reims and the Côte des Blancs. Aged 33 m below ground level and hand-riddled before being disgorged December 2023.
Rich, floral nose with a real spread of power on both nose and palate. Really very winning! Lemon-cream flavours – very seductive. Long. This has really opened out since I first tasted it from magnum in March 2024. Definitely rich – a world away from a zero-dosage grower champagne – but it should be hugely enjoyable in the relatively short term.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2024
“Very zesty with strong citrus notes. Still quite tight from magnum but very respectable. CEO Laurent d'Harcourt of Pol remarked that 'it had to be good after 2017' and that it was made in much bigger quantity. Much is expected of the 2019.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2018 Vintage is a very pretty, open-knit Champagne to drink now and over the next 10-15 years. In a vintage in which so many wines are on the lighter side, the 2018 is super-expressive, with lovely depth and impeccable balance. The 2018 can be enjoyed now, but I would prefer to cellar it for a year or two. Hints of pear, dried flowers, kirsch and mint are nicely layered on a spine of fruit and structure. ”
“Released rather young for a Pol Roger vintage, this wine is charmingly forward and lush, really epitomising its early blooming, supple harvest year. Red fruit leads the way, with some fruit drops and peachy tones. Fleshy and mouth-fillingly generous on the palate, and there is still good muscle behind all the richness. Delightfully fresh and airy, with sweet fruitiness, but there is more complexity to come. Dosage: 8g/l”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“Tasted at the Pol Roger 175th Birthday Celebration - Pol Roger Vintage 2018, disgorged summer 2023 is classic of the vintage. There was plenty of sunshine in the summer of 18 and you have this forward fruit and core of minerality that keeps it fresh and a lighter dosage than normal at 7 g/l. It oozes citrus and ripe red apples, bulked up on the palate with the #PinotNoir giving apricot and peach flavours. Lots of tropical notes and fresh pastry just emerging. The 4 years on lees works perfectly adding texture to the palate and such a lightness of touch on dosage. Excellent ”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2025
“Full bottle 1,581 g. 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay from 20 grand and premier cru villages in the Montagne de Reims and the Côte des Blancs. Aged 33 m below ground level and hand-riddled before being disgorged December 2023.
Rich, floral nose with a real spread of power on both nose and palate. Really very winning! Lemon-cream flavours – very seductive. Long. This has really opened out since I first tasted it from magnum in March 2024. Definitely rich – a world away from a zero-dosage grower champagne – but it should be hugely enjoyable in the relatively short term.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2024
“Very zesty with strong citrus notes. Still quite tight from magnum but very respectable. CEO Laurent d'Harcourt of Pol remarked that 'it had to be good after 2017' and that it was made in much bigger quantity. Much is expected of the 2019.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2018 Vintage is a very pretty, open-knit Champagne to drink now and over the next 10-15 years. In a vintage in which so many wines are on the lighter side, the 2018 is super-expressive, with lovely depth and impeccable balance. The 2018 can be enjoyed now, but I would prefer to cellar it for a year or two. Hints of pear, dried flowers, kirsch and mint are nicely layered on a spine of fruit and structure. ”
“Released rather young for a Pol Roger vintage, this wine is charmingly forward and lush, really epitomising its early blooming, supple harvest year. Red fruit leads the way, with some fruit drops and peachy tones. Fleshy and mouth-fillingly generous on the palate, and there is still good muscle behind all the richness. Delightfully fresh and airy, with sweet fruitiness, but there is more complexity to come. Dosage: 8g/l”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“Tasted at the Pol Roger 175th Birthday Celebration - Pol Roger Vintage 2018, disgorged summer 2023 is classic of the vintage. There was plenty of sunshine in the summer of 18 and you have this forward fruit and core of minerality that keeps it fresh and a lighter dosage than normal at 7 g/l. It oozes citrus and ripe red apples, bulked up on the palate with the #PinotNoir giving apricot and peach flavours. Lots of tropical notes and fresh pastry just emerging. The 4 years on lees works perfectly adding texture to the palate and such a lightness of touch on dosage. Excellent ”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2025
“Full bottle 1,581 g. 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay from 20 grand and premier cru villages in the Montagne de Reims and the Côte des Blancs. Aged 33 m below ground level and hand-riddled before being disgorged December 2023.
Rich, floral nose with a real spread of power on both nose and palate. Really very winning! Lemon-cream flavours – very seductive. Long. This has really opened out since I first tasted it from magnum in March 2024. Definitely rich – a world away from a zero-dosage grower champagne – but it should be hugely enjoyable in the relatively short term.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2024
“Very zesty with strong citrus notes. Still quite tight from magnum but very respectable. CEO Laurent d'Harcourt of Pol remarked that 'it had to be good after 2017' and that it was made in much bigger quantity. Much is expected of the 2019.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2018 Vintage is a very pretty, open-knit Champagne to drink now and over the next 10-15 years. In a vintage in which so many wines are on the lighter side, the 2018 is super-expressive, with lovely depth and impeccable balance. The 2018 can be enjoyed now, but I would prefer to cellar it for a year or two. Hints of pear, dried flowers, kirsch and mint are nicely layered on a spine of fruit and structure. ”
“The 2016 vintage resulted in happy surprises after all the numerous viticultural challenges the year brought about. Pol Roger Vintage shows an enticing combination of lush, ripe fruitiness combined to vibrant, energising acidity. The nose greets you with a charming tone of burned match and butter biscuits. Beyond, it comes with a mélange of both crunchy and sun kissed orchard fruit, sweet honey and fragrant orange blossom notes. On the palate it is equally fulfilling in its immediate appeal and juiciness. This is a generous and overt, aromatically sound vintage ready to please, yet it comes with muscle and intensity that rewards midterm ageing. ”
More Reviews +
94/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2016 Brut Vintage reveals a complex, gourmand bouquet with aromas of ripe orchard fruits, nectarine, pastry, nuts, sweet spices and ripe white fruits, signs of a warm vintage. Full-bodied, broad and vinous with a fleshy core of fruit, it’s rich and elegant with a penetrating, saline finish. It will drink at its peak in five to 10 years.”
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2023
“Very tight, dense nose with some honey and orange notes on the palate. Already very drinkable with the acidity not especially noticeable, although presumably it will gain in aromatic complexity with bottle age. I found it less than enthralling when I first tasted it and gave it a score of 16.5 but when I was served a glass blind from my re-stoppered bottle a few days later, I was impressed. So is the lesson, don't rush your pleasures?”
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“Bright fruit, jumps out the glass the Chardonnay richness of yellow fruit backed up o the palate by the red fruit adding the structure. Delicious lemon twist of the tropical with pineapple and guava and apricot and peach coming through from the PN on the palate. Delicious now and for 5+ years. Worth noting the Pol vintage magnums age beautifully.”
“The 2016 vintage resulted in happy surprises after all the numerous viticultural challenges the year brought about. Pol Roger Vintage shows an enticing combination of lush, ripe fruitiness combined to vibrant, energising acidity. The nose greets you with a charming tone of burned match and butter biscuits. Beyond, it comes with a mélange of both crunchy and sun kissed orchard fruit, sweet honey and fragrant orange blossom notes. On the palate it is equally fulfilling in its immediate appeal and juiciness. This is a generous and overt, aromatically sound vintage ready to please, yet it comes with muscle and intensity that rewards midterm ageing. ”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2023
“Very tight, dense nose with some honey and orange notes on the palate. Already very drinkable with the acidity not especially noticeable, although presumably it will gain in aromatic complexity with bottle age. I found it less than enthralling when I first tasted it and gave it a score of 16.5 but when I was served a glass blind from my re-stoppered bottle a few days later, I was impressed. So is the lesson, don't rush your pleasures?”
94/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2016 Brut Vintage reveals a complex, gourmand bouquet with aromas of ripe orchard fruits, nectarine, pastry, nuts, sweet spices and ripe white fruits, signs of a warm vintage. Full-bodied, broad and vinous with a fleshy core of fruit, it’s rich and elegant with a penetrating, saline finish. It will drink at its peak in five to 10 years.”
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“Bright fruit, jumps out the glass the Chardonnay richness of yellow fruit backed up o the palate by the red fruit adding the structure. Delicious lemon twist of the tropical with pineapple and guava and apricot and peach coming through from the PN on the palate. Delicious now and for 5+ years. Worth noting the Pol vintage magnums age beautifully.”
“The 2016 vintage resulted in happy surprises after all the numerous viticultural challenges the year brought about. Pol Roger Vintage shows an enticing combination of lush, ripe fruitiness combined to vibrant, energising acidity. The nose greets you with a charming tone of burned match and butter biscuits. Beyond, it comes with a mélange of both crunchy and sun kissed orchard fruit, sweet honey and fragrant orange blossom notes. On the palate it is equally fulfilling in its immediate appeal and juiciness. This is a generous and overt, aromatically sound vintage ready to please, yet it comes with muscle and intensity that rewards midterm ageing. ”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2023
“Very tight, dense nose with some honey and orange notes on the palate. Already very drinkable with the acidity not especially noticeable, although presumably it will gain in aromatic complexity with bottle age. I found it less than enthralling when I first tasted it and gave it a score of 16.5 but when I was served a glass blind from my re-stoppered bottle a few days later, I was impressed. So is the lesson, don't rush your pleasures?”
94/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Nov 2023
“The 2016 Brut Vintage reveals a complex, gourmand bouquet with aromas of ripe orchard fruits, nectarine, pastry, nuts, sweet spices and ripe white fruits, signs of a warm vintage. Full-bodied, broad and vinous with a fleshy core of fruit, it’s rich and elegant with a penetrating, saline finish. It will drink at its peak in five to 10 years.”
17.5+/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“Bright fruit, jumps out the glass the Chardonnay richness of yellow fruit backed up o the palate by the red fruit adding the structure. Delicious lemon twist of the tropical with pineapple and guava and apricot and peach coming through from the PN on the palate. Delicious now and for 5+ years. Worth noting the Pol vintage magnums age beautifully.”
“Very powerful, emphatic nose that suggests the riches to come. Fine mousse. Clean as a whistle. A hint of crème pâtissière with a very crisp, long finish. Super-accessible already – though not for the zero-dosage brigade.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Pol Roger Vintage relies on classic origins: 20 fine crus from the Montagne de Reims and the Côte des Blancs. The nose is sweetly fruity, with ripe orchard fruit, blood orange and even tropical whiffs. There is an earthy vegetal note in the background, typical of the vintage. A fruit bomb on the palate, too, which has lovely volume and zippy freshness. The finish is medium-long, with a degree of earthy mineral austerity. Dosage 7g/l”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2015 Brut Vintage is a very pretty Champagne to drink now and over the next decade or so. Gentle hints of apricot, spice, dried flowers and baked apple tart lend quite a bit of nuance. There’s gorgeous vinous intensity to the 2015 accompanied by a whole range of citrus, floral and chalk overtones that emerge over time, adding brightness as well as cut. All the elements are so nicely balanced. Disgorged: November 2021. Dosage is 7 grams per liter.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2022
“Pol Roger's 2015 Brut Vintage is generous and demonstrative, bursting with aromas of golden orchard fruit, nectarine, warm bread, buttered popcorn and orange oil. Full-bodied, broad and vinous, it's rich and fleshy, with a sweet, layered core of fruit, racy acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse. Stylistically, the 2015 has more in common with the richness and concentration of 2012 than the chiseled raciness of 2013. It's a beautiful bottle in the making.”
“Very powerful, emphatic nose that suggests the riches to come. Fine mousse. Clean as a whistle. A hint of crème pâtissière with a very crisp, long finish. Super-accessible already – though not for the zero-dosage brigade.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Pol Roger Vintage relies on classic origins: 20 fine crus from the Montagne de Reims and the Côte des Blancs. The nose is sweetly fruity, with ripe orchard fruit, blood orange and even tropical whiffs. There is an earthy vegetal note in the background, typical of the vintage. A fruit bomb on the palate, too, which has lovely volume and zippy freshness. The finish is medium-long, with a degree of earthy mineral austerity. Dosage 7g/l”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2015 Brut Vintage is a very pretty Champagne to drink now and over the next decade or so. Gentle hints of apricot, spice, dried flowers and baked apple tart lend quite a bit of nuance. There’s gorgeous vinous intensity to the 2015 accompanied by a whole range of citrus, floral and chalk overtones that emerge over time, adding brightness as well as cut. All the elements are so nicely balanced. Disgorged: November 2021. Dosage is 7 grams per liter.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2022
“Pol Roger's 2015 Brut Vintage is generous and demonstrative, bursting with aromas of golden orchard fruit, nectarine, warm bread, buttered popcorn and orange oil. Full-bodied, broad and vinous, it's rich and fleshy, with a sweet, layered core of fruit, racy acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse. Stylistically, the 2015 has more in common with the richness and concentration of 2012 than the chiseled raciness of 2013. It's a beautiful bottle in the making.”
“Very powerful, emphatic nose that suggests the riches to come. Fine mousse. Clean as a whistle. A hint of crème pâtissière with a very crisp, long finish. Super-accessible already – though not for the zero-dosage brigade.”
More Reviews +
92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Pol Roger Vintage relies on classic origins: 20 fine crus from the Montagne de Reims and the Côte des Blancs. The nose is sweetly fruity, with ripe orchard fruit, blood orange and even tropical whiffs. There is an earthy vegetal note in the background, typical of the vintage. A fruit bomb on the palate, too, which has lovely volume and zippy freshness. The finish is medium-long, with a degree of earthy mineral austerity. Dosage 7g/l”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2015 Brut Vintage is a very pretty Champagne to drink now and over the next decade or so. Gentle hints of apricot, spice, dried flowers and baked apple tart lend quite a bit of nuance. There’s gorgeous vinous intensity to the 2015 accompanied by a whole range of citrus, floral and chalk overtones that emerge over time, adding brightness as well as cut. All the elements are so nicely balanced. Disgorged: November 2021. Dosage is 7 grams per liter.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2022
“Pol Roger's 2015 Brut Vintage is generous and demonstrative, bursting with aromas of golden orchard fruit, nectarine, warm bread, buttered popcorn and orange oil. Full-bodied, broad and vinous, it's rich and fleshy, with a sweet, layered core of fruit, racy acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse. Stylistically, the 2015 has more in common with the richness and concentration of 2012 than the chiseled raciness of 2013. It's a beautiful bottle in the making.”
“The 2013 Vintage is a rich, effusive wine that beautifully captures the personality of the year in which ripeness and acids are both elevated. Pastry, orchard fruit, citrus peel, spice and dried flowers build in an extroverted, racy Champagne that is an absolute delight. Time in the glass brings out a feeling of weightlessness and translucence that is beguiling. As for the obvious next question….yes, I expect the Churchill will be superb.”
More Reviews +
92-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“Medium-deep lemon color. The pronounced nose is still reserved and primary but comes with delicious Pinot Noir fruit. Cranberries, wild strawberries, marshmallow and red apple. Fine intensity and mouthwatering succulence to the palate. Very young still but all pieces at place waiting for further expression. Richly flavored, perfectly clean and long with a sweet, fruity finish.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2020
“Quite a rich nose with come-on appeal – though probably not to a grower-champagne devotee! Firm cooking-apple flavour and apple-skin texture on the palate. Much lighter and more frivolous than the 2012. Just a little light, especially on the finish.”
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Oct 2020
“A beautifully chiseled, incisive wine that will appeal immensely to purists. Unwinding in the glass with scents of citrus zest, white flowers, crushed chalk and hints of fresh sourdoughs, it's medium to full-bodied, racy and precise, with a nicely concentrated and tightly wound core, tangy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. After the rich, muscular 2012 vintage, the 2013 represents quite a contrast; I'm not sure we'll see its stylistic like again for some time, so readers with classically inclined palates will want to stock up—advice I'll be following myself.”
“The 2013 Vintage is a rich, effusive wine that beautifully captures the personality of the year in which ripeness and acids are both elevated. Pastry, orchard fruit, citrus peel, spice and dried flowers build in an extroverted, racy Champagne that is an absolute delight. Time in the glass brings out a feeling of weightlessness and translucence that is beguiling. As for the obvious next question….yes, I expect the Churchill will be superb.”
More Reviews +
92-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2020
“Medium-deep lemon color. The pronounced nose is still reserved and primary but comes with delicious Pinot Noir fruit. Cranberries, wild strawberries, marshmallow and red apple. Fine intensity and mouthwatering succulence to the palate. Very young still but all pieces at place waiting for further expression. Richly flavored, perfectly clean and long with a sweet, fruity finish.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2020
“Quite a rich nose with come-on appeal – though probably not to a grower-champagne devotee! Firm cooking-apple flavour and apple-skin texture on the palate. Much lighter and more frivolous than the 2012. Just a little light, especially on the finish.”
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Oct 2020
“A beautifully chiseled, incisive wine that will appeal immensely to purists. Unwinding in the glass with scents of citrus zest, white flowers, crushed chalk and hints of fresh sourdoughs, it's medium to full-bodied, racy and precise, with a nicely concentrated and tightly wound core, tangy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. After the rich, muscular 2012 vintage, the 2013 represents quite a contrast; I'm not sure we'll see its stylistic like again for some time, so readers with classically inclined palates will want to stock up—advice I'll be following myself.”
“The 2012 Brut Vintage is an attractive, open-knit Champagne that captures the richness and ripeness of the year nicely. Baked apple, wild flowers, mint and brioche give this tasty, inviting Champagne much of its is immediacy and overall appeal, I would prefer to drink it over the next handful of years. Disgorged: February, 2019.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“Quite a rich nose and fairly rich on the palate too. An anti-Extra Brut? Nicely integrated with some lemon syllabub sensation. Not wondrously persistent, and more of a food wine than an aperitif.”
94+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Pol Roger's 2012 Brut Vintage continues to show very well indeed, offering up inviting aromas of citrus oil, crisp yellow orchard fruit, peach, smoke, and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, layered and complete, it's deep and fleshy, with excellent concentration, racy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. I purchased this wine for my own cellar in magnum, and I can't wait to open them a decade from now.”
“The 2012 Brut Vintage is an attractive, open-knit Champagne that captures the richness and ripeness of the year nicely. Baked apple, wild flowers, mint and brioche give this tasty, inviting Champagne much of its is immediacy and overall appeal, I would prefer to drink it over the next handful of years. Disgorged: February, 2019.”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2019
“Quite a rich nose and fairly rich on the palate too. An anti-Extra Brut? Nicely integrated with some lemon syllabub sensation. Not wondrously persistent, and more of a food wine than an aperitif.”
94+/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Mar 2021
“Pol Roger's 2012 Brut Vintage continues to show very well indeed, offering up inviting aromas of citrus oil, crisp yellow orchard fruit, peach, smoke, and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, layered and complete, it's deep and fleshy, with excellent concentration, racy acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. I purchased this wine for my own cellar in magnum, and I can't wait to open them a decade from now.”
“All grands and premiers crus. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. Aged for eight years on the lees. Dosage 7 g/l. Disgorged October 2017.
Tasted blind. Much more depth and complexity on the nose than the other vintage tasted alongside [the 2008]. Real concentration and undertow.
Drink 2019-2026”
More Reviews +
17/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2018
“Rich, creamy nose - super-seductive. Very different from the rigour of the 2008. Come on in, it says. Noticeably ripe and absolutely ready with relatively but not dangerously low acidity. A throat-soother with good undertow and medium body. Neat and friendly.”
“All grands and premiers crus. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. Aged eight years on the lees.. Dosage 7 g/l. Disgorged 17 October 2016.
Tasted blind. Rather simpler nose than the other vintage of Pol Roger tasted alongside [the 2009]. Lots of lemon on the palate – lemon soufflé. Then it falls away a little. Very brisk (a clue ignored?)! 2009?
Drink 2018-2023”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“Tasting at Pol Roger's 175th Birthday Celebration: The 2008 #MagnumEffect has really changed since my last taste, the reductive smoky charm has come forward and the fruit has real ripeness and now coming up for 8 years post disgorgement you see those dried fruits coming forward, dried apple and dried apricot really showing off. The texture is also softening as the 2008 freshness seems to have softened in perception now the fruit has expanded so well. ”
17.5/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2017
“Smoky reductive nose with real depth and lively age. Serious champagne, though at the full price it's quite expensive. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2017
“Lots here. All fired up on all cylinders with fireworks on the palate. Not the driest, but very substantial with minerals and stones dominating. Great zest and length.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“Really quite broad and ripe on the nose with mildly floral notes and a hint of putty. Really very dramatic! Even a hint of marzipan. Creamy texture with a little bruised apple acidity. Admirably long. Really exciting. Is this a worthy successor to the 2002? Dink 2017-2030.”
“All grands and premiers crus. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay. Aged eight years on the lees.. Dosage 7 g/l. Disgorged 17 October 2016.
Tasted blind. Rather simpler nose than the other vintage of Pol Roger tasted alongside [the 2009]. Lots of lemon on the palate – lemon soufflé. Then it falls away a little. Very brisk (a clue ignored?)! 2009?
Drink 2018-2023”
More Reviews +
18/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2024
“Tasting at Pol Roger's 175th Birthday Celebration: The 2008 #MagnumEffect has really changed since my last taste, the reductive smoky charm has come forward and the fruit has real ripeness and now coming up for 8 years post disgorgement you see those dried fruits coming forward, dried apple and dried apricot really showing off. The texture is also softening as the 2008 freshness seems to have softened in perception now the fruit has expanded so well. ”
17.5/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2017
“Smoky reductive nose with real depth and lively age. Serious champagne, though at the full price it's quite expensive. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2017
“Lots here. All fired up on all cylinders with fireworks on the palate. Not the driest, but very substantial with minerals and stones dominating. Great zest and length.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2017
“Really quite broad and ripe on the nose with mildly floral notes and a hint of putty. Really very dramatic! Even a hint of marzipan. Creamy texture with a little bruised apple acidity. Admirably long. Really exciting. Is this a worthy successor to the 2002? Dink 2017-2030.”
“Dense, tightly laced on the nose with real appeal. Some richness on the palate. Very flattering and spreads right across the palate. Fresh and clean. Lingering finish”
More Reviews +
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Aug 2016
“The 2006 Brut Vintage is a dense, powerful wine that is going to need time to fully unwind. A host of apricot pit, chamomile, orange blossom and smoke notes fill out the wine's ample frame effortlessly, but it is the wine's pure weight that stands out most at this stage. The ripeness of the year comes through as the wine continues to flesh out in the glass, but the 2006 is best cellared for at least a few years.”
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2016
“A big wine for Pol Roger vintage. Lots of Pinot opulence and depth coming with a tropical twist and spicy tones. Generous palate and velvety smoothness. Long, muscular, fruity finish. A keeper!”
94/100
Andrew Jefford,
Decanter.com,
Mar 2016
“If Bollinger’s Grande Année 2006 has an autumnal grandeur, the Pol Roger Brut Vintage 2006 is pure springtime: green, sappy, leafy, with just a whisper of bread, powder and talc to sweeten it. This is a Pinot-rich blend in which all overt ‘Pinotness’ has been transmuted into a light, chalky essence and a stony sappiness. Long, searching, deliciously tense — yet ripe, not raw: another superb steel-schooled effort. ”
92/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2015
“The 2006 Brut Vintage is an excellent choice for drinking now, as the flavors are just beginning to show the first signs of development. Peach, apricot, brioche, mint and sweet white flowers open up in a gracious, complex Champagne that is super-expressive today. The weight of Pinot Noir comes through beautifully in the 2006, a resonant and inviting Champagne that hits all the right notes.”
“Magnum. Disgorged January 2015. 60% Pinot Noir, 40% Chardonnay, 15-20% grands crus and premiers crus.
Floral nose, tight knit bead. Quite like the 2006. Fresh and tight and quite rich. Good bite.”
“The 2016 Brut Vintage Cuvée de Réserve Vinothèque is rich, powerful and explosive, with all the radiance that is such a signature of this warm year very much on display. A rush of apricot, chamomile, spice, baked apple tart, lemon confit and marzipan stains the palate. It's another wine in Pol Roger's Vinothèque series that shows how beneficial aging can be. This is the last batch of the original release from 2013.”
“The 2016 Brut Vintage Cuvée de Réserve Vinothèque is rich, powerful and explosive, with all the radiance that is such a signature of this warm year very much on display. A rush of apricot, chamomile, spice, baked apple tart, lemon confit and marzipan stains the palate. It's another wine in Pol Roger's Vinothèque series that shows how beneficial aging can be. This is the last batch of the original release from 2013.”
“The aromatics indicate this has aged so elegantly, bursting with dried fruit, charred pineapple and roasted cashews and zingy grapefruit and apricot. The bubbles are now more soft along with a super velvety texture; so beautiful at this age. Feels like the perfect drinking window. Tasted at Maison.”
“A light golden color with dried pineapple and citrus fruits, as well as honey on the nose. It still shows the richness of the warm growing season in champagne. Full-bodied and dense with spicy ginger, ginseng and orange-peel character. Flavorful finish. Energetic, very spicy and intriguing. Goes on for minutes. Fantastic library release. Very limited.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Mar 2024
“The 2002 Brut Vintage Cuvée de Réserve Vinothèque is a rich, heady wine for the dinner table. All of the exotic intensity of the year comes through in the wine's color and overall flavor intensity. At 22 years of age and with more than a dozen years post-disgorgement, the 2002 is peaking today. Apricot, chamomile, dried flowers, tangerine peel and lightly honeyed notes build in a deep, resonant Champagne endowed with notable beauty. I especially like the way this gains freshness with aeration.”
“The 2000 Brut Vintage Cuvée de Réserve Vinothèque is another gorgeous wine from Pol Roger's new Vinothèque program. It offers up scents of lemon confit, marzipan, burnt sugar, spice and baked apple tart. Rich and creamy, the 2000 has aged impeccably.”
More Reviews +
95/100
James Suckling,
jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“A library release with aromas of dried citrus, gunpowder and orange peel. Full-bodied with a dense and intense palate that is rich and flavorful. Layers of fruit, together with spices, lemon curd and peel. Fine bubbles. Drink now.”
“Pol Roger Blanc de Blancs 2002 - White flowers, lemon, slate and chamomile are some of the notes that burst from the glass in Pol Rogers 2002 Brut Blanc de Blancs Extra Cuvee de Reserve. A bright, tightly coiled wine, the 2002 comes across as quite fresh and vibrant, especially within the context of the year. Sweet floral and minty notes run through the precise, crystalline finish. Although the 2002 is absolutely delicious today, I am intrigued to see how it might age. It is utterly brilliant today.”
More Reviews +
93/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Nov 2012
“Pol Roger Blanc de Blancs 2002 - Firm, with a toasty base mixing with flavors of quince paste, pastry, dried apricot, raw almond and a hint of lemon curd. There's a clean -cut note of minerally salinity throughout, accompanied by a fine bead and a lingering finish.”
95/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Nov 2012
“Pol Roger Blanc de Blancs 2002 - Pale gold. Intense, mineral-dominated aromas of candied citrus fruits, pear, anise, smoky lees and chamomile, plus a sexy floral nuance and a hint of sweet butter. Palate-staining orchard and citrus fruit flavors show outstanding depth and energy, picking up chalky mineral and spice notes with air. Strikingly concentrated and precise wine with strong finishing punch and noteworthy persistence. This concentrated, deftly balanced Champagne is built for a long, graceful evolution.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Dec 2012
“Pol Roger Brut Vintage 2002 - Exuberant, yet graceful overall, with rich notes of ripe pineapple, guava, honey and baked peach mixing with a minerally undertow and accents of grated ginger, biscuit and fresh quince. Mouthwatering finish.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2012
“Pol Roger Brut Vintage 2002 - Pol Rogers 2002 Brut Extra Cuvee de Reserve is rich, creamy and seductive. An expressive, layered wine, the 2002 impresses for its overall harmony and balance. Light floral honey, mint, tangerine, cinnamon and dried pears are all woven together in this gracious, impeccable Champagne. This is a fairly reserved style for the year, but it works.”
93/100
Josh Reynolds,
International Wine Cellar,
Nov 2012
“Pol Roger Brut Vintage 2002 - Light gold. Vibrant, mineral-accented aromas of citrus fruits, quince and white flowers, along with subtle sea salt and iodine nuances and slow-building toastiness. Sappy, penetrating and pure, offering assertive Meyer lemon and pear flavors and complicating notes of anise and ginger. I'd have guessed that there was more chardonnay in here. Finishes with outstanding clarity and thrust, leaving a spicy quality behind.”
92/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Dec 2011
“Pol Roger Rosé 2002 - A floral rose, with a smoky undercurrent to subtle flavors of ripe plum, blackberry and black cherry. Mouthwatering acidity and fine texture steer this to the focused finish.”
94/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2011
“Pol Roger Rosé 2002 - From the great 2002 vintage, this is a beautiful structured wine, packed with a fine texture of red berries, intense acidity as well as richness. Intense, complex wine that could well age.”
19.5/20
Tom Stevenson,
Decanter,
Nov 2011
“Pol Roger Rosé 2002 - I had great difficulty tasting this: every time I went to spit it out, I swallowed it! It was so moreish, I couldnt help myself. Exquisite pale peach colour, sublime mousse, tantalising fruit, so yummy yet so classy how on earth do they do that? The 2002 is a ros of extraordinary finesse.”
“This Pol Rose has the full rich strong pink colouring and the aromatics are a combination of bright red fruits like raspberry and redcurrant, mixed with dark cherry and plum. Super attractive aromatics with a cool feel with hints of chalky charm. The palate is richly textured, bundles of fruit and a verticality with precision and great balancing of acidity. A great example of a 2019, has the ripeness of fruit with a core of chalky acidity on the finish.”
“The 2018 Brut Rosé opens to a superb bouquet revealing scents of plums, red berries, pastry, almond, mandarin orange and lemon oil complemented by classy autolytic notes. On the palate, this remarkable rosé has a tauter and more fine-boned texture than usual, which is enhanced by bright acids and a chalky, saline finish. It requires patience to realize all its potential.”
More Reviews +
95/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Nov 2023
“If you like Burgundian pinot noir reds then you should love this very winey and structured rosé champagne, with its zesty blood orange freshness. And, in spite of this it is very refreshing with a complex spicy finish. Good potential. ”
92+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Generous and demonstrative, shaped by the warm, early-ripening growing season, Pol Roger's 2018 Brut Rosé, disgorged in July 2024 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, bursts from the glass with a pretty bouquet of raspberry, cranberry and rose water, mingling with brioche and honeysuckle. On the palate, it reveals a full-bodied, broad-shouldered and textural profile, structured and vibrant, boasting a dense core of luscious fruit. A pillowy mousse and ripe yet lively acidity lend energy, guiding it toward a long, perfumed finish. Comprising 65% Pinot Noir and 35% Chardonnay, this is a gastronomic rosé Champagne, built to age gracefully and pair beautifully with dishes such as red meat or tuna.”
“Fleshy and dramatic, Pol Roger's 2015 Brut Rosé bursts with aromas of plums, red berries, blanched almonds and subtle hints of tangerine oil. On the palate, it's full-bodied, broad and enveloping, with an elegantly muscular, vinous profile, its fleshy core of fruit girdled by bright acids and delicately chalky structuring extract. This is an especially gastronomic rosé from this house, and it should age with style given its concentration and depth.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Mar 2022
“A lively rosé, offering wild strawberry and cherry fruit flavors that are ripe and expressive, with notes of blood orange peel, graphite and leafy herbs serving as a pleasing counterpoint to the sweet fruit. Well-cut and focused, with a fine, lively bead and a minerally, smoke- and spice-laced finish. Drink now”
94/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Mar 2022
“Pol Roger does not produce any non-vintage rosé. The 2015 Champagne Vintage Brut Rosé is structured and noble. The color is a deeply concentrated pink hue, and the wine is fragrant with fresh and dried herbs, wild raspberry, red flowers, and pepper spice. Dry and structured, this is a gastronomic rosé with a stiff upper lip. It is expressive, with savory notes of dried herbs, wild strawberry, and tangerine, along with a chalky texture and present tannins. This wine will benefit from time in bottle and continue to mature, bringing out more of its savory qualities and tertiary spice. Best After 2024”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2015 Brut Rosé is compelling. Far from an easygoing Champagne, the 2015 Rosé possesses striking depth and layers of fruit that open beautifully with a bit of time in the glass. Crushed flowers, raspberry, blood orange, mint and spice all run through a substantial, super-expressive Rosé from Pol Roger that is ideally suited to the dinner table. Disgorged: November 2021. Dosage is 7 grams per liter.”
93/100
Roger Voss,
wineenthusiast.com,
Mar 2022
“This rich Champagne highlights ripe Pinot Noir that glories in its red fruits and structure. Just ready to drink, the wine has intensity and well-textured acidity at the end.”
“Deeper-flavoured than the 2018 regular vintage wine. As rich but with more marked acidity. Very vibrant with more energy than many 2018 champagnes. But, unlike some 7-year-old versions of this wine, it's already delightfully approachable. Very long.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2025
“The 2018 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is an elegant, polished wine very much in the gracious, lighter style of the year. Subtle citrus inflections, white peach, flowers, mint and white pepper are all beautifully delineated in the glass. Clean mineral notes infuse the vibrant finish. This is an especially airy Churchill, a Champagne built more on finesse and persistence than size. ”
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2024
“Richness of citrus and layers of pear, apricot, peach and quince with a soft creamy lees texture and hints of tropical on the finish. Shorter lees time works really well on 2018. Currently freshness and lightness dominate, with time complexities will build further layers. These champagnes from hot vintages like 2018 can often surprise, this has bright acidity, largerly because it is grapes from Grand Cru villages, which are all on the chalky slopes, this gives them a very different minerality and low pH which results in wines from hot years having plenty of freshness.”
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Disgorged in June 2024 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, Pol Roger’s 2018 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill introduces itself with aromas of ripe pear, candied tangerine peel and peach mingling with dried fruit. On the palate, it is full-bodied, vinous and broad-shouldered, with a rich core of fruit and an ample, textural mid-palate, underpinned by ripe yet vibrant acidity. The wine concludes with a long, enveloping finish. Reflective of the warm growing season with a late-August harvest, this is a giving Sir Winston Churchill—undeniably in the more muscular register, with ample gourmand flesh and a presently blocky density that will reward some patience.”
“Deeper-flavoured than the 2018 regular vintage wine. As rich but with more marked acidity. Very vibrant with more energy than many 2018 champagnes. But, unlike some 7-year-old versions of this wine, it's already delightfully approachable. Very long.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2025
“The 2018 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is an elegant, polished wine very much in the gracious, lighter style of the year. Subtle citrus inflections, white peach, flowers, mint and white pepper are all beautifully delineated in the glass. Clean mineral notes infuse the vibrant finish. This is an especially airy Churchill, a Champagne built more on finesse and persistence than size. ”
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2024
“Richness of citrus and layers of pear, apricot, peach and quince with a soft creamy lees texture and hints of tropical on the finish. Shorter lees time works really well on 2018. Currently freshness and lightness dominate, with time complexities will build further layers. These champagnes from hot vintages like 2018 can often surprise, this has bright acidity, largerly because it is grapes from Grand Cru villages, which are all on the chalky slopes, this gives them a very different minerality and low pH which results in wines from hot years having plenty of freshness.”
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Disgorged in June 2024 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, Pol Roger’s 2018 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill introduces itself with aromas of ripe pear, candied tangerine peel and peach mingling with dried fruit. On the palate, it is full-bodied, vinous and broad-shouldered, with a rich core of fruit and an ample, textural mid-palate, underpinned by ripe yet vibrant acidity. The wine concludes with a long, enveloping finish. Reflective of the warm growing season with a late-August harvest, this is a giving Sir Winston Churchill—undeniably in the more muscular register, with ample gourmand flesh and a presently blocky density that will reward some patience.”
“Deeper-flavoured than the 2018 regular vintage wine. As rich but with more marked acidity. Very vibrant with more energy than many 2018 champagnes. But, unlike some 7-year-old versions of this wine, it's already delightfully approachable. Very long.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2025
“The 2018 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is an elegant, polished wine very much in the gracious, lighter style of the year. Subtle citrus inflections, white peach, flowers, mint and white pepper are all beautifully delineated in the glass. Clean mineral notes infuse the vibrant finish. This is an especially airy Churchill, a Champagne built more on finesse and persistence than size. ”
18.5/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2024
“Richness of citrus and layers of pear, apricot, peach and quince with a soft creamy lees texture and hints of tropical on the finish. Shorter lees time works really well on 2018. Currently freshness and lightness dominate, with time complexities will build further layers. These champagnes from hot vintages like 2018 can often surprise, this has bright acidity, largerly because it is grapes from Grand Cru villages, which are all on the chalky slopes, this gives them a very different minerality and low pH which results in wines from hot years having plenty of freshness.”
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Disgorged in June 2024 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, Pol Roger’s 2018 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill introduces itself with aromas of ripe pear, candied tangerine peel and peach mingling with dried fruit. On the palate, it is full-bodied, vinous and broad-shouldered, with a rich core of fruit and an ample, textural mid-palate, underpinned by ripe yet vibrant acidity. The wine concludes with a long, enveloping finish. Reflective of the warm growing season with a late-August harvest, this is a giving Sir Winston Churchill—undeniably in the more muscular register, with ample gourmand flesh and a presently blocky density that will reward some patience.”
“Deep golden straw colour. Full-bodied, meaty nose with lots of impact. Lovely, filigree mousse – very well judged for its impact on the palate. Flavours reach every bit of the palate. Quite a charmer! Definitely already approachable – in fact it tastes as though it would already have been pretty nice last year! A fine, succulent representative of this dry, ripe year. Pretty gorgeous actually. Maybe it won't be the longest-lasting Churchill but it's hugely satisfying now.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Feb 2023
“The 2015 Brut Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill shows off the savory side of the vintage to great effect. Hints of dried pear, sage, mint, dried flowers, lemon oil and chamomile open gradually in this mid-weight, lithe edition of Pol Roger’s tête de cuvée. The 2015 unfolds nicely with time in the glass, but I wouldn’t think of opening a bottle anytime soon. Reads will find a nervy Winston Churchill marked by notable freshness and vigor more than size. This is a fine effort in a vintage that has proven to be far trickier than most observers originally envisioned. Dosage is 7 grams per litre. Disgorged September 2022.”
94+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2023
“A strong effort in a less-acclaimed vintage, Pol Roger's newly released 2015 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill opens in the glass with aromas of confit citrus, ripe orchard fruits and dried white flowers mingled with hints of honeycomb, freshly baked bread and anise. Medium to full-bodied, vinous and concentrated, with bright acids, chalky structuring extract and a pinpoint mousse, this inherently rather rich, gastronomic Champagne is quite tightly wound out of the gates and will reward a bit of bottle age. Stylistically, it is somewhat reminiscent of a modern-day version of the 1985.”
“Deep golden straw colour. Full-bodied, meaty nose with lots of impact. Lovely, filigree mousse – very well judged for its impact on the palate. Flavours reach every bit of the palate. Quite a charmer! Definitely already approachable – in fact it tastes as though it would already have been pretty nice last year! A fine, succulent representative of this dry, ripe year. Pretty gorgeous actually. Maybe it won't be the longest-lasting Churchill but it's hugely satisfying now.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Feb 2023
“The 2015 Brut Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill shows off the savory side of the vintage to great effect. Hints of dried pear, sage, mint, dried flowers, lemon oil and chamomile open gradually in this mid-weight, lithe edition of Pol Roger’s tête de cuvée. The 2015 unfolds nicely with time in the glass, but I wouldn’t think of opening a bottle anytime soon. Reads will find a nervy Winston Churchill marked by notable freshness and vigor more than size. This is a fine effort in a vintage that has proven to be far trickier than most observers originally envisioned. Dosage is 7 grams per litre. Disgorged September 2022.”
94+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2023
“A strong effort in a less-acclaimed vintage, Pol Roger's newly released 2015 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill opens in the glass with aromas of confit citrus, ripe orchard fruits and dried white flowers mingled with hints of honeycomb, freshly baked bread and anise. Medium to full-bodied, vinous and concentrated, with bright acids, chalky structuring extract and a pinpoint mousse, this inherently rather rich, gastronomic Champagne is quite tightly wound out of the gates and will reward a bit of bottle age. Stylistically, it is somewhat reminiscent of a modern-day version of the 1985.”
“Deep golden straw colour. Full-bodied, meaty nose with lots of impact. Lovely, filigree mousse – very well judged for its impact on the palate. Flavours reach every bit of the palate. Quite a charmer! Definitely already approachable – in fact it tastes as though it would already have been pretty nice last year! A fine, succulent representative of this dry, ripe year. Pretty gorgeous actually. Maybe it won't be the longest-lasting Churchill but it's hugely satisfying now.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Feb 2023
“The 2015 Brut Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill shows off the savory side of the vintage to great effect. Hints of dried pear, sage, mint, dried flowers, lemon oil and chamomile open gradually in this mid-weight, lithe edition of Pol Roger’s tête de cuvée. The 2015 unfolds nicely with time in the glass, but I wouldn’t think of opening a bottle anytime soon. Reads will find a nervy Winston Churchill marked by notable freshness and vigor more than size. This is a fine effort in a vintage that has proven to be far trickier than most observers originally envisioned. Dosage is 7 grams per litre. Disgorged September 2022.”
94+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Feb 2023
“A strong effort in a less-acclaimed vintage, Pol Roger's newly released 2015 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill opens in the glass with aromas of confit citrus, ripe orchard fruits and dried white flowers mingled with hints of honeycomb, freshly baked bread and anise. Medium to full-bodied, vinous and concentrated, with bright acids, chalky structuring extract and a pinpoint mousse, this inherently rather rich, gastronomic Champagne is quite tightly wound out of the gates and will reward a bit of bottle age. Stylistically, it is somewhat reminiscent of a modern-day version of the 1985.”
“The 2013 Brut Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is fabulous. Rich and remarkably pure, the 2013 is super- expressive right out of the gate. Bright saline notes cut through a core of lemon confit, dried flowers, apricot, tangerine peel, mint and sage. As compelling as the 2013 is, it really needs more time to open a bit. There is a feeling of transparency here that is so alluring. The 2013 is a terrific example of power with no excess weight in Champagne. I loved it.”
More Reviews +
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2013 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill has turned out especially well, wafting from the glass with aromas of orange oil, confit lemon and crisp golden orchard fruit, complemented by subtle hints of brioche and clear honey. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and seamless, with a deep core of fruit, bright acids and a beautifully refined mousse, this is an elegant, penetrating rendition of Churchill that stands out for its charm and effortlessness. ”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2013 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill continues to show beautifully, wafting from the glass with aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, mandarin oil, freshly baked bread and pastry cream. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and precise, it's deep and vinous, with a racy spine of an acidity and a tensile but relatively charming profile that means it's already approachable. In style, the 2013 is in contrast with the broader, fleshier 2012, but the two vintages are very close in ultimate quality.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2022
“It's a (still youthful) wine with wonderful tension, freshness and real drive. This should make a sumptuous wine when it sheds its most youthful acidity. Great density and still to unfurl completely. Drink 2022 – 2036”
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Bright lemon colour. The soft nose is a charmer, with vanilla-laden ripe orchard fruit and orange peel, but also some darker, spicier tones. There are both rich, yeasty notes and brioche layers and an elegant, crystalline quality to the fruit on the palate. Acidity is accentuated, which makes up for a more agile and linear Churchill than we are used to. The hallmark silkiness and concentration are there. This is a particularly elegant vintage, worthy of cellaring. As usual, the varietal composition is not disclosed but kept as a family secret. Dosage 7g/l”
“This #Jeroboam has the distinct smoky gunflint charm and beautiful restraint of fruit from the cool and late October grape harvest. There is ripeness from the Chardonnay showing in rich lemon and grapefruit and undertones of riper fruits like guava and charred grilled pineapple. The Pinot Noir comes through on the palate with bundles of apricot, pear, dark cherry and peach. The texture is rich and full, velvety with a stunning fresh saline finish that leaves the palate wanting another mouthful! Although it is youthful and stunning already this would be more complex from 2030 to 2040”
More Reviews +
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2023
“The 2013 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill continues to show beautifully, wafting from the glass with aromas of crisp yellow orchard fruit, mandarin oil, freshly baked bread and pastry cream. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and precise, it's deep and vinous, with a racy spine of an acidity and a tensile but relatively charming profile that means it's already approachable. In style, the 2013 is in contrast with the broader, fleshier 2012, but the two vintages are very close in ultimate quality.”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2022
“It's a (still youthful) wine with wonderful tension, freshness and real drive. This should make a sumptuous wine when it sheds its most youthful acidity. Great density and still to unfurl completely. Drink 2022 – 2036”
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Bright lemon colour. The soft nose is a charmer, with vanilla-laden ripe orchard fruit and orange peel, but also some darker, spicier tones. There are both rich, yeasty notes and brioche layers and an elegant, crystalline quality to the fruit on the palate. Acidity is accentuated, which makes up for a more agile and linear Churchill than we are used to. The hallmark silkiness and concentration are there. This is a particularly elegant vintage, worthy of cellaring. As usual, the varietal composition is not disclosed but kept as a family secret. Dosage 7g/l”
97/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2013 Brut Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is fabulous. Rich and remarkably pure, the 2013 is super- expressive right out of the gate. Bright saline notes cut through a core of lemon confit, dried flowers, apricot, tangerine peel, mint and sage. As compelling as the 2013 is, it really needs more time to open a bit. There is a feeling of transparency here that is so alluring. The 2013 is a terrific example of power with no excess weight in Champagne. I loved it.”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Mar 2022
“The 2013 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill has turned out especially well, wafting from the glass with aromas of orange oil, confit lemon and crisp golden orchard fruit, complemented by subtle hints of brioche and clear honey. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and seamless, with a deep core of fruit, bright acids and a beautifully refined mousse, this is an elegant, penetrating rendition of Churchill that stands out for its charm and effortlessness. ”
“Pol Roger's flagship Brut Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is fabulous in 2012. Rich, open-knit and seductive, the 2012 will drink well right out of the gate, although it certainly has the pedigree to age well for decades. Lemon confit, chamomile, dried flowers, mint, spice and a kick of brioche infuse the 2012 with notable textural richness and resonance. Time in the glass brings out gorgeous aromatic lift to round things out. The 2012 is classy and polished all the way.”
More Reviews +
96+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2021
“Pol Roger's newly released 2012 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is showing brilliantly, bursting from the glass with youthful aromas of honeyed pears, toasted brioche, pomelo, fresh pastry, green apple and mandarin orange, with hints of stone fruit emerging with time in the glass. Full-bodied, vinous and textural, with an enveloping core of fleshy, concentrated fruit, bright acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse, it concludes with a long, penetrating finish. More muscular and vibrant than the generous and charming 2009, the 2012 ranks alongside the 2008 and 2002 as one of the three finest renditions of Sir Winston Churchill this millennium—and in style it resembles a hypothetical blend of those two vintages.
Pol Roger releases the 2012 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill this week, so in the interests of timeliness, I'm publishing this tasting note in advance of a substantial Champagne report slated for later this month. In that report, readers can look forward to—inter alia—reviews of Pol Roger's other current releases. But in the meantime, this superb 2012 merits serious attention. Drink: 2022 - 2045”
17++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“Admirably modest bottle weight and packaging for a de luxe champagne. Bravo, Pol Roger! (It might not win a prize for the design but it's not an extra burden on the planet.) All grand cru fruit and, most unusually, all hand-riddled. 'The must undergoes two débourbages (settlings), one at the press house immediately after pressing and the second, a débourbage à froid, in stainless steel tanks at 6 °C over a 24-hour period. A slow, cool fermentation with the temperature kept under 18 °C takes place in stainless steel with each variety and each village kept separate. The wine undergoes a full malolactic fermentation prior to final blending. Secondary fermentation takes place in bottle at 9 °C in the deepest Pol Roger cellars (33 metres below street level) where the wine is kept until it undergoes remuage (riddling) by hand, a rarity in Champagne.'
Rather open on the nose – a surprise! Looser textured than some and still decidedly embryonic. It does open out rather remarkably on the finish, suggesting that it is very much a long-distance runner. I think I would wait until at least 2022 to take full advantage of that interplay of flavours underneath, where it is positively throbbing!”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2021
“Medium-deep lemon-gold colour. Soft and overt nose of spicy, yeasty complexity meeting a lovely charred gunpowdery whiff. Crisp pristine fruitiness of ripe yellow apple, baked pear, candied lemon and vanilla, developing tropical nuances. The palate echoes the 2012 vintage’s hallmark vivacity, but is mellow, round and textured, as Winston ought to be. There is instant charm and drinkability to this well-built wine that finishes with a refreshing chalky-mineral bite. A fine Sir Winston vintage.”
Sir Winston Churchill was a close friend of the Pol Roger family, prompting the house to name their prestige cuvée after him. The great man himself, once commented: “My tastes are simple, I am easily satisfied with the best.”
95/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Creaminess on the nose is immediately evident, segueing into a lovely note of dry corn husk and salty shortbread with an echo of ripe Mirabelle. The palate continues with the same creaminess and a shortcrust vibe, smooth, billowing, almost mellow – but then there is the lovely and bright freshness that is sunny but brisk. It is the saltiness and a hint of oystershell that keeps pulling you back to this understated but really complex wine. Lovely now, certain to evolve.”
“Pol Roger's flagship Brut Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is fabulous in 2012. Rich, open-knit and seductive, the 2012 will drink well right out of the gate, although it certainly has the pedigree to age well for decades. Lemon confit, chamomile, dried flowers, mint, spice and a kick of brioche infuse the 2012 with notable textural richness and resonance. Time in the glass brings out gorgeous aromatic lift to round things out. The 2012 is classy and polished all the way.”
More Reviews +
96+/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Mar 2021
“Pol Roger's newly released 2012 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is showing brilliantly, bursting from the glass with youthful aromas of honeyed pears, toasted brioche, pomelo, fresh pastry, green apple and mandarin orange, with hints of stone fruit emerging with time in the glass. Full-bodied, vinous and textural, with an enveloping core of fleshy, concentrated fruit, bright acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse, it concludes with a long, penetrating finish. More muscular and vibrant than the generous and charming 2009, the 2012 ranks alongside the 2008 and 2002 as one of the three finest renditions of Sir Winston Churchill this millennium—and in style it resembles a hypothetical blend of those two vintages.
Pol Roger releases the 2012 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill this week, so in the interests of timeliness, I'm publishing this tasting note in advance of a substantial Champagne report slated for later this month. In that report, readers can look forward to—inter alia—reviews of Pol Roger's other current releases. But in the meantime, this superb 2012 merits serious attention. Drink: 2022 - 2045”
17++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“Admirably modest bottle weight and packaging for a de luxe champagne. Bravo, Pol Roger! (It might not win a prize for the design but it's not an extra burden on the planet.) All grand cru fruit and, most unusually, all hand-riddled. 'The must undergoes two débourbages (settlings), one at the press house immediately after pressing and the second, a débourbage à froid, in stainless steel tanks at 6 °C over a 24-hour period. A slow, cool fermentation with the temperature kept under 18 °C takes place in stainless steel with each variety and each village kept separate. The wine undergoes a full malolactic fermentation prior to final blending. Secondary fermentation takes place in bottle at 9 °C in the deepest Pol Roger cellars (33 metres below street level) where the wine is kept until it undergoes remuage (riddling) by hand, a rarity in Champagne.'
Rather open on the nose – a surprise! Looser textured than some and still decidedly embryonic. It does open out rather remarkably on the finish, suggesting that it is very much a long-distance runner. I think I would wait until at least 2022 to take full advantage of that interplay of flavours underneath, where it is positively throbbing!”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2021
“Medium-deep lemon-gold colour. Soft and overt nose of spicy, yeasty complexity meeting a lovely charred gunpowdery whiff. Crisp pristine fruitiness of ripe yellow apple, baked pear, candied lemon and vanilla, developing tropical nuances. The palate echoes the 2012 vintage’s hallmark vivacity, but is mellow, round and textured, as Winston ought to be. There is instant charm and drinkability to this well-built wine that finishes with a refreshing chalky-mineral bite. A fine Sir Winston vintage.”
Sir Winston Churchill was a close friend of the Pol Roger family, prompting the house to name their prestige cuvée after him. The great man himself, once commented: “My tastes are simple, I am easily satisfied with the best.”
95/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Creaminess on the nose is immediately evident, segueing into a lovely note of dry corn husk and salty shortbread with an echo of ripe Mirabelle. The palate continues with the same creaminess and a shortcrust vibe, smooth, billowing, almost mellow – but then there is the lovely and bright freshness that is sunny but brisk. It is the saltiness and a hint of oystershell that keeps pulling you back to this understated but really complex wine. Lovely now, certain to evolve.”
“A few years after its disgorgment now, the 2009 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill has digested its dosage and is beginning to offer up real complexity. Mingling aromas of freshly baked bread, honeycomb, crisp peach, pear and subtle hints of dried fruits, it's medium to full-bodied, sapid and vinous, with bright acids, a pearly mousse and a long, saline finish. Exhibiting more structure than was apparent on release, this has always been a very approachable Churchill, yet it is really benefiting from age.”
More Reviews +
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Apr 2020
“Pol Roger's 2009 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill has turned out very well, offering up a demonstrative bouquet of golden apples, clear honey, hazelnuts and fresh pastry that's still quite primary. Full-bodied, fleshy and textural, it's deep and concentrated, with an ample core of fruit, ripe but racy acids, a pinpoint mousse and a long, penetrating finish. This is an expressive, deceptively immediate rendition of this bottling, yet despite its charm out of the gates, readers willing to wait at least five years will be rewarded with significant additional complexity.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Mar 2020
“Particularly strong apples on the nose – even Golden Delicious, a variety I haven’t tasted in a while. Creamy texture and a slightly sweeter, certainly riper, impression than more typical vintages – certainly much fuller and more welcoming than the 2008. Like a liqueur version of Epernay character! But this wine is no simpleton; it really builds on the palate to a dramatically long finish. Powerful! Very friendly rather than stern and Churchillian. As Hubert de Billy says, the 2008 Churchill is for collectors, the 2009 is for drinkers.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2020
“The 2009 Brut Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill is a heady, explosive Champagne. Ample and deep, the Churchill is so expressive today. Apricot, tangerine oil, mint, baked apple tart and spice all flesh out. I would give the 2009 at least a year or two in bottle, as it is a bit tight at this stage. Even so, time in the glass brings out a feeling of raw power that is impossible to miss. ”
“Bright golden yellow, silver reflections, persistent, fine bubbly mousse. Nuances of dried apricots underlaid with a touch of honey and sponge cake, notes of pickled cherries and a hint of nougat. Juicy, creamy texture, well-integrated fruit expression, lively acidity, lingers on the palate, pastry and subtle dried fruit notes on the finish, great ageing potential.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Disgorged November 2016. To be launched end of September 2017. Mainly Pinot Noir.
Deep with impressively lively and tiny bead. Very intense with a fresh mint note. Round and magnificent. Excellent freshness. Impossible to spit. Beautiful balance. Satin-textured. Not as cigar-fumed as some vintages! A little mushroomy.
Drink 2016-2030”
95/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Nov 2017
“Some reductive meaty notes of bacon fat and flint, with lemon cream and butter too, as well as a light forest berry edge and toasted hazelnuts. The palate has attractive lemon citrus cream flavor. Super pure, there's power amongst the charm. This is a great '06.”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Sep 2017
“This dances gracefully on the palate, with rich and expressive flavors of peach tart, raspberry sorbet, candied ginger and orange peel, and sleek acidity that leaves a mouthwatering impression on the satiny finish. Drink now through 2031.”
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2017
“Rich evolved nose of ripe, sun-kissed fruit. Overt and sweetly fruity with pastry and baked apple. Full-on winey and round. Big plush style with some oxidative tones. Long and succulent with great concentration. Big, fleshy, even chewy, bold palate. ”
93/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“Made in the very best vintages, Pol Roger's white-golden colored 2006 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill offers a very clear, precise, ripe and complex bouquet with fruity and refreshingly chalky, nutty and brioche notes. Full-bodied and complex on the palate, the 2006 is supple, round and rich but also fine, elegant, fresh and well structured. It has a harmonious yet tight, persistent and very promising finish that puts this silky textured, Pinot-dominated cuvée (the exact blend is a closely guarded family secret) on the border of fatty richness. But the mousse gives so much freshness and finesse that everything seems lifted here. Though I have very limited experience with matured Champagnes from Pol Roger and namely Churchill, I suppose the 2006 will benefit a lot from further bottle aging. But don't get me wrong: the wine is already gorgeous. Tasted June 2018, disgorged in June 2017.”
“Magnum. Lighter weight than the 2002 in magnum but a pretty impressive savoury, minerally champagne that seems a bit drier than the Churchill norm and is suitably deep-flavoured. Notably persistent. Drink 2014 – 2028”
More Reviews +
96/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2017
“Bright golden yellow, silver reflections, persistent, fine bubbly mousse. Nuances of dried apricots underlaid with a touch of honey and sponge cake, notes of pickled cherries and a hint of nougat. Juicy, creamy texture, well-integrated fruit expression, lively acidity, lingers on the palate, pastry and subtle dried fruit notes on the finish, great ageing potential.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Disgorged November 2016. To be launched end of September 2017. Mainly Pinot Noir.
Deep with impressively lively and tiny bead. Very intense with a fresh mint note. Round and magnificent. Excellent freshness. Impossible to spit. Beautiful balance. Satin-textured. Not as cigar-fumed as some vintages! A little mushroomy.
Drink 2016-2030”
95/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Nov 2017
“Some reductive meaty notes of bacon fat and flint, with lemon cream and butter too, as well as a light forest berry edge and toasted hazelnuts. The palate has attractive lemon citrus cream flavor. Super pure, there's power amongst the charm. This is a great '06.”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
Sep 2017
“This dances gracefully on the palate, with rich and expressive flavors of peach tart, raspberry sorbet, candied ginger and orange peel, and sleek acidity that leaves a mouthwatering impression on the satiny finish. Drink now through 2031.”
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2017
“Rich evolved nose of ripe, sun-kissed fruit. Overt and sweetly fruity with pastry and baked apple. Full-on winey and round. Big plush style with some oxidative tones. Long and succulent with great concentration. Big, fleshy, even chewy, bold palate. ”
93/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“Made in the very best vintages, Pol Roger's white-golden colored 2006 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill offers a very clear, precise, ripe and complex bouquet with fruity and refreshingly chalky, nutty and brioche notes. Full-bodied and complex on the palate, the 2006 is supple, round and rich but also fine, elegant, fresh and well structured. It has a harmonious yet tight, persistent and very promising finish that puts this silky textured, Pinot-dominated cuvée (the exact blend is a closely guarded family secret) on the border of fatty richness. But the mousse gives so much freshness and finesse that everything seems lifted here. Though I have very limited experience with matured Champagnes from Pol Roger and namely Churchill, I suppose the 2006 will benefit a lot from further bottle aging. But don't get me wrong: the wine is already gorgeous. Tasted June 2018, disgorged in June 2017.”
“Tasted blind. Mytik cork. Deep gold. Deep and rich on the nose and very appealing. Tightly laced with a tiny bead. Some savoury notes with a suggestion of gunflint. Real race and pace.”
More Reviews +
92-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Sep 2016
“Strong, creamy and toasty nose with prominent Pinot power. Ripe fruit profile with an oxidative touch and plenty of robustness and vinosity. Surprisingly mature already lacking firmess and spine. Rich oily smooth palate and long, concentrated finish. ”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Very deep orangey straw. Lots of tension and autolysis on the nose and then it’s so introvert that it almost disappears on the palate. But there is so much that’s exclusive to champagne to enjoy here. Tingling! Slightly bitter. Interesting bitter-orange notes. Quite distinctive.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Aug 2016
“The flagship 2004 Brut Sir Winston Churchill is creamy, ample and highly expressive, but it is also a bit more forward than I expected for the vintage. Apricot jam, honey, spice, smoke, brioche and lovely hints of toastiness all add to the wine's considerable appeal, while there is no shortage of density or volume. All that said, the wine's balance is not as fine as I had hoped it would be. Perhaps a bit more time in bottle will do the trick. To be sure, the 2004 Churchill is more advanced than most other tête de cuvées in this vintage.”
94/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Dec 2015
“Refined and lacy, this vibrant Champagne shows rich mineral character and ripe flavors of baked plum, spun honey, brioche and lemon curd, set in an elegant, finely meshed framework. Drink now through 2029. ”
97/100
Roger Voss,
Wine Enthusiast,
Dec 2015
“Following on from the great 2002 vintage of this wine, the 2004 is equally memorable. It is a magnificent wine, structured and beautifully balanced between the ripe white fruits and the tight texture that will allow it to age many years. While drinkable now, it is still young at 11 years, still with great potential. Drink now, until 2024, and probably beyond.”
98/100
Stephen Brook,
Decanter,
Nov 2015
“Dense grilled nuts nose, backward and youthful, and shows aromatic depth at the expense of immediate charm. The palate is rich, broad, and weighty, very concentrated, achieving a majestic style that’s biscuitty and powerful. Although accessible now it will certainly improve with more bottle age that will allow the flavours to unfurl. Long.”
“The 2002 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Vinothèque is such a classic wine for the vintage. Explosive and opulent to the core, the 2022 is seriously impressive. Baked apple tart, chamomile, acacia honey, hazelnut, coffee and orange confit stain the palate. Plush, generous contours wrap it all together in style. This is what 2002 is all about. Disgorged: January 2015.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Pol Roger’s 2002 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Vinothèque—a late release of the same original disgorgement (January 2015, with a dosage of eight grams per liter)—has matured gracefully, opening with a deep bouquet of orange zest, Mirabelle plum and burnt sugar, mingled with dried fruit and a faint hint of gunpowder. On the palate, it is full-bodied and layered, with notable musculature and flesh supported by a racy spine of acidity and ample tension. The wine concludes with a long, enveloping finish marked by a delicate saline nuance.”
“The 2002 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Vinothèque is such a classic wine for the vintage. Explosive and opulent to the core, the 2022 is seriously impressive. Baked apple tart, chamomile, acacia honey, hazelnut, coffee and orange confit stain the palate. Plush, generous contours wrap it all together in style. This is what 2002 is all about. Disgorged: January 2015.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Jul 2025
“Pol Roger’s 2002 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Vinothèque—a late release of the same original disgorgement (January 2015, with a dosage of eight grams per liter)—has matured gracefully, opening with a deep bouquet of orange zest, Mirabelle plum and burnt sugar, mingled with dried fruit and a faint hint of gunpowder. On the palate, it is full-bodied and layered, with notable musculature and flesh supported by a racy spine of acidity and ample tension. The wine concludes with a long, enveloping finish marked by a delicate saline nuance.”
“The 1999 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Vinothèque is a powerful, vibrant Champagne that has aged impeccably. Lemon confit, marzipan, dried flowers, mint, spice and chamomile abound. Time in the glass releases gorgeous inner sweetness, while a touch of reduction adds freshness and vibrancy to balance things out. The 1999 has been exceptional in two recent tasting. The style is one more of linear intensity as opposed to the decidedly headier, more exotic 1998.”
More Reviews +
98/100
James Suckling,
jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“A rich and broad-shouldered Sir Winston library release. It's rich with cooked apple, light apricot and peach character, as well as pie crust. Just a hint of salted butter. A layered and rich center-palate and a flavorful finish with freshness at the end. This needs food. Drinking beautifully now.”
“The 1999 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Vinothèque is a powerful, vibrant Champagne that has aged impeccably. Lemon confit, marzipan, dried flowers, mint, spice and chamomile abound. Time in the glass releases gorgeous inner sweetness, while a touch of reduction adds freshness and vibrancy to balance things out. The 1999 has been exceptional in two recent tasting. The style is one more of linear intensity as opposed to the decidedly headier, more exotic 1998.”
More Reviews +
98/100
James Suckling,
jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“A rich and broad-shouldered Sir Winston library release. It's rich with cooked apple, light apricot and peach character, as well as pie crust. Just a hint of salted butter. A layered and rich center-palate and a flavorful finish with freshness at the end. This needs food. Drinking beautifully now.”
“The 1998 Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Vinothèque is a fabulous choice for readers who want to enjoy a fully mature Champagne. Apricot jam, spice, baked apple tart, honey, passion fruit, orange marmalade and butter are all beautifully amplified. Readers will find a heady, exotic Champagne that dazzles both the intellectual and hedonistic senses. I would prefer to drink this at the dinner table along a suitably rich, complex dish – maybe lobster or Dover Sole with a lot of butter.”
More Reviews +
98/100
James Suckling,
jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“Wow. This is like the finest silk on the palate with such a refined texture and ultra-fine bubbles. The nose shows ginger, dried apple, light honey and caramel. Medium body with a dense center-palate and a polished and silky texture. Structured and racy. Library release. Drinking beautifully now.”
“Pale, youthful color. Fragrant vanilla, white-flower, and lemon nose, with impressive toasty layers. Lovely, crisp, tropical fruitiness, with melon and guava notes. It sits beautifully on the reductive side. Mellow, fluffy mousse on the creamy-smooth palate. Round and fruit-forward, with fine fruit intensity for further keeping. There is a refreshing phenolic bite on the back palate. Impressively slow-aging for the vintage.”
“The 2003 production was tiny, a mere 2,000 bottles, but the result was ever more interesting. As usual it comes with the palest peachy colour. The nose instantly captures one with its soft, fragrant and stunningly toasty nose. Lovely coffee, gunpowder, apricot and wild strawberry tones mixed in then most elegant of ways. The palate is supple, lacey and caressing with the soft mousse contributing to the gentle yet fresh and expressive character. Stunningly light and invigoratingly tense wine. At a beautiful age to drink even if surprisingly youthful. Vivacious and complex and still on an ascent. ”
“Rich, still restrained nose with honey toned evolution, baking spices, apple, lime and lemon marengue. The full and rich palate is textured and generously open already. After the initial two vintages, a Clos Pompadour that shows less of the gunpowder and toast but comes with a detailed palate of a great length. ”
More Reviews +
18.5+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Pale greenish gold. So youthful! Pungent, promising and not simple. Tension. Savoury. Exciting. Cool! Broad and a bit solid.”
“The 2003 Les Clos Pompadour couldn’t be further away from the 2002. Such openness and richness already upon launch (1 year-old disgorgement). Toasty with roasted and smoky nuances but not to the level of the 2002. Fruit wise more on the red fruit side with a spicy generosity opening in the glass. Juicy and succulent on the soft and round palate. One of the finest wines of the vintage but drink this now or soon and leave the 2002 in the cellar. Available in magnum only. ”
“The first release of Les Clos Pompadour, an intriguing single-vineyard champagne from Pommery’s large walled vineyard in the centre of Reims, is available in precious magnums only. Confusingly labelled as non-vintage (mis en cave 2003), it is made exclusively of 2002 fruit. Full, rich style, initially tight and reserved, coming with a highly mineral struck match character. Over time it has mellowed down into fine, fragrant, gunpowder and toast complexity. Slowly evolving with Chablis-like notes and super intensity lined with razor-sharp acidity. Still full of unreleased potential. Rich exuberance of toasty generosity. Loaded with explosive pristine fruit. Outstanding intensity with coffee, honey, gunpowder and spicy vanilla complexity. Such vibrancy, even raciness on the firm, focused palate. Beautifully balanced and generous at 8g/l dosage. Already close to perfection and going up. ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Sep 2023
“The first bottling of Les Clos Pompadour was classified non-vintage even if the fruit comes in its entirety from the 2002 harvest. It is a selection from Pommery’s 25ha walled vineyard behind the winery in Reims, and it is only produced in magnum. The nose has reductive charm, with smoky and toasty complexity and cool fruit expression. There is ample volume on the palate, but the wine’s best feature is its sublimely creamy mousse. The very long but understated aftertaste suggests there is potential for improvement.”
“The 2013 vintage is so very Rare, so pure. True to the classical Rare recipe its Chardonnay origins include a luxurious amount of Villers-Marmery and Côte de Blancs Grand Cru fruit, without forgetting the all-important ‘spice’ of Montgueux. The Pinot Noir mix plays with the cool verticality of Verzy and Verzenay, but on a crisp year like this more generosity was lent from for example plush Ambonnay and Bouzy fruit. Intense, shiny bright lemon-green colour. Stunningly refined toasty nose with fine herbal freshness, lemon and birch leaves. There is a lovely vanilla-laden exotic spicy touch to the pineapple and peach fruitiness. Creamy-caressing and salivatingly energetic at the same time. There is a lovely ethereal lightness to the airy whole. Perfectly pure and compact, promising extreme longevity and capacity for majestic complexity. ”
More Reviews +
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“The 2013 Rare is a radiant beauty, true to its cool year, still rather tight and restrained but promising superb longevity. It opens on a creamy note over grilled pineapple, confit orange and gunpowder-roasted coffee. Driven by Chardonnay, the aromas are subtle and layered, building up to immense complexity where the steely and mineral notes of the Côte des Blancs meet the spicier and exotic tones of Villers-Marmery and Montgueux. There is laser-sharp precision on the palate, thanks to the acidity that drives this silky-textured wine to its long finish. Really youthful still; best given extra time for savouring the rich aromatics that Rare can offer. Dosage: 9g/l”
16.5++/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
May 2025
“Gold-encrusted bottle 1,653 g. Certified B Corp is cited on the back label but little other information so I am indebted to London champagne specialist retailer The Finest Bubble for these details: 70% Chardonnay, 30% Pinot Noir from 14 crus – 79% grand cru and 21% premier cru. Chardonnay was from Avize, Oger, Villers-Marmery, Vaudemanges, Verzy, Ambonnay, Chouilly and Montgueux while the Pinot Noir was from Verzy, Verzenay, Ambonnay, Bouzy and Tauxières. Aged for 8 years on lees and disgorged spring 2022 with a dosage of 9 g/l.
Still with very marked acidity. Very obviously Chardonnay-dominated with lemon-cream notes. Tight finish. I'm tasting it straight out of the fridge and I'll definitely keep it out of the fridge until our guests arrive. Mind you, in London tonight even indoors is pretty chilly. Still very dominated by 2013's tightly wound character. ”
96/100
Claire Nesbitt,
Jamessuckling.com,
May 2023
“Such a pleasingly elegant and multifaceted Champagne with salty, creamy and toasty elements all wound together. Plenty of apricot pastries, pears, brown butter, fennel and salted almonds, with some iodine. It’s silky on the palate, with soft and supple bubbles, while remaining fresh and on edge. 70% chardonnay and 30% pinot noir, from 11 cru villages mostly in Montagne de Reims with Cotes de Blancs.”
“One of the greatest hits from Rare Champagne, the 2012 Rare Millésime is produced from fruit harvested between September 10 and 26. Disgorged in November 2023 with a dosage of eight grams per liter, it is a rich and flamboyant wine that harnesses the season’s maturity to its advantage. It unfurls in the glass with a complex bouquet of crisp pear, freshly baked bread and white flowers, mingling with roasted pineapple, caramelized sugar and a deft touch of smoky reduction. On the palate, it is full-bodied, muscular, ample and textural, with a simultaneously generous but elegant expression of fruit underpinned by succulent yet vibrant acidity and concluding with a long, saline finish tinged with toast. Concentrated but harmonious, it is dangerously drinkable now yet promises a long window of pleasure. The blend is the classic 70% Chardonnay (predominantly from Villers-Marmery) and 30% Pinot Noir.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Alison Napjus,
wineenthusiast.com,
Sep 2024
“A graceful Champagne that waltzes across the palate, with a fine, plush mousse carrying a lovely range of ripe black cherry, pureed raspberry, candied ginger, Mandarin orange peel, grilled nut and pastry flavors enlivened by a vibrant spine of lemony acidity. To a certain extent, the precision and elegance belies the focus and breadth on display, so sip this slowly and enjoy as it opens in the glass and expands on the palate, echoing on the finish. Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. Drink now through 2040.”
96/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
Oct 2024
“The concentration, ripeness and paradoxical brightness of Rare 2012 leaps out, in contrast to the cooler, sharper 2013 and 2008 releases. There's no excess weight here, though, as there was in 2006. The voluptuous, fragranced Chardonnay of the Montagne de Reims is not shy with its fleshy orange citrus and tropical tones. It's held in beautiful tension by zesty acidity, gentle Pinot Noir firmness and the maturing notes of charry citrus, honey on toast and even vanilla, all lifted by emerging white pepper and spice details. What strikes most is the gliding, satin-smooth mousse and effortless length, all of which promises a great deal for those willing to wait.he concentration, ripeness and paradoxical brightness of Rare 2012 leaps out, in contrast to the cooler, sharper 2013 and 2008 releases. There's no excess weight here, though, as there was in 2006. The voluptuous, fragranced Chardonnay of the Montagne de Reims is not shy with its fleshy orange citrus and tropical tones. It's held in beautiful tension by zesty acidity, gentle Pinot Noir firmness and the maturing notes of charry citrus, honey on toast and even vanilla, all lifted by emerging white pepper and spice details. What strikes most is the gliding, satin-smooth mousse and effortless length, all of which promises a great deal for those willing to wait.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“Complex notes of buttered toast, orange rind, licorice, fig and brioche on the nose, followed by honey and salted caramel on the palate. It’s layered, powerful and rich, yet so fresh and lively, with very fine bubbles that are well integrated. Long and intense. 70% chardonnay and 30% pinot noir. At least 10 years on the lees. 8g/L dosage.”
““Tasting Rare 2008 upon launch, it is exquisitely elegant, radiantly fruity and mineral, but still holding back plenty. It is almost like a time bomb having so much fruit and vitality to it that it feels near immortal. Beautifully detailed nose with fresh fruity profile with pineapple, lemon, sweet vanilla and roasted coffee beans meeting liquorice and smoky almonds. The fruitiness is pure, ripe yet crunchy. On the palate it is tightly knit and driven with its crisp acidity perfectly bound to the radiant fruitiness. Lacey texture with shows tension, the wine finishes to a palate-cleansingly fresh salty tang. Really refined vintage of Rare with majestic longevity ahead.””
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“70% Chardonnay, 30% Pinot Noir from 11 crus (including Villers-Marmery, Vertus, Montgueux for Chardonnay and Aÿ, Verzy and Ambonnay for Pinot Noir). No oak. Full malo. Régis Camus left this blend on lees for 10 years and then aged it for a year after disgorgement in November 2019 with a dosage of 10 g/l. Interesting how difficult it is for this wine to shed its relationship with Piper-Heidsieck on search engines.
Brilliant pale coppery colour. Mmmm! So concentrated and heady with a huge array of aromas including, amazingly, coconut – but not in a tarty way. Masses of tense lime fruit aromas. Very dense nose. Lifted and refreshing and this seems much more youthful than12 years old. It does rather remind me of Dom Pérignon with its concentration and density but I don't suppose that comment will necessarily be welcome with the winemaker. It's just so electric in texture. Truly an exciting, luxurious champagne.”
97/100
Alison Napjus,
WineSpectator.com,
Dec 2020
“Like a stallion out of the gate, this shows an initial explosion of power, in the form of mouthwatering flavours and fine texture, before quickly settling into an elegant gait. The racy acidity is seamlessly knit, buoying the lacy mousse and flavours of cassis, toasted brioche and tangerine, with accents of candied ginger, hazelnut and fleur de sel lingering on the long, creamy finish. Drink now through 2035.”
96/100
Roger Voss,
WineMag.com,
Nov 2020
“The new release of this producer`s prestige cuvée comes in its usual beautifully sculpted bottle. The Champagne, from a great vintage in the region, is just approaching maturity still showing minerality from the high amount of Chardonnay in the blend. Nutty flavours are creeping in, keeping the great texture adding complexity. Drink this very fine wine now although it will also age further.”
95+/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
JebDunnuck.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2008 Champagne Rare is luxurious with aromas of graham cracker, honeysuckle, quince, and orange zest. It is round and opulent, with a fine and pillowy mousse, and retains freshness throughout, with apricot and yellow flowers. It is impressive and long, and fully luxurious. Drinking well now, it is sure to hold its own for years to come. Drink 2022-2044.”
“Bottle | Tasting Rare 2008 upon launch, it is exquisitely elegant, radiantly fruity and mineral, but still holding back plenty. It is almost like a time bomb having so much fruit and vitality to it that it feels near immortal. Beautifully detailed nose with fresh fruity profile with pineapple, lemon, sweet vanilla and roasted coffee beans meeting liquorice and smoky almonds. The fruitiness is pure, ripe yet crunchy. On the palate it is tightly knit and driven with its crisp acidity perfectly bound to the radiant fruitiness. Lacey texture with shows tension, the wine finishes to a palate-cleansingly fresh salty tang. Really refined vintage of Rare with majestic longevity ahead. ”
More Reviews +
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Bottle | With over two thirds of Chardonnay from Avize and Oger in the Côte des Blancs and Villers-Marmery on the Montagne de Reims, this always comes with freshness, elegance and sweet, exuberant toasty notes. In the cool 2008 vintage, Verzy Pinot Noir further amplifies the notions of linearity and tension, making this a hugely slowly ageing Rare. Shiny lemon colour. The nose is instantly impressive: deliciously toasty, with ginger and coffee playing with pineapple, blood orange and yellow peach. With time in glass, it opens up gloriously. It is still holding back a lot on the nose, but it appears utterly sophisticated already. There is such silkiness to the linear, driven, super-saline palate. Really youthful still, this is a magnificent Rare. Dosage 10g/l”
97/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“Bottle | 70% Chardonnay from Avize, Oger and Villers-Marmery, 30% Pinot Noir from Verzy. There is not even a hint of a crack in the armour of Rare 2008 yet; it manages to hold the imperious structure of the year without seeming 'difficult', as some 2008s do at the moment. The signatures of mango cream and exotic notes melt into nougat and fresh ground nut, sparks of gunpower and succulent citrus confit. Some coffee richness is coming too. The 08 acidity feels like a bit of a kicker, but it is never out on a limb or threatening austerity. A finely tuned, immaculately-built time machine which shows all the signs of remaining beautifully integrated over the long term.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“Bottle | 70% Chardonnay, 30% Pinot Noir from 11 crus (including Villers-Marmery, Vertus, Montgueux for Chardonnay and Aÿ, Verzy and Ambonnay for Pinot Noir). No oak. Full malo. Régis Camus left this blend on lees for 10 years and then aged it for a year after disgorgement in November 2019 with a dosage of 10 g/l. Interesting how difficult it is for this wine to shed its relationship with Piper-Heidsieck on search engines.
Brilliant pale coppery colour. Mmmm! So concentrated and heady with a huge array of aromas including, amazingly, coconut – but not in a tarty way. Masses of tense lime fruit aromas. Very dense nose. Lifted and refreshing and this seems much more youthful than12 years old. It does rather remind me of Dom Pérignon with its concentration and density but I don't suppose that comment will necessarily be welcome with the winemaker. It's just so electric in texture. Truly an exciting, luxurious champagne.”
93+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“Bottle | The 2008 Brut Cuvée Rare, now re-baptized as "Rare Champagne," continues to evolve at a glacial pace. Offering up aromas of citrus oil, freshly baked bread and wet stones, it's medium to full-bodied, taut and incisive, with a tangy spine of acidity and a pretty pinpoint mousse, but much in the way of texture or amplitude has yet to emerge. While I continue to think that this has the makings of a very attractive bottling, continued patience is advised.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2021
“Bottle | “Tasting Rare 2008 upon launch, it is exquisitely elegant, radiantly fruity and mineral, but still holding back plenty. It is almost like a time bomb having so much fruit and vitality to it that it feels near immortal. Beautifully detailed nose with fresh fruity profile with pineapple, lemon, sweet vanilla and roasted coffee beans meeting liquorice and smoky almonds. The fruitiness is pure, ripe yet crunchy. On the palate it is tightly knit and driven with its crisp acidity perfectly bound to the radiant fruitiness. Lacey texture with shows tension, the wine finishes to a palate-cleansingly fresh salty tang. Really refined vintage of Rare with majestic longevity ahead.””
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“Bottle | Lemon zest frames the creamy richness on the nose that has hints of chalk and coconut macaroon but also reveals a beautiful depth that evokes summer rain on limestone soils. The palate comes with all the precision and exquisite freshness of 2008 but encapsulates a truffle- like complexity at its concentrated core: there is a floral hit of peony, something rich reminiscent of milk chocolate ganache and more of that virile and pervasive lemon freshness. This is glorious and somehow manages to convey great richness within that elegant and characteristic framework set by the amazing 2008 vintage.”
97/100
Alison Napjus,
WineSpectator.com,
Dec 2020
“Bottle | Like a stallion out of the gate, this shows an initial explosion of power, in the form of mouthwatering flavours and fine texture, before quickly settling into an elegant gait. The racy acidity is seamlessly knit, buoying the lacy mousse and flavours of cassis, toasted brioche and tangerine, with accents of candied ginger, hazelnut and fleur de sel lingering on the long, creamy finish. Drink now through 2035.”
96/100
Roger Voss,
WineMag.com,
Nov 2020
“Bottle | The new release of this producer`s prestige cuvée comes in its usual beautifully sculpted bottle. The Champagne, from a great vintage in the region, is just approaching maturity still showing minerality from the high amount of Chardonnay in the blend. Nutty flavours are creeping in, keeping the great texture adding complexity. Drink this very fine wine now although it will also age further.”
98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“With over two thirds of Chardonnay from Avize and Oger in the Côte des Blancs and Villers-Marmery on the Montagne de Reims, this always comes with freshness, elegance and sweet, exuberant toasty notes. In the cool 2008 vintage, Verzy Pinot Noir further amplifies the notions of linearity and tension, making this a hugely slowly ageing Rare. Shiny lemon colour. The nose is instantly impressive: deliciously toasty, with ginger and coffee playing with pineapple, blood orange and yellow peach. With time in glass, it opens up gloriously. It is still holding back a lot on the nose, but it appears utterly sophisticated already. There is such silkiness to the linear, driven, super-saline palate. Really youthful still, this is a magnificent Rare. Dosage 10g/l”
97/100
Tom Hewson,
Timatkin.com,
Dec 2022
“70% Chardonnay from Avize, Oger and Villers-Marmery, 30% Pinot Noir from Verzy. There is not even a hint of a crack in the armour of Rare 2008 yet; it manages to hold the imperious structure of the year without seeming 'difficult', as some 2008s do at the moment. The signatures of mango cream and exotic notes melt into nougat and fresh ground nut, sparks of gunpower and succulent citrus confit. Some coffee richness is coming too. The 08 acidity feels like a bit of a kicker, but it is never out on a limb or threatening austerity. A finely tuned, immaculately-built time machine which shows all the signs of remaining beautifully integrated over the long term.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2021
“70% Chardonnay, 30% Pinot Noir from 11 crus (including Villers-Marmery, Vertus, Montgueux for Chardonnay and Aÿ, Verzy and Ambonnay for Pinot Noir). No oak. Full malo. Régis Camus left this blend on lees for 10 years and then aged it for a year after disgorgement in November 2019 with a dosage of 10 g/l. Interesting how difficult it is for this wine to shed its relationship with Piper-Heidsieck on search engines.
Brilliant pale coppery colour. Mmmm! So concentrated and heady with a huge array of aromas including, amazingly, coconut – but not in a tarty way. Masses of tense lime fruit aromas. Very dense nose. Lifted and refreshing and this seems much more youthful than12 years old. It does rather remind me of Dom Pérignon with its concentration and density but I don't suppose that comment will necessarily be welcome with the winemaker. It's just so electric in texture. Truly an exciting, luxurious champagne.”
97/100
Alison Napjus,
WineSpectator.com,
Dec 2020
“Like a stallion out of the gate, this shows an initial explosion of power, in the form of mouthwatering flavours and fine texture, before quickly settling into an elegant gait. The racy acidity is seamlessly knit, buoying the lacy mousse and flavours of cassis, toasted brioche and tangerine, with accents of candied ginger, hazelnut and fleur de sel lingering on the long, creamy finish. Drink now through 2035.”
96/100
Roger Voss,
WineMag.com,
Nov 2020
“The new release of this producer`s prestige cuvée comes in its usual beautifully sculpted bottle. The Champagne, from a great vintage in the region, is just approaching maturity still showing minerality from the high amount of Chardonnay in the blend. Nutty flavours are creeping in, keeping the great texture adding complexity. Drink this very fine wine now although it will also age further.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Aug 2021
“Lemon zest frames the creamy richness on the nose that has hints of chalk and coconut macaroon but also reveals a beautiful depth that evokes summer rain on limestone soils. The palate comes with all the precision and exquisite freshness of 2008 but encapsulates a truffle- like complexity at its concentrated core: there is a floral hit of peony, something rich reminiscent of milk chocolate ganache and more of that virile and pervasive lemon freshness. This is glorious and somehow manages to convey great richness within that elegant and characteristic framework set by the amazing 2008 vintage.”
93+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2022
“The 2008 Brut Cuvée Rare, now re-baptized as "Rare Champagne," continues to evolve at a glacial pace. Offering up aromas of citrus oil, freshly baked bread and wet stones, it's medium to full-bodied, taut and incisive, with a tangy spine of acidity and a pretty pinpoint mousse, but much in the way of texture or amplitude has yet to emerge. While I continue to think that this has the makings of a very attractive bottling, continued patience is advised.”
“Deep golden, evolving colour. Charred, honey toned maturing nose with tropical fruit and oriental spices alongside candied orange and dried apricots notes. Broad on the lusciously textured palate, which offers a soft, fluffy mousse of a warm vintage. Wide open and expressive already, highly pleasurable today. An early bloomer of a vintage.”
More Reviews +
97+/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
May 2019
“The flagship release is the 2006 Champagne Rare, a 70/30 split of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir that’s a cellar selection from 8 different Grand Cru vineyards. Tight, backward, and straight-up structured, it offers brilliant notes of stone fruits, toasted brioche, white flowers, and obvious minerality. Needing plenty of air to show at its best, this beauty has a wonderful mid-palate, a racy mousse, and the balance and class to cruise for over two decades in cool cellars.”
96/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Oct 2019
“Aromas and flavours of toasted brioche and grilled nut enrich the yellow plum, nectarine and grated ginger notes of this rich and creamy Champagne. Finely woven and beautifully integrated, with a firm backbone of mouthwatering acidity providing precise balance for the lush range of flavour.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“About to launch. Disgorged late 2018. Very sunny year, a bit like 2018. Deep coppery straw. Very powerful nose – and again quite powerful and broad and rich on the palate and then it’s drawn tight on the finish. Bitter orange-peel note. Long. It should age well but it’s already drinkable.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“The 2006 Brut Cuvée Rare is a rich, gourmand rendition of this prestige bottling, unfurling in the glass with a complex bouquet that mingles aromas of yellow orchard fruit, pears and fresh pineapple with nuances of buttered toast, iodine and smoke. On the palate, the wine is full-bodied, broad and textural, while remaining fresh and surprisingly tight-knit at the core, concluding with a long and saline finish. There's sufficient structural tension here to promise more than a decade's graceful evolution, and although this is nicely balanced, it's a generous, sun kissed rendition of the Cuvée Rare that reflects the warm vintage. The blend is 70% Chardonnay and 30% Pinot Noir.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“ Piper-Hiedsieck's 2006 Cuvée Rare is racy and polished to the core. Baked apple tart, apricot, lemon confit, vanillin and brioche infuse the 2006 with striking aromatic intensity and creaminess that builds with time in the glass. Sumptuous and forward, the 2006 offers tons of near and medium-term appeal.”
“Deep golden, evolving colour. Charred, honey toned maturing nose with tropical fruit and oriental spices alongside candied orange and dried apricots notes. Broad on the lusciously textured palate, which offers a soft, fluffy mousse of a warm vintage. Wide open and expressive already, highly pleasurable today. An early bloomer of a vintage.”
More Reviews +
97+/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
May 2019
“The flagship release is the 2006 Champagne Rare, a 70/30 split of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir that’s a cellar selection from 8 different Grand Cru vineyards. Tight, backward, and straight-up structured, it offers brilliant notes of stone fruits, toasted brioche, white flowers, and obvious minerality. Needing plenty of air to show at its best, this beauty has a wonderful mid-palate, a racy mousse, and the balance and class to cruise for over two decades in cool cellars.”
96/100
Alison Napjus,
Wine Spectator,
Oct 2019
“Aromas and flavours of toasted brioche and grilled nut enrich the yellow plum, nectarine and grated ginger notes of this rich and creamy Champagne. Finely woven and beautifully integrated, with a firm backbone of mouthwatering acidity providing precise balance for the lush range of flavour.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“About to launch. Disgorged late 2018. Very sunny year, a bit like 2018. Deep coppery straw. Very powerful nose – and again quite powerful and broad and rich on the palate and then it’s drawn tight on the finish. Bitter orange-peel note. Long. It should age well but it’s already drinkable.”
94/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“The 2006 Brut Cuvée Rare is a rich, gourmand rendition of this prestige bottling, unfurling in the glass with a complex bouquet that mingles aromas of yellow orchard fruit, pears and fresh pineapple with nuances of buttered toast, iodine and smoke. On the palate, the wine is full-bodied, broad and textural, while remaining fresh and surprisingly tight-knit at the core, concluding with a long and saline finish. There's sufficient structural tension here to promise more than a decade's graceful evolution, and although this is nicely balanced, it's a generous, sun kissed rendition of the Cuvée Rare that reflects the warm vintage. The blend is 70% Chardonnay and 30% Pinot Noir.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2019
“ Piper-Hiedsieck's 2006 Cuvée Rare is racy and polished to the core. Baked apple tart, apricot, lemon confit, vanillin and brioche infuse the 2006 with striking aromatic intensity and creaminess that builds with time in the glass. Sumptuous and forward, the 2006 offers tons of near and medium-term appeal.”
“Disgorged early 2018. Stocks are just coming to an end. According to Chef de Cave Regis Camus 2002 is a vintage with lots of richness. Rich because of 2001. ‘In 2002 there were two vintages in one which explains its richness.’
The mousse seems less fine than the old Charles Heidsiecks we have just been tasting. Straw gold. Intense and rather Dom Pérignon-like on the nose. Then on the palate it’s amazingly rich and tropical. Before slimming down into the corset of freshness. Lots of potential and tight and tense.”
More Reviews +
97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Jul 2017
“Super stylish, toasty nose with lovely floral and gunpowdery tones as well as tropical fruit, orange peel and candy notes. Super linear, driven, energetic palate which huge intensity and richness. Drinking perfectly today with lot’s of delicious ageing elements but very much in the fresh and vibrant side.This is a serial winner, we chose it as the Best Champagne at FINE Champagne magazine in 2011. ”
94/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Dec 2012
“This is top Champagne from Piper-Heidsieck, offering the delicious airy quality that's the hallmark of this house, with crisp apple flavour, tangy acidity and the first signs of yeasty, toasty bottle age. Its fruit intensity has transformed into a splendid selection. It's worth aging for a few more years, though also delicious now.
”
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2010
“Light yellow-gold. Pungent aromas of lemon zest, orange and pear, complicated by sexy floral and gingerbread qualities and hints of toasty lees and honey. Lively on entry, with lively citrus flavors, then deeper and smokier in the middle palate, offering juicy orchard fruit and honeyed nut flavors and good mineral snap. The finish lingers with suave floral and spice notes and excellent persistence. ”
“This vintage is described by the Cellar Master as 'extravagant', and so it truly is in its superby toasty and tropical, velvety character. Stylish, toasty and gunpowdery nose with sweet vanilla, mocha, pineapple, orange peel and white pepper. Rich and structured, stylish palate with a fine caressing texture. It still shows further potential. ”
“Magnum: Pale yellow. Nicely mature with some sweetness and lemon fruit. Clean and resolved though not that much evidence of autolysis. Complete, composed and fine and sophisticated rather than dramatic or showy. A hint of smokiness on the long finish.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Greenish pale gold. Intense and nourishing on the nose. Very pretty and zesty, complete and well balanced. Great for current drinking. Lovely!”
“Incorporating 13% red wine from Bouzy, the 2008 Rare Rosé Millésime—disgorged in July 2018 with a dosage of eight grams per liter—has evolved superbly. It opens with a deep bouquet of red cherry, cranberry and passion fruit, mingling with buttered toast and a hint of rosemary, framed by a deft touch of smoky reduction. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and elegantly muscular, with excellent concentration underpinned by bright acidity, concluding with a long, toasty finish. Already compelling upon release, it has since gained in depth, standing alongside the 2012 as one of the two most complete and harmonious expressions of Rare Rosé to date.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Lot code: L1990198098. Blend of 60% Chardonnay and 40% Pinot Noir (including the 13% still red added for colour). A blend of 13 crus (including Chardonnay from Villers-Marmery, Vertus and Montgueux and Pinot Noir from Aÿ and Verzy). Fermented in tank with full malo. Aged for nine years on the lees and a further two years after the disgorgement in July 2018 with dosage 8 g/l.
Another extraordinary bottle tasted immediately after the Belle Epoque 2012. (I wonder how long we will go on explaining how Rare was spun out of Piper Heidsieck with Régis Camus in charge?) Very bright, pale flame-orange – if that makes sense. Very exciting nose with layers of coconut (if Camus is not insulted by that), broad and rich initially but very lively, bright-fruited finish. Super-clean, refreshing but layered. Really pretty spiffy! Grown-up wine with a dry finish. Thundering, multi-layered finish. This is a wine that commands attention. Though it is a crazy price.
Drink 2019 – 2028”
97-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2021
“Elegant peachy colour. There is vanilla, light toastiness and roasted coffee complexity on the sweet berry nose of cherry, raspberry and blood orange. The pure and cool fruitiness impresses on the vibrant and structured palate. The characterful red fruitiness continues until the long mineral finish that has an attractive touch of ripe tannin to it. Still youthful but so fine and more and more expressive. ”
97/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Medium salmon pink, fine copper reflections; delicate mousse lingers very well. Nuances of fine biscuit, hints of wild berry jam, red and also black berries, a touch of liquorice, floral scents. Juicy on the palate with notes of ripe cherries and yellow apple from the high Chardonnay proportion, firm structure, pleasantly dry finish with a lemony-salty echo. A multi-faceted food wine with further development potential.”
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“The 2008 Brut Rosé Cuvée Rare is the second rendition of this cuvée ever produced, and the wine is showing very well, unwinding in the glass with a youthfully shy nose featuring white cherries, blood orange, Meyer lemon, honeysuckle and dried white flowers that offers the promise of considerable complexity to come. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, racy and tight-knit, with good concentration, beautifully integrated acids and a fine mousse, concluding with a long, saline and delicately phenolic finish. This is really quite reserved after its recent disgorgement but should develop beautifully with a few years on cork.”
97/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2019
“Medium salmon pink, fine copper reflections; delicate mousse lingers very well. Nuances of fine biscuit, hints of wild berry jam, red and also black berries, a touch of liquorice, floral scents. Juicy on the palate with notes of ripe cherries and yellow apple from the high Chardonnay proportion, firm structure, pleasantly dry finish with a lemony-salty echo. A multi-faceted food wine with further development potential.”
93/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Medium pink/copper colour. The nose has orange blossom and impressively dense fruit of pink grapefruit, peach and nectarine, raspberry, plum and lychee, with caffe mocha and caramalised nut nuances. It is rich and intense on the palate, structured with focused acidity.”
“Incorporating 13% red wine from Bouzy, the 2008 Rare Rosé Millésime—disgorged in July 2018 with a dosage of eight grams per liter—has evolved superbly. It opens with a deep bouquet of red cherry, cranberry and passion fruit, mingling with buttered toast and a hint of rosemary, framed by a deft touch of smoky reduction. On the palate, it is medium- to full-bodied and elegantly muscular, with excellent concentration underpinned by bright acidity, concluding with a long, toasty finish. Already compelling upon release, it has since gained in depth, standing alongside the 2012 as one of the two most complete and harmonious expressions of Rare Rosé to date.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Lot code: L1990198098. Blend of 60% Chardonnay and 40% Pinot Noir (including the 13% still red added for colour). A blend of 13 crus (including Chardonnay from Villers-Marmery, Vertus and Montgueux and Pinot Noir from Aÿ and Verzy). Fermented in tank with full malo. Aged for nine years on the lees and a further two years after the disgorgement in July 2018 with dosage 8 g/l.
Another extraordinary bottle tasted immediately after the Belle Epoque 2012. (I wonder how long we will go on explaining how Rare was spun out of Piper Heidsieck with Régis Camus in charge?) Very bright, pale flame-orange – if that makes sense. Very exciting nose with layers of coconut (if Camus is not insulted by that), broad and rich initially but very lively, bright-fruited finish. Super-clean, refreshing but layered. Really pretty spiffy! Grown-up wine with a dry finish. Thundering, multi-layered finish. This is a wine that commands attention. Though it is a crazy price.
Drink 2019 – 2028”
97-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Mar 2021
“Elegant peachy colour. There is vanilla, light toastiness and roasted coffee complexity on the sweet berry nose of cherry, raspberry and blood orange. The pure and cool fruitiness impresses on the vibrant and structured palate. The characterful red fruitiness continues until the long mineral finish that has an attractive touch of ripe tannin to it. Still youthful but so fine and more and more expressive. ”
97/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Medium salmon pink, fine copper reflections; delicate mousse lingers very well. Nuances of fine biscuit, hints of wild berry jam, red and also black berries, a touch of liquorice, floral scents. Juicy on the palate with notes of ripe cherries and yellow apple from the high Chardonnay proportion, firm structure, pleasantly dry finish with a lemony-salty echo. A multi-faceted food wine with further development potential.”
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“The 2008 Brut Rosé Cuvée Rare is the second rendition of this cuvée ever produced, and the wine is showing very well, unwinding in the glass with a youthfully shy nose featuring white cherries, blood orange, Meyer lemon, honeysuckle and dried white flowers that offers the promise of considerable complexity to come. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, racy and tight-knit, with good concentration, beautifully integrated acids and a fine mousse, concluding with a long, saline and delicately phenolic finish. This is really quite reserved after its recent disgorgement but should develop beautifully with a few years on cork.”
97/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2019
“Medium salmon pink, fine copper reflections; delicate mousse lingers very well. Nuances of fine biscuit, hints of wild berry jam, red and also black berries, a touch of liquorice, floral scents. Juicy on the palate with notes of ripe cherries and yellow apple from the high Chardonnay proportion, firm structure, pleasantly dry finish with a lemony-salty echo. A multi-faceted food wine with further development potential.”
93/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Medium pink/copper colour. The nose has orange blossom and impressively dense fruit of pink grapefruit, peach and nectarine, raspberry, plum and lychee, with caffe mocha and caramalised nut nuances. It is rich and intense on the palate, structured with focused acidity.”
“2015 | The latest 2015 Rare Millésime, disgorged in February 2025 with a dosage of 10 grams per liter, derives from 11 villages and comprises the customary blend of 70% Chardonnay (predominantly from the Montagne de Reims and notably Villers-Marmery) and 30% Pinot Noir. In the glass, the 2015 unfurls with aromas of passion fruit, freshly baked bread and honeysuckle, mingling with nuances of lime leaf and kiwi. On the palate, it is full-bodied and ample yet simultaneously tightly coiled at the core, enlivened by a pillowy mousse and concluding with a lingering finish. Originating from a hot and dry growing season—one in which some wines display an herbal aromatic signature indicative of incomplete ripening caused by hydric stress—this 2015 has largely, but not entirely, avoided such traits. It remains several years away from showing all its cards.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Kristaps Karklins,
wineadvocate.com,
Oct 2025
“1985 | Disgorged in February 2025 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, the 1985 Rare Millésime shows striking youthfulness, owing both to its recent disgorgement and its production without malolactic fermentation. It opens with aromas of freshly baked bread, lychee and lemon rind with a hint of smoky reduction. The palate is medium- to full-bodied, with a pillowy mousse, crisp core of fruit, brisk acidity and a long, citrus-tinged finish. More tightly knit and less marked by the toasty, empyreumatic nuances compared to the original release, this late-disgorged edition will be reissued alongside the 2015 vintage, offering a fascinating dialogue across three decades of evolution.”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Apr 2026
“1985: Disgorged Feb 2025. An outstanding wine, bundles of dried citrus, orange galore and charred spicy stone fruits follows with seaside salinity, ripe peach, lanolin and intense freshness. Combines richness with precision, with acidity carrying the wine to an exceptionally long finish. A standout of the tasting and one of the best examples I have tasted of a recent disgorgement when the champagne spent 40 years with its lees. Super fresh. Drink now to 2040+ could be a lot longer and I look forward to following its journey.”
97/100
Louis-Victor Charvet,
Bettane + Desseauve,
May 2026
“1985: Disgorged Feb 2025. Blood orange, apricot and pineapple, alongside toast, liquorice, mocha, resin and honey. They emphasise how extraordinarily fresh it remains after almost four decades on its lees and its ageing potential.”
“There was not to be a Rare 1997 but the cellar master put 1000 undeclared magnums in the experimental cellars. Some twenty years after Régis Camus finally let out the secret. And for that reason the wine does not bear a vintage on the label. Fresh nose with jasmin tea, fudge, oriental spices and peppery notes. Fresh palate with stylish minerality but its fruitiness does not reach the intensity of the best years. Peaking now showing both a fresh and a mature side. ”
“Candied angelica, candied peel, smoke packed into layer upon layer of polyhedric acidity and structure. A matrix of a wine that is shafted by helical verticality. Shimmering green acidity that sifts through light with nacreous iridescence, that tastes like crushed green cardamom in bergamot syrup, like spaces within clusters within the Milky Way. A fling of fine stars in the mouth. Absolutely outstanding. The electricity of this wine is off the chart.”
More Reviews +
94/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2023
“A tiny cuvée produced from a small parcel in the Côte de Blancs that's affected by fan leaf virus (producing smaller, more concentrated grapes as a result), the 2016 Extra-Brut Blanc de Blancs Chouilly Les Hauts Partas offers up aromas of sweet stone fruit, ripe citrus, vanilla pod and buttery pastry, followed by a medium to full-bodied, fleshy and satiny palate that's pure and concentrated, concluding with a saline finish.”
94/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2023
“The 2016 Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Les Hauts Partas from vines in Chouilly, sizzles with Côtes des Blancs tension. Lemon peel, chalk, slate, white pepper and bright saline notes all take shape in the glass. Linear and bursting with energy, the Hauts Partas is super-expressive today. This is an especially good wine for the year. Dosage is 2 grams per liter. Disgorged: November 2022”
“Based on the 2019 vintage and disgorged in 2022, Ruinart's newly released NV Blanc de Blancs bursts with characteristically reductive aromas of yellow orchard fruit, citrus oil, iodine and toasted bread. Medium-bodied, pillowy and fleshy, with lively acids and a saline finish, it is an attractive Champagne that incorporates 20% reserve wines.”
More Reviews +
90-92/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Nov 2020
“Pale lemon colour. Youthful, gunpowdery mineral nose with straw, floral and lemon notes. Tart, linear, driven palate. Super lean and fresh with a succulent, fruity finish. Can be closed and muted at first but opens up to a beautiful, soft, toasty richness. The 2010 based cuvée is exceptionally good and shows remarkably in magnums. The 2011 was notably lesser whereas the 2012 based ones are opulent and caressing with generous tropical fruit. Beware of storage conditions as the clear glass allows the light to spoil it quickly.”
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The secret to the supple deliciousness of this blanc de blancs lies in its broad blend, with Chardonnays from the Côte des Blancs and Montagne de Reims paired with softly fruity Vesle Valley and Sézannais grapes. Pale, greenish-yellow colour. The youthful nose is still very much on the primary fruit, with fine lemon and lime notes mixing with white flowers and green apple. Not much of Ruinart's hallmark smoky, toasty aromas surfacing yet. The palate is super-fresh, but there is fruity suppleness to it, too. Lean, long and finishing on a pure fruity note. This one feels like it needs more time.”
90/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Ruinart's NV Blanc de Blancs unwinds in the glass with scents of citrus zest, green apple, white flowers and fresh bread. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and incisive, with a vibrant core of fruit and brisk acids, complemented by a mouth-filling mousse, it concludes with a saline finish.”
94/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2020
“Light greenish yellow, silver reflections; lively mousse. Floral nose, fine white peach fruit and fresh apple, mineral freshness, a hint of biscuit. Fine, silky palate is carried by a lively acidity, vinous texture, lemony aftertaste; an animating food wine with good ageing potential.”
“Bready nose with some real interest. Solid stuff – something to get your teeth into, in a good way. Very clean and neat and tastes as though it had quite a bit of age on lees.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Crafted using reductive winemaking techniques (as all Ruinarts are), this Pinot Noir-led blend sees an addition of 25-30% of one- to two-year-old reserve wines. The fruity nose has fragrant floral tones alongside more substantial red- and yellow-fruit tones and a touch of spicy smokiness. The perky palate feels highly youthful, with the mousse a little coarse and aggressive. There is lovely, pure fruit, and the energetic palate lingers on in an elegant fashion.”
92/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2019
“Light greenish yellow, silver reflections, fine persistent mousse. White apple fruit with a hint of lime zest, delicate hazelnut, candied orange zest. Juicy, fine yellow tropical fruit, pleasant acidity, mineral touch, discreet blossom honey on the finish; versatile.”
“The bright, youthful salmon colour is typically attained by a red wine addition (almost 20%). The nose comes across primary, with plush Pinot aromas stealing the show: dark cherries, raspberries and strawberry jam. There is an edge of herbaceous spiciness to it, too. This is structured and sweetly berried on the palate, with good volume and only a touch of tannin. Long, winey finish. Really youthful for the time being, with even a short post-disgorgement time doing miracles in letting more complexity surface.”
More Reviews +
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Ruinart's NV Brut Rosé is a pretty, vibrant wine that offers up inviting aromas of tangerine, blood orange, plum and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with tangy acids and a pretty mousse, it's ca harming, comparatively vinous wine that is already showing well.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Only clue is the code LAK07 on the back label. Mostly premiers crus Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, we are told, with 20–25% reserve wines and 18–19% still red. Three years on lees. Dosage 8 g/l.
Pale orange. Small bead and appetising nose. Tight and focused with both fruit and grip, and a core of fruit that tastes a little like orange juice. But the finish is a little sweet so this is not the most appetising pink champagne. Nice texture though and very much an aperitif style.”
“Very attractive, bright and fragrant red fruits on the nose here. This has a wealth of fresh yeasty characters, fresh pastry and bread dough, plus red fruits, pink grapefruit, and some floral notes too. The palate has a strong nectarine and light cherry flavor thread. Chardonnay has a lot to say here; the texture is creamy and the balance right on the money. Drink now.”
More Reviews +
91/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“The bright, youthful salmon colour is typically attained by a red wine addition (almost 20%). The nose comes across primary, with plush Pinot aromas stealing the show: dark cherries, raspberries and strawberry jam. There is an edge of herbaceous spiciness to it, too. This is structured and sweetly berried on the palate, with good volume and only a touch of tannin. Long, winey finish. Really youthful for the time being, with even a short post-disgorgement time doing miracles in letting more complexity surface.”
91/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest rendition of Ruinart's NV Brut Rosé is a pretty, vibrant wine that offers up inviting aromas of tangerine, blood orange, plum and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with tangy acids and a pretty mousse, it's ca harming, comparatively vinous wine that is already showing well.”
88-90/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Oct 2016
“Deep bright cherry red colour. Clean, primary fruity nose of cherries and strawberry jam with attractive gunpowder notes. Rich, round, sweet fruity palate, delivers what the nose promises. Deep berried style but beautifully in absence of any excess tannin.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Feb 2021
“Only clue is the code LAK07 on the back label. Mostly premiers crus Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, we are told, with 20–25% reserve wines and 18–19% still red. Three years on lees. Dosage 8 g/l.
Pale orange. Small bead and appetising nose. Tight and focused with both fruit and grip, and a core of fruit that tastes a little like orange juice. But the finish is a little sweet so this is not the most appetising pink champagne. Nice texture though and very much an aperitif style.”
“This lightly Chardonnay-driven blend benefits from some 30% of reserve wines from the previous two harvests. Pale lemon-green colour. The lovely, fragrant sweetly fruity nose has ripe pear, crunchy red apple and zingy lemon. The palate is light and refreshing, but with a lovely fruit purity and intensity. Lingering silky palate and classy, creamy mousse. There is a lovely easiness and quaffing character to this. Dosage 9g/l”
More Reviews +
89/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2017
“Taittinger's NV Brut Reserve—a blend of more than 35 different vineyards, assembling 40% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 25% Pinot Meunier, including 30% reserve wines—has a clear, fresh and vinous bouquet with Pinot Meunier flavors in front. Bottled in 2014 and disgorged in March 2017 with nine grams of dosage, this is a lithe and fresh but mouth-filling Brut with round and aromatic fruit. It tastes almost as charming as the Rosé Prestige yet less vinous and is rather lean and fresh. Tasted in November 2017.”
17.5
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2016
“Particularly fine and strong stream of bubbles with lots of lemon and lime notes and hints of tropical fruits like guava and pineapple and some creaminess that you don't often see in these non vintage champagnes. Nice and dry and lingering. Lovely today on a hot London day. This current cuvee must have its core part of the blend from one of the great vintages like 2010. Wish this was declared on the label.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2015
“Tasted blind. Overall score placed it fourth out of 12 wines. Light straw. Sweetish nose – one of the few! Candied violets on the nose. Light and off dry. Quite chunky, lime-marmalade impression. Not much undertow. Good texture and refreshment value on the finish. A little chew on the end. Lots of acidity underneath. ”
“This lightly Chardonnay-driven blend benefits from some 30% of reserve wines from the previous two harvests. Pale lemon-green colour. The lovely, fragrant sweetly fruity nose has ripe pear, crunchy red apple and zingy lemon. The palate is light and refreshing, but with a lovely fruit purity and intensity. Lingering silky palate and classy, creamy mousse. There is a lovely easiness and quaffing character to this. Dosage 9g/l”
More Reviews +
89/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2017
“Taittinger's NV Brut Reserve—a blend of more than 35 different vineyards, assembling 40% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 25% Pinot Meunier, including 30% reserve wines—has a clear, fresh and vinous bouquet with Pinot Meunier flavors in front. Bottled in 2014 and disgorged in March 2017 with nine grams of dosage, this is a lithe and fresh but mouth-filling Brut with round and aromatic fruit. It tastes almost as charming as the Rosé Prestige yet less vinous and is rather lean and fresh. Tasted in November 2017.”
17.5
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2016
“Particularly fine and strong stream of bubbles with lots of lemon and lime notes and hints of tropical fruits like guava and pineapple and some creaminess that you don't often see in these non vintage champagnes. Nice and dry and lingering. Lovely today on a hot London day. This current cuvee must have its core part of the blend from one of the great vintages like 2010. Wish this was declared on the label.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2015
“Tasted blind. Overall score placed it fourth out of 12 wines. Light straw. Sweetish nose – one of the few! Candied violets on the nose. Light and off dry. Quite chunky, lime-marmalade impression. Not much undertow. Good texture and refreshment value on the finish. A little chew on the end. Lots of acidity underneath. ”
“This lightly Chardonnay-driven blend benefits from some 30% of reserve wines from the previous two harvests. Pale lemon-green colour. The lovely, fragrant sweetly fruity nose has ripe pear, crunchy red apple and zingy lemon. The palate is light and refreshing, but with a lovely fruit purity and intensity. Lingering silky palate and classy, creamy mousse. There is a lovely easiness and quaffing character to this. Dosage 9g/l”
More Reviews +
89/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2017
“Taittinger's NV Brut Reserve—a blend of more than 35 different vineyards, assembling 40% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 25% Pinot Meunier, including 30% reserve wines—has a clear, fresh and vinous bouquet with Pinot Meunier flavors in front. Bottled in 2014 and disgorged in March 2017 with nine grams of dosage, this is a lithe and fresh but mouth-filling Brut with round and aromatic fruit. It tastes almost as charming as the Rosé Prestige yet less vinous and is rather lean and fresh. Tasted in November 2017.”
17.5
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2016
“Particularly fine and strong stream of bubbles with lots of lemon and lime notes and hints of tropical fruits like guava and pineapple and some creaminess that you don't often see in these non vintage champagnes. Nice and dry and lingering. Lovely today on a hot London day. This current cuvee must have its core part of the blend from one of the great vintages like 2010. Wish this was declared on the label.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2015
“Tasted blind. Overall score placed it fourth out of 12 wines. Light straw. Sweetish nose – one of the few! Candied violets on the nose. Light and off dry. Quite chunky, lime-marmalade impression. Not much undertow. Good texture and refreshment value on the finish. A little chew on the end. Lots of acidity underneath. ”
“This lightly Chardonnay-driven blend benefits from some 30% of reserve wines from the previous two harvests. Pale lemon-green colour. The lovely, fragrant sweetly fruity nose has ripe pear, crunchy red apple and zingy lemon. The palate is light and refreshing, but with a lovely fruit purity and intensity. Lingering silky palate and classy, creamy mousse. There is a lovely easiness and quaffing character to this. Dosage 9g/l”
More Reviews +
89/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2017
“Taittinger's NV Brut Reserve—a blend of more than 35 different vineyards, assembling 40% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 25% Pinot Meunier, including 30% reserve wines—has a clear, fresh and vinous bouquet with Pinot Meunier flavors in front. Bottled in 2014 and disgorged in March 2017 with nine grams of dosage, this is a lithe and fresh but mouth-filling Brut with round and aromatic fruit. It tastes almost as charming as the Rosé Prestige yet less vinous and is rather lean and fresh. Tasted in November 2017.”
17.5
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2016
“Particularly fine and strong stream of bubbles with lots of lemon and lime notes and hints of tropical fruits like guava and pineapple and some creaminess that you don't often see in these non vintage champagnes. Nice and dry and lingering. Lovely today on a hot London day. This current cuvee must have its core part of the blend from one of the great vintages like 2010. Wish this was declared on the label.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2015
“Tasted blind. Overall score placed it fourth out of 12 wines. Light straw. Sweetish nose – one of the few! Candied violets on the nose. Light and off dry. Quite chunky, lime-marmalade impression. Not much undertow. Good texture and refreshment value on the finish. A little chew on the end. Lots of acidity underneath. ”
“This lightly Chardonnay-driven blend benefits from some 30% of reserve wines from the previous two harvests. Pale lemon-green colour. The lovely, fragrant sweetly fruity nose has ripe pear, crunchy red apple and zingy lemon. The palate is light and refreshing, but with a lovely fruit purity and intensity. Lingering silky palate and classy, creamy mousse. There is a lovely easiness and quaffing character to this. Dosage 9g/l”
More Reviews +
89/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
RobertParker.com,
Nov 2017
“Taittinger's NV Brut Reserve—a blend of more than 35 different vineyards, assembling 40% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir and 25% Pinot Meunier, including 30% reserve wines—has a clear, fresh and vinous bouquet with Pinot Meunier flavors in front. Bottled in 2014 and disgorged in March 2017 with nine grams of dosage, this is a lithe and fresh but mouth-filling Brut with round and aromatic fruit. It tastes almost as charming as the Rosé Prestige yet less vinous and is rather lean and fresh. Tasted in November 2017.”
17.5
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Jun 2016
“Particularly fine and strong stream of bubbles with lots of lemon and lime notes and hints of tropical fruits like guava and pineapple and some creaminess that you don't often see in these non vintage champagnes. Nice and dry and lingering. Lovely today on a hot London day. This current cuvee must have its core part of the blend from one of the great vintages like 2010. Wish this was declared on the label.”
16/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2015
“Tasted blind. Overall score placed it fourth out of 12 wines. Light straw. Sweetish nose – one of the few! Candied violets on the nose. Light and off dry. Quite chunky, lime-marmalade impression. Not much undertow. Good texture and refreshment value on the finish. A little chew on the end. Lots of acidity underneath. ”
“The 2016 vintage is characterized by its classically structured, rather fruit-forward but fresh wines. Only grand cru (70%) and premier cru sources were selected for this equal blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. There is a lovely gunpowdery whiff to the stylistically reserved nose. Cool, crunchy fruit profile of fresh yellow fruit, with a minty breeze to it. Well built and seamless, this ends on a rather sweet note. Worth cellaring. Dosage: 9g/l”
More Reviews +
97/100
Decanter World Wine Awards,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2024
“Outstanding elegance and finesse pervade this exceptional wine with its well-honed toasty sourdough, gunflint and grilled citrus notes, razor sharp acidity and mouth-filling mousse. Brilliantly poised and brimming with potential, the long and zesty finish runs and runs.”
17.5/20
Andy Howard MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2025
“50% Chardonnay, 50% Pinot Noir. 70% grand cru, 30% premier cru. Aged over 5 years on the lees. Dosage 9 g/l.
A very complete, delicious champagne, which will appeal to all tastes. Plenty of weight on the palate, complex aromas with hedgerow/floral notes to the fore. Ready to enjoy now but will keep.”
17.5++/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“The fruit is super expressive right from opening, a light smoky charm draws you into to expressive yellow fruits like ripe lemon, apple and hints of charred pineapple, the darker fruits emerge on the palate with plum and raspberry adding to the fruit. There is a lightness here which keeps it airy, the texture is super velvety and flavours linger. Super great example of 2016, a vintage I really look forward to seeing more releases. Drink now, lay down magnums for 10 years to see the wonders of Taittinger vintage ageing ability. 2004 Taittinger magnums are glorious now some 20 years on from harvest.”
93/100
Alison Napjus,
wineenthusiast.com,
Aug 2024
“This toasty Champagne features flavors of lemon curd, brioche, glazed apricot and vanilla-infused pastry cream riding a fine, lively mousse. Well-meshed and creamy, animated by vibrant acidity through the spiced finish. Chardonnay and Pinot Noir.”
“This toasty Champagne features flavors of lemon curd, brioche, glazed apricot and vanilla-infused pastry cream riding a fine, lively mousse. Well-meshed and creamy, animated by vibrant acidity through the spiced finish. Chardonnay and Pinot Noir.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2024
“The 2016 vintage is characterized by its classically structured, rather fruit-forward but fresh wines. Only grand cru (70%) and premier cru sources were selected for this equal blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. There is a lovely gunpowdery whiff to the stylistically reserved nose. Cool, crunchy fruit profile of fresh yellow fruit, with a minty breeze to it. Well built and seamless, this ends on a rather sweet note. Worth cellaring. Dosage: 9g/l”
97/100
Decanter World Wine Awards,
Decanter.com,
Sep 2024
“Outstanding elegance and finesse pervade this exceptional wine with its well-honed toasty sourdough, gunflint and grilled citrus notes, razor sharp acidity and mouth-filling mousse. Brilliantly poised and brimming with potential, the long and zesty finish runs and runs.”
17.5/20
Andy Howard MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Jun 2025
“50% Chardonnay, 50% Pinot Noir. 70% grand cru, 30% premier cru. Aged over 5 years on the lees. Dosage 9 g/l.
A very complete, delicious champagne, which will appeal to all tastes. Plenty of weight on the palate, complex aromas with hedgerow/floral notes to the fore. Ready to enjoy now but will keep.”
17.5++/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“The fruit is super expressive right from opening, a light smoky charm draws you into to expressive yellow fruits like ripe lemon, apple and hints of charred pineapple, the darker fruits emerge on the palate with plum and raspberry adding to the fruit. There is a lightness here which keeps it airy, the texture is super velvety and flavours linger. Super great example of 2016, a vintage I really look forward to seeing more releases. Drink now, lay down magnums for 10 years to see the wonders of Taittinger vintage ageing ability. 2004 Taittinger magnums are glorious now some 20 years on from harvest.”
“Taittinger Millésime is traditionally a 50/50 blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, with high-rated (70% grand cru) origins in the Côte des Blancs, Vallée de la Marne and Montagne de Reims. The fruity exuberance of red apple, lemon confit and poached pear meet a lovely toasty whiff on the overt nose. There is also a mild earthy vegetalness to it, which stays safely in the background. The palate is plush and full of fruit, but towards the finish the vegetal characters bring a note of austerity to the whole. A fruit-forward, generous vintage for mid-term drinking. Dosage 9g/l”
More Reviews +
93/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“This is a vivid Taittinger with notes of chalk, almond croissants, lemon curd and biscuits. Bright and linear, with a tight bead of bubbles. Focused with persistent pastry notes. 50% pinot noir and 50% chardonnay; 70% Grands Crus and 30% Premiers Crus. Drink or hold.”
93/100
Jeb Dunnuck,
Jebdunnuck.com,
Aug 2022
“The 2015 Champagne Millésime Brut is equal parts Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. The nose is fragrant with ripe peach and rose petal, and it has a rich texture, with a more viscous feel, and note of yellow flowers and Anjou pear. It speaks to the ripeness of the vintage, but it is long on the palate and has a light phenolic finish. I think this is ready to drink now.”
90/100
Decanter,
Decanter.com,
Aug 2022
“A classic style with honeyed creamy, quince and spices aromas. Lovely palate with hazelnuts and toasty notes. Attractive long finish. Blend : 50% Chardonnay, 50% Pinot Noir”
“Taittinger’s Vintage offers admirable consistency from vintage to vintage making it always a safe choice, and one that is worth following over a number of years. The impeccably fresh, deliciously fruity and fragrantly floral house style always comes across singing in the glass. The 2014’s youthful nose is tight and mineral still, with cool, crisp fruitiness of Granny Smith apple and lime with toasty complexity emerging in the glass. A refined and classically lean vintage with electric energy to it. ”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2020
“The newly released 2014 Brut Millésimé from Taittinger is showing very well, offering up aromas of white peach, green apple, nougat and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, bright and incisive, with a charming core of fruit and a delicate mousse, this is a pretty, expressive vintage for Taittinger. Sufficiently open and fruit-driven to be enjoyed, toasty complexity with come with a few years on cork.”
16+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Impressive autolysis on the nose. A lot of lemony froth and then a clean, flattering, crisp, well put together palate. I’d guess the dosage is very slightly higher than average nowadays (yes, it’s 9 g/l apparently) but the balance is good. A sort of mini Comtes?”
“Taittinger’s Vintage offers admirable consistency from vintage to vintage making it always a safe choice, and one that is worth following over a number of years. The impeccably fresh, deliciously fruity and fragrantly floral house style always comes across singing in the glass. The 2014’s youthful nose is tight and mineral still, with cool, crisp fruitiness of Granny Smith apple and lime with toasty complexity emerging in the glass. A refined and classically lean vintage with electric energy to it. ”
More Reviews +
92/100
William Kelley,
robertparker.com,
Sep 2020
“The newly released 2014 Brut Millésimé from Taittinger is showing very well, offering up aromas of white peach, green apple, nougat and freshly baked bread. Medium to full-bodied, bright and incisive, with a charming core of fruit and a delicate mousse, this is a pretty, expressive vintage for Taittinger. Sufficiently open and fruit-driven to be enjoyed, toasty complexity with come with a few years on cork.”
16+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Impressive autolysis on the nose. A lot of lemony froth and then a clean, flattering, crisp, well put together palate. I’d guess the dosage is very slightly higher than average nowadays (yes, it’s 9 g/l apparently) but the balance is good. A sort of mini Comtes?”
“Bright lemon yellow colour. Upon release the wine was reserved, not expressing much apart from very clean fruitiness of the primary kind. Lemon, pear drops, honey but mostly still smoky and mineral tones. On the light-weight and elegant palate there is silky texture and appetising tension to it. Lean, crisp and long with lots of promise but still not communicating all it has got. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Peter Moser,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2019
“Light greenish-yellow, silver reflections; very fine, persistent mousse. Nuances of fine white tropical fruit, a hint of fresh apricot, discreet minerality and biscuit crumbs. Juicy, good complexity, ripe yellow apple, discreet fruit expression on the finish, persistent. A balanced food wine with a salty finish.”
“Lovely yeast-complexed gunpowdery nose with lemon curd, meringue, white flowers. Superb acidity expressed as vitality and drive. Smooth and caressing but at the same time invigorating and energizing. Very youthful still shortly after release with potential.”
More Reviews +
17.5
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Feb 2017
“Good strong stream of bubbles. Initially on the nose you get lots of fresh apple and hints of baking bread and that creamy custard and french pastries that all come out more as you taste. There is a lovely freshness and delicacy to the mouthfeel, with ripe cooked apple richness and tantalising glimpses of that bricohe character. Good balance of acidity and roundness.”
16.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2018
“All grands and premiers crus. 50% Pinot Noir from the Montagne de Reims and Vallée de la Marne. 50% Chardonnay. Aged on lees for six years. Dosage 9 g/l .
Tasted blind. Smells a bit like putty. Quite rich and vibrant. Flattering. Chardonnay ascendant. Reminds me a little of a California Chard. Creamy, slightly sickly. The least impressive wine of the tasting. 2009?
Drink 2017-2021”
“Deep lemon colour. Layered, deep red fruit nose with a beautiful toasty overtone and leesy influence. Highly fruity, rich, muscular palate. Long and intense but quite obvious on the palate for the time being. ”
“Mellow soft white fruit nose with toast and honey. Rich, fruit-forward velvety palate refreshed by perky acidity, all elements finely intertwined to a seamless whole. Ready and perfectly generous but is still improving. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2012
“The 2005 Brut Millesime captures the essence of the vintage. Radiant, expressive and totally caressing, the 2005 offers up dried pears, cherries, hazelnuts, flowers and savory herbs, all with an exotic inner sweetness that is pure and totally beguiling. I don’t see the 2005 being a long-term ager, but it is absolutely beautiful today and should drink well for at least a handful of years. Anticipated maturity: 2012-2020.
”
“The 2014 Comtes de Champagne is pristine. In this tasting, it comes across as a mini-2008, similar in its linear personality, with just a touch more mid-palate creaminess. Readers will find a Comtes that plays in the realm of tension and energy. Citrus confit, white flowers, chalk, mint and chamomile are all finely sketched. Light tropical overtones grace the finish. What an absolute delight. The 2014 can be enjoyed now or cellared. Dosage is 9 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“This Comtes de Champagne opens with crystalline fruit; lemon meringue, pear, fruit drops, candied lime, and a hint of mint. Sweetly fruity yet marked by cool restraint, with a toasty nuance beginning to emerge. The palate is crisp and crunchy, glowing with sweet fruit appeal. An immediately rewarding Comtes that will gain more toasty glory with time. Disgorgement date:2024. Dosage:9g/l.”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
““Closed in style and character like the 2013, Taittinger's 2014 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne reveals aromas of ripe orchard fruit, confit citrus, dried flowers, herbs, spring blossoms and mirabelle mingled with customary autolytic notes. Full-bodied, seamless and enrobing, it has a delicate, elegant, fleshy core of fruit and racy acids, all enhanced by a saline, fresh and penetrating finish marked by finesse and elegance. This refined, chalky-inflected Comtes de Champagne has the potential to age gracefully over the next 30-40 years.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Occupying a stylistic middle ground between the incisiveness of the 2013 and the fleshier textures of the 2012, Taittinger’s 2014 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne—disgorged in July 2024 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—has turned out beautifully. It offers aromas of orange peel, peach, pear and brioche mingled with hazelnut and burnt buttered toast. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and textural, with a layered yet crisp core of fruit, considerable tension and a long, chalky finish. Harmonious and racy-fresh though it is, this is a marginally richer rendition than the 2013 tasted alongside it, yet both promise excellent longevity and will make for fascinating comparative tastings in the years to come.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2025
““Apricots, hazelnuts, lemons, white flowers, sliced almonds and hints of licorice on the nose. It's creamy and layered, with soft, rounded bubbles that spread across the palate. Lovely balance of breadth, ripeness and freshness, with delicious wildflower honey and nut notes lingering. 100% grand cru chardonnay from Avize, Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Cramant and Chouilly. Drink or hold.””
“The 2014 Comtes de Champagne is pristine. In this tasting, it comes across as a mini-2008, similar in its linear personality, with just a touch more mid-palate creaminess. Readers will find a Comtes that plays in the realm of tension and energy. Citrus confit, white flowers, chalk, mint and chamomile are all finely sketched. Light tropical overtones grace the finish. What an absolute delight. The 2014 can be enjoyed now or cellared. Dosage is 9 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“This Comtes de Champagne opens with crystalline fruit; lemon meringue, pear, fruit drops, candied lime, and a hint of mint. Sweetly fruity yet marked by cool restraint, with a toasty nuance beginning to emerge. The palate is crisp and crunchy, glowing with sweet fruit appeal. An immediately rewarding Comtes that will gain more toasty glory with time. Disgorgement date:2024. Dosage:9g/l.”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
““Closed in style and character like the 2013, Taittinger's 2014 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne reveals aromas of ripe orchard fruit, confit citrus, dried flowers, herbs, spring blossoms and mirabelle mingled with customary autolytic notes. Full-bodied, seamless and enrobing, it has a delicate, elegant, fleshy core of fruit and racy acids, all enhanced by a saline, fresh and penetrating finish marked by finesse and elegance. This refined, chalky-inflected Comtes de Champagne has the potential to age gracefully over the next 30-40 years.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Occupying a stylistic middle ground between the incisiveness of the 2013 and the fleshier textures of the 2012, Taittinger’s 2014 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne—disgorged in July 2024 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—has turned out beautifully. It offers aromas of orange peel, peach, pear and brioche mingled with hazelnut and burnt buttered toast. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and textural, with a layered yet crisp core of fruit, considerable tension and a long, chalky finish. Harmonious and racy-fresh though it is, this is a marginally richer rendition than the 2013 tasted alongside it, yet both promise excellent longevity and will make for fascinating comparative tastings in the years to come.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2025
““Apricots, hazelnuts, lemons, white flowers, sliced almonds and hints of licorice on the nose. It's creamy and layered, with soft, rounded bubbles that spread across the palate. Lovely balance of breadth, ripeness and freshness, with delicious wildflower honey and nut notes lingering. 100% grand cru chardonnay from Avize, Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Cramant and Chouilly. Drink or hold.””
“The 2014 Comtes de Champagne is pristine. In this tasting, it comes across as a mini-2008, similar in its linear personality, with just a touch more mid-palate creaminess. Readers will find a Comtes that plays in the realm of tension and energy. Citrus confit, white flowers, chalk, mint and chamomile are all finely sketched. Light tropical overtones grace the finish. What an absolute delight. The 2014 can be enjoyed now or cellared. Dosage is 9 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“This Comtes de Champagne opens with crystalline fruit; lemon meringue, pear, fruit drops, candied lime, and a hint of mint. Sweetly fruity yet marked by cool restraint, with a toasty nuance beginning to emerge. The palate is crisp and crunchy, glowing with sweet fruit appeal. An immediately rewarding Comtes that will gain more toasty glory with time. Disgorgement date:2024. Dosage:9g/l.”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
““Closed in style and character like the 2013, Taittinger's 2014 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne reveals aromas of ripe orchard fruit, confit citrus, dried flowers, herbs, spring blossoms and mirabelle mingled with customary autolytic notes. Full-bodied, seamless and enrobing, it has a delicate, elegant, fleshy core of fruit and racy acids, all enhanced by a saline, fresh and penetrating finish marked by finesse and elegance. This refined, chalky-inflected Comtes de Champagne has the potential to age gracefully over the next 30-40 years.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Occupying a stylistic middle ground between the incisiveness of the 2013 and the fleshier textures of the 2012, Taittinger’s 2014 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne—disgorged in July 2024 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—has turned out beautifully. It offers aromas of orange peel, peach, pear and brioche mingled with hazelnut and burnt buttered toast. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and textural, with a layered yet crisp core of fruit, considerable tension and a long, chalky finish. Harmonious and racy-fresh though it is, this is a marginally richer rendition than the 2013 tasted alongside it, yet both promise excellent longevity and will make for fascinating comparative tastings in the years to come.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2025
““Apricots, hazelnuts, lemons, white flowers, sliced almonds and hints of licorice on the nose. It's creamy and layered, with soft, rounded bubbles that spread across the palate. Lovely balance of breadth, ripeness and freshness, with delicious wildflower honey and nut notes lingering. 100% grand cru chardonnay from Avize, Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Cramant and Chouilly. Drink or hold.””
“The 2014 Comtes de Champagne is pristine. In this tasting, it comes across as a mini-2008, similar in its linear personality, with just a touch more mid-palate creaminess. Readers will find a Comtes that plays in the realm of tension and energy. Citrus confit, white flowers, chalk, mint and chamomile are all finely sketched. Light tropical overtones grace the finish. What an absolute delight. The 2014 can be enjoyed now or cellared. Dosage is 9 grams per liter.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Club Oenologique.com,
Aug 2025
“This Comtes de Champagne opens with crystalline fruit; lemon meringue, pear, fruit drops, candied lime, and a hint of mint. Sweetly fruity yet marked by cool restraint, with a toasty nuance beginning to emerge. The palate is crisp and crunchy, glowing with sweet fruit appeal. An immediately rewarding Comtes that will gain more toasty glory with time. Disgorgement date:2024. Dosage:9g/l.”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
““Closed in style and character like the 2013, Taittinger's 2014 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne reveals aromas of ripe orchard fruit, confit citrus, dried flowers, herbs, spring blossoms and mirabelle mingled with customary autolytic notes. Full-bodied, seamless and enrobing, it has a delicate, elegant, fleshy core of fruit and racy acids, all enhanced by a saline, fresh and penetrating finish marked by finesse and elegance. This refined, chalky-inflected Comtes de Champagne has the potential to age gracefully over the next 30-40 years.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Occupying a stylistic middle ground between the incisiveness of the 2013 and the fleshier textures of the 2012, Taittinger’s 2014 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne—disgorged in July 2024 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—has turned out beautifully. It offers aromas of orange peel, peach, pear and brioche mingled with hazelnut and burnt buttered toast. On the palate, it is full-bodied, ample and textural, with a layered yet crisp core of fruit, considerable tension and a long, chalky finish. Harmonious and racy-fresh though it is, this is a marginally richer rendition than the 2013 tasted alongside it, yet both promise excellent longevity and will make for fascinating comparative tastings in the years to come.”
97/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2025
““Apricots, hazelnuts, lemons, white flowers, sliced almonds and hints of licorice on the nose. It's creamy and layered, with soft, rounded bubbles that spread across the palate. Lovely balance of breadth, ripeness and freshness, with delicious wildflower honey and nut notes lingering. 100% grand cru chardonnay from Avize, Mesnil-sur-Oger, Oger, Cramant and Chouilly. Drink or hold.””
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne is a towering Champagne, as it was last year. Rich, sumptuous and explosive, the 2013 soars out of the glass with a captivating mix of tropical fruit, apricot, passion fruit, baked apple tart, mint and yellow flowers. It is one of the most explosive, extroverted Comtes I have ever tasted. Impressive. Drink 2025-2053.”
More Reviews +
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Taittinger’s 2013 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, disgorged in December 2023 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, is well worth seeking out. Derived from a long, slow ripening season marked by cool nights and an October harvest, it is slightly less acid-driven and a touch fleshier than the 2008, offering up a deep bouquet of nashi pear, lemon confit, freshly baked bread, almond paste and a gentle smoky reduction edge. On the palate, it is full-bodied and incisive, with a concentrated core of fruit, bright acids and considerable tension, culminating in a persistent, saline finish. While already indicative of its potential, its best days are still ahead, and it should continue to improve over the next two decades or more. Choosing a favorite between the 2013 and 2014 will be difficult, as both are strong editions of Comtes.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
Jul 2023
“Elegantly charred nose with ripe white fruit profile. Youthful, holding back a lot for the time being. Some candy tones and juicy fruit on the vibrant palate of pristine fruit quality. Aptly dosed, deliciously fruity finish. This will greatly reward ageing. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Dec 2023
“Pale lemony straw colour. This seems to have the characteristic intricate sort-of 'embroidered' nose – lots going on there but still delicate. Masses of lemon-curd flavours and a bit of something mineral. Much more refreshing than the 2011 rosé counterpart although there is lots of fruit on the finish too. The polar opposite of a grower's Zero Dosage! But very luxuriously textured and, with its marked acidity, definitely a champagne that will repay ageing. Drink 2023-2035. (JR)”
96/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
May 2024
“Tasted six months on from release, the restrained quality of this vintage is shining a little brighter with its lime leaf, floral honey and green mango scents, touches of oyster shell and an emerging floral honey depth, with few signs of outgoing creaminess or nuttiness just yet. Citric juiciness drives the narrow, long palate, perfectly built for ageing; this continues to be a vintage to watch. A blend of all the grand cru villages of the Côte des Blancs. Drink 2024-2040.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2023
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne captures all the pedigree of this great vintage in its energy, depth and vibrancy. Lemon confit, dried flowers, chamomile, spice and crushed rocks all race across the palate. Passionfruit, ginger, marzipan and mint appear later, filling out the layers beautifully. Harvest took place in October in what has become the exception rather than the norm in Champagne.”
98/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2023
“Nervy and tight with notes of crushed almonds, chalk, white grapefruit, digestive biscuits, lemons and apricot stones. Hints of fennel and white pepper. Deep and mineral, with plenty of power. Very fine bubbles. Long drive at the end. Try after 2024.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2023
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne's bouquet is compellingly fresh and minty, revealing aromas of white fruit—notably pear and apple—marzipan and sweet spices, as well as a light touch of citrus mingled with classy autolytic notes. On the palate, this is a structured, tensile and ethereal Champagne with high acidity—a sign of a classic vintage—animated by a mousse of striking finesse and delicacy. Although already enjoyable, it should develop well for several decades.
This concise review highlights Taittinger's newly released 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, a standout cuvée from the house, shaped by the vintage's classic profile. Aficionados of this cuvée will be pleased to find that it exemplifies the distinctive style that has garnered Comtes’s global recognition.”
95/100
Sarah Mayo,
thewineindependent.com,
Sep 2023
“Taittinger’s 2013 Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs captures an abundance of finesse from Champagne’s cooler 2013 vintage. Mineral-rich and taut, it opens with honeyed notes of ripe citrus, poached nashi pear, butter wafers, and crème fraiche that gradually gain aromatic intensity as it unfurls. Light to medium-bodied, it has well-heeled, vibrant acidity that lends an energetic tension and freshness to the long, toasty finish. This subtly assertive and refined Comtes de Champagne should evolve beautifully with bottle age for 15+ years. Drink 2023-2040.”
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne is a towering Champagne, as it was last year. Rich, sumptuous and explosive, the 2013 soars out of the glass with a captivating mix of tropical fruit, apricot, passion fruit, baked apple tart, mint and yellow flowers. It is one of the most explosive, extroverted Comtes I have ever tasted. Impressive. Drink 2025-2053.”
More Reviews +
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Taittinger’s 2013 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, disgorged in December 2023 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, is well worth seeking out. Derived from a long, slow ripening season marked by cool nights and an October harvest, it is slightly less acid-driven and a touch fleshier than the 2008, offering up a deep bouquet of nashi pear, lemon confit, freshly baked bread, almond paste and a gentle smoky reduction edge. On the palate, it is full-bodied and incisive, with a concentrated core of fruit, bright acids and considerable tension, culminating in a persistent, saline finish. While already indicative of its potential, its best days are still ahead, and it should continue to improve over the next two decades or more. Choosing a favorite between the 2013 and 2014 will be difficult, as both are strong editions of Comtes.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
Jul 2023
“Elegantly charred nose with ripe white fruit profile. Youthful, holding back a lot for the time being. Some candy tones and juicy fruit on the vibrant palate of pristine fruit quality. Aptly dosed, deliciously fruity finish. This will greatly reward ageing. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Dec 2023
“Pale lemony straw colour. This seems to have the characteristic intricate sort-of 'embroidered' nose – lots going on there but still delicate. Masses of lemon-curd flavours and a bit of something mineral. Much more refreshing than the 2011 rosé counterpart although there is lots of fruit on the finish too. The polar opposite of a grower's Zero Dosage! But very luxuriously textured and, with its marked acidity, definitely a champagne that will repay ageing. Drink 2023-2035. (JR)”
96/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
May 2024
“Tasted six months on from release, the restrained quality of this vintage is shining a little brighter with its lime leaf, floral honey and green mango scents, touches of oyster shell and an emerging floral honey depth, with few signs of outgoing creaminess or nuttiness just yet. Citric juiciness drives the narrow, long palate, perfectly built for ageing; this continues to be a vintage to watch. A blend of all the grand cru villages of the Côte des Blancs. Drink 2024-2040.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2023
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne captures all the pedigree of this great vintage in its energy, depth and vibrancy. Lemon confit, dried flowers, chamomile, spice and crushed rocks all race across the palate. Passionfruit, ginger, marzipan and mint appear later, filling out the layers beautifully. Harvest took place in October in what has become the exception rather than the norm in Champagne.”
98/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2023
“Nervy and tight with notes of crushed almonds, chalk, white grapefruit, digestive biscuits, lemons and apricot stones. Hints of fennel and white pepper. Deep and mineral, with plenty of power. Very fine bubbles. Long drive at the end. Try after 2024.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2023
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne's bouquet is compellingly fresh and minty, revealing aromas of white fruit—notably pear and apple—marzipan and sweet spices, as well as a light touch of citrus mingled with classy autolytic notes. On the palate, this is a structured, tensile and ethereal Champagne with high acidity—a sign of a classic vintage—animated by a mousse of striking finesse and delicacy. Although already enjoyable, it should develop well for several decades.
This concise review highlights Taittinger's newly released 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, a standout cuvée from the house, shaped by the vintage's classic profile. Aficionados of this cuvée will be pleased to find that it exemplifies the distinctive style that has garnered Comtes’s global recognition.”
95/100
Sarah Mayo,
thewineindependent.com,
Sep 2023
“Taittinger’s 2013 Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs captures an abundance of finesse from Champagne’s cooler 2013 vintage. Mineral-rich and taut, it opens with honeyed notes of ripe citrus, poached nashi pear, butter wafers, and crème fraiche that gradually gain aromatic intensity as it unfurls. Light to medium-bodied, it has well-heeled, vibrant acidity that lends an energetic tension and freshness to the long, toasty finish. This subtly assertive and refined Comtes de Champagne should evolve beautifully with bottle age for 15+ years. Drink 2023-2040.”
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne is a towering Champagne, as it was last year. Rich, sumptuous and explosive, the 2013 soars out of the glass with a captivating mix of tropical fruit, apricot, passion fruit, baked apple tart, mint and yellow flowers. It is one of the most explosive, extroverted Comtes I have ever tasted. Impressive. Drink 2025-2053.”
More Reviews +
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Taittinger’s 2013 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, disgorged in December 2023 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, is well worth seeking out. Derived from a long, slow ripening season marked by cool nights and an October harvest, it is slightly less acid-driven and a touch fleshier than the 2008, offering up a deep bouquet of nashi pear, lemon confit, freshly baked bread, almond paste and a gentle smoky reduction edge. On the palate, it is full-bodied and incisive, with a concentrated core of fruit, bright acids and considerable tension, culminating in a persistent, saline finish. While already indicative of its potential, its best days are still ahead, and it should continue to improve over the next two decades or more. Choosing a favorite between the 2013 and 2014 will be difficult, as both are strong editions of Comtes.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
Jul 2023
“Elegantly charred nose with ripe white fruit profile. Youthful, holding back a lot for the time being. Some candy tones and juicy fruit on the vibrant palate of pristine fruit quality. Aptly dosed, deliciously fruity finish. This will greatly reward ageing. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Dec 2023
“Pale lemony straw colour. This seems to have the characteristic intricate sort-of 'embroidered' nose – lots going on there but still delicate. Masses of lemon-curd flavours and a bit of something mineral. Much more refreshing than the 2011 rosé counterpart although there is lots of fruit on the finish too. The polar opposite of a grower's Zero Dosage! But very luxuriously textured and, with its marked acidity, definitely a champagne that will repay ageing. Drink 2023-2035. (JR)”
96/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
May 2024
“Tasted six months on from release, the restrained quality of this vintage is shining a little brighter with its lime leaf, floral honey and green mango scents, touches of oyster shell and an emerging floral honey depth, with few signs of outgoing creaminess or nuttiness just yet. Citric juiciness drives the narrow, long palate, perfectly built for ageing; this continues to be a vintage to watch. A blend of all the grand cru villages of the Côte des Blancs. Drink 2024-2040.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2023
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne captures all the pedigree of this great vintage in its energy, depth and vibrancy. Lemon confit, dried flowers, chamomile, spice and crushed rocks all race across the palate. Passionfruit, ginger, marzipan and mint appear later, filling out the layers beautifully. Harvest took place in October in what has become the exception rather than the norm in Champagne.”
98/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2023
“Nervy and tight with notes of crushed almonds, chalk, white grapefruit, digestive biscuits, lemons and apricot stones. Hints of fennel and white pepper. Deep and mineral, with plenty of power. Very fine bubbles. Long drive at the end. Try after 2024.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2023
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne's bouquet is compellingly fresh and minty, revealing aromas of white fruit—notably pear and apple—marzipan and sweet spices, as well as a light touch of citrus mingled with classy autolytic notes. On the palate, this is a structured, tensile and ethereal Champagne with high acidity—a sign of a classic vintage—animated by a mousse of striking finesse and delicacy. Although already enjoyable, it should develop well for several decades.
This concise review highlights Taittinger's newly released 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, a standout cuvée from the house, shaped by the vintage's classic profile. Aficionados of this cuvée will be pleased to find that it exemplifies the distinctive style that has garnered Comtes’s global recognition.”
95/100
Sarah Mayo,
thewineindependent.com,
Sep 2023
“Taittinger’s 2013 Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs captures an abundance of finesse from Champagne’s cooler 2013 vintage. Mineral-rich and taut, it opens with honeyed notes of ripe citrus, poached nashi pear, butter wafers, and crème fraiche that gradually gain aromatic intensity as it unfurls. Light to medium-bodied, it has well-heeled, vibrant acidity that lends an energetic tension and freshness to the long, toasty finish. This subtly assertive and refined Comtes de Champagne should evolve beautifully with bottle age for 15+ years. Drink 2023-2040.”
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne is a towering Champagne, as it was last year. Rich, sumptuous and explosive, the 2013 soars out of the glass with a captivating mix of tropical fruit, apricot, passion fruit, baked apple tart, mint and yellow flowers. It is one of the most explosive, extroverted Comtes I have ever tasted. Impressive. Drink 2025-2053.”
More Reviews +
96+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Taittinger’s 2013 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, disgorged in December 2023 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, is well worth seeking out. Derived from a long, slow ripening season marked by cool nights and an October harvest, it is slightly less acid-driven and a touch fleshier than the 2008, offering up a deep bouquet of nashi pear, lemon confit, freshly baked bread, almond paste and a gentle smoky reduction edge. On the palate, it is full-bodied and incisive, with a concentrated core of fruit, bright acids and considerable tension, culminating in a persistent, saline finish. While already indicative of its potential, its best days are still ahead, and it should continue to improve over the next two decades or more. Choosing a favorite between the 2013 and 2014 will be difficult, as both are strong editions of Comtes.”
96-99/100
Essi Avellan MW,
Essiavellan.com,
Jul 2023
“Elegantly charred nose with ripe white fruit profile. Youthful, holding back a lot for the time being. Some candy tones and juicy fruit on the vibrant palate of pristine fruit quality. Aptly dosed, deliciously fruity finish. This will greatly reward ageing. ”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Dec 2023
“Pale lemony straw colour. This seems to have the characteristic intricate sort-of 'embroidered' nose – lots going on there but still delicate. Masses of lemon-curd flavours and a bit of something mineral. Much more refreshing than the 2011 rosé counterpart although there is lots of fruit on the finish too. The polar opposite of a grower's Zero Dosage! But very luxuriously textured and, with its marked acidity, definitely a champagne that will repay ageing. Drink 2023-2035. (JR)”
96/100
Tom Hewson,
Decanter.com,
May 2024
“Tasted six months on from release, the restrained quality of this vintage is shining a little brighter with its lime leaf, floral honey and green mango scents, touches of oyster shell and an emerging floral honey depth, with few signs of outgoing creaminess or nuttiness just yet. Citric juiciness drives the narrow, long palate, perfectly built for ageing; this continues to be a vintage to watch. A blend of all the grand cru villages of the Côte des Blancs. Drink 2024-2040.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
May 2023
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne captures all the pedigree of this great vintage in its energy, depth and vibrancy. Lemon confit, dried flowers, chamomile, spice and crushed rocks all race across the palate. Passionfruit, ginger, marzipan and mint appear later, filling out the layers beautifully. Harvest took place in October in what has become the exception rather than the norm in Champagne.”
98/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2023
“Nervy and tight with notes of crushed almonds, chalk, white grapefruit, digestive biscuits, lemons and apricot stones. Hints of fennel and white pepper. Deep and mineral, with plenty of power. Very fine bubbles. Long drive at the end. Try after 2024.”
96/100
Yohan Castaing,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2023
“The 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne's bouquet is compellingly fresh and minty, revealing aromas of white fruit—notably pear and apple—marzipan and sweet spices, as well as a light touch of citrus mingled with classy autolytic notes. On the palate, this is a structured, tensile and ethereal Champagne with high acidity—a sign of a classic vintage—animated by a mousse of striking finesse and delicacy. Although already enjoyable, it should develop well for several decades.
This concise review highlights Taittinger's newly released 2013 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, a standout cuvée from the house, shaped by the vintage's classic profile. Aficionados of this cuvée will be pleased to find that it exemplifies the distinctive style that has garnered Comtes’s global recognition.”
95/100
Sarah Mayo,
thewineindependent.com,
Sep 2023
“Taittinger’s 2013 Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs captures an abundance of finesse from Champagne’s cooler 2013 vintage. Mineral-rich and taut, it opens with honeyed notes of ripe citrus, poached nashi pear, butter wafers, and crème fraiche that gradually gain aromatic intensity as it unfurls. Light to medium-bodied, it has well-heeled, vibrant acidity that lends an energetic tension and freshness to the long, toasty finish. This subtly assertive and refined Comtes de Champagne should evolve beautifully with bottle age for 15+ years. Drink 2023-2040.”
“As usual, the 2012 Comtes de Champagne is a classic blend of the five Côte des Blancs grands crus Avize, Chouilly, Cramant, Oger and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger. This is as classic a recipe as it gets, and it works like a dream. Right upon launch now, it holds back plenty but also gives generously, promising a lot. It's rich and expressive on the nose, with gorgeous toast-lined fruit of the utmost purity. Comtes de Champagne's hallmark toasty layers are already there and increasing. The palate is intense and structured, coming with fine nervosity and tension. Refined, linear and long. This is sheer perfection already, but it's greatly ageworthy. Despite the small yields of the year, an average good volume of Comtes was produced.”
More Reviews +
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2022
“The 2012 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne is showing beautifully out of the gates, offering up demonstrative aromas of sweet golden orchard fruit, buttery croissants, peach and hazelnuts. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and enveloping, it's a rich, textural, vinous Comtes somewhat reminiscent of the brilliant 2002. If it gains in tension and cut (as the 2002 did and as I suspect the 2012 will) with more time on cork, it will make this initial rating seem conservative.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Some smokiness on the nose. Lemony, youthful and still quite tight with a detailed undertow – lots going on there! Lacy texture and impressive length. This one will run and run and seems at this stage to have more pronounced acidity than some of its precursors.
Drink 2022–2040”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2022
“The 2012 Comtes de Champagne is gorgeous. Warm and resonant in the glass, the 2012 Comtes shows all the allure that makes this vintage so appealing. The combination of bright citrus, mineral and floral notes typical of Comtes, enhanced by the soft contours of the vintage, makes for an inviting, open-knit Champagne that is quite showy right out of the gate. Light tropical accents on the finish add an exotic flair. Usually I recommend cellaring just-released Comtes, but that won’t be necessary here.”
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“This is a fantastic and refined Blanc de Blancs. So layered and complex, with lemon curd, chalk, hazelnuts, pastries, baked apples and almond croissants. Structured and tightly wound, with almost imperceptible bubbles. Delicious salty notes at the end. Beautiful. Drink or hold.”
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“From a high-maturity vintage shaped by a mid-September harvest and reduced yields owing to significant frost and mildew pressure, the 2012 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne—disgorged in 2022 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—is showing nicely, offering aromas of mocha, pear, peach and dried flowers mingled with notes of browned, buttered toast. Full-bodied, deep and muscular, with a sweet, enveloping core of fruit, it is an ample and textural Comtes, though without the tension of the 2013 or 2014 editions, and it will age on its concentration rather than its acidity.”
“As usual, the 2012 Comtes de Champagne is a classic blend of the five Côte des Blancs grands crus Avize, Chouilly, Cramant, Oger and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger. This is as classic a recipe as it gets, and it works like a dream. Right upon launch now, it holds back plenty but also gives generously, promising a lot. It's rich and expressive on the nose, with gorgeous toast-lined fruit of the utmost purity. Comtes de Champagne's hallmark toasty layers are already there and increasing. The palate is intense and structured, coming with fine nervosity and tension. Refined, linear and long. This is sheer perfection already, but it's greatly ageworthy. Despite the small yields of the year, an average good volume of Comtes was produced.”
More Reviews +
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2022
“The 2012 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne is showing beautifully out of the gates, offering up demonstrative aromas of sweet golden orchard fruit, buttery croissants, peach and hazelnuts. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and enveloping, it's a rich, textural, vinous Comtes somewhat reminiscent of the brilliant 2002. If it gains in tension and cut (as the 2002 did and as I suspect the 2012 will) with more time on cork, it will make this initial rating seem conservative.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Some smokiness on the nose. Lemony, youthful and still quite tight with a detailed undertow – lots going on there! Lacy texture and impressive length. This one will run and run and seems at this stage to have more pronounced acidity than some of its precursors.
Drink 2022–2040”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2022
“The 2012 Comtes de Champagne is gorgeous. Warm and resonant in the glass, the 2012 Comtes shows all the allure that makes this vintage so appealing. The combination of bright citrus, mineral and floral notes typical of Comtes, enhanced by the soft contours of the vintage, makes for an inviting, open-knit Champagne that is quite showy right out of the gate. Light tropical accents on the finish add an exotic flair. Usually I recommend cellaring just-released Comtes, but that won’t be necessary here.”
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“This is a fantastic and refined Blanc de Blancs. So layered and complex, with lemon curd, chalk, hazelnuts, pastries, baked apples and almond croissants. Structured and tightly wound, with almost imperceptible bubbles. Delicious salty notes at the end. Beautiful. Drink or hold.”
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“From a high-maturity vintage shaped by a mid-September harvest and reduced yields owing to significant frost and mildew pressure, the 2012 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne—disgorged in 2022 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—is showing nicely, offering aromas of mocha, pear, peach and dried flowers mingled with notes of browned, buttered toast. Full-bodied, deep and muscular, with a sweet, enveloping core of fruit, it is an ample and textural Comtes, though without the tension of the 2013 or 2014 editions, and it will age on its concentration rather than its acidity.”
“As usual, the 2012 Comtes de Champagne is a classic blend of the five Côte des Blancs grands crus Avize, Chouilly, Cramant, Oger and Le Mesnil-sur-Oger. This is as classic a recipe as it gets, and it works like a dream. Right upon launch now, it holds back plenty but also gives generously, promising a lot. It's rich and expressive on the nose, with gorgeous toast-lined fruit of the utmost purity. Comtes de Champagne's hallmark toasty layers are already there and increasing. The palate is intense and structured, coming with fine nervosity and tension. Refined, linear and long. This is sheer perfection already, but it's greatly ageworthy. Despite the small yields of the year, an average good volume of Comtes was produced.”
More Reviews +
95+/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2022
“The 2012 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne is showing beautifully out of the gates, offering up demonstrative aromas of sweet golden orchard fruit, buttery croissants, peach and hazelnuts. Medium to full-bodied, pillowy and enveloping, it's a rich, textural, vinous Comtes somewhat reminiscent of the brilliant 2002. If it gains in tension and cut (as the 2002 did and as I suspect the 2012 will) with more time on cork, it will make this initial rating seem conservative.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Some smokiness on the nose. Lemony, youthful and still quite tight with a detailed undertow – lots going on there! Lacy texture and impressive length. This one will run and run and seems at this stage to have more pronounced acidity than some of its precursors.
Drink 2022–2040”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
May 2022
“The 2012 Comtes de Champagne is gorgeous. Warm and resonant in the glass, the 2012 Comtes shows all the allure that makes this vintage so appealing. The combination of bright citrus, mineral and floral notes typical of Comtes, enhanced by the soft contours of the vintage, makes for an inviting, open-knit Champagne that is quite showy right out of the gate. Light tropical accents on the finish add an exotic flair. Usually I recommend cellaring just-released Comtes, but that won’t be necessary here.”
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2022
“This is a fantastic and refined Blanc de Blancs. So layered and complex, with lemon curd, chalk, hazelnuts, pastries, baked apples and almond croissants. Structured and tightly wound, with almost imperceptible bubbles. Delicious salty notes at the end. Beautiful. Drink or hold.”
95+/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“From a high-maturity vintage shaped by a mid-September harvest and reduced yields owing to significant frost and mildew pressure, the 2012 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne—disgorged in 2022 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—is showing nicely, offering aromas of mocha, pear, peach and dried flowers mingled with notes of browned, buttered toast. Full-bodied, deep and muscular, with a sweet, enveloping core of fruit, it is an ample and textural Comtes, though without the tension of the 2013 or 2014 editions, and it will age on its concentration rather than its acidity.”
“After the tightly coiled, hyper-concentrated 2008, Taittinger's 2011 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne represents a more immediate, charming rendition of this cuvée. Bursting from the glass with aromas of orchard and stone fruit mingled with notions of pastry cream, blanched almonds and mandarin, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and fleshy, with a soft and enveloping profile, lively acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse. Readers might think of the 2011 as a somewhat less reductive and less intense stylistic sibling of the 2006, and as it takes on more toasty complexity with bottle age, it will make for immensely seductive drinking.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“A small-sized harvest from a difficult year with Chardonnay as the only performer. Bright, shiny lemon-green colour. On the charmingly open nose, Comtes's hallmark toasty deliciousness envelops plentiful orchard and stone fruit. With time in the glass, the glorious gunpowdery whiff is enhanced, but a mild vegetal note surfaces alongside it. The palate is joyously playful, with lovely silkiness carrying the lightweight, fresh wine. Long, juicy finish. A great effort for 2011. Dosage 8g/l”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Quite a deep greenish primrose yellow. Meaty, substantial, quite savoury evolution on the nose. Bone-dry finish but no shortage of rather captivating fruit before then. Very appetising with good steady bead and no aggressive froth. A very successful Comtes with a deep undertow. This may have been a challenging vintage but the Taittinger team seem to have risen well to the challenges.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Exquisite candied lemon and the first stirrings of blossom honey play on the nose before green apple and freshly toasted white bread appear. The body is slender but concentrated, a shimmering, silvery thread of freshness is woven throughout. The bubbles are creamy and smooth, An intriguing aftertaste of liquorice and subtle chalkiness pervade the zesty, smooth finish. A citric highway of beauty.”
97/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Apr 2021
“A firm, fresh Comtes with a tight and composed palate. It's full-bodied with a racy mid-palate. Long and persistent. Very structured with phenolics and acidity. Minerally. Floral, too. Refreshing and energetic. September 2021 release.”
“After the tightly coiled, hyper-concentrated 2008, Taittinger's 2011 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne represents a more immediate, charming rendition of this cuvée. Bursting from the glass with aromas of orchard and stone fruit mingled with notions of pastry cream, blanched almonds and mandarin, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and fleshy, with a soft and enveloping profile, lively acids and a pretty pinpoint mousse. Readers might think of the 2011 as a somewhat less reductive and less intense stylistic sibling of the 2006, and as it takes on more toasty complexity with bottle age, it will make for immensely seductive drinking.”
More Reviews +
94/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“A small-sized harvest from a difficult year with Chardonnay as the only performer. Bright, shiny lemon-green colour. On the charmingly open nose, Comtes's hallmark toasty deliciousness envelops plentiful orchard and stone fruit. With time in the glass, the glorious gunpowdery whiff is enhanced, but a mild vegetal note surfaces alongside it. The palate is joyously playful, with lovely silkiness carrying the lightweight, fresh wine. Long, juicy finish. A great effort for 2011. Dosage 8g/l”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2021
“Quite a deep greenish primrose yellow. Meaty, substantial, quite savoury evolution on the nose. Bone-dry finish but no shortage of rather captivating fruit before then. Very appetising with good steady bead and no aggressive froth. A very successful Comtes with a deep undertow. This may have been a challenging vintage but the Taittinger team seem to have risen well to the challenges.”
96/100
Anne Krebiehl MW,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2021
“Exquisite candied lemon and the first stirrings of blossom honey play on the nose before green apple and freshly toasted white bread appear. The body is slender but concentrated, a shimmering, silvery thread of freshness is woven throughout. The bubbles are creamy and smooth, An intriguing aftertaste of liquorice and subtle chalkiness pervade the zesty, smooth finish. A citric highway of beauty.”
97/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Apr 2021
“A firm, fresh Comtes with a tight and composed palate. It's full-bodied with a racy mid-palate. Long and persistent. Very structured with phenolics and acidity. Minerally. Floral, too. Refreshing and energetic. September 2021 release.”
“Tasted in magnum. Disgorged December 2018.
Aged under cork, which may explain why the magnum is actually much more aromatic and advanced than the bottle. Really exciting reductive custard powder! Lovely energy and refreshment.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“Taittinger's 2007 Comtes de Champagne will be nearly impossible to resist upon release. Soaring aromatics, mid-weight structure and soft contours give the 2007 its alluring personality. Lemon oil, white flowers, mint, chamomile and green pear add brightness and freshness throughout, with a persistent, clean finish that makes it impossible to resist a second taste. Today, the 2007 comes across as a slightly more open version of the 2004, with freshness that makes that wine so appealing, and a touch of textural richness that recalls the 2002. Although the 2007 does not have the explosive energy or verticality of the profound 2006, it will drink better earlier. The 2007 has been positively brilliant on the three occasions I have tasted it so far.”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2020
“Fresh fragrant nose with floral tones. Attractive cool fruitiness with a touch of vanilla. Comes with cool freutiness and stylish restraint. Crisp palate with super smooth texture and fine intensity. Playful, bright fruity style with elegance. Feisty, invigorating acidity and long mineral length. ”
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“The 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne continues to show very well, and it hasn't evolved appreciably since I last tasted it a few months ago. Revealing a pretty bouquet of lemon oil, lily pollen, dried white flowers, blanched almonds and crushed chalk, it's medium to full-bodied, chiseled and tensile, with excellent depth at the core, racy acids and a pure, precise and notably chalky finish. Tight-knit without being austere, it's a very classically balanced middleweight Comtes that has a long future ahead of it.”
“Tasted in magnum. Disgorged December 2018.
Aged under cork, which may explain why the magnum is actually much more aromatic and advanced than the bottle. Really exciting reductive custard powder! Lovely energy and refreshment.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“Taittinger's 2007 Comtes de Champagne will be nearly impossible to resist upon release. Soaring aromatics, mid-weight structure and soft contours give the 2007 its alluring personality. Lemon oil, white flowers, mint, chamomile and green pear add brightness and freshness throughout, with a persistent, clean finish that makes it impossible to resist a second taste. Today, the 2007 comes across as a slightly more open version of the 2004, with freshness that makes that wine so appealing, and a touch of textural richness that recalls the 2002. Although the 2007 does not have the explosive energy or verticality of the profound 2006, it will drink better earlier. The 2007 has been positively brilliant on the three occasions I have tasted it so far.”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2020
“Fresh fragrant nose with floral tones. Attractive cool fruitiness with a touch of vanilla. Comes with cool freutiness and stylish restraint. Crisp palate with super smooth texture and fine intensity. Playful, bright fruity style with elegance. Feisty, invigorating acidity and long mineral length. ”
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“The 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne continues to show very well, and it hasn't evolved appreciably since I last tasted it a few months ago. Revealing a pretty bouquet of lemon oil, lily pollen, dried white flowers, blanched almonds and crushed chalk, it's medium to full-bodied, chiseled and tensile, with excellent depth at the core, racy acids and a pure, precise and notably chalky finish. Tight-knit without being austere, it's a very classically balanced middleweight Comtes that has a long future ahead of it.”
“Tasted in magnum. Disgorged December 2018.
Aged under cork, which may explain why the magnum is actually much more aromatic and advanced than the bottle. Really exciting reductive custard powder! Lovely energy and refreshment.”
More Reviews +
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
Vinous.com,
Jul 2018
“Taittinger's 2007 Comtes de Champagne will be nearly impossible to resist upon release. Soaring aromatics, mid-weight structure and soft contours give the 2007 its alluring personality. Lemon oil, white flowers, mint, chamomile and green pear add brightness and freshness throughout, with a persistent, clean finish that makes it impossible to resist a second taste. Today, the 2007 comes across as a slightly more open version of the 2004, with freshness that makes that wine so appealing, and a touch of textural richness that recalls the 2002. Although the 2007 does not have the explosive energy or verticality of the profound 2006, it will drink better earlier. The 2007 has been positively brilliant on the three occasions I have tasted it so far.”
93-95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2020
“Fresh fragrant nose with floral tones. Attractive cool fruitiness with a touch of vanilla. Comes with cool freutiness and stylish restraint. Crisp palate with super smooth texture and fine intensity. Playful, bright fruity style with elegance. Feisty, invigorating acidity and long mineral length. ”
95/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Aug 2019
“The 2007 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne continues to show very well, and it hasn't evolved appreciably since I last tasted it a few months ago. Revealing a pretty bouquet of lemon oil, lily pollen, dried white flowers, blanched almonds and crushed chalk, it's medium to full-bodied, chiseled and tensile, with excellent depth at the core, racy acids and a pure, precise and notably chalky finish. Tight-knit without being austere, it's a very classically balanced middleweight Comtes that has a long future ahead of it.”
“The 2006 Comtes de Champagne is in a great spot. Baked apple tart, spice, chamomile, marzipan, slate and chalk confer tremendous vibrancy and power throughout. Bright saline notes play off the natural exuberance of the year. The 2006 was spectacular on release. It is all that today, too.”
More Reviews +
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Mar 2025
“A lovely bottle drinking beautifully now. Tight bead, neat composition, lemon-flavoured and creamy-textured. Still very fresh indeed for an 18-year-old wine.”
96/100
Stephan Reinhardt,
Robertparker.com,
Jun 2018
“Tasted almost two years after disgorgement, the 2006 Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs shows a beautiful golden-citrus color and opens with a fascinating intense, floral, slightly reductive nose that develops enormously in the glass, offering lemon and lemon confit aromas along with flinty notes of crushed chalk and the iodine flavors of the Atlantic Ocean. This is an utterly complex and promising bouquet! The palate is terribly fresh but also rich, lush and intense, with the purity of the finest wines of the Côte de Blancs, the concentration of perfectly ripe Chardonnay and the suppleness of 2006. This has impeccable balance paired with high tension. The wine is very tight and still seems to be on its way right now. Although there is a first hint of aromatic ripeness, this should be a great Comtes de Champagne in a couple of years. The finish is tensioned, concentrated and mineral but keeps its talents in an almost bursting bubble. Disgorged September 2016; tasted May 2018 (lot L6316UM13600).”
94-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2020
“Stylishly restrained, pure nose of coffee, smoke, milled chalk and peaches. There is an under-control reduced character waiting to express itself as toasty opulence. Subtly textured, seamless, perky palate with electric vivacity. Richer palate than what was promised by the slightly reserved nose. Fresh, light-weight and salivating.”
95/100
Alison Napjus,
WineSpectator.com,
Oct 2015
“A lovely Champagne, offering a rich and expressive palate of dried strawberry and white peach fruit, with toasted hazelnut, pastry, candied ginger and lemon curd flavors set in a fine and elegant frame. Long and creamy on the satiny finish. Drink now through 2031.”
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jul 2016
“Gnomic back label! The word Comtes is now privileged on the front label. Very pale greenish straw. Quite rich and yeasty on the nose. Tight bead and quite sweet on the front palate. Solid and flattering but far from intellectual. Exuberant. Clean. Gentler in texture than the 1996. 12.5%”
94/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Jul 2015
“Very fresh expression of pure chardonnay finished with Taittinger's signature toasty layer of autolysis, caramelized grilled nuts, brulée and a wealth of bright, fresh, pure lemon cirrus fruits. The palate has a superfine thread of acidity buried under peach and nectarine fruits. Long, even, focused and powerful, it finishes long and fine.”
97+/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Jul 2015
“The 2006 Comtes de Champagne is striking, especially in the way it brings together elements of ripeness and freshness in a hypothetical blend of the 2002 and 2004. Smooth and creamy on the palate, the 2006 is all about texture. There is a real feeling of density and weight in the 2006, qualities I expect to see grow with time in the bottle. All the elements fall into place effortlessly. The 2006 has been nothing short of magnificent both times I have tasted it. Comtes de Champagne remains the single best value (in relative terms) in tête de cuvée Champagne. I suggest buying a case and following it over the next 20-30 years, which is exactly what I intend to do. There is little doubt the 2006 Comtes de Champagne is a magical Champagne in the making.”
“Rich, ripe white fruit nose coming with a seductive charred, toasty nose. Plenty of pristinely clean fruit. Caressing, smooth silky palate with baking spices and yellow apples. Fresh, zesty palate of fine intensity. Long lingering and appealing.”
More Reviews +
17+/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Very fine bead. Very tight and some dried spices on the nose. Rich and nervy. Dry finish. Already starting to come out and beguile. Tighter knit than the vintage 2005 in magnum. Not yet ready.
Drink 2018-2030”
“Very good year for Chardonnay. Disgorged 2013.
Greenish tinge. Really quite delicate and refined. Like a tight string on a stringed instrument. Classic Chardonnay. Super-clean. Hint of liquid honey. Great refinement and refreshment.
Drink 2017-2030”
More Reviews +
94-96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2016
“Such an epitome of elegance. Soft, gunpowder, toast and vanilla lined white fruit nose. Smooth and intense with good tension and a playful nature. Round and mouth-filling with medium length. Seems to age very slowly and gracefully.”
17.5/20
Julia Harding MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2014
“100% Chardonnay (100% from grand cru vineyards). Dosage 9 g/l.
Highly aromatic with citrus and a touch of cedar but also something slightly sulphurous. There's quite a woody note on the palate with a slightly sour aftertaste. Wonder if this is in perfect condition? Excellent persistence and leaves your gums tingling.”
94/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Mar 2014
“A rich and enticing aroma of roasted hazelnut heralds this elegant blanc de blancs, with flavors of pastry, poached apple, crystallized honey and candied ginger riding the finely detailed mousse. This is a touch smoky, presenting a resonant minerality on the finish. Drink now through 2029.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Dec 2013
“Very neat, intense with notes of putty on the nose. Complex and well knit. Masses of acidity! Still quite tight. Very promising and one can certainly see a relationship with a grand cru Chablis here. Very youthful. Gentle bead. Great energy. But quite broad.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
May 2013
“I am thrilled with the way the 2004 Comtes de Champagne continues to evolve in bottle. A few years ago, the 2004 was quite focused and linear, in the style of the vintage, but more recently, the wine has begun to fill out beautifully. The 2004 remains bright, with a full range of citrus, white flower and mineral nuances that dance on the palate. A brisk, saline-infused finish rounds things out beautifully in a Comtes that impresses for its crystalline purity. I expect the 2004 will always remain a bit cool next to the more opulent 2002, but it is still drop-dead gorgeous.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Nov 2012
“It’s fascinating to taste the 2004 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne after the 2002, something I have been able to do on a few occasions. The 2004 is all about minerality, precision and tension. It doesn’t have the sheer richness or power of the 2002, but it makes up for that with its crystalline purity and sheer energy. Bright hints of lemon oil, white flowers and crushed rocks are layered into the pointed, vibrant finish. Anticipated maturity: 2014-2034.”
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jan 2024
“Tasted blind. Deep straw with a yellowish tinge that’s a bit greener than the 2002. But it smells more evolved! Brisk and energetic. More youthful than the earlier vintage but with great promise and persistence.”
“Pale straw. Very fresh and refreshing. Riesling-esque. Mouth-filling and filigree textured. Nicely matured – we’re at a good point to drink this. A delightful surprise, this one. Not a vintage with a fabulous reputation but it has developed well, better than Loïc Dupont expected, and this is beautifully balanced.”
More Reviews +
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2015
“This Comtes has been so impressive since the beginning. The pristine Chardonnay fruit and richness of the vintage just build up to a big wow. Pronounced, soft, creamy nose with charred toastiness, sweet apple and vanilla. Velvet-smooth, creamy on the palate with classy mineral bite at the end. Voluptuous and caressing texture. Crisp and intense. A perfect drink today but will further improve. A gorgeous, gorgeous Comtes. Very close to being the champagne of the vintage.”
96/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2011
“The 2000 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne is a huge wine bursting with ripe varietal fruit, smoke, ash, crushed rocks and slate. This is an unusual Comtes that deftly balances richness and power while maintaining considerable minerality. The 2000 will be hard to resist in its youth, but should also age beautifully for a number of years. It is a stunning, flat-out great bottle. This is Lot L0346UJ05700. Disgorged October 2010. Anticipated maturity: 2012-2030.”
96/100
Falstaff,
Falstaff.com,
Nov 2011
“Light gold with green glints, fine, consistent mousse. Multi-layered fruit nuances, which are underpinned by fresh meadow herbs, nut nuances, and fine caramel with hints of yellow apple. Solidly composed with a creamy texture and exhibiting a great freshness and vitality superseded by an elegant aromatic combination of dried fruits and floral elements on the finish. Immensely refined and pleasurable drinking flow, vibrancy and length. ”
94/100
Alison Napjus,
winespectator.com,
May 2011
“A savory, aromatic accent of dried herb and candied orange peel notes mixes with yellow peach, kumquat, honey, graphite and creamy mineral. Very refined and elegant, with finely tuned acidity driving this to the mouthwatering finish. 1,700 cases made.”
“Possibly the most famous Blanc de Blancs, this continues to be a yardstick. The style almost floats, a layer of bubbles that rests gently in the mouth, releasing great flavors of very crisp fruits and a texture that hovers between green apples and minerality. This is a classic.”
More Reviews +
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Aug 2017
“Nicely coming along and lively with full confidence and masses of acidity. Slight note of veg. Starting to become just a little bit loose.”
17.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Jun 2019
“Magnum. ‘This is our P2’, but they don’t have enough from the original disgorged to commercialise it. The original was disgorged in 2008. Deep gold straw. Smoky nose. Lots of lemon and creaminess. Layers and length. Quite rich. Seems sweeter than the 2007 and 2008.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
RobertParker.com,
Dec 2008
“The 1998 Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne is simply beautiful. Sweet notes of honey are intermingled with candied citrus peel, flowers, smoke and minerals as this gorgeous wine opens up in the glass. Comtes de Champagne is always an understated, elegant wine, but its pedigree is impossible to miss. Readers seeking instant gratification will find much to admire even today, but this is clearly a wine that has the potential to develop positively in bottle. If past vintages are an accurate indication, the wine should acquire the liqueur-like sweetness in bottle that is its hallmark over time. Old vintages of Comtes de Champagne are unlike any other wine. The Comtes de Champagne is 100% Chardonnay from the grand cru villages Avize, Cramant, Chouilly, Beergers-les-Vertus, Vertus and Mesnil-sur-Oger. A small amount of the wine is aged in new French oak barrels. Anticipated maturity: 2008-2028. This is Lot: L7081UB10000, disgorged February 5, 2007
Taittinger is one of Champagne’s historic houses. The estate is best known for its Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne, a wine that has a strong track record of developing beautifully in bottle, often for several decades after release. While a few bottles in the range aren’t quite up to par, in aggregate this is an impressive showing for a house of this scale.”
95/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Aug 2010
“The 1998 Comtes de Champagne is a different story altogether. This is a sexy, up-front Comtes endowed with lovely richness in its fruit and open, expressive aromatics. It remains an impressive, inviting Comtes that should also continue to develop nicely in the bottle for at least another decade plus.”
95/100
Roger Voss,
WineEnthusiast.com,
Dec 2008
“Possibly the most famous Blanc de Blancs, this continues to be a yardstick. The style almost floats, a layer of bubbles that rests gently in the mouth, releasing great flavors of very crisp fruits and a texture that hovers between green apples and minerality. This is a classic.”
“100% Chardonnay. Disgorged March 2012. RS 9 g/l.
Tasted blind. Very well mannered. Not at all showy, but all seems to be in the right proportion. Racy and energetic. Really very much in the spirit of 2002. Lots there but such pace! Marked acidity but great fruit too. Long. Youthful.”
More Reviews +
18.5/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Sep 2017
“Pale greenish straw. Quite a different colour from the vintage 2002 – paler. Lacy reductive nose. Distinctly smoky. Very readable and perfect, fine Chardonnay – richer and more powerful than the 2004.
Drink 2018-2030”
95/100
Michael Edwards,
Decanter.com,
Jul 2016
“Youthful vigour and purity of green fruits, hazlenuts and a touch of fennel. Great subtlety. Magnum
”
96-98/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
May 2016
“Bright lemon colour. Restrained yet intense nose still holding back. Beautiful underlying depth and gorgeous toasty layers. A warmer feel than in the 2004. Sweet, bright fruitiness with light spiciness, cinnamon. Superb toasty note. Plenty of character, delivering on every front. Superbly elegant. Regrettably a small-sized vintage for Comtes.”
95/100
Richard Juhlin,
Decanter,
Dec 2015
“Though very dumb when tasted soon after disgorgement, just three months later you could already taste the grandeur and concentration. There were just 35,000 bottles made in this vintage, 100,000 fewer than normal, so there will be fighting over these dense, lime-scented beauties when the wine finally awakens.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2016
“Disgorged March 2012. RS 9 g/l. From Taittinger's UK agent, Hatch Mansfield.
Tasted blind. Very pale greenish straw. Very, very fine bead. Dense and tight with layers. Comtes or Salon? Very tightly laced with a tiny little bead. Very fine. Comtes?”
19/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“Tasted blind. Disgorged March 2012.
Very delicate nose – hugely appetising. Taut and lemony – even lime. Even slightly astringent. I guessed this was definitely a magnum and most of the crowd agreed, but in fact it was a bottle! ”
18.5
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Oct 2015
“Tasted blind. Disgorged June 2012.
Richer, more evolved nose than the sample tasted alongside. Much broader and creamier. I thought it therefore had to be from a bottle but in fact it was a magnum.”
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
VinousMedia.com,
Dec 2012
“Taittinger’s 2002 Brut Blanc de Blancs Comtes de Champagne is off the charts. I have tasted the 2002 now many times, and it has never been less than thrilling. A vivid kaleidoscope of pure Chardonnay aromas and flavors opens up in the glass. The 2002 is at once incredibly rich yet also totally weightless and impeccable in its balance. All the classic Comtes notes are there, but with a level of detail and nuance I don’t think I have ever seen before. The 2002 is breathtakingly beautiful today, but also appears to have the stuffing to age for decades. Personally, I would be looking to buy the 2002 in magnums if at all possible. Sadly, there is little wine to go around as 2002 was a very short crop. Readers who can track down the 2002 are in store for something truly great. Anticipated maturity: 2012-2042”
94/100
Wine Spectator,
WineSpectator.com,
Dec 2012
“A rich base of toasted brioche and briny mineral supports flavors of poached quince, white peach puree, fleur de sel, pastry and smoked almond. There's a quiet verve to this wine, with a fine, silky texture throughout. Drink now through 2025.”
95/100
Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar,
Nov 2012
“Light, bright gold. A heady, intensely perfumed bouquet evokes lemon curd, pear skin, iodine, honeysuckle and toasty lees, with notes of ginger and honey emerging with air. Strikes an impressive balance of power and restraint, opening slowly to offer vibrant citrus and orchard fruit flavors, along with intense floral and spice nuances. Clings with superb tenacity on the gently smoky finish, which features zesty orange pith and mineral qualities. By the way, the 2004 Comtes de Champagne Rose has become even more intense over the last 12 months, gaining in both mineral and floral intensity. I know the old saw about aging rose Champagne but this is a wine that is built for the long haul.”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Nov 2012
“100% Chardonnay. Greenish straw. Nicely balanced and relatively open. Quite a high dosage but very easy to like. Fine and as though there’s a drawstring on the finish. All very neat on the end after quite an effusive beginning. Mid weight to light.”
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne Rosé is a gorgeous, exotic wine. Sweet dried cherry, kirsch, tobacco, rose petal, cedar and mint weave across the palate in a sumptuous, racy Rosé that delivers on all fronts. This fruit was picked during the last October harvest in Champagne, except for some small picks in 2021 and 2024. The 2013 is so expressive today. It offers a compelling mix of fruit density, complexity and dynamic energy. Sublime. Dosage is 9 grams per liter. Disgorged: July 2025.”
More Reviews +
98/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Aug 2025
“This shows fragrant grapefruit, wild raspberry, iodine, honey, blood orange, salty bread and hazelnut aromas. It's sleek, taut and superbly fresh on the palate. The red and orange citrus pinot noir character is singing at the moment, accompanied by salty and mineral nuances. Seamless and long, and taut at the end. 60% pinot noir and 40% chardonnay, all from grand cru sites. Drinkable now, but will be better in a few years”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2026
“Mid salmon colour with quite a bit of of orange in it. Seriously intense floral nose. Quite a rich, almost ratafia/almond palate entry, good intensity of fruit on the mid palate and then an appetisingly dry finish (despite the 9 g/l dosage) with even a hint of bitterness. I find this even more characterful than the Blanc de Blancs 2014. In fact it’s a seriously good wine!”
“The 2013 Comtes de Champagne Rosé is a gorgeous, exotic wine. Sweet dried cherry, kirsch, tobacco, rose petal, cedar and mint weave across the palate in a sumptuous, racy Rosé that delivers on all fronts. This fruit was picked during the last October harvest in Champagne, except for some small picks in 2021 and 2024. The 2013 is so expressive today. It offers a compelling mix of fruit density, complexity and dynamic energy. Sublime. Dosage is 9 grams per liter. Disgorged: July 2025.”
More Reviews +
98/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Aug 2025
“This shows fragrant grapefruit, wild raspberry, iodine, honey, blood orange, salty bread and hazelnut aromas. It's sleek, taut and superbly fresh on the palate. The red and orange citrus pinot noir character is singing at the moment, accompanied by salty and mineral nuances. Seamless and long, and taut at the end. 60% pinot noir and 40% chardonnay, all from grand cru sites. Drinkable now, but will be better in a few years”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
JancisRobinson.com,
Apr 2026
“Mid salmon colour with quite a bit of of orange in it. Seriously intense floral nose. Quite a rich, almost ratafia/almond palate entry, good intensity of fruit on the mid palate and then an appetisingly dry finish (despite the 9 g/l dosage) with even a hint of bitterness. I find this even more characterful than the Blanc de Blancs 2014. In fact it’s a seriously good wine!”
“Evoking a superb bouquet, the remarkable 2012 Brut Comtes de Champagne Rosé reveals aromas of mint, strawberries, ripe red berries, tangerine, plums, orange rind and blood orange. Full-bodied, vinous and concentrated, it has a delicately, perfectly balanced phenolic mid-palate framed by a pinpoint mousse of striking finesse and delicacy, concluding with a vibrant, vertical finish enhanced by gastronomic bitterness. A blend of 70% Pinot Noir, including 14% as red wine, and 30% Chardonnay, disgorged with a dosage of nine grams per liter, this is one of the most elegant and refined Comtes de Champagne Rosé releases from Taittinger.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2012 Comtes de Champagne Rosé is magnificent. Rich and explosive in the glass, the 2012 Comtes Rosé dazzles from start to finish. I like it even more today than I liked it last year! A rush of red cherry fruit, kirsch, blood orange, cinnamon and rose petal soars out of the glass. Vertical structure and tons of energy are the signatures. I would be thrilled to own this.”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“Bright juicy red fruits leap out the glass, expanding on the palate to delicious brambly and dark cherry fruits. The texture envelops the tongue, so much fruit, twist of spice and real concentration and then an uplift of freshness. This is a power rose, that finishes light and subtle. I love it to sip alone & will go well with, charcuterie, red meats and spiced foods. Drink Now for 15+ years.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Disgorged in February 2025 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, the 2012 Comtes de Champagne Rosé opens with a flamboyant, perfumed bouquet of crushed raspberry, blood orange and cherry, mingling with sweet red plum and hints of timut pepper. The full-bodied palate is layered, broad and textural, its generous core of fruit sustained by ripe yet racy acidity and a pillowy mousse that lends liveliness, before the wine culminates in a long, enveloping finish with a touch of phenolic bitterness. Composed of 60% Pinot Noir—including 16% still red wine from Bouzy—and 40% Chardonnay, it can already be enjoyed with satisfaction, though one should reasonably anticipate that it will accrue additional complexity after a few more years under cork.”
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“This is a structured, focused yet delicate rosé Comtes. Almost rust-colored, with tons of grapefruit, crushed stones, blackcurrants and wild raspberries, alongside oyster shells and chalk. Very precise and fine, with seamless bubbles and a fresh, very long finish. 60% pinot noir (from Mailly, Verzenay and Ambonnay) and 40% chardonnay (Avize, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oger), of which 16% red wine from Bouzy, all grand cru. Drink or hold.”
“Evoking a superb bouquet, the remarkable 2012 Brut Comtes de Champagne Rosé reveals aromas of mint, strawberries, ripe red berries, tangerine, plums, orange rind and blood orange. Full-bodied, vinous and concentrated, it has a delicately, perfectly balanced phenolic mid-palate framed by a pinpoint mousse of striking finesse and delicacy, concluding with a vibrant, vertical finish enhanced by gastronomic bitterness. A blend of 70% Pinot Noir, including 14% as red wine, and 30% Chardonnay, disgorged with a dosage of nine grams per liter, this is one of the most elegant and refined Comtes de Champagne Rosé releases from Taittinger.”
More Reviews +
98/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Apr 2025
“The 2012 Comtes de Champagne Rosé is magnificent. Rich and explosive in the glass, the 2012 Comtes Rosé dazzles from start to finish. I like it even more today than I liked it last year! A rush of red cherry fruit, kirsch, blood orange, cinnamon and rose petal soars out of the glass. Vertical structure and tons of energy are the signatures. I would be thrilled to own this.”
19/20
Nick Baker TFB Founder,
thefinestbubble.com,
Mar 2025
“Bright juicy red fruits leap out the glass, expanding on the palate to delicious brambly and dark cherry fruits. The texture envelops the tongue, so much fruit, twist of spice and real concentration and then an uplift of freshness. This is a power rose, that finishes light and subtle. I love it to sip alone & will go well with, charcuterie, red meats and spiced foods. Drink Now for 15+ years.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Disgorged in February 2025 with a dosage of nine grams per liter, the 2012 Comtes de Champagne Rosé opens with a flamboyant, perfumed bouquet of crushed raspberry, blood orange and cherry, mingling with sweet red plum and hints of timut pepper. The full-bodied palate is layered, broad and textural, its generous core of fruit sustained by ripe yet racy acidity and a pillowy mousse that lends liveliness, before the wine culminates in a long, enveloping finish with a touch of phenolic bitterness. Composed of 60% Pinot Noir—including 16% still red wine from Bouzy—and 40% Chardonnay, it can already be enjoyed with satisfaction, though one should reasonably anticipate that it will accrue additional complexity after a few more years under cork.”
99/100
James Suckling,
Jamessuckling.com,
Aug 2024
“This is a structured, focused yet delicate rosé Comtes. Almost rust-colored, with tons of grapefruit, crushed stones, blackcurrants and wild raspberries, alongside oyster shells and chalk. Very precise and fine, with seamless bubbles and a fresh, very long finish. 60% pinot noir (from Mailly, Verzenay and Ambonnay) and 40% chardonnay (Avize, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger and Oger), of which 16% red wine from Bouzy, all grand cru. Drink or hold.”
“Disgorged in October 2022, the 2011 Brut Comtes de Champagne Rosé is a blend of 40% Chardonnay and 60% Pinot Noir, including fully 14% of red wine that lends it notable depth of colour this year. The bouquet is complex and incipiently spicy, evoking aromas of cherries, buttery pastry, raspberries and tangerine, with an attractive minty top note. Medium to full-bodied, layered and vinous, with chalky structuring extract, it concludes with a long, sapid finish. The limitations of the vintage mean that this is giving, rather open-knit Comtes Rosé, but it is nevertheless a great effort in a challenging year and exhibits none of the herbaceous qualities that mar some of the wines produced in this year. Drink it now and over the next decade.”
More Reviews +
96/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Dec 2023
“Beautiful orange-cherry color, exuding aromas of dried flowers, cherry stones, wild strawberries, cloves and cinnamon pastries. It’s medium-bodied with excellent weight and balance. Soft bubbles. Layers of soft, supple berry fruit. Pastries and walnuts come through on a seamless finish. Drink or hold.”
“Disgorged in October 2022, the 2011 Brut Comtes de Champagne Rosé is a blend of 40% Chardonnay and 60% Pinot Noir, including fully 14% of red wine that lends it notable depth of colour this year. The bouquet is complex and incipiently spicy, evoking aromas of cherries, buttery pastry, raspberries and tangerine, with an attractive minty top note. Medium to full-bodied, layered and vinous, with chalky structuring extract, it concludes with a long, sapid finish. The limitations of the vintage mean that this is giving, rather open-knit Comtes Rosé, but it is nevertheless a great effort in a challenging year and exhibits none of the herbaceous qualities that mar some of the wines produced in this year. Drink it now and over the next decade.”
More Reviews +
96/100
James Suckling,
JamesSuckling.com,
Dec 2023
“Beautiful orange-cherry color, exuding aromas of dried flowers, cherry stones, wild strawberries, cloves and cinnamon pastries. It’s medium-bodied with excellent weight and balance. Soft bubbles. Layers of soft, supple berry fruit. Pastries and walnuts come through on a seamless finish. Drink or hold.”
“A beautiful color of bronze and orange with some pink at the end. Aromas of dried strawberry and orange peel with orange blossom and other flowers. Medium to full body with a round, creamy texture, very fine bubbles and a lovely, long finish. Plenty of subtle pie-crust and biscuit flavors at the end. Yet it remains so complex. Very vinous. Drink or hold.”
More Reviews +
95/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Taittinger used to release Comtes rosé before the blanc de blancs, but this is now changing, with the 2009 rosé entering the market alongside the 2012 white. This is great news for the rosé, which greatly benefits from ageing, amplifying its rich, wild Pinot characters. This copper-toned rosé is of a fruity style, supple and fragrant already upon launch. Dark cherry fruit with exotic spices, toffee, orange peel and sous-bois. Structured palate of firm but ripe tannin; sumptuously fruity with exemplary freshness. Gourmand and winey. On this year of great Pinot Noir, no white Comtes de Champagne was made. Dosage 9g/l”
18/20
Jancis Robinson MW,
Jancisrobinson.com,
Oct 2022
“Provence rosé, eat your heart out. This wine looks more like a clarete – deep orangey-strawberry pink. It's far from difficult to persuade yourself there are notes of both strawberry and orange in this concentrated, somehow upright wine. Nothing vapid about it, it's clearly a wine that would be extremely happy at a well-laden table. From a pretty ripe vintage, its superior pedigree is clear as it has an intense, sophisticated nose and a bone-dry finish after grabbing the palate and giving it a good scrub. There's no attempt to make a smooth-as-satin wine here. It's out to make an impression, and to prove that champagne really is a wine. The finish is even more adamant than the nose at this point. But I think it's time is now.
Drink 2018–2026”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2022
“The 2009 Brut Comtes de Champagne Rosé is a rich, gourmand rendition of this cuvée, bursting with aromas of sweet red plums, buttery pastry, tangerine and baking spices. Full-bodied, ample and fleshy, with a broad attack and a layered, enveloping mid-palate that's girdled by ripe acids, it already offers demonstrative drinking. This has turned out brilliantly.”
“Aromatic and quite floral. Big and introvert, still needs more time on lees. They are busy changing things. Only about 10% of the volume of the Comtes Blanc de Blancs is made. ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Anyone who has tasted Comtes rosé knows that it is a particularly structured rosé, with a twist of ripe tannins. Such a structured wine needs time to evolve and mellow, and now the winemaking team has extended its ageing time. A much appreciated move for the tight and firm 2008, which comes with a stylish, reserved nose of elegant Pinot Noir fruit: exotic spices, dark cherries, quince and baked peach. The characterful Bouzy red wine part that gives the wine its colour shines through. This is a tightly knit wine with fine tannins, but there is substantial fruity depth behind. Great acid structure and a silky textural feel. There is so much concentration here waiting to bloom. A beautiful and painfully slowly ageing Comtes rosé that deserves plenty of time in the cellar. Dosage 9g/l”
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2020
“Classy nose full of Pinot Noir fruit of exotic spices, cherries and peach. The characterful Bouzy red wines shines through. Big structure with bold tannins but there is also big fruit behind, still in a reserved stage. Great acid structure and silky textural feel. Full on rich palate. So much concentration here. Shows evolution while still holding back a lot. Very correct yet full of character. A beautiful future Comte Rosé but this one still deserves plenty of time in the cellar. ”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2021
“Taittinger's 2008 Brut Comtes de Champagne Rosé, which arrives on the market this year, has unwound considerably since I last tasted it. Offering up inviting aromas of red berries, plums, sweet spices, orange rind and freshly baked bread, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and vinous, with an ample core of fruit, lively acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. As I wrote in 2019, Taittinger is using more Pinot Noir and opting for longer sur lattes maturation for this bottling, and the result is that Comtes Rosé is becoming a more gastronomic Champagne. Deceptively charming as this 2008 is today, I suspect it will tighten up with a little age on cork.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Offering up a deep bouquet of blood orange, wild raspberry and plum, mingling with brioche and hints of Sichuan pepper, the 2008 Comtes de Champagne Rosé—disgorged in 2019 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—has developed nicely since I first tasted it that same year. Medium- to full-bodied, elegantly muscular and vinous, with a tauter core of fruit in the context of its siblings and laden with bright acids, it culminates in a long, chalky finish. Currently showing more depth than the 2012 and more incisiveness than the 2009, it stands out as one of the more complete renditions of this cuvée. A blend of 63% Pinot Noir and 37% Chardonnay, it derives from a harvest that took place in late September and extended into early October.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2008 Comtes de Champagne Rosé presents a classically austere façade. Crushed berry, mint, chalk and dried herbs emerge on the bouquet, and yet the wine remains very tight, even with aeration. The Comtes Rosé has a track record of aging brilliantly. Today, though, I am not sure the fruit will ever fully emerge. ”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
decanter.com,
Oct 2021
“With notes of spices, black cherry, morello cherry and black fruit, the bouquet is impressively complex and delicious. On the palate, the vinous texture, fine bubbles, depth and complexity allow for a long, chalky, chiselled finish. This is a gastronomic Champagne rose with great ageing potential.
”
95/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Bright medium pink colour. Fresh and vivid pomegranate, raspberry and plum, complete with lightly buttered toast and caramel biscuits. Rather linear in body with beautiful, crystalline acidity. it still has some austerity, yet it is delicious with depth. The complexity of flavour continues on the palate, with a chalky, salivating finish.”
“Aromatic and quite floral. Big and introvert, still needs more time on lees. They are busy changing things. Only about 10% of the volume of the Comtes Blanc de Blancs is made. ”
More Reviews +
96/100
Essi Avellan MW,
cluboenologique.com,
Aug 2022
“Anyone who has tasted Comtes rosé knows that it is a particularly structured rosé, with a twist of ripe tannins. Such a structured wine needs time to evolve and mellow, and now the winemaking team has extended its ageing time. A much appreciated move for the tight and firm 2008, which comes with a stylish, reserved nose of elegant Pinot Noir fruit: exotic spices, dark cherries, quince and baked peach. The characterful Bouzy red wine part that gives the wine its colour shines through. This is a tightly knit wine with fine tannins, but there is substantial fruity depth behind. Great acid structure and a silky textural feel. There is so much concentration here waiting to bloom. A beautiful and painfully slowly ageing Comtes rosé that deserves plenty of time in the cellar. Dosage 9g/l”
95-97/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Dec 2020
“Classy nose full of Pinot Noir fruit of exotic spices, cherries and peach. The characterful Bouzy red wines shines through. Big structure with bold tannins but there is also big fruit behind, still in a reserved stage. Great acid structure and silky textural feel. Full on rich palate. So much concentration here. Shows evolution while still holding back a lot. Very correct yet full of character. A beautiful future Comte Rosé but this one still deserves plenty of time in the cellar. ”
96/100
William Kelley,
Robertparker.com,
Oct 2021
“Taittinger's 2008 Brut Comtes de Champagne Rosé, which arrives on the market this year, has unwound considerably since I last tasted it. Offering up inviting aromas of red berries, plums, sweet spices, orange rind and freshly baked bread, it's medium to full-bodied, pillowy and vinous, with an ample core of fruit, lively acids and an elegant pinpoint mousse. As I wrote in 2019, Taittinger is using more Pinot Noir and opting for longer sur lattes maturation for this bottling, and the result is that Comtes Rosé is becoming a more gastronomic Champagne. Deceptively charming as this 2008 is today, I suspect it will tighten up with a little age on cork.”
96/100
Kristaps Karklins,
Robertparker.com,
Dec 2025
“Offering up a deep bouquet of blood orange, wild raspberry and plum, mingling with brioche and hints of Sichuan pepper, the 2008 Comtes de Champagne Rosé—disgorged in 2019 with a dosage of nine grams per liter—has developed nicely since I first tasted it that same year. Medium- to full-bodied, elegantly muscular and vinous, with a tauter core of fruit in the context of its siblings and laden with bright acids, it culminates in a long, chalky finish. Currently showing more depth than the 2012 and more incisiveness than the 2009, it stands out as one of the more complete renditions of this cuvée. A blend of 63% Pinot Noir and 37% Chardonnay, it derives from a harvest that took place in late September and extended into early October.”
93/100
Antonio Galloni,
vinous.com,
Nov 2021
“The 2008 Comtes de Champagne Rosé presents a classically austere façade. Crushed berry, mint, chalk and dried herbs emerge on the bouquet, and yet the wine remains very tight, even with aeration. The Comtes Rosé has a track record of aging brilliantly. Today, though, I am not sure the fruit will ever fully emerge. ”
97/100
Yohan Castaing,
decanter.com,
Oct 2021
“With notes of spices, black cherry, morello cherry and black fruit, the bouquet is impressively complex and delicious. On the palate, the vinous texture, fine bubbles, depth and complexity allow for a long, chalky, chiselled finish. This is a gastronomic Champagne rose with great ageing potential.
”
95/100
Yuri Shima,
cluboenologique.com,
May 2025
“Bright medium pink colour. Fresh and vivid pomegranate, raspberry and plum, complete with lightly buttered toast and caramel biscuits. Rather linear in body with beautiful, crystalline acidity. it still has some austerity, yet it is delicious with depth. The complexity of flavour continues on the palate, with a chalky, salivating finish.”
“The latest release of Taittinger's NV Brut Folies de la Marquetterie is showing superbly, bursting from the glass with aromas of fresh bread, crisp stone fruit, buttered toast, citrus oil and mirabelle plums. Full-bodied, vinous and fleshy, with an enveloping core of fruit, racy acids and a pillowy pinpoint mousse, it's a gourmand, concentrated wine with the substance to evolve with grace in the cellar.”
More Reviews +
89-91
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Feb 2017
“Medium-deep lemon yellow colour. Stylish, subdued but layered nose of toasty, mineral and sweet fruity nuances. Fine, creamy mousse. Firm and lively, this cuvée greatly benefits from time on cork, enhancing its depth and complexity. ”
92/100
Josh Reynolds,
Vinous.com,
Dec 2012
“ 55% pinot noir and 45% chardonnay, from a single vineyard in Pierry, due south of Epernay and near Cuis; L1202FC00100): Pale gold. Red berries, rose and orange peel on the fragrant, floral-accented nose and in the mouth. Sappy and broad, with very good depth and an energizing note of chalky minerals. Gains weight with air and finishes with excellent breadth, clarity and lingering mineral and honeysuckle notes. ”
“The latest release of Taittinger's NV Brut Prélude Grands Crus is showing nicely, offering up aromas of pear, crisp stone fruit, warm biscuits and marzipan. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with tangy acids and fine depth at the core, this is still a little reserved after what I suspect is quite a recent disgorgement, and it will merit a little patience.”
More Reviews +
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2018
“Highly toasty, developing, sweet fruity and perfumy nose. Rich and velvety on the super smooth palate with perfectly integrated soft mousse. Long, concentrated and fruity. Layers and layers of toast and fruit. The high quality of the fruit is evident. One of the very finest non-vintages. Well worth keeping for a few years. ”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“As always, the NV Brut Prélude Grands Crus is showing well, revealing aromas of ripe pear, marzipan, brioche, honey and ripe orchard fruits. Medium to full-bodied, enveloping and charming, it's elegantly suave, with good depth at the core, bright acids and a penetrating, delicate finish. This is a real success.”
“Smoky fresh, this magnum is so beautifully reductive adding that smoky charm to an already alluring aromatic. From base year 2014 this is one of the best value magnum on the market from grapes only from the top Grands Crus villages, there is real depth and concentration and amazing lightness of touch. ”
More Reviews +
93/100
William Kelley,
RobertParker.com,
Sep 2021
“The latest release of Taittinger's NV Brut Prélude Grands Crus is showing nicely, offering up aromas of pear, crisp stone fruit, warm biscuits and marzipan. Medium to full-bodied, fleshy and precise, with tangy acids and fine depth at the core, this is still a little reserved after what I suspect is quite a recent disgorgement, and it will merit a little patience.”
91-93/100
Essi Avellan MW,
EssiAvellan.com,
Aug 2018
“Highly toasty, developing, sweet fruity and perfumy nose. Rich and velvety on the super smooth palate with perfectly integrated soft mousse. Long, concentrated and fruity. Layers and layers of toast and fruit. The high quality of the fruit is evident. One of the very finest non-vintages. Well worth keeping for a few years. ”
92/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“As always, the NV Brut Prélude Grands Crus is showing well, revealing aromas of ripe pear, marzipan, brioche, honey and ripe orchard fruits. Medium to full-bodied, enveloping and charming, it's elegantly suave, with good depth at the core, bright acids and a penetrating, delicate finish. This is a real success.”
“70% Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier, 30% Chardonnay. Prettily pale. After so many still rosés playing the fruit card, seems unfruity. Relatively austere, stony aroma. But then a real vinous intensity on the palate, with depth and refinement.”
More Reviews +
91+/100
Yohan Castaing,
robertparker.com,
Oct 2024
“Based on the same blend as the Brut Réserve with an addition of red wine, the NV Brut Prestige Rosé reveals a delicate, perfumed bouquet of strawberries, red berries, herbs, blood orange and guava. Medium to full-bodied, elegantly vinous and perfectly balanced, it has a pinpoint mousse and a long, ethereal finish.”
“The NV 50 Year Old Tawny Port is a field blend bottled with a bar-top cork in 2022 and with 158 grams of residual sugar. Mature, with dark chocolate nuances, this is rich, deep and sensationally delicious. The concentration is exceptional too. Then, there's the long, long finish, filled with fruit and sugar. It is irresistible, in addition to being nuanced and complex. It's young enough so that it is never just a curiosity. The fruit is certainly not cracking.”
“The 1975 Taylor's Vintage Port is understated on the nose compared to the 1970 and 1977, with scents of degraded red fruit, ash, fig and clove, beautifully defined but discreet. The palate is medium bodied with a slightly candied entry, offering blood orange and red fruit, allspice and clove, with just a dab of gingerbread on the back palate. Very cohesive on the finish, this is not a powerful Vintage Port—that is a strength, not a weakness. Lovely.”
“In addition, Taylor Fladgate has recently released a 1970 Single Harvest Port, the seventh in a series of limited-edition 50-year-old colheitas, aged in the Taylor Fladgate cellars at Vila Nova de Gaia, that comes suitably attired in a frosted glass bottle and beech wood box. Released from the end of May this year, it does not come cheap, at £220 per bottle. Maybe a little deeper in color than expected, deep mahogany with very slight green tints on the rim, it has a striking bouquet of dried quince, camphor, a touch of furniture polish and grilled walnuts, and later just a touch of espresso. The palate is medium-bodied with a spicy opening: Chinese five-spice, cloves, satsuma and orange zest, then touches of California raisins and Medjool dates. Smooth and very sensual, this is a tempting and moreish Port with hedonistic flair. 2020 - 2050”
“Lovely deep amber-tawny with a olive-green tinged rim and a ruddy glow; very fine, lifted toffee and butterscotch aromas with a hint of spice emerging from the glass; wonderfully creamy – silky fruit with a cedar and spice character, retaining amazing verve, balancing richness (160gl residual sugar) and citrusy freshness in equal measure leading to a finish with supreme elegance and poise. A finely tuned blend on which it would be hard to improve: it is entirely fitting that this can be summed up as majestic!”
More Reviews +
94/100
Neal Martin,
Vinous.com,
May 2023
“I was sent a sample and naturally tasted it as our monarch was being handed his orb and scepter. It has quite a punchy bouquet, a little nuttier and smokier than expected, with Montecristo cigars mixed with sweeter scents of nougat and vanilla pod. The sweetness comes through more on the palate than the nose. It’s very well balanced and clearly blended to be drunk now instead of being cellared like nearly all tawny Ports. Molasses, grilled hazelnuts with a pinch of cracked black pepper appear toward the finish. There is a seductive viscosity towards the finish with just the faintest dab of dried honey. Delightful. ”
“This toasty, superbly mature wine is part of a series of releases featuring the house's cellar-matured Champagnes. This emerges from the glass with complex flavors of almond, brioche, citrus and a hint of steeliness. The majestic richness of the wine has fully justified its decades of aging.”