Blind Tasting New Releases from the 2018 Vintage


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

YouTube Video

 

What a fascinating blind tasting: sixteen champagnes from the 2018 vintage, a year that broke records for heat and sunshine, and delivered notably low acidities (total acidity averaging around 5.9 g/l, with malic acid largely negligible). Crucially, however, 2018 avoided the damaging heat spikes seen in vintages such as 2003 and 2015, when vines shut down photosynthesis and ripening became uneven.

Going in, I expected a softer, perhaps less vibrant profile. That wasn’t the case. The wines showed remarkable energy alongside their ripeness. There was an abundance of generous fruit, with Chardonnay often expressing guava and charred pineapple, while Pinot Noir leaned toward very ripe stone fruit.

The most overtly tropical expressions came from Pol Roger. Both the Brut Vintage 2018 and Sir Winston Churchill 2018 displayed layers of lush, ripe fruit. The former showed noticeably softer acidity, whereas Churchill retained greater composure and freshness.

At the other end of the spectrum was Louis Roederer Vintage 2018, a wine of striking tension. Composed of 80% Pinot Noir, much of it from the east-facing slopes of Verzy, it preserved a cooler profile. Here, ripeness was finely balanced by a pronounced mineral core, delivering the most saline and tightly wound wine of the tasting and my highest scoring at 18.5/20.

The question of acidity in 2018 is more nuanced than the headline figures suggest. While it was, on paper, the lowest-acid vintage of the past two decades across the region, that statistic doesn’t tell the full story. Champagnes sourced predominantly from Grand Cru vineyards behave differently. In these sites, shallow topsoil sits directly above chalk, which plays a crucial role. Chalk acts as a vast reservoir and capable of holding up to 400 litres of water per cubic metre, allowing vine roots to penetrate deep into fissures where they access both water and consistent coolness.

This has a marked effect on the grapes: musts tend to have lower pH levels, even in warm years. Lower pH correlates strongly with a perception of brightness and freshness, and contributes to longevity. Vineyard aspect further refines this. South-facing slopes receive full sun and promote ripeness, while north- and east-facing sites preserve acidity by limiting exposure.

In 2018, it is this interplay between chalk soils, vineyard orientation, and careful site selection that allowed producers to retain freshness despite the warmth of the growing season. The result is a vintage that combines generosity with precision more convincingly than one might expect from the raw numbers alone.

Louis Roederer Brut Vintage 2018 – 18.5+/20
Definite chalky notes on the aromatics and palate and a rich textural delight, this has “big mouthfeel” and builds on and on. The citrus palate dominates the entry, then you get grapefruit, hints of pineapple and super delicious red fruit, like ripe raspberry and dark plum. This is going to develop into a very classy champagne as the tension and attractive fruit are only just showing its greatness at this age.

Pol Roger Sir Winston Churchill 2018 – 18 /20
Loads of really ripe fruit here, the spread of citrus, peach and hints of bitter apricot blend with the chardonnay charred pineapple. There is weight and density here, perhaps the fruit is all so obvious at this age suggests it will be best enjoyed without too much age, let’s see!

Laurent-Perrier Brut Vintage 2018 – 18/20
Lightly smoky gunflint, bright lemon, grapefruit and hints of peach and apricot, has a real freshness on the palate, assume this I like the freshness here is the influence of grapes from Grand Cru villages, as there is a real a chalky saline kick on the finish. Delicious.

Charles Heidsieck Brut Millesime 2018 – 18/20
Plenty of fruit here, big bold texture, really rich with tropical notes coming forward, like pineapple and super ripe grapefruit. Very clean and refreshing, I like this. Has some nice bitter on exit and lingering chocolate and whiff of something smoky; tobacco?

Pol Roger Brut Vintage 2018 -17.5+
Lemon, grapefruit, charred pineapple in abundance and more complexity on the palate with peach, grapefruit and hints of pineapple & tropical fruits like guava and lychee. Can feel the  dosage on the finish along with a bit of bitter grip on the end, all positive though.

Piper Heidsieck 2018 – 17.5
Bit heavier aromatics, assume more PN, getting peach and apricot and noticeably more richness from dosage – very clean aromatically and some lees charm giving me the impression this would be great with food.

Delamotte Blanc de Blancs 2018 – 17.5/20
Opens with power of citrus, particularly lemon and grapefruit, this is showing bold and bright fruit lightly smoky and the texture shows the chalky origins, assume Grand Cru Chardonnay? Plenty of rich yellow fruit on the palate, dosage seems to stand out, but that’s after a run or low/no dosage champagnes.

Girard-Bonnet Grand Cru Blanc de Blancs Recueil Extrait No1 2018 – 17+/20
Tighter nose at first, hints of oak give way to grapefruit and lemon which build going creamy rich on the palate and loads of mineral freshness here. Opens up aromatically 10 minutes later.

Veuve Clicquot La Grande Dame 2018 – 17/20
Slightly evolutionary note to the apple, loads of lemon and grapefruit richness and a mass of stone fruit on the palate. There is freshness here assume this is mostly GC fruit and only slightly marking down as feels aromatically not as pure as I would want for long ageing.

Louis Roederer Brut Nature 2018 – 16.5/20
Lots of citrus and hints of juicy plum and grapefruit. Expands a lot more on the palate, richly textured filling the no dosage hole, citrus, stone fruit, quite short finish.

Champagne Marguet Blanc de Blancs Avize Grand Cru Brut Nature 2018 – 15/20
Some evolutionary notes, apple & grapefruit, broadened by a strong texture from oak helping the mouthfeel. Not my style with the obvious oak.

 

ROSE

Louis Roederer Rose 2018 18+/20
Rich strawberry and raspberry and bundles of ripe red berries on the palate, hints of peach and guava and a very chalky tone on the palate bringing a good balance with mineral fresh end. Great length super fresh and zippy. This is delicious now and I suspect will age for the long term.

Charles Heidsieck Rose Millesime 2018 -17.5/20
A stronger rose colour, with oodles of rich ripe red fruits, really quite powerful and unctuous peaches and dosage sticks out a little. Has great length and texture.

Pol Roger Rose 2018 – 17.5/20
Strong colour, loads of juicy fruit and soft red fruit raspberry and strawberry and some grip and lingering orange delight. This is showing very well now, just need the sunshine and the picnic!

Louis Roederer Rose Brut Nature 2018 – 16.5/20
Just the gesture of colour, quite tight to start, light red berry with dried raspberry, redcurrant and strawberry and on the palate the texture fills the mouth and you see stone fruit richness. Fur sure this is a no dosage, but holds up well on the finish.